THE REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
PETITION NO. E241 OF 2026
JAMES ODHIAMBO & 25 OTHERS PETITIONERS
(Suing on behalf of over 100,000 Junior Secondary School teachers of the proposed Kenya Junior School Teachers Union - KEJUSTU)
VERSUS
REGISTRAR OF TRADE UNIONS 1ST RESPONDENT
HON. ATTORNEY GENERAL 2ND RESPONDENT
AND
KENYA UNION OF POST-PRIMARY
TEACHERS (KUPPET) 1ST INTERESTED PARTY
KENYA NATIONAL UNION OF
TEACHERS (KNUT) 2ND INTERESTED PARTY
JUDGMENT
The petitioners are junior school teachers and represent other similarly situated teachers numbering 100,000. They intend to form a proposed trade union, the Kenya Junior School Teachers Union (KEJUSTU), pursuant to Articles 36 and 41 of the Constitution and Sections 12 to 19 of the Labour Relations Act (LRA). The 1st respondent is the office established under the LRA to regulate trade unions. The 2nd respondent is the office established under Article 156 of the Constitution and the government legal advisor. The interested parties are the trade unions for secondary school teachers and primary school teachers, respectively.
The petitioners' case is that they are appealing the 1st respondent's decision made on 1 July 2026 under section 30 of the LRA. Aggrieved by the 1st respondent's decision to decline to register KEJUSTU as their proposed union, the petitioners contend this violates their rights under the Constitution and the LRA; hence this petition.
The petition is that, through a letter dated 6 June 2026, the petitioners applied for a promotion certificate and registration of KEJUSTU. The 1st respondent replied and declined the request on the grounds:
a) The proposed membership of the proposed union is currently sufficiently covered by existing unions - Kenya Union of Post Primary School Teachers (KUPPET) and Kenya National Union of Teachers (KNUT) in the same sector.
b) Registration of new unions in this sector will lead to a disruption in the sector due to inter-union rivalry and scramble for members.
Hence, for these reasons, the application for promotion and registration was unsuccessful. However, the 1st respondent's decision violates the petitioners' constitutional and statutory rights. The question of sufficiency of representation by the interested party is a violation of KEJUSTU members in terms of section 14(1)(d) of the LRA. The 1st respondent failed to address section 14(2) of the LRA as required. The 1st respondent applied no sufficiency test in declining to register KEJUSTU, without providing evidence to justify the refusal.
The 1st respondent erred in replying on registration before considering KEJUSTU's promotion. The rejection of the application was premature as it sought the registration for promotion purposes. The reference to other unions was not necessary, and the 1st respondent became an advocate and champion for the Interested Party without mandate, as held in Aloise A. Otiende v Boniface M. Munyao.
The petition is that the 1st respondent's decision is discriminatory and contrary to Article 37 of the Constitution on the right to association and Article 41 on the right of every person to join a trade union of choice. The officer failed to appreciate the importance of Article 163(7) of the Constitution on the right to association, as held in NGO Co-ordination Board v EG & 4 others; Katiba Institute (amicus curiae) (Petition 16 of 2019) [2023] KESC.
Under section 14(1) (d) and 14(2) of the LRA, the 1st respondent was supposed to consider whether the proposed trade union sufficiently represents the whole and a substantial portion of the petitioners' interests and whether registration was necessary. There was no consideration of the constitution of the petitioners. Despite the Constitution allowing every worker to join a trade union of choice, the 1st respondent failed to register KEJUSTU to promote its mandate. The appeal is therefore justified, and the 1st respondent's decision should be declared null and void.
The petitioners and the members of the proposed KEJUSTU are solely drawn from junior secondary schools and seek registration to address their unique challenges, which no other trade union is likely to address. The proposed union is founded on the unique position occupied by junior secondary school teachers. The competency-based curriculum was introduced as a distinct level of learning, creating a new cadre of teachers with specialised qualifications. They form over 100,000 teachers countrywide. The Interested Party have not been able to address their specific concerns; hence the need to register and promote KEJUSTU.
