Background
Spent
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Spent
Paragraph 1 →Whether the Respondent/Applicant had shown a basis to review, vary or set aside the conditional stay order of 20 May 2026 requiring deposit of the entire decretal sum in a joint interest-earning account; and whether the Claimant/Respondent’s preliminary…
In the underlying judgment, the Claimant was awarded Kshs. 640,000 compensation, Kshs. 80,000 in lieu of notice, and Kshs. 863,153.30 as the assessed value of motor vehicle KCM 262K; costs were taxed at Kshs. 240,226. Family Bank Limited appealed. On 20 May…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT & LABOUR RELATIONS COURT
AT NAIROBI
ELRC CAUSE NO. 508 OF 2019
(Before Hon. Lady Justice Hellen Wasilwa, J)
PAUL VICTOR ONYANGO…………………………………….CLAIMANT
VS
FAMILY BANK LIMITED………………………………….RESPONDENT
RULING
1 The Respondent/ Applicant filed a Notice of Motion application dated 2nd June 2026 seeking orders THAT: -
1. Spent
2. This Honourable Court be pleased to review, vary and/or set aside the Ruling delivered on 20th May 2026 ordering that the entire decretal sum be deposited in an interest-earning account held in the joint names of both counsel on record within 60 days.
3. In the alternative and without prejudice to prayer 2 above, this Honourable Court be pleased to vary the conditions of the stay of execution granted on 20th May 2026 so as to take into account the sum of Kshs. 504,000 already paid by the Respondent/Applicant, and to limit the security to be furnished to the balance of the contested decretal sum, being Kshs. 863,153.30, together with the taxed costs of Kshs. 240,226.
4. Pending the hearing and determination of this application, this Honourable Court be pleased to issue a temporary stay of the order made on 20th May 2026 requiring deposit of the decretal sum so as to preserve the status quo.
5. The costs of this application be provided for.
2 The application is premised on the grounds on its face and the supporting affidavit of Joan Gachomba, the Respondent/Applicant's Legal Officer, sworn on 2nd June 2026.
Respondent/ Applicant’s Case
3 The Applicant avers that by its application dated 5th March 2026 it moved the Court for a stay of execution of the judgment delivered on 19th February 2025.
4 The judgment awarded the Claimant Kshs. 640,000 being compensation equivalent to eight months' salary, Kshs. 80,000 being one month's salary in lieu of notice, and the value of motor vehicle registration number KCM 262K assessed at Kshs. 863,153.30. The Claimant's costs were subsequently taxed at Kshs. 240,226.
5 The Applicant states that on 20th May 2026 the Court granted a conditional stay of execution, directing that the entire decretal sum be deposited in an interest-earning account held in the joint names of both counsel on record within 60 days, in default of which execution may proceed.
6 It avers that the Court, in its ruling, took into account that the Applicant had filed an appeal, being COACA/E685/2025 Family Bank Limited v Paul Victor Onyango, challenging the decision.
7 It is the Applicant's case that the said ruling contains an error apparent on the face of the record, in that the Court failed to take into account the sum of Kshs. 504,000 already paid in partial satisfaction of the decree.
8 The Applicant avers that this sum, being the net amount of Kshs. 720,000 after statutory deductions, was paid into the Claimant's account number 035000035594 domiciled with the Applicant, and it has annexed the account details and proof of payment.
9 The Applicant contends that in requiring the deposit of the "entire decretal sum" without specifying the precise figure or deducting the amount already paid, the Court created an error apparent on the face of the record.
10 It avers that the effect of the order as made is to require it to deposit a sum that includes monies already paid and no longer forming part of the balance due under the decree.
11 The Applicant avers that it stands to suffer substantial and irreversible prejudice if required to comply with the order as currently framed.
12 It states that compliance would effectively compel double payment of Kshs. 504,000 without any mechanism for recovery, would be disproportionate to the actual outstanding balance of the decree, and would amount to punishing it for its partial compliance with the decree.
13 It is the Applicant's case that the genuinely contested and outstanding balance under the decree comprises the motor vehicle value of Kshs. 863,153.30, which is the subject of the appeal, and the taxed costs of Kshs. 240,226.
14 The Applicant states that it is ready and willing to furnish security in respect of these amounts in a joint interest-earning account as directed by the Court, and that it has at all material times demonstrated good faith and willingness to abide by the conditions of the stay.
15 The Applicant avers that the application has been brought promptly and without undue delay, the ruling having been delivered on 20th May 2026 and the 60-day window for compliance expiring on or about 19th July 2026. It contends that it cannot adequately protect its interests by any other means, and urges the Court to allow the application.
Claimant/Respondent’s Case
16 In opposition to the application, the Claimant/Respondent filed a Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 16th June 2026, on the following grounds:
1. The application and/or issues raised therein were previously heard and conclusively determined by this honorable court
2. The present application is therefore res-judicata within the meaning of section 7 of the civil procedure act (or the applicable statutory provision in your jurisdiction)
3. Having rendered its final determination on issues now raised the honourable court is functus officio and lacks jurisdiction to re-open, review, or re-determine the matter as expressly provided by the law
4. The application constitutes an abuse of the court process and ought to be struck out with costs
17 The Claimant/Respondent thus prays that the application be struck out or dismissed with costs.
Respondent/Applicant’s Submissions
18 The Applicant submitted on two issues: whether it has established grounds for review; and whether the Preliminary Objection is merited.
19 On the first issue, the Applicant submitted that its application is founded on a single and narrow issue, namely the amount ordered to be secured as a condition for the stay of execution.
20 It was submitted that the Court inadvertently failed to account for the sum of Kshs. 504,000 which had already been paid to the Claimant before the delivery of the ruling. The effect of the order as presently framed, it argued, is that the Applicant is required to secure monies already paid to and received by the Claimant, resulting in double accounting of the same sum.
21 The Applicant submitted that it does not seek to challenge the Court's exercise of discretion in granting the stay, nor to re-litigate the application for stay of execution. It merely invites the Court to correct an apparent error arising from the omission to account for the undisputed payment already made towards satisfaction of the decree.
22 It submitted that the jurisdiction of the Court to review its own orders is donated by Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, under which a court may review its order where there exists an error apparent on the face of the record.
23 The Applicant relied on Sese (Suing as the Administrator of the Estate of the Late Shali Sese) v Karezi & 8 others [2023] KEELC 17427 (KLR), where the court, in allowing a similar application, cited Nyamogo & Nyamogo v Kogo [2001] EA 170, wherein it was held that an error apparent on the face of the record cannot be defined exhaustively and must be determined judicially on the facts of each case, there being a real distinction between a mere erroneous decision and such an error. A clear case is made out where an error on a substantial point of law stares one in the face and there could reasonably be no two opinions. An error which has to be established by a long-drawn process of reasoning does not qualify, and a mere error or wrong view is no ground for review though it may be one for appeal.
24 The Applicant argued that the error in the present case is readily identifiable, the Court having ordered security for the entire decretal sum notwithstanding that Kshs. 504,000 had already been paid.
25 It submitted that the payment was not made on a without prejudice basis but constituted actual part satisfaction of the decretal amount, which reduced its outstanding liability under the decree.
26 It was submitted that evidence of the payment was placed before the Court through the supporting affidavit and Exhibits JG4 and JG5, which show the Claimant's account and the monies being deposited into it. The Applicant contended that the Claimant has not demonstrated that the account was not his, or that the money was never deposited into the account bearing his name. Consequently, as at the date of the impugned ruling, the sum of Kshs. 504,000 no longer formed part of the outstanding decretal amount requiring security.
27 It is the Applicant's submission that only the decretal balance remaining after deduction of the Kshs. 504,000 ought to be secured pending the hearing and determination of the appeal. It maintained that the purpose of security in a stay application is to secure the due performance of the decree should the appeal fail, and not to secure sums that have already been satisfied. Unless the order is reviewed, the Applicant will be compelled to secure an amount already paid, exposing it to manifest prejudice and resulting in the unjust enrichment of the Claimant.
28 The Applicant submitted that it has approached the Court without delay and in good faith, and remains willing and ready to comply with any order requiring deposit of the actual outstanding decretal balance. It submitted that the application therefore falls squarely within the review jurisdiction of the Court.
29 On the second issue, the Applicant submitted that the Preliminary Objection is misconceived, does not raise a pure point of law and ought to be dismissed. It argued that a preliminary objection must be raised on the face of the proceedings without resort to facts that require investigation or proof, and relied on the Supreme Court decision in Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission v Cheperenger & 2 others [2015] KESC 2 (KLR), where it was held that:"It is quite clear that a preliminary objection should be founded upon a settled and crisp point of law, to the intent that its application to undisputed facts, leads to but one conclusion: that the facts are incompatible with that point of law."
30 The Applicant submitted that the gravamen of the Preliminary Objection is that the review application re-litigates issues previously heard and determined and that the Court is functus officio.
31 On functus officio, it submitted that the doctrine dictates that once a court has rendered its final decision it ceases to have jurisdiction over the matter, save for specific exceptions such as review or the correction of clerical or arithmetical errors.
32 Reliance was placed on Kenya Airports Authority v Mitu-Bell Welfare Society & 2 others [2016] KECA 432 (KLR), where the Court of Appeal reaffirmed that a court which has fully and finally adjudicated upon a matter cannot reopen or reconsider it except under defined circumstances, such as through a successful application for review.
33 The Respondent/Applicant submitted that the Court's power to review its own orders is expressly preserved under Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 of the Civil Procedure Rules, and that a court hearing a review application is exercising a jurisdiction specifically conferred by law. The Applicant contended that the review jurisdiction is a recognised exception to the functus officio principle, and its exercise cannot be precluded by invoking the very doctrine it is designed to temper.
34 The Applicant further submitted that the ruling of 20th May 2026 is a conditional interlocutory order relating to security for stay of execution, which remains in force and capable of being acted upon until the 60-day compliance window expires. It argued that the Court retains supervisory jurisdiction over the terms of interlocutory orders it has made pending the disposal of the appeal. To hold otherwise would be to deny the Court the ability to correct a plain error in an order whose consequences are still unfolding.
35 On res judicata, the Applicant submitted that the doctrine does not arise, as it is not seeking a rehearing of the stay application nor challenging the decision to grant the stay. The only issue before the Court is whether the stay order inadvertently failed to account for the Kshs. 504,000 already paid. The application therefore seeks correction of an apparent error and not a reconsideration of matters already determined.
36 It is therefore the Applicant’s submission that the Preliminary Objection is without merit and ought to be dismissed. It submitted that it has demonstrated that Kshs. 504,000 had been paid towards the decretal sum before the stay order was issued, and that unless the error is corrected it will be required to account for the same amount twice.
Claimant/Respondent’s Submissions
37 The Claimant/Respondent submitted that the Applicant appealed to the Court of Appeal challenging the award of the value of the motor vehicle. He submitted that the Applicant owns the account into which it claims to have deposited the money, and that it took the money back a day later as a loan repayment for the same motor vehicle that is the subject of its appeal.
38 It is the Respondent’s submission that the application is not a genuine application for review but a disguised appeal against the Court's conditional stay orders and the main judgment. He argued that, having already lodged an appeal challenging the judgment, including the findings on the repossession of his motor vehicle and the reliefs awarded, the Applicant cannot return to this Court seeking orders that would effectively vary or defeat the judgment under the guise of review.
39 The Claimant submitted that it is telling that the appeal challenges the motor vehicle award on the ground that he was not entitled to the compensation awarded, yet in the present application the Applicant seeks to justify appropriating the decretal sum to offset the very motor vehicle loan that is the subject of the pending appeal.
40 It was submitted that the Applicant cannot approbate and reprobate. If the issue of the motor vehicle loan and the legality of the repossession is pending before the appellate court, this Court cannot be invited to determine, directly or indirectly, that the Applicant was entitled to recover the loan from the decretal sum. Such a finding, it was submitted, would prejudge matters reserved for the appellate court.
41 He further submitted that by asking the Court to validate its unilateral appropriation of the decretal sum, and to vary the express condition requiring deposit of the decretal amount in a joint interest-earning account, the Applicant is asking the Court to revisit and alter the substance of its own decision. The Claimant argued that this falls outside the narrow jurisdiction of review under Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules.
42 The Claimant/Respondent submitted that once the Court delivered judgment and subsequently exercised its discretion by granting a conditional stay on specified terms, it became functus officio in respect of those issues, save for the limited jurisdiction conferred by law. He argued that the doctrine prevents a court from reopening or reconsidering matters it has conclusively determined, except as expressly permitted by statute, and that the Court lacks jurisdiction to grant orders that would substantially alter its previous orders and determine issues already pending before the appellate court.
43 On the threshold for review, the Claimant/Respondent submitted that review is governed by Section 80 of the Civil Procedure Act and Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules. An applicant must demonstrate the discovery of new and important matter or evidence which was not within its knowledge despite the exercise of due diligence, a mistake or error apparent on the face of the record, or any other sufficient reason.
44 It was submitted that the Applicant has not demonstrated any of these grounds. The fact that it allegedly deposited the decretal sum into the Claimant's account and thereafter appropriated it towards an outstanding motor vehicle loan was fully within its knowledge when the stay application was argued and determined, and cannot constitute a new matter warranting review. The application, he argued, merely invites the Court to reconsider and vary its earlier decision.
45 The Claimant/Respondent submitted that the order of the Court was clear, unambiguous and incapable of more than one interpretation. It required the entire decretal amount to be deposited in an interest-earning account held in the joint names of both advocates on record within 60 days, and not in the Claimant's account.
46 It is his submission that the Applicant did not comply with that order, but instead elected to deposit the funds into an account under its own control and thereafter appropriated them towards a disputed loan account. He reasoned that a party cannot substitute a court order with a procedure of its own choosing and subsequently seek validation through a review application, as to permit this would undermine the authority of court orders.
47 The Claimant/Respondent submitted that the contention that the decretal amount was deposited into his account is misleading, the critical issue being whether he received and enjoyed the benefit of the decretal sum. He submitted that he did not. Immediately upon crediting the account, the Applicant debited and appropriated the funds towards the alleged motor vehicle loan, so that he never received the decretal sum and had no access to it whatsoever. He argued that the Applicant cannot be heard to say that payment was effected when the very same funds were simultaneously withdrawn by it.
48 The Claimant/Respondent further submitted that one of the issues before the trial court concerned the legality of the repossession of the motor vehicle and the parties' rights arising from the loan relationship, and that the Applicant cannot unilaterally appropriate the decretal sum to settle a debt which remains disputed between the parties.
49 It is the Claimant/Respondent’s submission that the judgment debt arising from unlawful termination and unlawful repossession is distinct from any alleged indebtedness under the loan facility. The Applicant, he submitted, cannot set off or recover the alleged loan by disobeying a court order requiring security to be deposited in a joint interest-earning account.
50 The Claimant/Respondent further submitted that the application is an attempt to sanitize non-compliance. In effect, it invites the Court to retrospectively approve the Applicant's non-compliance with the stay conditions and to vary its judgment on the repossession of the vehicle, a judgment the Applicant has appealed against.
51 He submitted that the purpose of the order requiring deposit was to preserve the decretal sum pending the determination of the appeal and to place the funds beyond the reach of either party. By appropriating the money towards its own alleged debt, the Applicant defeated the very objective of the order. The Court, he argued, should not exercise its discretion in favour of a party that has deliberately departed from the express terms of its orders.
52 It is the Claimant/Respondent’s submission that the Applicant has failed to establish any error apparent on the face of the record or any other ground for review, that the decretal sum was never deposited as ordered and was never received by him, and that the application is an attempt to reopen issues already determined and to have the Court sit on appeal over its own decision.
53 I have examined all the averments and submissions of the parties herein. The applicant seeks review of stay orders of this court dated 20th May 2026 which directed them to deposit the entire decretal sum in an interest earning account held in joint names of counsels on record.
54 It is worth noting that the appellants have also filed an appeal on the issues in the judgment which issue is pending before the court of appeal. The order being sought in my view would be seeking a re- opening of this case which has been determined and an appeal filed. I do not find this application merited as the order of security being deposited will not prejudice the respondent applicants in any way. I decline to grant the orders accordingly and dismiss the application with costs.
Dated, Signed and Delivered virtually at Nairobi this 15th Day of October 2026.
HELLEN WASILWA
JUDGE