Land law

Vinya Wa Aka Group & 19 others v Ensi Investment Ltd [2026] KEELC 7488 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Misc Application 49 of 2018
Judgment date
5 November 2026

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Question before the court

The starting point on the first issue of whether the decree was clear as to the obligations imposed is the decree itself. The dispute between the parties was referred to arbitration, resulting in an award dated 2nd February 2018 and a correction dated 29th March 2018. By the ruling delivered on 29th July 2021, the Court dismissed the Respondent’s application to set aside the award and allowed its enforcement. The decree was…

Paragraph 13 →

Reasoning passage

The Court finds that the terms of the decree were clear and unambiguous and the decree stated clearly and unequivocally what should and should not be done.

Paragraph 18 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT MILIMANI

ELC MISC APPLICATION NO. 49 OF 2018

IN THE MATTER OF ENFORCEMENT OF AN ARBITRATION AWARD

1. VINYA WA AKA GROUP

2. VINYA WA AKA INVESTMENT COMPANY LTD

3. JANE WANZA MUTINDA

4. TERESIA MUTINDA

5. JOYCE NTHENYA KIITI

6. NDUNGE KIITI

7. RHODA MUENI MUSYOKA

8. FLORENCE NTHAMBI MUTHUSI

9. DOLLY WANZA KIVUVANA

10. RUTH KAMENGELE

11. WAKI LOIS MUTANY'A WAMBUA

12. FLORENCE MWIKALI KIITI

13. ALICE MANG’ELI MBINDU

14. FLORA NDUKU MUTISO

15. RUTH NDANU GICHOHI

16. DORIS MUTINDI KIOKO

17. CHRISTINE M. WASANGA

18. ANCHOR BUILDING TECHNOLOGIES LTD

19. APEX HOLDINGS LIMITED

20. NAMAKAO CAPITAL LIMITED………………………...APPLICANTS

VERSUS

ENSI INVESTMENT LIMITED ……………………………. RESPONDENT

RULING

1. The Applicants filed the Notice of Motion dated 28th October 2026 under Section 5 of the Judicature Act, sections 3A and 63 of the Civil Procedure Act and Article 159 of the Constitution seeking the following orders:

1) THAT Harun Osoro Nyamboki, Michael Nyabuto Nyamute, Hezron Nyabwari Osoro and Boniface Odhiambo Okello and or any other director of M/S Ensi Investments Limited, the Respondent be committed to civil jail for a period of six (6) months for disobedience of the Decree dated 29th July 2021 and issued on 31st January 2024.

2) THAT any other or further order as the court may deem appropriate.

3) THAT costs of the application be provided for.

2. The application is supported by the Supporting affidavit sworn by the 7th Applicant on 7th October 2025 and supplementary affidavit sworn on 15th June 2026 and the grounds set out on the face of the application. The Applicants contend that by a ruling dated 29th July 2020 the Court dismissed an application by the Respondent herein to set aside an arbitral award and confirmed the said arbitral award.

3. The Applicants state that on 31st January 2024, the Court issued a decree in terms of the arbitral award whose terms are set out elsewhere in this ruling. The decree was served upon the Respondent through its advocates and that the Respondent failed to issue the subdivision titles and completion documents despite the Applicants’ efforts to secure compliance. They state that, on 23rd June 2025, they forwarded a balance of Kshs. 113,800 in professional fees for the 3rd, 5th and 14th Claimants. They maintain that the Respondent has introduced charges described as completion costs, development approval costs and change-of-use charges which were not provided for in the award or decree.

4. The Applicants further contend that they are ready to pay stamp duty and registration fees upon being advised of the sums payable. They argue that the Respondent’s continued failure to complete the transfers undermines the authority of the Court and that its directors should be held personally accountable for the non-compliance.

5. In response, the Respondent denies wilful disobedience. It states that the delay has arisen from unresolved accounts, outstanding amounts and the need to reconcile the sums payable by individual claimants. It maintains that the professional fees and completion costs include statutory, professional and other attendant expenses and that a sum of Kshs. 1,247,998.50 remains outstanding in respect of six claimants.

6. The Respondent further states that the 17th Claimant, Christine M. Wasanga, paid the outstanding balance and collected her title documents. It maintains that it is willing to execute the necessary documents once the accounts have been reconciled and the outstanding sums settled. It consequently submits that committal is premature and that the Applicants should pursue the appropriate execution procedure. In the alternative, it proposes an accounting exercise or mediation.

Parties’ submissions

7. The Applicants submit that the Respondent and its advocates had knowledge of the decree and that service upon counsel was sufficient notice. They rely on Shimmers Plaza Limited v National Bank of Kenya Limited in support of the proposition that knowledge of a court order is material to contempt proceedings. They argue that the Respondent cannot impose obligations that were not contained in the decree and that its failure to issue the titles amounts to disobedience of a binding court order.

8. The Applicants also rely on the principle that court orders must be obeyed for the proper administration of justice. They contend that the Respondent’s explanation concerning additional charges does not excuse non-compliance with the decree.

9. The Respondent submits that the application is incompetent, premature and an abuse of the court process because the Applicants have not exhausted the available modes of execution under the Civil Procedure Act and the Civil Procedure Rules. It relies on section 38 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 22 of the Civil Procedure Rules, arguing that execution should first be pursued against the company as the judgment debtor.

10. The Respondent further submits that the decree is against the company and not its directors personally. It argues that the Applicants have neither established a legal basis for lifting the corporate veil nor demonstrated that any of the named directors personally obstructed execution. It relies on Jiwa v Idrata Developers Limited, Vimal Velji Shah v Chemafrica Limited & 5 Others and the principles governing the separate legal personality of a company.

11. The Respondent also maintains that the amount outstanding remains disputed and that the decree’s requirement for payment of professional fees has not been satisfied in respect of all the claimants concerned. It urges the Court to dismiss the application.

Analysis and Determination

12. From the application, the supporting and supplementary affidavits, the replying affidavit and the written submissions filed by the parties, the following issues arise for determination:

i. Whether the decree was clear as to the obligations imposed upon the Respondent and the conditions attached to their performance.

ii. Whether the Respondent and the directors sought to be committed had knowledge of the decree.

iii. Whether the Respondent’s failure to complete the transfers amounts to wilful disobedience, particularly in view of the dispute concerning additional charges.

iv. Whether the named directors may personally be committed for the company’s alleged non-compliance.

v. Whether the Applicants have established a proper basis for committal and what orders should issue.

13. The starting point on the first issue of whether the decree was clear as to the obligations imposed is the decree itself. The dispute between the parties was referred to arbitration, resulting in an award dated 2nd February 2018 and a correction dated 29th March 2018. By the ruling delivered on 29th July 2021, the Court dismissed the Respondent’s application to set aside the award and allowed its enforcement. The decree was subsequently issued on 31st January 2024 and stated as follows:

1) THAT the application dated 21st September 2020 be and is hereby dismissed and the Respondents are awarded costs of the suit.

2) THAT the claims by the 19th and 20th Claimants fail for lack of participation in the Arbitration and are dismissed with no orders as to costs.

3) THAT the Respondent was indeed a Trustee for the Claimants for purposes of the project relating to L.R. No. Mavoko Town Block 3/2359 as it purchased the land using money contributed by members who included the Claimants.

4) THAT the sale agreement with the Claimants was for plots measuring ¼ of an acre but since the subsequent subdivision was for plots measuring ⅛ of an acre, each purchaser who bought ¼ of an acre as per the agreement is entitled to two plots measuring ⅛ of an acre.

5) THAT the Claimants paid the entire consideration as set out in the sale agreement, Kshs. 500,000/- per plot and Kshs. 50,000/- for membership fees.

6) THAT the Claimants are liable to pay Kshs. 27,300/- per plot for professional/consultants’ fees as agreed in the meetings of the company. Therefore, the Claimants should get credit for any Claimant who has a balance should pay and if there is any money paid in excess of Kshs. 550,000/- towards the subdivision process that is over and above the sum of Kshs. 550,000/- per plot the Respondent should refund the balance.

7) THAT the plots allocated to the 3rd to 17th Claimants are not in dispute and the Respondent should sign the transfer forms and issue the relevant completion documents upon payment of the professional fees.

8) THAT for avoidance of doubt, the stamp duty and registration fees are payable by the Claimants.

9) THAT regarding the plots allocated to the 1st and 2nd Claimants, it is held as follows:—

i. The joint surveyor has confirmed that 6 plots allocated to the Claimants for development and are of the right size. Therefore, the Respondent should issue transfer forms and relevant completion documents for these plots namely L.R. No. Mavoko Town Block 3/13197, 13198, 13199, 13200, 13201, 13202.

ii. Plot No. 13203 is located in a gulley and is therefore not capable of development.

iii. Since the Claimants are entitled to 10 plots in total, the Respondent should allocate additional four plots measuring ⅛ of an acre each and issue the transfer forms and completion documents.

10) THAT the Counterclaim is not merited and it is hereby dismissed.

11) THAT each party to bear own costs but share, on equal basis, the Arbitrator’s fees and costs of arbitration.

14. In the case of Sheila Cassatt Issenberg & another v Antony Machatha Kinyanjui [2021] eKLR  Justice Mwita (as he then was) cited with approval the Supreme Court of Canada decision in Carey v. Laiken, 2015 SCC 17, outlining the three essential ingredients required to find a party in civil contempt as follows;

“The Cromwell J, writing for the Supreme of Canada in Carey v Laiken, 2015 SCC 17 (16th April 2015), expounded on the three elements of civil contempt of court which must be established to the satisfaction of the court, thus:

i) The order alleged to have been breached “must state clearly and unequivocally what should and should not be done.” This ensures that a party will not be found in contempt where an order is unclear. An order may be found to be unclear if, for example, it is missing an essential detail about where, when or to whom it applies; if it incorporates overly broad language; or if external circumstances have obscured its meaning.

ii) The party alleged to have breached the order must have had actual knowledge of it. It may be possible to infer knowledge in the circumstances, or an alleged contemnor may attract liability on the basis of the willful blindness doctrine.

iii) The party alleged to be in breach must have intentionally done the act that the order prohibits or intentionally failed to do the act that the order compels. (emphasis)”

15. In the present case, the decree found that the Respondent held the land comprised in L.R. No. Mavoko Town Block 3/2359 in trust for the claimants for purposes of the project. It further found that the claimants had paid the purchase consideration of Kshs. 500,000 per plot and membership fees of Kshs. 50,000.

16. The decree also provided for professional or consultant fees of Kshs. 27,300 per plot, with credit for payments made towards subdivision in excess of Kshs. 550,000. A claimant with an outstanding balance was required to pay it, while the Respondent was required to refund any amount paid in excess of the sum properly payable under the decree.

17. In relation to the 3rd to 17th Claimants, the decree directed the Respondent to sign the transfer forms and issue the relevant completion documents upon payment of the professional fees. In relation to the 1st and 2nd Claimants, the decree directed the Respondent to issue transfer forms and completion documents for the six identified plots and to allocate four additional plots measuring one-eighth of an acre each, together with the relevant documents. Stamp duty and registration fees were payable by the claimants.

18. The Court finds that the terms of the decree were clear and unambiguous and the decree stated clearly and unequivocally what should and should not be done.

19. On the question of whether the Respondent and the directors had knowledge of the decree. The Applicants state that the decree was forwarded to the Respondent’s advocates by a letter dated 7th March 2024. The Respondent does not materially dispute knowledge of the decree. Further, the Replying Affidavit sworn by Mr. Nyamboki demonstrates that he was aware of the proceedings and the obligations arising from the award and decree.

20. In Shimmers Plaza Limited v National Bank of Kenya Limited [2015] KECA 945 (KLR), the Court of Appeal stated:

“Would the knowledge of the judgment or order by the advocate of the alleged contemnor suffice for contempt proceedings? We hold the view that it does. This is more so in a case such as this one where the advocate was in Court representing the alleged contemnor and the orders were made in his presence.”

21. On the evidence before the Court, the Respondent had knowledge of the decree. Mr. Nyamboki’s affidavit also demonstrates his personal knowledge. In the Court’s view, for the Applicant to succeed in contempt proceedings against the directors, they were required to demonstrate that all the directors had actual knowledge of the terms of the decree or proper notice thereof. The material before the Court does not, however, sufficiently establish the individual knowledge and conduct of each of the other named directors merely by reason of their positions in the company. In the present case actual knowledge of the terms of the decree has not been proved on the part of the other directors cited apart from Mr. Nyamboki.

22. The other issue for determination is whether the alleged failure amounts to wilful disobedience. Contempt proceedings require proof of a deliberate breach of a clear court order. In Mutitika v Baharini Farm Ltd [1985] KECA 60 (KLR), the Court of Appeal stated:

“In our view the standard of proof in contempt proceedings must be higher than proof on the balance of probabilities, almost but not exactly, beyond reasonable doubt.”

The Court further held that:

“the guilt of a contemnor has to be proved with such strictness of proof as is consistent with the gravity of the charge.”

23. These principles require the Court to examine the specific obligation alleged to have been breached, the knowledge of the alleged contemnor and the evidence of deliberate disobedience. The fact that the Respondent has not issued all the completion documents does not, without more, establish that the named directors have committed contempt.

24. The Applicants assert that the only outstanding professional fees were Kshs. 113,800, which they paid by cheque. The Respondent, on the other hand, maintains that Kshs. 1,247,998.50 remains outstanding in respect of six claimants. The parties are therefore in disagreement over the sums properly payable and the conditions for completion of the transfers.

25. The decree provides at order (6) for professional and consultant fees of Kshs. 27,300 per plot and requires the Respondent to account for payments made towards subdivision, including credits and refunds where applicable. It also requires the claimants to pay stamp duty and registration fees. These provisions must be read together when determining whether the conditions for the issue of completion documents have been met.

26. The Respondent’s demand for additional charges described as completion costs, development approval costs and change-of-use charges raises a substantive question. The decree does not provide for those separate charges. The Respondent was therefore required to demonstrate the basis upon which it considered them recoverable under the decree or otherwise lawfully payable before treating them as conditions for completion. In the Court’s view the charges that the decree declares must be paid before execution of transfer

27. Where the Respondent considered the decree unclear as to the scope of the fees payable, the appropriate course was to seek clarification or directions from the Court executing the decree. It was not entitled to vary the decree or introduce additional conditions unilaterally. Its failure to seek clarification is relevant to the assessment of its conduct, but does not by itself prove contempt by each director.

28. Equally, the Court cannot determine the disputed accounts merely by accepting the Applicants’ assertion that all sums due have been paid. The evidence must establish the payments made by each claimant, the credits applicable under the decree, any balance properly outstanding and whether the relevant statutory fees have been addressed.

29. Taking into account the positions taken by both parties concerning what was due and payable to the Defendants arising from the decree on a condition-precedent to the signing of the transfer, the court is not satisfied that the applicant has proved that the Defendant or the parties cited willfully disobeyed the decree of the court. The place where this issue would have been determined was during the execution process.

30. The dispute over the amounts payable by individual claimants and whether the conditions for transfer have been satisfied falls within the execution court’s jurisdiction under section 34. Those questions must be resolved by reference to the decree and the evidence, rather than by assuming that every condition has been met or that every failure to issue a title is necessarily wilful disobedience.

31. Section 34(1) of the Civil Procedure Act provides:

All questions arising between the parties to the suit in which the decree was passed, or their representatives, and relating to the execution, discharge or satisfaction of the decree, shall be determined by the court executing the decree and not by a separate suit.

32. In Peter O. Ngoge t/a O.P. Ngoge & Associates v Ammu Investment Company Limited [2024] KECA 1690 (KLR), the Court of Appeal considered an application seeking, among other relief, the committal of the directors of a company for failure to satisfy a decree. At paragraph 18, the Court stated:

“Turning to the prayer for the directors of the respondent to be committed to civil jail for disobeying the orders issued by Khaminwa, J, while we appreciate that the decree has never been challenged by way of an appeal and the fact that the respondent and its directors have at all times been aware of the said decree, we fully associate ourselves with the finding of the trial court that the applicant, having commenced execution proceedings under the Civil Procedure Rules, it is only proper that he exhausts all the available modes of execution therein.”

The Court further stated:

“In addition, the applicant has not detailed any actions of the directors of the respondent which could have prevented him from executing the decree. In the circumstances, we are unable to grant an order citing the directors of the respondent for contempt of court. Consequently, the order to commit the said directors to civil jail for a period of six months cannot issue.”

33. The decision is relevant because it requires the Court to consider the available execution process and whether the directors personally obstructed the satisfaction of the decree. In the present matter, the decree requires the Respondent to execute transfer forms and issue completion documents.

34. Order 22 rule 31 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides a procedure for execution of a document where a judgment debtor neglects or refuses to execute a document required by a decree. The Applicants have not demonstrated that they invoked that procedure or otherwise pursued the available execution mechanisms before seeking the immediate committal of the directors.

35. The Respondent’s failure to seek clarification of the decree or to establish the basis for its additional charges does not relieve it of its obligations. Nevertheless, the present application requires proof of wilful disobedience and personal responsibility. The outstanding questions concerning accounts and completion requirements cannot, without more, sustain an order committing the directors to civil jail.

36. On the issue of whether the directors may personally be committed for the company’s non-compliance, the decree herein was issued against Ensi Investment Limited, a company with a legal personality distinct from that of its directors. The principle was affirmed by the Court of Appeal in Riccatti Business College of East Africa Limited v Kyanzavi Farmers Company Limited [2016] KECA 763 (KLR), where the Court stated:

“[A company] as a body corporate, is persona juridica, with a separate independent identity in law, distinct from its shareholders, directors and agents unless there are factors warranting a lifting of the veil.”

37. The separate legal personality of a company does not confer immunity where the evidence establishes a lawful basis for holding a director personally responsible. However, directorship alone does not make a director personally liable for every act or omission of the company. The Court must identify the legal basis for personal responsibility and the conduct attributable to the individual concerned.

38. The Court of Appeal in Muli & another v South Eastern Kenya University & 2 others [2024] KECA 1597 (KLR) while confirming the committal to civil jail of directors of a company, affirmed the position that a company operates and undertakes actions through its directors and that a director who is in office becomes responsible for the acts of the company both the past, the present and the future. The Court stated as follows;

“We begin by reiterating the position in law that a corporate entity can only act through its directors. In Director of Public Prosecutions v Attorney General & 12 others (Civil Appeal 206 of 2016) [2022] KECA 397 (KLR) (Civ) (4 March 2022) (Judgment) this Court stated as follows:

“It is also settled that a company can only operate and undertake actions through its directors. The consequences of the above is that any director who is in office becomes responsible for the acts of the company both the past, the present and the future.

Gikonyo, J, in Agricultural Development Corporation of Kenya v Nathaniel K Tum & Another [2014] eKLR put this issue as succinctly as possible when he stated as follows:

“I find myself re-stating the celebrated legal innovation in Salomon & Co Ltd v Salomon [1897] AC 22 HL.; that a company is a legal entity distinct from the its shareholders and the directors, in other words, it is a juristic person-a legal person - with corporate legal personality separate from those who compose it. Except, however, a company operates through human agents- the board of directors who are appointed in accordance with the Article of Association and registered with the Registrar of Companies. Therefore, the directors assume company abides by all legal requirements; all that will preserve its juristic personality and property; and avoiding default that would attract serious legal sanctions, or affect its juristic personality and assets….” (Emphasis added).

Conclusion

39. In the present matter, the Applicants have named four directors and have also sought committal of “any other director” of the Respondent. The Motion does not identify any other director by name or establish that person’s knowledge or conduct. Nor does the evidence sufficiently identify the individual acts or omissions by each of the four named directors that allegedly prevented compliance with the decree.

40. The evidence principally concerns the Respondent’s corporate position, correspondence between the parties and the dispute over the amounts payable and completion of the transfers. Although the Respondent’s position may ultimately be found inconsistent with the decree in respect of particular charges or claimants, that question does not establish that each director personally and wilfully disobeyed the decree.

41. The Court is therefore not satisfied that the Applicants have proved the personal and wilful disobedience required to justify committal. This finding does not absolve the Respondent from compliance with the decree. It means that the Applicants have not established a sufficient basis for the particular personal sanction sought in the Motion.

Disposition

42. For the foregoing reasons, the Court finds that the Applicants have not established, to the standard required in contempt proceedings, that the named directors personally and wilfully disobeyed the decree issued on 31st January 2024.

43. Accordingly,

a) the Notice of Motion dated 7th October 2025 is dismissed insofar as it seeks the committal of Harun Osoro Nyamboki, Michael Nyabuto Nyamute, Hezron Nyabwari Osoro, Boniface Odhiambo Okello and/or any other director of the Respondent to civil jail.

b) Each party shall bear its own costs of the application.

Delivered, dated and signed via Microsoft Teams this 5th day of November 2026.

HON. L. G. KIMANI

JUDGE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

The Ruling read in the presence of-

M/s Munyira holding Brief for Mutua SC for Applicant

Mwigai holding brief for Manyara for Respondent

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder