REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC CASE NO. 266 OF 2018
SOSPETER GITHENDU (Chairman)
CHARLES KIHORO (Treasurer)
ALEX MWANGI (Secretary)
Suing as the Registered Officials of
MWINGI COURT RESIDENTS ASSOCIATION ……… PLAINTIFFS
VERSUS
PETER KAIRU MATHERI ……………………….……. 1ST DEFENDANT
THE CHIEF LAND REGISTRAR ………….………… 2ND DEFENDANT
THE NATIONAL LAND COMMISSION ……….…. 3RD DEFENDANT
COUNTY GOVERNMENT OF NAIROBI …………. 4TH DEFENDANT
JUDGEMENT
1. The Plaintiffs commenced this suit vide a plaint dated 7th June 2018 and amended on 18th February 2019. They averred that they reside on LR No. 209/6434, herein referred to as the ‘mother title’, and that during subdivision of the said mother title with the approval of the 4th Defendant, two plots measuring approximately ¼ of an acre each were excised therefrom and set aside as green areas and common utility plots. She points out that LR No. 209/6434/52 was one of the said two plots, marked as a community area. However, the 1st Defendant claims to be the registered owner of the said parcel, on which he intends to put up a health club. It is their case that the 1st Defendant’s alleged title was fraudulently obtained, and particularized fraud allegations against him.
2. They sought judgment against the Defendants for:
a) A permanent injunction restraining the 1st Defendant whether by himself, his agents, servants or anybody claiming through him or under him from constructing, entering upon, trespassing, encroaching, or in any other manner whatsoever interfering with the Plaintiffs’ quiet user and possession on all that portion of land aptly described as LR No. 209/6434/52.
b) A declaration that the piece of land known as LR No. 209/6434/52 is a public utility land.
c) An order be issued to the 2nd Defendant and any other Registrar and/or employee of the 2nd Defendant undertaking duties of land registration and/or administration to revoke and or cancel the title in respect to the 1st Defendant, LR No. 209/6434/52.
d) Cost and interest of the suit.
Responses
3. The record indicates that upon being served via substituted service vide the Daily Nation newspaper of 6th March 2019, the 1st Defendant entered appearance five years later, on 8th March 2024 but he never filed a defence in the matter. The 2nd Defendant did not file a defence either but the Hon. Attorney General participated in the suit.
4. The 3rd Defendants filed a statement of defence in which it denied any role in the subdivision of the mother title or registration of the alleged title held by the 1st Defendant. It also denied knowledge of approvals for change of user or transfer of the suit parcel to the 1st Defendant.
5. On its part, the 4th Defendant filed a statement of defence denying allegations in the plaint and putting the Plaintiffs’ to strict proof.
6. The matter proceeded for hearing where the Plaintiff called one witness while the Defendants did not present any witness.
Evidence of the Plaintiff
7. PW1 Susan Manyara, who was a treasurer of Mwingi Court Resident Association testified that LR NO. 209/6434/52 was excised from L.R NO. 209/6434 as per approval of subdivision done by the then Town Planning Committee of the 4th Defendant’s predecessor on 13th September 1996, in accordance with Section 262 (g) of the Local Government Act (now repealed). She pointed out that the mother title originally belonged to Kenya Railways Corporation and that during subdivision, two (2) plots measuring approximately a quarter (1/4) of an acre each, were set aside as green areas and common utility community land, the suit parcel being among them, adding that its reference number was issued by the Survey of Kenya. She testified that vide a letter dated 5th October 1996, the Director of City Planning Architecture, Nairobi City (council confirmed at paragraph iii) that the land-colored green (0.25 ha) on the deposited plan would be reserved for public purpose (green space) and was to be surrendered to the 4th Defendant’s predecessor free of cost. She confirmed that todate, the suit parcel has remained a playground and meeting ground for estate residents and children.
8. It was her testimony that in the year 2015, the Plaintiffs put up a permanent ablution block on the suit parcel for use by all the residents during social occasions and by children while playing. However, to their dismay, the 1st Defendant served them with a letter and a copy of title on 12th December 2017, informing them that he is registered owner of the suit parcel and that he intended to develop it by putting up a health club. She pointed out that the 1st Defendant’s alleged title was issued on 9th August 2010, after the property had been set aside as public utility land. It was her testimony that the 1st Defendant’s actions were fraudulent in the conversion of public land into private land. She stated that despite informing the 3rd and 4th Defendants of the alleged dark dealings, no response was forthcoming. She produced the Plaintiffs’ list and bundle of documents dated 7th June 2018 as P. Exhibits 1-8.
9. Upon cross-examination by counsel for the 2nd Defendant, PW1 stressed that the Plaintiff would want the 2nd Defendant to cancel the title issued to the 1st Defendant, because they believe it is not accurate as the suit parcel has always been public land. She insisted that Kenya Railways owned the mother title and upon subdividing it, it excised the suit parcel as a green area. She denied the suggestion that Kenya Railways allocated the suit parcel to the 1st Defendant who did not claim it earlier because he was out of the country.
10. In cross-examination by counsel for the 4th Defendant, PW1 insisted that the Plaintiffs want the suit parcel protected as public utility land. She also confirmed that the 4th Defendant has never claimed the suit parcel.
11. The 2nd and 4th Defendants closed their cases without calling witnesses. Parties then proceeded to file their submissions.
Submissions
12. The Plaintiffs submit that they have established that the suit parcel is a green area, reserved for public purpose, thus they are entitled to the reliefs sought.
13. To buttress their averments, the Plaintiffs relied on the following decisions: Republic v Minister for Transport & Communication & 5 others ex parte Waa Ship Garbage Collector & 15 others [2004] 1 KLR (E&L); Daudi Kiptugen v Commissioner of Lands Nairobi Lands & 4 others [2015] eKLR; Munyu Maina v Hiram Gathiha Maina [2013] eKLR; Cancer Investments Limited v Nairobi City County Government, National Construction Authority & 4 others (Environment & Land Case 81 of 2019) [2023] KEELC 21607 (KLR) (15 November 2023) (Judgment).
14. On its part, the 2nd Defendant submits that the suit parcel assumed the character of public utility land for the benefit of Mwingi Court Residents Association that upon approval of subdivision as it had been reserved for that purpose, it is incapable of private alienation and no valid title could be issued to the 1st Defendant. Further, that the legal principle at Regulation 10(2) of the Physical and Land Use Planning (General Development Permission and Control) Regulations, 2021 is consistent with the long-established planning requirement that land reserved for open spaces and public amenities upon subdivision is surrendered for public use.
15. It also submits that the 1st Defendant failed to prove his root of title yet the doctrine of indefeasibility of title is not absolute, as Section 26(1) of the Land Registration Act provides that a title may be impeached where it is shown that it was acquired through fraud, misrepresentation or an illegality. It insists that the 1st Defendant’s title arises from land that was not available for allocation to private entities thus it is void.
16. On cancellation of the 1st Defendant’s title, it submits that while it has administrative powers of registration, the exercise of the power of cancellation of a title requires the authority of a Court.
17. To buttress its averments, the 2nd Defendant relied on the following decisions: Dina Management Limited v County Government of Mombasa & 5 Others, Supreme Court Petition No. 8 (E010) of 2021 [2023] KESC 30 (KLR); Super Nova Properties Ltd v District Land Registrar Mombasa - Civil Appeal No. 98 of 2016 [2018] KECA 17 (KLR) (19 April 2018), and Maina v Maina (Civil Appeal 239 of 2009) [2013] KECA 94 (KLR) (10 December 2013) (Judgment).
18. The 3rd Defendant submits that the suit parcel is public utility land, that under Article 62(4) of the Constitution and Section 9 of the Land Act, 2012, land reserved for public purposes cannot be lawfully alienated for private use unless proper procedures are followed, including change of user and public participation. Further, that the purported allocation and issuance of title to the 1st Defendant is illegal, and in any case, the legality of title depends on the process of acquisition, yet the 1st Defendant failed to file a defense, or adduce evidence to justify the root of his title.
19. To buttress its averments, the 3rd Defendant relied on the case of Adan Abdirahani Hassan & 2 others v Registrar of Titles, Ministry of Lands & 2 others [2013] KEHC 6319 (KLR), and others that have also been relied on by the 2nd Defendant.
20. On its part, the 4th Defendant submits that the Plaintiffs failed to prove the allegations of fraud against it and failed to link it to any wrong doing thus it should be declared to have been wrongly sued. Further, that the title held by the 1st Defendant was issued by the 2nd Defendant who is not its agent thus it was not involved in any wrongdoing. It also argues that the suit should have been commenced vide a petition as the Plaintiff alleges to advance public interest rights.
21. To buttress its averments, the 4th Defendant relied on the following
cases: Anne Wambui Nderitu v Joseph Kiprono Rapkoi & another [2005] 1EA 334; Brian Asin & 2 others v Wafula W Chebukati & 9 others [2017] eKLR; Devram Manji Daltani v Danda [1949]16 EACA 35; Nancy Wanjiru Kunyiha v Samuel Njoroge Kamau Nakuru ELC No.295 of 2014 [2018]eKLR, among others which the Court has carefully considered.
Analysis and Determination
22. I have considered the Pleadings, testimony of the witness, exhibits including parties’ submissions and the following are the issues for determination:
a) Whether LR No. 209/6434/52 is lawfully registered to the 1st Defendant and whether it is public land.
b) Whether the 1st Defendant’s title to the suit parcel ought to be revoked/cancelled.
23. It is not in dispute that the 1st Defendant is registered as proprietor of the suit parcel. The Plaintiffs have challenged his registration on the basis that the said parcel was surrendered as a public utility plot during subdivision of LR No. 209/6434.
24. The 1st Defendant did not file a defence while the 2nd and 3rd Defendants did concur with the Plaintiffs’ at the submission stage, that the suit parcel is public utility land. On its part, the 4th Defendant focused on exonerating itself from any wrongdoing and urged the Court to declare that it had been wrongly sued.
25. On whether the suit parcel is public land, Article 62(1) of the Constitution defines public land to include: “unalienated government land and land which no individual or community ownership can be established by any legal process. Article 62(2) goes further to vest public land to the following parties:
“Public land shall vest in and be held by a county government in trust for the people resident in the county, and shall be administered on their behalf by the National Land Commission.”
26. Alienation of public land is prohibited under Article 62(4) of the Constitution, unless it is in the manner provided by law. If the Court finds that the suit parcel is public land, then its alienation to the 1st Defendant is unlawful and Article 40(6) of the Constitution strips him of the protection accorded to property. It provides that:
“The rights under this article do not extend to any property that has been found to have been unlawfully acquired”
27. The Plaintiffs’ claim that the suit parcel was set aside as a public utility plot was not controverted. In Republic v Commissioner of Lands & 4 others & ex parte Associated Steel Mill [2014] KEHC 2498 (KLR), the Court stated thus:
“It is thus our holding that the disputed plot having already been set aside as a public utility plot, the same was held in trust by the 1st respondent for the public and public purposes and was not available for further alienation and could not at any rate be allocated to a private developer as a commercial plot.”
28. Further, in Dorcas Atieno Rajoru & 145 others v Mjahid Sub-chairman Harambee Maweni Committee SHG & 2 others [2016] KEELC 554 (KLR), the Court stated that:
“Indeed it is trite law that plots for public utilities and open spaces are usually surrendered to either the council, the county government or the national government that is required to hold plots meant for public utilities on behalf of the residents of the place where such plots are situated”
29. In this instance, PW1 explained that LR NO. 209/6434/52 was excised from L.R NO. 209/6434 as per approval of subdivision done by the then Town Planning Committee of the 4th Defendant’s predecessor on 13th September 1996, in accordance with Section 262 (g) of the Local Government Act (now repealed). It was her testimony that the mother title L.R NO. 209/6434 originally belonged to Kenya Railways Corporation and that during subdivision, two (2) plots measuring approximately a quarter (1/4) of an acre each, were set aside as green areas and common utility community land, the suit parcel being among them. The Plaintiff produced a letter dated 15th October 1996, from the Director of City Planning Architecture, Nairobi City to demonstrate that the suit plot was a green space.
30. As per letter dated the 15th October, 1996 addressed to the Commissioner of Lands, whose reference is subdivision of LR no. 209/6434, it indicated at paragraph (iii) as follows:
‘The land coloured green (0.25 ha) on the deposited plan to be reserved for public purpose (open space) and to be surrendered to Nairobi City Council free of cost.’
31. PW1 confirmed that the suit parcel had been surrendered for public utility. She further confirmed that todate, the suit parcel has remained a playground and meeting ground for estate residents and children. Further, that in 2015, the Plaintiff even constructed an ablution block and it is only 2017 when the 1st Defendant served them with a letter dated the 12th December, 2017 claiming to have a title over the suit parcel.
32. The 1st Defendant did not file a Defence to controvert the Plaintiffs averments while the 2nd and 3rd Defendants supported the Plaintiffs claim.
33. It is my considered view that once the suit parcel had been surrendered for public utility, it was not available for private alienation and no valid title could have been issued to the 1st Defendant on 9th August, 2010. Further, under Regulation 10(2) of the Physical and Land Use Planning (General Development Permission and Control) Regulations, 2021, it provides that land reserved for open spaces and public amenities upon subdivision is surrendered for public use. It is trite that under Article 62(4) of the Constitution and Section 9 of the Land Act, 2012, land reserved for public purposes cannot be lawfully alienated for private use unless proper procedures are adhered to, including change of user and public participation. At this juncture I opine that the 1st Defendant did not demonstrate the process he adhered to, to acquire a public utility plot as his private property.
34. In the foregoing, I find that the suit parcel was indeed public land and was not available for alienation and allotment to the 1st Defendant. With this finding, the question we hence need to ponder is whether the 1st Defendant’s title can be deemed indefeasible.
35. When a title to land is challenged, the proprietor of such land has the burden to prove its title. As earlier stated, the 1st Defendant did not even file his defence but all he did was serve the Plaintiffs’ with a copy of his title. Is this Court supposed to uphold such title? It would not do so, when its root is not demonstrated to the required standards and where it is demonstrated that such title was acquired illegally, unprocedurally, or through a corrupt scheme, pursuant to Section 26 (1) (b) of the Land Registration Act which states that:
“26 Certificate of title to be held as conclusive evidence of proprietorship
(1) The certificate of title issued by the Registrar upon registration, or to a purchaser of land upon a transfer or transmission by the proprietor shall be taken by all courts as prima facie evidence that the person named as proprietor of the land is the absolute and indefeasible owner, subject to the encumbrances, easements, restrictions and conditions contained or endorsed in the certificate, and the title of that proprietor shall not be subject to challenge, except
(a) On the ground of fraud or misrepresentation to which the person is proved to be a party; or
(b) Where the certificate of title has been acquired illegally, unprocedurally or through a corrupt scheme.”
36. The requirement for proof of root of title was discussed by the Court of Appeal which held as follows in the case of Munyu Maina v Hiram Gathiha Maina [2013] KECA 94 (KLR):
“We state that when a registered proprietor root of title is under challenge, it is not sufficient to dangle the instrument of title as proof of ownership. It is this instrument of title that is in challenge and the registered proprietor must go beyond the instrument and prove the legality of how he acquired the title and show that the acquisition was legal, formal and free from any encumbrances including any and all interests which would not be noted in the register.”
37. Further, the Supreme Court held as follows in Dina Management Limited v County Government of Mombasa & 5 others [2023] KESC 30 (KLR):
“Indeed, the title or lease is an end product of a process. If the process that was followed prior to issuance of the title did not comply with the law, then such a title cannot be held as indefeasible...”
38. From the evidence tendered before Court, I find that the 1st Defendant’s title to the suit parcel cannot be deemed as indefeasible as its root is fettered as it was obtained through fraud contrary to the provisions of section 26 of the Land Registration Act. Since the 1st Defendant’s title was obtained through fraud, I wish to make reference to Section 80 of the Land Registration Act which provides that:
“(1) Subject to subsection (2), the court may order the rectification of the register by directing that any registration be cancelled or amended if it is satisfied that any registration was obtained, made or omitted by fraud or mistake. (2) The register shall not be rectified to affect the title of a proprietor, unless the proprietor had knowledge of the omission, fraud or mistake in consequence of which the rectification is sought, or caused such omission, fraud or mistake or substantially contributed to it by any act, neglect or default.”
39. In the foregoing, I will rely on the aforementioned legal provisions and direct the 2nd Defendant to rectify the register as relates to the suit parcel and revert it back to the public.
40. In the circumstances, I find that the Plaintiffs have proved their case on a balance of probability and will proceed to enter judgement in their favour as against the Defendants in the following terms:
1) A permanent injunction be and is hereby issued restraining the 1st Defendant whether by himself, his agents, servants or anybody claiming through him or under him from constructing, entering upon, trespassing, encroaching, or in any other manner whatsoever interfering with the Plaintiffs’ quiet user and possession on all that portion of land aptly described as LR No. 209/6434/52.
2) A declaration be and is hereby issued that the piece of land known as LR No. 209/6434/52 is a public utility land.
3) An order be and is hereby issued to the 2nd Defendant and any other Registrar and/or employee of the 2nd Defendant undertaking duties of land registration and/or administration to revoke and or cancel the title in respect to the 1st Defendant, LR No. 209/6434/52.
4) The costs of the suit is awarded to the Plaintiff to be borne by the 1st Defendant.
DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
CHRISTINE OCHIENG
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Kobia for Plaintiffs
Muthoka for 1st Defendant
Court Assistant: Joan