Background
That the Kiambu Branch elections held on 10 January 2026 started at about 11 am and closed at around 10 or 11 pm into the night.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
That the Kiambu Branch elections held on 10 January 2026 started at about 11 am and closed at around 10 or 11 pm into the night.
Paragraph 1 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
PETITION NO. E025 OF 2026
JOHN THIUKU MBUGUA 1ST PETITIONER
TERESIA WANJIRU KIGURU 2ND PETITIONER
VERSUS
KENYA UNION OF POST PRIMARY EDUCATION
TEACHERS (KUPPET 1ST RESPONDENT
THE COUNTY LABOUR OFFICER 2ND RESPONDENT
THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE UNIONS 3RD RESPONDENT
AND
ROBERT KIMANI 1ST INTERESTED PARTY
LAWRENCE KIRUTHI 2ND INTERESTED PARTY
MOSES THOGO 3RD INTERESTED PARTY
SAMUEL KARIITHI 4TH INTERESTED PARTY
STEPHEN NGUGI 5TH INTERESTED PARTY
SIMON MWANIKI 6TH INTERESTED PARTY
JOSEPH MWANGI 7TH INTERESTED PARTY
BEN ISRAEL 8TH INTERESTED PARTY
OMIDO DAVID ONYANGO 9TH INTERESTED PARTY
PERIS WANGUI MWANIKI 10TH INTERESTED PARTY
MAUREEN MAKENA 11TH INTERESTED PARTY
BETH WANGITHI NJIGIGUA 12TH INTERESTED PARTY
PAULINE THANGWA 13TH INTERESTED PARTY
IRENE NTINYARI KINOTI ………… 14TH INTERESTED PARTY
JUDGMENT
The petitioners are seeking the following Orders:
a) A declaration that the KUPPET Kiambu Branch elections held on 10 January 2026 were unconstitutional, unlawful, null and void.
b) An order quashing the said elections and all results arising therefrom.
c) An order directing the 1st respondent to conduct fresh elections in strict compliance with the Constitution, Labour Relations Act, the KUPPET constitution and election regulations.
d) An order restraining the 3rd respondent from gazetting or recognising the impugned officials elected in the disputed elections held on 10 January 2026.
e) Consolidating orders barring the impugned officials from assuming office pending determination of the petition.
f) Any other order the court may deem just and equitable for the dispensation of justice.
g) Costs of the petition.
Petition
The 1st petitioner is a male adult, a teacher and a member of the 1st respondent. The 2nd petitioner is a female adult, a teacher and a member of the 1st respondent.
The 1st respondent is a trade union registered under the Labour Relations Act (the LRA). The 2nd respondent is the County Labour Officer, Kiambu County, who supervised the 1st respondent elections. The 3rd respondent is the office mandated to register and gazette elected trade union officials.
The petitioners state that they were nominated candidates for the positions of executive secretary and organising secretary, respectively, in the 1st respondent's Kiambu branch elections. The elections were held on 10 January 2026 at Kolping College, Kilimambogo, Kiambu County.
The petition is that the electoral process was marred by grave and substantive irregularities, including:
a) Delayed commencement of polling.
b) Unlawful extension of voting hours.
c) Collapse of voter verification.
d) Participation of ineligible voters, including agency fee payers.
e) Issuance of multiple ballot papers to single voters.
f) Lack of transparency in counting and tallying.
g) Presence of unauthorised persons in the polling Centre. and
h) Serious security lapses leading to voter disenfranchisement.
The petitioners lodged complaints with the 3rd respondent through a letter dated 13 January 2026 and, in response, there was an admission:
a) Voting started and ended late;
b) Voter verification was not consistently conducted; and
c) Some voters were issued up to 20 ballot papers.
However, the 3rd respondent, despite noting the irregularities, went ahead and gazetted the elected persons as officials of the 1st respondent.
The elections were held in contravention of Article 36 of the Constitution, by undermining the internal democracy within trade unions; Article 41 by denying the petitioners fair labour practices; Article 47 by subjecting the petitioners to unfair administrative processes; and Article 10 concerning the application of values of integrity, transparency, accountability and rule of law. The elections were conducted in breach of Articles 7 and 13 of the KUPPET Constitution, and the Notice of Branch Elections and Regulations dated 26 November 2025.
The petition is that the respondents' actions contravened sections 30 and 34 of the LRA. By failing to adhere to voting hours, verify voter eligibility, allow agency fee payers to vote, and issue excess ballot papers to voters, the respondents did not secure a free and fair election. This was compounded by the failure to secure the polling station environment, conduct the tallying and declaration of results in an opaque manner, and ensure compliance with election regulations or call for fresh elections due to the noted irregularities. The petitioners' rights to fair action and fair labour practices were thus not protected.
The petitioners seek that the orders sought in the petition be allowed and that the respondents be directed to call for fresh elections.
In support of the petition, the petitioners filed the supporting affidavit of John Thiuru Mbugua, together with his witness statement and those of Teresia Wanjiru Kiguru, the 2nd petitioner, Elijah Mwangi, and Michael Kiare, who testified in evidence.
The 1st petitioner avers that, as a member of the 1st respondent, he participated in the branch elections held on 10 January 2026 at Kolping College, Kilimambogo, Kiambu County, and was a candidate for the position of executive secretary. Under Article 7 of the KUPPET constitution, only registered and fully subscribed teachers are eligible to be members and to participate in union affairs, including elections. Under Article 13, union elections must be conducted in a free and fair manner, using only eligible voters and proper electoral procedures.
The 1st petitioner avers that the Kiambu branch elections were conducted in a blatant violation of the Constitution and the election regulations. The 2nd respondent, who was conducting the elections on behalf of the 1st respondent, commenced polling at approximately 11.1m instead of the stipulated 6 a.m., in clear violation of the election notice and regulations. This was without any lawful or reasonable explanation being offered to the members. Voter verification was done briefly from 11 to 11.25 a.m., after which the process was abandoned, and voters used the queuing method to vote. Persons not on the official voter register were manually added inside the polling station and allowed to vote, including teachers paying agency fees who are not eligible to vote.
The petitioner avers that voting proceeded until 9 pm, beyond the official voting hours. The polling station gates remained open until 8.45 pm, and persons who had already voted were able to re-enter and vote again. This breached the integrity of the process. If the voter register were verified, and those crossed out as having voted were checked, it would reveal that the total number of votes cast was higher than those marked on the register.
Due to congestion and the opening of multiple entry points into the polling room, persons who had already voted were able to re-enter and vote again, as identification checks were reduced to production of the payslip.
The 1st petitioner avers that several voters admitted to having received 20 ballot papers despite there being only 13 elective positions for which a ballot was being cast. There was gross mishandling and over-issuance of ballot papers.
The ballot papers were placed too close together in a congested room that lacked colour coding. The ballot papers did not indicate which office, leading to confusion and many stray ballot papers. The sorting and counting of votes lacked transparency and accountability, and the total votes per post varied significantly, indicating ballot stuffing and multiple voting.
The 1st petitioner testified that he voted last, but his name was not crossed off in the voter register to show that his details were verified. Several other teachers voted and were not verified, including Peter Githuka. This is confirmed by the tallying of votes that did not add up. The voter register indicated 2,423 voters, but the results showed a total of 2,536, exceeding the total number of votes cast. The disparity of over 130 votes remains unaccounted for.
The petitioner avers that the candidates and their agents were not briefed on the voting, verification, counting or dispute resolution procedures, thereby denying effective oversight. Unauthorised persons, including Kamau Kamatu, a non-teacher and non-agent, were allowed inside the polling station during the vote counting. This was despite protests from other candidates.
Security was deployed only at 4 pm, after chaos erupted and voting was suspended for 2 hours. This exposed the voters to danger, and most left without voting.
Due to disorder and insecurity, many teachers who had travelled long distances left without voting. They were disenfranchised.
The petitioners lodged a complaint with the 1st respondent, who replied and admitted that the voting process started late, voter verification was inconsistent, and most ballot papers could not be accounted for. On this basis, the elections were marred by irregularities, and the Court should allow the orders sought in the petition.
The 2nd petitioner testified that, as a member of KUPPET Kiambu Branch, she was nominated and registered as a candidate for the position of organisation secretary, which was held on 10 January 2026 at Kolping Vocational College, Kilimambogo, in Thika.
Ms Kiguru testified that the 1st respondent issued a notice of branch elections and regulations stating that elections would run from 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. and that only registered and fully paid-up members would be eligible to vote. As a candidate and union member, the petitioner relied on these directions and regulations and expected a fair electoral process.
On 10 January 2026, the petitioner arrived at the polling station early, expecting to begin voting by 6 am. She found the polling station not ready. No election official was present, and members were left waiting without any formal communication to the candidates or voters. The deviation from the stipulated start time was not addressed.
Ms Kiguru testified that, as the morning progressed, frustration and tension grew among voters, and many expressed concern that the delay was deliberate and prejudicial. Actual voting commenced late without any lawful justification. By the time voting started, many eligible voters had already left the polling station. This resulted in the systematic disenfranchisement of eligible voters, particularly those with other duties and family commitments. The indefinite wait before voting began denied most voters a fair chance to exercise their democratic right.
Ms Kiguru testified that the voter verification process was fundamentally flawed. The verification desk for the register of eligible voters was poorly positioned and inadequately staffed. Verification was applied inconsistently, and numerous persons were allowed to vote without being verified or marked on the official register, contrary to election regulations and the KUPPET constitution. As agitation increased and crowd pressure mounted, verification procedures collapsed. Security presence was minimal and insufficient to restore order. Election officials relocated the verification desk to the voting hall, worsening congestion, confusion, and lack of control.
The voting hall became crowded without order or supervision. No reliable mechanism existed to distinguish voters who had already voted from those yet to vote. The principle of “one person, one vote” could not be secured.
Ms Kiguru testified that she observed multiple voting and manipulation, both deliberate and inadvertent. Given the collapse of the verification process, lack of voter marking and uncontrolled crowd, any efforts to reconcile the votes were materially flawed. The elections were not fair, transparent, or credible. The procedures applied for tallying, verification, and voting were inconsistent; hence, the entire integrity of the elections is in doubt. The Court should issue the orders sought in the petition.
The petitioners called Michael Mwangi, a teacher and 1st respondent member, who testified that he was an eligible voter in the Kiambu branch elections held on 10 January 2026 at Kolping Vocational College, Kilimambogo. He supports the petition on the basis that voting did not start at 6 am or close at 6 p.m., as indicated. He planned to attend to vote as directed, but when he arrived at the polling station at 6 am, voting had not started and did not begin until around 11 am. Election officials were not ready, and they gave no explanation despite the breach of the announced voting time.
Mwangi testified that many teachers who arrived early like him became agitated and frustrated by the delay. When voting started at 11 am, most eligible voters had left. They effectively became disenfranchised.
Voter verification was disorganised and unreliable. The verification desk was initially placed about 50 meters away from the voting hall. The desk was poorly manned and overwhelmed, and officials did not consistently verify voters, allowing several teachers to vote without verification or being marked on the register.
Due to agitation and crowd pressure, the few police officers present could not control the situation, and officials bypassed verification procedures. Election officials later moved the verification desk inside the voting hall, which worsened the confusion and disorder. The voting hall became overcrowded with no separation of verified and non-verified voters. Voting was uncontrolled, with no mechanism to identify teachers who had already voted, and some voted several times.
Mwangi testified that he personally observed teachers re-entering the voting area after voting without any checks to prevent repeat voting. Multiple voting was inevitable. Verifying the voter register and votes cast would reveal a significant mismatch.
Responses
The 2nd and 3rd respondents’ case is that the Kiambu branch elections were conducted on 10 January 2026 and the same has since been registered and events have overtaken the orders sought. A labour officer presided over the elections, which were held peacefully and in accordance with the union constitution and the LRA. The labour officer submitted a report to the 2nd respondent in accordance with section 35(3) of the LRA. The petitioners wrote to the 2nd respondent about various issues with the elections, and the 2nd respondent responded in a letter dated 13 January 2026. However, the response has been misinterpreted as an admission that voter verification was not consistently done, which is not correct. In response to the petitioners' complaints, the Labour Officer filed a report confirming that the elections were conducted procedurally.
In evidence, the respondents called Cleopas Obiero Mbayaji, the Labour Officer who presided over the Thika Branch elections, and testified that the voting process started an hour late, as he arrived at the venue at 9.10 am. The late submission of election materials from the KUPPET National Office occasioned the delay. The security apparatus was delayed in being fully prepared for the elections at the polling station.
Mbayaji testified that the voting commenced at 11 am after a brief meeting and consultation with the candidates and their agents. Voters were verified by checking their identification cards and pay slips through the TSC online platform. About an hour into the process, poor crowd management halted verification, and the agents agreed to move the verification points to the voting room.
Mbayaji testified that a fresh verification process started inside the voting room after almost 4 hours of delay, forcing the elections to end at 9.15 pm. The candidates and the RI agents did not raise any complaints of any double voting as alleged in the petition. Every voter was issued with 13 ballot papers equal to the number of positions being contested. The vote counting was undertaken with the agents of the respective candidates present, and they signed the report. The agents verified the voting and the counting and confirmed it was procedural and valid.
Upon cross-examination, Mbayaji testified that under the KUPPET constitution, the elections should start at 6 am and close at 6 pm, but in this case, they started at 11 am and closed at 9.15 pm. This was because the elections started late, and candidates and agents agreed to start at 11 am. The agreement to start the elections late was by consensus. Later, the elections stopped for two hours due to poor voter verification management. To make up for the lost time, voting stopped for 2 more hours. Crowd management was a problem. There were 8 police officers, and later, over 15 were added. It was not his role to control the police officers providing security. However, due to poor security and voter verification processes, the election had to stop to bring in more security for crowd control.
Mbayaji testified that election management was his responsibility, but security within the polling station was not part of his duties. It is not correct that there was double voting without verification or a breach of voter verification. It was agreed that the candidates should vote first, and they were all verified on the voter register, which was crossed. The 1st petitioner voted, but the register was not crossed. He could not verify whether he was a candidate. About 2,500 teachers voted, and each voter had 13 ballot papers for each position.
The returning officer was responsible for verifying the voter register. The 1st petitioner is number 178 on the register, and her name is not crossed, as with voter number 151. The 2nd petitioner, No. 283, was a candidate, and her name is crossed as having voted. It was not necessary to verify the candidates. The respondents have not filed a report on the reconciliation of the ballot papers that are supposed to be deposited in court, but the 2nd and 3rd respondents hold them.
Ann Kanake, the Ag. Registrar of Trade Unions testified that the prayers sought in the petition are unjustified and that the Kiambu branch elections were held within the law and have since been registered. The Labour Officer who presided over the elections filed a report with her office and confirmed that the elections complied with the union constitution and the LR. The letter dated 13 January 2026 addressed all the petitioners' concerns. Voters were verified, and the election returns confirm this.
Ms Kanake testified that in her letter dated 13 January 2026, she addressed all the issues raised by the petitioners and gave the elections a clean bill of health. The presiding officer's report, prepared by the Labour Officer, was factual and complied with LRA requirements. There was sufficient security within the polling station, and the elections were peaceful. The few security breaches were addressed without compromising the elections. The election results have since been registered.
Upon cross-examination, Ms Kanake testified that she does not preside over the union elections; the Labour Officers do. In this case, she received a report confirming that the elections started late, and that reasons were addressed with the candidates and their agents. For lost time, additional time was allowed to ensure every voter in the queue voted, including the petitioners.
In response, the 1st respondent argues that it has no cause of action against the Interested Party. Article 41 of the Constitution protects a trade union's right to conduct its own affairs freely and independently of state or judicial interference. The LRA primarily governs trade union elections through the provisions of the union constitution. For the 1st respondent, Article 13.0 of its constitution provides the framework for KUPPET elections both at branch and national levels.
The 1st respondent lawfully discharged its mandate. The Interested Party’s role as candidates vying for elective seats was to join their supporters in voting and then await the outcome. Section 34 of the LRA was adhered to.
After the elections, the union gave notice to the 3rd respondent by tendering Form Q under section 35 of the LRA. The results have since been registered, and Kiambu Branch has new officials.
The response is that the elections were conducted in accordance with the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Trade Union Election Disputes) Procedures and Practice Directions 2025, which do not envisage a vacuum in union leadership. Following the Kiambu branch elections, the Registrar of Trade Unions has since registered new officials.
The Trade Union Elections Rules set a high evidentiary threshold for nullifying union elections. Rule 5(3)(b) requires the production of affidavits and exhibits by a petitioner to demonstrate the alleged irregularities, which the petitioners have failed to address. The elections-supervising authority was the 3rd respondent and lawfully discharged its mandate. The 3rd respondent addressed this in the Replying Affidavit dated 3 January 2026. It has attached the 2nd respondent’s report, which does not support the petitioners' assertions.
The petitioners sent no complaints to the 3rd respondent regarding the Kiambu branch elections. The ones received were addressed and found without merit. The proper cause of action was to file an appeal under section 30 of the LRA, which the petitioners have failed to address. Nothing remains to adjudicate, and the petition should be dismissed with costs.
In evidence, the 1st respondent called 8 witnesses.
Simon Mwaniki testified that he is an interested party in these proceedings and participated in the Kiambu branch elections held on 10 January 2026. The petitioner's allegations are misleading and not factual. The elections did not start on time due to logistical issues, but all the parties present, including the petitioners, agreed to start at 11 a.m., and everyone present voted. The 1st petitioner voted last to confirm that he had a fair chance.
Mwaniki testified that voter verification was adhered to up to the last voter, and only bona fide union members were allowed to vote. This was done in consultation with the petitioners' agents who were present; they participated and verified every step. Each voter was allocated a single ballot paper for each position, and multiple voting was not possible. There is no evidence of multiple voting. Security was in place, and the voting venue was secured.
Maureen Makena testified that she is an interested party and the union elections were held in compliance with the union constitution. National officials oversaw the elections, and the Labour Officer presided to ensure transparency and accountability in the electoral process. All eligible members were verified and allowed to vote. The petitioners have failed to substantiate the allegations, and the petition is intended to disrupt the will of the people in a lawful election.
Lawrence Kiruthi testified that he is an interested party and the voting started at 11 am and closed at 7.30 pm after the 1st petitioner had voted. The Labour Officer presided over the elections and filed a report, which the respondents confirmed, and the election returns were registered. The late start of voting was due to delays in the national office bringing the voting material to the polling station. All the voters were properly vetted before being allowed to cast their votes. Over 20 police officers provided security at the polling station. Because of the large crowd of over 3,000 teachers and the extended voting into the night, additional police officers were provided from Thika to enhance security. The voting area was marked and secured.
Kiruthi testified that the tallying of votes was conducted in the presence of all agents and upon request, a recount was conducted demonstrating transparency and openness. At the end of the elections, the agents signed the relevant forms to confirm the returns.
David Omido testified that he is an interested party in these proceedings and participated in the union elections on 10 January 2026. He was a candidate, and his agents were present throughout the voting, counting and tallying until the declaration of results. All the candidates, including the petitioners, and their agents were present throughout the voting process until the announcement of results at around 9 pm.
Omido testified that the presiding officer was present to oversee the elections. The extension of time was by consent of all the candidates, including the 1st petitioner. The extension of time was lawful and permitted under Part C of the KUPPET constitution to allow all those in the voting queue to cast their vote. No candidate objected that voter verification was not done properly, or that agency fee payers or unauthorised persons were allowed to vote. There is no evidence of multiple voting as alleged, or that some voters were issued with over 20 ballot papers. The elections were free and fair.
Oliver Wamachari testified that he participated in the Kiambu branch elections on 10 January 2026. However, during voting, the 1st petitioner attacked him, causing a commotion. Before the assault, voting was proceeding smoothly. After this incident, the police intervened and directed him to leave the voting area. At the time, the 1st petitioner was shouting at the voters, and when the witness tried to cast his vote, he was attacked. He reported the matter to Thika Police Station, and a criminal case is ongoing at Thika Law Court.
Wamachari testified that due to the assault, voting stopped for about 2 hours to have the matter resolved. He obtained a P3 form from the police, received treatment, and obtained a medical report. The 1st petitioner’s conduct solely caused the violence at the polling station. Before he was assaulted, he had been able to vote.
John Muriithi testified that he witnessed the 1st petitioner attacking Wamachari at the polling station. Before the assault, voting was peaceful, but protests after the assault caused chaos, and the voting exercise stopped for about 2 hours to resolve the matter. Additional police officers were called in. Wamachari reported the case to the police, and they took him to the nearest hospital. Wamachari was not attacked for holding over 20 ballot papers, as the petitioners alleged. There was no such evidence produced.
Pauland Machofi testified that he witnessed the 1st petitioner popularly known as “JT” assaulting Wamachari at the polling station. He pulled his shirt, climbed the table and then proceeded with the attack. The police were called, restored security, and voting went ahead to conclusion.
Samuel Ndungi Kariithi testified in support of the responses and said that, before voting, all voters and candidates were verified. National officials were present and ensured the voter register was crossed off after each voter was verified. He was a candidate for Assistant Executive Secretary, and the votes were tallied and the results announced, after which the Registrar of Trade Unions registered the election.
Submissions
The petitioners submitted that the elections held on 10 January 2026 for the Kiambu branch were flawed on the basis that they did not start on time, which is admitted; voting was suspended for several hours due to inadequate security, which is admitted; the voter verification process collapsed and was relocated midway through polling, and security arrangements were grossly inadequate. These facts are not contested. Additionally, the electoral register does not reconcile with the declared election results. The election results cannot be independently verified. The cumulative effect is that the elections were not credible and cannot be verified.
Under section 34(1) of the LRA, the mandatory term is that trade union officials' elections must be conducted in accordance with the union constitution. In Eliud Wanjohi Gwandaru v Samuel Waita K & 11 others [2021] KEELRC 1617 (KLR), the court held that section 34 of the LRA deals with the election of union officials and that, where there is a dispute, it must be referred to the court. In this case, the respondents did not address the petitioners' complaints, necessitating these proceedings.
In Michael Ochieng Magungu v Registrar of Trade Unions & 2 others [2017] KEELRC 923 (KLR), the court held that section 34(1) of the LRA requires a trade union election to be held in accordance with its constitution. However, in this case, although the election notice required the elections to be held on 10 January 2026 from 6 am to 6 pm, they did not start until 11 am without justification. The elections did not close until after 9 pm, contrary to the union constitution and the notice issued to the union members. This breach was not justified and resulted in invalid elections.
In Odinga & another v IEBC & 6 Others (Election Petition 1 of 2017) KESC 52 (KLR), the court held that verification, aggregation, tallying, and declaration of election results are interconnected stages of the electoral process, and each must be undertaken in accordance with the governing electoral framework. These principles apply in this case. The court cannot consider the KUPPET Kiambu branch elections in isolation based only on the announced results and voter verification. Security, candidate admission and regulation, actual voting, preservation of the electoral register, tallying, and declaration of results are all interconnected. Elections must be conducted in a manner that is accurate, verifiable, secure and transparent. The entire electoral system must be accountable.
The petitioners submitted that the elections were not conducted freely and fairly. The polling station environment was hostile, chaotic and lacked security. Additional police officers had to be called in later in the day and stretching into the night. The petitioners testified that voting had to stop for 2 hours due to chaos and overcrowding. The respondents corroborated this, stating that, due to security breaches, voting stopped and additional police officers were called in. The presiding officer, the Labour Officer, admitted on cross-examination that voting was suspended for 2 hours; crowd control was needed, and voters had to be shifted for verification due to disorder.
The 4th, 9th, and 6th interested parties, including Wamachari and John Muriithi, confirmed these assertions and evidence. Security at the polling station was poor, and voter verification was compromised. The case and incident relayed by Wamachari, that he was assaulted, led to the stoppage of voting.
The petitioner submitted that the elections were not verifiable and the official electoral register was not credible. The voter register is not an ordinary electoral document. It carries relevant information that goes to the heart of the elections. In IEBC v Mana Kiai & 5 others [2017] eKLR, the court held that accuracy of the count is fundamental in any election. Voter turnout determines the outcome of an electoral contest. Numbers therefore are unchangeable, but they are everything in an election. The declaration form containing those results is a primary document, and all subsequent forms are only tallies of the original and final result recorded.
The election results that were declared in this case reflect entirely different figures:
a) Chairman had 2,543 votes.
b) Organising secretary had 2,518 votes cast.
c) Vice chairperson had 2,514 votes cast.
d) Executive secretary had 2,536 votes cast.
e) Assistant executive secretary had 2,536 votes cast.
f) Treasurer had 2,537 votes cast.
g) Secretary secondary had 2,560 votes cast.
h) Gender secretary had 2,578 votes cast.
i) First assistant gender secretary had 2,545 votes cast.
j) Second assistant gender secretary had 2,206 votes cast.
In all positions except second assistant gender secretary, more votes were cast than the number of verified voters in the voter register. The data given is not correct. The Labour Officer, as the returning officer, could not explain the disparities. The Registrar of Trade Unions also could not decipher from the officer's report an explanation for these disparities.
The petitioners submitted that the case by the 1st petitioner that the voter register was not verifiable and hence unreliable is correct. The 1st petitioner voted, but his name is not marked on the voter register. No credible explanation exists for this lapse.
Under the prescribed voting procedure, the voter register should have been crossed after voting. A mark should have indicated that the voter had already been verified and voted. As a result, the voting process cannot be verified.
The registration of the election results cannot validate an unlawful and invalid electoral process. The petition should be allowed.
The 1st respondent and interested parties submitted that the petition is premised on allegations that the elections held on 10 January 2026 were marred by irregularities because they started late, there was a suspension, there were security challenges, the voter verification point was relocated, and there were alleged deficiencies in the voters' register. These allegations are incorrect, and the petitioners have not supported them with evidence. The elections were conducted peacefully and transparently; the petitioners were involved and confirmed that they voted, and their agents verified the process.
Articles 36 and 41 of the Constitution protect the right to associate and join a trade union of choice. Section 34 of the LRA allows the trade union to conduct elections in accordance with its constitution, which the 1st respondent adhered to. All eligible voters participated democratically. No complaint was raised, and the challenges noted by the 3rd respondent were adequately addressed.
Thus, the court's inquiry is not whether the election was flawless but whether it substantially complied with the governing framework. Procedural imperfections do not automatically invalidate an election unless they materially undermine democratic participation, electoral integrity or the outcome itself. In Mbaabu & another v Kenya National Union of Teachers (KNUT) & another [2026] KEELRC 1616 (KLR), the court held that not every irregularity warrants nullification of an election, and a petitioner must demonstrate material and consequential irregularities affecting either the integrity of the process or the electoral outcome.
The petition is premature for want of exhaustion of the statutory dispute resolution mechanism. After the elections, the presiding Labour Officer filed a report with the 3rd respondent. The petitioners filed complaints, which were considered and found to be without merit, and the elections proceeded. Pursuant to section 34 of the LRA, the petitioners ought to have invoked section 30 of the LRA to challenge the adverse decision. Moving the court under the petition is premature, as a law exists for challenging the registrar’s decision. In Geoffrey Muthinja Kabiru & 2 others v Samuel Munga Henry & 1756 others [2015] eKLR, the court held that where Parliament has established specialised dispute resolution mechanisms, such procedure should be invoked before moving the court.
The 1st respondent and interested parties submitted that the delayed commencement of polling was explained by the circumstances facing the presiding labour officer. A meeting was held, and the explanation given was found reasonable.
The temporary stoppage of elections was due to a security breach, which was addressed immediately by providing additional security officers. The disturbance did not affect the integrity of the elections, and every voter present, including the petitioners, was allowed to vote. A security breach alone is not sufficient ground to nullify the entire electoral process where voters expressed their democratic will.
The relocation of the verification point enhanced the integrity of the elections and did not amount to an irregularity as alleged. Significantly, the petitioner failed to identify a single unregistered voter who voted, a single voter who voted more than once or a single ballot unlawfully issued.
The petitioner did not particularise the alleged disparities in the voter register. They did not explain how they arose or affected the election result. Generalised allegations are insufficient to satisfy the burden imposed by section 107 and 109 of the Evidence Act.
The election satisfied the constitutional and legal provisions, and the 3rd respondent discharged its mandate by addressing the petitioners' complaints and finding them to have no merit. On this basis, the election results have since been registered, and there are no reasons to allow the petition, which essentially seeks to change the majority view and the democratic choices expressed during the elections held on 10 January 2026.
The 1st respondent and interested parties submitted that nullifying the elections would be disproportionate. The elections were held in January 2026, and results were declared, and Form Q was submitted with a registration. The respondents have since discharged their mandate. In George Ondiege & 3 others v Albert Obed Njeru & 2 others [2017] eKLR, the court held that registration and assumption of office are relevant considerations in determining whether the reliefs sought have been overtaken by events, which is the case here. The petition is premature, overtaken by events and raises no substantive issue that should allow the nullification of the elections.
The 2nd and 3rd respondents submitted that the petitioners seek nullification of the elections held on 10 January 2026, invalidation of the results registration, and an order for fresh elections. The petition largely rests on the commencement of polling, security and crowd-management difficulties, alleged defects in the voter register, failure to cross certain candidates' names, alleged multiple voting, and a numerical variance between names marked in the register and votes recorded for particular positions. The 2nd respondent officer presided over the elections and confirmed that the elections were operationally perfect. The presiding officer admitted that the elections did not start on time at 6 am and explained that the delay resulted from logistical difficulties, including the late arrival of election materials. This imperfection is not sufficiently serious to justify nullification of results.
The 2nd and 3rd respondents submitted that voter verification was undertaken, ballot papers were issued, and voting was done to the last person, including the 1st petitioner. The votes were counted and recounted to the satisfaction of all candidates and their agents. The alleged double voting or issuance of multiple ballot papers was not proved.
Regarding alleged security and crowd management incidents, the 2nd respondent cannot be held liable for any breaches. This role was not on the presiding officer; the security deployed at the polling station were additional security officers, and voting continued until the last voter.
In any case, the alleged violence at the polling station was caused by the 1st petitioner, and Oliver Wamachari testified and identified his attacker as the 1st petitioner. On this basis, the 1st petitioner was instructed to leave the polling station due to disruptions. This evidence is corroborated by Polland and David, who witnessed the attack on Wamachari. The petitioners cannot benefit from their misconduct.
The candidates and their agents verified the integrity of the vote. The petitioners confirmed that they had agents present during the entire polling process. Other candidates, including the interested parties who were candidates, had secured the process through their agents. The petitioners have therefore failed to establish that the elections held on 10 January 2026 were marred by irregularities sufficient to justify the reliefs sought. In Magare Gikenyi B & 3 Others v KUPPET & 3 Others [2026] KEELRC 243 (KLR), the court held that courts should be cautious about disturbing collective electoral choice absent proof of a fundamental failure of the electoral process.
The voter register and the numerical discrepancies should not invalidate the election. The respondents called evidence to disprove the petition. The 1st petitioner testified that he voted, but his name was not crossed off the voter register. He exercised his right to vote. The Labour officer admitted that the candidates underwent verification connected to their candidature, and the absence of a crossing out in the voter register, without more, does not prove that a candidate was not verified or voted illegally. Other candidates admitted that they voted without their names being crossed out on the register. This is not a material breach warranting nullification of the elections.
The petitioners rely on approximately 2,423 names crossed out in the register against 2,536 votes recorded for one position, with a variance of 113. This arithmetic variance does not necessarily mean 113 illegal votes. The returning officer testified that each voter received 13 ballot papers for the 13 positions. Stray votes could explain the variance. The petitioners did not reconcile the variance to show the additional votes were cast by non-members, represented multiple voting or favoured some candidates.
The voter register alone is inconclusive. The petition's claim that the crossed names are conclusive as to who voted, while arguing that it is unverifiable, is contradictory. If unreliable, the voter register cannot be used to assert that only 2,423 persons voted. Different results for each position do not prove the alleged fraud. In a secret ballot process, the 2nd respondent, as the presiding officer, could not guide any voter on how to cast the vote.
The elections were free and fair and conducted in accordance with the 1st respondent's Constitution, the LRA and Articles 36 and 41 of the Constitution. The 3rd respondent has since registered the elected officials who are serving. The petition is without merit and should be dismissed with costs.
The 7th interested party submitted and supported the 1st respondent and the interested parties' case. He reiterated that the issue of voting several hours late was compensated by extending the voting until late, and the 1st petitioner voted last. The suspension of voting was due to violence caused by the 1st petitioner, and the matter was reported to the police. The conduct of the 1st petitioner should be reviewed in view of the orders sought in this petition.
The petitioners did not protest the voter verification process being moved from one location to another. They should not be permitted to raise this matter to seek nullification of the elections. The alleged inadequacy of security within the polling station did not materially affect voting, tallying, counting, or the declaration of results. The petition should be dismissed with costs.
Determination
On the pleadings, the evidence, and the written submissions, the issues for determination are whether the KUPPET Kiambu Branch elections held on 10 January 2026 were lawful and valid; whether the reliefs sought by the petitioners have merit; and who should pay costs.
Before delving into the analysis of the petition, the 1st respondent and interested parties submitted that the petition is premature and that, upon the 3rd respondent's response on 13 January 2026, the petitioners ought to have moved the court under section 30 of the LRA. The petition is about the elections held on 10 January 2026 by the Kiambu branch of KUPPET. Under the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Trade Union Election Disputes) Procedures and Practice Directions 2025, a petitioner may challenge the lawfulness and constitutionality of the elections.
The petition challenges the lawfulness of the KUPPET Kiambu branch elections held on 10 January 2026. The 3rd respondent presided over the election as required under the LRA.
The petition challenges the entire electoral process, including the voter register and allowing those on agency fees to vote; the Election Day notice and the start and end hours altered without justification; the verification of the voters lacked integrity; and the allocation of ballot papers was unverifiable. Cumulatively, the vote counting vis-à-vis the eligible voters was compromised; hence, the elections should be invalidated, and fresh elections ordered. These are the issues in the petition and not the decision of the 3rd respondent.
Indeed, the facts admitted in this petition are as follows.
1) That the Kiambu Branch elections held on 10 January 2026 started at about 11 am and closed at around 10 or 11 pm into the night.
2) Voter verification was not properly managed. The voter register was not consistently marked. Some voters' names were not crossed out.
3) The petitioner lodged a complaint with the 1st respondent, and in the response dated 13 January 2026, there is an admission that the election started late. During voter verification, it was admitted that crowd management was poor.
4) At around 2 pm, voting stopped due to violence. The police had to be called in, and additional police officers were later called in.
5) The 1st petitioner voted last around 9 pm, and his name was not crossed off the voter register. He is voter No. 151 on the voter register.
6) Voter No. 178, Peter Githuka, is confirmed as having voted, but his name is not crossed off the voter register.
Voter verification is sacrosanct to any election. It is a fundamental requirement in any democratic election. Without voter verification, double voting, non-eligible persons voting, or manipulation of records to make an election appear genuine are possible. The petitioners raised the issue that when voting started late at 11 a.m on 10 January 2026, voter verification was in place. However, this was abandoned, and voters ended up queuing. This evidence is corroborated by the respondent’s witness Wamachari, who confirmed that he was in a queue and was allocated 13 ballot papers.
Some witnesses confirmed that despite receiving 13 ballot papers, they did not cast all of them. They were interested in specific offices. However, the remaining ballots were not accounted for. For example, someone may have voted only for the position of executive secretary and not any other office.
Where are the remaining ballot papers?
Who accounted for these?
Voter verification, therefore, matters to the entire election.
Accounting for each ballot paper is the result.
Announcing an election result without accounting for the entire electoral process is simply a mirage. It cannot suffice. Once the process's integrity is compromised, the result cannot sanitise it.
a) Some of the election returns are not signed or dated by the Returning Officer:
The position of treasurer is not signed and is overwritten;
The Assistant Executive Secretary is not signed or dated.
Assistant Treasurer is not signed or dated.
b) The returns overwritten are not countersigned.
c) Votes garnered do not tally based on the voter register. The example of the assistant treasurer,
Daniel Mureithi garnered 1119 votes;
Simon Mwangi garnered 1278 votes;
Total: 2,397 votes.
Casted votes = 2,498
Spoilt votes = 101.
There is a disparity in how each vote is accounted for. Whether spoilt or valid, each should be accounted for.
The 1st petitioner testified at length on the arithmetic. The audited voter register had 2,423 names crossed out, against 2,536 votes recorded for one position. The variance of 113 remains unexplained. This arithmetic variance is not minor, as the respondents submitted.
The petitioners gave the case of unauthorised persons voting. They cited the case of Kamau Kamatu as an example. He is not a teacher nor a member of the Kiambu branch. He, however, remained at the voting hall. No one identified him as an agent or as someone needed at the voting hall. This issue received no attention. There is no response at all!
Another example is the executive secretary position, with 2,536 votes cast, 107 spoilt votes, and 1,216 garnered votes.
The treasurer position had 2,537 votes cast, 178 spoilt, and 1,334 garnered votes.
The baseline was the voter register, which showed 2,423 voters.
A variance of 113 votes becomes a critical number. It cannot be ignored as being peripheral. Each vote should count, and this is the essence of an election.
Where each voter had 13 ballot papers, and in the position of assistant treasurer a total of 2,397 voted, a proper application of the voter register would show that, of all those who voted, a paltry 26 ballot papers were spoiled.
In an ideal situation, all 2,423 voters, each with 13 ballot papers, should account for 31,499 votes. These include correctly placed, spoiled, and unaccounted-for votes.
The petitioners' assertions that there was voting by non-members, voter registration, multiple voting, and that some voters received over 20 ballot papers are correct based on the voter register. Reconciling this was not the petitioners' function but the collective responsibility of the respondents.
The election returns, with each voter receiving 13 ballot papers for the 13 positions, should be accounted for in an open and democratic process. Such is lacking in this case. The disparities highlighted by the petitioners are not just random. They go to the integrity of the elections.
In Maina Kiai & 2 others v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & another [2016] KEHC 7738 (KLR), the court held that due process of law, as well as the integrity of the electoral process and the sanctity of the votes cast, is integral to the entire electoral process.
The integrity of the process secures good governance, integrity, transparency and accountability.
This position is supported by Article 41(1) and (4) of the Constitution and Section 34(1) of the LRA. Whereas the Constitution allows every trade union the freedom to organise its programmes and activities without restriction and to conduct union elections based on its constitution, in conducting elections, the trade union, such as the 1st respondent, has the opportunity, indeed a duty, to vet all its prospective voters to ensure they pass the integrity test before allowing them to participate and vote at branch or national elections. The core of section 34(1) of the LRA:
(1) The election of officials of a trade union, employers’ organisation or federation shall be conducted in accordance with their registered constitutions.
As with national elections, the 1st respondent owes a duty to its members and must protect its integrity. This position is aptly captured in Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission v Kiai & 5 others [2017] KECA 477 (KLR), where the court held:
“The responsibility of the appellant to deliver a credible and acceptable election in accordance with the Constitution is so grave and so awesome that it must approach and execute it with absolute fealty, probity and integrity. In all its dealings, the appellant must be truly above suspicion and command the respect of the people of Kenya for whom it acts. Much depends on it, indeed, the country's present and future peace.”
Equally, the 1st respondent, with membership spread nationwide, must, through each branch, like a constituency, cumulatively account for each vote and position. A credible and acceptable election, in accordance with the national values in the Constitution and the Union Constitution, must be above board.
Michael Mwangi's evidence was not materially challenged. His case was that:
“Voter verification was extremely disorganised and unreliable. The verification desk for the register of eligible teachers was initially placed approximately fifty meters away from the voting hall. The desk was poorly manned and overwhelmed, and verification was not consistently conducted, allowing several teachers to proceed to vote without being verified or marked on the register.”
This evidence is corroborated by the 1st petitioner and the Labour Officer who presided over the elections. The 1st petitioner confirmed that his name was not marked on the register, yet he voted. He observed several other voters whose names were not marked on the register.
The Labour Officer admitted that the candidates had agreed to vote first without being marked on the register. Such an agreement was not produced. Allowing some voters to vote without verifying their names on the register was a fundamental breach of the electoral process.
Who were allowed to vote without verification?
Where is the agreement? Even if such an agreement existed, is it valid and legitimate?
Who allowed these changes?
In Miano & 4 others v Kenya Union of Post-Primary Education Teachers (KUPPET) & 9 others [2026] KEELRC 1330 (KLR), the court grappled with the issue of indiscriminate application of the voter register. Non-members or those under agency were allowed to vote, and the voter verification was opaque.
The voter register therefore becomes a critical, foundational record for any election. When voters are not verified at the start, the result is already compromised.
This position is aptly captured in Frankline Kaburu Kinoti & 3 others v University Academic Staff Union [Uasu] Executive, Kenyatta University Chapter & 3 others; Kenyatta University (Interested Party) [2021] KEELRC 1059 (KLR), where the court held:
To borrow from the Supreme Court of Kenya in Raila Amolo Odinga & Another v. Independent Electoral Boundaries & 2 Others [2017] e-KLR, the UASU elections of 25th March 2021 were full of illegalities and irregularities. The electoral principles coming out of this decision, ought to guide Trade Unions in conduct of transparent, fair and accountable elections. Processes that do not meet the high standards of democracy set in the decision, risk being reversed, irrespective of the outcomes. No candidate claiming success under such a flawed process, merits being placed in office. The process leading to elections, is as important as the actual voting on the election date. The Chapter’s leadership bungled the entire electoral process.
The principle is that the process leading to elections is as important as the actual voting on election day. The voter register is too important to be ignored.
Regarding the venue for the elections, the issues forming part of the petition largely arose from the late commencement of the voting process. The Labour Officer presiding testified that he reported late to the venue at 7.30 am on 10 January 2026 due to logistical challenges. Eventually, voting could not start because the 1st respondent held the electoral materials.
Elections were held at Kolping Centre, Kilimambogo in Thika.
Accessibility to the polling station falls within the realm of transparency and accountability. In Joho & another v Shahbal & 2 others [2014] KESC 34 (KLR) and Odinga & another v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 2 others; Aukot & another (Interested Parties); Attorney General & another (Amicus Curiae) [2017] KESC 42 (KLR), the courts have held that a polling station should be at a public place convenient or accessible to the public. And in Shakombo & another v Registrar of Trade Unions & 13 others (Trade Union Election Petition E009 of 2026) [2026] KEELRC 1652 (KLR) (17 June 2026) (Judgment), the court held that a particular venue chosen as the polling station must be assessed for its accessibility, centrality, convenience, and familiarity to members. Choosing a venue that creates formidable access challenges impedes the right to vote. The chosen venue must be justified in light of these challenges.
Although Kolping Centre is within Kiambu County, a survey of the entire county places it at the furthest end to the east; the west end is Limuru, the north is Gatundu, and to the south is Kiambu town. A consultative process on the most central, accessible venue is necessary. KUPPET leadership, in consultation with the current leadership of the Kiambu branch and based on the voter register, needs to select an accessible venue. Choosing Kolping Centre, situated at the furthest eastern end of Kiambu County, largely disenfranchises most voters.
The petitioners also sought orders to stop the gazetting or recognition of the officials elected on 10 January 2026 and to bar them from assuming office. They sought these orders in the interim. However, the LRA does not envisage a vacuum. The 3rd respondent, based on the prevailing returns after the elections on 10 January 2026, has since registered the elected persons as Kiambu Branch officials.
For objectivity, and as outlined above, the elections held on 10 January 2026 for Kiambu Branch were irregular; listing these persons as officials and proceeding to organise a fresh election would be a great injustice to the petitioners and all members affected by the irregularities. The registration of officials effected on 15 January 2026 with effect from 10 January 2026 is hereby quashed.
The Kiambu branch shall revert to the position subsisting before 10 January 2026 until fresh elections are held and the 3rd respondent lawfully registers new officials for the branch.
In the penultimate paragraph, the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Trade Union Election Disputes) Procedures and Practice Directions 2025 were intended to facilitate and regulate trade union elections. Rules 5 and 13 thereof allow for the provision of election materials. The petitioners asked to be supplied with the voter register. This register under the Trade Union Rules should be preserved in court. However, the 2nd respondent should be the repository of such records. Whereas the Rules as couched exist, the clarity of where a petitioner is to source the election materials post the elections is a matter that all stakeholders, including the court, should address urgently. A review to ease this burden for a petitioner or any other party seeking to review such materials should be returned to the stakeholders.
On the whole, the Court is persuaded that the Petition is merited, in that the outcome of the KUPPET Kiambu Branch elections held on 10 January was not conducted in a transparent, fair, and accountable manner. The Court is satisfied that the rights of the petitioners guaranteed under Article 41(2)(c) of the Constitution and Section 4(2)(b) of the Labour Relations Act were violated through the elections marred by irregularities.
Accordingly, the petition is with merit, and the following orders are issued:
a) A declaration is hereby issued that the KUPPET Kiambu Branch elections held on 10 January 2026 were irregular and lacked credibility.
b) Consequently, the election results arising from the said elections held on 10 January 2026 are hereby nullified.
c) The registration of officials effected on 15 January 2026 with effect from 10 January 2026 is hereby quashed. The Kiambu branch officials shall revert to their positions as before 10 January 2026.
d) The respondents shall collectively update the voters’ register for the KUPPET Kiambu branch and make the same available to all members for scrutiny and verification before the conduct of fresh elections.
e) Upon the updating and verification of the voters’ register by members, fresh elections shall be conducted within sixty (60) days hereof in accordance with the applicable law and the Constitution of the Union.
f) The elections as in (d) above shall be held at a central venue within Kiambu County to accommodate all members for accessibility.
g) The parties are engaged in unionisation and for industrial peace; no orders on costs.
Dated this 15th Day of October 2026
M. MBARU
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Court Assistant: Mohammed Ali