Employment law

Nairobi East Hospital Ltd v Jaldesa [2026] KEELRC 14926 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
30 October 2026

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

Appeal allowed. The Court held the ex parte judgment irregular for want of service of the suit and summons; set aside the magistrate’s ruling and order dismissing the appellant’s motion; allowed that motion; remitted the matter for a fresh hearing before another competent magistrate; granted leave to file a response out of time and deemed the memorandum of appearance properly filed. Costs of the appeal were awarded to the appellant.

Supporting judgment passages

38. The appeal is allowed. The judgment of the trial court is held as irregular for want of service of the suit and summons upon the appellant.

Paragraph 38 →

a) The court sets aside in its entirety the Ruling and order of Hon. D.O. Mbeja (SPM), delivered on 27th November, 2025, in Milimani MCELRC/E1590/2023; and substitutes it with an order allowing the Appellant's Notice of Motion dated the 29th of September, 2025 as prayed;

Passage 116 →

b) The case is remitted back to the trial court for hearing afresh, with leave being granted to the appellant to file a response out of time, and further, the filed memorandum of appearance is deemed proper. The Court orders the suit be heard by any magistrate with jurisdiction other than Hon. D.O. Mbeja

Passage 117 →
Issue 1Whether the Respondent effected proper service of the Summons to Enter Appearance and the initial pleadings upon the Appellant herein.

Held. No. The purported affidavit concerned mention notices rather than the suit, summons, and supporting documents; it was sworn by Cynthia Kwamboka rather than the process server who purported to depone to its contents. It was incompetent and did not prove service. The record therefore established no valid service.

Ratio. An ex parte hearing under Order 12 rule 2 requires proof that notice was duly served. Where the record does not prove service of the suit and summons, an ex parte judgment is irregular and the affected party’s right to a fair hearing is violated.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

i. Whether the Respondent effected proper service of the Summons to Enter Appearance and the initial pleadings upon the Appellant herein.

Passage 60 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

34. A perusal of the affidavit of service of 4th December 2023(reproduced above before the trial court indicates it was by JAIRUS KATERE SHAMALA, who stated he was a process server. At paragraph 2, he states he was given mention notices by Kwamboka Marie & Associates dated 4th December 2023. There is no mention of the suit , summons and supporting documents. At this point, the court ought to have found there was no proof of service of the suit on the appellant. The court further found the affidavit was not sworn by Jairus but by a stranger namely Cynthia Kwamboka. The court holds that before the court was an incompetent affidavit and further there was no proof of service.

Paragraph 34 →

36. The record before the court established that there was no valid service as alleged and, of course, the court has, on re-evaluation of evidence, established the alleged affidavit of service was not an affidavit in the first place. The process server did not depone on the affidavit, but the deponent was a stranger. It was held in Mbogo V Shah [1968] EA Page 93 -

Paragraph 36 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

37. The court finds that the trial court erred in law and fact by failing to find that there was no service of the suit, and thus the judgment was irregular. The court finds that it has established a sound basis to interfere with the discretion of the trial court . I find no need to delve into whether there were triable issues, as it is a cardinal principle of natural justice that no one shall be condemned unheard, which right is guaranteed under the Constitution as the right to a fair hearing under Article 50. The trial court could only proceed under Order 12, Rule of the Civil Procedure Rules. There was no proof of service of the suit. The trial court violated the appellant's right to fair hearing. This was an irregular judgment. If the judgment was regular, I would have found that there was a draft defence (at pages 75-78 of ROA) disclosing triable issues of fact, namely that the employment had lapsed by effluxion of time rather than by termination. I would have found that any prejudice suffered by the respondent could have been addressed by awarding costs and allowing the case to be defended.

Paragraph 37 →
Issue 2Whether the Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact when he dismissed the Appellant’s Application dated 29th of September, 2025.

Held. Yes. The magistrate erred by treating the judgment as regular and dismissing the application despite the absence of proof of service. The appellate court found a sound basis to interfere with that exercise of discretion and allowed the appellant’s application to set aside and reopen the matter.

Ratio. An appellate court may interfere with a lower court’s discretionary decision where the lower court misdirected itself or failed to consider material matters and thereby reached a wrong conclusion. Here, the magistrate failed to recognize that there was no proof of service, resulting in an irregular judgment and denial of fair hearing.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

ii. Whether the Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact when he dismissed the Appellant’s Application dated 29th of September, 2025.

Passage 61 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

37. The court finds that the trial court erred in law and fact by failing to find that there was no service of the suit, and thus the judgment was irregular. The court finds that it has established a sound basis to interfere with the discretion of the trial court . I find no need to delve into whether there were triable issues, as it is a cardinal principle of natural justice that no one shall be condemned unheard, which right is guaranteed under the Constitution as the right to a fair hearing under Article 50. The trial court could only proceed under Order 12, Rule of the Civil Procedure Rules. There was no proof of service of the suit. The trial court violated the appellant's right to fair hearing. This was an irregular judgment. If the judgment was regular, I would have found that there was a draft defence (at pages 75-78 of ROA) disclosing triable issues of fact, namely that the employment had lapsed by effluxion of time rather than by termination. I would have found that any prejudice suffered by the respondent could have been addressed by awarding costs and allowing the case to be defended.

Paragraph 37 →

a) The court sets aside in its entirety the Ruling and order of Hon. D.O. Mbeja (SPM), delivered on 27th November, 2025, in Milimani MCELRC/E1590/2023; and substitutes it with an order allowing the Appellant's Notice of Motion dated the 29th of September, 2025 as prayed;

Passage 116 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

“I think it is well settled that this court will not interfere with the exercise of its discretion by an inferior court unless it is satisfied that its decision is clearly wrong, because it has misdirected itself or because it has acted on matters on which it should not have acted or because it has failed to take into consideration matters which it should have taken into consideration and in doing so arrived at a wrong conclusion.’’

Passage 112 →

37. The court finds that the trial court erred in law and fact by failing to find that there was no service of the suit, and thus the judgment was irregular. The court finds that it has established a sound basis to interfere with the discretion of the trial court . I find no need to delve into whether there were triable issues, as it is a cardinal principle of natural justice that no one shall be condemned unheard, which right is guaranteed under the Constitution as the right to a fair hearing under Article 50. The trial court could only proceed under Order 12, Rule of the Civil Procedure Rules. There was no proof of service of the suit. The trial court violated the appellant's right to fair hearing. This was an irregular judgment. If the judgment was regular, I would have found that there was a draft defence (at pages 75-78 of ROA) disclosing triable issues of fact, namely that the employment had lapsed by effluxion of time rather than by termination. I would have found that any prejudice suffered by the respondent could have been addressed by awarding costs and allowing the case to be defended.

Paragraph 37 →
Issue 3Whether the ruling and order of Hon. D.O. Mbeja (SPM), delivered on the 27th of November, 2025, in Milimani MCELRC/E1590/2023 should therefore be set aside.

Held. Yes. The ruling and order were set aside in their entirety and replaced with an order allowing the appellant’s 29 September 2025 motion. The case was remitted for hearing afresh before a magistrate other than Hon. D.O. Mbeja; the appellant received leave to file its response out of time and its memorandum of appearance was deemed properly on record.

Ratio. Because the ex parte judgment was irregular for want of service, it could not stand. The Court did not determine whether the draft defence raised triable issues, as the absence of service and resulting denial of a fair hearing was dispositive.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

iii. Whether the ruling and order of Hon. D.O. Mbeja (SPM), delivered on the 27th of November, 2025, in Milimani MCELRC/E1590/2023 should therefore be set aside.

Passage 62 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

38. The appeal is allowed. The judgment of the trial court is held as irregular for want of service of the suit and summons upon the appellant.

Paragraph 38 →

a) The court sets aside in its entirety the Ruling and order of Hon. D.O. Mbeja (SPM), delivered on 27th November, 2025, in Milimani MCELRC/E1590/2023; and substitutes it with an order allowing the Appellant's Notice of Motion dated the 29th of September, 2025 as prayed;

Passage 116 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

37. The court finds that the trial court erred in law and fact by failing to find that there was no service of the suit, and thus the judgment was irregular. The court finds that it has established a sound basis to interfere with the discretion of the trial court . I find no need to delve into whether there were triable issues, as it is a cardinal principle of natural justice that no one shall be condemned unheard, which right is guaranteed under the Constitution as the right to a fair hearing under Article 50. The trial court could only proceed under Order 12, Rule of the Civil Procedure Rules. There was no proof of service of the suit. The trial court violated the appellant's right to fair hearing. This was an irregular judgment. If the judgment was regular, I would have found that there was a draft defence (at pages 75-78 of ROA) disclosing triable issues of fact, namely that the employment had lapsed by effluxion of time rather than by termination. I would have found that any prejudice suffered by the respondent could have been addressed by awarding costs and allowing the case to be defended.

Paragraph 37 →
Issue 4Who bears the costs.

Held. The appellant was awarded the costs of the appeal.

Ratio. No separate legal rule is necessary for this finding. The Court made a costs order without separate reasoning.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

iv. Who bears the costs.

Passage 63 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

c) Costs of the appeal to the Appellant.

Passage 118 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Appellant herein, being dissatisfied with the Ruling and Orders of the Hon. D. O. Mbeja (SPM) delivered on 27th November, 2025 in Nairobi MCELRC E1590 of 2023 between the parties filed a memorandum of appeal dated the 2nd of December 2025 seeking the following orders:-

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The court discerned the following were the issues for determination in the appeal, taking into account the grounds of appeal -

Paragraph 21 →

Decision / orders

The appeal is allowed. The judgment of the trial court is held as irregular for want of service of the suit and summons upon the appellant.

Paragraph 38 →

Reasoning passage

A perusal of the affidavit of service of 4th December 2023(reproduced above before the trial court indicates it was by JAIRUS KATERE SHAMALA, who stated he was a process server. At paragraph 2, he states he was given mention notices by Kwamboka Marie & Associates dated 4th December 2023. There is no mention of the suit , summons and supporting documents. At this point, the court ought to have found there was no proof of service of the…

Paragraph 34 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the respondent proved proper service of the summons to enter appearance and initial pleadings on the appellant; whether the magistrate erred in dismissing the appellant’s 29 September 2025 application to set aside the ex parte proceedings and…

Material facts

Rahma Jaldesa filed a memorandum of claim dated 30 August 2023 alleging unfair termination and seeking terminal dues, interest, a certificate of service, costs, and further relief. Following Nairobi East Hospital Ltd’s non-appearance, the magistrate entered…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

ELRC APPEAL NUMBER E418 OF 2025

NAIROBI EAST HOSPITAL LTD……………………….….....................................................................APPELLANT

-VERSUS

RAHMA JALDESA……………...........................................................................................................RESPONDENT

(Being an Appeal from the Ruling and Orders of the Hon. D. O. Mbeja (SPM) delivered on 27th November, 2025 in Nairobi MCELRC E1590 of 2023)

CORAM

Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli

C/A Otieno

JUDGMENT

1. The Appellant herein, being dissatisfied with the Ruling and Orders of the Hon. D. O. Mbeja (SPM) delivered on 27th November, 2025 in Nairobi MCELRC E1590 of 2023 between the parties filed a memorandum of appeal dated the 2nd of December 2025 seeking the following orders:-

a) Allow this Appeal.

b) Set aside in its entirety the Ruling and order of Hon. D.O. Mbeja (SPM), delivered on 27th November, 2025, in Milimani MCELRC/E1590/2023;

c) Substitute therefore an order allowing the Appellant's Notice of Motion dated the 29th of September, 2025 as prayed;

d) In the alternative and without prejudice to the foregoing, direct that the suit in Milimani MCELRC/E1590/2023 be reallocated to another Magistrate for purposes of being heard de novo;

e) Grant such further or other orders as the Court may deem just and expedient in the circumstances; and

f) Award costs of this appeal and of the proceedings in the lower court to the Appellant.

g) The Ruling and Orders issued in Nairobi CMELR Cause No. E1085 of 2023, be set aside and the suit against the Appellant be dismissed with costs.

GROUNDS OF THE APPEAL

2. The Honourable Trial Magistrate erred in law and in fact by failing to appreciate that the Appellant was never served with the Statement of Claim, Summons to Enter Appearance, or any pleadings, thereby condemning the Appellant herein unheard and in violation of Articles 25(c), 47 and 50 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010 guaranteeing a fair hearing.

3. The Honourable Trial Magistrate erred in law and fact in finding and or assuming that service had been properly effected despite clear discrepancies and lack of acknowledgment in the purported affidavit of service on record.

4. The Honourable Trial Magistrate erred in law and fact in upholding that proper service of the Statement of Claim and the Summons to Enter Appearance was effected when no evidence had been produced by the Respondent herein to affirm the said position.

5. The Honourable Trial Magistrate erred in law and fact when he relied on an Affidavit of Service sworn by a Process Server namely JAIRUS KATERE SHAMALA and signed by the Advocate namely CYNTHIA KWAMBOKA despite the fact that the said Affidavit did not even disclose to whom the pleadings were served if at all.

6. The Honourable Trial Magistrate erred in law and in fact in dismissing the Appellant's Application on the basis that the ex-parte judgment was regular without considering the fact that the alleged service was defective and that the judgment was therefore irregular and void ab initio.

7. The Honourable Trial Magistrate erred in law and in fact by holding that no sufficient reason had been shown, notwithstanding evidence that the judgment had been obtained ex parte without affording the Appellant an opportunity to defend itself.

8. The Honourable Trial Magistrate erred in law by failing to apply the guiding principles on setting aside ex parte judgments, particularly that a party denied a hearing through lack of service should be entitled to unconditional leave to defend.

9. The Honourable Trial Magistrate misdirected himself by considering irrelevant matters and failing to exercise judicial discretion to prevent abuse of court process and injustice arising from execution of an irregular decree.

10. The Honourable Trial Magistrate erred in law and fact in failing to appreciate that the Appellant had demonstrated sufficient cause for stay of execution, including ongoing hospital operations serving the public interest, and that irreparable harm would result if execution proceeded.

11. The ruling and order are against the weight of the evidence, the law, and the interests of justice.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

12. The Claimant/Respondent filed suit vide a memorandum of claim dated 30th August 2023 seeking the following reliefs against the Appellant:-

a) A declaration be made that the claimant's termination was unfair by dint of the same failing to comply with the ambits of the Employment Act, 2007 and other labour laws.

b) The Claimant be paid terminal dues and accrued employment benefits as duly tabulated at paragraph 8 of the submissions.

c) The Respondent to pay interest on the total sum of claims.

d) The claimant herein be issued with a certificate of service.

e) The Claimant be awarded costs of the case.

f) The court may grant any further relief as it may deem necessary to grant.

(statement of claim and accompanying documents on pages 12-35 of ROA dated 20th April 2026).

13. Following a failure of the Appellant/Respondent to enter an appearance and file a defence, the Honourable Trial Magistrate delivered an ex parte judgment in favour of the Claimant/Respondent on 24th April 2025 (pages 49-53 of ROA).

14. The Appellant subsequently filed a Notice of Motion dated 29th September 2025, seeking the following orders:-

i. Spent

ii. That this Honourable Court be pleased to grant a stay of execution of the decree flowing from the ex-parte Judgement delivered on the 24th of April, 2025 by HON. D.O. MBEJA (SPM) pending the hearing and determination of this Application.

iii. THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to grant leave to the Applicant herein to enter appearance out of time and subsequently deem the Memorandum of Appearance filed on the 26th of September, 2025 as being properly on record.

iv. THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to issue an injunction restraining the Claimant/Decree Holder whether by herself or through her agents, servants, employees or anyone claiming through or deriving authority from her from proclaiming, attaching and or removing from the Applicant's premises and selling any property.

v. THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to set aside the ex-parte proceedings and the ex-parte Judgment entered on the 24th of April, 2025 and have the suit be heard de-novo.

vi. THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to grant leave to the Applicant herein to file the Reply to the Statement of Claim out of time.

vii. THAT the Honourable Court be pleased to reopen the case and have the matter be heard de novo and determined on merits.

viii. THAT costs of this Application be in the cause.

15. In support of the notice of motion application, the Appellant/Respondent filed a supporting affidavit sworn by DR. MOHAMED GIRAD SALAT on 29th September 2025 together with the annexures thereto (pages 57-72 of ROA).

16. The Respondent herein responded to the application dated 29th September 2025 vide a Replying Affidavit sworn on 14th October 2025 (pages 85-89 of ROA). She argued that the impugned judgment of the court was regular and proper for the reason that the Appellant was duly and personally served with the Statement of Claim and Summons to Enter Appearance on

4th December 2023 and again on 13th December 2023 at its registered offices at Nairobi East Hospital Ltd. She confirmed that the said documents were received, stamped, and acknowledged by the Appellant’s authorized representative. The Claimant/Respondent then filed an Affidavit of Service in court as proof of service. It was the Claimant/Respondent’s case that the Appellant ignored, neglected and/or wilfully declined to enter appearance or file any response within the statutory period. The Claimant/Respondent was adamant that the Appellant was guilty of indolence/laches and should receive the benefit of equity. Finally, the Claimant/Respondent criticized the Appellant’s "draft reply to the statement of claim" annexed to their application as being a mere sham, hollow and devoid of triable issues. She took the view that it could not justify reopening a case that was duly and regularly concluded on merit.

17. To counter the Claimant/Respondent’s averments, the Appellant filed a Further Affidavit sworn on 29th October 2025 by the same deponent as its Supporting Affidavit (pages 90-93 of ROA).

18. The court issued directions that the Notice of Motion dated 29th September 2025 be disposed of by way of written submissions, and the parties complied (pages 94-135 and 140-144 of ROA).

19. The Trial Magistrate Court delivered its ruling on the 27th of November 2025, dismissing the Appellant’s Notice of Motion dated 29th September 2025 for the reason that there was affidavit evidence that the Appellant was properly served with all the court documents but ignored them and failed to enter appearance, hence the judgment was regular (ruling at pages 145-149 of ROA).

DETERMINATION

20. The appeal was canvassed by way of written submissions. Both parties filed.

Issues for determination

21. The court discerned the following were the issues for determination in the appeal, taking into account the grounds of appeal -

i. Whether the Respondent effected proper service of the Summons to Enter Appearance and the initial pleadings upon the Appellant herein.

ii. Whether the Learned Magistrate erred in law and fact when he dismissed the Appellant’s Application dated 29th of September, 2025.

iii. Whether the ruling and order of Hon. D.O. Mbeja (SPM), delivered on the 27th of November, 2025, in Milimani MCELRC/E1590/2023 should therefore be set aside.

iv. Who bears the costs.

The law

22. The Civil Procedure Rules, Order 12, Rule 2 provides –

‘When only plaintiff attends [Order 12, rule 2]

If on the day fixed for hearing, after the suit has been called on for hearing outside the court, only the plaintiff attends, if the court is satisfied—

(a) that notice of hearing was duly served, it may proceed ex parte;

(b) that notice of hearing was not duly served, it shall direct a second notice to be served; or

(c) that notice was not served in sufficient time for the defendant to attend or that for other sufficient cause the defendant was unable to attend, it shall postpone the hearing.’

23. This being a first appellate court, it was held in Selle v Associated Motor Boat Co. [1968] EA 123 that:- “The appellate court is not bound necessarily to accept the findings of fact by the court below. An appeal to the Court of Appeal from a trial by the High Court is by way of a retrial and the principles upon which the Court of Appeal acts are that the court must reconsider the evidence, evaluate it itself and draw its own conclusions though it should always bear in mind that it has neither seen nor heard the witnesses and should make due allowance in this respect. In particular the court is not bound necessarily to follow the trial Judge’s findings of fact if it appears either that he has clearly failed on some point to take account of particular circumstances or probabilities materially to estimate the evidence or if the impression based on the demeanor of a witness is inconsistent with the evidence in the case generally.”

24. Further in on principles for appeal decisions in Mbogo V Shah [1968] EA Page 93 it was observed -

“I think it is well settled that this court will not interfere with the exercise of its discretion by an inferior court unless it is satisfied that its decision is clearly wrong, because it has misdirected itself or because it has acted on matters on which it should not have acted or because it has failed to take into consideration matters which it should have taken into consideration and in doing so arrived at a wrong conclusion.’’

Whether the Respondent effected proper service of the Summons to Enter Appearance and the initial pleadings upon the Appellant herein.

25. A default judgment dated 24th April 2025 was entered by the trial court following non- appearance by the respondent. (Judgment at pages 37-53 of the ROA).

26. The appellant entered appearance dated 26th September 2025 post the judgment and filed application under certificate of urgency dated 29th September 2025 with application by way of notice of motion of even date and sought stay of execution of the judgment dated 24th April 2025. It also sought leave to enter appearance out of time and deem the memorandum of appearance filed as properly on record. The appellant further sought for the trial court to set aside the proceedings and the default judgment of 24th April 2025 and to have the suit heard de novo. It also sought leave to file a response to the suit out of time. The crux of the application was that the suit pleadings had never been served and that the appellant had a triable defence vide draft annexed in supporting affidavit. (The draft response is at pages 75-78 of the ROA).

27. The application was opposed by the respondent vide his affidavit dated 14th October 2025. On the issue of service of the suit and summons, he stated in paragraph 3 -

‘3. THAT the Respondent/Applicant was duly and personally served with the Statement of Claim and Summons to Enter Appearance on 4th December 2023 and again on 13th December 2023 at its registered offices at Nairobi East Hospital Ltd. The said service was duly received, stamped, and acknowledged by its authorized representative. A duly commissioned Affidavit of Service to that effect is on record, confirming regular and proper service as required under Order 5 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010 and Rule 13(1) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2016.’

28. The respondent had no annexure of the affidavit of service alleged to have been effected on 4th December 2023.

29. The appellant filed a further affidavit by DR. MOHAMED GIRAD SALAT dated 29th October 2025 and stated that though the Claimant claims in Paragraph 3 that the Respondent was duly and personally served with the Statement of Claim and the Summons to Enter Appearance on the 4th of December, 2023 and on the 13th of December, 2023 and that the said documents were allegedly stamped and acknowledged by the Respondent's Authorized Representative, no evidence has been brought forth to affirm the aforesaid position. In any event and without prejudice to the above, I am advised by our Advocates on record which advice I verily believe that the only Affidavit of Service that is in the CTS, filed by the Claimant herein, is the Affidavit dated the 4th of December, 2023. Reference is made to Annexure MGS7 attached to the Supporting Affidavit dated the 29th of September, 2025. The aforesaid Affidavit of Service is irregular as the same is sworn by a Process Server namely JAIRUS KATERE SHAMALA but it is signed by the Claimant's Advocate namely CYNTHIA KWAMBОКА.

30. The said affidavit of service dated 4th December 2023 of alleged service was annexed to the application (see page 36 of ROA). It was by by a Process Server namely JAIRUS KATERE SHAMALA but it is signed /sworn by one CYNTHIA KWAMBОКА.

31. The trial court delivered its decision on the 27th November 2025 and dismissed the application. The court held as follows-

‘The applicant in the instant suit guided by affidavit evidence so far on record was served with all necessary court papers and pleadings but ignored them which is rather unfortunate. The applicant failed to enter appearance within the prescribed time having been duly served with summons. The ex parte judgment is regular and this court is satisfied as to service. In the circumstances having considered the special circumstances of the application before court I find that no sufficient cause has been demonstrated by the applicant for grant of the orders sought all circumstances considered. The Court of Appeal has held in Trust Bank Limited -vs- Amalo Co. Ltd, (2002) eKlr that parties to a suit are entitled to be heard on the documents presented before court and on record. In view of the foregoing, I hold in the result that the application before court is devoid of merit and I am not inclined to allow the application. On the same wavelength, the application dated 26/9/2025 is dismissed with costs all circumstances considered. Parties at liberty to apply.’’

32. In essence the trial court held the judgment as regular based on the affidavit of service on record. The service was alleged to have been effected on 4th December 2023. Before the court was affidavit of even date which is reproduced below-

‘AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE

I, JAIRUS KATERE SHAMALA, of P.O Box Number 102427-00101 Nairobi, a licensed court process server do make oath and state as follows;-

1. THAT I am a licensed process server, hence competent to swear this affidavit.

2. THAT on 4th December 2023, I received from the firm of Kwamboka Marie & Associates mention notices dated 4th December 2023.

3. THAT I proceeded to the Respondent's premises at Nairobi East Hospital, introduced myself at the reception.

4. THAT the mention notices were not received by the receptionist, who claimed that she was not authorized to receive documents.

5. THAT I now return the same to this Honourable Court duly served and not received copy of the mention notice.

6. THAT all that is sworn to herein is true to the best of my knowledge, information and belief.

SWORN by the said

CYNTHIA KWAMBOKA

AT NAIROBI THIS 4th DAY OF December 2023….’(page 36 OF ROA)

33. The relevant applicable procedure for regular ex parte hearing is Order 12, rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules. A court may proceed with an ex parte hearing in the absence of the respondent on proof of service. It states-

‘When only plaintiff attends [Order 12, rule 2]

If on the day fixed for hearing, after the suit has been called on for hearing outside the court, only the plaintiff attends, if the court is satisfied—

(a) that notice of hearing was duly served, it may proceed ex parte;

(b) that notice of hearing was not duly served, it shall direct a second notice to be served; or

(c) that notice was not served in sufficient time for the defendant to attend or that for other sufficient cause the defendant was unable to attend, it shall postpone the hearing.’

34. A perusal of the affidavit of service of 4th December 2023(reproduced above before the trial court indicates it was by JAIRUS KATERE SHAMALA, who stated he was a process server. At paragraph 2, he states he was given mention notices by Kwamboka Marie & Associates dated 4th December 2023. There is no mention of the suit , summons and supporting documents. At this point, the court ought to have found there was no proof of service of the suit on the appellant. The court further found the affidavit was not sworn by Jairus but by a stranger namely Cynthia Kwamboka. The court holds that before the court was an incompetent affidavit and further there was no proof of service.

35. The court noted as per the typed proceedings, it is recorded as follows-

‘4/12/2023

Before; Hon Wangari Mbulikah (PM)

Court Ass; Edward Kwamboka for Claimant

Respondent; No appearance

Kwamboka;

Pray for a further mention date to effect service. Mention 6/5/2024

HON W. MBULIKAH P.M.’’(PAGE 150 OF ROA)

36. The record before the court established that there was no valid service as alleged and, of course, the court has, on re-evaluation of evidence, established the alleged affidavit of service was not an affidavit in the first place. The process server did not depone on the affidavit, but the deponent was a stranger. It was held in Mbogo V Shah [1968] EA Page 93 -

“I think it is well settled that this court will not interfere with the exercise of its discretion by an inferior court unless it is satisfied that its decision is clearly wrong, because it has misdirected itself or because it has acted on matters on which it should not have acted or because it has failed to take into consideration matters which it should have taken into consideration and in doing so arrived at a wrong conclusion.’’

37. The court finds that the trial court erred in law and fact by failing to find that there was no service of the suit, and thus the judgment was irregular. The court finds that it has established a sound basis to interfere with the discretion of the trial court . I find no need to delve into whether there were triable issues, as it is a cardinal principle of natural justice that no one shall be condemned unheard, which right is guaranteed under the Constitution as the right to a fair hearing under Article 50. The trial court could only proceed under Order 12, Rule of the Civil Procedure Rules. There was no proof of service of the suit. The trial court violated the appellant's right to fair hearing. This was an irregular judgment. If the judgment was regular, I would have found that there was a draft defence (at pages 75-78 of ROA) disclosing triable issues of fact, namely that the employment had lapsed by effluxion of time rather than by termination. I would have found that any prejudice suffered by the respondent could have been addressed by awarding costs and allowing the case to be defended.

Disposition

38. The appeal is allowed. The judgment of the trial court is held as irregular for want of service of the suit and summons upon the appellant.

a) The court sets aside in its entirety the Ruling and order of Hon. D.O. Mbeja (SPM), delivered on 27th November, 2025, in Milimani MCELRC/E1590/2023; and substitutes it with an order allowing the Appellant's Notice of Motion dated the 29th of September, 2025 as prayed;

b) The case is remitted back to the trial court for hearing afresh, with leave being granted to the appellant to file a response out of time, and further, the filed memorandum of appearance is deemed proper. The Court orders the suit be heard by any magistrate with jurisdiction other than Hon. D.O. Mbeja

c) Costs of the appeal to the Appellant.

39. It is so Ordered.

DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT MACHAKOS THIS 30TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

JEMIMAH KELI,

JUDGE

IN THE PRESENCE OF:

Court Assistant: Otieno

Appellant – Ms Lusweti

Respondent-Ms Kwamboka