REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT MACHAKOS
PETITION NO. E004 OF 2023
IN THE MATTER OF ARTICLES 2, 3, 10, 41, 47,174,179,185,224,226 AND 236 СОNSTITUTION OF KENYA
AND
IN THE MATTER OF RIGHT TO A FAIR ADMINISTRATIVE ACTION AND A FAIR HEARING PROVIDED UNDER ARTICLES 47 AND 50 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA
AND
IN THE MATTER OF SECTION 13 OF THE COUNTY GOVERNMENTS АСТ, 2012
AND
THE RIGHT TO FAIR LABOUR PRACTISES UN CONSTITUTION UNDER ARTICLE 41 OF THE AND
IN THE MATTER OF THE OF THE UNFAIR, UNPROCEDURAL AND UNLAWFUL PROCESS OF REMOMOVAL FROM THE OFFICE OF THE CLERK OF THE COUNTY ASSEMBLY OF MАСНАКOS
BETWEEN
JOSEPH MUTISYA LABAN……………………………………………….……………………………………….PETITIONER
-VERSUS-
THE MACHAKOS COUNTY ASSEMBLY SERVICE BOARD…………………………………1ST RESPONDENT
THE COUNTY ASSEMBLY OF MACHAKOS…...…………………….…………………………2ND RESPONDENT
THE SPEAKER, COUNTY ASSEMBLY OF MACHAKOS…………………………………….3RD RESPONDENT
CORAM
Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli
C/A Otieno
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioner was a former Clerk of the 2nd respondent. The petitioner was issued a letter of suspension by the 1st respondent, and a gazette notice was published appointing another person as interim clerk. The petitioner was aggrieved by the disciplinary process and filed an amended petition dated 16th October 2024. The trial court issued conservatory orders on an interim basis on 27th November 2023, staying the suspension decision and the removal proceedings. While the petition was pending hearing, the 2nd and 3rd respondents filed a notice of preliminary objection dated 20th January 2025, challenging the court's jurisdiction pursuant to section 77 of the County Governments Act and sections 85 and 87 of the Public Service Commission Act. In a ruling dated 24th April 2025 on the preliminary objection, Justice Manani stayed the hearing of the petition and remitted the matter to the Public Service Commission for determination. The Public Service Commission heard the dispute and, on 19th December 2025, delivered its decision, dismissing the appeal and upholding the revocation of the petitioner's appointment as clerk. The petitioner was not satisfied with the decision of the Public Service Commission, returned to the court, sought leave, and was granted leave to amend his petition to take into account the decision of the Public Service Commission. In the further amended petition dated 14th May 2026, the petitioner sought the following orders-
a). A declaration that the respondent's decision and order made on the 14th November 2024, suspending the petitioner from the office of Clerk of the Machakos County Assembly as well as the resolution made on the 5th December 2023 and Gazette Notice No. 16763 of 7th December 2023, dismissing the petitioner from office, is unlawful and unconstitutional and thereby null and void ab initio.
b)An order of Mandamus directing the respondents to forthwith reinstate and restore the petitioner to the position of Clerk of the County Assembly of Machakos.
b)An order of certiorari to quash the decision of the Public Service Commission(PSC) made on the 19th November 2025 in Appeal No. 124 of 2025 ,Joseph Mutisya Laban -Vs- County Assembly of Machakos and Another.
c) Damages and compensation for unlawful dismissal from employment.
(d) General Damages for injury arising from the breach of the petitioner's constitutional rights as pleaded above
(e) Costs of the petition.
2. The 1st respondent filed a response vide replying affidavit of Ann Kiusya, (the Chairperson), and opposed the further amended petition on the following grounds-
a. THAT the dispute herein was filed before the Public Service Commission being Appeal No. 124 of 2025.
b. THAT the Appeal has been fully considered by the Public Service Commission and а decision delivered on 19th November 2025. Attached herein and marked "AK-1" is a true copy of the said decision.
c. THAT the decision above has determined the dispute and we request this Honourable Court to adopt the same and mark this matter as closed.
3. The 2nd & 3rd respondents, in response to the amended petition filed, filed a replying affidavit of Ann Kiusya (The Speaker of the Machakos County Assembly) dated 28th May 2026 and stated that the matter had been determined and that the petitioner was to blame for failing to place the alleged violations before the PSC for determination.
DETERMINATION
4. The further amended petition was canvassed by way of written submissions. The issue of finality of the decision of the PSC was canvassed by the parties vide oral submissions of counsel.
5. Issues for determination
a) Whether the PSC decision conclusively determined the dispute.
If the above is in the negative -
b) Whether the suspension and removal complied with Sections 22 and 23 of the County Assembly Services Act.
c) Whether the Petitioner was accorded a fair hearing.
d) Whether alleged breaches of Standing Orders invalidate the removal.
e) Whether the remedies sought are available.
The law
6. The Public Service Commission Act provides for appeal from decisions of cunty public service as follows-
‘86. Procedure for appeal
(1)Any person who is dissatisfied or affected by a decision made by any authority or person in respect of a County Government public service may appeal to the Commission against the decision.
(2)An appeal under subsection (1) shall be in writing and made within ninety days from the date of the decision: Provided that the Commission may consider an appeal out of time if, in the opinion of the Commission, the circumstances warrant it.
(3)The Commission shall make regulations to guide the hearing and determination of appeals from the county public service boards.
(4)After considering an appeal under this section the Commission may—
(a)uphold the decision;
(b)set the decision aside;
(c)vary the decision as it considers to be just; or
(d)give such directions as it may consider appropriate with respect to the decision.’’
7. Section 88 of the Public Service Commission Act provides for review as follows-
‘(1)A person who is dissatisfied or affected by a decision made by the Commission following an appeal under this section may apply for review and the Commission may admit the application if—
(a)fresh material facts arise which with due diligence could not be presented when the decision was initially made; or(b)there is an error apparent on the record of the earlier decision.
(2)An application for review under subsection (4) shall be in writing and made within six months from the date of the decision.
(3)Notwithstanding sub section (2), the Commission may consider an application for review out of time if, in the opinion of the Commission, the circumstances warrant the consideration.
(4)Despite the right of appeal or the right to apply for review in accordance with this Part, the implementation of the decision shall not be deferred or suspended pending the determination of the appeal or the application for review.
(5)After considering an application for review under this section, the Commission may—(a)uphold the decision;
(b)set the decision aside;
(c)vary the decision as it considers to be just;
(d)give such directions as it may consider appropriate with respect to the decision;
(6)The Commission shall state the reason for its decision on an appeal or application for review.’
8. Section 89 of the PSC Act provides for enforcement of appeal decision-
‘(1)Any person who is affected by the decision of the Commission made under this Part may file the decision for enforcement by the Employment and Labour Relations Court provided for under Article 162(2)(a) of the Constitution.
(2)Any person who refuses, fails or neglects to implement the Commission's decisions is liable to disciplinary action in accordance with the applicable laws including removal from office.’
9. Rule 56 of the ELRC(procedure )Rules provides-
‘Where the Constitution, a written law, collective bargaining agreement, contract of service, policy, or other instrument provides for alternative dispute resolution mechanisms—
(a)a person being party to a dispute may file a suit and seek appropriate interlocutory relief pending exhaustion of such alternative dispute resolution mechanisms or pending determination of the suit;
(b)want of exhaustion of such alternative dispute resolution mechanisms shall not operate as a bar to a suit for application for interim orders or alleging unconstitutionality or unlawfulness of the action, omission, decision or other matter in dispute pending such exhaustion; and
(c)a suit filed prior to exhaustion of such alternative dispute resolution mechanisms may be stayed and not struck out on account of such exhaustion.’
Whether the PSC decision conclusively determined the dispute and with finality.
10. The petitioner submitted as follows -
The court's ruling on 24/4/2025 was clear that, in the interim, the court halted this petition so that it be handled by the PSC, then revert to the court for final adjudication, as per Rule 56(5) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules (Legal Notice 133 of 2024). Therefore, the petitioner is not seeking re-litigation, as submitted by the 1st respondent, and the matter cannot be stopped, as alleged by the 1st respondent, because the matter, as presently cast, invites the court's determination of the constitutional issues raised, including even the said decision by the Public Service Commission. There is no substantive prayer before the court for the adoption of the said decision, and, in actual fact, its regularity is contested as an issue for determination in this matter. We submit that the PSC decision is unconstitutional because it failed to comply with Article 47 of the Constitution regarding fair administrative action.
11. Conversely, the 1st respondent submitted as follows: the Public Service Commission heard County Appeal No. 124 of 2025 and dismissed the appeal on 19 November 2025. The PSC in its decision expressly held that: -
"The Commission is satisfied that the respondents complied with the provisions of section 23 of the County Assembly Services Act... The revocation of his appointment... was not unfair." (See the PSC Decision at pages 34-35).
12. The 1st respondent further submitted that the PSC in its decision further ordered that: -
"The Gazette Notice No. 16763 dated 7th December 2023 revoking Appellant's appointment... is upheld." (See the PSC Decision at p. 36).
13. The 1st respondent asserted that the PSC is the statutory appellate body under Section 77 of the County Governments Act and Section 86 of the PSC Act. Its decision is final, subject only to judicial review, not a fresh constitutional petition disguised as an employment claim. The Petitioner did not file a judicial review. He instead seeks to re-litigate matters conclusively determined by PSC. This is barred by: - Issue estoppel and Section 88 (5) of the PSC Act. The PSC decision must therefore be adopted, as requested in the Replying Affidavit.
14. What was the purpose of the remittance of the dispute to the Public Service Commission? at paragraph 48 of the ruling dated 24th April 2025 Justice Manani ordered-
‘As such and in view of rule 56 (5) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024, I hereby issue an order remitting the matter to the Public Service Commission for determination. In the interim, I issue an order staying further hearing of the Petition by this Court.’
15. The petitioner was an employee of the county public service, and all employees’ employment disputes are subject to determination under section 86 of the Public Service Commission Act as read with section 85 of the Act to wit-
‘85. Appeal from County Government public service
The Commission shall, in order to discharge its mandate under Article 234(2)(i) of the Constitution, hear and determine appeals in respect of any decision relating to engagement of any person in a County Government, including a decision in respect of—
(a)recruitment, selection, appointment and qualifications attached to any office;
(b)remuneration and terms and conditions of service;
(c)disciplinary control;
(d)national values and principles of governance, under Article 10 and values and principles of public service under Article 232 of the Constitution;
(e)retirement and other forms of removal from the public service;
(f)pension benefits, gratuity and any other terminal benefits; or
(g)any other decision the Commission considers to fall within its constitutional competence to hear and determine an appeal in that regard.’
16. I find that the Public Service Commission’s decision under section 86 of the PSC Act is final. It can only be challenged under the Fair Administrative Act and not as a fresh claim. The court finds that the alleged constitutional violations relate to the right to fair labour practice, which can be competently redressed by the Public Service Commission. In arriving at its ruling remitting the case to the PSC, the court relied on the Court of Appeal decision in Wajir Wasco Limited alias Wajir Water & Sewerage Company & another v Mohamed & 2 others [2024] KECA 937 (KLR). In that decision, the Court of Appeal addressed the doctrine of constitutional avoidance with respect to a dispute falling under section 77 of the County Government Act (as read with section 85 of the PSC Act) as follows-
‘The doctrine of avoidance is primarily viewed by courts from the position that although a court could take up a matter and hear it, it would still decline to do so if there is another mechanism through which the dispute could be resolved. In Kenya, the Supreme Court stated in Communication Commission of Kenya & 5 Others v Royal Media Services Ltd & 5 Others [2014] eKLR (at para 256) that the principle of avoidance means that a court will not determine a constitutional issue when a matter may properly be decided on another basis.’’
17. I find the court would be violating the doctrine of constitutional avoidance in seizing jurisdiction over disputes under the statutory mandate of the Public Service Commission. I personally have doubts about the efficacy of Rule 56 of the ELRC Rules (2024) insofar as it stays such cases. What would be the purpose of the stay when the court has no jurisdiction in the first instance? I find the rule to be superfluous.
18. What does it mean by first instance? Some clarity is found in the Fair Administrative Action Act. Section 3 applies to the Public Service Commission decisions under section 77 of the County Government Act where it is stated-
‘This Act applies to all state and non-state agencies, including any person–
(a)exercising administrative authority;
(b)performing a judicial or quasi-judicial function under the Constitution or any written law;
or
(c)whose action, omission or decision affects the legal rights or interests of any person to whom such action, omission or decision relates.’
19. Section 9 of the Fair Administrative Action Act provides for exercise of quasi-judicial powers and for challenge of such decisions as follows-
‘ 9. Procedure for judicial review
(1)Subject to subsection (2), a person who is aggrieved by an administrative action may, without unreasonable delay, apply for judicial review of any administrative action to the High Court or to a subordinate court upon which original jurisdiction is conferred pursuant to Article 22(3) of the Constitution.
(2)The High Court or a subordinate court under subsection (1) shall not review an administrative action or decision under this Act unless the mechanisms including internal mechanisms for appeal or review and all remedies available under any other written law are first exhausted.
(3)The High Court or a subordinate Court shall, if it is not satisfied that the remedies referred to in subsection (2) have been exhausted, direct that applicant shall first exhaust such remedy before instituting proceedings under subsection (1).
(4)Notwithstanding subsection (3), the High Court or a subordinate Court may, in exceptional circumstances and on application by the applicant, exempt such person from the obligation to exhaust any remedy if the court considers such exemption to be in the interest of justice.
(5)A person aggrieved by an order made in the exercise of the judicial review jurisdiction of the High Court may appeal to the Court of Appeal.’’
20. The court finds that in the first instance means the dispute is to be determined in another statutory forum, and if a party is aggrieved with the decision of the alternative forum, then they can file judicial review proceedings in the court with original jurisdiction under the Fair Administrative Action Act2, section 9. That is why I stated that Rule 56(5) of the ELRC Rules is superfluous. The court cannot sit to decide the dispute afresh. The dispute has been decided by the PSC. A party can only challenge the decision under judicial review proceedings under the Fair Administrative Action Act.
21. The court for the foregoing reasoning, holds that the dispute was determined legally and with finality by the Public Service Commission under a decision dated 19th November 2025 where it was held as follows-‘
‘ In view of the above, and pursuant to Section 88(5) of the Public Service Commission Act, 2017 as read together with Regulation 24(8) of the Public Service Commission (County Appeals Procedures) Regulations, 2022, the Commission hereby orders that: -
i) The Appellant's appeal dated 6th May, 2025 is hereby disallowed;
ii) ii) The Gazette Notice No. 16763 dated 7th December, 2023 revoking the Appellant's appointment as Clerk of the County Assembly of Machakos, with effect from 5th December, 2023 is upheld.’
22. The petitioner ought to have sought review before the PSC and, if still aggrieved, file judicial review proceedings under the Fair Administrative Action Act. The amended petition is struck out, as the court has no jurisdiction to determine the dispute in the first instance, but only at judicial review, exercising supervisory jurisdiction over the Commission (section 9 of the FAAA). The decision of the Public Service Commission dated 19th November 2025 is adopted as the Decree of the court in determining the dispute.
23. The court is to temper justice with mercy, taking into account that the petitioner was following the court ruling, as he understood it; I order each party to bear its own costs.
24. The file is marked as closed.
25. It is so Ordered.
DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MACHAKOS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026.
JEMIMAH KELI,
JUDGE.
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
Court Assistant: Otieno
PETITONER- Swaka h/b Njenga
1ST Respondent- Saende
2ND AND 3RD RESPONDENT Akenga