Background
This ruling relates to the 1st 3rd party Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 15th May, 2026, wherein the first third party argues that:-
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
The Court upheld the 1st third party's preliminary objection. It struck out the Third-Party Notice dated 5 November 2025 against Pacific Insurance Brokers (E.A.) Limited because the Respondent had not obtained the required leave and the proposed commercial claim lacked the requisite connection to the employment dispute. The Respondent was ordered to bear the costs of both the preliminary objection and the third-party proceedings.
30. For the foregoing reasons, I proceed to uphold the Preliminary Objection dated 15th May 2026, and the Third Party Notice dated 5th November 2025, against Pacific Insurance Brokers (E.A) Limited is hereby struck out.
Paragraph 30 →
31. The Respondent shall bear both the costs of the Preliminary Objection and the third party proceedings.
Paragraph 31 →
Held. Decided. The preliminary objection was merited and the Third-Party Notice against Pacific Insurance Brokers (E.A.) Limited was struck out. The Respondent had not sought leave to join the third parties as required by Order 1 Rule 15(1). Independently, the proposed claim under software-development agreements for unpaid contractual sums and commercial indemnity did not arise from, or raise substantially the same questions as, the claimant's employment and termination claim. The Court therefore could not entertain that independent commercial claim through third-party proceedings. The asserted ulterior-motive abuse-of-process allegation was not sustained as a preliminary objection because it required evidence, but this did not affect the result.
Ratio. A preliminary objection may determine a pure legal point apparent from the record, but cannot be sustained on disputed facts requiring investigation. Order 1 Rule 15(1) requires a defendant to obtain leave by the prescribed ex parte, affidavit-supported application before issuing a third-party notice. Further, a third-party indemnity or related claim must concern the same original cause of action or be sufficiently connected to the suit's subject matter; an independent commercial dispute cannot be introduced into an employment claim merely because indemnity is sought. The Employment and Labour Relations Court's employment jurisdiction does not automatically extend to such an unconnected commercial claim.
Issue
12. The issue for my determination is whether the Preliminary Objection is merited, and whether the Third-Party Notice dated 5th November, 2025 should be struck out.
Paragraph 12 →
Held
30. For the foregoing reasons, I proceed to uphold the Preliminary Objection dated 15th May 2026, and the Third Party Notice dated 5th November 2025, against Pacific Insurance Brokers (E.A) Limited is hereby struck out.
Paragraph 30 →
31. The Respondent shall bear both the costs of the Preliminary Objection and the third party proceedings.
Paragraph 31 →
Ratio
17. The question in the present case is whether the record demonstrates non-compliance with the requirement for leave. It is apparent from the court record as well as the court online tracking system that the Respondent did not seek leave to join the Third Parties to this suit pursuant to Order 1 Rule 15(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. This defect is therefore without doubt a question of law.
Paragraph 17 →
22. The fact that the Respondent may seek indemnity does not, on its own, satisfy Order 1 Rule 15(1). The proposed indemnity must still relate to or be sufficiently connected with the original subject matter of the suit.
Paragraph 22 →
26. It then follows that this court unquestionably has jurisdiction to determine the Claimant’s employment dispute, including the preliminary question of whether an employment relationship existed. However, that jurisdiction does not automatically extend to an independent commercial claim between the Respondent and the proposed Third Party.
Paragraph 26 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
This ruling relates to the 1st 3rd party Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 15th May, 2026, wherein the first third party argues that:-
Paragraph 1 →It is its submission that the Respondent’s denial of an employment relationship while seeking indemnity in relation to the same dispute also raises an inconsistency, and contends that the proceedings are procedurally irregular and improperly before the Court, raising issues of law suitable for determination by preliminary objection.
Paragraph 6 →In the upshot, I find and hold that the third-party claim does not satisfy the substantive requirements of Order 1 Rule 15(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010.
Paragraph 29 →Whether the 1st third party’s preliminary objection dated 15 May 2026 was merited; whether the Respondent’s third-party notice dated 5 November 2025 complied with Order 1 Rule 15(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010; whether the proposed commercial claim…
Gloria Nyakerario Osoro’s underlying claim concerned an alleged employment relationship with Blockchain Cybertech Limited (B-Hub) and the consequences of its termination. The Respondent issued a third-party notice dated 5 November 2025 against Pacific…
Get the complete brief with membership →THE REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
CAUSE NO. E228 OF 2024
GLORIA NYAKERARIO OSORO……..………………………….CLAIMANT
VERSUS
BLOCKCHAIN CYBERTECH LIMITED (B-HUB)……………RESPONDENT
PACIFIC INSURANCE BROKERS EAST AFRICA LIMITED.….1ST 3RD PARTY
MYDOKTA LIMITED………………………………………….2ND 3RD PARTY
RULING
1. This ruling relates to the 1st 3rd party Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 15th May, 2026, wherein the first third party argues that:-
i. The Third-Party Notice is incompetent, defective and bad in law.
ii. The Third-Party proceedings are procedurally irregular and improperly before this Honourable Court.
iii. The issues sought to be introduced against the Proposed Third Party fall outside the scope of the present proceedings and disclose no proper basis for Third-Party proceedings.
iv. The Third-Party Notice is frivolous, vexatious and an abuse of the Court process and ought to be struck out with costs.
2. Parties were directed to canvass the Objection by way of written submissions. The first third party filed submissions in support of its Preliminary Objection. The Respondent had not filed its submissions as at the time of writing this ruling.
The First Third Party’s Submissions
3. The 1st third party submits that each ground of the Preliminary Objection raises a pure question of law, namely the competence of the Third-Party Notice, compliance with joinder procedures, the relevance of the issues introduced, and possible abuse of process. It submits that these issues are determinable from the pleadings without requiring evidence and are therefore properly raised by way of a Preliminary Objection.
4. It is its further submission that Order 1 Rule 15(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules requires a defendant to obtain leave of the Court, through an ex parte application supported by affidavit, within fourteen days after close of pleadings, before issuing a Third-Party Notice. It sought to rely on Surajpur Construction Co. Ltd v Salome Otunga & 2 others [2013] eKLR, where the Court struck out a notice issued without the requisite leave. It thus avers that failure to comply with the mandatory procedure renders the Third-Party Notice incompetent and liable to be struck out.
5. It submits that Third-party proceedings must comply strictly with Order 1 Rule 15(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules and demonstrate a sufficient connection with the original cause of action. It argues that the proposed third-party claim concerns a commercial dispute arising from software development agreements, which fall outside this Court’s employment and labour relations jurisdiction. It further submits that the agreements provide for consultation, mediation, and arbitration, potentially engaging Section 6 of the Arbitration Act.
6. It is its submission that the Respondent’s denial of an employment relationship while seeking indemnity in relation to the same dispute also raises an inconsistency, and contends that the proceedings are procedurally irregular and improperly before the Court, raising issues of law suitable for determination by preliminary objection.
7. The first third party further submits that the test for joinder under Order 1 Rule 15(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules is whether the third-party claim is sufficiently connected to the original cause of action. It had reliance in Dias & another v Afkoluck Investments Limited t/a Lucky & Casino; Addisalem Belachew Demisse (Proposed Third Party) [2023] KEELRC 3211 and Interactive Advertising Limited & another v Equity Bank Limited & 2 others [2016] eKLR, where the Courts emphasized the need for a substantive link between the claims.
8. It argues that in the present case, the Claimant’s claim concerns an alleged employment relationship and its termination, whereas the third-party claim relates to unpaid sums under separate software development agreements. It submits that the absence of a common subject matter or substantially similar issues renders the proposed third-party proceedings inappropriate and liable to be struck out.
9. The first third party submits further that the Court has inherent power under Section 3A of the Civil Procedure Act to prevent abuse of its process. It submits that third party proceedings that disregard mandatory procedural requirements and introduce unrelated commercial disputes into an employment claim undermine the overriding objective under Sections 1A and 1B of the Act.
10. It accordingly submits that where a third party notice is procedurally defective and introduces unrelated issues, it may be struck out with costs for being an abuse of the Court’s process.
11. It finally prays that the Preliminary Objection be upheld, the Third Party Notice dated 5th November, 2025 and the proceedings against Pacific Insurance Brokers (E.A) Limited be struck out, and costs be awarded against the Respondent.
Analysis and Determination
12. The issue for my determination is whether the Preliminary Objection is merited, and whether the Third-Party Notice dated 5th November, 2025 should be struck out.
13. The principles governing preliminary objections were settled in Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] EA 696, where the Court held that a preliminary objection consists of a pure point of law which is argued on the assumption that the facts pleaded by the other side are correct, and which may dispose of the suit. The Court further cautioned that a preliminary objection cannot be raised where the Court must ascertain facts or exercise judicial discretion.
14. For starters, the fact that the Respondent did not file submissions does not, by itself, mean that the objection automatically succeeds. The Court must independently evaluate the merits of the objection.
15. The first issue concerns compliance with Order 1 Rule 15(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. The provision contemplates a defendant seeking contribution, indemnity or related relief from a third party, or raising an issue substantially similar to one arising between the Claimant and the Respondent.
16. The provision requires in mandatory terms an application for leave, by ex parte summons in chambers supported by affidavit, within fourteen days after the close of pleadings. In Surajpur Construction Co. Ltd v Salome Otunga & 2 others [2013] eKLR, the Court considered the failure to comply with the prescribed procedure for third party proceedings and struck out the notice.
17. The question in the present case is whether the record demonstrates non-compliance with the requirement for leave. It is apparent from the court record as well as the court online tracking system that the Respondent did not seek leave to join the Third Parties to this suit pursuant to Order 1 Rule 15(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. This defect is therefore without doubt a question of law.
18. The second issue is whether the proposed Third Party claim satisfies the requirements of Order 1 Rule 15(1). In Interactive Advertising Limited & another v Equity Bank Limited & 2 others [2015] KEHC 8088 (KLR), the Court, relying on Yafesi Walusimbi v Attorney General of Uganda (1959) EA 223, held that the subject matter between the defendant and the third party must be the same as that between the plaintiff and the defendant, and that the original cause of action must be the same.
19. The same principle was applied in Dias & another v Afkoluck Investments Limited t/a Lucky & Casino; Addisalem Belachew Demisse (Proposed Third Party) [2023] KEELRC 3211 (KLR), where the Court disallowed joinder because of the absence of proximity between the alleged infractions of the proposed third party and the claim before the Court.
20. The Claimant’s claim herein concerns an alleged employment relationship with the Respondent and the consequences of its termination. The claim sought to be introduced against Pacific Insurance Brokers (E.A) Limited, however, arises from two software development agreements entered into in September, 2022 and concerns alleged unpaid contractual sums of Kshs. 7,353,873.85, interest and commercial indemnity.
21. On the pleadings as described, the commercial dispute does not arise from the Claimant’s alleged employment relationship, nor does it raise substantially the same questions as those arising in the employment claim.
22. The fact that the Respondent may seek indemnity does not, on its own, satisfy Order 1 Rule 15(1). The proposed indemnity must still relate to or be sufficiently connected with the original subject matter of the suit.
23. In the absence of that connection, joining the proposed third party would introduce a distinct commercial dispute into proceedings intended to resolve an employment claim.
24. The objection on this ground is therefore merited, and so I hold.
25. On the third issue, which concerns jurisdiction, Article 162(2)(a) of the Constitution and Section 12(1) of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act confer jurisdiction upon this Court over employment and labour relations disputes. In Republic v Chengo & 2 others [2017] KESC 15 (KLR), the Supreme Court affirmed that courts of equal status exercise distinct and constitutionally defined jurisdictions, and that parity of status does not confer jurisdiction over matters reserved for another court.
26. It then follows that this court unquestionably has jurisdiction to determine the Claimant’s employment dispute, including the preliminary question of whether an employment relationship existed. However, that jurisdiction does not automatically extend to an independent commercial claim between the Respondent and the proposed Third Party.
27. Further, since the claim under the software development agreements is not shown to be sufficiently connected to the employment dispute, it cannot properly be introduced through third party proceedings in this Court.
28. On the question of abuse of process, the Court must distinguish between defects apparent from the pleadings and allegations that require evidence. In Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors (Supra), it was held that a preliminary objection cannot be sustained on disputed facts requiring investigation. Although the pleadings present an apparent lack of nexus between the claims, the allegation that the Respondent acted with an ulterior motive to extract a commercial concession requires evidence and cannot, on its own, sustain the objection.
29. In the upshot, I find and hold that the third-party claim does not satisfy the substantive requirements of Order 1 Rule 15(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010.
30. For the foregoing reasons, I proceed to uphold the Preliminary Objection dated 15th May 2026, and the Third Party Notice dated 5th November 2025, against Pacific Insurance Brokers (E.A) Limited is hereby struck out.
31. The Respondent shall bear both the costs of the Preliminary Objection and the third party proceedings.
32. Orders accordingly.
SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED BY VIDEO-LINK AND IN COURT AT NAIROBI THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
C. N. BAARI
JUDGE
Appearance:
N/A for the Claimant
Mr. Musyoki present for the Respondent
Ms. Saad h/b for Ms. Kabage for the 1st 3rd Party
N/A present for the 2nd 3rd party
Ms. Faith -C/A