REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC PETITION E149 OF 2026
(Before Hon. Justice Dr. Jacob Gakeri)
PETER O. NGOGE T/A
O.P. NGOGE & ASSOCIATE ADVOCATES ………………….. PETITIONER
VERSUS
REV. JOEL KANDIE CHEBII …….……………………….. 1ST RESPONDENT
REGISTRAR OF TRAE UNIONS …………………………. 2ND RESPONDENT
ATTORNEY GENERAL …………………………………….. 3RD RESPONDENT
TAILORS AND TEXTILE WORKERS UNION .……. INTERESTED PARTY
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioner’s case is that following the judgement of the Court in Nairobi ELRC Petition No. E005 of 2026, the 1st Respondent unilaterally, arbitrarily and clandestinely amended the Union’s constitution, and forwarded the same to the 2nd Respondent. That the 2nd Respondent arbitrarily gazetted the same without verifying that the same was done in conformity of Rule 4 and 8 of the existing constitution. It was averred that the amendments to the constitution contravenes Articles 10, 36 and 41 of the Constitution and the Labour Relations Act. That the same has invoked objections whereby the Chairman of the Union filed cause No. E469 of 2026, which has since been transferred to the Judicial Review and Constitutional Division of this Court under Petition E142 of 2026. That the Petition is brought on behalf of the Petitioner and that of all the unionisable workers, who were neither notified nor consulted before the amendments were effected.
The petitioner prays for:
i. Orders of prohibition be issued forthwith directed at the Registrar of Trade Unions to block him/her from Registering the purported amended constitution of the Tailors and Textiles workers Union as was purportedly revised on the 22nd January 2026 contrary to the Law.
ii. Further or in the alternative, Orders of Certiorari be issued forthwith to remove to this Honourable Court for the purposes of quashing the purported amended constitution of the Tailors and Textiles Workers Union as was purportedly revised by the Respondents herein on the 22nd January 2026 contrary to the Law.
iii. A declaration that the 1st Respondent herein and the 2nd Respondent herein lacked jurisdiction to unilaterally and to clandestinely amend the working Constitution of Tailors And Textiles Workers Union without following Rules 4 and 8 of the working Constitution of the Tailors And Textiles workers Union and without involving the public, the Petitioner herein, the unionizable workers, the general membership of the said Trade Union and the Chairman of the said Trade Union and thereby contravening Articles 10,36 and 41 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010.
iv. A declaration that by purporting to amend Rule 11(f) of the Constitution of Tailors And Textiles Workers Union in a bid to ward off competition from the Petitioner and by pre-empting the outcome of the Petitioner’s arguable intended Appeal to the Court of Appeal, the 1st and 2nd Respondents herein have attempted to curtail the Petitioner’s legal rights as are enshrined under Articles 10, 36 and 41 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010 and Section 31 (4) (a) of the Labour Relations Act and to steal a march on the Petitioner.
v. General damages of Kshs. 500,000,000 be assessed and awarded in favour of the Petitioner herein against the Respondents herein for attempting to steal a match on the Petitioner and by attempting to render the Petitioners intended Appeal to the Court of Appeal arising from the Judgment delivered by the Hon. Lady Justice Wasilwa on the 4th May 2026 in the said ELRC Petition No. E005 of 2026, academic, moot and nugatory vie the said amendments contrary to Articles 10, 25, 27, 28, 29, 48 and 50 of the Constitution of Kenya.
vi. A declaration that the above-mentioned unlawful conduct of the 1st and 2nd Respondents herein of orchestrating unlawful amendments of the working constitution of the Tailors and Textiles Workers union contrary to rules 4 and 8 of the working constitution of the said trade union altogether and cumulatively contravened Articles 10, 25, 27, 28, 29, 36, 41, 48, 50 and 159 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010 as pleaded above.
vii. The Costs of this Petition be awarded to the Petitioner herein and interests thereon be provided for.
2. The 1st Respondent and the Interested Party opposed the Petition vide their affidavit sworn by the 1st Respondent, the National General Secretary, on 15th May 2026. He stated that his description under paragraph 1 of the Petition was malicious and demeaning. He denied the Petition in toto save for paragraphs 2,3 and 13. He stated that the Petition attempted to resuscitate Petition E005 of 2026, and therefore it ought to be dismissed with costs for want of merit.
3. The 2nd Respondent opposed the Petition vide its Replying Affidavit sworn by Ann Kanake, on 28th May 2026. She stated that her mandate is the registration and regulation of trade unions, employer’s organization and federations. She stated that the Petitioner's suit is overtaken by events, incompetent, misconceived, premature and an abuse of the process of this Honorable Court. She added that the Petitioner is not a member of the Union and thus will not suffer any irreparable loss by the change of the Constitution. She deposed that Rule 4 of the Union's Constitution as well as Section 27 of the Labour Relations Act 2007 (the Act), provides for an elaborate procedure for amendment of the Interested Party Union's Constitution. She outlined the documents required to be submitted to the Registrar under Section 27(2) of the Labour Relations Act, to be: the notice in the prescribed form signed by the Secretary, a copy of the resolution containing details of the proposed change; and a certificate signed by the Secretary confirming that the resolution was passed in accordance with the Union constitution and rules.
4. She deponed that it is required that upon receipt of the application for amendment of the Constitution, the Registrar commences the statutory process by publishing a Gazette Notice inviting objections from members and interested parties within twenty-one (21) days in accord with with Section 27(4) of the Labour Relations Act. She stated that Section 27(4) expressly provides that after publication of the Gazette Notice; the Registrar shall receive and investigate objections before making any determination on whether to approve or reject the proposed amendments. She outlined that the Registrar subsequently had the power to: refer the matter to the Employment and Labour Relations Court; refuse to accept the proposed amendments; or make any orders deemed appropriate in the circumstances.
5. The affiant deposed that while conducting an inquiry into the matter, the Applicant prematurely approached the court, before she made any decision to register or decline the registration of the amendments to the Union Constitution. She added that it is trite law that where statute provides a clear procedure for redress, the same ought to be strictly followed before invocation of the Court's jurisdiction. She added that the Petitioner approached this Honorable Court prematurely before exhausting the dispute resolution mechanism expressly provided under Section 27 of the Labour Relations Act. She urged that the instant proceedings are overtaken by events, and were intended to circumvent the statutory mandate vested upon the Registrar of Trade Unions under the Labour Relations Act. She further urged that the petition be dismissed with costs to the Respondent.
6. In rejoinder, the Petitioner in his further affidavit sworn on 15th June 2026, reiterated that procedure was not followed in the amendment of the constitution, more so Rule 4, 8 and 20 of the constitution. He deposed that there was no evidence adduced to show that there were made proposals to amend the constitution at least two weeks before the Quinquennial Conference held at NITA Hotel, Athi River on 22nd January 2026. He added that there were no written proposals for the amendment of the constitution as the proposals were allegedly made orally, by way of ambush for the first time at the conference contrary to the said Rule. He contended that the minutes presented to the Registrar showed that the proposal sailed through without a vote by secret ballot.
7. The affiant contended further that the proposal ought to have been passed to the members through their shop stewards in order to grant them an opportunity to air their views democratically. He directed the Court’s attention to the conference’s agenda, stating that the same was strictly to conduct national elections as per the 1st Respondent’s circular of 2nd January 2026. He termed the amendment as denial of the member’s right to participate in trade union activities contrary to Articles 10, 36 and 41 (2) (c) of the Constitution and sections 4 and 34(2)(a) of the LRA.
8. He deponed that aggrieved by the manner in which the proposals were made, the union’s Chairman, treasurer and organizing secretary lodged objections with the Registrar under sections 18 and 27 of the Labour Relations Act. He contended that the amendments birthed the positions of 1st and 2nd Assistants- National General Secretary, now occupied by John Nyaga Ngari and James Cheptirim. He added that by the fact that the occupants were elected at the conference implies that the amendments were unlawfully and clandestinely approved by the Respondents prior to the conference. As such, he rubbished the assertion that the amendments were approved on 13th May 2026.
9. The affiant accused the Registrar of hurriedly, clandestinely and unprocedurally sanitizing and approving the amendments and failure to decide on the objections before victimizing the chairman, treasurer and organizing secretary by suspending them and dismissing them as officers of the union for raising objections. He further contended that he proffered this Petition under Article 258 of the Constitution 2010 on behalf of the chairman, treasurer and organizing secretary, and other members condemned unheard. He added that he also brought it on his behalf as amendment of rule 11(f) of the constitution blocked him from contesting for General Secretary as an outsider, contrary to section 31(4a) of the Labour Relations Act (LRA). He stated further that the letter dated 25th September 2025 precluded the Respondents from asserting that the amendments were proposed and effected during the conference. He contended that the Petition was lodged following the Registrar’s disregard of the objections raised. He urged that due to the unlawfulness of the amendments, the same is ripe for quashing and can therefore not overtaken by events. He therefore urged that the prayers sought be allowed.
Petitioner’s submissions
10. The Petitioner submitted on the issues on: (i) whether the amendment process complied with rules 4 and 8 of the Interested Party’s constitution; and (ii) whether the amendments were ultra vires section 31(4)(a) of the Labour Relations Act.
11. It was submitted that the process leading to the amendment of the Interested Party's internal constitution did not comply with the Rules. It was argued that Rule 4 was abridged with impunity because the Respondents produced neither written proposals for the proposed amendments nor minutes of the Conference held on 22nd January 2026 to prove that the amendments were passed by a majority vote through secret balloting. It was submitted that memberswere denied the right to participate, contrary to Articles 10, 36, 41, and 47 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010, as read with Sections 4 and 34(2a) of the Labour Relations Act.
12. Counsel submitted that the Registrar of Trade Unions did not comply with Section 27 of the Labour Relations Act in approving the amendments and that the amendments created the new positions of 1st and 2nd Assistant National General Secretaries, which did not exist in the original constitution. Counsel added that on 22nd January 2026, the Registrar officially returned Mr. John Nyaga Ngari and Mr. James Cheptirim as duly elected to those positions. It was argued that by recognizing the new positions and giving legal effect to the elections, the Registrar of Trade Unions clandestinely and unlawfully approved and sanitized the amendments before complying with Section 27, thereby curtailing Articles 10, 36, 41, and 47 of the Constitution and Sections 4 and 34(2a) of the Labour Relations Act.
13. On the second issue, it was submitted that the amendments were ultra vires Section 31(4)(a) of the Labour Relations Act. It was argued that by amending Rule 11(f) to exclude outsiders and non-members from contesting the position of General-Secretary; and to block the Petitioner from challenging Rev. Joel Kandie Chebii for that position, the Respondents contravened Section 31(4)(a) and Articles 10, 27, 28, 29, 36, 41, and 47 of the Constitution, as read with Sections 4 and 34(2a) of the Labour Relations Act.
1st Respondent and Interested Party’s Submission’s
14. The 1st Respondent and the Interested Party submitted on: (i) whether the amendments were unlawful, (ii) whether the Petition is merited and (iii) whether the Petitioner is entitled to the reliefs sought.
15. Counsel submitted that the Petition was overtaken by events because the registration of the amended Constitution had already been lawfully and procedurally effected. It was submitted that the Notice of Amendment was duly advertised in newspapers of nationwide circulation on 22nd April 2026 in line with Section 27(4) of the Labour Relations Act 2007, without any objection from the Petitioner. It was argued that the Petition was belated, misconceived, and lacked merit, and that the Petitioner was not a member nor eligible to vie in the Union, and did not stand to suffer any loss. It was further submitted that the Union had the mandate to amend its Constitution, which it did on 22nd January 2026, and the changes were lodged with the 2nd Respondent on 12th May 2026. Reliance was placed on ELRC Petition No. E095 of 2025 (Anthony Ndegwa Kinyua v KUPPET & Another) and ELRC Petition No. E163 of 2023 (Patrick Sakwa Kadukha & 3 Others v Kenya National Private Security Workers Union and Others) to reinforce their position that the amendments were lawful and the Petition should be dismissed with costs.
2nd and 3rd Respondent’s submissions
16. The 2nd and 3rd Respondents raised the issues on: (i) whether the Registrar of Trade Unions acted lawfully and in accordance with Section 27 of the LRA, and (ii) whether the Petition has been overtaken by events.
17. On the first issue, it was submitted that the Registrar acted in accordance with the laid down procedure under Section 27 of the Labour Relations Act in discharging the statutory mandate vested in that office. It was submitted that the Registrar upon receipt of the application for amendment of the Interested Party’s Constitution, published Gazette Notice No. 6021 inviting objections within 21 days.
18. It was submitted that the Registrar received and considered objections prior to making any determination thus, the Petitioner had not demonstrated any procedural impropriety, illegality, irrationality or breach of statute on the part of the Registrar. The Court was urged to affirm that the conduct of the Registrar was procedural and lawful.
19. On the second issue, it was submitted that the Petition and the reliefs sought had been overtaken by events, as its primary objective was to invite the Court to intervene in a statutory process that had since progressed beyond the stage sought to be restrained. Reliance was placed on the decision in Republic v Kenya National Examinations Council ex parte Gathenji & Others [1997] eKLR, for the proposition that the law is settled that courts do not act in vain and will not issue orders where such orders have been rendered impracticable, ineffective or incapable of enforcement by subsequent events. It was argued that from the circumstances of this case, granting the orders sought would serve no practical purpose and would amount to an exercise in futility. The Court was urged to dismiss the Petition with costs to the Respondents.
Analysis and determination
20. Having considered the respective cases, submission and the law the issues that arise for determination are;
(i) whether the amendments to the constitution were unlawful;
(ii) whether the Registrar’s actions were ultra vires, and
(iii) whether the instant Petition is merited.
21. On the first issue, it was argued that the amendments were unlawful for having been introduced on the floor rather than through the draft agenda circulated before the meeting. Under Minute 5/26, there is indication that the constitutional amendment to integrate women and youth affairs had been deferred from a previous meeting. Minute 7/26 introduced the proposed constitutional amendments and their proposers. It further indicated that the present delegates unanimously voted for the amendments. Rule 4 and Rule 20 of the previous constitution provided for amendments of rules and voting respectively as follows:
“RULE 4: AMENDMENTS AND ALTERATION OF RULES.
a) Rules shall be made, amended, altered or rescinded by majority vote by secret ballot at a Quinquennial Conference or Special Programme. All proposals for amendments, alterations or rescinding of any Rules shall be submitted to the National General Secretary in writing not later than two weeks before the date of such Quinquennial Conference or Special Conference.
b) Amendments, alterations, additions or rescissions of these Rules approved by the Quinquennial or Special Conference shall be submitted to the Registrar of Trade Unions by the National General Secretary and shall take effect from the date of registration thereof unless some later date is specified in respect thereof.
“RULE 20: VOTING
Taking of all decision in respect of electing National Officers, National Executive Committee Members, Trustees and Branches, the amendment of rules, strike, dissolution of the Union and any other matter affecting members of the Union in general shall be by secret ballot.”
22. The Petitioner’s contention is that there were no proposals that were received two weeks before the election as the same were presented orally at the meeting. In support of their argument that the changes were proper, the 1st and 2nd Respondent provided letters by delegates from 10 branches endorsing the changes to the constitution. In all the letters, it was stated that the changes were presented, proposed, seconded and discussed before they were passed. In their letter dated 11th May 2026 the Nairobi Delegates noted that:
“… the General Secretary read his report which contained some constitutional amendments, and the delegates agreed that the changes were long overdue. The Proposed amendments were discussed by all the delegates present, and they unanimously agreed and resolved to amend the constitution accordingly.”
23. The report was also produced by the Petitioner as annexure to his Further Affidavit. In light of the foregoing, the court is satisfied that the proposals were made, lodged in advance and properly accepted by the General Secretary. Further, the court is satisfied that the delegates ratified the amendments that the process was sufficient and proper. In the court’s view, ordering fresh elections would not be in the interest of justice as it would prejudice the Respondents in terms of money and time and the process is likely to yield the same outcome. Similarly, no evidence was adduced to show that the changes did not conform with the requirements for the registration by the Registrar of Trade Unions.
24. On the second issue, the Petitioner accused the Registrar of Trade Unions for failure to comply with section 27 of the Labour Relations Act. Section 27 provides that:
27. Change of name or constitution of trade union, employers’ organisation or federation
(1) A trade union, employers’ organisation or federation may resolve to—
(a) change or replace its constitution; or
(b) change its name.
(2) A registered trade union, employers’ organisation or federation may apply to the Registrar to approve a change of name or an amendment to its constitution and rules by submitting to the Registrar—
(a) a notice in Form I or Form J as the case may be set out in the Second Schedule duly completed and signed by the secretary;
(b) a copy of the resolution containing details of the change; and
(c) a certificate signed by the secretary stating that the resolution was passed in accordance with the constitution and rules.
(3) Notice of the change specified in subsection (2) shall be submitted to the Registrar within fourteen days of any resolution to change the name or constitution.
(4) Upon receipt of the notice of change of name or constitution, the Registrar shall give a notice of at least twenty-one days in the Gazette and in three daily newspapers of national circulation inviting any objections to the proposed change of name or constitution by members of the trade union and where any such objection is raised, the Registrar shall investigate the complaint and the grounds relied upon and may—
(a) refer the matter to the Industrial Court;
(b) refuse to accept the proposed amendments; or
(c) make any orders that he may deem fit in the circumstances.
(5) The Registrar may approve a change of name or to the constitution if the applicable requirements of registration of a trade union, employer’s organisation or federation are met.
(6) The Registrar shall issue a certificate of change of name or change of the constitution in Form K or Form L, as the case may be. Emphasis supplied.
25. In her defence, the Registrar adduced evidence to show that she complied with the requirements before registering the changes. She added that despite gazetting the changes, there was no objection by the Petitioner. From the Petitioner’s annexure, the contention by the chairman, in his suit, was that the Registrar failed to notice that he, as the national chairman had not signed the minutes. However, it neither a requirement under section 27 of the Labour Relations Act nor the stated Rule 12 of the Constitution raised in the objection, and therefore cannot stand. It is worth noting that the law solely mandates the Secretary in matters pertaining the issues at hand.
26. From the record, the court that upon receipt of the objection to the registration, the Registrar notified the 1st Respondent vide her letter dated 29th April 2026, seeking his response within 7 days. No evidence was provided to show that the Registrar disregarded the objections raised. Furthermore, section 27(4) of the Labour Relations requires Act the Registrar to investigate the complaint and grounds relied upon and make an appropriate decision. No evidence was tendered to show misuse of the discretion by the Registrar or that her actions were outside her scope of mandate. The court is not persuaded that her actions were ultra vires. The court is guided by the holding in Okoiti & 3 others v Anne Waiguru, the Cabinet Secretary, Devolution and Planning & 5 others [2021] KEELRC 2306 (KLR) where the Court observed thus:
“72. An act is ultra vires when the decision making authority commits an error of law in the process of taking the decision or making the act, the subject of the complaint. Acting without Jurisdiction or ultra vires, or contrary to the provisions of a law or its principles renders the decision made laced with illegality. See Republic v Secretary of the Firearms Licensing Board & 2 others ex -parte: Senator Johnson Muthama [2018] eKLR. In the case of Pastoli v Kabale District Local Government Council & others, (2008) 2 EA 300 the court held that;
In order to succeed in an application for Judicial Review, the applicant has to show that the decision or act complained of is tainted with illegality, irrationality and procedural impropriety.
73. And in the case of Republic v Cabinet Secretary, Ministry of Agricultures, Livestock & Fisheries; Cabinet Secretary, Ministry of Industry, Trade & Co-operatives (Interested Party) Tanners Association of Kenya(Suing through its Chairman Robert Njoka Ex Parte Applicant [2019] eKLR the court in addressing the question of whether the decision made was ultra vires held that;
• the decision-maker must understand correctly the law that regulates his decision-making and must give effect to it… Judicial intervention is posited on the idea that the objective is to ensure that the agency of government functionary remains within the area assigned to it by Parliament. A decision, which falls outside that area, can therefore be described, interchangeably, as a decision to which no reasonable decision-maker could have come; or a decision, which was not reasonably open in the circumstances.
27. On locking out the Petitioner from vying as an official of the union the issue was determined in ELRC PET NO.E005 of 2026. But since it has been raised in this case, it is important to note that elections of officials to trade unions are provided for under section 34 of the Act as follows:
34. Election of officials
(1) The election of officials of a trade union, employers’ organisation or federation shall be conducted in accordance with their registered constitutions.
28. This section vests upon trade unions the power to determine how elections shall be conducted which means that despite the provisions of section 31(4)(a) of the Labour Relations Act notwithstanding, relied upon by the Petitioner, that non-members may be allowed to participate in election is the constitution of the particular trade union so ordains. This discretion is protected by the Constitution under Article 41(4), which provides for the autonomy of trade unions as follows:
(4) Every trade union and every employers’ organisation has the right—
(a) to determine its own administration, programmes and activities;
(b) to organise; and
…
29. Although the Petitioner maintains that the amendment of the Constitution was driven towards rendering his appeal nugatory, this Court cannot interfere in the internal workings of the trade union. That said, in order to understand the intention of the legislators, it is important to evaluate the section in relation to the other sections so as to give a just interpretation. The court is guided by the Supreme Court’s holding in Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital & 3 others v Gikenyl & 74 others [2026] KESC 50 (KLR) where it noted that:
“…While the language in Section 12 of the ELRC Act may be plain, as a rule of statutory interpretation, courts must ensure that the interpretation of legislation leads to a fair and just outcome, aligning with the Constitution and the purpose of the legislation. Secondly, it is a well-established legislative interpretative principle that statutes dealing with the same subject matter, or which are in pari materia, should be construed together and harmoniously, in order to avoid inconsistencies. This principle was articulated by the South African Constitutional Court in the case of The Independent Institute of Education (Pty) Limited Vs Kwazulu-Natal Law Society and Others [2019] ZACC 47) on which the Court of Appeal relied in its decision in Njuguna Vs Republic [2025] KECA 850 (KLR). We shall return to apply these principles to the question under consideration.”
30. In the Courts view section 31(1) (4) (a) of the Labour Relation Act does not grant the 1st Petitioner absolute rights to participate in union elections or be elected for any position.
31. Consequently, the court finds that the instant Petition lacks merit and is hereby dismissed with no orders as to costs.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI ON THIS 27TH OCTOBER, 2026.
DR. JACOB GAKERI
JUDGE
ORDER
In view of the declaration of measures restricting court operations due to the COVID-19 pandemic and in light of the directions issued by His Lordship, the Chief Justice on 15th March 2020 and subsequent directions of 21st April 2020 that judgments and rulings shall be delivered through video conferencing or via email. They have waived compliance with Order 21 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which requires that all judgments and rulings be pronounced in open court. In permitting this course, this court has been guided by Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution which requires the court to eschew undue technicalities in delivering justice, the right of access to justice guaranteed to every person under Article 48 of the Constitution and the provisions of Section 1B of the Civil Procedure Act (Chapter 21 of the Laws of Kenya) which impose on this court the duty of the court, inter alia, to use suitable technology to enhance the overriding objective which is to facilitate just, expeditious, proportionate and affordable resolution of civil disputes.
DR. JACOB GAKERI
JUDGE