The refusal to register and promote KEJUSTU is discriminatory, given the existing unions in the education sector, including the Interested Party, UASU, KUNOPPET, and KUSNET. Whereas the 1st respondent refused to register KUJESTU on the basis that other trade unions exist, the 2nd Interested Party is registered for primary school teachers, the 1st Interested Party for post-primary teachers, KUSNET for special needs teachers, and KUNOPPET for pre-primary teachers. The rejection of the petitioners' proposed union is unjustified and therefore discriminatory.
The petition is that even in other sectors like transport, there are various trade unions, including Kenya Transport Workers (TAWU). Later, the Kenya Aviation Workers Union, Long Distance Truck Drivers Workers Union, Public Transport Workers Union, Matatu Workers Union, Taxi Operators Workers Union, Airline Pilots Union, and Union for Logistics, Road Transport and Warehousing were registered.
The petitioners have a legitimate expectation that the 1st respondent would register their proposed union, and its rejection is ultra vires and contrary to the Constitution and the law. The petitioners are seeking various declarations:
a) The 1st respondent’s decision dated 1 July 2026 declining promotion and registration of the union be set aside.
b) The court to direct the 1st respondent to allow the promotion and registration of KUJESTU in terms of section 18(4) (a) of the LRA as a trade union.
c) An order of judicial review by way of an order of mandamus compelling the 1st respondent to issue statutory gazette notices and any other statutory instrument for purposes of promoting and registering KEJUSTU and any other appropriate name as provided under the LRA.
d) A declaration that the refusal for registration by the 1st respondent is discriminatory and without justification and contrary to articles 27 and 28 read with article 24 of the Constitution.
e) An order of prohibition and permanent injunction restraining the respondents from impeding the promotion and registration of the petitioners' union, KEJUSTU and any other appropriate name as a trade union as envisaged under Articles 36 and 41 of the Constitution and the LRA.
f) Costs of the petition.
The petitioners also filed a Memorandum of Appeal Petition. They repeat the assertions under the petition.
The petitioners also filed the Supporting Affidavit of James Odhiambo, the 1st petitioner, which supports the petition and the orders sought.
In reply, the 1st Interested Party filed the Replying Affidavit of Akelo Misori, who avers that the petition purports to challenge the decision of the 1st respondent, Registrar of Trade Unions, and the proper move is not through a constitutional petition but an appeal under section 30 of the LRA. The proceedings herein are misconceived, incompetent and contrary to the doctrine of constitutional avoidance.
Misori avers that the petitioners seek to relitigate issues touching on the representation and demarcation of JSS Teachers within the education sector, issues already addressed within the existing labour relations framework. As JSS teachers, the petitioners are, by definition, post-primary teachers. The statutory inquiry is therefore not whether the promoters desire a separate union but whether the interests they seek to represent are already adequately represented within the sector. The 1st respondent considered existing teacher representation through other unions, including KUPPET, and concluded that the proposed constituency was already sufficiently represented.
Sections 12, 14, 18, 19, 20, 54 (1), (6) and (7) of the LRA are instructive on the issue of trade union registration. The petitioners never sought conciliation and have failed to exhaust the dispute resolution mechanisms under the LRA; hence, the court lacks jurisdiction.
Misori avers that in Nairobi Petition 17 of 2018 – KNUT v KUPPET; TSC, Commissioner for Labour, Kenya Union of Pre-Primary Teachers & Boniface Omari Tom (Interested parties) admitted the JSS teachers as a collective interested party. The dispute concerned the demarcation of all trade unions within the education sector in Kenya. The joinder of JSS teachers resulted from negotiations between KUPPET and JSS teachers regarding accommodations within the union.
KUPPET amended its constitution in 2024 to ensure the representation of JSS teachers at branch and national level. Omari represents JSSC in KUPPET and holds the position of Assistant National Secretary, Junior Schools.
