REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC CASE NO. 1577 OF 2014
AKATSH HIMATLAL DODHIA..……….............….PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT
VERSUS
DOROTHY MARGARET WANJIKU KUNG’U….1ST DEFENDANT/APPLICANT
CHIEF LAND REGISTRAR…………….……................…..…..…2ND DEFENDANT
RULING
1. Before this court is the notice of motion dated 29th June, 2026 filed by the 1st defendant/applicant, and it is expressed to be brought under Article 50(1) of the Constitution, Sections 1A,1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules and Regulations 9 and 21 of the Judicial Service (Code of Conduct and Ethics) Regulations, 2020 seeking the following orders:-
1. Spent.
2. Pending the inter-partes hearing and determination of this application, this honourable court be pleased to stay and arrest the execution of any and all judgments and/or orders and/or directions and/or further contempt enforcement proceedings made or intended to be made against the 1st defendant.
3. The Honourable Mr. Justice Mbogo C.G be pleased to recuse himself from further hearing, handling, conducting or determining this suit, and/or any applications arising therefrom.
4. This matter be referred to the principal/presiding Judge of the Environment and Land Court for further directions and/or allocation to another Judge of concurrent jurisdiction for hearing and determination.
5. All further proceedings before this court be stayed pending the hearing and determination of Nairobi Civil Appeal no. E321 of 2026(Dorothy Margaret Wanjiku Kung’u v Akash Himatlal Dodhia and Another) preferred against the ruling of Honourable Mr. Justice Mbogo C.G delivered on 11th June 2026.
6. The costs of this application be provided for.
2. The application is premised on the grounds on its face. It is further supported by the affidavit of David Njoroge Kung’u, the son of the 1st defendant/applicant sworn on even date. He deposed that on 11th June 2026, this court dismissed the 1st defendant/applicant’s application for accommodation of the 1st defendant displaying total disregard for uncontroverted medical evidence, and her advanced age. Further, and prior to this, the court had noted in its ruling that neither of the parties had filed their written submissions yet the same were properly on record. He deposed that the court’s failure to read and consider the evidence and the submissions presented on behalf of the 1st defendant/applicant is a profound violation of the right to be heard demonstrating that the court’s mind was completely closed to the applicant’s plight which was prejudicial.
3. The deponent averred that the 1st defendant/applicant family were deeply aggrieved and have preferred a formal appeal against the said ruling. Further, that in the impugned ruling delivered on 11th June 2026, the court noted the necessity for the appointment of a legal guardian of the 1st defendant/applicant with regard to the strict compliance of the directions of the court is manifestation of a fixed bias against her whereas she lacks the capacity to instruct counsel. It was deposed that this court has lost judicial attachment by its rigid and unyielding insistence on the physical production in court of a 90-year-old bedridden and mentally incapacitated party to the extent that she cannot comprehend the very judgment being enforced against her. Further, that the court has demonstrated an unshakable bias by dismissing her application for medical accommodation actively favouring a punitive and adversarial stance over express constitutional protections guaranteed under Article 57 of the Constitution.
4. Further, and in light of the previous findings and rulings delivered by this court, it is clear that the court has taken a predetermined and fixed view of the 1st defendant/applicant’s which she cannot comprehend. For this reason, it is untenable for the court to deliver consequential rulings, and because of the court’s hostile approach, the 1st defendant/applicant’s family has suffered justifiable loss of confidence in the court’s ability to act as a neutral arbiter. In conclusion, the deponent averred that justice must not only be done, but must be seen to be done, and that to preserve the integrity of the judicial process, it is only fair and just for the court to step aside and refer the file to the principal judge for reallocation to another judge.
5. In response thereto, the plaintiff/respondent filed his replying affidavit sworn on 16th July, 2026. He deposed that the 1st defendant/applicant being dissatisfied with the ruling of this court delivered on 11th June, 2026 preferred an appeal which was certified urgent and directions given as to its disposal. With regard to the impugned ruling, the plaintiff/respondent deposed that the same did not require the physical attendance of the 1st defendant/applicant, and had she complied with the said directions, the dispute would have been solved.
6. He deposed that this court has inherent powers to make orders for the ends of justice to be met, and this being an old matter, the court ensured that this was done. The plaintiff/respondent deposed that the fact that a party has obtained an unfavourable decision is not a ground for recusal of a judge. He believes that the instant application is intended to circumvent the orders issued on 11th June, 2026.
7. The application was canvassed vide written submissions. The 1st defendant/applicant filed written submissions dated 9th September 2026, while the plaintiff/respondent filed written submissions dated 19th August, 2026. I have considered the application, the reply thereof and the written submissions filed. The main issue for determination is whether the 1st defendant/applicant has established sufficient grounds for my recusal.
8. The gravamen of the 1st defendant/applicant’s complaint is that this court, in its ruling of 11th June 2026, failed to properly consider the medical evidence and submissions presented on behalf of the 1st defendant/applicant and adopted an unduly rigid and punitive approach towards her. It is contended that these circumstances have created a reasonable apprehension of bias and that the court has formed a predetermined view against her. On the other hand, the plaintiff/respondent stated that being dissatisfied with the said ruling, the 1st defendant/ applicant has already exercised her right of appeal and that the fact that a party has obtained an adverse decision is not a ground for recusal. He contends that the present application is intended to circumvent the orders made by the court.
5. The applicable test in this case must be objective. The question is whether a fair-minded and informed observer, having considered all the circumstances of the case, would conclude that there exists a real possibility that this court is biased. This was emphasized by the court of appeal in the case of Gachagua & 5 others v Maingi & 80 others [2025] KECA 790 (KLR) Thus, the burden rests upon the person alleging bias to place before the court facts from which such apprehension can reasonably be inferred. In this case, the basis for the allegation of bias is the ruling delivered by this court on 11th June, 2026. The 1st defendant/applicant takes issue with the court’s treatment of the medical evidence, the submissions filed on her behalf and the directions concerning her attendance and compliance with the orders of the court.
6. With all respect, an adverse ruling or an order which a party considers erroneous, harsh or prejudicial does not, demonstrate bias. The court is required to consider the evidence and submissions placed before it and thereafter exercise judicial discretion. The fact that a party disagrees with the manner in which that discretion has been exercised is a matter for review or appeal and does not establish a reasonable apprehension of bias. Indeed, the 1st defendant/applicant has already preferred an appeal against the ruling of 11th June, 2026. That avenue provides the appropriate forum for challenging the correctness of the findings and orders contained in the impugned ruling. Recusal cannot properly be employed as an alternative avenue of appeal.
7. I have also considered the allegation that the court has formed a predetermined view against the 1st defendant/applicant. No extraneous relationship, interest, statement or conduct has been demonstrated from which an objective and informed observer would reasonably conclude that this court is incapable of approaching the remaining issues with an open and impartial mind. The fact that the court has previously made orders or expressed views in the course of these proceedings does not, by itself, amount to bias. Judges have a duty to determine applications and make necessary interlocutory and consequential orders as the proceedings progress. The mere fact that such orders are adverse to one party cannot constitute a basis for recusal.
9. The 1st defendant/applicant has also sought stay of further proceedings pending the determination of Nairobi civil appeal no. E321 of 2026. The mere filing of an appeal does not automatically operate as a stay of proceedings. The 1st defendant/applicant has not demonstrated sufficient grounds to warrant halting the proceedings before this court merely because an interlocutory ruling has been challenged on appeal. In my considered view, the 1st defendant/applicant has not established a reasonable apprehension of bias sufficient to warrant the recusal of the court. The prayer for referral of the matter to another judge cannot stand.
10. From the above, I find no merit in the notice of motion dated 29th June 2026. The same is hereby dismissed. I make no orders as to costs. The matter to be mentioned on 19th November, 2026 to confirm compliance with the orders issued on 11th June, 2026.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED VIRTUALLY
THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
HON. MBOGO C.G.
JUDGE
15/10/2026.
In the presence of:
Mr. Benson Agunga - Court assistant
Mr. Ochieng and Mr. Amwayi for the Plaintiff
Mr. Kabebe for the Plaintiff