REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
ELRC CAUSE NO. E570 OF 2023
(Before Hon. Lady Justice Hellen Wasilwa, J)
DR. SAMSON ROBERT MISANGO……………………........CLAIMANT
VS
HUMAN RESOURCES MANAGER,
KIAMBU COUNTY……………………………………..1ST RESPONDENT
PAYROLL MASTER, KIAMBU COUNTY……….….2ND RESPONDENT
CEC HEALTH, KIAMBU COUNTY……………..…...3RD RESPONDENT
CHIEF OFFICER HEALTH, KIAMBU COUNTY…..4TH RESPONDENT
MEDICAL SUPERINTENDENT,
KIAMBU LEVEL 5 HOSPITAL…………………..…...5TH RESPONDENT
COUNTY GOVERNMENT OF KIAMBU……………..6TH RESPONDENT
AND
KENYA MEDICAL PRACTITIONERS PHARMACISTS &
DENTISTS UNION……………………..………….INTERESTED PARTY
JUDGMENT
1 The Claimant filed this claim through a Statement of Claim dated 18th June 2023 and prays for judgement against Respondent jointly and severally for:-
i. A declaration that the right of the Claimant as relates to remuneration of labour provided to the Respondents has been violated
ii. A order for payment of special damages for the charges and/or interest levied on the standing charges that were not honoured by the Claimant due to non-remittance of the Claimant June, 2023 salary amounting to Kshs. 20,588/=.
iii. General damages due to the pecuniary embarrassment caused to the Claimant by the Respondents herein in the manner his June 2023 salary was stopped.
iv. Cost of this suit and Interest g -
v. Any other relief that this honourable court deems fit to grant.
Claimant's Case
2 The Claimant avers that the 1st to 6th Respondents are sued under Article 156 of the Constitution; and that the Interested Party is the body that negotiates the collective bargaining agreement between him and the Respondents.
3 It is the Claimant's case that he was employed by the Ministry of Medical Services on 31st August 2009 as an Assistant Director of Medical Services (Surgeon) on probationary terms with effect from the date he reported on duty.
4 He states that on 5th January 2015 he was confirmed in his appointment and admitted to the permanent and pensionable establishment with effect from the date he was placed on probation, that is 30th September 2009.
5 He further avers that he has been offering his services to the Respondents at the Kiambu Level 5 Hospital. On 11th December 2018, he was promoted to the post of Medical Specialist (1), Job Group Q, with effect from 1st September 2018, pursuant to the decision of the County Public Service Board vide its Memo No. CPBS/ST/11/VOL.III/97/MW dated 4th December 2018.
6 The Claimant states that he receives his salary through the Co-operative Bank, Nairobi Upper Hill branch. He was paid his salary for March, April and May 2023, however, his salary for June 2023 was stopped by the Respondents under unclear circumstances, occasioning him great financial embarrassment.
7 It is the Claimant’s case that he has standing bank charges deducted upon receipt of his salary. These are a Co-operative Bank loan serviced at Kshs. 116,409 per month, a Faulu Kenya Ltd loan serviced at Kshs. 83,796 per month, union dues of Kshs. 3,000 per month and WCPS contributions of Kshs. 2,677.
8 He avers that at a bare minimum he is required to pay out Kshs. 205,882 monthly; and when the money is not available, interest is levied at 10% per month, which exposes him to being reported to the Credit Reference Bureau.
9 The Claimant further states that he was in the process of acquiring a loan from Kingdom Bank to finance these debts. The loan forms had been filled on 23rd June 2023, with his salary and payslip as the only security; and as a result of stoppage of his June 2023 salary, the bank terminated the loan process.
10 It is the Claimant’s case that he only realised his salary had been stopped when he visited his bank to confirm the status of the standing order. He was informed that the Respondents did not remit his salary for June 2023 to the bank as had been the tradition.
11 He states that upon the realization, he wrote a protest letter to the Secretary, County Public Service Board, referenced “Unprocederal stoppage of June Salary,” in which he wrote thus: “It has been brought to my attention that my June 2023 salary was illegally stopped without any reference to me contrary to my terms of employment as a public servant in Kenya and the County of Kiambu. This was after I was unable to access my online pay slip for the month and confirming with my bank that the June salary has not been deposited into my account as of today 13th July 2023 at 12.00 noon. I have verbally confirmed with the payroll staff Mr Isaac that the salary has been stopped purportedly for non compliance by an internal communication from your office that was not copied to me and I have also similarly confirmed from the Human Resource staff Mr. Julius that this communication was not copied to that department.”
12 The Claimant states that the letter continued thus: “Kindly be informed that I am duly employed by the County on permanent and pensionable terms having complied with all conditions for employment upon my first appointment, confirmation and promotions and at no time have I been accused or found guilty of an offence called “non compliance”. In any case, if you believe that I have committed an offence of any type, the procedures for disciplinary action are clearly spelt out and none of them prescribes arbitrary stoppage of salaries. My salary is not a favor given to me by your office but rather a non negotiable contractual obligation for having worked during the month and I plan with that salary for my recurring expenses for the following month as indeem fit. Arbitrary stoppage of the salary is an act of impunity and abuse of your office, an infringement of my terms of employment and grossly against the rules of natural justice.”
13 He states that the letter concluded thus: “Please note that I have been greatly inconvenienced by your arbitrary and illegal actions which have caused me great pecuniary embarrassment. I therefore demand that you correct this anomaly within the next 24 hrs from the time of this email failure to which I will take legal action against you without further reference to you but at your own cost and prejudice.”
14 The Claimant states that he provided labour to the Respondents in June 2023 and was not paid for it; and he continues to work for the Respondents without any assurance that he will be paid now or in the coming months.
15 The Claimant contends that by converting his employment into servitude, the Respondents violated Article 30(1) of the Constitution.
16 He asserts that his rights to fair labour practices and fair remuneration under Article 41 were violated because he was not remunerated for June 2023. Additionally, his right to fair administrative action under Article 47 was violated because he was never given written reasons for the stoppage.
17 He further asserts that His right to equality and freedom from discrimination under Article 27 was offended because he was singled out and his salary stopped arbitrarily and without notice.
18 The Claimant further contends that the Respondents breached Section 17(1)(b) of the Employment Act by failing to pay his wages into his designated bank account, and Section 18(2)(c) of the Act, under which his salary fell due at the end of the month. He asserts that the Respondents are culpable under Section 17(10) of the Act for willfully failing to pay wages due.
19 The Claimant avers that the Respondents' conduct was unfair, unlawful and illegal, actuated by malice and spite, and contrary to the rules of natural justice.
20 He states that despite demand and notice of intention to sue, the Respondents have failed, neglected or refused to admit liability.
21 He further states that there is no other suit pending between the parties over the same subject matter and that this Court has jurisdiction to hear and determine the matter.
Respondent’s Case
22 The Respondent opposed the claim through a Response to the Statement of Claim dated 18th November 2024, in which they deny the Claimant's claim.
23 The Respondents aver that the Claimant's promotion letter dated 11th December 2018 was clear that the Claimant shall continue to abide by the current terms and conditions of service which may be reviewed from time to time.
24 It is the Respondents' case that under Article 41(4) of the Constitution, every employers' organization, the Respondents included, has the right to determine its own administration, programmes and activities.
25 They state that pursuant to the power bestowed upon them under the County Governments Act, 2012, they issued a memo Ref. No. CPSB/ST/GED/VOL.X/22 dated 4th April 2023. The memo directed all employees serving at Job Groups "P", "Q" and "R" in the Department of Health Services, the Claimant included, to appear before the County Public Service Board on 13th and 14th April 2023 for authentication of their academic and professional certificates.
26 The Respondents contend that, as required under Article 47(2) of the Constitution, written reasons for the stoppage of the Claimant's salary were given. The Board communicated the reasons to the County Secretary, as the Head of Public Service, and copied them to the Chief Officer, who later communicated the Board's decision to the Claimant.
27 The Respondents deny that the Claimant was discriminated against and put him to strict proof thereof. They deny receiving any demand letter from the Claimant and aver that he is therefore not entitled to costs.
28 They further assert that the claim is not brought under any specific provision of the law and that the Claimant is not entitled to the reliefs sought.
Evidence in Court
29 The Claimant, Dr. Samson Robert Misango, testified as CW1. He stated that he is a medical specialist working at the Kiambu Level 4 Hospital as a general surgeon. He adopted his witness statement dated 18th July 2023 as his evidence in chief and produced the documents in his list of documents of the same date as Claimant's Exhibits 1 to 6.
30 On cross-examination, the CW1 testified that he is in Job Group Q and that he is aware of the Kiambu County Human Resource Manual. He acknowledged that the Manual provides that a person dissatisfied with a decision of the County Public Service Board ought to appeal to the Public Service Commission.
31 He testified that he did not appeal to the Public Service Commission and that he did not receive any decision from the Board.
32 CW1 testified that he received his salary for March, April and May 2023, and that his June 2023 salary was received much later.
33 CW1 testified that by a memo dated 6th March 2023, the Board embarked on a verification exercise of the academic credentials of officers in Job Groups P, Q and R, directing them to appear before it on 13th and 14th March 2023.
34 He testified that he appeared for the verification exercise, and that the documents he filed in Court show this.
35 It was CW1’s testimony that he was not aware that the Board stopped his salary and those of other officers for failing to appear for the exercise. He confirmed that his salary was reinstated after a long time, in December 2023, and that he was paid for the months it was withheld. He stated that the letter he wrote to the Respondents in July 2023 is before the Court and was sent through his advocate.
36 On re-examination, the CW1 testified that he never received any notice of disciplinary action for failing to attend the verification meeting.
37 He testified that his salary was stopped without any communication, and that nothing was ever communicated to him about the stoppage.
38 The Respondents' witness, Dr. Martin Njeri, the Secretary of the County Public Service Board of Kiambu, testified as RW1. He adopted his witness statement dated 18th November 2024 as his evidence in chief and produced the Respondents' documents filed on the same date as Respondents' Exhibits 1 to 6.
39 RW1 testified that the verification exercise involved a large group of staff, and the Claimant was also required to present himself for it, and that he failed to do so. That is why the Claimant's salary was stopped. He maintained that the minutes of the Board were produced and that the Board followed all the laid-down procedures.
40 On cross-examination, RW1 stated that the Board stopped the Claimant's salary on 26th April 2023 vide a Board memo, and that it was reinstated vide a letter dated 27th October 2023.
41 He testified that he did not know when the Claimant was paid as reflected in his payslip, but that payment was made in March 2024.
42 RW1 testified that the Board had written a notice indicating that salaries would be stopped, but conceded that he did not have that letter before the Court and that the Board did not write to the Claimant individually in March or April 2023.
43 RW1 testified that the Board did not know whether the Claimant was working at the hospital, as it does not supervise staff, and that the Chief Officer would be the one to confirm whether he was on duty. He confirmed that the Claimant was not paid for the period from 26th April 2023 to March 2024.
44 On re-examination, RW1 referred to the letter of 6th March 2023 addressed to all departments on the authentication of academic certificates, the letter of 4th April 2023, and the letter of 5th June 2023 on the stoppage of salary.
45 He testified that the Claimant's salary was stopped vide the memo and reinstated after the Court order, after which the Claimant appeared for verification.
Claimant’s Submissions
46 The Claimant filed written submissions dated 10th June 2026 and supplementary submissions dated 15th July 2026, in reply to the Respondents' submissions dated 29th June 2026.
47 The Claimant identified the following issues for determination: whether the stoppage of his salary without notice or hearing was lawful; whether the Respondents violated his rights under Articles 41 and 47 of the Constitution; whether he suffered compensable injury despite payment of the arrears; whether he is entitled to general and special damages; and who should bear the costs of the suit.
48 On the first issue, the Claimant submitted that the stoppage was unlawful, arbitrary and procedurally unfair. He argued that the Respondents issued him no written notice, gave him no reasons at the time of the action and accorded him no opportunity to be heard, in direct violation of Article 47(1) and (2) of the Constitution, which provide that "Every person has the right to administrative action that is expeditious, efficient, lawful, reasonable and procedurally fair" and that "If a right or fundamental freedom of a person has been or is likely to be adversely affected by administrative action, the person has the right to be given written reasons for the action."
49 He further relied on Sections 17 and 18 of the Employment Act and submitted that wages are due for work done and are payable at the end of each month. Having worked fully during the period in question, he contended that the Respondents had no legal basis to withhold his salary without first following due disciplinary or administrative procedure.
50 In reply to the Respondents' submissions, the Claimant argued that the Respondents had made express admissions that substantially support his case.
51 He submitted that the Respondents admit that his salary was stopped in June 2023, that the stoppage was deliberate and implemented pursuant to a resolution of the County Public Service Board, and that it continued until the Board resolved to reinstate his salary, which only happened after the Respondents were made aware of this suit and of the Court Order issued on 4th August 2023. He contended that the Respondents no longer dispute the act complained of, and the only question left is whether the stoppage was lawful.
52 He submitted that the Respondents further admit that no show cause letter, notice to show cause, suspension letter or interdiction letter was issued, and that no disciplinary charge was preferred against him. Therefore, these admissions demonstrate that his salary was stopped outside any process recognized under the Employment Act or the applicable human resource framework.
53 The Claimant further submitted that the Respondents have failed to identify any law authorizing the stoppage of the salary of an employee who continued working. Although the Respondents rely on Sections 59 and 59A of the County Governments Act, they point to no provision in those sections empowering the Board to stop payment of earned salary, to compel an employee to continue working without remuneration, or to impose a financial penalty for failure to attend a verification exercise. He contended that administrative powers are not synonymous with the power to withhold earned wages.
54 He further submitted that the Respondents concede, at paragraph 21 of their submissions, that wages are payable monthly under Sections 17 and 18 of the Employment Act, yet fail to identify any statutory exception permitting the withholding of his wages in the circumstances.
55 On the alleged insubordination, the Claimant submitted that if the Respondents genuinely considered his conduct to amount to insubordination, as they characterize it at paragraph 9 of their submissions, the Employment Act required them to commence disciplinary proceedings. He argued that the Respondents cannot rely on alleged misconduct while admitting that no charge existed, no hearing occurred and no disciplinary process was commenced, as this amounts to deliberately bypassing the statutory disciplinary framework.
56 On the violation of his constitutional rights, the Claimant submitted that the Respondents violated his rights under Article 41(2) of the Constitution, which guarantees every worker the right to fair remuneration and to reasonable working conditions, as well as his protection from arbitrary employer conduct. He maintained that forcing an employee to continue working without pay or explanation constitutes a gross violation of fair labour practices.
57 He submitted that the Respondents do not deny that he continued reporting to work throughout the period, and that paragraph 15(iii) of their submissions in fact confirms it. He argued that the inevitable conclusion is that the Respondents required him to keep rendering services while withholding his remuneration, and they offer no legal basis upon which an employer may receive an employee's labour while withholding his wages for several months.
58 The Claimant faulted the Respondents for failing to justify the duration of the stoppage, arguing that they offer no explanation why a reminder could not be issued, why the verification could not have been completed earlier, or why his salary remained withheld for months while he was in active service. He termed the prolonged deprivation manifestly disproportionate.
59 On Article 47, the Claimant submitted that the Respondents failed on all fronts, as there was no prior notice, no hearing and no written reasons at the time of the action. Further, the Respondents do not dispute these facts but instead argue that Article 47 does not apply. He contended that this argument cannot stand, because the Respondents themselves repeatedly describe the stoppage as an administrative action, and having admitted as much, they cannot simultaneously argue that the constitutional safeguards regulating administrative action are inapplicable.
60 He further submitted that the Respondents identify no letter communicating the stoppage, no written explanation issued before its implementation and no written reasons supplied to him.
61 It is the Claimant’s submission that the reasons were advanced for the first time in pleadings filed after the commencement of litigation, and such post-litigation justification cannot retrospectively cure procedural unfairness or a constitutional violation that was already complete at the time of the stoppage.
62 On whether damages are payable despite the payment of his salary, the Claimant submitted that the Respondents' argument that no loss exists because his salary was later reinstated is legally untenable. He argued that Kenyan courts have consistently held that a violation of constitutional rights is compensable even where pecuniary loss is later mitigated.
63 The Claimant submitted that the wrong in this case is not non-payment alone, but the arbitrary deprivation of income, forced financial distress, procedural unfairness and reputational and credit harm. He reasoned payment of arrears does not erase months of unlawful deprivation of income, penalties already incurred, disruption of his contractual obligations or an infringement of constitutional rights that had already crystallised.
64 He maintained that the wrong was complete when the Respondents withheld his salary without according him procedural fairness, and that subsequent compliance cannot retrospectively validate an unlawful administrative decision.
65 The Claimant submitted that he produced documentary evidence of bank penalties and charges, loan repayment distress, credit exposure and the risk of listing with the Credit Reference Bureau, as well as a loan facility rejected on account of the stoppage. He argued that these are direct consequences of the Respondents' unlawful action and not remote or speculative losses.
66 He further submitted that the Respondents merely put him to strict proof without demonstrating that the documents are forged, inaccurate or unrelated to the stoppage, and that a bare denial cannot displace documentary evidence already before the Court.
67 On general damages, the Claimant submitted that he is entitled to an award for violation of his constitutional and labour rights on account of the unlawful stoppage of his salary without due process, his continued compulsory labour without remuneration, the financial embarrassment and distress he suffered, and the injury to his dignity and financial standing.
68 He submitted that this Court is empowered to grant appropriate relief, including compensation, under Article 23 of the Constitution and Section 12 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act.
69 On special damages, he argued that he specifically pleaded and proved Kshs. 20,588, being bank penalties and charges directly linked to the stoppage, and that he has thereby satisfied the settled requirement that special damages must be both pleaded and proved.
70 On costs, the Claimant submitted that costs follow the event and that the Respondents' unlawful administrative action necessitated these proceedings and prolonged the litigation until the Court intervened.
Respondents’ Submissions
71 The Respondents submitted that the Claimant’s salary was temporarily stopped in June 2023 following his failure to comply with the County Public Service Board’s directive requiring employees in Job Groups “P”, “Q” and “R” in the Department of Health Services to appear for authentication and verification of their academic and professional certificates. They relied on the Board’s memoranda dated 6th March 2023 and 4th April 2023, issued pursuant to Sections 59 and 59A of the County Governments Act, which also sought to address human resource audit and headcount concerns. They contended that the exercise applied to all employees within the specified job groups and was neither discriminatory nor intended to single out the Claimant.
72 The Respondents submitted that the Claimant failed to appear before the Board on the scheduled dates of 13th and 14th April 2023 and did not provide any explanation for his non-compliance. They contended that the Board consequently resolved, at its meeting held on 26th April 2023, to stop the salaries of eight officers, including the Claimant, with effect from June 2023. They maintained that the action was an administrative measure arising from the Claimant’s failure to comply with the Board’s directive and not a disciplinary or punitive sanction.
73 They further submitted that, following the Court order issued on 4th August 2023, the Board resolved on 9th November 2023 to reinstate the Claimant’s salary and directed him to present his credentials for verification. The Claimant subsequently appeared before the Board on 5th December 2023 and presented his credentials, after which the matter was addressed.
74 On whether the Claimant’s rights under Articles 41 and 47 of the Constitution were violated, the Respondents submitted that no disciplinary proceedings were instituted against him. The Claimant was neither issued with a notice to show cause, interdiction or suspension letter nor subjected to any disciplinary charge, and he continued reporting to work and discharging his duties throughout the period in question.
75 They submitted that the salary stoppage was an administrative measure undertaken pursuant to Sections 59 and 59A of the County Governments Act and did not constitute disciplinary action against the Claimant.
76 The Respondents further submitted that Article 47 of the Constitution did not automatically require a notice, hearing and written reasons in every instance of temporary salary interruption. They argued that the constitutional safeguards were intended to address unlawful, unreasonable or procedurally unfair administrative action likely to adversely affect a person, particularly where an adverse decision is made against an identified employee following an allegation or finding of wrongdoing.
77 They distinguished Kisa & another v National Police Service Commission & 3 others (Cause E931 of 2023) [2025] KEELRC 1601 (KLR), in which the Court found a violation of Article 47 following the stoppage of police officers’ salaries and their subsequent purported dismissal without notice, reasons or a hearing. They argued that, unlike in that case, the Claimant herein was not dismissed, interdicted, suspended or subjected to any adverse finding, and that the verification exercise was capable of correction and was ultimately concluded without disciplinary consequences.
78 The Respondents also denied violating Article 41 of the Constitution, submitting that the Claimant was not denied fair remuneration, demoted, dismissed or subjected to a reduction in his employment terms. They maintained that his salary was temporarily interrupted because of his non-compliance with the Board’s directive but was subsequently reinstated with arrears.
79 It is the Respondents submission that characterizing the temporary stoppage as a gross violation of fair labour practices conflated an administrative measure with substantive unfairness of the kind Article 41 seeks to prevent.
80 Further, while acknowledging that Sections 17 and 18 of the Employment Act ordinarily require wages to be paid when due, they submitted that the circumstances did not amount to unlawful withholding of wages in the punitive sense alleged by the Claimant, particularly since his full salary was eventually paid and no arrears remained outstanding.
81 In the alternative, the Respondents submitted that, even if Article 47 were found to apply, the absence of an adverse finding or disciplinary sanction, together with the subsequent reinstatement of salary, ought to be considered in determining whether the Claimant suffered compensable injury and, if so, the appropriate award. They argued that the Claimant bore the burden of proving both the existence and extent of the alleged loss on a balance of probabilities.
82 They further submitted that special damages must be specifically pleaded and strictly proved, while a claim for general damages founded on an alleged constitutional violation presupposes proof of the violation itself.
83 In support of their position on damages, the Respondents relied on Kenya Revenue Authority v Mwongela (Civil Appeal E268 of 2022) [2025] KECA 262 (KLR), submitting that compensation must be proportionate to the actual prejudice suffered and should not result in a windfall. They also relied on Achieng v Agimba & another (Cause E180 of 2021) [2025] KEELRC 540 (KLR), in which the Court declined to award damages founded on assertions unsupported by credible evidence. They argued that the Claimant’s allegations of financial distress, reputational and credit harm, and injury to his dignity and financial standing were insufficiently particularized and unsupported by adequate evidence.
84 Regarding the claim for special damages of Kshs. 20,588 in bank penalties and charges, the Respondents put the Claimant to strict proof of the causal connection between the charges and the temporary salary stoppage, the reasonableness of the charges and the authenticity and completeness of the supporting documents. They further contended that the Claimant was under a duty to mitigate his loss. In any event, they argued that even if the amount were proved, it would not, without more, establish the broader allegations of substantial financial loss and constitutional injury or justify an award of general damages.
85 The Respondents thus submitted that the basis for an award of general damages had not been established, as there was no unlawful salary stoppage, loss of employment, demotion or disciplinary record, and the Claimant ultimately received his full salary with arrears. In the alternative, should the Court find that the Claimant suffered injury, they urged it to award only modest and proportionate damages, having regard to the temporary nature of the salary stoppage and the subsequent restoration of his remuneration.
86 On costs, the Respondents submitted that, as the claim lacked merit, costs should follow the event and be awarded to them. Alternatively, should the Court find partially in the Claimant’s favour, they urged it to direct each party to bear its own costs pursuant to Section 12(4) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act. They therefore prayed that the claim be dismissed with costs or, in the alternative, that any award be limited to strictly proved special damages, with no award of general damages.
87 I have examined all the evidence and submissions of the parties herein. The respondents have admitted that there was temporary stoppage of the claimant’s salary which was finally restored following a court order.
88 The respondents have averred that the salary of the claimant was stopped due to none compliance of their memo requiring verification of employees. The respondents do however admit that they did not serve this memo upon the claimant but upon his department.
89 The respondents also admit that they never served the claimant with any notice of disciplinary action before stopping his salary. The respondents evidence show failure by the respondents to follow laid down procedure. Stoppage of salary is a disciplinary measure and thus can only be enforced after due notice and a disciplinary hearing as envisaged under section 41 of the Employment Act 2007 which states as follows:
41. (1). Subject to section 42 (1), an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee, on the grounds of misconduct, poor performance or physical incapacity explain to the employee, in a language the employee understands, the reason for which the employer is considering termination and the employee shall be entitled to have another employee or a shop floor union representative of his choice present during this explanation.
90 In the case of the claimant, there was no hearing and so the claimant was condemned unheard. Due to this omission, I find that the respondents violated the claimant’s rights under the contract and I accordingly award him damages equivalent to kshs 500,000/- for the breach. The respondents will also pay kshs 20,588/- interest due upon the contract for unremitted standing orders. Total kshs 522,588/-.
91 The respondents will pay costs of this suit plus interest at court rates with effect from the date of this judgment.
Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nairobi this 27th Day of October 2026.
HELLEN WASILWA
JUDGE