Background
This ruling relates to the Notice of Motion dated 16/07/2025 and the Preliminary Objection dated 17/11/2025.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
This ruling relates to the Notice of Motion dated 16/07/2025 and the Preliminary Objection dated 17/11/2025.
Paragraph 1 →The applicants rely on written submissions dated 16/02/2026 isolating two issues for determination. On the Preliminary Objection, it is submitted that it does not meet the threshold set out in Oraro v. Mbaja [2005] 1 KLR 141, for it is based on disputed facts as to whether the plaintiffs were parties in the previous suits, which is captured in the supporting and supplementary affidavits.
Paragraph 22 →From the pleadings, the court finds that the plaintiffs have failed to meet the test of a prima facie case with a probability of success at the hearing. The plaintiffs have also deliberately withheld material facts which were within their knowledge at the time they applied for ex parte interim orders against eviction.
Paragraph 46 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
MILIMANI LAWS COURTS
ELELC/E342/2025
ELIJAH MWANGI NJUGUNA …………………………………………1ST PLAINTIFF
MOSES KAMUYU KABURU
(Administrator of the Estate of Lucy Mwihaki Kaburu) ……….………2nd PLAINTIFF
JENNIFER NJOKI NJAU
(Administrator o fthe Estate Hannah Wamuhu Njau)…………………3rd PLAINTIFF
Versus
RUTH WAMBUI WAMBUI (Sued in her personal Capacity and as the Administratix of the ESTATE OF THE LATE JOHN Muigai MUGO )………………………………………………1ST DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
EMBAKASI RANCHING COMPANY LTD…….. 2nd DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
JAMES WACHIRA HARRISON ………….………. 3RD DEFENDANT/REPSONDENT
STANLEY THIONGO NDUATI …………..………. 4TH DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
LAND REGISTRAR ………………………………… 5TH DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
RULING
1. This ruling relates to the Notice of Motion dated 16/07/2025 and the Preliminary Objection dated 17/11/2025.
2. The Notice of Motion seeks a temporary injunction to restrain the 1st defendant from selling, leasing, trespassing, charging, pledging, alienating, tampering with, altering, or otherwise dealing with LR Nos. Nairobi Block 105/5813, 5814, 5606, 5607, 5812, and 5810 pending the hearing and determination of this suit.
3. The grounds are set out on the face of the application and in the supporting affidavit of Moses Kamuga Kaburu sworn on 16/07/2025. It is deposed that the plaintiffs brought the suit property in 2008, took possession, and have constructed homes therein as per the annexures.
4. The applicant deposes that the 1st defendant has issued an eviction notice under Section 152 of the Land Act (No. 6 of 2012) giving 90 days with effect from 27/03/2025, which notice expired on 27/06/2025.
5. The applicant states that the notices are fatally defective for non-compliance with the law it does not identify the evictees and were not personally served upon them.
6. The applicant deposes that they have been warned to remove their developments from the suit property, yet they have equitable and legal rights to the land, which claims cannot be summarily dealt with through an eviction notice hence praying for the reliefs sought.
7. The application is opposed through a Preliminary Objection dated 17/11/2025 and a replying affidavit sworn on 16/11/2025 by Rose Wambui Muigai, the 1st respondent. She denies the alleged occupation and enjoyment of possession of the land by the plaintiffs, as the 1st defendant has always visited the property for either survey or beaconing, therefore, the plaintiffs have always known that they are illegal occupants therein as per attached receipts for survey and beaconing marked RWM-1.
8. The 1st defendant deposes that if the applicants bought the land in 2008, the alleged sellers, the 3rd and 4th respondents, filed ELC Civil Suit No. 317 of 2010, ELC Civil Suit No. 860 of 2013, and ELC Civil Suit No. 874 of 2013 over the suit properties, which the plaintiffs were all aware of as per the annexed plaints marked RWM-2, 3, and 4, meaning that there was no peaceful possession as alleged by the plaintiffs.
9. The 1st defendant deposes that the illegal purchase in 2008 does not prove that the plaintiffs have been in occupation of the land as alleged at all. The 1st defendant deposes that having served a notice that expired on 27/06/2025, the application and suit filed five months after the expiry of the notice comes too late, is a delaying tactic, and aims to frustrate the bona fide owner who has no relationship with the applicants.
10. The 1st defendant terms the suit as statute-barred, the second and third defendants as lacking locus standi to be sued, and the suit as res judicata by a ruling delivered on 25/03/2025 to which the plaintiffs were interested parties as per Annexure RWM-6.
11. The 1st defendant deposes that herself and the deceased were not party to the sale agreement going by the forensic report attached as RWM-7. The 1st defendant deposes that in 2021, the President of Kenya gave directions that titles for Embakasi Ranching Company Limited be issued, whereupon a committee was set up to oversee the titling, leading to the issuance of over 30,000 titles; therefore, if the plaintiffs were bona fide purchasers, they ought to have approached the committee alongside the second defendant as per the notice attached as RWM-8.
12. The 1st defendant deposes that other than the sale agreements, the plaintiffs did not follow up to have title deeds registered, as the second defendant's procedure prior to the transfer of a share involved the presentation of various documents including surveyor's receipts, beacon certificates, site visit receipts, and share certificates, among others, none of which the plaintiffs have shared with this court.
13. The 1st defendant deposes that the original land belonged to the second defendant, who invited people to join the company by selling shares, followed by the issuance of share certificates equivalent to a portion of land.
14. The 1st defendant deposes that after subdividing the land, the shareholders were allocated the subdivided land as per their shareholding, which was then subdivided into various plots sold to interested parties.
15. The 1st defendant deposes that once a share was issued equivalent to a plot, all documents with plot numbers, letter parcel numbers, and beacon certificates accompanied them. The 1st defendant deposes that during the presidential directive, shareholders presented all the above documents issued by the second defendant, which the second defendant would verify and clear shareholders for the issuance of title deeds.
16. The 1st defendant deposes that she followed that process to the letter, leading to the issuance of title deeds by the Ministry of Lands as proof of ownership, though the physical titles are yet to be collected.
17. The 1st defendant deposes that the plaintiffs have availed no documents from the second defendant to show they indeed were owners of the land. The 1st defendant deposes that it is far-fetched for the plaintiffs to claim that they were not aware of the titling, as it was ably advertised in daily newspapers and news channels.
18. The 1st defendant deposes that matters raised in these applications were also raised in the ruling delivered in ELC Civil Suit No. 874 of 2013 as part of the consolidated suit. Otherwise, the plaintiffs as interested parties knew that they had no chances of success in the claim, filed no substantive supporting documents, and neither have they filed any in this suit.
19. The 1st defendant deposes that further to the receipt of eviction notices, no substantive grounds have been given for the delay, nor is there evidence by way of documentation of proof of payment of the alleged purchase price or due diligence carried out for the purchase of the land (such as verification of ownership from the second defendant or payment receipts thereof).
20. The 1st defendant deposes that the claim to have bought the land through the fourth defendant, who is an Advocate of the High Court of Kenya, meant they should have done their due diligence.
21. The 1st defendant terms the suit vexatious, ambiguous, and an abuse of the court process, given that the plaintiffs as interested parties lost in the previous suits and lack a cause of action against her. The 1st defendant deposes that the suit is an attempt to revive, review, and/or appeal against previous orders contrary to law.
22. The applicants rely on written submissions dated 16/02/2026 isolating two issues for determination. On the Preliminary Objection, it is submitted that it does not meet the threshold set out in Oraro v. Mbaja [2005] 1 KLR 141, for it is based on disputed facts as to whether the plaintiffs were parties in the previous suits, which is captured in the supporting and supplementary affidavits.
23. On the application for temporary injunction, the plaintiffs submit they have met the conditions in Giella v. Cassman Brown & Co. Ltd [1973] EA 358, Mrao Limited v. 1st American Bank of Kenya Limited & 2 Others [2003] KLR 125, and National Bank of Kenya Limited v. Pipeplastic Samkolit (K) Ltd & Another [2001] eKLR / Civil Appeal No. 9 of 1997.
24. The 1st respondent relies on written submissions dated 17/02/2026 that the suit is time-barred by dint of Sections 4 and 7 of the Limitation of Actions Act (Cap 22), contravenes Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act (Cap 21), fails to satisfy the facts required for granting an interim injunction, and discloses no cause of action against her. Reliance is pressed on Gathoni v. Kenya Co-operative Creameries Limited [1982] KLR 104 and Mehta v. Shah [1965] EA 321.
25. It is submitted that the plaintiffs were fifth interested parties in the former consolidated suit, which was heard and determined by a court of competent jurisdiction. Reliance is pressed on Okaka v. Ojango & Another [2025] KEELC 1230 (KLR) and Registered Trustees of the Anglican Church of Kenya, Diocese of Eldoret v. Attorney General & Another [2020] eKLR.
26. The 1st defendant submits that the suit discloses no cause of action against her, for there is no connection established between her and the plaintiffs in regard to the alleged sale agreement, to which she is a total stranger.
27. The 1st defendant submits that the 1st applicant was the fourth interested party in the previous suit, whereas the second and third plaintiffs lack capacity to sue and are coming in too late.
28. A preliminary objection is a pure point of law which is raised on undisputed facts and which is likely to dispose of a suit, as held in Attorney General & Another v. Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & Others [2017] eKLR. It cannot be raised if there are contested issues of fact and law or where it seeks the exercise of judicial discretion, as held in Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v. West End Distributors Ltd [1969] EA 696.
29. In this matter, the plaintiffs are blamed for an abuse of the court process, relitigating issues already determined in previous suits, non-disclosure of previous litigation where they were involved, and abuse of court process.
30. A party who comes to court for ex parte orders must disclose all material facts within its knowledge. In Tiwi Beach Hotel Limited v. Julian Donald Harding & Others [1995] eKLR / [1995–1998] 1 EA 258, the court said that non-disclosure is an affront to the dignity and credibility of the court.
31. In Owners of Motor Vessel "Lillian S" v. Caltex Oil (Kenya) Limited [1989] KLR 1, the court said that it is automatic that in ex parte proceedings, there should be full and frank disclosure to the court of facts known to the applicants, otherwise, failure to do so may result in the discharge of any orders made, for it amounts to an abuse of the process of the court.
32. Non-disclosure may lead to striking out an injunction for want of good faith, as held in Mutula & Others v. Milligan & Company Limited [1961] EA 345.
33. The doctrine of res judicata, as held in Gitaka v. Waweru & Others [Civil Appeal No. 155 of 2020] (Judgment delivered 13th February 2026), prohibits the court in absolute terms from entertaining a suit that raises issues already heard and determined finally by a court of competent jurisdiction in an earlier suit between the same parties or parties claiming under them over the same subject matter.
34. In Kenya Commercial Bank Limited v. Muiri Coffee Estate Limited & Another [2016] eKLR, the court held that once the legal rights of parties have been judicially determined, such edicts stand as conclusive statements on those rights. The court said that the doctrine in effect allows a party only one bite at the cherry and prevents such a party from returning to court to claim further relief not claimed in the earlier suit.
35. The doctrine prevents multiplicity of suits which ordinarily clog the courts, occasion unnecessary costs to the parties, ensures litigation comes to an end, and translates one verdict into fruits for one party and a liability for another conclusively, as held in John Florence Maritime Services Limited & Another v. Cabinet Secretary for Transport and Infrastructure & 3 Others [2015] eKLR. The test to apply was set out in Isaac Babu Andasi v. Maina Kiang'a & Others [2017] eKLR, namely, sameness of parties, issues, subject matter , and a final determination on the merits by a competent court.
36. The doctrine of res judicata applies not only to the issues raised in the earlier suit but also to all issues that ought to have been raised in the earlier suit. Parties therefore cannot be allowed to litigate in installments, as held in Henderson v. Henderson [1843] 3 Hare 100. Parties cannot evade the doctrine by adding new parties or new causes of action so as to seek the same remedy as sought in the earlier suit, as held in Kenya Commercial Bank Limited v. Muiri Coffee Estate Limited & Another (supra).
37. Courts must therefore be vigilant to guard against parties evading the doctrine, the test being whether the new suit is trying to reopen issues already determined in an earlier suit to attempt to obtain a different verdict or outcome, as held in Mweikari & Another v. Mutungi & Others [Civil Appeal No. 189 of 2026].
38. Res judicata, as held in Kioko v. Attorney General [2024] eKLR, precludes continued litigation after a final order on the same case, the same issue, and subject matter between the same parties.
39. The plaintiffs allege that they have been issued with an eviction notice dated March 2025, yet they hold beneficial interests over the land arising out of alleged sale agreements and uninterrupted occupation or possession.
40. The 1st defendant admits issuing eviction notices but says that the alleged occupation has not been peaceful, open, or uninterrupted in view of previous litigation where the plaintiffs were parties.
41. In Mwirobua & Others v. Naicha [Civil Appeal No. E014 of 2026] (Judgment delivered 25th September 2026), the court stated that time for adverse possession starts to run upon registration of title, and that a claim for recovery of land by a true owner will be barred if not undertaken within 12 years of registration. Otherwise, after 12 years, the title stands extinguished under Section 17 of the Limitation of Actions Act (Cap 22).
42. The 1st defendant has faulted the basis of the plaintiffs' claim based on an alleged sale agreement which was found to be a forgery in the previous suit. She also takes issue that the said sale agreement is not enforceable in law.
43. She also claim is also statute-barred, and due to its legal infirmity and lack of consideration, the applicants have nothing to rely on to enforce such a claim for lack of documentation or representation made to the second defendant at the time of the Presidential initiative leading to registration and issuance of titles.
44. Time for adverse possession as held in Kakuzi PLC v. Makuyu Club (Suing through Joel Nyoike, Irungu Ndirangu and S. Kirubi as Trustees of the Club) [2026] KESC (SC Petition No. E035 of 2025) ceases to run either when the owner asserts his rights or when his right is admitted by the adverse possessor. Assertion of rights occurs when the owner takes legal proceedings or makes an effective entry onto the land, as held in Mwangi Githu v. Livingstone Ndeete [1980] KLR 256 .
45. The 1st defendant has pleaded that in the previous suits, the plaintiffs were interested parties who never agitated any adverse claims to recover or took effective steps to recover possession (see Abdirahman & Others v. Attorney General [1982] KLR 198).
46. From the pleadings, the court finds that the plaintiffs have failed to meet the test of a prima facie case with a probability of success at the hearing. The plaintiffs have also deliberately withheld material facts which were within their knowledge at the time they applied for ex parte interim orders against eviction.
47. The law of eviction is governed by Section 152 of the Land Act (No. 6 of 2012). In William Musembi & Others v. The Moi Educational Centre Co. Ltd & Others [2021] eKLR / SC Petition No. 2 of 2018, the court held that where a title remains unimpeached, the question is whether in evicting the occupants, the owner violated the petitioners' rights to human dignity, security, housing, and health.
48. The negative obligation not to interfere with socio-economic rights applies to both public and private entities. In Satrose Ayuma & 11 Others v. Registered Trustees of the Kenya Railways Staff Retirement Benefits Scheme & 3 Others [2013] eKLR, the court held that forced eviction without proper notice and court orders violates constitutional rights.
49. Section 152 of the Land Act sets out the steps preceding a lawful eviction from private, public, and community land. It contains safeguards for all situations to avoid an unlawful eviction, as held in Lucy Njeri Gunjiri & Others v. Anthony Kimeu & Others [2018] eKLR and Gusi Mwalimu Investments Company Limited & Others v. Mwalimu Hotel Kisii [Civil Appeal No. 160 of 1995], to avoid resort to the law of the jungle or self-help instead of the rule of law.
50. In Mitu-Bell Welfare Society v. Kenya Airport Authority & Others [2016] eKLR, the court held that a violation of a right to due process under the law invites a reprieve or remedy for the violation. Wrongful eviction and conversion can attract damages, as held in Moreu v. Karoga [2004] 1 KLR 83. A party served with an eviction notice has a right to move to court. Similarly, a party who has given an eviction notice may move the court for an eviction order as held in Margaret Nyambura Mongera v. Francis Kofi [2019] eKLR.
51. If brought before court, the court may question its legality, It has to comply with Section 152G of the Land Act. The legal framework was tested in Wafula v. Hagins & Others [1985] and in Munavu v. Halai, as well as Munaver N. Alibhai t/a Diani Boutique v. South Coast Fitness & Sports Centre Limited [1995] KECA 166 (Civil Appeal 203 of 1994) , where the court struck down a termination noticee for failure to meet statutory notice requirements.
52. In Oscar Uvaha, T/A Explore and Suvariwa Limited & Another v. Bamburi Investments & Another [2021] eKLR, the court reaffirmed that a valid termination notice must comply strictly with the law.
53. In this application, the applicants allege beneficial and equitable rights to the land which the respondents are alleged to be breaching. There is evidence of previous proceedings.
54. For parties to be entitled to a temporary injunction, they must meet the conditions set in Giella v. Cassman Brown & Co. Ltd [1973] EA 358, Mrao Limited v. 1st American Bank of Kenya Limited & 2 Others [2003] KLR 125, Nguruman Limited v. Jan Bonde Nielsen & 2 Others [2014] eKLR, and Kogo v. Tenai [2018] eKLR. The applicants have demonstrated an interest in the land.
55. The loss or damage likely to arise is quantifiable in damages. The balance of convenience tilts in favor of maintaining or preserving the status quo in view of previous proceedings and determinations.
56. The Preliminary Objection by the 1st defendant does not pass muster on res judicata and is dismissed with no orders as to costs.
57. The upshot is that the application is also dismissed with costs.
58. Orders accordingly.
Dated ,Signed and delivered this 28th October,2026 atMilimani-Nairobi
….……………
HON. Justice C.K. NZILI
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Miss Muiga for 1st defendant
Mr Murin for 4th defendant.
Mr. Jama for plaintiff
Court Assistant: Julius
Legal Researcher: Bevalyn Nyakwana