REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND ALND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC CASE NO. E331 OF 2026
PETER MWANGI NYAGA …………………………PLAINTIFF/APPLICANT
VERSUS
HARROGATE LIMITED ………………….1ST DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
GARAM INVESTMENT AUCTIONEERS .2ND DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
RULING
1. The Notice of Motion before court is dated 27/07/2026. It seeks a temporary injunction restraining the defendants from entering, trespassing, taking possession, selling by public auction, charging, disposing of, or interfering with the plaintiff’s use, possession, and occupation of LR No. 2327/52 (originally LR No. 2327/21/13), pending the hearing and determination of this suit.
2. The grounds are set out on the face of the application and in the supporting affidavit of Peter Nyaga sworn on 27/07/2026. The applicant deposes that by an agreement dated 10/12/2019, he bought the suit property from the first defendant as per the attached agreement marked "PN1", paid a deposit, and took vacant possession on condition that the balance shall be paid upon successful completion of the transfer.
3. The plaintiff deposes that efforts to seek the first defendant to finalize the transfer have been futile. He claims that its directors have been out of the country, only for him to learn on 19/07/2026 that the title to the suit property has been re-advertised for sale by the 2nd defendant, as per a copy of a newspaper advertisement attached as "PN2".
4. The applicant deposes that if the land title is sold, he risks suffering loss and damage. Otherwise, the delay and refusal to transfer has been occasioned by the first defendant, yet he has always been ready to complete the transaction.
5. The application is opposed through replying affidavits sworn on 27/07/2026 by the first defendant and on 24/09/2026 by the 2nd defendant. It is deposed that the plaintiff has never held any proprietary interest in the suit property, save for the contractual relationship he had by virtue of a sale agreement. The respondents state that the purported sale agreement is a total fabrication, defective, and incapable of enforcement for lack of consideration.
6. It is deposed that the applicant had filed another suit, namely MC ELC No. E605 of 2026, where he obtained interim orders as per the annexed application dated 20/07/2026 and interim orders marked "JG1". The defendants state that upon filing a response challenging jurisdiction due to the value of the land, the plaintiff instead filed parallel proceedings herein seeking similar orders, after which he withdrew the lower court suit by a notice dated 23/07/2026.
7. It is therefore deposed that the applicant is guilty of forum shopping, abusing the court's process, and approaching the court with unclean hands. The notice of withdrawal is attached as annexure marked "JG2".
8. The defendants depose that the present suit property has been subject to extensive litigation both at the High Court and in the Court of Appeal. Otherwise, the advertisement for sale was regular on account of a valid legal charge in favor of Mwananchi Credit Limited, who had instructed the 2nd defendant to realize the security after default to repay the loan advanced in 2020 to the first defendant, as per the annexed letter of offer and charge marked "JG3A" and "JG3B", respectively.
9. The 2nd defendant deposes that after the advertisement, the first defendant filed HCC E843 of 2021 to stop the intended sale, leading to a ruling delivered on 03/06/2022. Thereafter, it moved to the Court of Appeal, which also declined to grant interim orders to stop the impending sale as per the attached ruling marked "JG4".
10. The 2nd defendant deposes that after numerous litigations, the first defendant and the chargee entered into a consent judgment adopted by the court on 16/05/2024 to pay Kshs 1,000,000/=, failure of which the chargee would be at liberty to issue a 45-day auctioneer's notice and proceed with the sale of the suit property, as per the annexed copy marked "JG5".
11. The 2nd defendant deposes that following a default, an auctioneer's notice was issued dated 11/03/2026 marked as "JG6A" and "JG6B". The 2nd defendant deposes that for failure to redeem the property, the property was advertised for sale on 21/07/2026; otherwise, the plaintiff and the first defendant are abusing the court process to frustrate the sale.
12. The 2nd defendant deposes that the first defendant had also attempted to stop the sale by filing an application to set aside the consent judgment, which was dismissed by a ruling delivered on 02/07/2026 (copy attached as "JG7").
13. The 2nd defendant deposes that the first defendant then moved to the Constitutional Division of the High Court in HC Petition No. E458 of 2026 for conservatory orders, which application was dismissed by a ruling delivered on 23/07/2026 (copy attached as "JG8").
14. The 2nd defendant states that the chargee has not been joined in this suit; otherwise, issuing orders likely to affect a third party or a consent judgment of a superior court and the prayers sought would be untenable. The 2nd defendant deposes that the plaintiff's remedy, if any, is in damages.
15. The 2nd defendant further deposes that at the time of obtaining credit, the first defendant did not disclose the alleged sale agreement.
16. Order 40 Rule 1A of the Civil Procedure Rules and Section 63(e) of the Civil Procedure Act allow the court to issue a temporary injunction where it is proved that the defendant threatens or intends to dispose of his property to obstruct or delay execution of any decree that may be passed against the defendant, or where the defendant seeks to alienate, sell, or dispose of the subject property to the suit.
17. To qualify for injunctive relief, the applicant has to meet the principles of establishing a prima facie case, irreparable loss or damage, and the balance of convenience, as held in Giella -vs- Cassman Brown & Co. Ltd.
18. A prima facie case, as per Nguruman Limited -vs- John Belcher Neilson & Others (2014), is a clear and unmistakable right to be protected, which is directly threatened by an act sought to be restrained. The invasion of the right has to be material and substantive. It must be urgent and of necessity to prevent irreparable damage that may result out of such damages must be unquantifiable or incapable of compensation in the absence of an injunction.
19. The inconvenience to the plaintiff if the injunction is not granted and the suit ultimately succeeds should be more than what will be experienced by the defendants if the vice versa were to happen, as held in Tenai -vs- Kogo. Courts of law do not rewrite contracts but enforce enforce them unless vitiated by, inter alia, fraud, illegality, or undue influence, as held in National Bank of Kenya -vs- Pipeplastic Samkolit (T) Limited & Another (2001) KLR 112.
20. A court will not allow a man to rely on his own wrong to defeat an otherwise sound claim of another, as held in Mohamed -vs- Bakari & Others (2008) 3 KLR (EP) 54. A contract for sale is capable of specific performance.
21. Issuance of a temporary injunction is not a matter of right but a discretionary relief, as held in Walter Investments Limited -vs- Simon K. Sang, Civil Appeal No. 315 of 2004.
22. In this application, the applicant has attached an agreement which he says is valid and enforceable. He blames the first defendant for the delay in completing the transaction. There is no dispute that the first defendant has put up the suit property for a public auction even when the plaintiff says he is in occupation, has paid partly for it, and has always been ready to clear the balance.
23. The law is that parties have freedom of contract. Specific performance is an equitable remedy issued based on the existence of a valid and enforceable contract; it shall not be issued where a contract suffers from a defect.
24. Courts cannot relieve a party, unless in exceptional circumstances, from a bad bargain or assist them to walk away from what they signed for, as held in Fina Bank Limited -vs- Spares & Industries Limited, Civil Appeal No. 51 of 2001.
25. The first defendant blames the plaintiff for defaulting on the terms and conditions. Equity shall suffer no wrong without a remedy. Equity, as held in Macharia Mwangi Maina & 87 Others v. Davidson Mwangi Kagiri [2014] eKLR (Civil Appeal Nos. 6, 26 & 27 of 2011), deprecates unjust enrichment. The clean hands doctrine allows the court to deny equitable relief to a party that acted unfairly or in bad faith. Equity aids the vigilant and not the indolent. The equitable jurisdiction of the courts can be exercised to set aside any bargain found to be harsh or oppressive or where, having agreed, a party imposes additional terms unilaterally, as held in Kenya Commercial Finance Co. Ltd -vs- Ngeno & Another [2000]eKLR
26. The 2nd defendant has made several disclosures relating to previous and pending litigation over this suit property. It is the law that when a party moves to court ex parte, it has a duty of utmost good faith to disclose all matters—favorable or unfavorable—that the court may wish to know before exercising its discretion, as was held in Republic -vs- KRA ex parte Yaya Towers Limited (2008) eKLR and Bahadurali Habibrahim Shamji -vs- Halimul Jamal & Others (1998) eKLR.
27. Interim orders may be discharged if obtained without full disclosure. The rationale is to deprive the wrongdoer of an advantage improperly obtained. It also serves as a deterrent to ensure that persons who make an ex parte application realize that they have this duty of disclosure and of the consequences if they fail in that duty, as held in Tiwi Beach Hotel Limited v. Juliane Ulrike Stamm [1991] KLR 658
28. In the plaint and verifying affidavit dated 20/07/2026, the plaintiff avers and deposes on oath that there have been no previous proceedings between the plaintiff and the defendants over the same subject matter. It has now turned out that at the time the plaintiff approached this court, he was already enjoying interim orders from the lower court and only withdrew that suit due to an impending objection on jurisdiction after obtaining similar orders from this court.
29. Therefore, the deposition used to obtain interim orders deliberately left lacunae on the facts of the matter by concealing from the court's records previous and pending proceedings and orders. Non-disclosure is an affront to the dignity and credibility of the court.
30. In Owners of the Motor Vessel "Lillian S" v. Caltex Oil (Kenya) Limited [1989] KLR 1 the court said that it is automatic that in ex parte proceedings, there should be full and frank disclosure to the court of facts known to the applicant; otherwise, failure to do so may result in the discharge of any interim orders.
31. In this matter, the materials not disclosed are relevant. It cannot be innocent is the part of the applicant that he did not know of the pending suit and orders in the lower court at the time he falsely swore that there were no pending proceedings over the matter.
32. The non-disclosure reeks of guilt and a calculation to mislead the court. It shows that the applicant came to court with unclean hands to seek and obtain equitable remedies.
33. Want of good faith can be used as a sufficient ground to strike out an injunction, as held in Mutiso & Others -vs- Milligan & Company Limited (1991) KLR 45 and in Republic v. Minister for Information & Communications & Another ex parte Kenya National Federation of Co-operatives Limited [2015] KLR 242.
34. Abuse of court process, as held in Mwangi & 26 Others v. Administrators of the Estate of Letoire-Ole Ntirori (Deceased) & 9 Others [2026] KEELC 4865 (KLR), is when one makes an excessive or improper use of a thing or acts contrary to the natural legal rules for its use.
33. The consequence is that the court finds the application dated 20/07/2026 lacking merit. It is dismissed with costs.
34. Any interim orders herein issued are hereby set aside and vacated forthwith.
35. Costs to the respondents.
36. Orders accordingly.
Dated, signed and delivered this 28th day of October,2026 at Milimani Nairobi.
….……………
Hon.Justice C.K. Nzili
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Mr. Buluma for defendant
Mr. Mulanga for Kiprop for plaintiff
Court Assistant: Julius
Legal Researcher: Bevalyn N.