Land law

Republic v Business Premises Rent Tribunal & another; Acacia Supermarket Limited & 2 others (Ex parte Applicants) [2026] KEELC 7519 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
5 November 2026
Judge(s)
Mbogo C.G.

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The substantive motion succeeded. The court quashed the BPRT proceedings and orders in Nairobi BPRT Reference No. E1240 of 2025, including the orders of 11 and 14 November 2025 as extended on 26 November 2025. It prohibited the BPRT from continuing or entertaining that reference concerning the 18 April 2025 lease for want of jurisdiction. The ex parte applicants were awarded costs of both the motion and the impugned tribunal proceedings, payable by the interested party.

Supporting judgment passages

i. An order of certiorari is hereby issued removing into this court and quashing the proceedings and orders of the Business Premises Rent Tribunal in Nairobi BPRT reference no. E1240 of 2025, including the orders issued on 11th and 14th November, 2025 and extended on 26th November, 2025.

Passage 56 →

ii. An order of prohibition is hereby issued prohibiting the Business Premises Rent Tribunal from continuing or further entertaining Nairobi BPRT reference no. E1240 of 2025 concerning the tenancy created by the lease agreement dated 18th April 2025, for want of jurisdiction under the Landlord and Tenant (Shops, Hotels and Catering Establishments) Act, Cap. 301.

Passage 57 →

iii. The ex parte applicants shall have costs of the substantive motion and the impugned proceedings before the Business Premises Rent Tribunal. The same shall be borne by the interested party.

Passage 58 →
Issue 1Whether the lease agreement contained a provision permitting termination otherwise than for breach of covenant within five years of its commencement.

Held. Decided. The lease was for five years and three months, and its forfeiture provisions were default-based rather than an ordinary right to terminate otherwise than for breach within five years. The tenancy was therefore not a controlled tenancy under section 2 of Cap. 301, so the BPRT lacked jurisdiction to entertain the interested party’s reference or grant substantive relief arising from it.

Ratio. The BPRT’s jurisdiction under Cap. 301 is confined to tenancies governed by that Act. A written tenancy exceeding five years is controlled only if it contains a provision permitting termination otherwise than for breach within five years. Default-based forfeiture provisions do not satisfy that requirement; procedural directions while jurisdiction is considered cannot create substantive jurisdiction over a matter outside the tribunal’s statute.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

9. I have perused the lease agreement dated 18th April, 2025. The term stipulated is five years and three months, with an expiry date of 18th July, 2030. The agreement is signed on behalf of the parties, and the interested party acknowledges the existence of a lease relationship in his affidavits before the tribunal. The court must therefore determine whether the agreement contains a provision permitting termination otherwise than for breach of covenant within five years of its commencement.

Paragraph 9 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

13. In applying the statutory definition and the foregoing authorities, I find that the tenancy created by the written lease dated 18th April, 2025 is not a controlled tenancy within the meaning of Section 2 of Cap. 301. Consequently, the tribunal lacked jurisdiction under the Act to entertain the reference filed by the interested party and to grant substantive relief arising from that tenancy. It is worth noting that the question of jurisdiction had been raised before the tribunal through the application dated 2nd November, 2025. The orders issued on 11th November, 2025 expressly directed that jurisdiction be determined first. Notwithstanding this direction, the tribunal proceeded to grant orders protecting the interested party’s possession of the suit property, followed by the break-in orders of 14th November, 2025.

Paragraph 13 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

8. The jurisdiction of the BPRT is derived from the Landlord and Tenant (Shops, Hotels and Catering Establishments) Act, Cap. 301. Section 12(1) empowers the tribunal to determine disputes concerning tenancies governed by the Act, including determining whether a tenancy is controlled. However, that jurisdiction must be read together with the definition of a controlled tenancy under Section 2. Section 2(1) of the Act defines a controlled tenancy, in the relevant part:-

Paragraph 8 →

10. Clause 5.1 of the lease deals with forfeiture. It provides among other circumstances, for the landlord’s remedies where rent remains unpaid, where the lessee fails to observe contractual covenants, or where specified insolvency-related events occur. I find these are default-based provisions and do not constitute an ordinary right to terminate the tenancy within five years otherwise than for breach of covenant.

Paragraph 10 →

14. I am alive to the fact that the tribunal may make appropriate procedural directions while considering its own jurisdiction. However, that does not confer substantive jurisdiction where the subject matter falls outside the statute establishing the tribunal. In this case, the orders directing quiet possession and authorizing entry into the premises went beyond the mere preservation of an opportunity to determine jurisdiction. In my view, the tribunal could not derive jurisdiction from the urgency of the interested party’s complaints.

Paragraph 14 →
Issue 2Whether the ex parte applicants were entitled to the judicial-review remedies sought.

Held. Decided. Certiorari and prohibition were warranted because the BPRT lacked jurisdiction. Prohibition was confined to Nairobi BPRT Reference No. E1240 of 2025 and continuation of the same dispute under Cap. 301 on the subsisting lease; the requested prohibition of every possible future reference concerning the lease was too broad.

Ratio. Certiorari is available where a statutory tribunal acts without or in excess of jurisdiction. Prohibition is prospective and may prevent continuation of proceedings beyond jurisdiction, but judicial-review relief must correspond to the jurisdictional error established and cannot determine the competence of hypothetical future proceedings regardless of their circumstances.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

21. From the above, I find merit in the substantive notice of motion dated 8th December 2025, and I grant the following orders:-

Paragraph 21 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

20. As regards prohibition, the remedy is prospective in nature and is intended to prevent a tribunal from continuing proceedings in excess of its jurisdiction. Since the BPRT lacks jurisdiction over the particular tenancy, an order prohibiting continuation of Nairobi BPRT reference No. E1240 of 2025 is warranted. However, the prayer seeking to prohibit the tribunal from entertaining any other reference whatsoever concerning the lease is framed too broadly. Judicial review relief must correspond to the jurisdictional error established. The court cannot prospectively determine the competence of every hypothetical future proceeding, irrespective of its circumstances or subsequent changes in the parties’ legal relationship. The order of prohibition shall therefore be confined to the present reference and any continuation of the same dispute under Cap. 301 on the basis of the subsisting lease.

Paragraph 20 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

19. The second issue is whether the ex parte applicants are entitled to the judicial-review remedies sought. In Zakayo Michubu Kibuange v Lydia Kaguna Japheth & 2 others (supra), the court of appeal affirmed that certiorari is available where a statutory tribunal acts without or in excess of jurisdiction. Having found that the tenancy was not controlled, I am satisfied that the BPRT lacked jurisdiction to entertain Nairobi BPRT reference no. E1240 of 2025. The impugned orders issued on 11th and 14th November 2025, together with their subsequent extension on 26th November 2025, cannot stand.

Paragraph 19 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Pursuant to leave granted on 4th December 2025, the exparte applicants filed the substantive notice of motion dated 8th December 2025, brought under Article 159(2)(c) of the Constitution, Sections 2, 3, 6, 9, 12, 13 and 15 of the Landlord and Tenant (Shops, Hotels and Catering Establishments) Act, Sections 19 and 33 to 40 of the Companies Act, Section 6 of the Arbitration Act, and Order 53 of the Civil Procedure Rules seeking the…

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Despite service of these pleadings, the respondent and the interested party did not file any response to the substantive motion. The said motion was canvassed through written submissions. The ex parte applicants filed written submissions dated 10th July, 2026. I have considered the substantive motion, and the written submissions. The issue for determination is whether the BPRT acted without or in excess of its statutory jurisdiction…

Paragraph 7 →

Decision / orders

From the above, I find merit in the substantive notice of motion dated 8th December 2025, and I grant the following orders:-

Paragraph 21 →

Reasoning passage

Clause 5.1 of the lease deals with forfeiture. It provides among other circumstances, for the landlord’s remedies where rent remains unpaid, where the lessee fails to observe contractual covenants, or where specified insolvency-related events occur. I find these are default-based provisions and do not constitute an ordinary right to terminate the tenancy within five years otherwise than for breach of covenant.