Misori avers that the petitioners are 26 and that no authority can sue on behalf of the 100,000 alleged JSS teachers. The application for registration was signed by 54 JSS teachers and submitted after the close of the election cycle in 2026, after the petitioners failed to vie for the elective seats in the branches.
Currently, KUPPET has 131 officials at both national and branch levels, including JSS teachers. Specific seats are reserved for JSS teachers to ensure affirmative action.
Therefore, the 1st respondent's decision to reject the petitioners' application is lawful and justified. Article 41 of the Constitution contemplates the regulation of labour relations through legislation and, in this case, the LRA is the statutory framework within which the unionisation framework is addressed. The petitioners' allegations are without foundation and should be dismissed with costs.
The 2nd Interested Party filed the Replying Affidavit of Henry Collins Oyuu, the secretary general, who avers that the petition is defective and should be struck out. Section 30 of the LRA grants any person aggrieved by the 1st respondent's decision the right to file an appeal with the court. Filing a constitutional petition against the 1st respondent's decision in a dispute already decided is an unnecessary attempt to convert an ordinary dispute into a constitutional petition. It should be dismissed with costs.
You aver that the 2nd Interested Party is the union that represents teachers in all cadres, including JSS teachers. A Recognition Agreement has since been registered with the Court in Nairobi JR Misc. Application No. 17 of 2014, and the Court held that KNUT, as the older union, has membership across primary school institutions and post-primary school institutions and thus represents unionisable teachers in both cadres. The 2nd Interested Party has advanced the interests of all its members and successfully negotiated CBAs as part of its mandate.
The petitioners have not demonstrated that the 2nd Interested Party has not advanced their rights and interests, noting that JSS teachers were and are essentially primary school teachers. The mere change in the education system from 8-4-4 to CBC does not mean the 2nd Interested Party cannot engage the employer and agitate for their rights.
You aver that the 1st respondent's letter dated 1 July 2026, in response to the petitioners’ application for registration, acknowledges that the Interested Party adequately represents the interests and rights of JSS teachers. The 2nd Interested Party has not excluded the petitioners from its membership and remains free to join.
The petitioners are 26 and purport to enjoin 100,000 without authority. No evidence supports such membership. The application placed with the 1st respondent did not include the numbers alleged in this petition.
The petitioners have further conflated the issue of promotion with that of registration to justify these proceedings. However, sections 12 and 13 of the LRA provide the mechanism for issuing a promotion certificate. Such a certificate does not determine whether the proposed trade union is entitled to registration. Sections 14, 18, and 19 of the LRA set out the substantive requirements and procedures governing trade union registration. These provisions prohibit the registration of another trade union in a sector that is sufficiently represented, in whole or in part, or in a substantial proportion, in respect of the registration sought. Accordingly, the 1st respondent's letter of 1 July 2026 addressed the petitioners' application sufficiently and refused it on merit.
Oyuu avers that the petitioners' contention that multiple unions exist within the dear education sector and that this amounts to discrimination against them is without merit. The petitioners admit that the listed trade unions were registered to represent distinct and identifiable cadres of employees. In the letter dated 1 July 2026, the 1st respondent places the JSS teachers under the existing mandate of the interested parties. Such cannot be treated as discriminatory under Articles 27 and 41 of the Constitution. The petition is without merit and should be dismissed with costs.
The parties filed written submissions and reiterate the matters set out in the pleadings, affidavits, and case law.
Determination
The issues for determination are whether this is a proper petition; whether the petitioners have been discriminated against; whether the 1st respondent's decision, by letter dated 1 July 2026, should be set aside; whether the orders sought for mandamus and prohibition should ultimately be issued; and who should pay costs.
The issues outlined above are intertwined, as they result from the 1st respondent's letter dated 1 July 2026 refusing to allow the promotion and registration of KUJESTU.
In response, the petitioners have moved the Court by way of a constitutional petition. Under paragraphs 1 and 25 of the petition, the petitioners assert that they are aggrieved by the 1st respondent's decision, issued on 1 July 2026, refusing to register KEJUSTU as a trade union. They rely on section 30 of the LRA.
It is now a settled principle that where a statute provides a dispute resolution mechanism, that procedure should be followed instead of constitutionalising an ordinary labour relations issue(s) by merely appending constitutional provisions, as such offends the doctrine of constitutional avoidance. Not every dispute should result in a constitutional petition, as held in Cytonn Investment Partners Four LLP & 6 others v Official Receiver; Chys Creditors' Committee & another (Proposed Interested Parties) [2026] KESC 51 (KLR). An ordinary commercial dispute can well be addressed under the applicable statutory provisions instead of invoking the constitutional petition route.
Therefore, unless a party can demonstrate that the primary forum for litigation is insufficient, a court should reserve the constitutional petition procedure. Constitutional avoidance means a court should not determine a constitutional issue when it can decide the matter on another basis.
In Jovet (Kenya) Limited v Bavaria NV [2025] KESC 27 (KLR), the court held:
“…as a general principle that where it is possible to decide any case, civil or criminal, without reaching a constitutional issue, that is the course which should be followed. … Meaning that where a law that is being applied to resolve a particular dispute does not guarantee an outcome reflecting the values embodied in the Bill of Rights, then the values that underpin the Bill of Rights ought to be integrated into the subject non- constitutional law intermediary norm and guide the development of the norm. Such a norm will thereafter be applied to resolve the dispute in a transformed form.
In this case, the challenge relates to the 1st respondent's decision. An application to register KEJUSTU for promotion was made and refused. Under section 30 of the LRA, the court is not the primary forum for challenging a refusal to register a trade union for promotion.
Upon the 1st respondent's decision, an appeal lies to the court. The petitioners have made no case that the procedures under the LRA are insufficient or that, in refusing registration, the law does not guarantee an outcome reflecting the values embodied in articles 36 and 41 of the Constitution.
In Kenya Plantation & Agricultural Workers’ Union v Omulama & 9 others [2020] KESC 59 (KLR), the court allowed an appeal where the Registrar of Trade Unions had refused to register the proposed trade union to promote its mandate. Because the primary forum for adjudicating disputes regarding the promotion of a proposed trade union lies with the office of the 1st respondent, a petition cannot lie with the court. No special or exceptional circumstances demonstrate that moving the court under a petition, instead of applying the dispute resolution mechanism under section 30 of the LRA, is warranted.
The court is not properly moved.
Even if the petition were proper, as outlined above, the petitioners seek to represent 26 petitioners and 100,000 other JSS teachers. The 1st respondent's extract of 18 April 2026 confirms that the JSSC teachers have a representative within the KUPPET union. Further, the petitioners are represented within each branch countrywide.
Such representation must be accounted for.
The motions to hold elections at the branch and national levels serve a purpose.
Section 31(2) of the LRA is couched in mandatory terms:
(2) No person shall be an official of more than one trade union or employer’s organisation.
Where the petitioners have secured representation within KUPPET through their elected representatives at the branch and national level, seeking to form and promote another trade union covered within an existing union is specifically prohibited. Where such registration for promotion is sought because the petitioners lost in the elections, such cannot be cured as herein sought.
The question of whether there is discriminatory treatment against the petitioners is then subsumed under the failure to move the court appropriately as required under section 30 of the LRA. As set out above, the core issue is the challenged refusal to allow the promotion of KEJUSTU through the 1st respondent's letter dated 1 July 2026; such a matter would have been addressed in an ordinary suit without the need to invoke a constitutional petition. In any case, under Rule 10 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, a party may raise a case of constitutional rights and freedoms violations in an ordinary suit. Unless the statutory framework is established to be inadequate, filing a petition is unnecessary.
As this is not a proper petition, it is without merit. For industrial peace, an order on costs.
Accordingly, the petition herein is without merit and is struck out. No orders on costs.
Dated this 15th Day of October 2026
M. MBARU
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Court Assistant: Mohammed Ali