Background
The plaintiff, by an application dated 26.3.2025, seeks orders that:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
The application was declined in its entirety. Julius Njoroge was not joined after final judgment; the requested stay/status quo and review were declined. There was no order as to costs, and the file was marked closed.
56. Given that the Court has declined to join the applicant to this finalised matter and in view of the parallel pending application against the applicant, the prayers in this application are declined in their entirety with no order as to costs. File marked closed.
Paragraph 56 →
Held. Denied. Although Njoroge showed a direct and tangible asserted interest in the property sufficient in substance to warrant participation, the suit had already been finally determined. The court therefore declined post-judgment joinder.
Ratio. Order 1 Rule 10(2) contemplates joinder in pending proceedings. Once a suit has been fully heard, determined and resolved, there is nothing remaining in which to join a party and the joinder rule is inapplicable.
Issue
34. What the applicant is seeking, however, is to join the suit post-judgment. Courts have held that addition of parties under order 1 civil procedure rules envisages a pending proceeding or suit but not where the issues have been fully heard ,detrmined or resolved as was held in jmk versus mwm aand nnor 2015eklr .in everton coal enterprises ltd versus rose wakanyi karanja and others application no e026 of 2023 ,the court that an application for joinder can only be filed in pending proceedings,either before or during the trisl .The court said that it is only when a suit is pending that a party may be joined; otherwise, when a suit has been finally determined, there is nothing more to be done and that the rule becomes inapplicable.
Paragraph 34 →
Held
56. Given that the Court has declined to join the applicant to this finalised matter and in view of the parallel pending application against the applicant, the prayers in this application are declined in their entirety with no order as to costs. File marked closed.
Paragraph 56 →
Ratio
34. What the applicant is seeking, however, is to join the suit post-judgment. Courts have held that addition of parties under order 1 civil procedure rules envisages a pending proceeding or suit but not where the issues have been fully heard ,detrmined or resolved as was held in jmk versus mwm aand nnor 2015eklr .in everton coal enterprises ltd versus rose wakanyi karanja and others application no e026 of 2023 ,the court that an application for joinder can only be filed in pending proceedings,either before or during the trisl .The court said that it is only when a suit is pending that a party may be joined; otherwise, when a suit has been finally determined, there is nothing more to be done and that the rule becomes inapplicable.
Paragraph 34 →
Held. Denied. The applicant had not shown service of the decree, an execution notice, or an eviction notice. The court held that execution disputes fell to the deputy registrar/executing court and declined to assume that jurisdiction.
Ratio. A stay of execution is discretionary, but the court would not usurp the executing court's powers where there was no evidence that execution steps or the requisite decree or eviction notice had been served on the applicant.
Issue
37. The application asks for a review instead of a stay pending appeal; There is no evidence that a notice to execute or of eviction has been served upon the applicant by the decree holder. The jurisdiction to handle disputes relating to execution falls under the deputy registrar and not this court. Jurisdiction is everything. Without it, a court downs its tools. There is no evidence that a decree has been served upon the applicant as per Order 22 of the Civil Procedure Rules or an eviction notice under section 152 of the Land Act. The court declines to usurp the powers of the executing court.
Paragraph 37 →
Held
37. The application asks for a review instead of a stay pending appeal; There is no evidence that a notice to execute or of eviction has been served upon the applicant by the decree holder. The jurisdiction to handle disputes relating to execution falls under the deputy registrar and not this court. Jurisdiction is everything. Without it, a court downs its tools. There is no evidence that a decree has been served upon the applicant as per Order 22 of the Civil Procedure Rules or an eviction notice under section 152 of the Land Act. The court declines to usurp the powers of the executing court.
Paragraph 37 →
56. Given that the Court has declined to join the applicant to this finalised matter and in view of the parallel pending application against the applicant, the prayers in this application are declined in their entirety with no order as to costs. File marked closed.
Paragraph 56 →
Ratio
37. The application asks for a review instead of a stay pending appeal; There is no evidence that a notice to execute or of eviction has been served upon the applicant by the decree holder. The jurisdiction to handle disputes relating to execution falls under the deputy registrar and not this court. Jurisdiction is everything. Without it, a court downs its tools. There is no evidence that a decree has been served upon the applicant as per Order 22 of the Civil Procedure Rules or an eviction notice under section 152 of the Land Act. The court declines to usurp the powers of the executing court.
Paragraph 37 →
Held. Declined. The court acknowledged that the applicant's explanation for moving promptly after learning of the judgment was plausible, but declined all prayers because it had refused joinder in the finalized matter and there was a parallel pending application against him. No costs were awarded.
Ratio. Review is a limited jurisdiction under section 80 and Order 45 Rule 1, available only on qualifying grounds and not as a rehearing. The application was ultimately declined in the context of the finalized suit and the parallel pending application.
Issue
45. According to the applicant, the subject property was purchased from the plaintiff in February 2020, at which point the applicant took possession and established a school on the site. The applicant further maintains that he had no notice of the ongoing litigation until March 2025, when a related application was formally served upon him.
Paragraph 45 →
Held
56. Given that the Court has declined to join the applicant to this finalised matter and in view of the parallel pending application against the applicant, the prayers in this application are declined in their entirety with no order as to costs. File marked closed.
Paragraph 56 →
Ratio
40. Order 45 Rule 1 provides, in substance, that an aggrieved person may seek review based on the discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, despite the exercise of due diligence, was not within the person's knowledge or could not be produced when the decree was passed; a mistake or error apparent on the face of the record; or any other sufficient reason. The application must be made without unreasonable delay.
Paragraph 40 →
56. Given that the Court has declined to join the applicant to this finalised matter and in view of the parallel pending application against the applicant, the prayers in this application are declined in their entirety with no order as to costs. File marked closed.
Paragraph 56 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The plaintiff, by an application dated 26.3.2025, seeks orders that:
Paragraph 1 →The guiding issue for consideration is whether the proposed party has a tangible interest in the subject matter, and whether the court can fully resolve that interest without their involvement. In JMK v MWM & another [2015] eKLR, the Court of Appeal emphasised that all individuals essential for a comprehensive and final resolution of a dispute must be included in the lawsuit.
Paragraph 24 →What the court finds curious is whether the applicant has responded to the misc application and, if so, what is his defence. Again, the applicant does not tell the court that the forum in which he has been allowed to be heard is inadequate or inefficient.
Paragraph 52 →Whether Julius Njoroge should be enjoined as an interested party after judgment; whether execution should be stayed or the status quo preserved; and whether the judgment should be reviewed under section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 rule 1 of the…
Julius Njoroge, the proposed interested party, stated that he bought Komarock Shopping Centre Plot No. 68 from the plaintiff on 10 February 2020 after conducting due diligence, including inquiries at Nairobi City County’s Dandora office. He said he took…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC SUIT NO. 648 OF 2015
MAURICE INGOI……………………………………....……………..PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
JOSIAH MACHARIA………………………...………………….1ST DEFENDANT
LANDAN MBOTE HUTHU……………...……………………2ND DEFENDANT
JULIUS NJOROGE……....…………………..PROPOSED INTERESTED PARTY
RULING
1. The plaintiff, by an application dated 26.3.2025, seeks orders that:
a. Spent
b. THAT the court do enjoin Julius Njoroge as an interested party to these proceedings.
c. THAT this court be pleased to grant orders of stay of execution of the decree herein and/or status quo ante pending the hearing of this application inter parties.
d. THAT this court be pleased to grant orders of stay of execution of the decree herein and/or status quo ante pending the hearing and determination of this application.
e. THAT this court be pleased to review its judgment dated 9.6.2023 with a view to varying it and/or setting aside on such terms as it deems fit and expedient in the circumstances
2. The application is based on the grounds set out on its face and the averments contained in the supporting affidavit sworn by Julius Njoroge on 26.3.2025.
3. The applicant deposes that in June 2019, the plaintiff herein approached him with an offer to sell to him the property known as Komarock Shopping Centre Plot No. 68 (hereinafter referred to as the suit property).
4. Following the said offer, the applicant deposes that he undertook due diligence by requesting the plaintiff to provide documents evidencing ownership of the suit property, who then furnished him with a bundle of documents purportedly confirming ownership of the property, which documents are annexed to the affidavit and marked as JN/1.
5. The applicant further deposes that, as part of his due diligence, he visited the Nairobi City County offices at Dandora Branch, and was informed that the plaintiff was the duly registered owner of the suit property. He further states that the Dandora office confirmed receipt of ground rates in respect of the property for the period between 2017 and 2020, as evidenced by the receipt annexed to the affidavit and marked as JN/2.
6. The applicant avers that, having received the aforesaid confirmation and satisfied as to the plaintiff's ownership of the suit property, he executed a sale agreement with the plaintiff on 10.2.2020, and took possession of the property. A copy of the sale agreement is annexed to the affidavit and marked as JN/3.
7. The applicant further deposes that, from 4.3.2020, he commenced the construction of a permanent school on the suit property and that throughout the construction period, no one challenged his ownership or informed him of the existence of any court proceedings concerning the property.
8. By June 2024, the applicant states that he had constructed more than five classroom blocks and a staffroom, as evidenced by the photographs annexed to the affidavit and marked as JN/4.
9. The applicant states that the school was inspected by the relevant government authorities and was subsequently authorised to commence operations. He further avers that he registered the school under a business name in compliance with the applicable licensing requirements. A copy of the certificate of registration is annexed to the affidavit and marked as JN/5(a).
10. The applicant deposes that, in January 2025, the school admitted its first cohort of 200 learners enrolled in various grades up to Grade 5. He further states that he employed ten teachers, four support staff members and a school manager to oversee the institution's operations and ensure the provision of quality education, as per the documents duly approved by the appropriate authorities, annexed to the affidavit and marked as JN/5(b).
11. The applicant avers that the school has operated without interruption from the time it opened its doors to learners until 21.3.2025, when he was served with Miscellaneous Civil Application No. E061 of 2025. He states that this was the first time he became aware of the existence of the present proceedings. A copy of the said application is annexed to the affidavit and marked as JN/6.
12. The applicant further deposes that, upon being served with the said application, he instructed his present advocates, who perused the court record and established that the proceedings had been conducted without his knowledge or participation and that judgment had already been delivered. Copies of the judgment and decree are annexed to the affidavit and marked as JN/7(a) and JN/7(b), respectively.
13. The applicant contends that the judgment has far-reaching implications on his proprietary rights over the suit property, particularly in view of the substantial investment he has made in developing the property, which he estimates to be worth millions of shillings.
14. The applicant further avers that since he is currently operating a school on the suit property, his eviction pursuant to the court's orders, without having been afforded an opportunity to be heard, would not only occasion substantial prejudice to his investment but would also adversely affect the learners attending the institution.
15. He particularly emphasises that the learners would face difficulties in securing alternative schools in the middle of the academic year.
16. The applicant states that his attempts to contact the plaintiff, from whom he purchased the suit property, have been unsuccessful. He therefore urges the court to preserve the subject matter pending the determination of the dispute over ownership.
17. The applicant further alleges that the sale agreement and power of attorney purportedly relied upon by the defendants to establish their purchase of the suit property were forged. In support of this allegation, he annexes a letter from Rumba Kinuthia & Co. Advocates, marked as JN/8.
18. The applicant further deposes that he has received a letter from the Directorate of Criminal Investigations Officer in Charge of Buru Buru Police Station confirming that the suit property is the subject of ongoing police investigations. A copy of the said letter is annexed to the affidavit and marked as JN/9.
19. The applicant additionally avers that he is at the final stages of obtaining a title to the suit property pursuant to the purchase. He consequently maintains that the interests of justice demand that he should not be deprived of the property without being allowed to be heard. The relevant documents in support of this assertion are annexed to the affidavit and marked as JN/10.
20. Notwithstanding service of the application upon the respondents, none of them filed or served a response thereto.
21. This Court notes that judgment in this matter was delivered on 9.7.2023.
22. Before addressing the substantive issues, it is necessary to define the legal meaning of the term enjoin.
23. Addition of parties to a lawsuit is primarily regulated by Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. This rule allows the court, either through a party's request or on its own initiative, to add any individual to the case at any point during the litigation. This power is exercised when the person's involvement is vital for the court to fully, fairly, and conclusively resolve every issue raised in the lawsuit.
24. The guiding issue for consideration is whether the proposed party has a tangible interest in the subject matter, and whether the court can fully resolve that interest without their involvement. In JMK v MWM & another [2015] eKLR, the Court of Appeal emphasised that all individuals essential for a comprehensive and final resolution of a dispute must be included in the lawsuit.
25. The court noted that adding new parties to a case should be allowed flexibly, as long as it does not cause unfair disadvantage or harm to the current parties that cannot be resolved through a financial award of costs.
26. The Supreme Court in Francis Karioki Muruatetu & another v Republic & 5 others [2016] eKLR further held that an applicant seeking to be joined as an interested party must demonstrate a personal interest or stake in the matter, establish the prejudice likely to be suffered if joinder is denied, and explain the relevance of the intended participation.
27. The applicant states under oath that he signed an agreement to buy the property from the plaintiff on 10.2.2020. As proof, he provided the agreement, his background check documents, and receipts showing he paid the property tax.
28. He has further deposed that he took possession of the suit property and commenced construction of a school on 4.3.2020. The photographs annexed to his affidavit allegedly demonstrate the construction of more than five classroom blocks and a staffroom. He has also exhibited documents relating to the school's registration and operation.
29. These averments, backed by the attached documents, demonstrate a direct and tangible legal interest in the matter. The applicant claims rights as a buyer from a transaction completed years before learning about the lawsuit. Furthermore, they maintain physical possession of the property and have made significant improvements to it.
30. The court is aware of the distinction between a claim of ownership and proof of ownership. At this stage, the applicant's documents have not yet been evaluated in a full trial. His claims that the plaintiff was the registered owner and that he is nearly finished securing the title still need to be verified. Nevertheless, the question presently before the Court is not whether the applicant has conclusively established title, but whether his asserted interest is sufficiently substantial to warrant participation in the proceedings.
31. The applicant risks losing the property they invested in and significantly developed if the judgment is enforced without their involvement. Because the original lawsuit overlooked the transaction granting the applicant their property rights, pausing execution ensures their claims are fairly evaluated.
32. The prejudice he alleges is therefore direct and substantial. Moreover, his intended participation is relevant because it may enable the Court to examine the circumstances surrounding the competing claims to the suit property, including the validity of the documents relied upon by the respective parties.
33. The Court is guided by Article 159(2)(a) and (d) of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010, which requires justice to be administered to all irrespective of status and without undue regard to procedural technicalities. These provisions do not dispense with procedural rules; rather, they reinforce the obligation to apply those rules in a manner that facilitates the fair determination of disputes.
34. What the applicant is seeking, however, is to join the suit post-judgment. Courts have held that addition of parties under order 1 civil procedure rules envisages a pending proceeding or suit but not where the issues have been fully heard ,detrmined or resolved as was held in jmk versus mwm aand nnor 2015eklr .in everton coal enterprises ltd versus rose wakanyi karanja and others application no e026 of 2023 ,the court that an application for joinder can only be filed in pending proceedings,either before or during the trisl .The court said that it is only when a suit is pending that a party may be joined; otherwise, when a suit has been finally determined, there is nothing more to be done and that the rule becomes inapplicable.
35. The applicant also seeks a stay of execution of the decree and orders preserving the status quo pending the hearing and determination of the application.
36. The power of the court to grant a stay of execution is discretionary. Where the application is made under Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules, the court is required to consider the risk of substantial loss, whether the application has been made without unreasonable delay, and the provision of such security as the court may order for the due performance of the decree.
37. The application asks for a review instead of a stay pending appeal; There is no evidence that a notice to execute or of eviction has been served upon the applicant by the decree holder. The jurisdiction to handle disputes relating to execution falls under the deputy registrar and not this court. Jurisdiction is everything. Without it, a court downs its tools. There is no evidence that a decree has been served upon the applicant as per Order 22 of the Civil Procedure Rules or an eviction notice under section 152 of the Land Act. The court declines to usurp the powers of the executing court.
38. The power of the Court to review its judgment is conferred by Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act, read together with Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010.
39. Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act empowers a person who considers himself aggrieved by a decree or order to apply to the Court that passed the decree or made the order for review.
40. Order 45 Rule 1 provides, in substance, that an aggrieved person may seek review based on the discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, despite the exercise of due diligence, was not within the person's knowledge or could not be produced when the decree was passed; a mistake or error apparent on the face of the record; or any other sufficient reason. The application must be made without unreasonable delay.
41. These grounds are not interchangeable with an appeal. Review is a limited jurisdiction intended to correct qualifying errors or address qualifying circumstances within the parameters established by law.
42. In National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Ndungu Njau [1997] eKLR, the Court of Appeal explained that review is not an avenue for a litigant to obtain a rehearing merely because the litigant is dissatisfied with the decision. An error requiring reconsideration of the merits of a decision is not necessarily an error apparent on the face of the record.
43. Similarly, in Benjoh Amalgamated Limited & another v Kenya Commercial Bank Limited [2014] eKLR, the Court of Appeal considered the scope of the review jurisdiction under Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 of the Civil Procedure Rules.
44. The court must therefore determine whether the circumstances presented by Julius Njoroge, the intended interested party herein, constitute a legally sufficient basis for review, rather than merely a disagreement with the outcome of the original suit.
45. According to the applicant, the subject property was purchased from the plaintiff in February 2020, at which point the applicant took possession and established a school on the site. The applicant further maintains that he had no notice of the ongoing litigation until March 2025, when a related application was formally served upon him.
46. The applicant bears the burden of proving that their situation explicitly satisfies the legal criteria outlined in Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules.
47. A distinction must be made between parties attempting to relitigate a case solely due to an unfavourable outcome, and those showing that the decision directly compromises a substantial interest that lacked representation during the initial proceedings.
48. Article 50(1) of the Constitution provides that every person has the right to have any dispute that can be resolved by the application of law decided in a fair and public hearing before a court or, where appropriate, another independent and impartial tribunal or body.
49. Article 25(c) further identifies the right to a fair trial as a right that shall not be limited. In Mbaki & others v Macharia & another [2005] 2 EA 206, the Court of Appeal emphasised the importance of the right to be heard and the principle that a person should not be condemned without an opportunity to present his case.
50. The right to be heard is not a guarantee that a party will succeed. It is a guarantee that, where the law entitles a person to participate in the determination of a dispute affecting that person's rights, the person must be afforded a meaningful opportunity to do so.
51. The applicant contends that the judgment directly impacts his proprietary and possessory rights over the suit property, notwithstanding his non-participation in the underlying proceedings. In the absence of a responsive pleading from the respondents, the applicant's averments and annexed documentary evidence remain uncontroverted.
52. What the court finds curious is whether the applicant has responded to the misc application and, if so, what is his defence. Again, the applicant does not tell the court that the forum in which he has been allowed to be heard is inadequate or inefficient.
53. Order 45 Rule 1 requires an application for review to be made without unreasonable delay. The reasonableness of the delay must be assessed in the circumstances of each case.
54. The applicant asserts that he lacked knowledge of the proceedings until 21.3.2025. He further states that promptly after becoming aware of the judgment, he instructed counsel and moved to seek relief within days.
55. The court acknowledges that if the applicant's timeline is accurate, the delay between learning of the judgment and submitting the application was minimal. Furthermore, evaluating the delay strictly from the date the judgment was issued would be unfair, as it overlooks the applicant's explanation that he was unaware of the proceedings and was not a party to them. The explanation is plausible on the material presently before the Court.
56. Given that the Court has declined to join the applicant to this finalised matter and in view of the parallel pending application against the applicant, the prayers in this application are declined in their entirety with no order as to costs. File marked closed.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 28th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026.
….……………..
HON. JUSTICE C.K. NZILI
JUDGE
Delivered In the Presence of:
No appearance for plaintiff & defendant
Julius-CA
Bevalyn N -Legal Researcher