Background
By a Memorandum of Claim dated 21st July, 2020, the claimant pleaded inter alia: -
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
The claim was dismissed with costs. The court found that dismissal was supported by valid and justifiable reasons and that the disciplinary procedure satisfied section 41 of the Employment Act. It also disallowed the claim for withheld half salary during interdiction and held reinstatement inappropriate in any event.
17. In conclusion, the court finds the claim herein without merit and is hereby dismissed with costs.
Paragraph 17 →
16. Regarding payment of the balance of the half salary withheld during interdiction, as rightly submitted by counsel for the respondent, this is only payable where the disciplinary or criminal proceedings result in the officer not being dismissed or otherwise punished. This is in line with the provisions of section 70(2) of the Public Service Commission Act. This claim is therefore unsustainable and is hereby disallowed. Concerning prayer for reinstatement, in view of the reasons for which the claimant was dismissed, which in the court’s view quite serious and as rightly submitted by counsel for the respondent, bordered on threat to national security and the fact that it has been more than eight years since the termination of the claimant’s service, reinstatement would not have been an appropriate remedy in the circumstances even if the court were to find the termination unfair.
Paragraph 16 →
Held. Decided for the respondents. They had valid and justifiable reasons to dismiss the claimant. His acknowledgement that he may have overlooked required procedures, including recommending passport applications lacking vetting reports or required comments/signature, established the material infraction. The challenge based on the escalation from 24 to 55 files did not undermine the reason for dismissal: the serious issue was recommending passport issuance without proper vetting, not the number of affected files. The unfair-termination allegation was dismissed.
Ratio. Under section 43, an employer must prove the reasons it genuinely believed existed when terminating employment. The court assesses whether the employer’s decision falls within the range of reasonableness, rather than conducting a forensic re-evaluation of every alleged incident. Where the admitted or established misconduct is recommending passport issuance without required vetting, the seriousness of that infraction can justify dismissal regardless of whether one, 24, or 55 files were involved.
Issue
11. The Court has considered either side’s contention and considers the main issues to be determined in this claim are whether the grounds proffered by the respondent in terminating the claimant’s service met the threshold set under section 43 of the Employment Act and existing case law. Secondly whether the respondent in carrying out the termination adhered to the provisions as set out under section 41 of the Employment Act and rules of natural justice generally. As a corollary, should the court reach the conclusion that the respondent failed to prove and or justify the reasons for termination of the claimant’s service as required of it under section 47(5) of the Employment Act, what remedies are the claimant entitled to and finally which party should bear the costs of the suit.
Paragraph 11 →
Held
14. To the above extent the court is persuaded that the respondent had valid and justifiable reasons for terminating the service of the claimant. The allegation of unfair termination is therefore found without merit and is hereby dismissed.
Paragraph 14 →
Ratio
12. Under section 43 of the Employment Act, in any claim arising out of termination of a contract, the employer shall be required to prove the reason or reasons for the termination, and where the employer fails to do so, the termination shall be deemed to have been unfair within the meaning of section 45(2) of the Act. Further, the reason or reasons for termination of a contract are the matters that the employer at the time of termination of the contract genuinely believed to exist, and which caused the employer to terminate the services of the employee. This Court has held in several cases that it is not within its jurisdiction to conduct a near forensic audit of the reasons for termination of service of an employee. In the often-quoted case of British Leyland UK Ltd v. Swift [1981] IRLR 91, Lord Dening stated as follows:-
Paragraph 12 →
The claimant however is on record as having through his letter dated 7th July 2017 acknowledging that he may have overlooked important procedures, including instances where applications lacked the required Passport Vetting Committee reports and where he may have recommended applications without making the necessary comments and appending his signature as required. This seems to the court to be the main issue in the matter and not the number of files involved. It could be one file, twenty-four or fifty-five but that may not matter much if recommending a file for passport issuance without proper vetting was impermissible under the respondent’s operating procedures. That is to say, it was not the volume or number of times the infraction was committed that mattered, but the seriousness attached by the employer to the omission or infraction by the employee.
Paragraph 13 →
Held. Decided for the respondents. The notice to show cause/interdiction set out the allegations and allowed 21 days for representations; the claimant responded after the prescribed period without seeking an extension. He was also invited before the Investigation Committee and had opportunities to participate in the initial inquiry, investigations, committee process, appeal, and review. Section 41 procedural requirements were sufficiently met.
Ratio. Section 41 procedural fairness was satisfied where the employee received particulars of the allegations, an opportunity and time to respond, and further opportunities to make representations during the disciplinary process. The court treated participation across the inquiry, investigation, committee, appeal, and review stages as sufficient compliance with natural justice.
Issue
11. The Court has considered either side’s contention and considers the main issues to be determined in this claim are whether the grounds proffered by the respondent in terminating the claimant’s service met the threshold set under section 43 of the Employment Act and existing case law. Secondly whether the respondent in carrying out the termination adhered to the provisions as set out under section 41 of the Employment Act and rules of natural justice generally. As a corollary, should the court reach the conclusion that the respondent failed to prove and or justify the reasons for termination of the claimant’s service as required of it under section 47(5) of the Employment Act, what remedies are the claimant entitled to and finally which party should bear the costs of the suit.
Paragraph 11 →
Held
15. Regarding the procedure followed prior to the termination, the notice to Show Cause/interdiction letter dated 1st August 2017 set out the particulars of the allegations against the claimant and granted him twenty-one (21) days within which to submit his representations. The Claimant did not submit his response within the stipulated period, which lapsed on or about 21st August 2017, he did not seek an extension of time within which to respond. His subsequent response dated 31st August 2017 was therefore made after the prescribed period had lapsed. The Respondent subsequently invited the claimant to appear before an Investigation Committee on 15th January 2018 where he was granted a further opportunity to make representations regarding the allegations against him.
Paragraph 15 →
From the foregoing, the court is also persuaded that the Claimant was granted opportunity to participate at various stages of the disciplinary process, including the initial inquiry by his supervisor, Investigations, appearance before the Investigation Committee, and the subsequent appeal and review processes before the Public Service Commission. The procedural requirements under section 41 of the Act were therefore sufficiently met.
Paragraph 15 →
Ratio
From the foregoing, the court is also persuaded that the Claimant was granted opportunity to participate at various stages of the disciplinary process, including the initial inquiry by his supervisor, Investigations, appearance before the Investigation Committee, and the subsequent appeal and review processes before the Public Service Commission. The procedural requirements under section 41 of the Act were therefore sufficiently met.
Paragraph 15 →
Held. No compensatory relief was due because the dismissal was upheld. Separately, the claim for the balance of salary withheld during interdiction was disallowed because such withheld benefits are restored only if disciplinary or criminal proceedings do not result in dismissal or other punishment. Reinstatement was also inappropriate, even had the termination been unfair, because the misconduct was serious, implicated national security, and more than eight years had elapsed since termination.
Ratio. Under section 70(2) of the Public Service Commission Act, an interdicted officer’s withheld benefits are payable only where the disciplinary or criminal process does not result in dismissal or punishment. Reinstatement is not appropriate where the nature of the misconduct, the public-security-sensitive role, and the lengthy elapsed time make restoration of the employment relationship unsuitable.
Issue
11. The Court has considered either side’s contention and considers the main issues to be determined in this claim are whether the grounds proffered by the respondent in terminating the claimant’s service met the threshold set under section 43 of the Employment Act and existing case law. Secondly whether the respondent in carrying out the termination adhered to the provisions as set out under section 41 of the Employment Act and rules of natural justice generally. As a corollary, should the court reach the conclusion that the respondent failed to prove and or justify the reasons for termination of the claimant’s service as required of it under section 47(5) of the Employment Act, what remedies are the claimant entitled to and finally which party should bear the costs of the suit.
Paragraph 11 →
Held
16. Regarding payment of the balance of the half salary withheld during interdiction, as rightly submitted by counsel for the respondent, this is only payable where the disciplinary or criminal proceedings result in the officer not being dismissed or otherwise punished. This is in line with the provisions of section 70(2) of the Public Service Commission Act. This claim is therefore unsustainable and is hereby disallowed. Concerning prayer for reinstatement, in view of the reasons for which the claimant was dismissed, which in the court’s view quite serious and as rightly submitted by counsel for the respondent, bordered on threat to national security and the fact that it has been more than eight years since the termination of the claimant’s service, reinstatement would not have been an appropriate remedy in the circumstances even if the court were to find the termination unfair.
Paragraph 16 →
Ratio
16. Regarding payment of the balance of the half salary withheld during interdiction, as rightly submitted by counsel for the respondent, this is only payable where the disciplinary or criminal proceedings result in the officer not being dismissed or otherwise punished. This is in line with the provisions of section 70(2) of the Public Service Commission Act. This claim is therefore unsustainable and is hereby disallowed. Concerning prayer for reinstatement, in view of the reasons for which the claimant was dismissed, which in the court’s view quite serious and as rightly submitted by counsel for the respondent, bordered on threat to national security and the fact that it has been more than eight years since the termination of the claimant’s service, reinstatement would not have been an appropriate remedy in the circumstances even if the court were to find the termination unfair.
Paragraph 16 →
Held. The claimant’s claim was dismissed with costs.
Ratio. No separate legal rule is necessary for this finding. The judgment gave no distinct reasoning on costs beyond the dispositive order.
Issue
11. The Court has considered either side’s contention and considers the main issues to be determined in this claim are whether the grounds proffered by the respondent in terminating the claimant’s service met the threshold set under section 43 of the Employment Act and existing case law. Secondly whether the respondent in carrying out the termination adhered to the provisions as set out under section 41 of the Employment Act and rules of natural justice generally. As a corollary, should the court reach the conclusion that the respondent failed to prove and or justify the reasons for termination of the claimant’s service as required of it under section 47(5) of the Employment Act, what remedies are the claimant entitled to and finally which party should bear the costs of the suit.
Paragraph 11 →
Held
17. In conclusion, the court finds the claim herein without merit and is hereby dismissed with costs.
Paragraph 17 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
By a Memorandum of Claim dated 21st July, 2020, the claimant pleaded inter alia: -
Paragraph 1 →In conclusion, the court finds the claim herein without merit and is hereby dismissed with costs.
Paragraph 17 →Whether the respondents proved valid and justifiable reasons for dismissing the claimant under section 43 of the Employment Act; whether the disciplinary process met section 41 and natural-justice requirements; whether withheld interdiction salary,…
Charles Temoi Ndiema was employed in the Immigration Department from 9 August 2005 and was Chief Immigration Officer when disciplinary proceedings arose. He was first asked on 6 July 2017 to explain recommendations for 24 passport applications allegedly made…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. E484 OF 2020
CHARLES TEMOI NDIEMA……................................................. CLAIMANT
-VERSUS-
MINISTRY OF INTERIOR AND
CORDINATION OF NATIONAL GOVERNMENT
AND CITIZEN SERVICES……................………………1ST RESPONDENT
PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION…….....……………2ND RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
1. By a Memorandum of Claim dated 21st July, 2020, the claimant pleaded inter alia: -
a) That at all material times the claimant was an employee at the immigration department, the 1st respondent herein having been employed on the 9th August, 2005 as an immigration officer on probation basis and eventually confirmed as a permanent employee on the 28th December,2006 to 12th July 2017 when he was dismissed and released from his duties.
b) That the claimant was holding a position of Chief Immigration Officer at the time he was unlawfully terminated and discharged from his duties and/or services in the immigration department.
c) The claimant avers in the line of his duty as the recommender at the Immigration department he worked diligently and dutifully throughout the course of his employment until when he was unfairly and unlawfully dismissed and/or discharged from his duties as the immigration officer.
d) The claimant avers that on the 6th July, 2017 through a letter he was required to explain why he recommended applications for passport issuance, most of which had scanty information, with the applicants having not been vetted as required.
e) The allegations were that the claimant in his capacity as “a recommender” recommended that twenty-four (24) applicants for passports to be issued with the travel documents before the said applicants appeared for vetting by the Passports Vetting Committee (PVC), thereby disregarding the committee’s role in the process. It was also alleged that the said application forms through which the passports were issued did not have all the details of the applicants to warrant such issuance.
f) That following the allegations above the claimant was interdicted on the 1st August 2017 subject to terms and conditions as provided by the HR Manual Policy and was required within 21 days to show cause as to why he should not be dismissed from service on account of gross misconduct.
g) The claimant avers that on the 31st August, 2017, the claimant wrote a letter seeking more time to put in his response and also, he further requested to be supplied with the details of the fifty five (55) copies of passports he had issued subject to vetting which was never responded to by the 1st respondent.
h) That however, on the 26th April,2018 the claimant was dismissed from service on accounts of gross misconduct, a letter that was not served on him until in the month of June, 2018 when he did not receive the half salary and decided to inquire and realized that he had been discharged from duties two months prior without any communication.
i) That upon dismissal from service, on the 10th July, 2018 the claimant appealed to the 2nd respondent that is the Public Service Commission Secretary/C.E.O against the dismissal but his appeal was disallowed through a letter dated 6th December, 2018. Subsequently, on the 22nd February, 2019 the claimant applied for review of the appeal decision and again the same was declined on grounds for lack of new grounds/evidence to warrant review.
j) Reasons wherefore; the claimant claim against the respondents jointly and severally prays for-;
a) That a declaration do issue that the interdiction dated the 31st August 2017 and subsequently a dismissal dated the 26th April, 2018 was unlawful, unprocedural, unfair, without any lawful and accordingly be declared null and void ab initio and set aside in its entirety.
b) That an order that the claimant be reinstated to the service of the 1st respondent.
c) That the claimant be paid his benefits and withheld salaries for the period the claimant was under interdiction and dismissal up to the date of reinstatement.
d) Costs and interest of the claim.
e) Any other or further remedy that the honourable court deems it fit and necessary to grant.
2. The Respondent filed a statement of response dated 24th March, 2021 and averred among others that: -
a) The Respondents aver that the Claimant is a former Chief Immigration Officer responsible for recommending applications for passports after being satisfied that the applications have undergone all the processes, including vetting. The claimant abdicated his duties and committed commissions and/or omissions resulting to issuance of passports to non - deserving applicants hence putting national security of our country at jeopardy.
b) On 6th July, 2017 the Claimant was addressed a letter Ref. No. CONF/2005046776/ (15) by the Director Immigration Services to explain why he recommended the applications for passport issuance, most of which had scanty information, with the applicants having not been vetted as required.
c) That the Claimant was given an opportunity to scrutinize the first 24 files listed in the letter addressed to him of 6th July. 2017 (refer to preceding paragraph). The claimant responded to the said letter of 6th July, 2017 through handwritten response of 7th July, 2017. That further to the preceding paragraph, the claimant scrutinized the physical files listed in the letter to him dated 6th July, 2017 and admitted that he overlooked some important procedures. The claimant regretted his unwarranted acts of omissions and commissions that occurred during the course of his employment.
d) The Respondents aver upon receipt of the claimant’s response, the Director of Immigration Service through letter Ref: PF/CONF/2005046776/(8) dated 10th July, recommended to the Authorized Officer to take disciplinary action against the claimant for the role he played in the issuance of passports to applicants who had not been vetted by the passport vetting committee.
e) On 1st August, 2017 vide letter Ref. No. 2005046776/16 the Claimant was addressed a Show Cause/interdiction letter with details of the charges preferred against him and the period within which the offences were committed. The Claimant was given an opportunity to make his representations within twenty-one (21) days as required by the Public Service Commission regulations and the Employment Act.
f) The claimant refused/ignored/neglected and/or squandered the opportunity granted to him to submit a response to the show cause letter within the stipulated 21 days, which period lapsed on or around 21st August, 2017. As an afterthought, the claimant wrote a letter/response to the show cause dated 31s1 August, 2017. The contents and form of the claimant’s letter is a copy and paste of similar letters wrote by Mr. Isaac Ngaruiya and James Kinuthia, the Claimants in ELRC Cause 1718 of and who were dismissed together with the claimant herein on related accounts of gross misconduct.
g) That a committee to investigate the issuance of irregular passports by the Claimant among others herein was formed in accordance with Section 4 (c) of the Public Service Commission Act No. 10 of 2017. The Claimant was invited to appear before the Committee and appeared on 15th January 2018 where he made his representations to the Investigating Committee.
h) The investigation Committee upon concluding the investigations came to the finding that the Claimant herein was guilty of the charges levelled against him and upon tabling of the Report before the Ministerial Human Resource Management Advisory Committee on 28th February, 2018 it was recommended that the Officers be dismissed from service.
i) That on 28th February, 2018, the Ministerial Human Resource Management Advisory Committee deliberated on the issue and recommended that the Claimant be dismissed from service with effect from 12th July, 2017. The Claimant was informed of the decision vide letter Ref. No. 2005046776/21 dated 26th April, 2018.
j) That on 10th July, 2018 the claimant appealed against the dismissal from service on account of gross misconduct to the Public Service Commission. The Commission dismissed the Appeal and the Claimant was informed of the decision through a letter Ref. No. 2005027756/37 dated 6th December, 2018.
k) That on 9th August, 2018, the Ministerial Human Resource Management Advisory Committee deliberated on the claimant’s appeal and recommended to the authorized officer that the claimant’s appeal against dismissal be rejected since he had not new grounds in the appeal.
l) That the Claimant applied for review of appeal against dismissal from service on account of gross misconduct through a letter dated 22nd February, 2019 to the Public Service Commission.
m) The Public Service Commission disallowed the application for review and the same was communicated to the Claimant by the Authorized Officer vide letter Ref. No. 2005046776 (43) dated 8th August, 2019. That on 26th March, 2019, the Ministerial Human Resource Management Advisory Committee deliberated on the claimant’s application for review of his appeal and recommended to the authorized officer the earlier recommendation to dismiss the claimant on account of gross misconduct be upheld as he did not raise any new grounds to warrant review of the case.
n) The claimant’s allegations that he was never given fair hearing and that he was not informed of his right to legal representation or be accompanied by an employee of his choice are baseless for the claimant appeared before the Director of Immigration Services on 6th July. 2017 and scrutinized the first 24 files and again appeared before the investigation committee on 15th January, 2018 where he made his representations together with Mr. Isaac Ngaruiya and James Kinuthia, the Claimants in ELRC Cause 1718 of 2018the claimants.
o) The Respondents aver that the Claimant was under duty and bound by the Public Officers Ethics Act and Chapter six of the Constitution 2010 which call for among other things, integrity.
EVIDENCE
3. The Claimant’s case was heard on 14th October 2025 and he testified among others that:-
i. He recorded a statement 10th July 2024 which he sought to adopt as his witness statement in the matter and that he used to work for the respondent. His claim was dated 21st July 2020, and he relied on the documents filed with the claim as his exhibits. According to him, he was terminated on 26th April, 2018 and filed the suit herein on 21st July, 2020.
ii. It was his evidence that he was accused of recommending issuance of passports without vetting and that he was informed of the allegations by the Director. It was his evidence that he was asked to admit the mistake and the respondent would be lenient and wrote as instructed. He was subsequently interdicted and issued with a notice to show cause. He responded asking to be furnished with copies of the suspicious passports but was not furnished with the files. He wanted to ensure that he was the one who worked on the files in question. He further stated that he was given one day to respond to the allegations and that the time was not sufficient.
iii. It was further his evidence that the process of issuing passport did not involve only one officer and that they were about 10 other officers who must have participated in the process and wondered why he was the only one picked out.
iv. Concerning the dismissal letter found at p35 of CBD and dated 26th April, 2018, it was his evidence that he was not taken through a just process. Initially the files were 24 and later they increased to 55 and further that he never received any response to his request for the files. Regarding the remedies sought he stated that he sought to be reinstated.
v. In cross examination he stated that he was served with a Notice to show cause and given 21 days to respond and later invited to the disciplinary hearing by a phone call. After dismissal, he was informed of his right of appeal through the dismissal letter.
vi. In reexamination he stated that the show cause letter was a follow up after his first response. The 1st letter from the Director required him to respond within set hours. Mr. Arusei
4. The Respondent’s case on the other hand was heard on 11th January, 2026 and a Mr. Hemedy for the respondent testified that:-
i. He worked for immigration services and filed a statement dated 16th October, 2025 which he relied on as his evidence in chief. He further relied on the documents filed in support of the defence.
ii. In cross examination he stated that the claimant was dismissed in February, 2018 after disciplinary hearing. The reason for dismissal found at page 6 of RBD was issuance of passports to persons not vetted. They were initially 24 passports but this increased to 55. He stated that the show cause letter listed passports issued without vetting.
iii. He stated that the claimant was provided with other 24 files and he could see that from the letter dated 10th July, 2017 found at page 12 of RBD. He however did not know if the claimant signed for the receipt of the files. He further stated that the dismissal was on account of 55 files and that the claimant admitted his mistake. This was found at page 8-9 of RBD. The claimant however did not admit gross abuse of office. According to him the claimant admitted the mistake and stated that it was due to pressure of work. He however maintained that it was the claimant’s duty to be careful and that the claimant was not the only one processing issuance of passports. There were other officers. The claimant was the 5th in the chain. There were also others above him in the chain. The claimant was accused with two other officers in charge of printing passports.
CLAIMANTS’ SUBMISSIONS
5. Counsel for the claimant Mr. Arusei submitted among others that:
i. The respondent was shifting accusations. Initially on the 6th July ,2017, the claimant was accused of recommending 24 passport applications for passport issuances without proper vetting. Later on the 1st August,2017 the allegations were escalated to 55 passports, doubling the scope of the alleged Passport applications and this later accusation of 55 Passports applications ultimately formed the basis of the claimant’s interdiction on the 1st August,2017 and dismissal via the dismissal letter dated the 26th April,2018. According to Counsel, this shifting of allegations was not a mere error but a substantive and a procedural matter that went to the very root of fairness. In a sense the goalposts were being shifted and that went to the root of the matter and also to the procedural fairness and it would be a remiss on the claimant part not to put this plainly and clearly in this litigation.
ii. Most fundamentally, when the claimant received another letter to show cause/interdiction letter dated 1st August,2017 the accusation was that the claimant recommended 55 applicants for issuance of Passports spanning a different period contrary to the initial allegation of 24 Passport applications. No explanation was tendered before this court to help the court ascertain whether the 55 files were entirely new files, different from the initial 24 or were an addition to the 24 files. Of importance was the fact that the claimant wrote to request for the 55 files so that he could look through the files in preparation of a proper response, but those files were not availed to him. It is these 55 files that became the subject of Gross misconduct/interdiction and yet the very files (55 files) were not availed to the claimant. That is acknowledged by the respondent in paragraph 9 of the respondent witness statement dated 16th October,2025 by Hemed Eddy. That also came out during the trial and it was therefore common ground on both sides of the “aisle” that the 55 Files, the subject of the dismissal from employment were never availed to the claimant for perusal and to respond to the allegations.
iii. According to counsel, the respondent (employer) was seeking to have its cake and eat it at the same time in the sense that it accused the claimant of grave allegations involving 55 Passport Files and never availed those files to the claimant to peruse and respond and therefore making the process leading to the claimant dismissal procedurally and substantively unfair
iv. In the end, the failure to furnish the Claimant with the 55 files so he could review them and properly prepare his defence was a clear miscarriage of justice. In the case of Regent Management Limited v Wilberforce Ojiambo Oundo [20181 KECA 883 (KLR) the Court of Appeal emphasized the importance of providing copies of the evidence/documents to the employee because it is the only way an employee can prepare their defence and held as follows and we quote:-
“…We are at a loss as to why the appellant refused to grant the respondent certified copies of the documents requested even at his own expense. In our view, these documents were integral to the respondent preparing his defence. By only availing the documents for his perusal at its premises for a number of hours was not adequate. It is also not clear whether the appellant considered the respondent’s appeal….for the reasons outlined above we concur with the learned Judge that the respondent’s dismissal was unfair…”
v. In the case of Walter Ogal Anuro Vs Teachers Service Commission [20131 KEELRC 386(KLR), the court held that for a termination to pass the fairness test, it must be both substantively justified and procedurally fair. The court held thus:-
“…However, for a termination to pass the fairness test, it must be shown that there was not only substantive justification for the termination but also procedural fairness…”
vi. The court has previously underscored the necessity of specificity as observed in the case of Olumbe v Standard Global East Africa Limited I2022IKEELRC 54 (KLR) where the Honorable judge stated as follows
“…It is not difficult to state that the particular misconduct that the Claimant had been found culpable of was not specifically brought forth in the letter. It should be known to employers that it is not enough for an employer to just generally state that the termination has been occasioned by gross misconduct. Specificity of the conduct is imperative for the employee to know what exactly hit him, for gross misconduct can come in many forms and shades…”
vii. According to counsel, the above principles spoke directly to the matter before the court. By altering the number of irregular passports without granting the claimant access to the files to review them, the Respondents effectively ambushed the Claimant and denied him the opportunity to mount a meaningful defence. This conduct violated the principles of natural justice, particularly the rule against condemnation unheard. It was the claimant humble submission that Article 47 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010 guaranteed every person the right to administrative action that was lawful, reasonable and procedurally fair. On the other hand, Article 50 and Article 25(c) of the Constitution of Kenya,2010 safeguards the right to fair hearing.
viii. The respondent argument herein that the claimant “admitted” that he overlooked important procedures, amounts in the claimant’s submissions to “a case of a pot calling the kettle black”. For the record, the initial letter of accusation dated 6th July,2017 was with regards to the 24 Files, but the thrust of the matter that led to the claimant interdiction and dismissal was on the fifty five(55) files and which the respondent witness admitted in court that they did not give to the claimant for perusal and that the respondent witness had no evidence that the claimant was availed the files and that this was the accusation that commenced with the respondent’s letter dated 1st August,2017 to the claimant titled Gross misconduct /interdiction and the subject of interdiction and dismissal of the claimant revolved around fifty five (55) Passport files. It was not about 24 files whose accusation was dated 6th July,2017.
ix. According to counsel, a line has to be drawn in the sand about the allegations and accusation dated the 6th July,2017 which did not lead to any investigation, interdiction and dismissal of the claimant and the accusation dated 1st August,2017 which spiraled and escalated to investigations, interdiction and dismissal. The two were different in terms of allegations and in terms of the number of files but most fundamentally, it thus appear that they cover the same period, something that was not crystal clear from reading the two letters above leaving one with irresistible conclusion that in the totality of the process, the claimant was not treated in accordance with the rules of natural justice and equity and that alone constituted unfair termination of employment.
x. Counsel further submitted that during the hearing, the Claimant was not afforded proper representation. The respondents’ assertion that he was represented by Mr. Isaac Ngaruiya and Mr. James Kinuthia could not amount to adequate or proper representation, as both individuals were co-accused in the same matter and were not representatives of the Claimant’s choosing. In Postal Corporation of Kenva v Andrew K. Tanui |2019|eKLR, the Court of Appeal stated:
“ Four elements must thus be discernible for the procedure to pass muster:
i) an explanation of the grounds of termination in a language understood by the employee;
ii) the reasons for which the employer is considering termination;
iii) entitlement of an employee to another employee of his choice when the explanation of grounds of termination is made.
iv) Hearing and considering any representations made by the
employee and the person chosen by the employee ”
xi. Having submitted that the termination was unfair and unlawful, the claimant prays for relief under section 49 of the employment Act. The claimant therefore prays to this Court for declaratory orders, reinstatement and also for the withheld salary due from the 12th July,2017 up to and including the 26th April,2018 (date of dismissal) and all other withheld salaries up to the date of Judgement to be tabulated by the 1st respondent and paid within 30 days, costs of the claim and interest thereon at court rates until paid in full.
RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS
6. Counsel for the respondent Ms. Mochoge on the other hand submitted among others that:
i. The Respondent’s dismissal of the Claimant was substantively justified and lawful in the circumstances of the case since the Claimant engaged in acts and omissions that amounted to gross misconduct in the performance of his duties as a Chief Immigration Officer, thereby warranting disciplinary action. It was the Respondents’ evidence that by virtue of his position, the Claimant was entrusted with the responsibility of recommending passport applications only after satisfying himself that the applicants had complied with all mandatory requirements, including undergoing the requisite vetting process by the Passport Vetting Committee. The Claimant's role was therefore not merely administrative but was a critical safeguard in the passport Issuance process, ensuring that travel documents were only issued to persons who had satisfied the legal and security requirements.
ii. According to counsel, on 6th July 2017, the Claimant’s supervisor, the Director of Immigration Services, raised concerns regarding the Claimant’s conduct in recommending passport applications for issuance where the applicants had not undergone the mandatory vetting process by the Passport Vetting Committee. The Claimant was required to explain why he recommended applicants for issuance of travel documents before they appeared before the Vetting Committee and why several of the application forms through which the passports were issued lacked crucial details necessary to warrant such issuance.
iii. It was the Respondents submissions that following the said concerns, the Claimant was issued with a Show Cause/lnterdiction letter dated 1st August 2017 requiring him to explain why disciplinary action should not be taken against him. The allegations set out against the Claimant were that between 30th September 2015 and 14th June 2O17, he recommended fifty-five (55) applicants for issuance of passports, some of whom had not been vetted by the Passport Vetting Committee, while others had not fulfilled the requirements for registration as Kenyan citizens before acquiring Kenyan passports. It was also alleged that some of the application forms recommended by the Claimant lacked basic information required for the processing and issuance of passports.
iv. It was the Respondents further submissions that the allegations against the Claimant were not mere procedural lapses but amounted to serious misconduct considering the sensitive nature of the Claimant’s office and the importance of maintaining the integrity of the passport issuance system. The Claimant, being a Chief Immigration Officer, was expected to exercise a high degree of diligence, integrity and professionalism in the execution of his duties. Failure to ensure compliance with mandatory vetting requirements before recommending issuance of passports amounted to a breach of the trust placed upon him by the Respondents and risked the security of the Nation.
v. According to the respondent, the Claimant was accorded an opportunity by his supervisor to clarify and explain the alleged omissions and commissions before any recommendation for disciplinary action was made against him. He was permitted to scrutinize the relevant files forming the basis of the concerns raised. Upon reviewing the said files, the Claimant submitted his response dated 7th July 2017, which was produced in evidence as Exhibit 2 (RD-2). In the said response, the Claimant acknowledged that he had overlooked some important procedures and expressed regret for the omissions and commissions that occurred in the course of performing his official duties. The Respondents therefore submitted that this response was a material consideration in the decision-making process and confirmed that the disciplinary action taken against the Claimant was based on genuine concerns arising from his own conduct and performance of his duties.
vi. Consequently, the decision to interdict and subsequently dismiss the Claimant was not arbitrary, malicious or unlawful but was founded on a valid and reasonable cause arising from the Claimant’s conduct in the performance of his official duties. The disciplinary process was initiated after the Director of Immigration Services reported irregularities in the passport issuance process, and upon consideration of the circumstances surrounding the matter, the Claimant’s conduct was found to amount to gross misconduct. The Respondents submit that they discharged the burden placed upon them under Sections 43 and 45 of the Employment Act by demonstrating that the reasons for termination were valid, fair and related to the Claimant’s conduct, which justified the disciplinary action and eventual dismissal.
vii. Counsel submitted that in Kiago v Roben Aberdare Limited [2026] KEELRC1387 (KLR) the court concurred with the position of Court of Appeal in Kenya Revenue Authority v Reuwel Waithaka Citahi & 2 others [2019] eKLR where it was held that:
“… in employment disputes, the employer is only required to demonstrate the reasons it genuinely believed to exist at the time of termination, and not to prove misconduct beyond reasonable doubt… it is not for the court to substitute its own view of “reasonable grounds" for that of the employer."
It was therefore the Respondents submissions that the Claimant’s misconduct went to the core of his employment obligations and was incompatible with the responsibilities of a Chief Immigration Officer. The issuance of passports was a matter touching on national security and public interest, and the Respondents were entitled to take appropriate disciplinary measures to safeguard the integrity of the process. The dismissal of the Claimant was therefore founded on a valid, fair and lawful reason and the Claimant’s assertion that his termination was unlawful or unfair was without merit and ought to be dismissed.
viii. Concerning the question whether the Respondents followed due process and accorded the Claimant a fair hearing, it was the Respondents submission that the allegation of not being accorded a fair process by the claimant was without basis and was contrary to the evidence presented before the Honourable Court. The Claimant was accorded several opportunities to be heard and to explain himself before the decision to dismiss him was made. On 6th July 2017, the Claimant’s supervisor raised concerns regarding the irregularities noted in the passport applications which the Claimant had recommended for issuance and invited him to explain the said anomalies before recommending any further disciplinary action. The Claimant was granted an opportunity to scrutinize the relevant files forming the basis of the concerns raised and thereafter submitted his response dated 7th July 2017, which was produced in evidence as Exhibit 2 (RD-2). The Respondents further submitted that the Claimant’s allegation that he was not supplied with sufficient particulars or evidence to enable him respond was without merit.
ix. The Claimant was provided with the relevant passport application files for his review and was able to make representations on the issues raised. In his response dated 7th July 2017, the Claimant acknowledged that he may have overlooked important procedures, including instances where applications lacked the required Passport Vetting Committee reports and where he may have recommended applications without making the necessary comments and appending his signature as required. This dearly demonstrates that the Claimant understood the allegations facing him and was able to provide a response. In addition, it was the Respondents submission that the Claimant was subsequently issued with a Notice to Show Cause/interdiction letter dated 1st August 2017 setting out the particulars of the allegations against him and granting him twenty-one (21) days within which to submit his representations. The Claimant did not submit his response within the stipulated period, which lapsed on or about 21st August 2017, nor did he seek an extension of time within which to respond. His subsequent response dated 31st August 2017 was therefore made after the prescribed period had lapsed.
x. The Respondents further submitted that the Claimant was invited to appear before an Investigation Committee on 15th January 2018 where he was granted a further opportunity to make representations regarding the allegations against him. The Claimant therefore was granted an opportunity to participate at various stages of the disciplinary process, including the initial inquiry by his supervisor, Investigations, appearance before the Investigation Committee, and the subsequent appeal and review processes before the Public Service Commission.
xi. The Claimant could not allege that he was denied a fair hearing when the evidence demonstrated that he was Informed of the allegations, allowed to inspect the relevant documents, given opportunities to respond, and participated throughout the disciplinary process. The process undertaken by the Respondents went beyond the minimum requirements of procedural fairness contemplated under Section 41 of the Employment Act. The allegation that there were no clearly framed charges was unfounded. The Notice to Show Cause/interdiction letter clearly set out the allegations that between 30th September 2015 and 14th June 2017, the Claimant recommended fifty- five (55) applicants for issuance of passports, some of whom had not undergone vetting by the Passport Vetting Committee while others had not fulfilled the requirements for registration as Kenyan citizens before acquiring Kenyan passports. The Claimant was therefore fully aware of the allegations he was required to answer. The particulars of the affected applications and the irregularities noted were also provided to him.
xii. It is the Respondents submission that the allegation that the Claimant was not accorded an opportunity to be accompanied by a fellow employee or representative, was not backed by evidence that the Claimant requested to be accompanied by an employee of his choice or a shop floor union representative and that such request was denied. The right under Section 41(1) of the Employment Act is one to be exercised by the employee and does not require an employer to compel representation where the employee has not elected to exercise that right. The Respondents submit that the Claimant was informed of the allegations against him, invited to participate in the disciplinary process, and accorded an opportunity to make representations. The requirements of Section 41 do not transform disciplinary proceedings into a court trial but require notification of the allegations, an opportunity to respond, and consideration of the employee’s representations before a decision is reached. In the case of Carolyne Munala v Hoggers Limited [2018] KEELRC 522 (KLR) the court held as follows:-
“…It is now common knowledge that the claimant herein was given an opportunity vide the employer’s letter dated 28.3.2018 to choose whether to undergo a disciplinary hearing or be served with termination letter. She however declined to undergo the disciplinary hearing as shown by the copy of the letter dated 28.3.2013 she produced as Appendix 6(a). She cannot therefore accuse the employer for dismissing her without according her prior hearing…”
And further in the case of Esha Chlzi Lugogo Vs Pack Kenya [2013]eKLR where Ndolo J cited with approval Jackson Butlya Vs Eastern Produce Limited, where this court held that:
"An employee who squanders the internal grievance handling mechanism provided by an employer cannot come to court and say, "I refused to talk with those people and therefore I was not heard, order them to pay me." It Is not the role of court to supervise the internal grievance handling processes between employers and employees. The role of the court is to ensure that such processes are undertaken within the law."
viii. The Claimant sought reinstatement and payment of withheld salaries. It was the Respondents submission that the remedies sought were not to be granted as a matter of course but were discretionary remedies that must be considered within the circumstances of each particular case. Section 49 of the Employment Act required the Court, in determining appropriate remedies, to consider the circumstances surrounding the termination and whether the relief sought was suitable in the circumstances. According to counsel, reinstatement was an exceptional remedy which could only be granted where it was practical and appropriate to restore the employment relationship. In Kenya Airways Limited v Aviation & Allied Workers Union Kenya & 3 others [2014] KECA 403 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held that reinstatement must be considered cautiously, taking into account the circumstances surrounding termination and the practicality of restoring the employment relationship. Further, in Teachers Service Commission v Kobe [2024] KEELRC 2658 (KLR), the Court held that:-
"The Court finds and returns that the Learned Senior Magistrate fell Into error by issuing orders of reinstatement of the Respondent to employment with the Appellant after lapse of three (3) years from the date of dismissal contrary to the provisions of section I2(j)(vli) of the Employment and Labour Relations Act."
ix. In the present case, the Claimant was dismissed from service on 26th April 2018 following a disciplinary process arising from serious misconduct involving the irregular recommendation of passport applications contrary to established immigration procedures. The Claimant held the position of Chief Immigration Officer, a position that required a high level of integrity, diligence and strict compliance with procedures relating to national security. It Is the Respondents submission that the misconduct went to the core of the employment relationship and resulted in a breakdown of the trust and confidence required for the continued performance of his duties. Further, considering the nature of the misconduct, the sensitive nature of the Claimant’s role, and the considerable period that has elapsed since his dismissal, reinstatement would neither be practical nor in the public interest. Such an order would undermine institutional discipline and interfere with the Respondents’ obligation to safeguard the integrity of the passport issuance process.
x. With regard to the claim for withheld salaries and benefits, the Respondents submit that the same is without basis. Section 70(2) of the Public Service Commission Act provides that a public officer under interdiction is entitled to half basic salary and full house allowance, while other benefits may be withheld pending the conclusion of disciplinary proceedings. Further, Section 70(3) provides that any withheld benefits shall only be restored where the disciplinary or criminal proceedings result in the officer not being dismissed or otherwise punished. In the present case, the disciplinary proceedings against the Claimant culminated in his dismissal from service. Consequently, the statutory requirement for restoration of withheld benefits was not met. The Claimant, having been dismissed following a disciplinary process, ceased to be an employee of the Respondents and was therefore not entitled to payment of salaries or benefits for the period subsequent to dismissal or restoration of benefits withheld during interdiction.
xi. In conclusion counsel submitted that the remedies sought by the Claimant were undeserved and ought to be declined. The Claimant’s employment was lawfully brought to an end following due process, and the Claim ought to be dismissed with costs to the Respondents.
DETERMINATION
7. The claimant herein was terminated from the respondent’s service on 26th April,2018. He disputed the grounds for termination contending among others that initially on the 6th of July 2017, he was accused of recommending 24 applications for passport issuances without proper vetting. Later, on the 1st of August, 2017 the allegations were escalated to 55 passports, doubling the scope of the alleged passport applications and this later accusation of 55 passports applications ultimately formed the basis of the claimant’s interdiction on the 1st August,2017 and dismissal via the dismissal letter dated the 26th of April,2018. According to Counsel, this shifting of allegations was not a mere error but a substantive and a procedural matter that went to the very root of fairness. The claimant further contended that when he received another letter to show cause/interdiction dated 1st of August 2017 the accusation was that he recommended 55 applicants for issuance of passports spanning a different period contrary to the initial allegation of 24 Passport applications. No explanation was tendered before the court to help the court ascertain whether the 55 files were entirely new files, different from the initial 24 or were an addition to the 24 files. The claimant further complained that he wrote to request for the 55 files so that he could look through the files in preparation of a proper response, but those files were not availed to him. The sum total of the claimant’s disputing the reason for termination was that he was never provided with the 55 files which informed his interdiction and eventual termination to ascertain if the initial 24 files were included in the 55 or they comprised of additional files to the 24.
8. Regarding the procedure for termination, the claimant contended that during the hearing, he was not afforded proper representation. The respondents’ assertion that he was represented by Mr. Isaac Ngaruiya and Mr. James Kinuthia could not amount to adequate or proper representation, as both individuals were co-accused in the same matter and were not his representatives of choosing.
9. The respondent on the other had justified the termination on the grounds inter alia that it followed due process and accorded the Claimant a fair hearing. The Claimant was accorded several opportunities to be heard and to explain himself before the decision to dismiss him was made. On 6th July 2017, the Claimant’s supervisor raised concerns regarding the irregularities noted in the passport applications which the Claimant had recommended for issuance and invited him to explain the said anomalies before recommending any further disciplinary action. The Claimant was granted an opportunity to scrutinize the relevant files forming the basis of the concerns raised and thereafter submitted his response dated 7th July 2017, which was produced in evidence as Exhibit 2 (RD-2). Further, the Claimant was provided with the relevant passport application files for his review and was able to make representations on the issues raised. In his response dated 7th July 2017, the Claimant acknowledged that he may have overlooked important procedures, including instances where applications lacked the required Passport Vetting Committee reports and where he may have recommended applications without making the necessary comments and appending his signature as required. The claimant however blamed pressure of work but according to the respondent, the forgoing clearly demonstrated that the Claimant understood the allegations facing him and was able to provide a response.
10. Regarding the procedure prior to termination, the respondent stated that the Claimant was subsequently issued with a Notice to Show Cause/interdiction letter dated 1st August 2017 setting out the particulars of the allegations against him and granting him twenty-one (21) days within which to submit his representations. The Claimant did not submit his response within the stipulated period, which lapsed on or about 21st August 2017, nor did he seek an extension of time within which to respond. His subsequent response dated 31st August 2017 was therefore made after the prescribed period had lapsed.
11. The Court has considered either side’s contention and considers the main issues to be determined in this claim are whether the grounds proffered by the respondent in terminating the claimant’s service met the threshold set under section 43 of the Employment Act and existing case law. Secondly whether the respondent in carrying out the termination adhered to the provisions as set out under section 41 of the Employment Act and rules of natural justice generally. As a corollary, should the court reach the conclusion that the respondent failed to prove and or justify the reasons for termination of the claimant’s service as required of it under section 47(5) of the Employment Act, what remedies are the claimant entitled to and finally which party should bear the costs of the suit.
12. Under section 43 of the Employment Act, in any claim arising out of termination of a contract, the employer shall be required to prove the reason or reasons for the termination, and where the employer fails to do so, the termination shall be deemed to have been unfair within the meaning of section 45(2) of the Act. Further, the reason or reasons for termination of a contract are the matters that the employer at the time of termination of the contract genuinely believed to exist, and which caused the employer to terminate the services of the employee. This Court has held in several cases that it is not within its jurisdiction to conduct a near forensic audit of the reasons for termination of service of an employee. In the often-quoted case of British Leyland UK Ltd v. Swift [1981] IRLR 91, Lord Dening stated as follows:-
Further in the case of Kenya Revenue Authority Vs Menginya Salim Murgani, Civil Appeal No. 108 of 2009 as cited in Republic Vs National Police Service Commission Exparte Daniel Chacha JR 36 of 2016 (2016) eKLR-“ Justice (Prof) Ojwang’ stated that: -
“…There is ample authority that decision making bodies other than courts and bodies whose procedures are laid down by statute are masters of their own procedures. Provided that they achieve the degree of fairness appropriate to their tasks. It is for them to decide how they will proceed”
13. The foregoing having been outlined and considering the reasons proffered by the respondent for terminating the claimant’s service, the court now seeks to interrogate if the reasons met the threshold of the above cited caselaw. As observed, the claimant was accused of recommending 24 applications for passport issuances without proper vetting. Later, on the 1st of August, 2017 the allegations were escalated to 55 passports. The claimant has taken issue with the increase in the numbers and contended that not having been provided with the copies of the escalated files, he was unable to establish whether the 55 included the 24 he was earlier accused of recommending for approval or was a new batch altogether or included the initial 24. The claimant however is on record as having through his letter dated 7th July 2017 acknowledging that he may have overlooked important procedures, including instances where applications lacked the required Passport Vetting Committee reports and where he may have recommended applications without making the necessary comments and appending his signature as required. This seems to the court to be the main issue in the matter and not the number of files involved. It could be one file, twenty-four or fifty-five but that may not matter much if recommending a file for passport issuance without proper vetting was impermissible under the respondent’s operating procedures. That is to say, it was not the volume or number of times the infraction was committed that mattered, but the seriousness attached by the employer to the omission or infraction by the employee.
14. To the above extent the court is persuaded that the respondent had valid and justifiable reasons for terminating the service of the claimant. The allegation of unfair termination is therefore found without merit and is hereby dismissed.
15. Regarding the procedure followed prior to the termination, the notice to Show Cause/interdiction letter dated 1st August 2017 set out the particulars of the allegations against the claimant and granted him twenty-one (21) days within which to submit his representations. The Claimant did not submit his response within the stipulated period, which lapsed on or about 21st August 2017, he did not seek an extension of time within which to respond. His subsequent response dated 31st August 2017 was therefore made after the prescribed period had lapsed. The Respondent subsequently invited the claimant to appear before an Investigation Committee on 15th January 2018 where he was granted a further opportunity to make representations regarding the allegations against him. From the foregoing, the court is also persuaded that the Claimant was granted opportunity to participate at various stages of the disciplinary process, including the initial inquiry by his supervisor, Investigations, appearance before the Investigation Committee, and the subsequent appeal and review processes before the Public Service Commission. The procedural requirements under section 41 of the Act were therefore sufficiently met.
16. Regarding payment of the balance of the half salary withheld during interdiction, as rightly submitted by counsel for the respondent, this is only payable where the disciplinary or criminal proceedings result in the officer not being dismissed or otherwise punished. This is in line with the provisions of section 70(2) of the Public Service Commission Act. This claim is therefore unsustainable and is hereby disallowed. Concerning prayer for reinstatement, in view of the reasons for which the claimant was dismissed, which in the court’s view quite serious and as rightly submitted by counsel for the respondent, bordered on threat to national security and the fact that it has been more than eight years since the termination of the claimant’s service, reinstatement would not have been an appropriate remedy in the circumstances even if the court were to find the termination unfair.
17. In conclusion, the court finds the claim herein without merit and is hereby dismissed with costs.
18. It is so ordered.
Dated at Nairobi this 30th day of October 2026
Delivered virtually this 30th day of October 2026
Abuodha Nelson Jorum
Presiding Judge-Mombasa ELRC