Paragraph 10 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Business Premises Rent Tribunal (BPRT) acted without or in excess of statutory jurisdiction in entertaining Nairobi BPRT Reference No. E1240 of 2025 and issuing orders on 11, 14 and 26 November 2025; and whether certiorari and prohibition should…

Material facts

Acacia Supermarket Limited, the 1st ex parte applicant, entered a written lease dated 18 April 2025 with Dalton Saitoti over commercial premises at Acacia Pavilion, Kitengela, on Kajiado/Kaputiei-North/1006. The lease ran for five years and three months,…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELCLJR NO. E080 OF 2025

(FORMERLY KAJIADO ELCLJR NO. E020 OF 2025)

(FORMERLY NAIROBI ELCLJR NO. E078 OF 2025)

IN THE MATTER OF: AN APPLICATION FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW ORDERS OF CERTIORARI AND PROHIBITION

AND

IN THE MATTER OF: THE ILLEGAL ORDERS ISSUED BY THE BUSINESS PREMISES RENT TRIBUNAL (HON. JAMES NDEGWA, HON. JOYCE MURIGI & HON. PATRICK KITUR)

AND

IN THE MATTER OF: NAIROBI BUSINESS PREMISES RENT TRIBUNAL REFERENCE CASE NO. E1240 OF 2025 DALTON SAITOTI VS JOHN WAINAINA THUO T/A ACACIA SUPERMARKET LIMITED & JENNIFER WANGONDO

AND

IN THE MATTER OF: SECTIONS 2, 3, 6, 9, 12, 13, AND 15 OF THE LANDLORD TENANT (SHOPS, HOTELS AND CATERING ESTABLISHMENTS) ACT, Cap 301, LAWS OF KENYA

BETWEEN

REPUBLIC…...............................................................................APPLICANT

VERSUS

THE BUSINESS PREMISES RENT TRIBUNAL……..................RESPONDENT

AND

DALTON SAITOTI………...……………….......................….INTERESTED PARTY

AND

ACACIA SUPERMARKET LIMITED…...............…..1ST EXPARTE APPLICANT

JOHN WAINAINA THUO………………...............……2ND EXPARTE APPLICANT

JENNIFER WANGONDO……………...............………3RD EXPARTE APPLICANT

JUDGMENT

1. Pursuant to leave granted on 4th December 2025, the exparte applicants filed the substantive notice of motion dated 8th December 2025, brought under Article 159(2)(c) of the Constitution, Sections 2, 3, 6, 9, 12, 13 and 15 of the Landlord and Tenant (Shops, Hotels and Catering Establishments) Act, Sections 19 and 33 to 40 of the Companies Act, Section 6 of the Arbitration Act, and Order 53 of the Civil Procedure Rules seeking the following orders:-

1. That an order of certiorari to move into this court for purposes of quashing the proceedings and orders issued by the Business Premises Rent Tribunal on 11th and 14th November, 2025 (extended on 26th November, 2025) in Nairobi BPRT Reference Case No. E1240 of 2025 Dalton Saitoti v John Wainaina Thuo T/A Acacia Supermarket Limited & Jennifer Wangongo.

2. That an order of prohibition be granted to prevent the Business Premises Rent Tribunal from continuing, maintaining and sustaining any such proceedings against the ex-parte applicants herein either under Nairobi BPRT Reference Case No. E1240 of 2025 Dalton Saitoti v John Wainaina Thuo T/A Acacia Supermarket Limited & Jennifer Wangondo or any other reference whatsoever either before it or at all with respect to the Lease Agreement dated 18th April, 2025 between the 1st ex-parte applicant and the interested party.

3. That the honourable court be pleased to grant such other or further relief as it may deem fit in the circumstances.

4. That the costs of this application be borne by the respondent and interested party.

2. The application is premised on the grounds on its face and further supported by the affidavit of the 2nd exparte applicant sworn on even date. The 2nd ex parte applicant deposed that he is a director of the 1st ex parte applicant which entered into a written lease agreement dated 18th April, 2025 with the interested party, concerning commercial premises situated at Acacia Pavilion, Kitengela, on land parcel number Kajiado/Kaputiei-North/1006.

3. The ex parte applicants deposed that the lease was for a term exceeding five years and did not provide for termination otherwise than for breach of covenant within the first five years. They maintained that the tenancy is therefore not a controlled tenancy under Section 2 of the Landlord and Tenant (Shops, Hotels and Catering Establishments) Act, Cap. 301, and that the Business Premises Rent Tribunal lacked jurisdiction to entertain the interested party’s reference. They further deposed that the lease was executed between the 1st ex parte applicant and the interested party, and that the tribunal proceedings were improperly instituted against the 2nd and 3rd ex parte applicants in their individual capacities. They relied on clause 10.2 of the lease, which provides for arbitration of disputes arising from the agreement.

4. The ex parte applicants’ grievance arises from proceedings instituted by the interested party in Nairobi BPRT case no. E1240 of 2025 on 31st October, 2025. The interested party complained of harassment, threatened eviction, interference with quiet possession, failure to repair the premises and disputes concerning payment of rent. He sought orders restraining interference with his occupation and compelling the landlord to undertake repairs and accept rent through traceable means.

5. Following service of the reference, the 2nd and 3rd ex parte applicants filed an application dated 2nd November, 2025 challenging the tribunal's jurisdiction. When the matter came before the BPRT on 11th November 2025, the tribunal directed that the question of jurisdiction be determined first and gave directions for the filing of responses and submissions. It nevertheless ordered that the interested party be allowed quiet possession of the premises subject to continued payment of rent. The ex parte applicants deposed that a subsequent version of the order issued on 13th November, 2025 included a direction requiring the OCS, Kitengela police station, to ensure compliance, although such a direction had not been pronounced during the proceedings of 11th November, 2025.

6. It was further deposed that on 14th November 2025, the tribunal differently constituted, granted the interested party orders permitting him to break into the premises and resume occupation, together with orders requiring the respondents before the tribunal to respect his quiet possession and directing police assistance in enforcement. As a result, the ex parte applicants subsequently moved the tribunal to set aside the adverse orders. Instead, the tribunal proceeded to extend the impugned orders on 26th November, 2025 without first determining the pending jurisdictional challenge. In addition to the jurisdictional objection, the ex parte applicants deposed that the interested party misrepresented the status of his rent payments, improperly procured orders through the tribunal registry and failed to disclose material facts. They deposed that the interested party was in substantial rent arrears, while his affidavits before the tribunal dispute the alleged arrears and attribute the interruption of rent payments to the landlord’s interference with his business.

7. Despite service of these pleadings, the respondent and the interested party did not file any response to the substantive motion. The said motion was canvassed through written submissions. The ex parte applicants filed written submissions dated 10th July, 2026. I have considered the substantive motion, and the written submissions. The issue for determination is whether the BPRT acted without or in excess of its statutory jurisdiction and, consequently, whether the ex parte applicants are entitled to the orders of certiorari and prohibition.

8. The jurisdiction of the BPRT is derived from the Landlord and Tenant (Shops, Hotels and Catering Establishments) Act, Cap. 301. Section 12(1) empowers the tribunal to determine disputes concerning tenancies governed by the Act, including determining whether a tenancy is controlled. However, that jurisdiction must be read together with the definition of a controlled tenancy under Section 2. Section 2(1) of the Act defines a controlled tenancy, in the relevant part:-

“as a tenancy of a shop, hotel or catering establishment:

a. Which has not been reduced into writing; or

b. Which has been reduced into writing and which:

i. Is for a period not exceeding five years; or

ii. Contains provision for termination, otherwise than for breach of covenant, within five years from the commencement thereof; or

iii. Relates to premises of a class specified under subsection (2) of this section.”

9. I have perused the lease agreement dated 18th April, 2025. The term stipulated is five years and three months, with an expiry date of 18th July, 2030. The agreement is signed on behalf of the parties, and the interested party acknowledges the existence of a lease relationship in his affidavits before the tribunal. The court must therefore determine whether the agreement contains a provision permitting termination otherwise than for breach of covenant within five years of its commencement.

10. Clause 5.1 of the lease deals with forfeiture. It provides among other circumstances, for the landlord’s remedies where rent remains unpaid, where the lessee fails to observe contractual covenants, or where specified insolvency-related events occur. I find these are default-based provisions and do not constitute an ordinary right to terminate the tenancy within five years otherwise than for breach of covenant.

11. The fact that the lease may be determined before expiry in the circumstances contemplated by clause 5.1 does not, convert it into a controlled tenancy. The distinction under Section 2 is between termination for breach and termination otherwise than for breach. In Zakayo Michubu Kibuange v Lydia Kaguna Japheth & 2 others [2014] KECA 822 (KLR), the court of appeal considered a comparable dispute concerning a written lease for five years and three months and orders issued by BPRT. The court held as follows:- 

“Confronted with such evidence, we doubt that the judge would have reached any other conclusion than that the sub-lease agreement had been reduced into writing and was for a period of 5 years and 3 months.  Accordingly, the sub-lease agreement did not fall within the armbit of controlled tenancies as contemplated by Cap 301.  This being the case, it follows logically that the 2nd respondent lacked jurisdiction to entertain and arbitrate over a dispute turning the on sub-lease.” 

12. This position was reiterated in Ganjoni Properties Limited & 11 others v Al-Riaz International Limited; F. Kinyua Kamundi & Muyaa D. T t/a Kinyua Muyaa & Co. Advocates & 11 others (Affected Party) [2025] KECA 1711 (KLR) where the court of appeal reproduced the statutory definition of a controlled tenancy, including the requirement that a written lease exceeding five years must contain a provision for termination otherwise than for breach within five years before it falls under the Act.

13. In applying the statutory definition and the foregoing authorities, I find that the tenancy created by the written lease dated 18th April, 2025 is not a controlled tenancy within the meaning of Section 2 of Cap. 301. Consequently, the tribunal lacked jurisdiction under the Act to entertain the reference filed by the interested party and to grant substantive relief arising from that tenancy. It is worth noting that the question of jurisdiction had been raised before the tribunal through the application dated 2nd November, 2025. The orders issued on 11th November, 2025 expressly directed that jurisdiction be determined first. Notwithstanding this direction, the tribunal proceeded to grant orders protecting the interested party’s possession of the suit property, followed by the break-in orders of 14th November, 2025.

14. I am alive to the fact that the tribunal may make appropriate procedural directions while considering its own jurisdiction. However, that does not confer substantive jurisdiction where the subject matter falls outside the statute establishing the tribunal. In this case, the orders directing quiet possession and authorizing entry into the premises went beyond the mere preservation of an opportunity to determine jurisdiction. In my view, the tribunal could not derive jurisdiction from the urgency of the interested party’s complaints.

15. The ex parte applicants also rely on clause 10.2 of the lease agreement. Having examined the same, I note that it provides for resolution of disputes through the courts or arbitration at the sole option of the lessor, following unsuccessful amicable discussions. It does not impose a mandatory obligation upon the parties to refer every dispute exclusively to arbitration. I do not consider it necessary to determine whether Section 6 of the Arbitration Act was properly invoked. The absence of jurisdiction under Cap. 301 is sufficient to dispose the issue of jurisdiction.

16. As regards the contention that the proceedings were improperly instituted against the 2nd and 3rd ex parte applicants personally, the lease identifies the 1st ex parte applicant as the contracting lessor. The separate legal personality of the company is relevant to the proper identification of the parties responsible under the lease. However, the question whether either individual incurred an independent legal obligation need not be conclusively determined in this judicial-review application. The tribunal’s want of jurisdiction is dispositive.

17. The ex parte applicants further alleged that an altered version of the orders issued on 11th November, 2025 was issued on 13th November 2025, introducing a direction requiring the OCS Kitengela to assist in enforcement. I have seen the two versions of the said orders. The version issued on 11th November, 2025 provides for quiet possession and continued payment of rent, while the latter version includes police assistance. The discrepancy is apparent. Without any evidence controverting the inclusion of orders not granted initially, there is proof that the respondent unprocedurally issued unlawful orders.

18. The allegations concerning rent arrears are disputed. The ex parte applicants claim that substantial arrears had accrued, while the interested party in the proceedings before the tribunal maintained that he had paid the rent due for the premises occupied and disputed liability for rent relating to the unfinished second floor. These questions concern the parties’ contractual rights and obligations under the lease. They do not require determination for purposes of the present judicial-review proceedings, whose main concern is the tribunal’s jurisdiction. I will not make any findings on the existence or amount of rent arrears, the lawfulness of the alleged lockout or the interested party’s entitlement to damages.

19. The second issue is whether the ex parte applicants are entitled to the judicial-review remedies sought. In Zakayo Michubu Kibuange v Lydia Kaguna Japheth & 2 others (supra), the court of appeal affirmed that certiorari is available where a statutory tribunal acts without or in excess of jurisdiction. Having found that the tenancy was not controlled, I am satisfied that the BPRT lacked jurisdiction to entertain Nairobi BPRT reference no. E1240 of 2025. The impugned orders issued on 11th and 14th November 2025, together with their subsequent extension on 26th November 2025, cannot stand.

20. As regards prohibition, the remedy is prospective in nature and is intended to prevent a tribunal from continuing proceedings in excess of its jurisdiction. Since the BPRT lacks jurisdiction over the particular tenancy, an order prohibiting continuation of Nairobi BPRT reference No. E1240 of 2025 is warranted. However, the prayer seeking to prohibit the tribunal from entertaining any other reference whatsoever concerning the lease is framed too broadly. Judicial review relief must correspond to the jurisdictional error established. The court cannot prospectively determine the competence of every hypothetical future proceeding, irrespective of its circumstances or subsequent changes in the parties’ legal relationship. The order of prohibition shall therefore be confined to the present reference and any continuation of the same dispute under Cap. 301 on the basis of the subsisting lease.

21. From the above, I find merit in the substantive notice of motion dated 8th December 2025, and I grant the following orders:-

i. An order of certiorari is hereby issued removing into this court and quashing the proceedings and orders of the Business Premises Rent Tribunal in Nairobi BPRT reference no. E1240 of 2025, including the orders issued on 11th and 14th November, 2025 and extended on 26th November, 2025.

ii. An order of prohibition is hereby issued prohibiting the Business Premises Rent Tribunal from continuing or further entertaining Nairobi BPRT reference no. E1240 of 2025 concerning the tenancy created by the lease agreement dated 18th April 2025, for want of jurisdiction under the Landlord and Tenant (Shops, Hotels and Catering Establishments) Act, Cap. 301.

iii. The ex parte applicants shall have costs of the substantive motion and the impugned proceedings before the Business Premises Rent Tribunal. The same shall be borne by the interested party.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED IN VIRTUAL COURT

THIS 5TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026.

HON. MBOGO C.G.

JUDGE

05/11/2026.

In the presence of:

Mr. Benson Agunga - Court assistant

Mr. Otieno holding brief for Mr. Kere for the Ex-parte Applicant

Interested party - present in person

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder