Land law

Ooko v Mbugua & another [2026] KEELC 7094 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
28 October 2026
Judge(s)
C.K. Nzili

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Plaintiff, by the notice of motion dated 8.8.2024, seeks review of the court's judgment dismissing his initial suit where he had prayed for :

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

The court finds that the applicant is simply repeating the same ownership claim from the dismissed claim. Granting this request now made would wrongly allow him to reopen the original case without meeting the necessary legal requirements.

Paragraph 37 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

MILIMANI LAW COURTS

ELC NO. E034 OF 2021

ALBERT OKOTH OOKO………………………………PLAINTIFF/APPLICANT

VERSUS

MOSES MBUGUA…………………………….1ST DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT

LOISE NDUTA MBUGUA………………….2ND DEFENDANT/ RESPONDENT

RULING

1. The Plaintiff, by the notice of motion dated 8.8.2024, seeks review of the court's judgment dismissing his initial suit where he had prayed for :

a. A declaration that the plaintiff is the rightful owner of the suit parcel of land known as L.R. NO 27/13 situated at RIDGEWAYS KASARANI, within NAIROBI together with the developments thereon.

b. An Order that the parcel of land known as L.R. NO 27/13 be registered in the name of the plaintiff as the rightful owner by transfer.

c. A permanent injunction to evict and restrain the defendants, their servants, agents, employees, assigns and/or representatives from entering, evicting and/or interfering with the plaintiff's quiet possession or enjoyment of the parcel of land known as L.R. NO 27/13 situated at RIDGEWAYS KASARANI, within NAIROBI or otherwise interfering therewith in any manner whatsoever and the orders of this court be supervised by the OCS KASARANI POLICE STATION.

d. Costs and incidentals of this suit

e. Any other relief that this Honourable Court deems appropriate to award.

2. The reasons in support of his application are contained on the face of the application and in a supporting affidavit. They include;

a. Search in 2019 did not show the defendants as owners.

b. Search on 5/8/2024 reveals the plaintiff as owner.

c. Registrar of Documents confirmed on 7/5/2024 that the plaintiff's title is registered.

d. The defendants could not have become registered owners if the caveat was still on.

e. The initial title belonged to ROBERT SIMPSON and the plot named LINDHURST ESTATES after LINDHURST.

3. The applicant relies on written submissions dated 6.8.2026, which the court has looked at, and the authorities relied upon. Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act (Cap. 21) grants this court the authority to review its own decisions or orders. An aggrieved party may apply for a review of a decree or order from the same court that issued it, subject to statutory conditions.

4. The procedural requirements under Order 45 Rule 1(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, dictate that an applicant for review must establish that their application rests upon one or more recognised statutory grounds:

a. Discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, despite the exercise of due diligence, was not within the applicant's knowledge or could not be produced when the decree was passed or the order made;

b. Some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record; or

c. Any other sufficient reason.

d. The application must also be made without unreasonable delay.

5. A court will not grant a review simply because a party is unhappy with the verdict. To qualify for a review, the applicant must demonstrate that their case meets the specific legal criteria outlined by the law.

6. In National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Ndungu Njau [1997] eKLR, the Court of Appeal clarified the difference between an error apparent on the face of the record and a ruling with which a party merely disagrees with . It noted that a reviewable error must be self-evident and recognisable without extensive argument. Additionally, the court ruled that the mere potential for a different judicial interpretation does not justify a review.

7. Similarly, in Muyodi v Industrial and Commercial Development Corporation & Another [2006] 1 EA 243, the Court of Appeal restated the principles governing review and emphasised that an applicant must demonstrate the discovery of new and important evidence, an error apparent on the face of the record, or any another sufficient reason. The court also underscored the requirement that an application for review be brought without unreasonable delay.

8. In Nyong’o & others v Attorney General (Civil Appeal 250 OF 2019) [2026] KECA 200 (KLR) (6 February 2026) (Judgment), the Court of Appeal held:

“It is trite that review is not an appeal in disguise and cannot be used to re-open matters on the merits simply because a party is dissatisfied with the outcome. As this Court stated in National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Ndungu Njau, Civil Appeal No. 211 of1996 (Court of Appeal at Nairobi) [1997] eKLR, an error or omission warranting review must be self-evident and must not require elaborate argument; and misconstruing a statute or reaching an erroneous conclusion of law is not a ground for review. See also, Muyodi v Industrial and Commercial Development Corporation & Another [2006] 1 EA 243”

9. Further, in Tokesi Mambili and Others v Simion Litsanga [2004] eKLR, the court outlined the circumstances in which review may be granted, including the discovery of new and important evidence that could not have been produced when the decision was made, a mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, or any another sufficient reason.

10. The Court of Appeal in Okero v Onchoke (Civil Appeal 143 of 2020) [2026] KECA 346 (KLR) (27 February 2026) (Judgment) cited with approval in Benjoh Amalgamated Ltd & Another v Kenya Commercial Bank Ltd [2014] eKLR, stating that review jurisdiction is not an avenue to re-litigate matters already determined.

11. The court's power to review as per the cited case law is strictly restricted and can only be used under the specific boundaries set by Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

12. A court will not grant a review merely to give a dissatisfied litigant a second chance to re-argue and/or re-litigate a matter that has already been resolved. The core assertion of the applicant is that title documents and search histories establish his lawful ownership of the subject property, thereby justifying a review of the judgment dismissing his case.

13. The court recognises the importance of the applicant's claims regarding several key points: the property searches done in 2019 and 2024, the verification reportedly provided by the Registrar of Documents on 7.5. 2024, the rumoured presence of a legal notice (caveat), and the past links between the property, Robert Simpson, and Lindhurst Estates.

14. Review based on the ground of discovery of new and important evidence, under Order 45 Rule 1 of Civil Procedure Rules, requires more than the mere production of a document obtained after judgment. The applicant must demonstrate that the evidence is material to the decision and that, despite the exercise of due diligence, it was not within his knowledge or could not have been produced when the judgment was delivered.see Kiliavo Fresh Limited v. National Environment Tribunal & 4 Others [2025] KECA 623 (KLR)

15. In the present application, the applicant relies on a 2019 search that was conducted before the judgment on 2.11.2023. However, the applicant has failed to explain why this information could not have been introduced during the original trial.

16. Additionally, the Applicant bases his claim on a search conducted on 5.8.2024, and a confirmation supposedly provided by the Registrar of Documents on 7.5.2024. Crucially, both of these dates occurred after the judgment had already been delivered. Although the documents were allegedly found, simply getting them after the fact is not enough on its own to justify review. To successfully request a review based on this new evidence, the applicant is required to explain the circumstances in which the documents were obtained, demonstrate the materiality of the information contained therein, and establish why the relevant evidence could not have been obtained and presented before judgment despite the exercise of due diligence as held in Jackton Siundu Mukhwana v. Protus Sawenja & John Wakoli Sawenja [2026] KEELC 3332 (KLR) (Environment and Land Case No. 60 of 2019, Kitale, Jeremiah M'Njogu M'Torugoji v. District Land Registrar Meru Central & 6 Others [2019] eKLR (Subsequent updates tracked through M'torugoji v. Meru County Land Registrar [2024] KEELC 730 (KLR), Francis Kimathi, Jacob Nturibi & Peter Nturibi v. Attorney General & Land Registrar Meru Central [2022] KEELC 1959 (KLR) (Environment & Land Case E006 of 2021, Meru), Joel Rotich Changarok v. The Attorney General, Land Adjudication & Settlement, Eunice Nasimiyu Wanyama & Khaemba Division Siangura [2026] KEELC 1446 (KLR) (Environment and Land Case No. 173 of 2016, Kitale),

17. The court must evaluate the applicant’s argument that the property could not be legally registered while a caveat was active. The applicant has not shown that the claimed caveat is an obvious mistake in the judgment of 2.11.2023. He has also failed to meet the requirements of Order 45 Rule 1 of Civil Procedure Rule , which requires the error to be completely obvious on its own without needing a deep dive into the facts.

18. Additionally, the court observes that the applicant's points about the property's past ownership by Robert Simpson and Lindhurst Estates focus mainly on the property’s title history. Although important for an ownership claim, the applicant has not proven how these historical facts were not brought to the force during the hearing satisfy the specific statutory criteria for a review.

19. In National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Ndungu Njau (supra), the Court of Appeal made it clear that review is not an avenue for reopening a judgment merely because a party believes that the court reached the wrong conclusion. The applicant must demonstrate an error apparent on the face of the record or another ground expressly recognised by the law.

20. This court therefore finds that the applicant has not established that the judgment of 2.11.2023 contains a mistake or error apparent on the face of the record warranting review.

21. As to any other valid reason to warrant the court to review the decision,the term "any other sufficient reason" does not mean the court has total freedom to reopen closed cases. It must be interpreted using standard legal rules and the unique facts of this specific case.

22. In the present case, the applicant's primary goal is evidently clear to alter the 2.11.2023 judgment. The remedies requested for in this application, specifically the declaration of ownership, the order for property transfer and registration, and permanent injunction against the defendants, are essentially identical to the core reliefs pursued in the initial lawsuit.

23. A review is not a second chance to argue a whole case. A dissatisfied litigant cannot use it to make the court rehear all the evidence from the scratch just because they disagree with the outcome.

24. In National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Ndungu Njau (supra), the Court of Appeal cautioned against using review to substitute a different judicial opinion for the decision already made. The principle is that review corrects qualifying errors or addresses qualifying new evidence; it is not a substitute for an appeal.

25. As a result, the applicant cannot get what he asked for in the original lawsuit just by repeating that he own the property in a review request. He has to follow the specific legal rules for reopening a decided case. This court therefore declines to reconsider the substantive ownership dispute under the guise of review.

26. Order 45 Rule 1(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules further requires an application for review to be made without unreasonable delay. The judgment under review was delivered on 2.11.2023, and the corresponding application is dated 18.8.2024. Accordingly, the application was instituted approximately nine and a half months following the rendition of the judgment. Whether a delay is reasonable depends entirely on the unique facts of each case. Simply taking a long time does not automatically disqualify an application. However, an applicant must justify any seemingly unreasonable delay, especially when trying to reopen a matter that has already been resolved. In Muyodi v Industrial and Development Corporation & Another (supra), the Court of Appeal affirmed that an application for review must satisfy the requirement of being brought without unreasonable delay.

27. The applicant has failed to adequately account for the delay between the issuance of the judgment and the filing of this application. Furthermore, he has not presented compelling reasons to warrant revisiting the judgment after such a delay. The later written submissions dated 6.8.2026 do not fix the core failure to provide valid legal grounds for a review. This court therefore finds that the delay has not been satisfactorily explained. This consideration further weighs against the exercise of the court's discretion in favour of the applicant.

28. The court cannot help but observe that a party dissatisfied with a judgment cannot simply repackage the same dispute, attach a fresh set of documents, and invite the court to begin again as though the previous proceedings had never occurred. A change in packaging does not necessarily change the substance, and an application for review is not an opportunity to take a second bite at the cherry.

29. The doctrine of res judicata is central to the finality of judicial proceedings and the administration of justice. Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act, Cap. 21, Laws of Kenya, provides that:

“No Court shall try any suit or issue in which the matter directly and substantially in issue has been directly and substantially in issue in a former suit between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title, in a Court competent to try such subsequent suit or the suit in which such issue has been subsequently raised, and has been heard and finally decided by such Court.”

30. The doctrine of res judicata prevents the same parties in a dispute from suing each other again over a dispute that a proper court has already concluded. It protects the finality of judicial decisions, prevents abuse of the court process and safeguards parties from being subjected to endless litigation over the same subject matter.

31. In Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission v Maina Kiai & 5 Others [2017] eKLR, the Court of Appeal identified the essential elements of res judicata. The ingredients include: the matter in issue must have been directly and substantially in issue in the former suit; the former suit must have been between the same parties or their privies; the parties must have litigated under the same title; the court that determined the former suit must have been competent; and the matter must have been heard and finally decided by that court.

32. This court acknowledges as a fact that the plaintiff's lawsuit regarding the Ridgeways property, L.R. No. 27/13 in Kasarani, Nairobi, has already been resolved. Specifically, a judgment issued on 2.11.2023 dismissed the plaintiff's claim. The applicant's current prayers include a declaration of ownership over the suit property, a transfer and registration order, and a permanent injunction to bar the defendants from interfering with his rights. These claims or prayers mirror the remedies pursued in the original action.

33. Due diligence includes tracing the root of title by obtaining historical records. The applicant should have collected those documents before the trial closed. The applicant cannot reopen this case simply by pointing to past property records and searches, which he negligently and recklessly failed to obtain and produce before the trial court.

34. Merely relying on the 2019 and 2024 search results, the Registrar’s May 2024 confirmation, the purported caveat, or the property's historical ties to Robert Simpson and Lindhurst Estates is insufficient.

35. Instead, the applicant must legally justify a review by proving this "new" evidence meets strict statutory rules such specifically, demonstrating that he could not have been uncovered and presented before the original judgment, even with careful and diligent effort. See Mwangi & 2 Others v. Mohammed Abdi Elmi & 3 Others.

36. In Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission v Maina Kiai & 5 Others [2017] EKLR (supra), the Court of Appeal emphasised the importance of preventing the reopening of matters that have already been finally determined by a competent court. The underlying principle is that litigation must come to an end and that parties must not be permitted to repeatedly agitate the same dispute in the absence of a recognised legal basis for doing so.

37. The court finds that the applicant is simply repeating the same ownership claim from the dismissed claim. Granting this request now made would wrongly allow him to reopen the original case without meeting the necessary legal requirements.

38. A final court judgment is not a test run for another lawsuit. Simply looking for new evidence or restating a claim of ownership does not give someone the right to reopen a settled case, unless they strictly meet the legal criteria for a formal review. On the legal system cannot act as a revolving door where the same dispute is repeatedly brought back until a party gets the result they want.

39. This court therefore finds that the principles of finality of litigation and the prohibition against abuse of the court process weigh against the reopening of the substantive ownership dispute in the circumstances of this case. The applicant has not demonstrated a sufficient legal basis to disturb the judgment previously delivered.

40. The court is therefore not satisfied that the application meets the legal threshold for review. The application dated 18.8.2024 is accordingly dismissed with costs for lack of merit.

41. Orders accordingly.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 28th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026.

….………………

HON. JUSTICE C.K. NZILI

JUDGE

Delivered In the Presence of:

Miss Mkaburi for 1st and 2nd defendants

Albert Okoth in present in person

Miss Auma Advocate next friend for the applicant

Julius-CA

Bevalyn N -Legal Researcher

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder