Land law

JM Njenga & Co Advocates LLP v Kimuri Housing Co Ltd [2026] KEELC 6829 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Environment and Land Miscellaneous Case E130 of 2023
Judgment date
15 October 2026
Judge(s)
JG Kemei

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

This ruling determines two applications arising from the taxation of an Advocate-Client Bill of Costs dated 30/11/2023. By the Court’s direction, the two applications are: one seeking entry of judgment and the other seeking leave to file a Reference out of time.

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

Having carefully considered the rival applications, the supporting and opposing affidavits, and the written submissions filed by the Advocate, I find two issues that merit determination in the following order:

Paragraph 11 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT MILIMANI

ELC. MISC. NO. E130 OF 2023

____________________________________________________________

J.M. NJENGA & CO. ADVOCATES LLP - ADVOCATE /APPLICANT

VS

KIMURI HOUSING CO. LIMITED - CLIENT/ RESPONDENT

RULING

(In respect of the Advocates’ application dated 23/10/2025 and the Client’s application dated 15/6/2026)

1. This ruling determines two applications arising from the taxation of an Advocate-Client Bill of Costs dated 30/11/2023. By the Court’s direction, the two applications are: one seeking entry of judgment and the other seeking leave to file a Reference out of time.

The Advocates’ application dated 23/10/25

2. The first application is by the Advocate, which is said to be under Section 81 of the Advocates Act (Cap.16), Rule 7 of the Advocates Remuneration Order, and Order 50 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The Advocate seeks the following orders:

a. That Judgment for the sum of Kshs. 4, 640,000/= plus accrued interest thereon at 14% p.a. from 17/3/2022 until payment in full be entered in favour of the Advocate/ Applicant as against the Client/ Respondent.

b. That the costs of this Application be provided for.

3. The application is grounded on the face of it and on the Supporting Affidavit of Bilha Kimani, sworn on 23/10/2025. The Applicant avers that on 9/10/2023, the Taxing Master taxed the Advocate-Client Bill of Costs dated 30/11/2023 and allowed it at a sum of Kshs. 4, 640, 000/=. A Certificate of Costs dated 14/10/2025 was subsequently issued therefrom, and that certificate has not been set aside, varied, reviewed or altered by this Court or otherwise. It is averred that the Client has failed, refused or neglected to settle the said sum, hence the instant application.

4. The deponent further avers that interest at 14% p.a. applies from one month after the fee note dated 17/2/2022. That interest is therefore payable from 17/3/2022 at 14% p.a. until payment in full.

Client’s Grounds of Opposition

5. In its grounds of opposition dated 15/4/2026 and the supplementary grounds dated 22/6/2026, the Client avers that the application is incompetent, fatally defective and bad in law. The Advocate has not accounted for funds received in this matter. The Client further contends that the application is premature, as it will render its intended Reference nugatory. The Application is contrary to the Court's overriding objectives.

The Client’s application dated 15/6/26

6. The second application is brought pursuant to the provisions of Paragraph 11 (1), (2) & (4) of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order, 2009, and Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act. The Client seeks orders that: -

a. The Respondent be granted leave to file a Reference out of time against the ruling/taxation delivered on 14/10/2025.

b. Costs of this application be in the cause.

7. The application is premised on the face of it and supported by the affidavit of the Client's Counsel, Achieng’ Otieno, deposed on 15/6/2026. Counsel avers that the Client, aggrieved by the said taxation, intends to challenge it by way of Reference under Paragraph 11 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order. The deponent argues that the intended Reference raises arguable issues, including misapplication of taxation principles and excessive instruction fees. The deponent avers that the delay in filing the Reference was not deliberate but was occasioned by the recent appointment of new Advocates, who required time to peruse the Court file and obtain instructions. The deponent further attributes the delay to the former Advocate's failure to communicate the October 2025 ruling in a timely manner and to miscommunication in May 2026 regarding a ruling allegedly delivered on 22/4/2026. The Client therefore seeks leave to file the Reference out of time in the interests of justice. She contends that unless the Court grants a stay of enforcement, entry of judgment, and execution, the intended Reference will be rendered nugatory and the Respondent will suffer irreparable prejudice.

Advocate’s Replying Affidavit

8. Referring to the Replying Affidavit deposed by Jeremy Njenga, sworn on 30/6/2026, Counsel contends that the application is fundamentally incompetent, baseless, and an afterthought designed to frustrate the entry of judgment. He avers that the taxation orders sought to be challenged vide the intended reference were issued on 9/10/2025, approximately 8 months prior to the instant application. He asserts that no sustainable explanation has been offered for this inordinate delay. He further avers that the mere change of Advocates cannot excuse the Applicant's failure to act, given that the Applicant was previously represented by a Senior Counsel of unquestionable experience in taxation matters. It is further deposed that the supporting affidavit is defective, as it has been deposed to by an Advocate who has not been on record since the filing of the bill of costs and is therefore not conversant with the facts.

9. The deponent avers that the Client has not demonstrated an arguable case, as the Taxing Master merely followed the dictates of the ruling delivered on 8/4/2025. The Client’s reliance on the letter dated 22/4/2026, which postdates the taxation orders by 6 months, is further noted. The letter also references a ruling date and a taxed sum of Kshs. 9,435,748.30/= that do not correspond with the taxation orders of 9/10/2025, which concerned a sum of Kshs. 4,640,000/=. This discrepancy indicates that the Client is merely seeking, as a ploy, to buy time and delay the entry of judgment rather than to raise sufficient grounds to challenge the taxation orders. On that basis, the Advocate prays that the application be dismissed with costs.

Court’s directions

10. The Court directed the parties to file their submissions. The parties complied and filed their respective submissions. The Advocate’s submissions are dated 10/8/2026, whereas the Client’s submissions are dated 22/6/2026 and 24/6/2026, respectively. The Court has read and considered both sets of written submissions, which, in any event, now form part of the Court record.

Analysis and Determination

11. Having carefully considered the rival applications, the supporting and opposing affidavits, and the written submissions filed by the Advocate, I find two issues that merit determination in the following order:

a. Whether counsel for the Client had capacity to swear the supporting affidavit on its behalf

b. Whether the Client should be granted Leave to file a Reference out of time

c. Whether judgment should be entered in favour of the Advocate pursuant to Section 51(2) of the Advocates Act as prayed.

Whether counsel for the Client had capacity to swear the supporting affidavit on its behalf

12. The Advocate contends that the Affidavit in support of the application is defective and should be struck out, as it is sworn by an Advocate who lacks personal knowledge of the contested facts. The issues deponed on occurred prior to the Advocate's involvement in June 2026, and the Advocate has improperly deposed to matters not within her knowledge, hence the depositions are hearsay. Relying on Order 19 Rule 3 of the Civil Procedure Rules and prevailing jurisprudence, counsel argues that it is incompetent for an Advocate to swear an affidavit in contested matters where the Client is available, thereby exposing the Advocate to the dual role of Advocate and witness. Consequently, as no justification has been provided for the Client's failure to swear the affidavit, the contents of paragraphs 4 through 10 should be struck out as hearsay, leaving the application devoid of merit and ripe for dismissal.

13. In the case of Barrack Ofulo Otieno –vs- Instarect Limited (2015) eKLR, the Learned Judge observed as follows: -

"The learned authors of Halsbury’s Laws of England, 3rd Edition, Paragraph 845 say as follows with regard to affidavit:

"Affidavits filed in the High Court must deal only with facts which a witness can prove of his own knowledge, except that, in interlocutory proceedings or with leave, statements as to a deponent’s information or belief are admitted, provided the sources and grounds thereof are stated…”

14. In the case of Regina Waithira Mwangi Gitau –vs- Boniface Nthenge (2015) eKLR, the Learned Judge held that:

"On issue number one, the established principle of law is that Advocates should not enter into the arena of the dispute by swearing an affidavit on contentious matters of fact. By swearing an affidavit on contentious issues, an Advocate makes himself a viable witness for cross-examination on the case he is handling merely as an agent, which practice is irregular. In Simon Isaac Ngugu Vs Overseas Courier Services (K) Ltd 1998 eKLR and Kisya Investments Ltd & Others Vs Kenya Finance Corporation Ltd, it was held that: -

"…it is not competent for a party’s Advocate to depose to evidentiary fact at any stage of the suit."

15. Also in the case of East African Foundry Works (K) Ltd Vs Kenya Commercial Bank Ltd [2002] eKLR the Court held;

"I have considered the rival arguments. I accept the submissions of Mr. Akiwumi that in reality paragraphs 3, 4 and 8(c) of the affidavits of Mr. Ngatia contain not statements of facts of which he had personal knowledge although statements based on information the source whereof he has not revealed. Accordingly, those paragraphs offend Order 18 rule 3(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules…..I have always deprecated depositions by Advocates on contentious matters of fact in suits or applications which they canvass before the Courts and I have never had any hesitation in striking out such depositions as a matter of good practice in our Courts. The unseemly prospect of counsel being called upon to be cross-examined in matters in which they appear as counsel must be avoided by striking out such affidavits as a matter of good practice. As regards paragraph 9, I accept the submission of Mr. Ngatia that it is no more than a deposition as to his understanding of the law in response to an affidavit by a fellow Advocate."

16. The averments contained in the supporting affidavit sworn by Achieng Otieno, counsel for the Client, generally on matters of law, save for paragraphs 7 and 8, which are erroneously listed as 7 and 9. Counsel deposes that;

“7. The delay in filing the intended Reference is not deliberate but is due to the fact that the Respondent recently appointed new Advocates who required time to peruse the Court file & obtain better instructions from the Client before moving this Honourable Court.

9 The former Advocate failed to communicate to the Respondent in a timely manner what transpired in October 2026 and, in May 2026, only miscommunicated that a ruling had been delivered on 22/04/2026 in respect of taxation herein. (As annexed)”

17. Evidently, the two paragraphs contain not statements of facts of which counsel had personal knowledge although statements based on information the source whereof she has not revealed. Accordingly, those paragraphs offend Order 18 rule 3(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules and are thus struck out.

Whether the Client should be granted Leave to file a Reference out of time

18. Rule 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order makes provision for the procedure an aggrieved party must adopt. It provides:

“(1) Should any party object to the decision of the taxing officer, he may within fourteen days after the decision give notice in writing to the taxing officer of the items of taxation to which he objects.

(2) The taxing officer shall forthwith record and forward to the objector the reasons for his decision on those items and the objector may within fourteen days from the receipt of the reasons apply to a judge by chamber summons, which shall be served on all the parties concerned, setting out the grounds of his objection.

(3) Any person aggrieved by the decision of the judge upon any objection referred to such judge under subsection (2) may, with the leave of the judge but not otherwise, appeal to the Court of Appeal.

(4) The High Court shall have power in its discretion by order to enlarge the time fixed by subparagraph (1) or subparagraph (2) for the taking of any step; application for such an order may be made by chamber summons upon giving to every other interested party not less than three clear days’ notice in writing or as the Court may direct, and may be so made notwithstanding that the time sought to be enlarged may have already expired.” 

19. My understanding of paragraph 11(4) is that when a party is confronted with limitation of time, it must apply for an extension of time to file a notice of objection or the reference itself out of time. The Court’s power to enlarge the time fixed by subparagraph (1) is discretionary. It is trite that a party seeking exercise of a Court’s discretion in its favour is obligated to demonstrate valid and reasonable grounds as to why the Court should exercise discretion in his favour. This principle was clearly established in Nicholas Kiptoo Arap Korir Salat v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 7 others [2014] eKLR.

20. Having struck out paragraphs 7 and 9 of the supporting Affidavit, the Client’s application lacks reasons to justify the delay, leaving the Court unable to exercise its discretion.

21. Further, Rule 11(1) requires that a party aggrieved by the decision of a taxing master file and/or lodge a notice of objection to taxation against that decision within 14 days of the date of such taxation. The filing of the notice of objection is therefore mandatory.

22. Imperatively, the notice of objection to taxation must specify the particular items with which the Applicant contends to be aggrieved and/or dissatisfied. A Notice of Objection to taxation should not be omnibus. An omnibus notice, if any, would be incompetent and incapable of grounding a Reference.

23. In the case of Machira & Company Advocates -vs- Arthur K. Magugu & Another (2012) eKLR, the Court of Appeal agreed with the findings of Ringera J who had struck out the reference for being incompetent on the finding that there was no written notice of objection under rule 11. The Court held, inter alia,

“Sub-rule (1) requires the party objecting to give notice in writing within 14 days “of the items of taxation to which he objects”. As the trial judge correctly found, the Respondents notice of 1st August, 2001 did not comply with that provision. It did not specify the items objected to so that the taxing officer could give his reasons on them.

As we have pointed out the intendment of the Rules Committee in providing for objections to bills of costs to be dealt with by references and not appeal or review was expedition. If vague notices are given taxing officers might be forced to give their reasons for their taxation of each item including even those not objected to. That would of course defeat the purpose of that expeditious procedure. Having not specified the items objected to and sought reasons for their taxation, the Respondents notice of 1st August, 2001 was fatally defective. It follows that the Respondents’ reference based on it was incompetent and we agree with counsel for the Appellant that it should have been struck out.

Having not given a proper notice specifying the items objected to and seeking the reasons for their taxation at the figures they were taxed, the issue of when the taxing master’s decision was received is immaterial and does not avail the Respondents. Under sub-rule (2), time stops running from the date a proper notice is filed, which of course must be within 14 days of taxation, until receipt of the taxing master’s reasons for his decision.”

24. In the case of Twiga Motor Limited -vs- Hon. Dalmas Otieno Anyango (2015) eKLR, the Court stated that;

“The time limits in Rule 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order have been set for a reason. Failure to adhere to the said time limits would mean that the application would be rendered incompetent in the first instance.” [own emphasis]

25. In the present case, the Client has sought only leave to file the Reference out of time, not leave to file a Notice of Objection out of time. I have perused the record and note that the Client never filed a Notice of Objection, not even an incompetent one. In the absence of a Notice of Objection to taxation, properly identifying the items objected to and filed within the statutory timeframe, or a prayer for leave to file one out of time, there cannot be a Competent Reference, even if leave to file a Reference were to be granted.

26. The Notice of Objection to taxation is the equivalent of a memorandum of appeal which identifies the grounds of appeal in an appeal. This procedural error cannot be remedied by invoking the oxygen principles or the provisions of Article 159 of the Constitution. To this end I am persuaded by the decision in Chadha (Sued as the Executrix of the Estate of Kulwant Singh Chadha (Now Deceased) -vs- Chaudhri & Associates (2024) e KLR, where the Learned Judge struck a Reference for non-filing of the requisite Notice of Objection to Taxation.

Whether judgment should be entered in favour of the Advocate pursuant to Section 51(2) of the Advocates Act as prayed.

27. Turning to the Notice of Motion dated 23/10/2025, the Advocate has based his plea for judgment on the Certificate of taxation on Section 51 of the Advocates Act which provides:

“(1) Every application for an order for the taxation of an Advocate’s bill or for the delivery of such a bill and the delivering up of any deeds, documents and papers by an Advocate shall be made in the matter of that Advocate.

(2) The certificate of the taxing officer by whom any bill has been taxed shall, unless it is set aside or altered by the Court, be final as to the amount of the costs covered thereby, and the Court may make such order in relation thereto as it thinks fit, including, in a case where the retainer is not disputed, an order that judgment be entered for the sum certified to be due with costs.”

28. It appears from the section that whereas sub section (1) refers to applications for an order of taxation of Advocate’s Bill and therefore determination of the Advocates costs, subsection (2) is clear that the certificate of costs once issued by the Taxing officer is final unless set a side or altered by the Court. The Court may also make an order that judgment be entered in terms of the amount in the certificate of costs.

29. In the case of Lubulellah & Associates Advocates –vs- N. K. Brothers Limited [2015] eKLR the Court observed that;

“The law is very clear that once a taxing master has taxed the costs, issued a Certificate of costs and there is no reference against his ruling or there has been a ruling and a determination made and not set aside and/or altered, no other action would be required from the Court save to enter judgment. An Applicant is not required to file suit for the recovery of costs”.

30. See also the Supreme Court decision in Kenya Airports Authority vs Otieno Ragot and Company Advocates (Petition E011 of 2023) [2024] KESC 44 (KLR) (2 August 2024) (Judgment).

31. Although the Client intended to challenge the taxation of the Advocate’s Bill of Costs pursuant to Rule 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order, the same has been disallowed by the Court herein.

32. The Client’s intended reference having been disallowed, the Court enters judgment for the Advocate against the Client for the sum of Kshs. Kshs. 4,640,000/=.

33. On the aspect of interest, Rule 7 of the Advocates Remuneration Order stipulates:

“An Advocate may charge interest at 14 per cent per annum on his disbursements and costs from the expiration of one month from the delivery of his bill to the Client, provided that such claim for interest is raised in the bill of costs."

34. The Court of Appeal decision in Otieno, Ragot & Company Advocates Vs Kenya Airports Authority (2021) eKLR. The Court of Appeal while considering an appeal from the decision of the High Court held that: -

“As such, the rule (rule 7) deals with interest chargeable by an Advocate in respect of its claim for disbursements and costs following submission of a fee note. It is patently clear from the rule that interest begins to accrue from the expiry of one month from the date of delivery of the bill or fee note. The learned judge’s reasoning that the rule does not specify the date from which time begins to run was therefore a misdirection”.

35. The Court went further to consider the claim of interest after taxation of an Advocate -Client bill of costs and held that: -

“Additionally, it is notable that a review of the Applicant’s Bill of Costs does not disclose that the Applicant included a charge for “interest at 14% per annum on his (her) disbursements and costs…” in the Bill of Costs. As the sole basis upon which the taxing officer determines the amounts due to an Applicant, the element of interest defined by rule 7 ought to have been included in the Bill of Costs, but it was not. This omission would thereby negate the application of rule 7 and instead render the bill liable to an exercise by the Court of its discretion under section 26 of the Civil Procedure.”

36. I have perused the Bill of Costs that was drawn, filed and presented by the Advocate herein. The Applicant did include a charge for interest in the Bill of Costs. Accordingly, guided by the above cited binding authority, Rule 7 is applicable in this case.

37. I therefore award the Applicant interest at 14% per annum from 14/11/2025, which is one month after the Certificate of Costs was issued. The Advocate is awarded costs of the Application.

38. The upshot of my findings is as follows:

a. The Client’s Notice of Motion dated 15/6/2026 be and is hereby dismissed with costs to the Advocates.

b. The Advocate’s Notice of Motion dated 23/10/2025 is allowed, and Judgment is hereby entered for the Advocate against the Client for the sum of Kshs. 4, 640,000.00/= only, together with interest accruing therefrom at 14% per annum from 14/11/2025 until payment in full.

c. The Advocate is awarded costs for both applications.

39. It is so ordered

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026 THROUGH MICROSOFT TEAMS.

J G KEMEI

JUDGE

Delivered in the presence of;

1. N/A for the Applicant

2. N/A for the Respondent

3. C/A – Mr Eglon

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder