REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC CASE NO. 991 OF 2015
MILLICENT MUTHONI MAINA……………….............………………..PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
MARY NYAKINYUA MURICHU…………………….............………..DEFENDANT
AND
JAMES MBURU IKABA.......INTENDED INTERESTED PARTY/APPLICANT
RULING
1. Before this court for determination is the notice of motion dated 18th March 2026, and the notice of preliminary objection dated 28th May, 2026 respectively. The notice of motion is filed by the intended interested party/applicant and it is expressed to be brought under Order 1 Rule 10(2), Order 10 Rule 11, Order 22 Rule 25, Order 40 Rules 1 and 2(1), and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, Sections 1A, 1B and 3A of the Civil Procedure Act and Articles 40, 50 and 159 of the Constitution seeking the following orders:-
1. Spent.
2. That the applicant, James Mburu Ikaba, be enjoined as an interested party in this suit.
3. That Kiambu Dandora Farmers Company Limited be enjoined as a necessary party to these proceedings.
4. Pending the hearing and determination of this application, a temporary injunction do issue restraining the plaintiff’s by themselves, servants, agents or otherwise from entering, trespassing, harassing, intimidating, threatening, provoking, inciting, or otherwise howsoever interfering with the intended interested party’s quiet enjoyment, possession and occupation of plot no. 388 on L.R No. 11379/3 (the suit property).
5. That this honourable court do review and set aside the judgement delivered on the 9th June, 2022 and all other subsequent orders.
6. That in the alternative, the judgment be stayed/held in abeyance pending determination of the pending ELC Petition No. 47 of 2011 challenging the compulsory acquisition of land belonging to Kiambu Dandora.
7. That the costs of this application be provided for.
2. The application is premised on the grounds on its face and the supporting affidavit of the intended interested party/applicant sworn on even date. The intended interested party/applicant deposed that he purchased plot no. 388, the suit property from Kiambu Dandora Farmers Company Limited, which he describes as the original owner of the mother title, L.R. No. 11379/3. He deposed that he has been in possession of the same since 2014, having developed the property and erected permanent structures thereon.
3. The intended interested party/applicant deposed that the suit proceeded to judgment without his knowledge or participation, notwithstanding his proprietary interest in the property. Further, that the execution of the judgment threatens his occupation and developments. Further, that the root title of the suit property is traceable to Kiambu Dandora Farmers Company Limited which was not joined in these proceedings. He further challenged the plaintiff's chain of title and relied on the existence of ELC Petition No. 47 of 2011, which he deposed concerns the legality of the compulsory acquisition of the mother title.
4. The application was opposed through the replying affidavit of the plaintiff/respondent sworn on 28th May, 2026. The plaintiff/respondent averred that the dispute was conclusively determined by the judgment delivered on 30th June 2022, and that the intended interested party/applicant has not demonstrated any proprietary interest capable of defeating that judgment. She further disputed his alleged occupation, the authenticity and sufficiency of his ownership documents, and his assertion that he was unaware of the proceedings.
5. The plaintiff/respondent further deposed that eviction orders were issued against Ferides Njoki Njoroge, trading as Pioneer Hardware, and that she subsequently took possession of the suit property pursuant to the court’s orders. She deposed that the intended interested party/applicant’s claim is an attempt to reopen concluded litigation and obstruct execution.
6. In response thereto, the intended interested party/applicant filed the supplementary affidavit sworn on 23rd July, 2026 and reiterated that he was never served with the proceedings and further, that Ferides Njoki Njoroge was his tenant. He relied on a judgment delivered on 28th June 2018 in National Bank of Kenya v Pipeplastic Samkolit (K) Ltd, Prof. Samson Kegengo Ongeri & Jesus Hernandz Dela Rosa, Civil Suit No. 432 of 2006, and an alleged subsequent discharge of a charge over L.R. No. 209/9499. He deposed that these documents constitute new and material evidence affecting the plaintiff/respondent’s root of title.
7. The plaintiff/respondent filed the notice of preliminary objection dated 28th May, 2026 challenging the instant application on the following grounds: -
1. That the intended interested party/applicant’s application dated 18th March, 2026 is fatally defective, incompetent, misconceived and an abuse of the process of this honourable court.
2. That the application is res judicata pursuant to Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act as the issues concerning ownership and proprietary rights over the suit property Plot No. 191 Kwa Miwaa Umoja III were substantially and conclusively heard and determined by this honourable court vide the judgment delivered on 30th June, 2022.
3. That the intended interested party/applicant is improperly attempting to reopen, relitigate issues already conclusively determined by this honourable court through a collateral process disguised as joinder, injunction, stay and review proceedings.
4. That this honourable court became functus officio upon delivery of its final judgment on 30th June, 2022 and therefore lacks jurisdiction to reopen, rehear and redetermine the merits of the dispute as sought by the intended interested party/applicant.
5. That the application does not satisfy the mandatory legal threshold for review under Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules as:
a. no discovery of new and important matter or evidence has been demonstrated;
b. no error apparent on the face of the record has been established;
c. no sufficient reason has been advanced to warrant review and/or setting aside of the judgment;
d. the application has been brought after inordinate and unexplained delay.
6. That the intended interested party/applicant lacks locus to seek joinder of a third party, Kiambu Dandora Farmers Company Limited, review, setting aside and/or stay of a judgment in proceedings to which he was never a party to.
7. That the participation of an interested party in this suit is limited, a fact that the supreme court has pronounced itself as in the case of Methodist Church in Kenya v. Mohamed Fugicha & 3 Others (Petition 16 of 2016).
8. That the applicant’s alleged claim lies independently against the persons from whom he allegedly acquired the suit property and not against the plaintiff/respondent who obtained a lawful judgment after full hearing.
9. That the application is intended to delay and defeat execution of a lawful decree and deny the plaintiff/respondent the fruits of judgment.
10. That the intended joinder of Kiambu Dandora Farmers Company Limited at the execution stage is legally untenable, prejudicial and intended to reopen this suit contrary to the law on res judicata.
11. That allowing the intended interested party/applicant’s application would occasion grave prejudice to the plaintiff/respondent and contravene the principles of finality of litigation and administration of justice.
12. That the application is thus bad in law and an abuse of court process and should be dismissed with costs.
8. The application and the preliminary objection were canvassed through written submissions. The intended interested party/applicant filed written submissions dated 23rd July, 2026. By the time of writing this ruling, the plaintiff/respondent had not filed her written submissions. Be that as it may, I have considered the application, the replies thereof, the notice of preliminary objection and the written submissions. The issues for determination are whether the preliminary objection has merit, and whether the intended interested party/applicant has established grounds for joinder, review, stay or the injunctive relief sought.
9. I will begin with the notice of preliminary objection. In Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] EA 696, the court held that a preliminary objection raises a pure point of law which, if upheld, may dispose of the proceedings. It must proceed on the assumption that the facts pleaded by the opposing party are correct and cannot properly be raised where disputed facts require ascertainment.
10. The plaintiff/respondent ground on res judicata is founded on Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act which provides as follows:-
“No court shall try any suit or issue in which the matter directly and substantially in issue has been directly and substantially in issue in a former suit between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title, in a court competent to try such subsequent suit or the suit in which such issue has been subsequently raised, and has been heard and finally decided by such court.
Explanation. —(1) The expression 'former suit' means a suit which has been decided before the suit in question whether or not it was instituted before it.
Explanation. —(2) For the purposes of this section, the competence of a court shall be determined irrespective of any provision as to right of appeal from the decision of that court.
Explanation. —(3) The matter above referred to must in the former suit have been alleged by one party and either denied or admitted, expressly or impliedly, by the other.
Explanation. —(4) Any matter which might and ought to have been made ground of defence or attack in such former suit shall be deemed to have been a matter directly and substantially in issue in such suit
Explanation. —(5) Any relief claimed in a suit, which is not expressly granted by the decree shall, for the purposes of this section, be deemed to have been refused.
Explanation. —(6) Where persons litigate bona fide in respect of a public right or of a private right claimed in common for themselves and others, all persons interested in such right shall, for the purposes of this section, be deemed to claim under the persons so litigating.”
11. From the above, it will be observed that for res judicata to apply, the issue in the latter suit must have been directly and substantially in issue in the former suit, between the same parties, or between parties under whom they are litigating. The court of appeal in the case of Uhuru Highway Development Ltd V Central Bank & Others, CA No. 36 of 1996 held that:-
“In order to rely on the defence of res judicata, there must be a previous suit in which the matter was in issue; the parties must have been the same or litigating under the same title; a competent court must have heard the matter in issue and the issue is raised once again in the fresh suit.”
12. In applying the above principles to the circumstances of this case, I noted two main issues. The application seeks orders to review and set aside the judgement of the court delivered on 9th June, 2022. From the record, the judgment in this matter was delivered on 30th June, 2022. Secondly, in this matter, the plaintiff sought orders with respect to plot 191 situate at Kwa Miwaa, Umoja III. The intended interested party/ applicant asserts ownership over the property known as plot no. 388 on LR no. 11379/3. On the face of it, it appears that these are two distinct properties and the intended interested party/applicant has not shown that they are one and the same albeit stating that the allocation of the suit property (mother title) is contested.
13. It is clear that the intended interested party/applicant was not a party to the proceedings that culminated in the judgment delivered on 30th June, 2022. Whether he claims through a party bound by that judgment, whether his asserted interest is genuinely independent and whether he acquired such interest before the suit are matters which require consideration of the documentary evidence. These issues cannot be conclusively determined from the face of the preliminary objection.
14. The plaintiff/respondent also argued that this court is functus officio. While the doctrine ordinarily prevents a court from reopening a dispute already conclusively determined, it does not extinguish the review jurisdiction expressly conferred by Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 of the Civil Procedure Rules. The objections concerning the authenticity of the intended interested party/applicant’s proprietary documents, his knowledge of the proceedings, the alleged delay and the sufficiency of the evidence relied upon for review similarly require an examination of the affidavits and annexures. These questions are only appropriate for determination in an application. I find that the notice of preliminary objection, as framed, cannot dispose of the application purely as a matter of law. The same is declined, and I will proceed to determine the merits of the application.
15. Turning to the notice of motion, the intended interested party/applicant first seeks joinder under Order 1 Rule 10(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules. The discretion to join a party is intended to facilitate the effective and complete adjudication of the questions in controversy. However, the stage at which joinder is sought and its intended effect upon the proceedings are material considerations. In JMK v MWM & another [2015] KECA 524 (KLR), the court of appeal observed that: - “Order 1 Rule (10)(2) contemplates an application for amendment or joinder of parties where proceedings are still pending before the Court.” The court nevertheless recognized that exceptional circumstances may justify reopening proceedings where a person has been directly condemned without being heard.
16. The scope of participation of an interested party was addressed in the case of Coalition for Reforms and Development (CORD) & 2 others v Republic of Kenya & another [2024] KECA 1955 (KLR), where the court of appeal at paragraph 126, while considering the supreme court’s jurisprudence on interested parties reiterated the principle that an interested party cannot introduce new questions for determination outside the issues raised by the principal parties. The court further considered Methodist Church in Kenya v Fugicha & 3 Others [2019] KESC 59 (KLR), particularly paragraph 53, which addresses the limits of an interested party’s participation.
17. In this case, judgment was delivered on 30th June, 2022 following determination of the dispute between the plaintiff and the defendant. The intended interested party/applicant seeks joinder nearly four years thereafter, to challenge the proprietary rights upon which the judgment was founded. He also seeks to introduce Kiambu Dandora Farmers Company Limited, a separate entity which is not itself an applicant before this court.
18. I have evaluated the intended interested party’s/applicant’s assertion that he purchased the property from Kiambu Dandora Farmers Company Limited and has occupied the same since 2014. The documentary evidence in support of this contention shows that he has a competing claim against the property. This does not establish that his interest is superior to that determined in the judgment or that he must be admitted into concluded proceedings in order to vindicate that claim. More importantly, and as stated earlier, it has not been shown whether plot 191 and 388 are one and the same. In my view, the intended interested party/applicant seeks to introduce an independent chain of title and challenge findings already made after trial. Granting joinder for this purpose would require reopening the pleadings and substantially reconsidering the ownership dispute yet the properties on the face of it are distinct.
19. Having found that joinder of the intended interested party/applicant cannot issue, I find no need to determine the prayers for review and setting aside as well as the orders of injunction sought. The notice of motion dated 18th March 2026, and the notice of preliminary objection dated 28th May 2026 both lack merit and they are hereby dismissed. Each party to bear its own costs.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED IN VIRTUAL COURT
THIS 5TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026.
HON. MBOGO C.G.
JUDGE
05/11/2026.
In the presence of:
Mr. Benson Agunga - Court assistant
Mr. Thuo for the Plaintiff
No appearance for Mbichire & Company Advocates for the Interested Party/Applicant