Meet Sheriaplex AI. Research, draft and review with tools for Kenyan legal work.

Try AI chat ↗Explore AI Tools →
Employment law

Kenya Airline Pilots Association (KALPA) v Kenya Airways Ltd [2026] KEELRC 14787 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elrc Cause 854 of 2018
Judgment date
27 October 2026
Judge(s)
Hellen Wasilwa

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The Court awarded Kshs. 2,790,250 less statutory deductions, ordered issuance of a certificate of service, and ordered the respondent to pay costs and interest at court rates from the date of judgment.

Supporting judgment passages

TOTAL AWARDED – 2,790,250/- less statutory deductions.

Passage 204 →

(4) The respondent be issued with a certificate of service.

Passage 205 →

(5) The respondent will pay costs of this suit plus interest at court rates with effect from the date of this judgment.

Passage 206 →
Issue 1Whether the claimant’s termination was fair and lawful.

Held. No. The Court held that the grievant’s termination was procedurally flawed and unsupported by established valid reasons, and was therefore unfair and unjustified. It also found differential treatment: two other pilots facing similar concerns were retained or warned, while the grievant was terminated. The Court further held that the CEO’s unilateral revocation of the HR Director’s reinstatement decision was illegal.

Ratio. Under sections 41 and 45(2) of the Employment Act, termination cannot proceed without due process and is unfair where the employer fails to prove a valid reason and fair procedure.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

(1) Whether the claimant’s termination was fair and lawful.

Passage 148 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

141 RW1 admitted that there were other pilots considered at the same TRB sitting who were retained. John Koiti’s case had similar concerns as for the grievant and he was given a warning. Milton Muturi’s issues also included failed examination, non attendance and flying with an expired licence and was given a final performance warning and offered counselling. This in itself is proof of differential treatment between the grievant and others.

Passage 185 →

142 The RW1 confirmed that a letter of 2/8/2017 reinstated the grievant on behalf of management under the head of the group HR director Sammy Chepkwony and was revoked by the respondent’s MD vide a letter of 9/2/2018. The revocation of the reinstatement done by the respondents CEO was also an act done illegally and unilaterally given that the reinstatement had been done by the HRD for respondent and the CEO had no power to revoke the same.

Passage 186 →

146 In the circumstances of the grievant case, there was both lack of proper procedure and establishment of valid reasons for termination and I therefore return the verdict that the grievant’s termination was both unfair and unjustified.

Passage 198 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

144 Section 41 of the Employment Act 2007 envisages that a termination could not progress without due process. As admitted by RW1 the decisions were made against the grievant without due process stated therein.

Passage 188 →

employer is unfair if the employer fails to prove―

Passage 191 →

(c) that the employment was terminated in accordance with fair procedure

Passage 197 →
Issue 2Whether the claimant is entitled to the prayers sought.

Held. Partly. The Court awarded 12 months’ compensation for unlawful termination of Kshs. 1,432,200; three months’ salary in lieu of notice of Kshs. 358,050; and Kshs. 1,000,000 as discrimination damages.

Ratio. Maximum compensation was warranted because of the discriminatory manner of treatment, delayed career progress, and retraining expense. The discrimination award rested on unequal treatment compared with two other pilots facing similar complaints.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

(2) Whether the claimant is entitled to the prayers sought.

Passage 149 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

(1) 12 months’ salary as compensation for the unlawful termination = 12x119,350= kshs 1,432,200/-.

Passage 201 →

(2) I also award her 3 months’ salary in lieu of notice = kshs 3x119,350/-=358,050/-.

Passage 202 →

(3) I also award the grievant kshs 1million as damages for discrimination as seen from the unequal treatment of 2 other pilots who were facing similar complaints.

Passage 203 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

147 On issue of remedies, having found for the grievant and given the discriminatory manner she was treated and her career progress delayed leading her to incur expense for retraining, it is my finding that maximum compensation is payable to her. I therefore award her:

Passage 200 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

The court identified whether the grievant’s termination was fair and lawful, and whether she was entitled to the remedies sought. Although the respondent submitted that the union, rather than the grievant, was the named claimant and therefore could not obtain…

Material facts

KALPA brought the claim for its member, First Officer Samira Khan, employed by Kenya Airways from 2005 and later assigned to the B767 fleet. Her B777, command-upgrade and B737 training did not culminate in promotion. Kenya Airways terminated her employment…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

ELRC CAUSE NO. 854 OF 2018

(Before Hon. Lady Justice Hellen Wasilwa, J)

KENYA AIRLINE PILOTS ASSOCIATION (KALPA)........CLAIMANT

VS

KENYA AIRWAYS LIMITED......................................RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

1 The Claimant union instituted this claim vide an Amended Memorandum of Claim dated 20th July 2020 and prays that this Court grants him an award as follows:

a. A declaration that the Respondent unfairly and unlawfully terminated the Claimant’s employment;

b. Compensation in accordance with Section 49 of the Employment Act, 2007 equivalent to FO Samira’s 12 months’ salary for unfair and unlawful termination;

c. Award of general and/or exemplary and/or punitive and/or aggravated damages for the Respondent’s discriminatory and traumatic treatment of FO Samira;

d. Special damages for the expenses incurred as a result of the matters pleaded at paragraphs 24 and 25 above (full particulars of which shall be supplied before the hearing);

e. Costs of the suit;

f. Interest on the above until payment in full.

Claimant’s Case

2 The Claimant union avers that it is a trade union established to represent the interests of all pilots employed by the Respondent and its subsidiaries, and that its relationship with the Respondent is governed by the Recognition Agreement dated 5th May 1978 and a Collective Bargaining Agreement. It states that it filed this suit on behalf of its member, First Officer Samira Khan (the grievant).

3 It is the Claimant union's case that by a contract of employment dated 9th February 2005, the Respondent employed the grievant as a Second Officer with effect from 28th February 2005, at a basic salary of Kshs. 100,000, house allowance of Kshs. 14,000 and transport allowance of Kshs. 5,350.

4 It states that she successfully completed her probation and was confirmed as a First Officer on permanent terms, and that throughout her employment she was placed on the Respondent's B767 fleet.

5 The Claimant union avers that at all material times the grievant carried out her duties with faithfulness, diligence and professionalism, in full compliance with her employment contract and job description.

6 It states that in or about February 2009, the grievant came up for promotion to the B777 fleet in the rank of First Officer, subject to her undergoing training and demonstrating proficiency on the aircraft.

7 The Claimant union contends that during this training, she was subjected to bullying, harassment, humiliation and intimidation by the Fleet Manager and instructors, who ganged up against her and exhibited a pre-conceived notion that she was difficult and undeserving of the promotion.

8 It further contends that she was frustrated by the Respondent's delays in finalizing the training, and was unfairly denied remedial training after she was failed, despite the instructor's assurance that the training had gone well and that she would be scheduled for another Route Proficiency Check to validate her proficiency.

9 The Claimant union states that after three months of forced leave, the grievant was informed on 25th January 2010 of the decision to terminate her training and return her to her previous fleet. She appealed on 2nd February 2010, citing her mistreatment and the training gaps, but the appeal was declined on 8th February 2010.

10 It avers that it lodged a further appeal, which was discussed at a meeting of both parties held on 9th March 2010, but the Respondent remained adamant that the decision would be upheld. Consequently, the grievant was sent back to the B767, where she was restricted for two years up to July 2012.

11 It is the Claimant union's case that in September 2012 the grievant was again up for promotion and was sent to South Africa for a course meant to prepare candidates for an upgrade from First Officer to Captain.

12 It avers that according to the instructor's comments in her training file, the training went well. However, the grievant was later informed that she had failed and would be sent back to the B767, on the basis of numerous alleged failures in her training file. This came as a surprise, as she had never failed any checks or trainings on the B767.

13 The Claimant union further avers that in December 2014, the grievant was again up for promotion to the B737, but the instructor terminated the training prematurely on the ground that he was not confident she would pass the final check with only three sessions remaining.

14 It contends that this was contrary to normal practice, especially during initial command training, where a pilot is given extra sessions.

15 The union avers that the grievant’s pleas to the instructor, the Fleet Manager, the Director of Flight Operations and the Head of Training yielded no positive results, and she was informed that her case would be referred to the Training Review Board (TRB).

16 The Claimant union states that on 5th June 2015, the grievant's employment was terminated on grounds of alleged unsatisfactory simulator performance. This was despite Clause 4 of the Seniority and Promotions Policy of the CBA, which provided that failure in transitional training or in the necessary exams would result in automatic return to an employee's previous fleet or position, and despite its recommendation at the TRB meeting that she be given a chance to train on the B787 or be considered for training on the right seat of the B737.

17 It avers that the grievant has since lodged numerous appeals personally, through her lawyers, through the Claimant union and by way of conciliation, but the Respondent has refused and neglected to address the matter fairly.

18 It states that following its appeal the grievant was reinstated on 2nd August 2017, but the decision was nullified by the Respondent's Managing Director on 9th February 2018, on the ground that he had found no sufficient grounds to review the termination.

19 The Claimant union contends that the Respondent's actions were discriminatory, unconstitutional, vindictive, pre-determined, unfair, unlawful and malicious.

20 It asserts that the termination was carried out without any valid reason or lawful cause and contrary to Section 41 of the Employment Act, in that the grievant was not given an explanation of the allegations against her, was not accorded an opportunity to be heard at a disciplinary hearing, and was denied representation by the Claimant union before the decision was made.

21 It further faults the premature termination of her training, the premature referral to the TRB instead of remedial training, and the denial of the opportunity to continue as a First Officer on the B787.

22 It is the Claimant union's further case that the termination was exacerbated by the Respondent grounding the grievant for five months and waiting until her instrument rating expired before informing her of the decision, and by the Respondent continuing to perpetuate the lie that she performed poorly, rendering it impossible for her to secure alternative employment.

23 It avers that the Respondent's actions have subjected the grievant to untold psychological and mental trauma and anguish, amounting to unfair labour practices contrary to Article 41 of the Constitution.

24 The Claimant union states that in an attempt to secure alternative employment, the grievant had to go back to flying school in 2017, where she sat the air law exam, flew six hours on a single engine and undertook a type rating on a twin engine (Seneca 1) aircraft to facilitate recurrency and exams to renew her Airline License and Instrument rating. In May 2018 she did the same, save that she renewed on a single engine aircraft because the twin engine is very expensive, and she is therefore quite limited on job options. It avers that the two trainings cost her USD 18,328 and Kshs. 377,240 respectively.

25 The Claimant union denies that the grievant exhibited poor performance, including inconsistent decision making and poor judgment, and puts the Respondent to strict proof. It asserts that for the entire duration of her employment she passed her annual checks, including proficiency checks, base checks and ground school refreshers, and had no problem at all in her flying duties on the B767 fleet for ten years. Her problems only arose when she was due for promotion, and that the Respondent, its servants and agents were determined to frustrate her progress.

26 It further denies that the grievant was given any remedial training. It states that the route training on the B777 fleet took 220 hours instead of the scheduled 180 hours because of the large gaps between flights since 7th September 2009 and constant changes to her training schedule, which made her preparation difficult.

27 The Claimant union avers that with effect from March 2014, the basic salary of First Officers operating the B767 fleet was Kshs. 489,502, the house allowance was Kshs. 30,814 and the layover allowance was USD 180 per day for 10 days.

28 It states that despite demand and notice of intention to sue, the Respondent has refused to admit liability or compensate the grievant.

Respondent’s Case

29 In opposition to the claim, the Respondent filed a Memorandum of Reply dated 24th January 2019.

30 The Respondent avers that the grievant was employed as a Second Officer in 2005 at a basic salary of Kshs. 100,000 and a housing allowance of Kshs. 14,000. However, her employment was terminated with effect from 5th June 2015 due to unsatisfactory performance while in the Boeing 737 command training.

31 It is the Respondent's case that the grievant underwent simulator training scheduled from 29th December 2014 to 20th January 2015, which was discontinued by a simulator instructor on 13th January 2015. The reasons given were inconsistency in decision making leading to poor judgment, and lack of concentration and planning resulting in loss of situational awareness. A panel of instructors thereafter recommended that she be reviewed by a Training Review Board (TRB), whose membership consists of Flight Operations Management and representatives of the Claimant union.

32 The Respondent states that at its meeting of 19th May 2015, the TRB noted that the two weaknesses needed to be at a very high standard for a command candidate, which the grievant lacked. The management team further observed that she had the same problems in her previous fleet and during the failed conversion training on the Boeing 777. It was also noted that since her previous fleet, the Boeing 767, had exited the service, the only option available was for her to separate with the company.

33 The Respondent avers that the TRB considered the grievant's weaknesses to be non-technical and non-aircraft specific, and therefore retraining on the Boeing 787 was not an option.

34 It contends that the TRB was guided by Clause 9.11.3 of the Operations Manual Part D, which states that "where unsatisfactory performance includes or is in areas which are non-aircraft specific like general aircraft handling, situational awareness, SOPs or instrument flying, retraining on a previous fleet shall not be an option", and that it had no choice but to comply.

35 It states that the TRB arrived at a unanimous recommendation that, as the grievant had no previous fleet to return to and due to her poor performance over her time as a pilot in the airline, she should separate with the company.

36 The Respondent asserts that the Claimant union was represented at this meeting by its then Chairman, its then General Secretary and its current Chairman, and that the signed minutes are annexed.

37 The Respondent further avers that in 2010 the grievant's B777 route training was terminated because she had accumulated 220 hours on route training without checking out and failed the Route Proficiency Certificate (RPC) examination on 27th December 2009.

38 It states that grievant’s performance was assessed by a panel of four experienced instructors, who recommended that the training be terminated for lack of situational awareness, as communicated by the letter of 25th January 2010. And her appeal for reinstatement into the B777 fleet training was rejected after exhaustive discussion by both the Claimant union and management on 9th March 2010.

39 The Respondent states that the Group Human Resources Director concurred with the TRB's recommendation and, upon approval by the Group Managing Director, the decision to terminate the grievant's employment was reached.

40 It is the Respondent’s case that the grievant was called to a meeting with the Director Flight Operations and the HR Relationship Manager on 15th June 2015, where she was briefed on the recommendation and its approval, and issued with her termination letter and certificate of service. She was advised that she was at liberty to appeal.

41 The Respondent further avers that the grievant appealed to the Group HR Director by a letter dated 14th July 2015, claiming the termination was unfair and unjust. In her appeal, she admitted that an instructor stopped her training in January 2015 after she had completed session 5 of the Full Flight Simulator program, and that she had verbally requested the Fleet Manager and the Head of Flight Operations Training for extra simulator sessions to take corrective measures.

42 The Respondent contends that this shows she acknowledged her weaknesses, and that the training was stopped because her performance was below the expected standards.

43 The Respondent states that the grievant challenged the ground of having no fleet to return to as an excuse, since all other ex-B767 pilots had been trained on the B787, and sought another chance at the B737 command training or to be type-rated on the B787. It maintains, however, that she previously had performance challenges while training for the B777 and later in the simulator.

44 On the instrument rating, the Respondent avers that the grievant was being trained on the B737 as a Captain when she failed due to poor performance, and that had she completed the training she would have had a current rating on the B737 and a renewed Instrument Rating.

45 It contends that it is therefore not at fault for the grievant’s lack of currency, and that any attempt to blame it for the expiry of her instrument rating is a ploy to tarnish its reputation. Additionally, the Respondent should not give her a free rating on the B737 by completing her training, as this would expose the company in case of any incident arising from her competency.

46 The Respondent states that the Group HR Director found no grounds to support the appeal and upheld the termination by a letter dated 23rd October 2015. The grievant then appealed to the Group Managing Director and CEO, who informed her by a letter dated 29th June 2016 that he found no grounds to vary the decision. A second appeal to the same office was similarly declined.

47 It avers that in June 2017 the Claimant union made a further appeal to the newly engaged Group HR Director, who issued a letter reinstating the grievant without complying with Clause 17.14(b) of the HR Policies Manual, which requires the Group HR Director to consult the Group Managing Director and CEO in determining appeals involving termination or dismissal. The reinstatement was rescinded by the Group Managing Director and CEO after a meeting with the Claimant union, at which it was informed of the decision to uphold the termination. The Respondent maintains that the rescission was not done in bad faith.

48 The Respondent states that the Claimant union reported a trade dispute to the Cabinet Secretary for Labour and Social Protection by a letter dated 27th March 2018. Following conciliation, the parties were unable to agree and the Conciliator issued a Certificate of Unresolved Dispute dated 5th May 2018, recommending that the termination be upheld and the grievant be paid her terminal dues plus two months' salary as compensation for loss of employment. It avers that neither party pursued this recommendation.

49 In specific response to the claim, the Respondent denies the allegations of bullying, harassment, humiliation and intimidation, and states that it never received any such complaint from the grievant or the Claimant union.

50 It denies that refusal and neglect to address the grievant’s appeals fairly, and states that she did not proffer any valid reasons to warrant variation of the decision and was informed of the reasons her appeals were declined.

51 The Respondent maintains that the termination was lawful, that the reasons were satisfactorily explained to the grievant, that she was given ample notice, and that she was accorded the opportunity to be heard after her termination. It denies that its actions amount to unfair labour practices.

52 As regards her retraining expenses, it states that it is unclear why it is being dragged into the grievant’s attempts at personal development, and that she is perhaps limited on job options because of her inconsistency and poor performance.

53 The Respondent contends that the termination was performance related and that, the grievant having failed her command training including the remedial training given in her favour, there was little option but to terminate her employment.

54 It asserts that the termination was on valid grounds and in strict adherence to the law, and prays that the claim be dismissed with costs.

Evidence in Court

55 The grievant, Samira Khan (CW1) appeared as the Claimant’s witness.

56 On cross-examination, CW1 conceded that the TRB is one of the forums governing her relationship with her employer, that it comprised representatives of both KALPA and the Respondent, and that it was KALPA which filed the claim on her behalf.

57 She admitted that she had produced no evidence of having passed the B777 ground school. She further admitted that she did not complete the 2015 simulator training on the B737-800 and never reached route training.

58 CW1 confirmed in her testimony that she had a training file which she and her instructor both signed, that she was aware of whatever the instructor recorded in it, and that she could have complained to her superiors, physically or in writing, if she disagreed. She maintained, however, that signing the file did not mean the instructor was correct.

59 It was CW1’s testimony that at the TRB her union did not take the position that she was unfit to continue, but proposed that she be retrained on the B787 and restricted to the First Officer's position for some years, with other fleets such as the B737 also available.

60 She testified that after the TRB, KALPA appealed and she appealed directly to two Chief Executive Officers, both of whom upheld the separation. She conceded that the letter of 2nd August 2017 indicated only that her appeal had been reviewed and did not say her termination had been revoked. She insisted that her superiors' judgment of her was wrong, since she has for three years flown for Etihad, a major airline.

61 CW1 admitted that after termination she did not collect her clearance certificate, undergo medicals or pick her three months' pay, as she had appealed, did not agree with the termination and had been so advised.

62 On her licence, she testified that it expired because the Respondent grounded her for about a year, including six months when the B767 fleet was retired, and that it was the Respondent's responsibility to keep her proficient and provide for her instrument rating.

63 In re-examination, she clarified that she was still an employee when grounded. She stated that the letter of 10th February 2015 gave no particulars of the alleged poor judgment and inconsistency in decision making, that her file contained nothing on how she had performed, and that no report was ever shared with her.

64 CW1 further testified that her union did not agree at the TRB that she could not be placed elsewhere, that the minutes do not explain how the decision was arrived at, and that it was management which decided. She also pointed out that her 2010 training was stopped at 220 hours, whereas the CBA allows a maximum of 250.

65 RW1, Captain Paul Njoroge, the Respondent's Director of Flight Operations and Acting Chief Operating Officer and its Head of Training at the material time, adopted his witness statement of 24th January 2019 and produced the Respondent's bundle as his exhibits.

66 On cross-examination, he admitted that he had no document showing that FO Samira was invited to be heard before the decision of 10th February 2015 to discontinue her training, and none prior to 2015 inviting her to a hearing.

67 RW1 testified that he had tendered no evidence of the alleged inconsistency in decision making or poor judgment. He had attached no performance appraisal and no trainer's report showing her scores, and she was never placed on a performance improvement plan. The report he prepared for the TRB was also not before the Court.

68 In his testimony, RW1 accepted that the Respondent's policy provides for remedial lessons where a pilot has not passed training, and that the CBA allows 250 hours for conversion to the B777, although he stated that the maximum as of today should be 150 to 180 hours and that she had also failed the route proficiency check.

69 RW1 further conceded that the two other pilots considered at the same TRB sitting were retained. In John Koiti's case the concerns were both technical and non-technical, including poor situational awareness, which was also a ground for FO Samira's termination, yet he was given a warning. Milton Muturi, whose issues included failed examinations, non-attendance and, according to management, flying with an expired licence, was given a final performance warning and offered counselling.

70 RW1 testified that FO Samira's termination was upheld because her weaknesses were non-technical in nature and retraining was therefore not an option.

71 On the reinstatement, he admitted that the letter of 2nd August 2017 arose from her appeal and communicated a decision to reinstate her on behalf of management, under the hand of the Group Human Resource Director, Sammy Chepkwony.

72 RW1 testified that the revocation of 9th February 2018 came from the CEO and not from management, and no misconduct was pointed out between the two dates. He also stated that pilots whose fleets had been retired were redeployed to other fleets.

Claimants’ Submissions

73 The Claimant union submitted that the grievant's promotions were subject to her undergoing training and demonstrating proficiency on the aircraft, and that the Respondent denied her promotion by frustrating her trainings.

74 On the B777 training of 2009, the Claimant union submitted that the training was terminated before completion of all the lessons in the training plan, by the Respondent's letter of 25th January 2010, on the ground that she had accumulated over 220 hours on route training without checking out and had failed her RPC. The Claimant union argued that this was unfair, unlawful and contrary to the Respondent's own Seniority and Promotion Policy, Clause 2(b)(iv) of which provides that:"The pilot must qualify on advanced type as follows; obtain B767 and B777 route qualification within 250 hours."

75 It submitted that it is not a fair labour practice for an employer to deny an employee promotion by applying standards contrary to its own internal policy, and that the termination of the training therefore violated the grievant's right under Article 41 of the Constitution.

76 Relying on Jane Samba Mukala v Ol Tukai Lodge Limited [2013] eKLR, as quoted in Chira v Messier Inclusive Technology Limited [2026] KEELRC 1012 (KLR), for the proposition that where poor performance is alleged, an employer must set clear targets, give guidance and allow reasonable time to improve. The Claimant union submitted that the grievant was not even allowed to exhaust the time prescribed for her training, let alone given more time and a chance to improve. In its view, fair labour practice required that she exhaust her training hours and, if she did not perform satisfactorily, be given remedial lessons.

77 As regards the 2012 training in South Africa, the Claimant union submitted that the grievant's testimony that her instructor informed her that the training had gone well, only for her to be told later that she had failed, was not controverted.

78 On the B737 training of December 2014, it submitted that the instructor terminated the training prematurely on the ground that he was not confident the grievant would pass the final check, although the training period had not ended. It contended that this was the height of unreasonableness and arbitrariness and a further violation of Article 41. Additionally, despite the grievant’s pleas to be allowed to complete the training, her case was referred to the TRB without her being given an opportunity to be heard.

79 On the termination, the Claimant union submitted that it was unfair both in procedure and in substance. The termination letter of 5th June 2015 opens with a reference to the grievant's B737 Command report, which impliedly formed the basis of the termination, yet that report was never shared with her nor produced in court.

80 It is the Claimant union’s submission that she was never issued with a notice to show cause, was not invited to any disciplinary hearing and was not heard, contrary to Section 41(1) of the Employment Act, which provides:"Subject to section 42(1), an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee, on the grounds of misconduct, poor performance or physical incapacity explain to the employee, in a language the employee understands, the reason for which the employer is considering termination and the employee shall be entitled to have a shop floor union representative of his choice present during his explanation."

81 On the substance, the union submitted that the burden of proving unsatisfactory performance rested with the Respondent under Section 45(2) of the Employment Act and was not discharged. It relied on Chira (Supra), where termination for poor performance was held unlawful because no documentary evidence of clear measurable targets and no appraisal reports were produced.

82 It was submitted that the Respondent's witness admitted in cross-examination that instructors award marks or scores during training, that these are kept in the trainee's file, and that the file is in the Respondent's custody, yet no scores were produced or shared with the grievant. It is therefore impossible to verify the allegation that she failed, and that the natural inference is that she passed and registered high scores.

83 It further submitted that the witness admitted that her performance was never appraised and that she was never placed on a Performance Improvement Plan.

84 The Claimant union further argued that the two reasons given for discontinuing the training, namely inconsistency in decision making leading to poor judgment, and lack of concentration and planning leading to loss of situational awareness, were vague and lacking in particulars. Further, the grievant was never told when, where and how she made poor judgment or lost situational awareness, and was not given an opportunity to defend herself before the discontinuation and referral to the TRB.

85 It was also submitted that the grievant's uncontroverted testimony was that she was allowed only one attempt on the B777, and that in the 2014 training she passed all the exams but was denied the final check in the simulator. The Claimant union relied on Clause 4 of the Seniority and Promotions Policy of the CBA, which provides that failure in training or in the necessary exams results in automatic return to the employee's previous fleet or position, and on Clause 2, which allows retraining to a more advanced fleet provided "the pilot had not more than 2 failures in checks in the last 12 months". It submitted that she was not accorded this opportunity.

86 The Claimant union submitted that where a previous fleet ceased to exist, the Respondent had a practice of assigning the pilot to a different fleet, as referred to in its letter of 23rd January 2017 and in the grievant's own letter, and that the Respondent never denied this practice.

87 It argued that under Section 5(8)(c) of the Employment Act such a practice is equated to an employment policy to be applied to all employees without discrimination, and that the Respondent discriminated against the grievant by not applying it to her while applying it to pilots in similar circumstances.

88 On discrimination, the Claimant union submitted that the grievant was denied the equal treatment accorded to her fellow pilots and, being the only female among three pilots referred to the TRB, was discriminated against on the ground of her sex. It submitted that discrimination is prohibited under the Discrimination (Employment and Occupation) Convention, 1958 (No. 111), the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women, 1979, the Constitution, the Employment Act, the Persons with Disabilities Act and the National Cohesion and Integration Act.

89 It is the Claimant union’s submission that the TRB minutes show that two male officers were reviewed alongside the grievant. The first, Milton Muturi, had failed a company exam, had not attended computer based training and had flown with an expired CPL, yet the TRB only recommended a final performance warning letter and counselling. The second, John Thoiti, had concerns of both a technical and non-technical nature, the TRB noting that he "consistently performs below standards and demonstrates poor technical knowledge", with other areas of poor performance including "poor situational awareness and workload management". The recommendation in his case was only a letter pointing out the deficiencies.

90 In the grievant's case, it submitted that the TRB acknowledged that "she had put in a lot of effort in her command training", but concluded that: "The candidate has been dogged by the same problems in her previous fleet on the 767 and during the failed conversion on the 777. The only option for her seeing that her previous fleet is no longer in service as per the CBA is exit."

91 The Claimant union argued that no evidence was produced to support this, the grievant having flown the B767 for ten years, and that its plea at the TRB that she be given a chance to train on the B787 or on the right seat of the B737 was disregarded.

92 It is the Claimant union's submission that the reasons advanced against the grievant were the same as those against Mr. Thoiti, whose loss of situational awareness was equally non-technical, yet he was allowed to continue in service. Further, Mr. Muturi, not only failed his exams but committed the serious offence of flying without a licence, was retained, while the grievant, who had committed no offence and whose alleged failure was never proved, was terminated. This amounted to discrimination contrary to Section 5 of the Employment Act and Article 27 of the Constitution, and on account of her sex contrary to Article 27(5).

93 On the reinstatement, the Claimant union relied on the Respondent's letter of 2nd August 2017, which stated:"This is to advise that after due consideration of the presentations made at the appeal hearing as well as all the facts in the matter, Management has exceptionally decided to reinstate you back to employment in the rank of First Officer in the Embraer fleet…"It argued that the decision was thus made by management after considering all the relevant facts.

94 It submitted that the revocation by the letter of 9th February 2018 was unfair, unlawful and a violation of the right to fair labour practice, as the Respondent adduced no evidence of wrongdoing by the grievant between the reinstatement and its revocation, and pointed to no fault in management's decision.

95 On career stagnation, the Claimant union relied on Section 7(4) of the National Cohesion and Integration Act, which makes it unlawful for an employer to discriminate against an employee "in the way he affords him access to opportunities for promotion, transfer or training" or "by dismissing him, or subjecting him to any other detriment". It submitted that the grievant's uncontroverted evidence was that she incurred USD 18,328 and Kshs. 377,240 to renew her Airline Licence and Instrument Rating, an expense an employer would ordinarily bear.

96 It is the Claimant union’s submission that the Respondent ensured the grievant did not secure employment for a long time by issuing negative references to potential employers. It relied on an email of 13th November 2017 from a prospective employer, whose authenticity was not questioned, informing her that it had checked with the Respondent, learnt of performance issues and could therefore not invite her for further steps.

97 It submitted that the grievant only secured employment three years ago, eight years after the termination, and still serves as a First Officer, while the Respondent's witness testified that her former peers now serve as fleet captains, instructors and senior management pilots.

98 On reliefs, the Claimant union urged the court to award the maximum compensation under Section 49 of the Employment Act. It cited Simon Gitau Gichuru v Package Insurance Brokers Ltd (SC Petition No. 36 of 2019), where the Supreme Court awarded 12 months' compensation and stated that a court ought to look into the circumstances of each case, and on Adpack Limited v Nyamasage [2025] KEELRC 262 (KLR), where it was held that a maximum award is permissible provided the court explains the reason for it.

99 The Claimant union computed the grievant's gross monthly remuneration under the CBA at Kshs. 534,265, being basic salary of Kshs. 489,502, house allowance of Kshs. 30,814 and transport allowance of Kshs. 13,949, together with a guaranteed layover allowance of USD 1,800, and thus sought Kshs. 6,411,180 and USD 21,600. It further sought general damages of Kshs. 5,000,000 under Article 23 of the Constitution for discrimination and violation of the right to fair labour practice.

100 In support thereof, the Claimant union relied on Simon Gitau Gichuru (supra), where Kshs. 2,000,000 was awarded for discrimination and the Supreme Court considered the employee's salary and the period the employee would have continued working. It also cited Ol Pejeta Ranching Limited v David Wanjau Muhoro [2017] eKLR, where the Court of Appeal substituted an award of Kshs. 18,256,947 with Kshs. 7,500,000, and Pandya Memorial Hospital v Geeta Joshi [2020] eKLR, where Kshs. 3,000,000 was awarded.

101 It is the Claimant union’s submission that given the grievant's remuneration of over Kshs. 500,000 a month and eight years of unemployment, the sum sought is reasonable and within the range awarded by the superior courts.

102 The Claimant union also sought special damages as pleaded, and the final dues set out in the termination letter, which it submitted the Respondent's witness admitted were never paid. These include three months' salary and fixed allowances in lieu of notice, computed at Kshs. 1,602,795 and USD 5,400.

103 Citing Section 49 of the Employment Act, it submitted that the court ought to consider the extent to which an employee contributed to the termination and any payment made upon termination. It maintained that the grievant did not contribute to her termination in any way and was not paid even her final dues.

Respondent’s Submissions

104 By way of background, the Respondent submitted that FO Samira's employment was terminated on 5th June 2015 on account of unsatisfactory performance during her Boeing 737 command training.

105 The Respondent submitted that the grievant underwent simulator training between 29th December 2014 and 20th January 2015, which the simulator instructor discontinued on 13th January 2015 for two reasons: inconsistency in decision making leading to poor judgment, and lack of concentration and planning resulting in loss of situational awareness. Thereafter, a panel of instructors recommended that her case be referred to the Training Review Board (TRB), which comprises four representatives of the Respondent's Flight Operations Management and three representatives of the Claimant.

106 The Respondent submitted that the TRB, upon deliberation, found FO Samira's training weaknesses to be non-technical and non-aircraft specific, so that retraining on her previous fleet was not an option. The TRB was guided by clause 9.11.3 of the Operations Manual Part D, which provides that: "where unsatisfactory performance includes or is in areas which are non-aircraft specific like general aircraft handling, situational awareness, SOP's or instrument flying, retraining on a previous fleet shall not be an option."

107 It was submitted that the TRB unanimously recommended that FO Samira separate with the Respondent, as she had no fleet to return to and her performance as a pilot had been poor over time. The Respondent emphasized that the Claimant was represented at the TRB by its then Chairperson, Captain Isaac Areri, its then Secretary General, Captain Ronald Karauri, and Captain Njoroge Murimi, and that the matter reached the TRB only after FO Samira had been instructed and assessed by four instructors.

108 As regards the grievant’s reinstatement, the Respondent submitted that the Group Human Resource Director acted unilaterally, without consulting the Group Managing Director who had effected the termination, and contrary to the Respondent's Human Resource policies. It denied any bias, mistreatment or discrimination against her.

109 On whether the termination should be declared unfair and unlawful, the Respondent submitted that the prayer as framed seeks a declaration that the Respondent unfairly and unlawfully terminated the Claimant's employment, yet the Claimant is a trade union which has never been its employee. It argued that this cannot be treated as a typographical error, since the Claimant amended its pleadings two years later and altered only its address, leaving the prayer intact.

110 The Respondent submitted that parties are bound by their pleadings and relied on Ann Wairimu Wanjohi v James Wambiru Mukabi [2021] eKLR, where the Court of Appeal cited with approval David Sironga ole Tunai v Francis Arap Muge & 2 Others [2014] eKLR as follows: "It is well established in our jurisdiction that the court will not grant a remedy, which has not been applied for, and that it will not determine issues, which the parties have not pleaded… each party is bound by its own pleadings. For this reason, a party cannot be allowed to raise a different case from that which it has pleaded without due amendment being made."

111 It is the Respondent's submission that a claim for unfair termination can only be sustained where an employment relationship exists between the parties, and that none exists between it and the Claimant. The Respondent contended that this ground goes to the root of the claim, and that the entire suit be dismissed as null and void ab initio, with costs.

112 On compensation, the Respondent submitted that Section 49(1)(c) of the Employment Act, 2007 sets a ceiling of twelve months' gross salary, however, the Claimant having never been terminated, cannot claim compensation on the strength of the testimony of FO Samira, whom it described as an independent individual. It argued that nowhere in the pleadings has FO Samira herself pleaded unfair termination, and that what is before the Court is not, on the pleadings, a trade dispute.

113 The Respondent submitted that under Section 21 of the Labour Relations Act, 2007 the Claimant is a body corporate capable of suing and being sued in its own name, which is what it has done, while FO Samira, an adult with the same capacity, has not sued.

114 Reliance was placed on Kenya Aviation Workers Union v Kenya Airways Limited [2024] KECA 1411 (KLR), where the Court of Appeal stated:"By dint of section 21 of the Labour Relations Act, KAWU as a duly registered trade union, is a body corporate with capacity to sue and be sued in its own name. KAWU filed the claim in the ELRC in its name, as well as the notice of appeal on record, and KAWU is therefore the intended appellant." From this authority, the Respondent submitted that the Claimant and FO Samira are distinct parties to be treated separately, and that compensation equivalent to her twelve months' salary cannot be awarded on the basis of a termination allegedly visited upon the union.

115 Without prejudice to the foregoing, the Respondent submitted that it followed lawful procedure, involving both the Claimant and FO Samira, and that this evidence stands unrebutted.

116 It was submitted that FO Samira was given numerous chances to improve her performance but failed to do so, leaving the Respondent no option but to separate with her, a decision reached together with the Claimant's top officials.

117 The Respondent further submitted that the grievant testified herself that she did not clear with it, or collect her certificate of service and dues, because she had been advised not to. Therefore, cannot be heard to say that its member was unfairly terminated.

118 On general, exemplary, punitive and aggravated damages, the Respondent submitted that the suit belongs to the Claimant, which was itself never discriminated against or traumatized. In the alternative, it submitted that discrimination was not proved, as the grievant testified to mistreatment by some of her instructors in class, in the simulator and during flights, she made no written complaint, yet its witness, Captain Paul Njoroge, testified that every trainee kept and signed a training file which had provision for noting matters of concern.

119 On the burden of proof, the Respondent relied on Sections 108 and 109 of the Evidence Act and on the Supreme Court decision in Samson Gwer & 5 others v Kenya Medical Research Institute & 3 others [2020] eKLR, where it was held:"…the petitioners, in the instant case, bore the overriding obligation to lay substantial material before the Court, in discharge of the evidential burden establishing their treatment at the hands of the 1st Respondent as unconstitutional. Only with this threshold transcended, would the burden fall to the 1st Respondent to prove the contrary."

120 The Respondent further submitted that FO Samira produced no evidence of breach of her terms of employment over her ten years of service. It maintained that the TRB's unanimous recommendation was explained by the fact that her difficulties were personal to her and not remediable, that the aircraft she could fly at her level was no longer in service, and that confining her to one side of an aircraft would have imposed a mandatory limit on her development.

121 On general damages, it submitted that no breach of contract was demonstrated and cited Consolata Anyango Ouma v South Nyanza Sugar Co. Ltd (HCCA No. 53 of 2015) on the principle that damages for breach of contract are intended to place a claimant, as far as possible, in the position he would have been in had the breach not occurred.

122 On exemplary and punitive damages, it relied on Godfrey Julius Ndumba Mbogori & another v Nairobi City County [2018] eKLR, which applied Rookes v Barnard [1964] AC 1129, limiting such damages to oppressive, arbitrary or unconstitutional action by servants of the government, conduct calculated to make a profit exceeding the compensation payable, and cases where statute expressly authorizes them. It submitted that none of these ingredients was demonstrated and that the prayer should be dismissed.

123 On special damages, the Respondent submitted that the expenses pleaded at paragraphs 24 and 25 of the Amended Memorandum of Claim, being USD 18,328 and Kshs. 377,240 for flying school, examinations and licence renewal in 2017 and 2018, were incurred in FO Samira's own personal interest, she having testified that she needed further tuition to pass her tests.

124 It is the Respondent’s submission that no receipt, payment voucher or transcript was produced to show that the training was attended or paid for. Reliance was placed on Francis v Mash East Africa Ltd), where the Court restated:"…the immutable principle that special damages must be specifically pleaded and strictly proved with particularity and certainty as they represent actual, quantifiable, out of pocket expenses…"

125 The Respondent also cited John Njenga Vs Bata Shoe Company Limited [2001] eKLR, which adopted the dictum in Bonham-Carter v Hyde Park Hotel [1948] TLR 177 that it is not enough for a plaintiff to write down particulars of loss and throw them at the head of the court; the loss must be proved.

126 On costs and interest, the Respondent submitted that the suit is defective and none of the reliefs has been proved, so that no compensation is payable and no interest accrues. It prayed that the claim be dismissed with costs.

127 I have examined all the evidence and submissions of the parties herein. The issues for this courts’ determination are:

(1) Whether the claimant’s termination was fair and lawful.

(2) Whether the claimant is entitled to the prayers sought.

Issue No 1

128 From the claimant’s evidence she was terminated vide a letter of termination dated 8/6/2015 which states as follows:

Kenya Airways

The Pride of Africa

DM/7800/PF

5 June 2015

Samira Khan

S/N 7800

Thru' Director Flight Operations

Dear Samira,

Re: Termination

We refer to your B737 Command training report.

We regret to inform you that due to unsatisfactory performance while in B737 training, the Company has decided to terminate you from employment with effect from 5 June 2015.

Accordingly, upon clearing from the Company and returning all Kenya Airways property that may be in your possession, going through exit medical check-up with KQ Clinic and signing all the necessary discharges, you will be paid the following final dues less any amount owed to the Company-:

a) Salary and fixed allowances up to and including 5th June 2015.

b) Three (3) months' salary and fixed allowances in lieu of notice.

c) Your own and Company's contribution to the Provident Fund in accordance with the Staff Provident Fund Rules.

We take this opportunity to thank you for the service you have rendered to the Company and wish you all the best in your future undertakings.

Yours faithfully..

Elseba Onyango

HR Relationship Manager

CC. General Secretary KALPA

Signed………………………….. Date………………………

129 From this letter, the claimant was terminated due to unsatisfactory performance while in B737 training. The termination was with effect from 5/6/2015. Prior to this termination, the claimant had been employed as a 1st officer on respondent’s B767 fleet. In February 2007 the claimant came up for promotion to the B777 fleet in the rank of First Officer subject to her undergoing training and demonstrating proficiency in the aircraft.

130 The claimant avers that during the training, the grievant was subjected to harassment, humiliation, intimidation and bullying and was sent on forced leave for 3 months until 25th January 2010 when a decision to terminate her training and return her to her previous fleet was made. She appealed this decision but the appeal was declined on 8th February 2010. She remained on the B767 fleet where she was restricted up to July 2012.

131 In September 2012 the grievant was again up for promotion and was sent to South Africa for the course meant to prepare her for upgrade from 1st officer to captain.

132 The grievant avers that she was informed after her training that she had failed the test which came as a surprise as she had never failed any checks or training.

133 In 2014 December, the grievant was again up for promotion to the B737 fleet but the training was terminated prematurely on the ground that supervisor was not confident she would pass the final check with only 3 sessions remaining.

134 She appealed to her instructor fleet manager and Director of Flight operation and Head of training and she was informed that her case would be referred to the Training Review Board (TRB).

135 The greviant has contended that the termination was contrary to clause 4 of the Seniority and Promotions policy of the IBA which provides that failing in transitional training or in the necessary exams would result to an employees’ previous fleet on position and despite its recommendation at the RB meeting that she be given a chance to train on the B787 or be considered for training on the right seat of the B737. The greviant averred that she lodged various appeals on the termination and was finally reinstated on 2/8/2017 but the decision was nullified by the respondent’s MD on 9th February 2018 on the ground that he had found no sufficient ground to review the termination.

136 From the evidence of the greviant in court, the greviant indicated that in the TRB her union proposed that she be retrained on the B787 and be restricted to the First Officer’s position for some years with other fleets such as B737 also available.

137 The grievant further indicated that her superior’s judgment of her was wrong since she has for three years flown for Etihad a major airline. The grievant also averred that in 2010 her training was stopped at 220 hours whereas the CBA allows a maximum of 250 hours.

138 From the evidence of the respondent, the RW1 indicated that the grievant was never invited to be heard before the decision of 10/2/2015 to discontinue her training was done and there was also no invite sent to her before the hearing.

139 The RW1 also indicated that he had not tendered any evidence of the alleged inconsistency in decision making or poor judgment on performance appraisal and no trainer’s report showing her scores was also placed before the court. The report of the TRB is also not before court.

140 RW1 further admitted that the respondent’s policy provides for remedial lessons where a pilot has not passed training and CBA allows 250 hours or conversion to the B777. All these were not accorded to the grievant.

141 RW1 admitted that there were other pilots considered at the same TRB sitting who were retained. John Koiti’s case had similar concerns as for the grievant and he was given a warning. Milton Muturi’s issues also included failed examination, non attendance and flying with an expired licence and was given a final performance warning and offered counselling. This in itself is proof of differential treatment between the grievant and others.

142 The RW1 confirmed that a letter of 2/8/2017 reinstated the grievant on behalf of management under the head of the group HR director Sammy Chepkwony and was revoked by the respondent’s MD vide a letter of 9/2/2018. The revocation of the reinstatement done by the respondents CEO was also an act done illegally and unilaterally given that the reinstatement had been done by the HRD for respondent and the CEO had no power to revoke the same.

143 Given the analysis of the evidence above, it is apparent that the termination of the grievant was procedurally flawed and the existence of valid reason to warrant termination fell below the standard of proof coupled with different treatment of 2 pilots faced with similar flaws.

144 Section 41 of the Employment Act 2007 envisages that a termination could not progress without due process. As admitted by RW1 the decisions were made against the grievant without due process stated therein.

145 Section 45(2) of the Employment Act 2007 states as follows:

(2) A termination of employment by an

employer is unfair if the employer fails to prove―

(a) that the reason for the termination

is valid;

(b) that the reason for the termination is a fair reason―

(i) related to the employees conduct, capacity or compatibility; or

(ii) based on the operational requirements of the employer; and

(c) that the employment was terminated in accordance with fair procedure

146 In the circumstances of the grievant case, there was both lack of proper procedure and establishment of valid reasons for termination and I therefore return the verdict that the grievant’s termination was both unfair and unjustified.

Issue No 2

147 On issue of remedies, having found for the grievant and given the discriminatory manner she was treated and her career progress delayed leading her to incur expense for retraining, it is my finding that maximum compensation is payable to her. I therefore award her:

(1) 12 months’ salary as compensation for the unlawful termination = 12x119,350= kshs 1,432,200/-.

(2) I also award her 3 months’ salary in lieu of notice = kshs 3x119,350/-=358,050/-.

(3) I also award the grievant kshs 1million as damages for discrimination as seen from the unequal treatment of 2 other pilots who were facing similar complaints.

TOTAL AWARDED – 2,790,250/- less statutory deductions.

(4) The respondent be issued with a certificate of service.

(5) The respondent will pay costs of this suit plus interest at court rates with effect from the date of this judgment.

Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nairobi this 27th Day of October 2026.

HELLEN WASILWA

JUDGE

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder