Employment law

Mwangeka v Unga Farmcare E.A Ltd [2026] KEELRC 14873 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Petition E194 of 2026
Judgment date
27 October 2026
Judge(s)
Dr. Jacob Gakeri

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

Judgment for the petitioner: termination was declared unfair and unlawful due to procedural unfairness; he was awarded Kshs.252,129 (three months’ gross salary), interest at court rates from judgment until payment in full, and costs at half scale. The privacy claim and other constitutional compensation claims failed; reinstatement and pay in lieu of notice were declined.

Supporting judgment passages

(a) Declaration that termination of the petitioner’s employment by the respondent was unfair and unlawful.

Passage 128 →

(b) Equivalent of three (3) months’ gross salary, Kshs.252,129.00.

Passage 129 →

(d) Costs of the suit at ½ scale.

Passage 131 →
Issue 1Whether termination of the petitioner’s employment by the respondent was unlawful.

Held. Decided. The termination was unlawful/unfair procedurally, although the respondent had substantive justification to dismiss. The petitioner admitted receiving Kshs.2,000 in cash from a supplier, contrary to the Gifts and Hospitality Policy, so the employer had a valid reason. However, the respondent gave him 48 hours to answer the notice to show cause when its Disciplinary Policy prescribed three days, subject to extension on request. That breach rendered the termination procedurally unfair.

Ratio. A fair termination requires both substantive justification and procedural fairness. An employer must establish a valid and fair reason and use a fair procedure. Where the employer breaches its own prescribed disciplinary process in a manner implicating the employee’s right to be heard, the termination is unfair despite a substantively justified reason.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

(i) Whether termination of the petitioner’s employment by the respondent was unlawful.

Passage 55 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

Applying the foregoing principles to the facts in this case, the court is satisfied that the respondent has established on a preponderance of probabilities that it had a substantive justification to terminate the petitioner’s employment.

Passage 82 →

As regards the number of days, clause 12.3.4 of the Disciplinary Policy, 2024 provided for 3 days, which could be extended on request. The petitioner raised the issue at the appeal hearing. Clearly, the respondent breached its own prescription.

Passage 93 →

For the foregoing reasons, the court is satisfied that termination of the petitioner’s employment was unfair by dint of the provisions of section 45(4) and (5) of the Employment Act.

Passage 114 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

For a termination of employment to pass the fairness test, it must be shown that the employer had a valid and fair reason for the termination and the procedure used must have been fair. Put another way, there must have been a substantive justification and procedural fairness as aptly captured by Ndolo J (as she then was) in Walter Ogal Anuro v Teachers Service Commission (2013) eKLR thus;

Passage 59 →

“From the foregoing, termination of employment may be substantively and/or procedurally unfair. A termination is also deemed substantively unfair where the employer fails to give valid reasons to support the termination. On the other hand, procedural unfairness arises where the employer fails to follow the laid down procedure as per contract or fails to accord the employee an opportunity to be heard as by law required.”

Passage 62 →

While section 45 (2) (c) of the Employment Act provides that termination of employment must be conducted in a fair procedure the provisions of section 41 of the Act prescribe sthe elements of procedural fairness as enumerated in Postal Corporation of Kenya v Andrew K. Tanui (2019) eKLR where the Court of Appeal stated.

Passage 86 →
Issue 2Whether the respondent violated the petitioner’s right of privacy;

Held. Decided. The respondent did not violate the petitioner’s privacy. The petitioner neither particularised nor proved that his own bank account or phone number was accessed. The investigation concerned suppliers/transporters, and the admitted Kshs.2,000 transfer could be established from the supplier’s records. The police investigator’s access to the single transaction was in the course of investigating another person.

Ratio. Personal data may be collected indirectly where necessary for the prevention, detection, investigation, prosecution, or punishment of crime under section 28(2)(f)(i) of the Data Protection Act. On the facts, the indirect access fell within that statutory exception, and no privacy violation was proved.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

(ii) Whether the respondent violated the petitioner’s right of privacy;

Passage 56 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

From the foregoing, it is the finding of the court that the respondent did not violate the petitioners right of privacy.

Passage 111 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

Article 50(4) of the Constitution provides: Evidence provided obtained in a manner that violates any right or fundamental freedom in the Bill of rights shall be excluded if the admission of that evidence would render the trial unfair, or would otherwise be detrimental to the administration of justice. The petitioner’s allegation that his right to privacy was violated lacked particulars as neither the petition nor the Supporting Affidavit alleged that the petitioners bank account or cellphone number was among those being investigated. Relatedly, petitioner availed no evidence of what information was accessed from what cellphone number as he was not the subject of the investigation respondent maintained that the investigation was exclusively on its suppliers/transporters. It is trite that a persons M-Pesa statement shows the cellphone numbers to which cash was remitted and the investigator did not require the petitioner’s statement to appreciate the fact that the petitioner received Kshs.2,000 from Flawless Ltd, a fact he admitted. The company’s statement showed as much.

Passage 99 →

In this case, the police investigator accessed the single transaction involving the petitioner in the course of investigating another person, thus falling within the ambit of section 28(2) (f) (i) of the Data Protection Act.

Passage 110 →
Issue 3Whether the petitioner is entitled to the reliefs sought.

Held. Decided in part. The court granted a declaration of violation of the right to fair hearing and compensation for unfair termination of three months’ gross salary, Kshs.252,129. It declined the other declarations, constitutional-rights compensation, reinstatement, and salary in lieu of notice. Reinstatement was unsuitable because the petitioner had served about six years, substantially contributed to the dismissal, and showed no exceptional circumstances. Notice pay was unsustainable because there was substantive justification for dismissal.

Ratio. Reinstatement is discretionary and requires consideration of the statutory factors, with exceptional circumstances required before ordering specific performance of a contract of service. Compensation for procedurally unfair termination is available under section 49(1)(c); quantum may account for the employee’s service, record, wish to remain employed, and contribution to the termination.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

(iii) Whether the petitioner is entitled to the reliefs sought.

Passage 57 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

Having found that the Petitioner was not accorded sufficient time to respond to the notice to show cause as provided by the Disciplinary Policy which implicated the petitioner’s right to fair hearing, the declaration on violation of the right to fair hearing is merited. None of the other declarations sought were merited and the summary dismissal letter was validly issued. Similarly, the court did not discern any violation of rights or fundamental freedoms to warrant an order compensation.

Passage 116 →

In the circumstances, the court is not satisfied that the remedy of reinstatement would be an appropriate remedy in the circumstance. The prayer is declined.

Passage 122 →

In the circumstances the court is satisfied that the equivalent of three (3) months gross salary is fair, Kshs.252,129.00

Passage 126 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

It requires no belabouring that reinstatement is one reliefs provided for under the provision of section 12(3) (ii) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act read with section 49(3) of the Employment Act and as held by the Court of Appeal in Kenya Airways Ltd v Ailation & Allied Workers Union Kenya & 3 others (2014) KECA 404 (KLR) the remedy is discretionary and the discretion is exercisable in the context of the factors enumerated in section 49 (4) of the Employment Act.

Passage 117 →

In the instant case, although the petitioner appealed the dismissal, prayed for reinstatement, thus expressing his wish to remain in employment, he had served the respondent as an employee for about six (6) years which is short, substantially contributed to the dismissal and did not demonstrate the very exceptional or unique circumstances which would justify qualification of the common law principle that there should be order of specific performance in a contract of service.

Passage 121 →

Finally, having found that the termination of the petitioner’s employment by the respondent was procedurally flawed and thus unfair, the petitioner qualifies for the relief under section 49(1) (c) of the Employment Act.

Passage 124 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Confirmed receipt of Kshs.2,000 from a supplier on 16th May 2024.

Paragraph 1 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

The court identified whether the respondent’s termination of the petitioner’s employment was unlawful, whether it violated his privacy, and whether he was entitled to the remedies sought. The dispute also required determination of whether the M-Pesa-related…

Material facts

Jackson Kirangi Mwangeka was employed as Fleet Administrator under a 26 June 2019 contract and was subject to the respondent’s Code of Conduct, Human Resource Manual, Disciplinary Policy, and Gifts and Hospitality Policy. Following a whistleblower report and…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

PETITION NO. E194 OF 2026

(Before Hon. Justice Dr. Jacob Gakeri)

JACKSON KIRANGI MWANGEKA……………………...…. PETITIONER

-VERSUS-

UNGA FARMCARE E.A LIMITED………………………… RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

The petitioner filed the instant petition on 15th June 2026 alleging that the Respondent had terminated his employment unfairly, violated his Constitutional rights including the right to privacy by accessing his personal data, namely M-Pesa transaction records, right to fair Labour practices and the right to fair hearing.

The petition identifies Articles 1(3) (c), 2(1), 10, 31, 41, 47, 50(4) and 259 of the Constitution of Kenya as well as sections 4 of the Fair Administrative Action Act, 25, 26, 30(1) and 32(1) of the Data Protection Act as the Legal formulation of the petition.

The petitioner prays for:

(i) Declaration that the respondent violated the petitioner’s right to fair labour practices, fair hearing and fair administrative action.

(ii) Declaration that the undated Suppliers Investigation Report violated the petitioners right to privacy, fair labour practices, fair administrative action, access to justice and fair hearing rendering it void.

(iii) Declaration that the Notice to show cause dated 15th September 2025 is invalid and void as it was based on illegally obtained evidence.

(iv) Declaration that the suspension letter dated 15th September 2015 and dismissal letter dated 8th October 2025 are invalid.

(v) Declaration that termination of the petitioner’s employment was unfair, illegal and a violation of his fundamental rights.

(vi) An order of certiorari calling into this court and quashing the summary dismissal letter dated 8th October 2015 as well as the appeal decision dated 13th November 2025.

(vii) Compensation for unfair dismissal.

(viii) Payment in lieu of notice, Kshs.84,043

(ix) An order of compensation for violation and contravention of his rights and fundamental freedoms.

(x) Costs of this petition.

Respondent’s case

Vide a Replying Affidavit sworn on 5th July 2026 in opposition to the petition, Mr. John Mwendwa the Respondent’s Group Human Resource Director deponed that the petitioner was appointed the Respondent’s Fleet Administrator pursuant to a contract dated 26th June 2019 and was subject to the Respondents code of conduct and Human Resource Manual; which contained the Disciplinary Policy as well as the Gifts and Hospitality Policy.

The affiant deponed that in March 2025, a whistle blower reported that there had been financial impropriety involving employees and the matter was reported to the police OB No. 70/07/4/2025 and the police conducted an investigation the ODPP sought a court order to access financial statements in transactions by suppliers/transporters and the court granted the order on 8th April 2025 in Misc Application No. E584/2025 and no data privacy had been violated as access is permitted for purposes of an investigation and the investigation contained in the Investigation Report related to transactions of a supplier of the respondent and no personal data was accessed.

The affiant further deponed that receipt of cash from a supplier violated the respondent’s Code on conflict of interest and led to the issuance of the notice to show cause together with the Investigation Report showing that the petitioner received Kshs.2,000 from a supplier contractor and investigations were still on-going hence the suspension on 15th September 2025.

That in his response dated 16th September 2025, the petitioner admitted having received cash from the supplier/transporter and as a consequence was invited to a disciplinary hearing and was entitled to be accompanied by a colleague of his choice, was heard on 25th September 2025, admitted having received the cash again and was aware of the respondents’ policies.

The affiant-deponed that the petitioner was dismissed on 8th October 2025, appealed, was invited for the appeal hearing, was heard on 24th October 2025 and a decision communicated vide letter dated 3rd November 2026.

Finally, the affiant deponed that the respondent had a valid reason to dismiss the petitioner from employment, was heard during the disciplinary hearing and appeal and the petition was for dismissal and no relief was merited.

In addition, the Respondent filed grounds of opposition dated 14th July 2026 to justify the respondents’ conduct.

In his further Affidavit sworn on 4th September 2026 the Petitioner deponed that the Respondent’s code of Ethics allowed him to receive seasonal gifts (Easter/Christmass valued to a maximum of USD 50 and the Kshs.2000 gift did not violate the code and his to privacy was violated.

Petitioner’s submission

As to whether the evidence used to dismiss the petitioner was unlawful, counsel submitted that it was as the Respondent intruded into the Petitioner’s mobile wallet and the order from the Makadara law courts had conflicting dates.

Reliance was placed on the decision in MacFoy v United Africa Co. Ltd (1961) ALLER 1169 (PC) to urge that the court order relied upon was a sham.

Reliance was further placed on the decisions in Cold Grown Beverages (Kenya) Ltd v Maina Ngugi (2019) KEELRC 2262 (KLR) where the court declined orders to compel Safaricom M-pesa to disclose and Foldida Construction Machinery Ltd v Wanyonyi (2025) KEELRC 1675 (KLR), where the court found that it could compel specific and time-bound M-pesa statements where necessary.

Counsel urged that generic contractual consent was not a waiver of the Bill of rights citing the decisions in GJK v KPMG & Advisory Services (2017) KEELRC 1236 (KLR) and Mwambu v Twiga Foods Ltd (2024) KEHC 10889 (KLR) on consent.

On procedural unfairness and illegal evidence counsel urged that the respondent was bound by articles 47 and 50 (1) of the Constitution on fair administrative action and fair hearing and the 48 hours given by the Respondent violated the rights.

Counsel urged that illegally obtained evidence was inadmissible citing the decisions in Mathew Kipkemboi Kitai v Postal Corporation of Kenya (2016) KEHC 4065 (KLR) and Kenya Union of Commercial Food & Allied Workers v Delmonte (K) Ltd (2013) KEHC 3872 (KLR), on procedural fairness.

On substantive justification of the termination, counsel submitted that since the respondent failed to establish conflict of interest, it had no justification to terminate the petitioner’s employment which rendered the termination substantively unlawful. Counsel, further submitted that the termination was equally procedurally unlawful for the short notice and the petitioner was not involved in the investigation.

On receipt of Kshs.2000 from a supplier, counsel submitted that the petitioner’s admission of having received the cash was not an admission of liability as gifts were acceptable and ambiguities are construed contra proferentes as held in Kenya Airways, Ltd v Allies Nyando & others (2014) eKLR.

On reliefs counsel submitted that the petitioner was entitled to the reliefs prayed for violation of the right to human dignity and unfair termination of employment.

Respondent’s submissions

Counsel did not isolate specific issue for determination but addressed various topics including petitioner’s terms of employment, petitioner being required to uphold the respondents polices, investigation into the petitioners suspected misconduct, show cause letter and petitioner’s response, information in investigation Report lawfully obtained, petitioners’ consent had been given Admission of breach and the impracticability of reinstatement as a remedy.

According to the Respondent, the petitioner was bound by its code of conduct and Ethics, the Human Resource Manual and the Gifts and Hospitality Policy.

Reliance was placed on Mark T. Mwangi v Gateway Insurance Co. Ltd (2013) eKLR on conduct by employees.

Counsel urged that the Respondent was entitled to investigate the alleged misconduct as held in Mutiga v Proto Energy Ltd (2015) KEELRC 1747 (KLR) and the notice to show cause was issued with the investigation report.

Reliance was placed on the decision in Judicial Service Commission v Shollei & another (2014) KECA 334 (KLR) on investigations to urge that the information in the report was lawfully obtained by dint of sections 28(1(f), 52 (2) (c), 31 (1) (b) (1) and (vii) and 51 (2) (b) of the Data Protection Act and the court order by the Makadara court.

Reliance was placed on the sentiments of the court in Waweru v Majid AI Fuhaim Hypermarkets Ltd t/a Carrefour (2024) KEELRC 837 (KLR) on receipt of money from a supplier and Kaunda Vunga Ltd (2026) KEELRC 2225 (KLR) on access to personal records under the Data Protection Act.

Also cited on the issue of access to personal dated was the decisions in Dixon v North Bristal NHS Trust (2022) EWHC 3127 (KB). Counsel urged that by clause 29(b) of the Employment contract the petitioner had consented to the Respondent processing the data it collected in relation to the petitioner’s employment citing the decision in National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Pipe plastic Samklit (K) Ltd & another (2001) KEEH 362 (KLR) for the proposition that a court of law cannot re-write a contract between parties unless it is proved to have been vitiated by fraud coercion or undue influence. That the petitioner admitted having received monies from a supplier citing Harum Kibui Thuo v Teachers Service Commission (2022) KEELRC 481 (KLR) to reinforce the submission.

On reinstatement, reliance was placed on the sentiments of the Court of Appeal in Kenya Airways Ltd v Aviation & Allied Workers Union Kenya & 3 others (2014) KEEA 404 (KLR) on its impracticability in this case.

Finally, counsel, submitted that the petitioner’s conduct was detrimental to the Respondent citing the decision in Opiyo v AAR Health Care Kenya Ltd (2025) KECA 1408 – (KLR) on financial and reputational risks.

Counsel urged the court to dismiss the petition for want of merit.

Analysis and determination

Having considered the respective pleadings, submissions on record and the law, the issues for determination are:

(i) Whether termination of the petitioner’s employment by the respondent was unlawful.

(ii) Whether the respondent violated the petitioner’s right of privacy;

(iii) Whether the petitioner is entitled to the reliefs sought.

As regard termination of employment, it is trite law that for a termination of employment to pass muster, it must be effected in accordance with the provisions of the Employment Act, specifically Sections 35, 41, 43, 44, 45 and 47 (5) of the Act.

For a termination of employment to pass the fairness test, it must be shown that the employer had a valid and fair reason for the termination and the procedure used must have been fair. Put another way, there must have been a substantive justification and procedural fairness as aptly captured by Ndolo J (as she then was) in Walter Ogal Anuro v Teachers Service Commission (2013) eKLR thus;

“However, for a termination to pass the fairness test, it must be shown that there was not only substantive justification for the termination but also procedural fairness.”

Similarly, in Naima Khamis v Oxford University Press (E.A) Ltd (2017) eKLR the Court of Appeal stated;

“From the foregoing, termination of employment may be substantively and/or procedurally unfair. A termination is also deemed substantively unfair where the employer fails to give valid reasons to support the termination. On the other hand, procedural unfairness arises where the employer fails to follow the laid down procedure as per contract or fails to accord the employee an opportunity to be heard as by law required.”

While the petitioner avers and counsel submitted that his termination from employment was in violation of constitutional rights, the respondent maintained that the petitioner violated its policies and the termination of employment was justified and conducted in accord with the law.

Reasons for termination

Under section 43 of the Employment Act-

(1) In any claim arising out of termination of a contract, the employer shall be required to prove the reason or reasons for the termination and where the employer fails to do so, the termination shall be deemed to have been unfair within the meaning of section 45.

(2) The reason or seasons for termination of a contract are the matters that the employer at the time of termination of the contract genuinely believed to exist, and which caused the employer to terminate the services of the employee.

The letter of termination dated 8th October 2025 identified three reasons for termination of the petitioner’s employment namely;

1. Confirmed receipt of Kshs.2,000 from a supplier on 16th May 2024.

2. The receipt violated the responder’s Gift and Hospitality Policy knowledge of which the petitioner acknowledged.

3. Acknowledged that he did not declare receipt of the payment to the line manager.

The charges were in violation of the Disciplinary Policy, Code of Conduct and the Gift and Hospitability Policy.

It is common ground that the petitioner admitted having received the Kshs.2,000 from Flawless Ltd on 16th May 2024 at 1.23 pm after having assisted the supplier to secure a technician at Voi. According to the petitioner it was just a gift, not a bribe or extortion. A copy of the Respondent’s Code of Ethics & Conduct date June 2019 required employees to avoid conflict of interest. However, employees were free to accept seasonal gifts (Easter/Christmass) valued to a maximum of Kshs.5,000.00 (VSD 50).

Under clause 7.1.2 of the Respondent’s Gifts and Hospitality Policy 2020, other types of favours, gifts and entertainment are simply wrong and unacceptable, either infact or in appearance; they are never permissible regardless of any other provision of this policy. No one can accept, request, offer, give or approve the following types of gifts in connection with work at Unga.

(a) Any amount of cash or cash equivalents, including, but no limited to gift certificates, gift cards discount cards, (even if any redeemable for merchandise), stock, or other securities.

During the hearing on 26th September 2025 the petitioner admitted that he was aware of clause 7.1.2 (a) of the Gift and Hospitality Policy that any form of cash was not permitted. The Disciplinary Policy had a threshold of Kshs.5,000 and the Code of Ethics & Conduct Prohibited conflict of interest.

Under section 43 (2) of the Employment Act, all the employer is required to demonstrate is that it had a reasonable basis for the genuine belief as held in Galgalo Jarso Jillo v Agricultural Finance Corporation (2021) eKLR.

Similarly in Kenya Revenue Authority v Reuwel Waithaka Gitahi & other (2018) eKLR the Court of Appeal held that the test under section 43(2) of the Employment Act is partly subjective.

The sentiments of Lord Denning in British Leyland UK Ltd v Swift (1981) 1 RLR 91 provide further guidelines.

The judge held:

“The correct test is: was it reasonable for the employers to dismiss him? If no reasonable employer would have dismissed him, then the dismissal was unfair, but if a reasonable employer might reasonably have dismissed him, the dismissal was fair. It must be remembered that in all these cases there is a band of reasonableness, within which an employer might reasonably take one view: another quite reasonably take a different view. One would quite reasonably dismiss the man. The other quite reasonably keep him on. Both views may be quite reasonable. If it was quite reasonable to dismiss him then the dismissal must be upheld as fair even though some other employers may not have dismissed him.”

Applying the foregoing principles to the facts in this case, the court is satisfied that the respondent has established on a preponderance of probabilities that it had a substantive justification to terminate the petitioner’s employment.

Needless to emphasize, section 44 of the Employment Act provides for summary dismissal and allows an employer to dismiss an employee without notice or by a shorter notice if the employee is found to be in fundamerial breach of her/his obligations or gross misconduct and under sub-section 4, the provision exemplifies what may constitute gross misconduct.

The list under sub-section 4 is in exhaustive and the test applicable are the provisions of section 43 (2) of the Act as demonstrated above.

On procedure, while the respondent averred and counsel submitted that the termination of employment was procedurally fair and all processes were complied with the Petitioner. Contended that termination was substantively and procedurally unfair.

While section 45 (2) (c) of the Employment Act provides that termination of employment must be conducted in a fair procedure the provisions of section 41 of the Act prescribe sthe elements of procedural fairness as enumerated in Postal Corporation of Kenya v Andrew K. Tanui (2019) eKLR where the Court of Appeal stated.

“Four elements must thus be discernible for the procedure to pass master:-

(i) an explanation of the grounds of termination in a language understood by the employee;

(ii) the reason for which the employer is considering termination;

(iii) entitlement of an employee to the presence of another employee of his choice when the explanation of grounds of termination of grounds of termination is made;

(iv) hearing and considering any representations made by the employee and the person chosen by the employee.”

From the evidence on record, it is discernible that the respondent issued a notice to show cause on 15th September 2025 subsequent to an investigation and accorded the petitioner 48 hours to respond. The letter cited a whistleblower report and investigation. The petitioner contested the 2 days accorded and the Investigation Report. In the case of the latter the petitioner contended that the evidence was illegally obtained.

As regards the number of days, clause 12.3.4 of the Disciplinary Policy, 2024 provided for 3 days, which could be extended on request. The petitioner raised the issue at the appeal hearing. Clearly, the respondent breached its own prescription.

On the alleged illegally obtained evidence, the petitioner questioned the incongruence of the dates of the court order and the application contending that while the court order was dated 8th April 2025, the Miscellaneous Application and Supporting Affidavit were dated 10th April 2025.

It is unclear as to who mis-stated the date or missed the correct date. However, in the absence of evidence to show the order was improperly obtained of lacked validity, the order is deemed valid and actions taken in its furtherance were valid too.

In the court’s view, an incorrect date per se would not invalidate a court order.

The order authorized the Investigating Officer CPL Kisoi Kitaka to investigate six (6) bank accounts at Diamond Trust Bank, NCBA Bank, Co-operative Bank of Kenya and the National Bank of Kenya. Three of the accounts were at the NCBA Bank.

In addition, the Investigating Officer was authorized to investigate cell phone numbers M-pesa Accounts of 0722848409, 0722233732, 0701699033, 0723451881, 0726674468 and 0721315915 and did so.

Article 50(4) of the Constitution provides: Evidence provided obtained in a manner that violates any right or fundamental freedom in the Bill of rights shall be excluded if the admission of that evidence would render the trial unfair, or would otherwise be detrimental to the administration of justice. The petitioner’s allegation that his right to privacy was violated lacked particulars as neither the petition nor the Supporting Affidavit alleged that the petitioners bank account or cellphone number was among those being investigated. Relatedly, petitioner availed no evidence of what information was accessed from what cellphone number as he was not the subject of the investigation respondent maintained that the investigation was exclusively on its suppliers/transporters. It is trite that a persons M-Pesa statement shows the cellphone numbers to which cash was remitted and the investigator did not require the petitioner’s statement to appreciate the fact that the petitioner received Kshs.2,000 from Flawless Ltd, a fact he admitted. The company’s statement showed as much. It is also essential to note that the law permits the collection of personal data indirectly in various circumstances.

Under section 28 of the Data Protection Act,

(1) A data controller or data processor shall collect personal data directly from the data subject;

(2) Despite subsection (1) personal data may be collected indirectly where-

(a) …

(b) …

(c) …

(d) …

(e) …

(f) Collect data from another source is necessary-

(i) For the prevention, detection, investigation, prosecution and punishment of crime;

In this case, the police investigator accessed the single transaction involving the petitioner in the course of investigating another person, thus falling within the ambit of section 28(2) (f) (i) of the Data Protection Act.

From the foregoing, it is the finding of the court that the respondent did not violate the petitioners right of privacy.

Back to other elements of fair procedure. As adverted to elsewhere, the Notice to show cause was a consequence of the investigation and the petitioner responded, was invited for a disciplinary hearing informed of his right to be accompanied by a colleague of his choice, attended and participated received the outcome, was informed of the right to appeal appealed, was invited for an appeal hearing attended and participated received the outcome.

The minutes of the disciplinary hearing held on 26th September 2025 and the Appeal hearing held on 24th October 2026 clearly show that the petitioner understood the charge levelled against him and the panelists took time to explain to him the concept of conflict of interest in the respondent’s Human Resource instruments.

For the foregoing reasons, the court is satisfied that termination of the petitioner’s employment was unfair by dint of the provisions of section 45(4) and (5) of the Employment Act.

Appropriate relief

Having found that the Petitioner was not accorded sufficient time to respond to the notice to show cause as provided by the Disciplinary Policy which implicated the petitioner’s right to fair hearing, the declaration on violation of the right to fair hearing is merited. None of the other declarations sought were merited and the summary dismissal letter was validly issued. Similarly, the court did not discern any violation of rights or fundamental freedoms to warrant an order compensation.

It requires no belabouring that reinstatement is one reliefs provided for under the provision of section 12(3) (ii) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act read with section 49(3) of the Employment Act and as held by the Court of Appeal in Kenya Airways Ltd v Ailation & Allied Workers Union Kenya & 3 others (2014) KECA 404 (KLR) the remedy is discretionary and the discretion is exercisable in the context of the factors enumerated in section 49 (4) of the Employment Act.

In Kenya Power & Lighting Co. Ltd v Aggrey Lukorito Wasike (2017) eKLR, the Court of Appeal held;

“…It is couched in mandatory terms and requires the court to take into account any of the following matters set out in section 49(4) (a) to (m) before it can order reinstatement…

At the very least it ought to set out the factors that mark out a particular case as possessed of exceptional circumstances before reinstatement can be ordered. This provision properly understood, ought to render orders of reinstatement rarities, not common place and routine pronouncements…”

In the instant case, although the petitioner appealed the dismissal, prayed for reinstatement, thus expressing his wish to remain in employment, he had served the respondent as an employee for about six (6) years which is short, substantially contributed to the dismissal and did not demonstrate the very exceptional or unique circumstances which would justify qualification of the common law principle that there should be order of specific performance in a contract of service.

In the circumstances, the court is not satisfied that the remedy of reinstatement would be an appropriate remedy in the circumstance. The prayer is declined.

Concerning salary in lieu of notice, having found that the respondent had a substantive justification to terminate the petitioner’s employment, the prayer for pay in lieu of notice is unsustainable and it is declined.

Finally, having found that the termination of the petitioner’s employment by the respondent was procedurally flawed and thus unfair, the petitioner qualifies for the relief under section 49(1) (c) of the Employment Act.

In determining the quantum of compensation, the court has taken into account the fact that the petitioner wished to remain in the respondent’s employment, prayed for reinstatement, had been an employee for about six (6) years had no recorded warning or other form of misconduct and substantially contributed to the termination of employment. Indeed, he was solely to blame for what befell him.

In the circumstances the court is satisfied that the equivalent of three (3) months gross salary is fair, Kshs.252,129.00

In the end, judgment is entered in favour of the petitioner against the respondent in the following terms:

(a) Declaration that termination of the petitioner’s employment by the respondent was unfair and unlawful.

(b) Equivalent of three (3) months’ gross salary, Kshs.252,129.00.

(c) Interest at court rates from date of judgment till payment in full.

(d) Costs of the suit at ½ scale.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI ON THIS 27TH OCTOBER, 2026.

DR. JACOB GAKERI

JUDGE

ORDER

In view of the declaration of measures restricting court operations due to the COVID-19 pandemic and in light of the directions issued by His Lordship, the Chief Justice on 15th March 2020 and subsequent directions of 21st April 2020 that judgments and rulings shall be delivered through video conferencing or via email. They have waived compliance with Order 21 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which requires that all judgments and rulings be pronounced in open court. In permitting this course, this court has been guided by Article 159(2)(d) of the Constitution which requires the court to eschew undue technicalities in delivering justice, the right of access to justice guaranteed to every person under Article 48 of the Constitution and the provisions of Section 1B of the Civil Procedure Act (Chapter 21 of the Laws of Kenya) which impose on this court the duty of the court, inter alia, to use suitable technology to enhance the overriding objective which is to facilitate just, expeditious, proportionate and affordable resolution of civil disputes.

DR. JACOB GAKERI

JUDGE