Land law

Gatimu & another v Omwenga (Sued on his own Behalf and as Chairman Amani Self Help Group) & 12 others [2026] KEELC 6613 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Case 288 of 2013
Judgment date
15 October 2026
Judge(s)
CG Mbogo

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this court for determination is the notice of motion dated 24th October, 2025 and the notice of motion dated 25th February, 2026 respectively. The notice of motion dated 24th October, 2025 is filed by the defendants/judgment debtors and it is expressed to be brought under Article 50 (1) of the Constitution, Sections 1,1A,3,3A and 63(e) of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 22 and Order 50 rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules seeking…

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Both applications were canvassed through written submissions. The defendants/judgment debtors filed their written submissions dated 18th March, 2026 and 27th April, 2026. The 2nd plaintiff/respondent filed written submissions dated 21st April, 2026. By the time of writing this ruling, the 1st plaintiff/respondent had not filed written submissions. I have considered both applications, grounds of opposition and the written submissions…

Paragraph 10 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC CASE NO. 288 OF 2013

CHARLES MUNENE GATIMU......................................................1ST PLAINTIFF

KAREGI CATHERINE KAMANJA…………….....................………….2ND PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

EARNEST OMWENGA(Sued on his own behalf

and as Chairman AMANI SELF HELP GROUP)….......................1ST DEFENDANT

PETER KINYUA……………………………………......................………2ND DEFENDANT

ABEL OYARO……………………………….......................……………...3RD DEFENDANT

PROTAS MANDELA……………………......................………………...4TH DEFENDANT

JOHN NGIGE…………………………………........................……………5TH DEFENDANT

CHARLES AKUNGA……………………………......................…………6TH DEFENDANT

SAMUEL MOTURI……………………………….......................………..7TH DEFENDANT

EVANS OBIERO………………………………….......................………..8TH DEFENDANT

FRANCIS NDIRANGU…………………..........................................9TH DEFENDANT

PETER KIOKO…………………….…………........................………….10TH DEFENDANT

STEPHEN KIBUNJA…………………...........................................11TH DEFENDANT

MARY WAMBUI………………………………......................………….12TH DEFENDANT

LUCY NJERI……………………………………........................………..13TH DEFENDANT

RULING

1. Before this court for determination is the notice of motion dated 24th October, 2025 and the notice of motion dated 25th February, 2026 respectively. The notice of motion dated 24th October, 2025 is filed by the defendants/judgment debtors and it is expressed to be brought under Article 50 (1) of the Constitution, Sections 1,1A,3,3A and 63(e) of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 22 and Order 50 rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules seeking the following orders:-

1. Spent.

2. That execution proceedings against the defendants/judgment-debtors be stayed pending the final determination of the present motion.

3. That the honourable court be pleased to make a determination that the plaintiffs/decree-holders are not under any legal obligation to enjoy an order of demolition for the same is not pleaded in their suit and/or pending proceedings before the honourable court.

4. That the honourable court be pleased to make a finding that in the absence of an express order for demolition, the plaintiffs/decree-holders are bound by their pending proceedings on record.

5. That the honourable court be pleased to make a judicial finding that the judgment of 21-9-2025 is incapable of valid execution on account of the plaintiffs/decree holders lack of appropriate prayers on account of the reality on the ground where the judgment-debtors/applicants have occasioned massive development on the suit property the subject-matter of this suit.

2. The application is premised on the grounds on its face. It is further supported by the affidavit of the 1st defendant/judgment-debtor sworn on even date on his own behalf and on behalf of the other applicants. The 1st defendant/judgment-debtor deposed that the plaintiffs/decree-holders have executed plans to demolish the housing developments on the suit property which they have been in occupation since the year 2007 having initiated elaborate developments incorporating developed housing units.

3. He further deposed that the plaintiffs/decree holders were under the legal obligation to make disclosure of the activities on the suit property and subsequently seek a prayer for demolition and that in the absence of the said plea, the orders of eviction cannot transition to demolition under the law. It was highlighted at paragraph 18 of the plaintiffs/decree holders’ plaint dated 21st February, 2013 that there is a clear admission by the plaintiff that the “defendants have illegally invaded and occupied the plaintiffs Parcel of Land known as L.R. No. 209/11970” but, neglected to plead for an order of demolition.

4. The plaintiffs/decree holders filed their grounds of opposition dated 4th December, 2025 opposing the application on the following grounds:-

1. The application lacks good faith with sole intention to disregard and disobey the orders granted in the decree.

2. The application is meant to perpetuate and continued illegal and unlawful occupation to the suit property contrary to the orders granted in the decree herein.

3. The application herein is a clear manifest of an intention to delay execution of the decree.

4. The application intends to deny the decree holders from enjoying the fruits of their judgement.

5. The court herein is functus officio in as far as the parameters of the orders prayed in this application.

6. The application herein be dismissed with cost.

5. The notice of motion dated 25th February, 2026 is also filed by the defendants/applicants and it is expressed to be brought under Articles 50(1) and 159(2) of the Constitution, Sections 1A,1B,3,3A and 63(e) of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 22 Rule 22, Order 51 Rule 7 and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules seeking the following orders:-

1. Spent.

2. That the plaintiffs/decree holders/respondents be restrained by an order of the honourable court from demolishing the defendants/applicants/judgment-debtors massive developments on land reference no. Nairobi/block 209/11970 pending the final determination of the present motion and the other motion scheduled for 18-3-2026.

3. Any other suitable order which the honourable court may be pleased to give in the circumstances.

4. That the costs of the application be provided for.

6. The application is premised on the grounds on its face. It is further supported by the affidavit 1st defendant/applicant sworn on even date. He deposed that despite the pendency of this application, the plaintiffs/respondents have attempted to demolish their homes in the absence of such an order in the final decree, and to date, neither the court bailiff nor the auctioneers have effected any notice of the decree upon them.

7. The 1st defendant/applicant deposed that the plaintiffs/respondents are circumventing the due process of court by using the police to intimidate them with the said demolition. For this reason, he urged the court to allow the instant motion.

8. The 1st plaintiff/respondent filed grounds of opposition dated 21st April, 2026 challenging the instant application on the following grounds:-

1. The court herein upon interpartes hearing heard the suits herein and entered substantive and final judgment thus cannot litigate on the same issue or related.

2. The matter herein is res judicata having litigated on the rights and co-related issues touching on them and decisions been made the same cannot be reopened whatsoever.

3. The application herein is an abuse of the court. The applicants have not sought leave to reopen this matter and therefore procedurally defective in absence of such a leave.

4. That the applicant herein having filed an appeal against the judgment of this court in COACA/E892/2023 Ernest Omwenga and Abel Oyaro and 6 Others v Charles Munene Gatimu and Karegi Catherine Kamanja which appeal has been heard and determined in substance vide judgment dated 20th December, 2024 cannot purport to file further proceedings in a lower court with an intention to supersede the judgment of the appellate court over the same matter.

5. That thereafter the applicants expressed their intentions to appeal to the supreme court of Kenya in COACAPPL/E025/2025 Ernest Omwenga v Charles Munene Gatimu and Karegi Catherine Kamanja which leave was not granted in a ruling delivered on 21st November, 2025.

6. That in the upshot the applicants have exhausted litigation herein thus litigation must come to all end and should not be allowed to reopen in the circumstances.

9. The 2nd plaintiff/respondent filed grounds of opposition dated 21st April, 2026 challenging the instant application on the following grounds:-

1. That the application is incompetent and an abuse of due process meant to achieve nothing as this court has already determined the rights of the parties herein.

2. That this court having ordered vacant possession cannot be expected to have control of how the plaintiff intends to use their land.

3. That the defendants have failed to comply with this court’s orders for vacant possession and are in contempt hence should not be given any audience.

4. The defendants having been declared trespassers through the decision of this court cannot have locus herein.

5. The applicants have not approached this court with clean hands any in any event litigation must come to an end.

6. That the main appeal from the judgment of this court has been determined by this court of appeal and the same has been dismissed hence this court has nothing remaining to deal with in relation to the application herein.

10. Both applications were canvassed through written submissions. The defendants/judgment debtors filed their written submissions dated 18th March, 2026 and 27th April, 2026. The 2nd plaintiff/respondent filed written submissions dated 21st April, 2026. By the time of writing this ruling, the 1st plaintiff/respondent had not filed written submissions. I have considered both applications, grounds of opposition and the written submissions filed. The issue for determination is whether both applications have merit.

11. The defendants/judgment debtors contend that without an express order seeking demolition of the suit property in the plaint dated 21st February 2013, the plaintiff/decree holders cannot demolish the massive developments made on the suit property. They argue that the plaintiffs/decree holders should have sought for an order of demolition, since they were fully aware that the defendants/judgment debtors have made developments on the suit property.

12. The terms ‘eviction’ and ‘vacant possession’ often go hand in hand in the term ‘demolition’ in the context of trespass to land. Eviction often entails giving up vacant possession of the suit property, and if one was a trespasser thereof, it means returning the suit property to the state it was in before the trespass. Mogeni, J in a similar case where the plaintiffs did not expressly seek an order for demolition but claimed trespass and prayed for vacant possession held as follows in Gori Investments Limited v Basco Products (K) Limited & another (Environment & Land Case 1528 of 2016) [2024] KEELC 7447 (KLR):-

“One of the rights belonging to absolute ownership of land is the right to possession of the same to the exclusion of all others. This is precisely the right that the Plaintiff is seeking in this suit. This court has no difficulty in finding that indeed the Plaintiff is entitled to occupy the entire suit property to the exclusion of the Defendants. The Plaintiff is therefore entitled to vacant possession of the suit property by the 1st Defendant. I order that the 1st Defendant do give the Plaintiff vacant possession of the suit property and do bear the costs of demolition of the illegal structures erected by its agents thereon.”

13. It is also notable that Section 152 of the Land Act which provides for the process of evictions includes the removal of buildings or structures as provided under 152E(c). Section 152I of the Act further demonstrates that eviction may involve demolition in some instances. Munyao Sila J (as he then was) in the case of Bamaftah v County Government of Kilifi (Environment & Land Case 26 of 2021) [2023] KEELC 15865 (KLR) (1 March 2023) found as follows:-

“It should be understood that demolishing property is drastic, very drastic. Developments are by their nature expensive ventures for which persons have made immense sacrifice. Demolition will not only cause actual loss of investment but may shatter a person and bring him down to the depths of hopeless and depression. One may not be able to recover from such loss. Demolition is thus a remedy that should be used very sparingly and as a last resort, probably only where, despite the developer being given ample opportunity to regularize the development, he has failed to do so, and/or where the development in issue is a threat to the environment or infringes on the rights of others.”

14. In the present case, the development infringes on the proprietary rights of the decree holders who are yet to realize the fruits of the judgment, noting that the matter was already fully heard and determined and their rights were established. Having said this, the defendants/judgment-debtors have no other choice but to comply with the orders of this court, otherwise they will be in default thereof.

15. Turning to the application dated 25th February 2026, the defendants/applicants seek an injunction restraining the plaintiffs/respondents from demolishing the developments pending determination of the application and the earlier application. The two applications have now been considered together. To the extent that the second application sought interim protection pending determination of the first application, that limb has been overtaken by events.

16. The court is not persuaded that the defendants/applicants have established a sufficient basis for granting the broader injunctive relief sought. From the above, both the notice of motion dated 24th October, 2025 and 25th February, 2026 lack merit, and they are hereby dismissed with costs to the plaintiffs/decree holders.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED VIRTUALLY

THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

HON. MBOGO C.G.

JUDGE

15/10/2026.

In the presence of:

Mr. Benson Agunga - Court assistant

Mr. Obonyo for the 1st Plaintiff

Ms. Awandu holding brief for Mr. Were for the 2nd Plaintiff

Mr. Soila for the Contemnors in the application dated 17/08/2026

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder