Background
For determination is the Statement of Claim dated 27th February 2019, where the Claimant seeks the following remedies against the Respondent: -
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
The claim succeeded in part. The Court declared the termination unfair and unlawful; awarded KShs. 2,725,100, being seven months’ salary as compensation; ordered a certificate of service within 14 days; directed interest at court rates from judgment until payment; and awarded the Claimant costs. Reinstatement, salary for the unexpired contract period, and general, aggravated, exemplary, and constitutional damages were refused.
a) A declaration be and is hereby issued that the termination of the Claimant’s employment was unfair and unlawful.
Passage 121 →
b) That the Claimant is awarded compensation equivalent to seven (7) months’ salary for the unfair termination at KShs. 2,725,100/-
Passage 122 →
e) The Claimant shall have the costs of the suit.
Passage 125 →
Held. The termination was substantively and procedurally unfair, and therefore unlawful. The Respondent did not prove that the forgery/dishonesty allegations were valid and fair grounds for dismissal: its evidence was inconsistent and lacked reliable supporting proof. It also failed to establish a Section 41-compliant disciplinary hearing, including notice of the right to be accompanied and a meaningful hearing before termination.
Ratio. Under Sections 43, 45 and 47(5) of the Employment Act, once unfair termination is put in issue, the employer must justify the reasons for termination as valid and fair and establish fair procedure. For misconduct dismissal, Section 41 requires an explanation of the contemplated grounds, an opportunity to be accompanied by a fellow employee or union representative, and an opportunity to be heard before the decision. Asking an employee to explain a transaction does not, without more, satisfy that disciplinary process.
Issue
i. Whether the Claimant’s termination was both substantively and procedurally fair and lawful.
Passage 77 →
Held
62. In the circumstances, I am not satisfied that the Respondent discharged its burden under Sections 43 and 45 of the Employment Act, and which renders the termination substantively unfair.
Paragraph 62 →
69. Consequently, I find and hold that the termination was also procedurally unfair.
Paragraph 69 →
Ratio
53. On substantive fairness, Section 43(1) of the Employment Act places the burden upon an employer to prove the reason or reasons for termination, while Section 45(2) requires the employer to establish that the reason (s) was valid and fair and that the termination was undertaken in accordance with fair procedure. Under Section 47(5), the employee bears the initial burden of demonstrating that the termination was unfair, while the employer bears the burden of justifying the grounds for the termination.
Paragraph 53 →
63. On whether the termination adhered to the tenets of procedural fairness, Section 41 of the Employment Act demands that an employer contemplating termination on grounds of misconduct explains to the employee, in a language the employee understands, the reason for which termination is being considered. The provision further requires that the employee be allowed to have another employee or a shop-floor union representative present during the explanation and should also be accorded an opportunity to be heard before the decision is made.
Paragraph 63 →
66. Further, the correspondence concerning the financial queries and the meeting held to obtain an explanation cannot, without more, be equated with compliance with the statutory disciplinary process. The fact that an employee is asked to explain a transaction does not dispense with the obligation to conduct a fair hearing before a decision to terminate employment is made.
Paragraph 66 →
Held. The Claimant was awarded compensation of seven months’ salary, KShs. 2,725,100, and a certificate of service. Reinstatement was unavailable because more than three years had elapsed since dismissal. Salary for the unexpired contract term was denied, as unfair termination does not automatically entitle an employee to the contractual balance. General, aggravated and exemplary damages were declined because no independent basis or special circumstances were proved; no separate constitutional damages were warranted. The monetary award attracts interest from judgment, and the Claimant received costs.
Ratio. Reinstatement cannot be ordered after the three-year statutory limit. Remedies for unfair termination are governed by Section 49; compensation, up to twelve months’ gross salary, is discretionary and must reflect the statutory factors and the case circumstances, including mitigation. A finding of unfair termination alone does not justify separate general, aggravated, or exemplary damages without an independent legal basis and supporting circumstances.
Issue
ii. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the remedies sought.
Passage 78 →
Held
71. The Claimant’s employment was terminated on 30th November, 2018, and the matter is now being determined in 2026. The statutory period has therefore expired, and the Court cannot grant reinstatement.
Paragraph 71 →
84. These prayers are therefore without basis, and are hereby declined.
Paragraph 84 →
b) That the Claimant is awarded compensation equivalent to seven (7) months’ salary for the unfair termination at KShs. 2,725,100/-
Passage 122 →
Ratio
70. The Claimant seeks reinstatement without loss of benefits, seniority or continuity of service. Section 12(3)(vii) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act limits the power to order reinstatement to three years from the date of dismissal.
Paragraph 70 →
75. The appropriate remedy is determined within the statutory framework governing unfair termination, specifically Section 49 of the Employment Act.
Paragraph 75 →
82. The Claimant has sought general, aggravated and exemplary damages, alleging psychological distress, reputational harm and malicious treatment. The finding of unfair termination does not, by itself, justify separate awards of general or exemplary damages.
Paragraph 82 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
For determination is the Statement of Claim dated 27th February 2019, where the Claimant seeks the following remedies against the Respondent: -
Paragraph 1 →The question for this court is whether the Respondent proved its allegations against the Claimant and further whether the allegation is a valid and fair basis for terminating the Claimant’s employment.
Paragraph 55 →Consequently, I find and hold that the termination was also procedurally unfair.
Paragraph 69 →Whether the Respondent proved a valid and fair reason for terminating the Claimant’s employment; whether it followed the disciplinary procedure required by the Employment Act; and whether the Claimant was entitled to reinstatement, salary for the unexpired…
Desterius Shitsama Mulama was employed by Cezam and Associates Limited from 9 January 2012, initially as Financial Officer and later Program Coordinator for the USADF programme. His employment was terminated on 30 November 2018, shortly after a renewal said…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT A& LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. 152 OF 2019
DESTERIUS SHITSAMA MULAMA...........................................CLAIMANT
VERSUS
CEZAM AND ASSOCIATES LIMITED..................................RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
Introduction
1. For determination is the Statement of Claim dated 27th February 2019, where the Claimant seeks the following remedies against the Respondent: -
i. A Declaration that the Respondent intentionally breached the provisions of Section 41 of the Employment Act, 2007, Articles 10, 28, 41, 47 and 50 of the Constitution, 2010.
ii. A declaration that the Claimant has suffered unfair and wrongful termination of his employment.
iii. An order of permanent injunction to quash the termination letter dated 30th November, 2018 issued by the Respondent.
iv. An order for reinstatement of the Claimant to his former employment and position without any loss of benefit and/or seniority and continuity of service.
v. In the alternative, the payment to the Claimant’s actual pecuniary loss suffered since his date of termination of employment, including payment for salary/wages as would have been earned, housing allowance, together with all accrued allowances of the balance of the contract period, being Kshs. 4,671,600.
vi. Maximum compensation for loss of employment being 12 months.
vii. Certificate of service.
viii. General Damages.
ix. Aggravated and Exemplary Damages.
x. Any other and further relief the Honourable court may deem fit to grant.
xi. Costs of this suit with interest.
2. The Respondent entered an appearance on 2nd April 2019 and filed a Response to the claim dated 21st May 2019, in which it denied the Claimant’s claim and his entitlement to the reliefs sought.
3. An earlier ex parte judgment delivered on 30th April 2024 was set aside upon the Respondent’s application, paving the way for a full hearing of the parties herein.
4. The Claimant’s case was heard on 5th May, 2025 when CW1, Desterius Shitsama Mulama, testified in support of the Claim.
5. The Respondent’s case was subsequently heard on 3rd July 2025, when three witnesses testified in support of the Respondent’s case. RW1, Nelson Ekonmwa, adopted his witness statement dated 9th May 2019 as his evidence-in-chief. RW2, Christopher M. Chege, adopted his witness statement dated 17th January 2025, and produced the Respondent’s list and bundle of documents dated 21st May 2019, together with the supplementary documents dated 17th January 2025, as Exhibits 1-15. RW3, Moses Mwendwa, equally adopted his witness statement dated 9th May 2019.
The Claimant’s Case
6. The Claimant, CW1 Desterius Shitsama Mulama, testified that he was employed by the Respondent on 9th January 2012, initially as a Financial Officer and later as a Program Coordinator. He states that he was in charge of the United States African Development Foundation (USADF) Program in Turkana and its subsequent roll-out. He maintained that he served the Respondent for about seven years without receiving a warning or facing disciplinary proceedings, and that he had a clean employment record.
7. The Claimant further states that together with his team, he developed and implemented the USADF program and that the program underwent seven financial audits and one program audit by the Office of the Inspector General of the United States Government, which it passed. He maintains that, despite his efforts, the Respondent did not appreciate his work and that his working environment became strained.
8. The Claimant states that the circumstances preceding his termination concerned queries relating to financial records for a training conducted in Machakos in 2017. The Claimant avers that he received an email dated 26th March 2018 summoning him to the Respondent's Nairobi office, and that he attended a meeting on 27th March 2018, where he was asked to explain the accounting for the training and the alleged loss of funds, which he did, and in his view he considered it resolved.
9. He further states that no minutes were recorded in that meeting, and that he subsequently attempted to send an email setting out his explanations, but his emails did not go through after he was blocked from communicating with the Respondent.
10. On cross-examination, the Claimant confirmed that he attended the meeting and was questioned concerning the Machakos training. He maintained that his explanations established that the accounting was proper and that no money was lost. He further stated that he was not aware of any subsequent investigations and did not participate in them. He also confirmed that he had provided authentic documents relating to the training held in 2017.
11. The Claimant further testified that he was aware of the USADF policy manuals, but did not know why the grounds ultimately relied upon by the Respondent remained outstanding after the financial queries had, in his view, been addressed.
12. The Claimant testified that on 30th November, 2018, at about 6.00 p.m., as he was preparing to leave the office, he was served with a termination letter. He contended that the letter referred to matters already raised and addressed in March, 2018. He stated that he did not know the reason for his termination and that he did not receive further communication from the Respondent thereafter.
13. It is the Claimant's contention that the termination was particularly unusual on the basis that his employment contract had been renewed on or about 1st November, 2018 for a period running until 30th October 2019. He therefore contended that he had a legitimate expectation of remaining in employment until the renewed contract expired.
14. The Claimant further confirmed on cross-examination that he did not write to the Respondent through his advocates following the termination, but that he proceeded to institute the present proceedings.
15. The Claimant pleaded that at the time of termination he earned a monthly gross salary of Kshs.389,300 plus benefits. He stated that the termination left him unemployed and deprived him of salary, allowances, medical and insurance benefits and other employment benefits. He stated that the manner of termination caused him psychological distress and reputational harm.
16. The Claimant further avers that the Respondent acted maliciously and in bad faith, including by failing to issue a show cause letter, failing to accord him a fair hearing, portraying him as dishonest and fraudulent without giving him an adequate opportunity to respond, and delivering the termination letter through a junior officer after working hours.
The Claimant’s Submissions
17. The Claimant submits that the Respondent failed to establish a valid and fair reason for terminating his employment as required by Sections 43 and 45 of the Employment Act. It is his submission that the financial queries concerning the Machakos training had been addressed and that he had accounted for the funds.
18. He submits that he was not given the relevant materials nor a meaningful opportunity to answer the allegations; hence, the termination was substantively unjustified.
19. On procedural fairness, the Claimant submits that the Respondent failed to comply with Section 41 of the Employment Act by failing to issue a proper show cause letter, adequate time to respond, an invitation to a disciplinary hearing, and to inform him of his right to be accompanied by another employee or representative. He submits that he was not given an opportunity to challenge the allegations or appeal the decision.
20. It is his further submission that the alleged communication of 26th March, 2018 and the subsequent meeting did not constitute a disciplinary hearing within the meaning of Section 41.
21. Counsel relied on the renewal of the Claimant's contract on 1st November,2018 shortly before the termination, to submit that it gave rise to a legitimate expectation that he would continue serving until 30th October 2019.
22. Counsel further submitted that the Respondent's conduct violated Articles 10, 28, 41, 47 and 50 of the Constitution, particularly the Claimant's rights to dignity, fair labour practices, fair administrative action and fair hearing.
23. The Claimant finally urged the Court to find that his termination was substantively and procedurally unfair and to allow his claim as drawn.
The Respondent’s case
24. The Respondent’s case was presented through three witnesses. RW1, Nelson Ekonmwa, testified that he is a Finance Officer of the Respondent. He avers that the Claimant was unwilling to relinquish some of the roles he had previously performed.
25. The Respondent states that discrepancies had arisen between the receipts submitted by the Claimant and those held by the Respondent in relation to the Machakos training.
26. On cross-examination, RW1 admitted that he had not filed the Claimant’s job description or any evidence showing that he had protested against the Claimant taking over his roles. He further conceded that he was not an expert in forgery and therefore could not testify to the authenticity of the receipts. He also confirmed that the investigation report concerning the receipts had not been produced in evidence.
27. On re-examination, RW1 testified that the issue arose when the Director presented receipts from the same hotel which were different from those submitted by the Claimant. He stated that he informed the Director that the receipts the Claimant presented did not match those held by the Respondent, after which the Director took up the matter and conducted investigations. RW1, however, told the court that he did not know the outcome of those investigations.
28. The Respondent states that it relied on the alleged discrepancies to support its contention that the expenditure had not been satisfactorily accounted for.
29. RW2, Christopher M. Chege, testified that he is a shareholder and director of the Respondent. He denied that the Claimant was not issued with a notice to show cause or invited to a hearing. He testified that the Claimant had pleaded for forgiveness and admitted that the documents he had submitted were forged.
30. According to RW2, the Claimant did not subsequently produce authentic receipts. He confirmed that although the Claimant’s contract had been renewed, the Claimant left approximately one month thereafter. He explained that the Respondent continued engaging the Claimant because investigations were ongoing.
31. He further stated that the Claimant was issued with a notice to show cause, but he failed to respond and was subsequently notified of his termination. He avers that the termination was a summary dismissal and maintained that the Claimant was therefore not entitled to notice.
32. It is RW2's further testimony that the Respondent was implementing a program funded by the United States African Development Foundation (USADF), whose objectives included supporting agriculture and women empowerment initiatives in Africa. He stated that the Claimant was dismissed for dishonesty, arising from allegations that he had forged receipts. He confirmed that investigations were conducted but admitted that the investigation report was not produced in evidence.
33. He stated that the investigations were undertaken by several persons and not solely by the late Mr. Muchunguzi. He further confirmed that he contacted Golden Breeze Hotel to verify the receipts but admitted that no document from the hotel confirming the alleged fraud had been produced in court.
34. RW2 testified that the Respondent had a policy on internet cash handling, although he was uncertain whether the policy had been filed in court. He confirmed that the Claimant had signing authority in respect of one of the relevant documents and that the Claimant had prepared unauthorized payment vouchers which he stated were produced in evidence.
35. He also confirmed that the Respondent conducted financial audits and that no issue of the Claimant embezzling donor funds was raised in those audits. Although he alleged that the Claimant intimidated other employees, he admitted that he had not produced any complaints from the aggrieved employees. He further confirmed that Lydia Kimani had resigned, but her resignation letter was not before the Court.
36. On the disciplinary process, RW2 confirmed that an email dated 26th March, 2018 informed the Claimant that the directors wished to meet him at 4.00 p.m. of the same day. He maintained that the Claimant had sufficient time to respond and that he had been called to explain the irregularities. He acknowledged that the meeting held on 27th March 2018 was not, strictly speaking, a disciplinary hearing, but was intended to enable the Claimant to explain the irregularities relating to the receipts.
37. He further confirmed that the Respondent did not invoke a specific policy relating to forged receipts. He further confirmed that the Claimant did not attend the meeting of 27th March 2018, but maintained that he was afforded an opportunity to explain the authenticity of the receipts.
38. RW2 further confirmed that the Claimant’s contract was renewed pursuant to USADF requirements notwithstanding the ongoing investigations. He stated that the termination occurred approximately eight months after the correspondence of 26th March 2018.
39. On re-examination, RW2 stated that the late Mr. Muchunguzi was the Claimant’s supervisor and that the meeting of 27th March 2018 was convened to enable the Claimant to explain the alleged forged receipts. It is his position that the Claimant did not authenticate the receipts. He further stated that the Respondent was governed by its own operational policies and its agreement with USADF.
40. RW3, Moses Mwendwa, testified that he is an accountant employed by the Respondent, which undertook tax, financial, and accounting consultancies under the USADF program. He testified that the Respondent served the Claimant with a notice to show cause and subsequently requested a meeting by email, and that a meeting was thereafter held in the evening in the presence of three persons, namely a director in charge of the program, RW3, and the Claimant.
41. According to RW3, the Claimant was asked to account for the money and that he admitted that the invoices were wrong or fictitious. He stated that the Claimant was asked to provide authentic receipts, but he failed to do so.
42. RW3 further testified that during the meeting, the late Mr. Muchunguzi was shown receipts which were similar to those held by other officers while the Claimant’s receipts were computer-generated. He stated that Mr. Muchunguzi discovered the discrepancy during an audit he conducted.
43. On cross-examination, RW3 told the court that the Claimant was summoned to a meeting on 19th April 2018, and that an invitation had been sent by the late Mr. Muchunguzi by email on 27th March 2018. He confirmed that the letter indicated that the Claimant was being invited for a disciplinary hearing. He, however, admitted that the Claimant was not advised to attend with a witness and that no minutes of the alleged disciplinary hearing were produced.
44. RW3 maintained that the Claimant admitted to forgery through emails and sought leniency. He further confirmed that the alleged forgery was not reported to the police. Unlike RW2, RW3 testified that the investigation report was before the Court, and further stating that it formed part of the bundle and that the letter sent to the Claimant on 27th March 2018 contained details of the investigations. He nevertheless confirmed that no witness from Garden Breeze Hotel was called to testify or authenticate the receipts.
45. On further re-examination, RW3 reiterated that all staff had receipts from Garden Breeze Hotel and that the Claimant’s receipts were computer-generated.
The Respondent’s Submissions
46. The Respondent submitted that the Claimant’s employment was governed by the Cooperative Agreement between USADF and Cezam and Associates Limited, which was incorporated into the Claimant’s employment contract. The Respondent sought to rely on Section 10(3) of the Employment Act and the decision in Mekenye v National Bank of Kenya Limited, Cause No. 1813 of 2017 [2025] KEELRC 2928 (KLR), for the proposition that documents external to an employment contract may form part of the contractual terms where they are incorporated into the employment relationship.
47. It is the Respondent’s submission that the Claimant was notified of the allegations against him, issued with a notice to show cause inviting him to explain the alleged irregularities and afforded an opportunity to provide authentic supporting documentation vide the correspondence of 27th March 2018. It relied on Omanga v Kenya Commercial Bank Limited [2024] KEELRC 13357 (KLR) to support the proposition that Section 41 does not prescribe a particular form of hearing, but requires the employee to be informed of the allegations and afforded an opportunity to respond.
48. The Respondent further submitted that the delay between the initial allegations and the eventual termination did not render the dismissal unfair. It submits that the intervening period demonstrated that the Respondent did not act precipitately, but instead allowed the Claimant time to account for the questioned expenditure, undertook investigations and considered his explanation before making a decision. It relied on Sirma v Kenya Pipeline Company Limited & another [2023] KECA 1136 (KLR), on the right to be heard where an employer has reasonable suspicion of misconduct.
49. The Respondent further submitted that the Claimant failed to establish that his termination was unfair and that it has, on its part, demonstrated sufficient grounds for termination.
50. The Respondent therefore maintains that the Claimant’s dismissal was founded on allegations of dishonesty and submission of forged receipts, which it contends amounted to gross misconduct and breach of the contractual obligations governing his employment.
51. The Respondent consequently urges the Court to find that the termination was lawful and fair and to dismiss the Claim with costs.
Analysis and Determination
52. Having considered the pleadings, the evidence tendered by both parties and their respective submissions, the issues that arise for determination are:-
i. Whether the Claimant’s termination was both substantively and procedurally fair and lawful.
ii. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the remedies sought.
Whether the Claimant’s termination was both substantively and procedurally fair and lawful
53. On substantive fairness, Section 43(1) of the Employment Act places the burden upon an employer to prove the reason or reasons for termination, while Section 45(2) requires the employer to establish that the reason (s) was valid and fair and that the termination was undertaken in accordance with fair procedure. Under Section 47(5), the employee bears the initial burden of demonstrating that the termination was unfair, while the employer bears the burden of justifying the grounds for the termination.
54. The central allegation against the Claimant is that he submitted forged or fictitious receipts in accounting for expenditure incurred during a training exercise in Machakos in 2017.
55. The question for this court is whether the Respondent proved its allegations against the Claimant and further whether the allegation is a valid and fair basis for terminating the Claimant’s employment.
56. RW1 in his oral testimony acknowledged that he was not an expert in detecting forgery and did not know the outcome of the investigations that were undertaken by the Respondent on the issue. On his part, RW2 confirmed that the investigation report was not produced and that no written confirmation from Golden Breeze Hotel was tendered to authenticate the allegation of fraud levelled against the Claimant.
57. Further, although RW3 asserted in his testimony that the investigation report was in the bundle of documents, which assertion is not confirmed by the court record, this assertion did not resolve the evidential gaps concerning the authenticity of the receipts, as no representative of the hotel was called to testify, and the alleged forgery was not reported to the police.
58. An employer is not required to prove misconduct beyond reasonable doubt as in a criminal trial, but the seriousness of the allegation of dishonesty does not relieve the employer of its statutory obligation to demonstrate that the reason for termination was valid, fair, and justified.
59. The Court of Appeal in Isindu v Lavington Security Guards Ltd [2017] KECA 225 (KLR), held that an employer must prove the reason for termination, demonstrate its validity and fairness, and comply with the mandatory procedure prescribed by Section 41.
60. Similarly, in Walter Ogal Anuro v Teachers Service Commission [2013] KEELRC 386 (KLR), this Court explained that a fair termination requires both substantive justification and procedural fairness.
61. The Respondent’s witnesses gave inconsistent accounts of the allegations made against the Claimant, the dates and nature of the disciplinary meeting, and the existence of an investigation report. Further, although the Respondent alleged that the Claimant admitted to submitting forged receipts and sought forgiveness, no evidence was led to show that he indeed admitted the allegations, and this position is aggravated by the contradictions elicited during cross-examination.
62. In the circumstances, I am not satisfied that the Respondent discharged its burden under Sections 43 and 45 of the Employment Act, and which renders the termination substantively unfair.
63. On whether the termination adhered to the tenets of procedural fairness, Section 41 of the Employment Act demands that an employer contemplating termination on grounds of misconduct explains to the employee, in a language the employee understands, the reason for which termination is being considered. The provision further requires that the employee be allowed to have another employee or a shop-floor union representative present during the explanation and should also be accorded an opportunity to be heard before the decision is made.
64. The Respondent’s position is that it issued a notice to show cause and invited the Claimant to explain the disputed receipts. The evidence before the court, however, presents significant inconsistencies. RW2 acknowledged that the meeting of 27th March 2018 was not strictly a disciplinary hearing, while RW3 referred to different dates for the invitation and the meeting that is considered a disciplinary hearing.
65. No minutes of the alleged disciplinary hearing were produced, and the evidence does not establish that the Claimant was informed of his right to be accompanied by a fellow employee or union representative.
66. Further, the correspondence concerning the financial queries and the meeting held to obtain an explanation cannot, without more, be equated with compliance with the statutory disciplinary process. The fact that an employee is asked to explain a transaction does not dispense with the obligation to conduct a fair hearing before a decision to terminate employment is made.
67. Although the Respondent relied on Sirma v Kenya Pipeline Company Limited & another [2023] KECA 1136 (KLR), that decision recognizes the importance of affording an employee a reasonable opportunity to be heard where misconduct is alleged, but does not absolve an employer from demonstrating compliance with the applicable disciplinary procedure.
68. In the present case, the evidence does not satisfactorily establish that the Claimant was afforded the hearing contemplated under Section 41.
69. Consequently, I find and hold that the termination was also procedurally unfair.
Whether the Claimant is entitled to the remedies sought
Reinstatement
70. The Claimant seeks reinstatement without loss of benefits, seniority or continuity of service. Section 12(3)(vii) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act limits the power to order reinstatement to three years from the date of dismissal.
71. The Claimant’s employment was terminated on 30th November, 2018, and the matter is now being determined in 2026. The statutory period has therefore expired, and the Court cannot grant reinstatement.
72. This claim therefore fails.
Salary for the unexpired contract period.
73. The Claimant contends that his contract was renewed shortly before the termination and was due to expire on 30th October, 2019.
74. As a general practice, the balance of the contract period is not automatically payable as salary merely because the termination was unfair, as there was never a guarantee that a worker will serve to the end of his/her contract or to retirement.
75. The appropriate remedy is determined within the statutory framework governing unfair termination, specifically Section 49 of the Employment Act.
76. This claim is equally devoid of merit, and it fails.
Compensation for unfair termination
77. Section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act permits an award of compensation equivalent to twelve months’ gross salary, subject to the considerations set out in Section 49(4), which includes the employee’s length of service, the circumstances of the termination, the employee’s contribution to the termination, and the reasonable expectation of continued employment.
78. In Kenfreight (E.A) Limited v Benson K. Nguti [2016] KECA 409 (KLR), the Court of Appeal affirmed the statutory nature of remedies for unfair termination, and held that an award of the maximum twelve months’ salary is not automatic and the same must be justified by the circumstances of each case.
79. The Claimant served the Respondent for approximately seven years, and his contract was renewed shortly before it was terminated. Further, his termination was effected without a demonstrably fair disciplinary process.
80. I light of the foregoing, and considering that the Claimant did not demonstrate the effort he made to mitigate his losses, I deem an award of seven (7) months’ salary sufficient compensation for the unfair termination.
Certificate of service
81. Under Section 51 of the Employment Act, the Claimant is entitled to a certificate of service.
General, aggravated and exemplary damages
82. The Claimant has sought general, aggravated and exemplary damages, alleging psychological distress, reputational harm and malicious treatment. The finding of unfair termination does not, by itself, justify separate awards of general or exemplary damages.
83. Further, the Claimant has not demonstrated an independent legal basis for these additional awards nor established the particular circumstances warranting aggravated or exemplary damages.
84. These prayers are therefore without basis, and are hereby declined.
Constitutional violations
85. Although the Claimant invoked Articles 10, 28, 41, 47 and 50 of the Constitution, the evidence principally establishes unfair termination under the Employment Act. No distinct constitutional violation has been sufficiently demonstrated to justify a separate award of constitutional damages.
86. In the final analysis, the Claimant’s Claim succeeds in terms of the following orders:-
a) A declaration be and is hereby issued that the termination of the Claimant’s employment was unfair and unlawful.
b) That the Claimant is awarded compensation equivalent to seven (7) months’ salary for the unfair termination at KShs. 2,725,100/-
c) That the Respondent shall issue the Claimant with a certificate of service within 14 days of this judgment.
d) The monetary award shall attract interest at court rates from the date of judgment until payment in full.
e) The Claimant shall have the costs of the suit.
87. It is so ordered.
SIGNED, DATED AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
C. N. BAARI
JUDGE
Appearance:
Ms. Okeyo h/b for Ms. Oduo for the Claimant
N/A for the Respondent
Ms. Faith - C/A