Meet Sheriaplex AI. Research, draft and review with tools for Kenyan legal work.

Try AI chat ↗Explore AI Tools →
Employment law

Mbugua & 20 others v Kenyatta University [2026] KEELRC 14670 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Cause 12 of 2020
Judgment date
16 October 2026
Judge(s)
Abuodha Nelson Jorum
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

By a Memorandum of Claim dated 10th January, 2020, the claimant pleaded inter alia: -

Paragraph 1 →

Decision / orders

In conclusion the Court finds and holds that the claim herein is unmerited and dismisses the same without costs since the claimant may have genuinely, albeit wrongly, believed that they were entitled to the benefits contained in the circular dated 12th January 2012 from the Office of the then Prime Minister, which was a genuine but honestly mistaken agitation for better terms and conditions of work and therefore ought not to be…

Paragraph 57 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Office of the Prime Minister circular dated 12 January 2012 applied to the claimants, who worked in Kenyatta University laboratories; whether non-payment of health-risk and extraneous allowances constituted unlawful discrimination; and whether the…

Material facts

The 21 claimants were employees of Kenyatta University who stated that they served as medical technologists in its Schools of Medicine, Pharmacy and Nursing. They prepared practicals, handled and sourced specimens, and alleged exposure to pathogens. They…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT

AT NAIROBI

CAUSE NO. 12 OF 2020

JOSEPHINE MBUGUA & 20 OTHERS……..…….................. CLAIMANTS

-VERSUS-

KENYATTA UNIVERSITY………............. ………………… RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

1. By a Memorandum of Claim dated 10th January, 2020, the claimant pleaded inter alia: -

a. The Claimants are employees of the Respondent who serve in the schools of Medicine, Pharmacy and Nursing as Medical Technologists.

b. The Claimants handle the practical aspects of medicine as offered in the three respective schools and therefore their domain mainly resides in the laboratory. As such, the nature of their work compels them to go beyond their assigned duties, for instance, they source for the specimen to be used in the laboratory for practical aspects of studies.

c. The Claimants' periods of service with the Respondent have exhibited outstanding professional performance, which have earned some of them steady promotions over the years of their respective services.

d. On 11th June 2010, a task force was constituted by the office of the Prime Minister via office circular letter reference no. MSPS/2/1/3A Vol. III/(77) to look into the allowances of medical staff in the public medical based institutions (Public Hospitals and Universities offering Medical Courses). The task force came up with recommendations of payment of inter alia, Health Risk and Extraneous allowances to the Health Workers. Accordingly, this was approved and the universities were requested to submit their budgets to facilitate the said payments to their staff.

e. The recommendations were subsequently adopted by the Salaries and Remuneration Commission and the said allowances were released through the Ministry of Higher Education, Science and Technology to the institutions including the respondent that received, in addition to the normal capitation, a total of Kshs. 40.9 Million for medical allowances for its staff, in accordance with its financial request. The universities obtained the funds to cater for payments of these allowances but payments have not been remitted to some of the Claimants which their counterparts in other universities have been receiving.

f. On 24th November 2016, The Kenya Universities' Staff Union (KUSU) to which the Claimants are members signed a Collective Bargaining Agreement together with the Respondent's Council which Agreement in paragraph 24 provides for the payment of the said allowances to health workers in compliance with the rates adopted by the Salaries and Remuneration Commission which are:

i) Payment of extraneous allowance at Twenty-Five Thousand Shillings (Kshs 25,000/=) monthly; and

ii) Payment of risk allowance at Twenty Thousand Shillings (Kshs. 20,000/=) monthly

iii) The Claimants have made and/or submitted numerous and constant reminders to the Respondent to this effect, imploring the Respondent to facilitate the payment of these allowances by issuance of a variety of letters and memos

g. However, despite the constant reminders as, the Respondent has absconded, abandoned, refused and/or wilfully neglected its legitimate and lawful payment obligations. As a result of the abandonment, refusal and/or wilful neglect, the Respondent has strained and continues to strain the Claimants plugging them to grave difficulties in their operations. Further, the said inaction and/or failures pose and continue to pose serious threats on the Claimants' livelihoods since they greatly rely on the payments by the Respondent to meet their basic necessities and almost entirely the rest of their necessities in life The remittances from the Respondent are their only source of income. As these circumstances deteriorate, they aggravate further as the Claimants' said risks intensify with their continued exposure occasioned by their responsibilities.

h. The Claimants have reasons to believe that their claim is within their right, legally sanctioned and that the pursuit thereof does not constitute an abuse of court process.

i. Further, the Claimants go beyond the nature of their usual duties to source for specimen used for practical lessons in the medical schools at their own expense.

j. No provision regarding the laboratory specimen is made by the Respondent hence the need for extraneous allowances. Further, the Claimants while in their ordinary course of duty are exposed to numerous pathogens occasioned by the nature of the specimen they handle. This continued exposure is dangerous and poses great risks to the Claimants' health status as they may contact harmful bacteria. This justifies the basis for health risk allowances.

PARTICULARS OF ALLOWANCES CLAIMED

i. Extraneous allowances for the Claimants unpaid

ii. from 1st July 2013 Kshs 32,525,000.00

iii. Risk allowances for the Claimants unpaid from

iv. 1st July 2013 at Kshs 22,346,000.00

v. TOTAL Kshs 54,871,000.00

2. REASONS WHEREOF the Claimants prays for:-

a) A declaration that the Respondent in withholding the payments of health risk and extraneous allowances to the Claimants is unfair and unlawful.

b) A declaration that the act of discrimination exhibited in the selective and/or disparity in remittance of the health risk and extraneous allowances to other health workers excluding the Claimants is unconstitutional, unlawful and illegal and amounts violation of the Claimants' rights and fundamental freedoms.

c) Payment of the sum of Kshs. 54,871,000.00 being the amount for which the Respondent has not paid since 1st July 2013, the effective date of implementation of the 2013/2017 Collective Bargaining Agreement and Medical Allowances for University Staff working in Public Hospitals.

d) A declaration that the Respondent implement with due immediacy the inclusion of the said allowances (health risk and extraneous) at the said approved rates in the Claimants' payrolls from October 2019 henceforth during the subsistence of their work life as the Respondent's employees.

e) A declaration that the Claimants reserve the right to claim interest at 12% per annum since due date for late payments plus legal costs for recovery.

f) Cost of the suit and interest thereon at court rates.

3. The Respondent filed a statement of response dated 4th April, 2018 and averred among others that: -

a) In response to paragraph 3 of the Memorandum of Claim, the Respondent admits that the Claimants are its employees. However, the Respondent does not make any admission as to the Claimants’ qualifications, their nature of employment or their respective work stations. The Claimants are put to strict proof of their allegations in that regard.

b) In further response to paragraph 3 of the Memorandum of Claim, the Respondent avers that the Claimants have not demonstrated that they are Medical Technologists as defined in law and as alleged in the said paragraph,

c) The Respondent denies the contents of paragraph 4 of the Memorandum of Claim and puts the Claimants to strict proof thereof. In further response to the said paragraph 4 of the Memorandum of Claim, the Respondent avers as follows: -

i. It is specifically denied that the nature of the Claimants’ work compels them to go beyond their assigned duties

ii. It is specifically denied that sourcing of specimens for use in the Respondent’s laboratories is a task outside the Claimants’ respective duties

iii. Without prejudice to paragraph 6 (a) and (b) above, the Respondent contends that if any Claimant docs any work outside his duties, he is usually compensated as per the Respondent’s Policy.

iv. The Claimants are engaged in different departmental laboratories of the Respondent where they work under instructions of the relevant unit lecturer. The Claimants do not work in a hospital setting

v. The Claimants’ work is to assist a lecturer to set up a laboratory for practical aspects of the unit, at no time do the Claimants deal with medical aspects of medicine as alleged or at all. The Claimants arc put to strict proof of the allegations.

vi. The Respondent denies the contents of paragraph 6 of the Memorandum of Claim and puts the Claimants to strict proof thereof. The Respondent further avers as follows: -

vii. The insinuation that the alleged Prime Minister’s Circular applied to tire Claimants or to members of staff in universities offering medical courses is specifically denied and the Claimants put to strict proof thereof.

viii. The Prime Minister’s Circular was triggered by negotiations after a strike by health workers in public hospitals. It has not been demonstrated that the Claimants or their Union participated in the strike or in the negotiations which led to the circular.

d. The alleged recommendations of the Task Force allegedly appointed by the Prime Minister are specifically denied and the Claimants put to strict proof thereof

e. It is further denied that the recommendations, which are themselves denied, were approved and that Universities were asked to submit budgets. The Claimants are put to strict proof of the allegation.

f. The Respondent avers that whatever recommendations were made vide the Prime Minister’s circular were meant to apply to health workers in public hospitals and were never meant to apply to persons who do not work in hospitals.

g. The Respondent avers that there is a huge difference between medical technicians and technologists working in hospitals and other medical technicians and technologists. The health workers who work in hospitals are exposed to a far great risk compared to those who work outside hospitals.

h. The Respondent denies the contents of paragraph 7 of the Memorandum of Claim and puts the Claimants to strict proof thereof. The Respondent further avers as follows: -

i. It is denied that Salaries and Remuneration Commission, approved the alleged recommendations

ii. The Respondent has not received any monies from the government which were meant to be paid to the Claimants in form of allowances as alleged or at all

iii. It is denied that persons who work in other Universities in similar capacity as the Claimants herein do receive the claimed allowances. The Claimants are put to strict proof of entire allegations,

iv. It is reiterated that the Claimants do not work in hospitals

v. The Respondent denies the contents of paragraph 8 of the Memorandum of Claim and puts the Claimants to strict proof thereof. The Respondent further avers as follows: -

vi. It is not admitted that the Claimants, and each of them, are members of The Kenya Universities’ Staff Union (KUSU). The Claimants, and each of them, are put to strict proof of the allegation.

vii. It is not true that clause 24 of the Collective Bargaining Agreement dated 24th November, 2016 provides for payment of allowances as alleged at paragraph 8 of the Memorandum of Claim or at all,

viii. Indeed, the Collective Bargaining Agreement documents do not provide for the claimed allowances

ix. In further response to paragraph 10 of the Memorandum of Claim, the Respondent avers that risk allowance is supposed to apply to medical personnel who routinely come into contact with patients suffering from highly infectious diseases. The Claimants do not meet that criteria as they operate in University Laboratories which are controlled environment.

i. The Respondent denies the contents of paragraph 12 of the Memorandum of Claim and puts the Claimants to strict proof thereof. It is not true that the Claimants’ source for specimen to be used in the Respondent’s laboratories at their own expense

j. The Respondent denies that the Claimant’s jobs expose them to health risk as alleged or at all

k. It is denied that the Claimants are entitled to the Claim itemized as paragraphs 2 (a) and (b). In any event, the particulars of the said Claim have not been given. The Respondent reserves its right to respond further in the event such particulars are provided.

l. REASONS WHEREFORE the Respondent prays that the Claimants’ Cause be dismissed with costs to the Respondent.

EVIDENCE

4. The Claimants was heard on 12th March, 2025. The claimant’s witness Khamisi Mwaleso who stated he was giving evidence on behalf the rest stated that he wrote a witness statement on 20th November, 2019 which he relied on as his evidence in chief. He also relied on the list of documents filed in support of the claim. The claimant’s filed supplementary bundle of documents dated 7th February, 2025 which he also relied on as his evidence in chief. It contained witness affidavits. The claimant further testified that he was the chief Lab technologist and that he conducted practicals for students. He stated that he collected specimens for the practicals he also participated in hospital set up. He further stated that he and his colleagues were registered registered by Kenya Medical Laboratrologist Board and that they claimed risk and extra work allowance. The same was paid to their colleagues in other public universities yet they were not paid. He further stated that extra allowances were paid to lecturers who teach medical students, but they were not paid yet they participated during practicals.

5. In cross-examination he stated that he did not file his certificate of registration with KMLTTB and that other claimants too hold similar qualifications, but none had filed evidence of qualifications in court. He further stated that they worked in the University laboratory and sometimes work in hospital situations during internships. He however stated that they reported to the University Laboratory and that he believed Kenyatta University Lab was registered with KMLTTB but had never seen any certificate of registration. Concerning the circular from the then Prime Minister’s office at page 58 CBD, he confirmed that it was addressed to Permanent Secretary – Ministry of Health and Permanent Secretary Ministry – Medical Services and that it mentioned lab technicians. He confirmed that they fell under paramedics. He further stated that the memo referred to allowances but did not mention directly risk allowances and that the memo was triggered by strike by KMPDU and that he not a member and further that none of the claimants were members. Their union was KUSU (Kenya University Staff Union). KUSU did not participate in negotiations that led to the circular.

6. The claimant further stated that he did not work for the county government and that the circular did not refer to workers in public universities. He acknowledged that at page 62 of CBD, Lab technologist risk allowance was Kshs.3,000 and that they were claiming Kshs.20,000 as risk allowance and that the claim was based on risk allowance paid to lecturers who they work with, he however admitted that he had not brought evidence of risk allowance paid to lecturers but insisted Universities pays risk allowance. He stated that he understood that extra allowance was meant for those who worked outside their jurisdiction. He admitted that at page of 78 RBD their job description at age 79, paragraph 7 included collecting samples and that it was not an extra duty to collect samples. He stated that Kenyatta University has a hospital and that they worked at the university.

7. In re-examination Mr. Khamisi Mwaleso stated that they did not work in a hospital set up but they followed up students in hospital set up and that their work included work in hospital laboratories. He clarified that the Job description found at page 58 of the RBD touched on health care workers applied to county health workers but confirmed that those in their category were also paid. He further clarified that sourcing of samples and specimens was for the purpose of teaching students and that the specimens had pathogens that were infectious and hazardous and that Kshs.20,000 was based on what was paid to lecturers. It ought therefore to cut across to everyone.

8. The claimant’s second witness (CW2) after duly sworn stated that his name was Gideon Omondi and that he wrote a witness statement on 20th November 2019 which he relied on as his evidence in chief. He also relied on the documents in support of the claim. At Page 99-124 CBD was the Collective Bargaining Agreement between Kenya University and KUSU. At page 124 of the same, he stated he was one of the persons who signed the Collective Bargaining Agreement and that at page 119 of CBD paragraph 24 of the same, health workers allowances were payable at a rate payable to workers in public service. He further stated that at page 213 – 214 SCBD was a letter from KUSU which confirmed membership to KUSU. Page 81 – CBD was a memo from Ag. Chair medical, surgical, nursing and pre-clinical sciences addressed to DVC requesting for payment of clinical allowances.

9. In cross-examination he stated that he was a pharmaceutical technologist and had a diploma in Analytical Chemistry and a degree in Industrial Chemistry and that he did not have diploma, certificate or degree in medical lab technology and that KMTTB cannot register one if they do not have the required qualifications, he further stated that some claimants were registered and some were not.

10. He clarified that page 99 – 124 of the CBA it referred to medical health workers and did not specifically refer to medical lab workers and further that “medical health workers” was not defined in the Collective Bargaining Agreement.

11. In re-examination he stated that he was registered under Chemical Society of Kenya and that other claimants are registered by other bodies. The Collective Bargaining Agreement applies to claimants because they are health workers.

12. The Respondent’s case on the other hand was heard on 13th May, 2025 where the Respondent’s witnesses (RW1) testified that his name was John Kamuiru and that he recorded a witness statement on 28th July, 2025 which he relied on as his evidence in chief he also relied on the bundle of documents filed with the response. He further stated that he was the Human Resource Manager at Kenyatta University. He also relied on SRBD dated 12th May 2025 as his exhibits.

13. In cross-examination he stated that he was employed on 9th June 2025 and that he was seconded from public services. He took over from the previous Human Resource Manager at the respondent. He further stated that he has never worked for Salaries Remuneration Commission. It was Mr. Kamuiru’s evidence that he knew about the claim based on the documents available from the respondent and filed in court. He admitted that he did not know if the claimants held the position they claim they held but stated that the respondent could not employ unqualified persons. I have not interacted fully with the claimants’ contacts. Page 34 CBD – appointment and promotion for Gideon Omondi.

14. It was his evidence that the claimants set the instruments and conducted practicals for the students. He also admitted that some of the claimant’s sourced for pathological specimens from various hospitals used in teaching and assisting students in practicals. He further stated that the claimants used to take imprest to source cadavers and that they worked in Kenyatta University labs.

15. He clarified that those working in hospitals were exposed to more risk than those working in university labs and that he could not confirm if the samples used in the university labs were obtained from hospitals, but some specimens were collected from hospitals. He however admitted that in the collection of samples, claimants were exposed to risk from pathogens.

16. Concerning the circular from the Prime Minister’s Office, he stated that the same was released when KPMDU called a strike and according to him, the claimants were paid Kshs. 3,000/= for risk allowance and that they were exposed to minimal risk. He further stated that the respondent pays teaching allowances based on the circular from PM’s office and further that Lab technicians do not qualify as doctors. The circular from PM’s office therefore did not apply to the claimants and that teaching staff allowances were paid based on SRC recommendations. According to him, teaching staff were paid 40,000/= as extraneous allowance and risk allowance was paid in accordance with job grade. As shown at page 53 of CBD, risk allowance was stated as Kshs.2,000/= and at page 83 risk allowance was stated as Kshs. 3,000.

17. He reiterated that the circular was meant for health technicians working in hospitals not in universities and that it was an initiative of health workers and not university workers. He concluded his cross-examination by stating that the university paid the allowances based on the nature of the work, the claimants were doing and that there was a CBA before the court between the Respondent and KUSU.

18. In re-examination he stated that at page 34 of CBD, Omondi was appointed as technician and that there were no document showing the claimants were registered as lab technicians. Health workers were different from lab technicians. He clarified that health workers dealt with sick people but university lab technicians do not and that the circular on concerned health workers in hospitals.

CLAIMANTS’ SUBMISSIONS

19. Counsel for the claimant Mr. Kanjama (SC) submitted among others that the Claimants were covered under the Circular dated 12th January 2012 and quoted Section 2 of the Medical Laboratory Technicians and Technologists Act, Cap 253A Laws of Kenya which defined medical laboratory technologists and technicians as follows:

"Medical laboratory technician" means a person holding a certificate in medical laboratory technology issued by the Kenya Medical Training College or other similar institution recognised by the Board; and"Medical laboratory technologist" means a person holding a diploma, higher diploma or degree in medical laboratory technology issued by the Kenya Medical Training College or other similar institution approved by the Board."

20. According to counsel, it is undisputed that the Claimants herein were employed within the Respondent’s workforce as medical laboratory technologists and technicians It was also undisputed that the office of the Prime Minister released the circular dated 12th January 2012 wherein it outlined the various allowances payable to public health workers, including health risk and extraneous allowances. As per the Office of the Prime Minister's communication, this circular was to be read together with the circular dated 19th December 2011. Counsel further submitted that vide an article titled, "Insight into the remuneration of health workers in the public service’’ published on the SRC’s website on 25th September 2023, the Commission defined the various cadres of health workers as follows:

"The health worker cadres in Kenya include: doctors, pharmacists, dentists, nurses, clinical officers, lab technicians and other paramedics (physiotherapist, radiographers, occupational therapists, nutrition and dietetics officer, entomologists, chemist, technologists and technicians, public health officers, health record officers, medical social workers, community oral health officers, parasitologist, biochemists, anesthetists, mortuary attendants, orthopedics, radiation protection officers, and biomedical engineers)."

In Wycliffe Lisalitsa v Chief Executive Officer Kenyatta National Hospital & 5 others [2014] eKLR. the Claimants, employees of the 6th Respondent deployed in various departments such as engineering, maintenance, laundry, catering, administration and human resources sought Order compelling the Respondents to pay them extraneous allowances pursuant to the circular by the Office of the Prime Minister dated 12th January 2012. The Court (Hon M. Onyango, J) in determining whether the Claimants were covered under the said circular held as follows:

"The Claimants have submitted that all the staff of the 6th Respondent should be paid extraneous allowance as the circular dated 12th January 2012 refers to all public health workers which covers all the Claimants.

It is my opinion that the circular of 12th January 2012 must be interpreted in the light of the circular dated 19th December 2011 which was the originator of the allowance. That circular categorized employees to be paid as medical Officers (Dentists/Pharmacists’ Clinical Officers, nurses, technologists and technicians, mortuary attendants, drivers deployed in hospitals, and finally, patient attendants in hospital wards/dispensaries/health Centre’s”

The Court of Appeal (Asike-Makhandia, W. Ouko, K, M’inoti, JJA) upheld the holding of the trial court and stated as follows:

“It is common ground that the decision to pay extraneous allowance was precipitated by a strike called by the Union. The strike was only called off following negotiations between the Union, the Government through the 2nd to 5th respondents and Cotu. The negotiations resulted into a return to work formula which provided for payment of extraneous allowances ranging from Kshs.30,000/= to Kshs.40,000/= with effect from 1st December, 2011. This was followed by a circular from the office of the then Prime Minister dated 19th December, 2011 specifying the category of the employees covered in the negotiations which included: -

• Medical officers, Dentists and Pharmacists;

• Clinical officers, Nurses and Technologists;

(Hi) Mortuary attendants;

• Drivers deployed in hospitals; and

• Patient attendants (Hospital wards/Dispensaries/Health centres)."

21. In the upshot, counsel invited the Honourable Court to find that the Claimants were covered under the circular dated 12th January 2012. Concerning the issue whether the Respondent actions amounted to discrimination against the Claimants, counsel submitted that the provisions of Article 27 of the Constitution provided for equal treatment of all persons and entitled them to equal protection and benefit of the law. The Constitution further barred both public and private entities from discriminating against an individual either directly or indirectly on various grounds. On the other hand, Section 5 of the Employment Act, Cap 226 Laws of Kenya prohibits discrimination in employment. The Act mandates all employers to promote equal opportunity in employment and strive to eliminate discrimination in any employment policy or practice. The Act prohibits employers from discriminating against their employees, either directly or indirectly, on the basis of race, social origin or other reasons laid out therein.

22. Regarding judicial definition of discrimination counsel relied on the decision of Mumbi Ngugi, J (as she then was) in Rose Wangu Mambo & 2 others versus Limuru County Club & 17 others [2014] eKLR which cited with approval the definition in Peter K. Waweru versus Republic [20061 eKLR as follows:

“...Discrimination means affording different treatment to different persons attributable wholly or mainly to their descriptions by...sex whereby persons of one such description are subjected to...restrictions to which persons of another description are not made subject or are accorded privileges or advantages which _ are_ not accorded to persons of another such description...Discrimination also means unfair treatment or denial of normal privileges to persons because of their race, age, sex...a failure to treat all persons equally where no reasonable distinction can be found between those favoured and those not favoured"

23. Mr. Kanjama submitted that under the circular dated 14th September 2015, the SRC outlined the health risk and extraneous allowances payable to public health workers. Although the Respondent implemented the circular for teaching staff across its medical fraternity, it failed and/or declined to extend the same benefits to the Claimants. The Respondent offered no justification for this unequal treatment. Counsel further submitted that as evidenced under the various Claimants' job descriptions, their obligations were similar to those carried out by laboratory technologists stationed in hospitals in terms of sourcing for and handling pathological medical/ human materials including human cadavers, human body fluids of all kinds, human body parts, biopsies and autopsy samples; bacterial, fungal and viral cultures, human stool and parasites to be used for practical by the lecturers and students within the Respondent’s medical fraternity, conducting the practical sessions with the students and disposing off the specimen after the experiments.

24. Counsel further submitted that as demonstrated by the Claimants during the hearing, the role of collection and disposal of specimen exposed them to a myriad of bacterial, fungal, viral and parasitic infections including tuberculosis, AIDS, Hepatitis, Typhoid, Cholera and Covid-19 which had continuous deleterious effect on their health and therefore they ought to be compensated subject to the terms of the SRC’s circular. Counsel further submitted that vide the SRC’s article outlined under paragraph 26 of these submissions, the Commission explained the basis of the allowances to be as follows:

(i) "Extraneous Allowance: For staff who work long hours on a continuous basis and may include extra responsibilities. It is payable to officers whose duties expose them to excess physical and mental stress and extended undefined long working hours.

(ii) Health Risk Allowance: For employees engaged in hazardous duties or whose work will have a deleterious effect on health over a period of time. It is paid to health workers whose salaries have not been consolidated to include the risk factor."

25. The Respondent had been paying, and continued to pay, health risk and extraneous allowances to the teaching staff within its medical fraternity in accordance with the SRC circular. However, it denied, failed, and/or neglected to pay the same allowances to the Claimants, despite their clear entitlement under both the Office of the Prime Minister and SRC circulars. The Claimants performed the same responsibilities as the teaching staff as they conducted practical, thereby warranting equal entitlement to the health risk and extraneous allowances.

26. The Respondent alleges that risk allowance was only payable to medical personnel who routinely come into contact with patients suffering from highly infectious diseases. Additionally, the Respondent alleges that the health risk and extraneous allowances recommended by the SRC are only applicable to health workers in public hospitals and not in laboratories. To the contrary, it was submitted that this stance was misleading and a misrepresentation of the correct position. In fact, vide an Internal Memo dated 5th September 2019, the Chairperson of the Department of Medical Surgical Nursing and Preclinical Sciences within the Respondent’s School of Nursing Sciences informed the Deputy Vice Chancellor (Administration) that the Claimants were entitled to health risk and extraneous allowances by virtue of their involvement in conducting laboratory practicals and teaching students.

27. According counsel, the SRC circular dated 14th September 2015 applied to all health workers. Specifically, Part B outlined the extraneous allowance and identified the amounts payable to Technologists and Technicians. It also set out the health risk allowance and expressly included laboratory technologists. Notably, the circular did not limit entitlement to these allowances to health workers in public hospitals, nor does it confine the health risk allowance to those who routinely interact with patients suffering from highly infectious diseases, as the Respondent claimed. Mr. Kanjama submitted that the Respondent herein who had given a preferential treatment to the teaching staff, the other public institutions that offer similar medical courses pay the health risk and extraneous allowances to all their health workers in line with the SRC’s circular. In this regard counsel relied on the case of East Africa Portland Cement Co. Ltd v Kenya Chemical & Allied Workers Union T20171KECA 215 (KLR), where the Appellants appealed against the trial court's finding to the effect that its decision to apply preferential remuneration terms to contractual employees while excluding casual staff, despite a CBA covering all cadres of employees, was discriminatory. The Court of Appeal upheld the trial court’s decision, holding that the Appellants' conduct violated the equality provisions under Article 27 of the Constitution. The Court of Appeal (G.B.M. Kariuki, F. Sichale, S. ole Kantai, JJA) held as follows:

“It is clear to us that upon the contract staff who were not part of management becoming members of the respondent Union on payment of union dues, the negotiations by the parties on wages and terms of employment relating to 2013 to 2015 CBA were in relation to the cadre of staff doing the work done by the casuals which included the work done by the contract staff and it did not therefore matter whether the respondent explicitly stated the full category of workers covered by the negotiations so long as it was understood that the negotiations covered Union members of that particular cadre unless the contract staff were expressly excluded in the CBA. It was understood that the negotiations related to members of the respondent (Union) and that they all performed the same task save that some were continually on renewable two year contracts while the others (casuals) were not. In our view, the practice of paying the casuals wages different from those for contract staff who were not in management when both were Union members and performed the same task and when negotiations under the CBA related to the members of the Union would be frowned at as being contrary to section 5 of the Employment Act which upholds equality of opportunity in employment in order to eliminate discrimination,”

28. In the upshot, counsel invited the Court to find that the Respondent’s decision to accord preferential treatment to its teaching staff by paying them health risk and extraneous allowances of KShs. 20,000/- and KShs. 25,000/- respectively in line with the SRC circular, while paying the Claimants only a health risk allowance of ranging between KShs.2,000/- and KShs.3,000/- and denying them extraneous allowances despite the nature of their work and their clear entitlement to the said allowances, is discriminatory and a violation of the provisions of article 27 of the Constitution and section 5 of the Employment Act.

29. Regarding the issue of breach of the Collective Bargaining Agreement dated 24th November 2016 by declining to pay the Claimants health risk and extraneous allowances, counsel argued that it was undisputed that the Claimants were bona fide members of KUSU and had been making their monthly contribution to the said Union at all relevant times leading to the institution of this suit. According to counsel, on 24th November 2016, the representatives of the Claimants’ Union, KUSU, and the Respondent signed a CBA operational for the period of 1st July 2013 to 30th June 2017. Paragraph 24 of the said CBA provided for payment of allowances in accordance with the rates adopted by the SRC as follows:

“24. _Health Workers Allowances

Health workers allowances shall be payable to the relevant categories of staff at the current rates applicable in the Public Service.”

However, the Respondent had failed, ignored and/or refused to implement and honour the terms of the CBA to the extent that it entitled the Claimants to health risk and extraneous allowances despite having been issued with numerous requests, notifications, reminders and demands to implement the same. Counsel therefore concluded by submitting that the claimants were entitled to the reliefs sought in the Memorandum of Claim dated 10th January 2020.

RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS

30. Counsel for the respondent Ms. Mutinda submitted among others that: First concerning objection to the admission of Exhibits 18 to 22 on page 84 to 98 of the Claimant’s Bundle of Documents dated 18th October 2025, it was submitted that that the said exhibits which were purported circulars issued by public bodies were not certified as mandatorily required under section 68 of the Evidence Act, and are as a matter of law, inadmissible. According to Counsel, the provisions of section 64 of the Evidence Act, Cap 80 Laws of Kenya, the contents of documents may be proved either by primary or by secondary evidence and under section 66, secondary evidence included certified copies given under the provisions of the Act. Section 67 required that documents must be proved by primary evidence, except in cases mentioned in section 68(1) when secondary evidence may be given of the existence, condition or contents of a document in the following cases, the relevant ones for our purposes being paragraphs (e) and (f). Counsel further submitted that section 80 of the Evidence Act provided for the manner in which public documents are to be certified. It states: -

“Certified copies of public documents (l)Every public officer having the custody of a public document which any person has a right to inspect shall give that person on demand a copy of it on payment of the legal fees therefor, together with a certificate written at the foot of such copy that it is a true copy of such document or part thereof, as the case may be, and such certificate shall be dated and subscribed by such officer with his name and his official title, and shall be sealed whenever such officer is authorized by law to make use of a seal, and such copies so certified shall be called certified copies. (2) Any officer who by the ordinary course of official duty is authorized to deliver copies of public documents shall be deemed to have the custody of such documents within the meaning of this section.”

31. In light of the foregoing provisions of the Evidence Act, Cap 80 Laws of Kenya, it is evident that documents which constitute public documents could only be admitted in evidence through certified copies, as expressly required under sections 68, 79 and 80 of the Act. In this regard, counsel submitted that The Claimant’s Exhibits 18—22, which were purported circulars issued by public bodies, had not been produced in the form of certified copies as mandated by law. Consequently, the said documents did not meet the statutory threshold for admissibility and therefore could not properly be received as evidence before this Honourable Court. To admit such documents in their present form would be contrary to the clear provisions of the Evidence Act governing the proof of public documents.

32. Further, and without prejudice to the foregoing, the said documents carry no evidentiary value, as their authenticity and source cannot be verified in the absence of certification by the relevant public officers having custody of the original records. As such, they cannot be relied upon to establish the facts alleged by the Claimants.

33. The Respondent therefore respectfully urges this Honourable Court to uphold the objection raised during the hearing and to decline the admission of Exhibits 18—22 appearing on pages 84—98 of the Claimant’s Bundle of Documents dated 18th October 2025. In Attorney General v Torino Enterprises Limited [2022] KECA 78 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held as follows: -

“We have examined the documents appearing at pages 32 and 52 of the record of appeal and at pages 21, 22, 23-27, 28-29,30, 32 and 33 of the respondent’s supplementary record of appeal and have no doubt that they fall under the category of public documents specified in section 79. These documents have no certification stamp or seal at all. The respondent did not disclose how it acquired any of these documents which do not appear to be addressed to it by the makers thereof, or how they came to be in its possession. Some of them include confidential cabinet documents and correspondence between top DoD officers and the head of Public service. This Court in the case of Dickson Ngigi Ngugi v Morrison Njenga Waweru [1979] eKLR stated thus:“...We are of the opinion that copies of documents which are filed in Court being secondary evidence and which could be certified should be certified as required in the Evidence Act...The Court must be satisfied of the authenticity of the copies filed...”

34. The aforesaid holding of the Court of Appeal was upheld by the Supreme Court in Torino Enterprises Limited v Attorney General [20231 KESC 79 (KLR) where the Supreme Court stated as follows: -

“The appellant faults the Court of Appeal for expunging documents on pages 32, 52 and 21, 22 23-27, 28-29, 30, and 33 of its record and supplementary record respectively. It urged that the appellate court crafted and imposed an asymmetrical application of section 80 of the Evidence Act. It also contended that once the Attorney General had been granted leave to introduce confidential documents, it too had an automatic corresponding right to adduce similar evidence obtained from the same chains of communication. The appellant urged that the asymmetrical application contravened article 50(1) of the Constitution and amounted to suppression of evidence. In response, the Attorney General submitted that public documents within the meaning of section 79 of the Evidence Act must be produced in accordance with sections 68(l)(e)(f), (2)(c) and 80 of the Evidence Act, and the non-compliance rendered the evidence inadmissible.

“We agree with the Court of Appeal’s reasoning that the impugned documents were public documents within the meaning of section 79 of the Evidence Act requiring certification in accordance with sections 68(l)(e)(f), (2)(c) and 80 of the Evidence Act.”

35. Concerning whether the claimants were covered under the circular dated 12th January 2012, Counsel submitted that the purported circular was not certified as mandatorily required under section 68 of the Evidence Act but without Prejudice to the Respondent’s objection to the production of the said Circular as evidence, the Claimants’ allegation that they were covered by the said Circular were misguided. According to counsel, a closer perusal of the purported Circular revealed that the same was specifically intended to benefit health workers in public hospitals and health care facilities. Nowhere did it mention workers employed in any University and more specifically the Respondent’s University. More particularly, sub-tide (ii) of the Circular outlined the persons eligible for allowance as follows:

“This allowance should be payable to all Doctors (Medical Officers, Dentists and Pharmacists) employed in hospitals at the rate of Kshs.30,000 per month, irrespective of grade, with effect from 1st December, 2011. The allowance should in addition be paid to Provincial and District Medical Officers.

Extraneous Allowance and Emergency Call Allowance will also be applicable to Medical Officers, Dentists, Pharmacists and other relevant Health Workers in both Kenyatta National Hospital and Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital as specified. The two institutions are requested to liaise with treasury for funding”

36. The purported Circular was explicit and unambiguous in both its language and scope. A plain reading of its provisions left no room for doubt that it did not extend to, nor did it contemplate, medical laboratory technicians or medical laboratory technologists. Moreover, the Circular was equally clear regarding the institutional context within which it applied. Its provisions are directed specifically to personnel working within hospitals, which are clinical service institutions operating within the public health sector.

37. The Respondent herein is a public university, whose statutory mandate is the provision of higher education, research, and training, and not delivery of hospital-based clinical services. The distinction is neither trivial nor technical. It is central to the applicability of the Circular. Counsel further submitted that even assuming, purely for the sake of argument, that the Claimants were members of the cadres expressly contemplated in the Circular, namely Medical Officers, Dentists, or Pharmacists, they would still fall outside its scope by virtue of the simple and incontrovertible fact that they were not employed within hospital setting.

38. The Claimants are employees of a university and serve within an academic institution, not within a hospital structure contemplated by the Circular. It is undeniable that the addressee of a Circular was a critical determinant of its applicability. The purported Circular was addressed exclusively to the Ministry of Public Health and Sanitation.

39. Were it genuinely intended to govern or affect those within universities, it would have been directed to the Ministry of Higher Education, which had statutory oversight over public universities and their employees. The absence of any reference to the Ministry of Higher Education was therefore fatal to the Claimants’ argument and underscored that the Circular was never intended to apply to university employees, including the Respondent herein. This clear targeting of the Circular confirmed that its provisions could not be stretched or construed to cover personnel outside the public hospital system. Accordingly, the Claimants’ attempt to invoke the Circular in these proceedings therefore amounted to a misapplication of a policy instrument that was plainly inapplicable to them both in terms of professional cadre and institutional setting.

40. Regarding allegations of discrimination, counsel relied on the case of Nvarangi and Others V Attorney General [2008] KLR 688 where the Court stated as follows with regards to discrimination: -

“Direct discrimination involves treating someone less favorably because of their possession of an attribute such as race, sex, religion compared to someone without that attribute in the same circumstances”

Similarly, in Peter K. Waweru V Republic [2006] KLR the Court held as follows:

“...Discrimination means affording different treatment to different persons attributable wholly or mainly to their description whereby persons of one such descriptions are subjected to ...restrictions to which persons of another description are not made subject or are accorded privileges or advantages which are not accorded to persons of another such description...”

41. Notably, for an employee to succeed in asserting discrimination, he or she must demonstrate a prima facie case of discrimination, and it is only then that the burden shifts to the employer. The foregoing is fortified by the sentiments of the Court of Appeal in Boniface Momanyi Nyachae V Kenya Orient Insurance Co. Ltd [20231 KECA 136 (KLR) where the court expressed itself as follows:

“The appellant’s assertion regarding the issue of discrimination is hinged on the evidentiary burden and who bears it in the circumstance. As noted above, Section 5(7) of the Employment Act places the burden of disproving discrimination on the employer. The crux of that provision is that once an employee has made out a prima facie case of discrimination, the burden then shifts to the employer to disprove the allegation. A prima facie case is one in which a court properly directing itself would conclude on the evidence presented that there exists a right which has been infringed. Only then can the burden shift to the respondent to disprove the allegation”.

In the instant case, the Claimants have not identified particulars of discrimination or availed supportive evidence. In Boniface Momanyi Nyachae V Kenya Orient Insurance Co. Ltd the Court of Appeal laid it bare that: -

“...In essence, the claimant bears the burden to set out prima facie, the claim upon which the burden shifts to the respondent to disprove the allegation. All the appellant did was state a claim but failed to prove. It is not enough to just make a blanket claim without making a proper showing of the claim. Accordingly, therefore we find that the appellant failed to show any prima facie case of discrimination against him...”

42. The Claimants have urged the court to find that they were discriminated. They claim that the Circular had been implemented for some teaching staff in the Respondent’s Medical Fraternity. The Claimants’ allegation that they have been subjected to discrimination is untenable and legally baseless. Further, the allegation of discrimination fails the evidential test. The Claimants did not adduce any proof that they were intentionally or unfairly singled out. Mere dissatisfaction with the allocation of allowances does not, and cannot, amount to discrimination. Legal recognition of discrimination requires evidence of differential treatment arising from prohibited grounds, which is absent in this case. The distinction in treatment between hospital-based staff and university’ employees reflect legitimate policy, professional scope, and institutional mandate, and not any improper bias or unfairness. To construe this as discrimination would be to impose liability for lawful administrative distinctions, a position that has no basis in law or precedent.

43. Regarding the CBA, Counsel submitted that the Claimants alleged that the Respondent had breached the Collective Bargaining Agreement between it and KUSU by failing to pay the extraneous allowances as outlined in the Office of the Prime Minister Circular dated 12th January 2012 adopted by the Salaries and Remuneration Commission. More particularly, the Claimants alleged that the Respondent breached Section 24 of the Collective Bargaining Agreement which provided that Health Workers’ allowances “shall be payable to the relevant categories of staff at the current rates applicable in the Public Service”. This allegation according to counsel was fundamentally misconceived. According to counsel for the respondent, the word “relevant” in the above quotation was critical. In a nutshell, there were health workers of the respondent who would be deemed “relevant” and others who would not be deemed “relevant” for purposes of the allowances. Even then, the Claimants herein were not health workers leave alone relevant health workers. The onus was upon the Claimants to prove that they were covered by section 24 of the CBA. It was upon them to prove that they were in the “relevant category of staff’ that would be entitled to benchmark their allowances with those of medical staff in public hospitals.

44. The Claimants failed woefully in that regard. The Circular relied upon by the Claimants was explicitly limited in scope and did not cover university employees such as the Claimants. The Circular, by its own terms, was addressed to the Ministry of Public Health and Sanitation, and its provisions were intended exclusively for personnel engaged in hospital-based service delivery. It was neither directed to, nor applicable to, public universities or their staff. The Respondent, as a public university, does not operate hospitals, and its employees, including the Claimants, were therefore categorically outside the institutional and professional categories contemplated by the Circular. In conclusion counsel urged that the Claimants were therefore not entitled to any reliefs sought.

DETERMINATION

45. The court has extensively considered the claim herein and notes that the claimants mainly seek from the respondent, a declaration from this court that the Respondent in withholding the payments of health risk and extraneous allowances to them was acting unfairly and by so doing was discriminating against them. As a result, the claimants sought from the court an order directing the respondent to compensate them in the sum of Kshs. 54,871,000/- being the amount the Respondent had not paid since 1st July 2013, the effective date of implementation of the 2013/2017 Collective Bargaining Agreement and Medical Allowances for University Staff working in Public Hospitals. The claimants further claimed the costs of the suit.

46. The respondent on the other hand maintained that the claimants were not entitled to the reliefs sought in that they had not first of all demonstrated that they were Medical Technologists as defined in law and as alleged in the statement of claim. According to the respondent, the Claimants were engaged in different departmental laboratories of the Respondent where they worked under instructions of the relevant unit lecturers and that they never worked in a hospital setting and further that they never dealt with medical aspects of medicine as alleged or at all.

47. The gravamen of the claimant’s claim is the circular dated 12th January 2012 from the then Office of the Prime Minister. In the court’s view therefore the critical issue to determine in this claim is whether this circular applied to the claimants. If the court reaches the conclusion, that it was applicable to the claimants, the payment of arrears of the allowances claimed will be ordered payable by the respondent and the court would naturally be inclined to find that by leaving out the claimants from the benefits of the circular while their colleagues in public service benefited was an act of discrimination for which they would be entitled to compensation.

48. The Court has reviewed and considered which although not very clear and notes that the same was dated 12th January, 2012 and was specifically addressed to Mr. Mark Bor, then PS for Public Health and Sanitation and Ms. Mary Ngari, then PS in the Ministry of Medical Services. It was neither addressed nor copied to the Ministry in charge of Higher Education under whose docket the respondent, hence the claimant, fell.

49. Counsel for the claimants Mr. Kanjama (SC) submitted among others that the Claimants were covered under the Circular dated 12th January 2012 and quoted Section 2 of the Medical Laboratory Technicians and Technologists Act, Cap 253A Laws of Kenya which defined medical laboratory technologists and technicians as follows:

"Medical laboratory technician" means a person holding a certificate in medical laboratory technology issued by the Kenya Medical Training College or other similar institution recognised by the Board; and

"Medical laboratory technologist" means a person holding a diploma, higher diploma or degree in medical laboratory technology issued by the Kenya Medical Training College or other similar institution approved by the Board."

50. According to counsel, it was undisputed that the Claimants herein were employed within the Respondent’s workforce as medical laboratory technologists and technicians It was also undisputed that the office of the Prime Minister released the circular dated 12th January 2012 wherein it outlined the various allowances payable to public health workers, including health risk and extraneous allowances. As per the Office of the Prime Minister's communication, this circular was to be read together with the circular dated 19th December 2011. Counsel further submitted that vide an article titled, "Insight into the remuneration of health workers in the public service’’ published on the SRC’s website on 25th September 2023, the Commission defined the various cadres of health workers as follows:

"The health worker cadres in Kenya include: doctors, pharmacists, dentists, nurses, clinical officers, lab technicians and other paramedics (physiotherapist, radiographers, occupational therapists, nutrition and dietetics officer, entomologists, chemist, technologists and technicians, public health officers, health record officers, medical social workers, community oral health officers, parasitologist, biochemists, anesthetists, mortuary attendants, orthopedics, radiation protection officers, and biomedical engineers)."

51. Counsel for the respondent Ms Mutinda on the other hand contended that a closer perusal of the contested circular revealed that the same was specifically intended to benefit health workers in public hospitals and health care facilities. Nowhere did it mention workers employed in any University and more specifically the Respondent’s University. More particularly, sub-title (ii) of the circular outlined the persons eligible for allowance as follows:

“This allowance should be payable to all Doctors (Medical Officers, Dentists and Pharmacists) employed in hospitals at the rate of Kshs.30,000 per month, irrespective of grade, with effect from 1st December, 2011. The allowance should in addition be paid to Provincial and District Medical Officers.

Extraneous Allowance and Emergency Call Allowance will also be applicable to Medical Officers, Dentists, Pharmacists and other relevant Health Workers in both Kenyatta National Hospital and Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital as specified. The two institutions are requested to liaise with treasury for funding”

According to counsel, the Respondent herein was a public university, whose statutory mandate was the provision of higher education, research, and training, and not delivery of hospital-based clinical services and further that distinction was neither trivial nor technical. It was central to the applicability of the Circular. The Claimants are employees of a university and serve within an academic institution, not within a hospital structure therefore not contemplated by the Circular.

52. Concerning the issue of discrimination has been ably submitted on by both counsel and the court finds nothing useful to add except to reiterate as was held in the case of Peter K. Waweru V Republic [2006] KLR that:-

“...Discrimination means affording different treatment to different persons attributable wholly or mainly to their description whereby persons of one such descriptions are subjected to ...restrictions to which persons of another description are not made subject or are accorded privileges or advantages which are not accorded to persons of another such description...”

53. And concerning the burden of proof on allegations of discrimination, reliance will be placed on the case of Boniface Momanyi Nyachae v Kenya Orient Insurance Co. Ltd [20231 KECA 136 (KLR) where the court stated inter alia:-

“…Section 5(7) of the Employment Act places the burden of disproving discrimination on the employer. The crux of that provision is that once an employee has made out a prima facie case of discrimination, the burden then shifts to the employer to disprove the allegation. A prima facie case is one in which a court properly directing itself would conclude on the evidence presented that there exists a right which has been infringed. Only then can the burden shift to the respondent to disprove the allegation”.

54. In the instant case, the Court is not persuaded that the claimants had been discriminated by the respondent. I say so because first of all in their own evidence they conceded that they did not work in a hospital environment but the respondent’s laboratory where they prepared specimens for teaching by lecturers and during examinations and further that none of them was registered by Kenya Medical Laboratories Board and that they did not file any evidence to show that they hold the requisite qualifications. Further, as correctly contended by counsel for the respondent, the contested circular from the Office of the then Prime Minister dated 12th January 2012 was explicit and unambiguous in both its language and scope. In its plain reading, it left no room that it could be extended to cover laboratory technicians working in non-hospital environment. The circular was curiously addressed to the Ministry of Public Health and Sanitation and not Ministry of Higher Education or both, the latter, under whose docket the respondent hence the claimant fell.

55. The Court further notes that the said circular stated that: -

Extraneous Allowance and Emergency Call Allowance will also be applicable to Medical Officers, Dentists, Pharmacists and other relevant Health Workers in both Kenyatta National Hospital and Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital as specified. The two institutions are requested to liaise with treasury for funding” (underlining mine).

56. The Court in the above context takes judicial notice that Kenyatta University Teaching and Referral Hospital (the respondent) began operations in October, 2019 and was officially opened in September, 2020 and therefore could not have been in the contemplation of the Circular from the Office of the then Prime Minister dated 12th January 2012. From the above context, the allegations by the claimants that they were entitled to the benefits contained in the circular dated 12th January 2012 from the Office of the then Prime Minister and that they were discriminated in its implementation is therefore without basis and is hereby rejected.

57. In conclusion the Court finds and holds that the claim herein is unmerited and dismisses the same without costs since the claimant may have genuinely, albeit wrongly, believed that they were entitled to the benefits contained in the circular dated 12th January 2012 from the Office of the then Prime Minister, which was a genuine but honestly mistaken agitation for better terms and conditions of work and therefore ought not to be condemned for being innovative in agitating for better labour rights.

58. It is so ordered.

Dated at Nairobi this 16TH day of OCTOBER 2026

Delivered virtually this 16TH day of OCTOBER 2026

Abuodha Nelson Jorum

Presiding Judge-Appeals Division

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder