REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
PETITION NO. E120_OF 2026
JUDICIAL REVIEW AND LABOUR RIGHTS DIVISION
IN THE MATTER OF ARTICLE 2 (1), 3 (1), 10 (2) (c) and 22 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA AND IN THE MATTER OF ALLEGED CONTRAVENTION OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS AND FREEDOMS UNDER ARTICLES 27 (4) and 41 (1) OF THE CONSTITUTIONOFKENYA2010.
BETWEEN
MOSES NJENGA….……………………………………..……………………………………………………………..…PETITONER
VERSUS
KENYA INSTITUTE FOR PUBLIC POLICY RESEARCH
AND ANALYSIS (KIPPRA)………………………………....…………………..……………………………..…RESPONDENT
CORAM
Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli
C/A Otieno
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioner is an employee of the respondent, employed as a Principal Policy Analyst, Grade KIP 4. Until 13th February 2026, the petitioner had been acting in the position of Head of Department for the Private Sector Department for approximately 10 years, when the acting capacity was terminated and the substantive holder of the position returned to office. The petitioner, prior to the decision to terminate his acting capacity, had sued the respondent in Nairobi ELRC JR E005 OF 2026, which he says triggered retaliation by the employer through the termination of his acting capacity. He alleged discrimination and filed a petition dated 17th April 2026 seeking the following reliefs-
a. A declaration by this honourable court that maintaining the petitioner in an acting capacity for a prolonged period of 10 years, without granting him the substantive appointment and only relieving him of his role in that capacity because he filed a case against the respondent to demand accountability and adherence to the law and to the KIPPRA Human Resource Policy and Procedure Manuals, amounts to discrimination and unreasonable and/or unfair labour practices on the part of the respondent, and is contrary to the provisions of Article 41 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010, as read together with Section 5 of the Employment Act, No. 11 of 2007.
b. A declaration that by approving all other acting appointments except the petitioner’s on 30th January 2026 after the petitioner had served the respondent with the pleadings in ELRCJR/E005/2026, the respondent violated the petitioner’s constitutional right enshrined at Article 27 (1) and (4) of the Constitution as read with Section5oftheEmployment Act not to be discriminated against.
c. An award of compensation for violation of the respondent’s constitutional rights protected under Article 27 (1) and (4) of the Constitution, Article 41 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010 as read together with Section 5 of the Employment Act. No. 1 1 of 2007 and Article 236 of the Constitutions of Kenya to be assessed at Ksh 5,000,000.
d. An award for aggravated damages to be assessed by the court.
e. Costs and interest.
f. Any other order or relief the court may deem fit to grant.
2. The petitioner filed an affidavit in support of the petition of even date and produced letters of acting appointment from 21st November 2016 for 6 months, with the last renewal dated 10th November 2025, effective 5th May 2025 for 6 months, performance appraisal with good ratings, an email from Prof Kieyah confirming reported back on 5th May 2025, pleadings in the JR suit, the January 2020 human resources policy and procedures manual of the respondent, a letter of 11th February 2026 concluding the acting appointment, and an extract of the minutes of the meeting held on 30th January 2026, which approved internal recruitment.
3. The petition was opposed by the respondent via a replying affidavit of Dr Eldah Onsumu, dated 29th May 2026, and denied the allegation that the decision not to renew the acting position was informed by the JR suit, stating that the substantive holder took back his position. He attached the petitioner's contract of employment, several letters of appointment to acting also produced by the petitioner, and communications regarding the secondment of the substantive holder of the position, Prof Keiyah.
4. The respondent further produced an extract of the minutes of the meeting of 30th January 2026, where it was resolved not to renew the acting of 3 staff, including the petitioner. The other 2 were not available for retention following exit from service, and another had requested to be relieved from acting. As relates to the petitioner, it was indicated that the reason for non-approval of acting was that ‘the substantive HOD, Prof Joseph Keiyah, to resume his substantive position as HOD, private sector’. Other 9 officers were approved for acting with a caveat of recruitment in 3 months.
5. The petitioner filed a further affidavit on 17th June 2026 and reiterated his claim of discrimination, stating that the decision of 30th June was made exactly 2 days after he served the employer with the JR suit. He stated that, although his 6-month appointment had expired, he continued to act in the position. That the renewal of May 2025 was done while the said substantive holder had returned on 5th May 2025. He contended that the only reason for non-renewal was retaliation for filing the JR suit.
DETERMINATION.
6. The court, having perused the pleadings, was of the considered opinion that the issues for determination were-
A. Whether the petitioner had legitimate expectation of continued acting because he had been acting for 10 years
B. Whether the non-renewal of acting was discriminatory
C. Whether the petitioner was entitled to the relief sought
The law-
7. Articles 22, 27, 41, 47, 236 of the Constitution.
8. Section 5 and 46 of the Employment Act.
9. Section 34 of the Public Service Commission Act.
Whether the petitioner had a legitimate expectation of continued acting because he had been acting for 10 years
10. The facts are not in dispute. The petitioner had been acting for 10 years, with consecutive renewals of 6 months, the last of which, effective May 2025, expired in November 2025, but he continued acting. It is also not in dispute that, when the last renewal was done, the substantive holder of the office was around but was deployed to another office. It is also not in dispute that Prof Kieyah's contract of employment with respect to the position the petitioner was acting in, had not been revoked.
11. There is no difficulty with the court finding that acting is temporary and the acting contract held by the petitioner had expired.
12. This court has consistently held that prolonged acting is an unfair labour practice. Indeed, this is the position espoused in authorities relied on by the petitioner in Njoroge v Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Company Limited (2024) KEELRC1135 (KLR) among others. In the decision cited by the respondent in Ogogoh v Public Service Commission and 2 others; Nyaberi (interested party) (2025) KEELRC 2543 (KLR), Justice Mbaru cited several cases by different judges of the court, including myself, against prolonged acting. The petitioner tells the court he had a legitimate expectation to continue acting while he had been at it for 10 years. That expectation flies in the face of established jurisprudence. The petitioner has not sought compensation for the long acting, and the substantive position was not vacant. I find that the decisions the petitioner relied on to support his case, where there was a vacancy of the substantive post, are not applicable.
13. The court asked itself whether the petitioner would have had a case of expectation of continued acting were it not for the claim of retaliation. The answer is no. Long acting does not give an employee a vested right to be substantively appointed to the post unless the HR policies or the contract expressly provide for automatic absorption. This was not the case here. The court is alive to the fact that the respondent is a public body. Section 34 of the PSC Act provides for acting as follows-
‘34. Acting appointments
(1)Acting appointments shall be—
a)made by the lawful appointing authority; and
(b)subject to the prescribed regulations and procedures which apply to appointments
.(2)A person shall not be appointed to hold a public office in an acting capacity unless the person satisfies all the prescribed qualifications for holding the public office.2
(3)An officer may be appointed in an acting capacity for a period of at least thirty days but not exceeding a period of six months.
(4)A public officer may be assigned to perform duties vested in another public officer during a temporary absence of the other public officer.’’(emphasis given)
14. It appears to the court that the petitioner was appointed under clause 34(4) of the PSC Act. The substantive holder of the position in question had been on secondment at the time of the appointment for acting was first done. When he returned, the employer deployed him to another department. His contract was not amended. He was always available to return to his substantive post; thus, the petitioner cannot assert that he expected to be formally appointed to the position. The position was not vacant. I find that the claim of legitimate expectation is not supported by law and facts.
15. In the public service under Article 232 of the Constitution, fair competition, merit, and equal opportunity in filling positions are mandatory requirements. The court can thus not uphold a legitimate expectation to defeat competitive recruitment.
Whether the petitioner was discriminated against.
16. The court noted the coincidence between the non-renewal and the JR suit. Article 236 of the Constitution protects public officers as follows-
‘236. Protection of public officers
A public officer shall not be—
(a)victimised or discriminated against for having performed the functions of office in accordance with this Constitution or any other law; or
(b)dismissed, removed from office, demoted in rank or otherwise subjected to disciplinary action without due process of law.’
17. It is further stated in section 46 (h) of the Employment Act-
‘The following do not constitute fair reasons for dismissal or for the imposition of a disciplinary penalty—
h)an employee's initiation or proposed initiation of a complaint or other legal proceedings against his employer, except where the complaint is shown to be irresponsible and without foundation; ‘
18. The JR suit ELRCJR/E005/2026, was served, and the employer conceded. The case was marked as closed. The reason for non-renewal is reflected in the minutes relied on by the petitioner of 30th January, 2026, being that the substantive HOD, Prof Joseph Keiyah, was to resume his substantive position as HOD private sector. The court noted that at this time the appointment for acting had expired. There was no termination. I find no basis for the claim of discrimination under the alleged retaliation.
19. I already held there was no basis to find a legitimate explanation for the continued acting. I noted that the subsequent appointment of 9 officers to acting was done later on 27th March 2026. The reason for the non-renewal was explained. I find the reason as valid. The owner of the position resumed duty. Acting is a temporary measure.
Whether the petitioner is entitled to the relief sought
20. The petitioner sought for a declaration by this Honourable Court that maintaining the petitioner in an acting capacity for a prolonged period of 10 years, without granting him the substantive appointment and only relieving him of his role in that capacity because he filed a case against the respondent to demand accountability and adherence to the law and to the KIPPRA Human Resource Policy and Procedure Manuals, amounts to discrimination and unreasonable and/or unfair labour practices on the part of the respondent, and is contrary to the provisions of Article 41 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010, as read together with Section 5 of the Employment Act, No. 11 of 2007.I return in the negative as there was no proof of discrimination related to the JR suit. The court found the reason for non-renewal of acting was valid. Acting is temporary, and there cannot be a legitimate expectation of longer acting. Confirmation to the position on the basis of a long period of acting would amount to a violation of Article 232 of the Constitution. The claim is disallowed.
21. The petitioner further sought for a declaration that by approving all other acting appointments except the petitioner’s on 30th January 2026 after the petitioner had served the respondent with the pleadings in ELRCJR/E005/2026, the respondent violated the petitioner’s constitutional right enshrined at Article 27 (1) and (4) of the Constitution as read with Section 5 of the Employment Act not to be discriminated against. I held in the negative on the issue.
22. Having found no case of discrimination based on the JR suit ELRCJR/E005/2026, as alleged, and no legitimate expectation for continued acting or confirmation to the substantive position, I find no basis to award any relief sought.
Disposition
23. The petition is held to lack merit and is dismissed.
24. The parties are in active employment relations. To promote industrial harmony, I order each party to bear its own costs.
25. It is so Ordered.
DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MACHAKOS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
JEMIMAH KELI,
JUDGE.
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
Court Assistant: Otieno
Applicant: Otieno
Respondent- Jepkemei