REPUBLIC OF KENYА
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROВІ
ELC LC NO. E468 OF 2025
AHMED HASSAN JAMA ……....…………….……………1ST PLAINTIFF
NYAYO VIEW SUITES …………………….………..…….2ND PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
NAIROBI CITY COUNTY…………………………...………. DEFENDANT
RULING
1. Vide a Notice of Motion dated 8th September, 2025 brought pursuant to the provisions of Section 1A, 1B, 3A, 3B and 63(e) of the Civil Procedure Act, and Order 40 Rules 1, 2 and 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules, the Plaintiffs/Applicants seek the following reliefs:
i. Pending the hearing and determination of this Application, this Honorable Court be pleased to issue a temporary injunction restraining the Defendant/ Respondent either by themselves, servants, agents and/or people acting on their instructions from interfering with the Plaintiffs/Applicants’ ongoing construction works on LR No. 37/256/2 Nairobi West, Nairobi County “Nyayo View Suites.”
ii. This Honorable Court be pleased to issue a permanent injunction restraining the Defendant/ Respondent either by themselves, servants, agents and/or people acting on their instructions from interfering with the Plaintiffs/Applicants’ ongoing construction works on LR No. 37/256/2 Nairobi West, Nairobi County “Nyayo View Suites”.
iii. The costs of this Application be provided for.
2. The Motion is supported by the affidavit of Ahmed Hassan Jama, the 1st Applicant of an even date. He deponed that the Applicants are the developers of LR No. 37/256/2 Nairobi West, Nairobi County “Nyayo View Suites”; that the 2nd Applicant, vide a joint venture agreement dated 7th March 2023, agreed to develop the suit property by putting up a modern apartment complex consisting of one basement level, ground floor, mezzanine floor and one hundred and thirty (130) one bedroom apartments comprising of thirteen floors in total and a borehole subject to Architectural Design and Nairobi City County and NEMA approvals.
3. He explained that the Applicants applied for, and duly obtained all the requisite approvals and permits from the Respondent including the development permission, approved building plans and NEMA clearance. Despite this, the Respondent through its agents, acting on its instructions has on multiple occasions threatened to stop, interfere with and stop the construction works.
4. According to Mr. Jama, the Respondent’s actions have caused considerable anxiety among the homeowners, tenants and other occupants of the suit property and that unless restrained, those actions are likely to occasion substantial loss, damage and prejudice to the Applicants and the property owners. He further contended that the Respondent’s conduct is unlawful and arbitrary and, in the long term, may undermine the Applicants’ ability to fulfil their obligations under the respective leases and sale agreements with the homeowners and tenants.
5. In his view, once a property owner has paid the requisite fees and obtained all necessary approvals and permits, that owner is entitled to peaceful and quiet possession and enjoyment of the property.
6. In response, the Respondent filed a replying affidavit sworn by Wilfred Masinde, its Deputy Director of Development Inspection and Planning Litigation dated the 21st November, 2025. Mr. Masinde deponed that he is conversant with the planning matters in dispute and the enforcement notice dated 28th July 2025 and has authority to swear the affidavit on the Respondent’s behalf.
7. At the onset, he asserted that the present Motion and the substantive suit are procedurally and substantively defective. He pointed out that the pleadings refer to three Applicants although only two had been named. He further averred that prayer 3 of the application seeks a permanent injunction under Order 40 Rules 1, 2 and 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules, provisions which govern interlocutory rather than final relief. He also asserted that prayer 2 is spent because it had not been granted at the ex parte stage. On that basis, he contended that the application is fatally defective.
8. Mr. Masinde denied that the Applicants had obtained all the requisite development permissions, approved building plans and other permits from the Respondent. He stated that the documents exhibited as annexure “AHJ-3” and described as copies of the approvals and permits are illegible and unverifiable and are therefore of little evidential value. He also denied knowledge of the joint venture referred to in the supporting affidavit and questioned its relevance to the proceedings.
9. He explained that the Respondent has a statutory duty to enforce planning and building laws and to ensure that construction is undertaken in accordance with approved plans and all applicable legal and regulatory requirements. That mandate includes issuing enforcement notices whenever construction is undertaken without the requisite approvals or in a manner inconsistent with the plans approved by Nairobi City County. According to him, the Applicants had carried out building works which departed from the approved plans.
10. He further deponed that the enforcement notice dated 28th July 2025 remains valid and in force and that the Applicants continue to be in breach of it. In his view, the application and suit are intended to delay enforcement of the notice, frustrate the ordinary operation of the law and impede due process. He therefore urged the court to dismiss the application with costs and allow the Respondent to enforce the notice in accordance with the Physical and Land Use Planning Act, 2019 and the applicable Nairobi City County by-laws.
11. Mr. Masinde lastly contended that the Applicant had not exhausted the dispute-resolution procedure prescribed under the Physical and Land Use Planning Act, 2019. Although the parties were granted 14 days each from the 15th July, 2026 to file submissions, none of the parties had filed submissions as at 11th September, 2026.
12. Having considered the pleadings, the issues that arise for determination are whether the motion is competent, and if so, whether the Applicants are entitled to the injunctive orders sought?
13. The Respondent challenges the competence of the Motion on three principal grounds. First, that the pleadings refer to three Applicants although only two are named. Second, that a permanent injunction has improperly been sought through an interlocutory application and third, that the Applicants have not exhausted the dispute-resolution mechanism prescribed by the Physical and Land Use Planning Act, 2019.
14. To begin with, the court has indeed noted that the Motion references a 4th Applicant whereas only two are named in the pleadings. This is plainly an inconsistency. It does not however obscure the identities of the parties before the court or occasion any demonstrated prejudice to the Respondent. Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution and Sections 1A and 1B of the Civil Procedure Act require the court to administer justice without undue regard to procedural technicalities. That discrepancy is therefore curable and does not render the Motion incompetent.
15. The next contention is as regards the doctrine of exhaustion. The interference complained of by the Applicants arises from the enforcement notice dated 28th July 2025, issued by the Respondent in the exercise of its development-control mandate.
16. Section 72(1)(b) of the Physical and Land Use Planning Act, 2019 authorizes the relevant County Executive Committee Member to serve an enforcement notice where a condition attached to a development permission has not been complied with. Section 72(3) further provides that a person aggrieved by such a notice may appeal to the relevant County Physical and Land Use Planning Liaison Committee within fourteen days of service.
17. Ordinarily, therefore, a person who disputes an enforcement notice must first invoke the appellate mechanism provided under Section 72(3). The exhaustion doctrine, however, presupposes the existence of an accessible and operational statutory forum. A party cannot be faulted for failing to pursue a remedy which was not practically available at the time the dispute arose or the proceedings were instituted.
18. The enforcement notice was issued on 28th July 2025, while the present suit and Motion were filed on 8th September 2025. The court is alive to the fact that the Nairobi County Physical and Land Use Planning Liaison Committee has long been redundant and members were only sworn in on 30th July, 2026. The Committee was therefore not operational when the enforcement notice was issued or when these proceedings were instituted.
19. Consequently, since the statutory appellate body was unavailable at the material time, the Applicants cannot be said to have deliberately bypassed an existing and effective dispute-resolution mechanism. The Respondent’s objection based on the doctrine of exhaustion consequently fails.
20. Lastly, it is urged that the prayer 3 seeks a permanent injunction in an interlocutory application. Indeed, it is trite that a permanent injunction is not a preliminary order capable of being granted before trial. Unlike a temporary injunction, which preserves the subject matter pending the determination of the suit, a permanent injunction finally determines the parties’ rights and may only issue after the suit has been heard on its merits. There is no basis for granting such relief at this stage. Prayer 3 is consequently unavailable.
21. The Respondent’s assertion that prayer 2 became spent merely because it was not granted at the ex parte stage is not correct. The refusal or omission to grant an order ex parte does not, without more, finally determine an interlocutory prayer. Nonetheless, prayer 2 was expressly framed as a temporary injunction to remain in force only pending the hearing and determination of the present application.
22. Of course, it is possible that the Applicants meant that the temporary application should issue pending the hearing and determination of the suit. However, as presently drafted, its duration was tied to the determination of the application itself. Upon delivery of this ruling, the application stands determined and the period for which the temporary injunction was sought necessarily comes to an end. Prayer 2 is accordingly spent and no substantive order falls to be made on it.
23. In the end, the Motion is found to be incompetent and is hereby struck out. Costs shall abide the outcome of the suit.
Dated, signed and delivered virtually in Nairobi this 15th day of October, 2026.
O. A. Angote
Judge
In the presence of;
Ms Wangari for Kihera for Defendant
No appearance for Plaintiff
Court Assistant: Tracy