Background
What is before the Court for determination is the Respondent’s Notice of Motion application dated 24th January 2026 where she seeks the following Orders’
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
What is before the Court for determination is the Respondent’s Notice of Motion application dated 24th January 2026 where she seeks the following Orders’
Paragraph 1 →It is against the foregoing that I find the Notice of Motion Application dated 24th January 2026 unmerited and will dismiss it.
Paragraph 21 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC CASE NO. 199 OF 2019 (OS)
BENJAMIN NYAKUNDI OPANDE ………………….... 1STAPPLICANT
BERNARD OBUDI …………………………..………..….. 2ND APPLICANT
MARGARET MUTHONI NJERI ………………………. 3RD APPLICANT
MARGARITA NJOKI MURIUKI …………….……….. 4TH APPLICANT
SAMSON OTIENO NGWALA ………………………….. 5TH APPLICANT
RICHARD MUNYAO ………………………………….….. 6TH APPLICANT
GEORGE NYAGUTI ……………………………….……… 7TH APPLICANT
MARTHA LUCHIRI …………………………….………… 8TH APPLICANT
ELISHA OWITI …………………………………………….. 9TH APPLICANT
JOYCE JEROTICH ………………………………..…….. 10TH APPLICANT
CHARLES ODHIAMBO ODONGO ……………...….. 11TH APPLICANT
DICKSON MWANGI GATHUTHI ………………….. 12TH APPLICANT
GEORGE TYSON AWOUR ………………………...…. 13TH APPLICANT
POLYCARP NDEDE ……………………………….……. 14TH APPLICANT
JOAN SYLVIA GATAKAA ………………………..……. 15TH APPLICANT
JOHN SEBASTIAN MALOBA ……………….……….. 16TH APPLICANT
BERNARD AUKA OKOTH ……………………….....… 17TH APPLICANT
RODA LYALI …………………………………………....… 18TH APPLICANT
FLORENCE ATIENO ABUTO ………………………… 19TH APPLICANT
KEVIN OMONDI …………………………………….…… 20TH APPLICANT
MARGARET ABUTO ………………………………....…. 21ST APPLICANT
KEVIN MESHACK OTIENO ………………….....….. 22ND APPLICANT
NORAH MUCHITI …………………………………….... 23RD APPLICANT
NEMUEL NYAKERIGA ONDIEKI ……………....… 24TH APPLICANT
FAITH MUTHONI …………………………………..…… 25TH APPLICANT
OCHIENG OGUTA ……………………….........………. 26TH APPLICANT
JAMES NYANGENA MOSE ……………………….….. 27TH APPLICANT
DAVID MUASYA NZUVE ……………………………… 28TH APPLICANT
DAVID MWITHI ………………………………..……….. 29TH APPLICANT
SHEILLA WERE ………………………………….……… 30TH APPLICANT
BERNARD NYANG’AU …………………………….…… 31ST APPLICANT
ROSE ODHIAMBO …………………………………..…. 32ND APPLICANT
JACKSON KISANG ……………………………………… 33RD APPLICANT
KAREN OGOTI …………………………………………… 34TH APPLICANT
MAURICE OGOL YALA ………………………….……. 35TH APPLICANT
MAUREEN AKINYI OTIENO …………………….….. 36TH APPLICANT
VERSUS
NAOMI WANJIKU MUKUNDI……………..……………RESPONDENT
RULING
1. What is before the Court for determination is the Respondent’s Notice of Motion application dated 24th January 2026 where she seeks the following Orders’
a) Spent.
b) That leave be granted to the firm of Mukele & Kakai Advocates LLP to come on record on behalf of the Respondent.
c) Spent.
d) Spent.
e) That this Honorable Court be pleased to set aside all the ex-parte proceedings, orders and the consequent ex-parte judgment and decree in this case dated 29th September, 2021 and 7th October, 2021 respectively.
f) That this honorable court be pleased to reopen the case and allow the Respondent to file a response to the Originating Summons dated 13th June, 2019 and thereafter tender her evidence in support of her defence unconditionally or upon such terms as are just.
g) That Francis Njoroge, be summoned for cross examination before this Honourable Court on the veracity of the Affidavit of service sworn on the 28th of June, 2019.
h) That this honorable court be pleased to grant further orders and/or directions as it deems fit and expedient in the circumstances.
i) That the costs of this application be borne by the Respondent.
2. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the
Respondent’s supporting affidavit. She avers that the Applicants instituted the instant suit against her, vide Originating Summons dated 13th June 2019, but they did not serve her with any summons or pleadings but later on filed an affidavit of service alleging personal service. She deposes that on 18th July, 2019, this Court directed that service upon her be effected via substituted service, which order she contends was prejudicial to her since the Applicants had neither filed an application for leave to effect service by substituted service nor demonstrated any difficulty faced at either tracing or locating her. She claims that the Court, based on the affidavits filed by the Applicants proceeded to hear and determine the suit without her involvement and issued Judgment.
3. She contends that she was condemned unheard in total disregard of her non derogable right to a fair hearing, yet she has an arguable case with a high probability of success. She explains that she succeeded her late husband on the 10th of July, 2018, when she was issued with a Certificate of Title to the suit property upon the conclusion of succession proceedings thus the Applicants have no adverse cause of action against her as she became the proprietor of the suit land less than one year prior to the institution of the suit.
4. She states that she only learnt of this Court’s judgment in December 2025, while at the Survey of Kenya where she was informed about ongoing subdivisions on her land pursuant to this Court’s impugned Judgment and that she subsequently approached her advocate. She insists that she has been diligently paying rates and that she stands to suffer substantial loss and lose the only property left by her late husband while in contrast, the Applicants will have an opportunity to challenge her evidence.
5. She annexed her copy of the Certificate of Title to the suit property, receipts and her draft replying affidavit and avers that the Applicants failed to disclose to the Court a crucial fact about when she had become the registered proprietor of the suit property thus they are guilty of material non-disclosure.
Response
6. In opposition, the Applicants filed a replying affidavit sworn by the 1st Applicant. He insists that the Respondent was duly served with the pleadings and Court processes but failed to enter appearance or defend the suit, and has not given sufficient reasons for her failure to participate. Further, that the Respondent’s draft replying affidavit does not disclose any triable issue. He also contends that the Applicants have been in adverse possession of the suit property since the 1990’s and that the Respondent’s predecessor in title, Njiru Githunguri Farm (1966) Limited, had already lost title to the suit property through their long occupation before the property was transferred to the Respondent in 2018. He disputes the Respondent’s claim that the suit property was registered in her name in 2018, arguing that the suit land is a subdivision of LR No. 6845/16 and that the mother title existed long before the alleged transfer. In response to the allegations in the Respondent’s draft response, he denies that the Applicants were parties to Nairobi HCCC No. 971 of 2006, and contend that Nairobi CMCC No. 81 of 2006 is irrelevant as it involves third parties.
7. He avers that following the impugned judgment herein, the Applicants have invested millions of shillings in developing the suit property thus reopening the case would occasion them substantial prejudice, without changing the eventual outcome as the Respondent’s intended action is time barred. Further, that the Respondent has, for eight years since acquiring title, failed to take meaningful steps to assert her alleged ownership thus she is not deserving of the orders sought.
8. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions.
Submissions
9. The Respondent submits that she has a meritorious defence raising triable issues, particularly that she only became the registered proprietor of the suit property on 10th July 2018 following succession proceedings, less than one year before the suit was filed, making the claim for adverse possession unsustainable against her. She reiterates her averments in support of the application and urges the Court to exercise its discretion under Order 10 Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Rules, set aside the ex parte judgment and allow her to defend the suit.
10. To buttress her averments, she relied on the following cases: James Kanyiita Nderitu & Another v Marios Philotas Ghikas & Another [2016] eKLR; Patel v E.A. Cargo Handling Services Ltd [1974] EA 75; Shah v Mbogo & Another [1967] EA 116; Philip Kiptoo Chemwolo v Augustine Kubende [1982–1988] KAR; Pithon Waweru Maina v Thuka Mugiria [1983] eKLR; Kenyatta National Hospital Board & Another v Ruteere [2025] eKLR; Gabriel Kariuki Gitonga & 2 Others v Redken Wells Ltd & 11 Others [2021] eKLR; Re Estate of Julius Ndubi Javan (Deceased) [2018] eKLR and Johmat Distributors Ltd v Central Bank of Kenya & 3 Others [2024] eKLR.
Analysis and Determination
11. Upon consideration of the instant Notice of Motion application including the respective affidavits and submissions, the following are issues for determination:
a) Whether leave should be granted to the firm of Mukele & Kakai Advocates LLP to come on record for the Respondent.
b) Whether the Respondent has demonstrated sufficient grounds to warrant the setting aside of the judgment and decree delivered herein and if the suit should commence de novo.
c) Whether Francis Njoroge, should be summoned for cross examination before this Honourable Court on the veracity of the Affidavit of service sworn on the 28th of June, 2019.
12. The Respondent contends that she was never served with the Originating Summons and proceedings herein and was consequently condemned unheard. Further, that she has a triable defence, being that she only became the registered proprietor of the suit property on 10th July 2018 following succession proceedings, less than one year before the suit was instituted. She also states that she only learnt of the impugned judgment in December 2025 and that the Applicants obtained it through material non-disclosure.
13. On their part, the Applicants contend that the Respondent was duly served with the Originating Summons but failed to enter appearance or defend the suit and has not provided sufficient reasons for her failure to participate. They also assert that they have been in adverse possession of the suit property since the 1990s, long before it was transferred to the Respondent in 2018, and that her draft defence raises no triable issues. Further, that they have invested millions in developing the property following judgment and that reopening the suit would occasion them substantial prejudice.
14. As to whether leave should be granted to the firm of Mukele & Kakai Advocates LLP to come on record for the Respondent. The Respondent has sought for leave to be granted to the aforementioned law firm to represent her post judgement. Order 9 Rule 9 of the Civil Procedure Rules provides that:
“Where there is a change of advocate, or when a party
decides to act in person having previously engaged an advocate, after judgment has been passed, such change or intention to act in person shall not be effected without an order of the court-
a. Upon an application with notice to all parties or
b. Upon a consent filed between the outgoing advocate and the proposed incoming advocate or party intending to act in person, as the case may be.”
15. Since the Applicants did not oppose the Respondent’s prayer to have an advocate come on record for her post judgment, while relying on the aforementioned legal provisions, I will allow this prayer as sought.
16. As to whether the Respondent has demonstrated sufficient grounds to warrant the setting aside of the Judgment and Decree delivered herein and whether the suit should commence de novo. The Respondent claims that the Judgement issued against her was irregular on the basis that she was neither served with pleadings nor summons. The Applicants insist that she was duly served. The Court of Appeal in James Kanyiita Nderitu & Another vs Ghikas & Anor (Civil Appeal 6 of 2015) [2016] KECA 470 (KLR) 17 June 2016) (Judgement), stated that:
“……In an irregular default judgment, on the other hand; judgment will have been entered against a defendant who has not been served or properly served with summons to enter appearance. In such a situation, the default judgment is set aside ex debito justiae, as a matter of right. The court does not even have to be moved by a party once it comes to its notice that the judgment is irregular; it can set aside the default judgment on its own motion….”
17. Further, in the case of Shah v Mbogo and Another [1967] EA 116 it was held that:
“This discretion is intended to be exercised to avoid injustice or hardship resulting from accident, inadvertence, or excusable mistake or error, but is not designed to assist a person who has deliberately sought, whether by evasion or otherwise, to obstruct or delay the course of justice.”
18. While in the case of CMC Holdings Limited -vs- Nzioki [2004] 1 KLR 173, it was held that:
“In law, the discretion that a Court of law has, in
deciding whether or not to set aside ex-parte order was meant to ensure that a litigant does not suffer injustice or hardship as a result of among other things an excusable mistake or error. It would not be proper use of such a discretion if the Court turns its back to a litigant who clearly demonstrates such an excusable mistake, inadvertence, accident or error.’
19. In this instance I note the Respondent was served via substituted service in the Standard Newspaper on the 3rd August, 2019. This service was effected after the Respondent had been previously served. I note the Respondent despite service failed to enter appearance nor file a response. The matter proceeded for hearing and the Judge entered Judgement in favour of the Applicants on the 29th September, 2021 and the Decree has since been executed. The Respondent now claims she will suffer irreparable harm as the suit property is the only one she inherited from her late husband. Further, that she had been sued for adverse possession only one year after she had inherited it. It is trite that adverse possession is attached to land and when it was registered, for the Court to count when time begun to run. I note the instant application was filed five years later and the Respondent has not provided plausible reasons on why the impugned Judgement should be set aside and the suit commence de novo.
20. Based on the facts before me while associating myself with the
decisions cited, I find that the Respondent has brought this application after an inordinate delay. Further, she has not demonstrated sufficient cause why this suit should be reinstated.
21. It is against the foregoing that I find the Notice of Motion Application dated 24th January 2026 unmerited and will dismiss it.
22. Costs will be in the cause.
DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 5TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
CHRISTINE OCHIENG
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Ngome for Respondent/Applicant
Gichigi for Applicants/Respondents
Court Assistant: Joan