Meet Sheriaplex AI. Research, draft and review with tools for Kenyan legal work.

Try AI chat ↗Explore AI Tools →
Employment law

Ojuka v Chebii & 2 others [2026] KEELRC 4680 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Petition E142 of 2026
Judgment date
15 October 2026
Judge(s)
M. Mbaru

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The petition was dismissed as without merit. Costs were awarded to the 1st respondent and the interested party.

Supporting judgment passages

The petition is therefore without merit and is hereby dismissed. Costs to the 1st respondent and the interested party.

Passage 75 →
Issue 1whether the 2nd respondent failed to address its mandate under section 27(4) of the LRA

Held. No. The court held that the Registrar exercised the challenged mandate. The Registrar issued the Gazette notice inviting objections, and the subsequent registration of the amended constitution was permissible under section 27. The petitioner's demand that the Registrar should have refused the proposed amendments was unjustified.

Ratio. Under section 27(4), the Registrar must issue at least 21 days' Gazette notice inviting objections. If objections arise, the Registrar has latitude to investigate and may refer the matter to court, refuse the changes, or make an appropriate order. Section 27(5) permits approval of constitutional changes where registration requirements are met.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

On the pleadings, the statements and written submissions, the issues which emerge for determination are whether the 2nd respondent failed to address its mandate under section 27(4) of the LRA; whether the refusal to accept the proposed amendments to the interested party constitution is in violation of articles 41(1) and (4) of the Constitution; and whether an order of certiorari to quash Gazette Notice No. 6021 in the Kenya Gazette V.CXXVIII of 24 April 2026 should be issued.

Issues →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

The petition seeking to find that the 2nd respondent failed to exercise the powers under section 27(4) of the LRA to refuse the proposed amendments to the interested party constitution is unjustified. The 2nd respondent's mandate was to issue a 21-day notice in the Gazette inviting objections to the proposed changes. The next step was for the 2nd respondent to investigate any complaints and grounds relied upon and may then refer the matter to this Court, refuse to accept the changes, or make any orders he may deem fit in the circumstances.

Passage 67 →

In this case, the 2nd respondent has since caused the interested party constitution to be registered with the amendments. This is permissible under section 27 of the LRA. Section 27(5) of the LRA allow the 2nd respondent:

Passage 69 →

Therefore, the 2nd respondent's actions under section 27 of the LRA are, to the extent that this is just. Still, the office is to receive proposed constitutional amendments, including those from the interested party. The allegation that the 2nd respondent should have refused to accept the proposed amendments would be an abdication of duty.

Passage 71 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

The petition seeking to find that the 2nd respondent failed to exercise the powers under section 27(4) of the LRA to refuse the proposed amendments to the interested party constitution is unjustified. The 2nd respondent's mandate was to issue a 21-day notice in the Gazette inviting objections to the proposed changes. The next step was for the 2nd respondent to investigate any complaints and grounds relied upon and may then refer the matter to this Court, refuse to accept the changes, or make any orders he may deem fit in the circumstances.

Passage 67 →

Hence, under section 27(4)(a) to (c), the 2nd respondent has the latitude to investigate the objections/complaint and may refer the matter to court, refuse to accept the changes or make any orders that may be deemed fit in the circumstances.

Passage 68 →

(5) The Registrar may approve a change of name or to the constitution if the applicable requirements of registration of a trade union, employer’s organisation or federation are met.

Passage 70 →
Issue 2whether the refusal to accept the proposed amendments to the interested party constitution is in violation of articles 41(1) and (4) of the Constitution

Held. No violation of Article 41 was established. The court found that Form J emanated from the union, was filed and signed by several union members with the General Secretary's approval, and that the Registrar performed the office's legal mandate. The claim that the petitioner or union was denied the right to determine its own administration, programmes and activities could not stand.

Ratio. The General Secretary, rather than the chairman, has the statutory mandate to communicate trade-union affairs. The union constitution must be read as a whole: the quinquennial conference has supreme authority, while the chairman presides over its meetings and the General Secretary communicates its decisions. A chairperson who presided over the conference could not later rely on alleged illegality in those proceedings to obtain equitable relief.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

On the pleadings, the statements and written submissions, the issues which emerge for determination are whether the 2nd respondent failed to address its mandate under section 27(4) of the LRA; whether the refusal to accept the proposed amendments to the interested party constitution is in violation of articles 41(1) and (4) of the Constitution; and whether an order of certiorari to quash Gazette Notice No. 6021 in the Kenya Gazette V.CXXVIII of 24 April 2026 should be issued.

Issues →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

Form J to the LRA schedule emanates from the subject trade union and not the 2nd respondent. In this case, several interested party members filed and signed Form J with the 1st respondent's approval. Under section 41(1) and (4) of the Constitution, the case that the petitioner or the interested party was not allowed to determine its own administration, programme and activities cannot stand. Upon being moved, the 2nd respondent executed the office's legal mandate as necessary.

Passage 72 →

The Court finds no violation of Article 41 of the Constitution.

Passage 73 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

Although the LRA gives prominence to the union constitution regarding holding elections, the 2nd respondent's challenged mandate to apply section 27(4) of the LRA was exercised. As the chairman of the interested party, the General Secretary, not the chairman, is responsible for communicating the quinquennial conference resolutions. Section 2 of the LRA grants the General Secretary the sole mandate to communicate the matters relating to the affairs of the trade union. The General Secretary therefore approved the notice of proposed amendments to the interested party Constitution, issued on 22 January 2026.

Passage 62 →

Rule 4 of the Interested Parties Constitution cannot be read in isolation. Rule 8 gives the quinquennial conference supreme authority within the interested party. The union's power lies within it. The petitioner is the chairperson, and the 1st respondent has authority to communicate interested-party decisions. Rule 12(a) therefore gives the power to preside over interested-party meetings and conferences to the chairman, a position held by the petitioner.

Passage 64 →

The petitioner therefore cannot turn back on the meetings he presided over and assert that illegalities were committed. Such would render him tainted and with unclean hands to seek in equity. Under his leadership and chairmanship, the quinquennial conference was held on 22 January 2026, and part of the resolution registered with the 2nd respondent was through a Form J dated 22 January 2026, seeking amendments to the interested party constitution.

Passage 65 →
Issue 3whether an order of certiorari to quash Gazette Notice No. 6021 in the Kenya Gazette V.CXXVIII of 24 April 2026 should be issued

Held. No. Quashing Gazette Notice No. 6021 was unjustified because it was issued to invite objections and afforded the petitioner an opportunity to state his complaint; the Registrar had discharged the lawful mandate.

Ratio. Certiorari was unavailable where the challenged Gazette notice was the statutory mechanism for inviting objections to proposed constitutional amendments and the Registrar had lawfully performed that function.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

On the pleadings, the statements and written submissions, the issues which emerge for determination are whether the 2nd respondent failed to address its mandate under section 27(4) of the LRA; whether the refusal to accept the proposed amendments to the interested party constitution is in violation of articles 41(1) and (4) of the Constitution; and whether an order of certiorari to quash Gazette Notice No. 6021 in the Kenya Gazette V.CXXVIII of 24 April 2026 should be issued.

Issues →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

Quashing Gazette Notice No. 6021 in the Kenya Gazette V.CXXVIII of 24 April 2026 would be unjustified, as it was issued to invite objections and allow the petitioner the right to state his case and complaint. The 2nd respondent discharged its lawful mandate, which it did.

Passage 74 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

Quashing Gazette Notice No. 6021 in the Kenya Gazette V.CXXVIII of 24 April 2026 would be unjustified, as it was issued to invite objections and allow the petitioner the right to state his case and complaint. The 2nd respondent discharged its lawful mandate, which it did.

Passage 74 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

The court considered whether the Registrar of Trade Unions failed to perform the mandate under section 27(4) of the Labour Relations Act; whether the refusal to reject the proposed constitutional amendments violated Articles 41(1) and 41(4) of the…

Material facts

The petitioner, the national chairman of the Tailors and Textiles Workers Union, challenged amendments said to have been made at its quinquennial conference on 22 January 2026. He said the conference notice concerned national elections only, the minutes…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

PETITION NO. E142 OF 2026

[Previously ELRC Cause No. E469 of 2026]

EZRA ODONDI OJUKA PETITIONER

VERSUS

REV. JOEL KANDIE CHEBII 1ST RESPONDENT

REGISTRAR OF TRADE UNIONS 2ND RESPONDENT

AND

TAILORS AND TEXTILES

WORKERS UNION INTERESTED PARTY

JUDGMENT

The petition was initially filed under ELRC Cause No. E469 of 2026. The court directed that this be moved as a petition.

The petitioner is seeking the following orders:

a) A declaration that the failure by the 2nd respondent to exercise the powers in section 27(4) of the Labour Relations Act, 2007, or refusing to accept the proposed amendments to the union constitution is an abdication of mandate.

b) A declaration that the failure by the 2nd respondent to refuse to accept the proposed amendments despite the obvious irregularities in the minutes and Form J is a violation of Article 41(1) and (4) of the Constitution of Kenya on the right to fair labour practices and trade unions’ right to determine their own administration, programmes and activities.

c) An order of certiorari to remove into this Court and quash Gazette Notice No. 6021 in the Kenya Gazette V.CXXVIII of 24 April 2026.

d) Costs of the suit.

e) Any other reliefs that the court may deem fit, just and expedient.

The petitioner is a male adult and the national chairman of the Tailors and Textiles Workers Union, the interested party. The 1st respondent is a male adult and the national general secretary of the interested party. The 2nd respondent is the public officer under the Labour Relations Act (LRA) mandated to register and oversee trade unions in Kenya. The interested party is a trade union registered under the LRA.

The petitioner’s case is that, by letter dated 21 April 2026, the 2nd respondent, without verifying that the national chairperson of the interested party had not signed the minutes, forwarded a Gazette Notice for the amendment of the union constitution to the Government Printer, which was published through Gazette Notice No. 6021 in the Kenya Gazette Vol. CXXVIII of 24 April 2026.

By a letter dated 22 April 2026, the claimant lodged his objections to the 2nd respondent after noting the irregular and illegal actions of the respondents. Under section 27(4) of the LRA, upon receipt of the notice of changes of name or constitution, the 2nd respondent should give notice of at least 21 days in the Gazette and in 3 daily newspapers of national circulation, inviting any objections to the proposed change of name or constitution by members of the trade union. Where any such objections are raised, the 2nd respondent should investigate the complaint and the grounds thereof and may undertake the following:

a) refer the matter to the court,

b) refuse or accept the proposed amendments, or

c) Make any orders that may be deemed fit in the circumstances.

The claim is that no notice was published in the three national daily newspapers. The 2nd respondent has neither referred the matter to the court, nor indicated refusal or acceptance of the proposed amendments, nor made any order, despite the petitioner bringing the irregularities in Form J and the purported minutes of the quinquennial conference of 22 January 2026 to the office's attention. The petitioner had a legitimate expectation that, upon bringing the irregularities in Form J and the purported minutes of the quinquennial conference of 22 January 2026 to the 2nd respondent's attention, the 2nd respondent would reject the registration and not proceed with the gazettement of the proposed amendments.

The 2nd respondent's failure to exercise the powers under section 27(4) of the LRA, and its refusal to accept the proposed amendments to the interested party constitution, was an abdication of duty. Despite the noted irregularities in the submitted minutes, the interested party failed to comply with Article 41(1) and (4) of the Constitution, which guarantees the right to fair labour practices and that every trade union has the right to determine its own administration, programmes and activities. Under Article 47 of the Constitution, the petitioner has the right to fair administrative action. Before the interested party's Constitution was amended, he had the right to be heard on his objections.

In support of the petition, the petitioner filed his statement and avers that the chairman of the interested party, by circular dated 2 January 2026 to all branch secretaries, the 1st respondent, notified them of the quinquennial conference for 22 January 2026. The only agenda was the national elections of the interested party.

As the national chairman, he chaired the meeting. Under Rule 12(d) of the interested party constitution, the 1st respondent is mandated to take minutes during the National Executive Committee meeting, special conference, and quinquennial conference.

On 22 January 2026, the 1st respondent prepared minutes of the conference containing Min 7/26 Constitutional Amendment, an item that was not on the agenda and forwarded the same to the 2nd respondent without a certified copy by the petitioner as the chairperson of the meeting.

The petitioner avers that under section 27(2) (a) of the LRA, a notice in Form J should be filed with the 2nd respondent for amendment to the constitution of the interested party. Form J should be accompanied by a copy of the minutes of the meeting at which the amendment was made and certified by the chairperson of the meeting.

By a letter dated 21 April 2026, the 2nd respondent, without verifying the minutes, forwarded the Gazette Notice for the amendment of the interested party's constitution. This was published as Gazette Notice No. 6021 of 24 April 2026. The 2nd respondent acted contrary to the law, and the Court should issue the orders sought.

In response, the 1st respondent filed his Replying Affidavit on his behalf and on behalf of the interested party as the national general secretary. He avers that the amendments to the union constitution are lawful and valid, and the orders sought are without merit and should be dismissed with costs. The respondents and the interested party have not violated Articles 41 and 47 of the Constitution, as alleged. The changes made to the interested party's constitution following the quinquennial conference held on 22 January 2026 were lawfully effected and were registered by the 2nd respondent on 12 May 2026.

The response is also that the 1st respondent and interested party are aware of another suit, High Court Petition No. E009 of 2026 filed in Nyeri regarding the same subject matter. The same parties are as herein. This petition should be dismissed with costs.

In the petition, the petitioner submitted that there was no compliance with the procedure for amending the Interested Party Constitution. Rule 4 of the Interested Party Constitution provides the procedure for amending and altering the constitution. This should be done by majority vote at the quinquennial conference or special programme. All proposals for amendments should be submitted to the National Secretary General in writing not later than 2 weeks before the date of the conference.

Rule 4 also requires the General Secretary to submit amendments to the constitution to the Registrar of Trade Unions, and for them to take effect from the date of registration.

Additionally, Rule 8 provides for convening the quinquennial conference every 5 years at a venue agreed by the National Executive Committee and in line with government directives on Trade Union Elections (Registrar of Trade Unions). The General Secretary should issue at least 2 weeks' notice of the conference to each branch.

Further, Rule 9 provides that the General Secretary may convene the conference, or it may be convened on written request by two-thirds of fully paid-up members.

In this case, the notice of the quinquennial conference held on 22 January 2026 was issued through a circular dated 2 January 2026, which directed the branches to conduct elections and national elections on 22 January 2026. The notice did not include an agenda item to amend the interested party constitution; it included only national elections. The 1st respondent did not issue notice of any intention to amend the constitution. Including the amendment of the constitution on the agenda did not comply with the LRA.

The petitioner submitted that the changes to the interested party constitution are unlawful and unconstitutional. Without this item on the agenda, the resulting changes are unlawful and denied interested party members their participation rights, and are thus unconstitutional.

The statutory compliance required before effecting the amendment to the interested party constitution was not met. By a letter dated 21 April 2026, the 2nd respondent, without verifying that the petitioner did not sign the minutes as the chairman, caused them to be gazetted and published through Gazette Notice No. 6021 of 24 April 2026. Under Section 27(4) of the LRA, the petitioner filed a complaint with the 2nd respondent, raising the irregularities and the failure to exhaust the mandatory provisions of the LRA, but the 2nd respondent did not address them. Section 27(2) (a) of the LRA requires Form J to be filed when applying to the 2nd respondent for amendments to the constitution. It should be accompanied by minutes signed by the chairperson of the meeting. The petitioner did not sign the minutes before these were forwarded to the 2nd respondent for publication through the Gazette Notice.

No investigation was conducted into the complaint. No notice was issued in the newspapers inviting objections to the interested party constitution amendments; therefore, the same are unlawful and unconstitutional, and the orders sought should be issued. Costs of the petition be awarded to the petitioner.

The 1st respondent and the interested party submitted that on 22 January 2026, the interested party held the quinquennial conference where the union constitution was lawfully amended, and the relevant body effected the same. The 2nd respondent registered the amendments on 12 May 2026. The interested party did not receive any objections to the amendments from the petitioner before submitting them.

The 1st respondent and the interested party submitted that the amendments to the interested party's constitution are lawful and were procedurally made by the union's highest authority, the quinquennial conference. Contrary to the petitioner's assertions, the union received no objections. Indeed, under Article 41(1) and (4) of the Constitution, the interested party could address its activities, including amending its Constitution. The amendments were advertised in various newspapers circulated nationwide on 22 April 2026, in line with section 27 of the LRA.

The petition is without merit and should be dismissed. The reliefs sought are untenable and should be dismissed with costs.

In Anthony Ndegwa Kinyua v KUPPET & another, Petition E095 of 2025, the court held that the union did not violate its constitution by amending it. The Registrar of Trade Unions lawfully approved and registered the proposed changes as submitted by the union.

Determination

On the pleadings, the statements and written submissions, the issues which emerge for determination are whether the 2nd respondent failed to address its mandate under section 27(4) of the LRA; whether the refusal to accept the proposed amendments to the interested party constitution is in violation of articles 41(1) and (4) of the Constitution; and whether an order of certiorari to quash Gazette Notice No. 6021 in the Kenya Gazette V.CXXVIII of 24 April 2026 should be issued.

The petitioner’s case is that, as the chairman of the interested party, the 1st respondent issued notice of the quinquennial conference on 2 January 2026, to be held on 22 January 2026. The agenda item was to hold national elections. However, without compliance with the LRA or the interested party constitution, amendments were submitted to the 2nd respondent and, without investigation or compliance with section 27(4) of the LRA, were gazetted. His complaint and objections dated 22 April 2026 were not addressed.

The 1st respondent and interested party case is that the interested party has a mandate to protect the welfare and rights of all interested party members. On 22 January 2026, the interested party held its quinquennial conference, which lawfully amended the constitution. The interested party's lawful body effected the amendments, and the 2nd respondent has since gazetted and published the registration of the amendments on 12 May 2026. No objections were raised to the amendments at the quinquennial conference or before it, and the 2nd respondent has since caused a notice to be issued in the Gazette.

Notice of the interested party quinquennial conference was issued on 2 January 2026, and the same was held on 22 January 2026.

The 2nd respondent received the returns on the conference on interested party constitution amendments by notice dated 22 January 2026. The notice of the constitution amendment is signed by 7 persons and approved by the 1st respondent as the SG. The petitioner filed this record with his supporting affidavit dated 29 April 2026 as annexure “EO-3”.

The amended constitution is attached to the form.

On 21 April 2026, the 2nd respondent issued notice for the publication of the interested party's Constitution amendments.

On 24 April 2026, Gazette Notice No. 6021 was issued. It related to the amendments to the interested party's Constitution. Objections were invited upon the notice.

The petitioner has relied on section 27(4) of the LRA in challenging the refusal by the 2nd respondent to investigate which states:

(4) Upon receipt of the notice of change of name or constitution, the Registrar shall give a notice of at least twenty-one days in the Gazette and in three daily newspapers of national circulation inviting any objections to the proposed change of name or constitution by members of the trade union and where any such objection is raised, the Registrar shall investigate the complaint and the grounds relied upon and may—

These provisions require the 2nd respondent to publish any amendments to the union constitution. Upon the 2nd respondent's Gazette Notice, any objections to the proposed amendments should be made. In Monanda & 7 others v Universities' Academic Staff Union (UASU) & 3 others; Registrar of Trade Unions & another (Interested Parties) [2025] KEELRC 1708 (KLR), the court held that the Gazette Notice by the Registrar of Trade Unions about the Union's proposed amendments to its constitution should follow the publication of the same. Section 27(4) of the LRA provides for 21 days.

In this case, the petitioner made his objections through a letter dated 22 April 2026. He argued that the proposed interested party Constitution amendments were not on the agenda; under Rules 4 and 20 of the interested party Constitution, no vote was taken on the proposed amendments, and the conference never approved them. Fundamentally, the petitioner objected that, as national chairman, he did not approve the minutes as required under Rule 12 of the interested party Constitution.

What is clear to the court is that the petitioner is the interested party chairman. He made his complaint on behalf of the interested party. This was done together with Silas Ngweso Otwala.

The logic then of adding the union as an interested party is lost.

Although the LRA gives prominence to the union constitution regarding holding elections, the 2nd respondent's challenged mandate to apply section 27(4) of the LRA was exercised. As the chairman of the interested party, the General Secretary, not the chairman, is responsible for communicating the quinquennial conference resolutions. Section 2 of the LRA grants the General Secretary the sole mandate to communicate the matters relating to the affairs of the trade union. The General Secretary therefore approved the notice of proposed amendments to the interested party Constitution, issued on 22 January 2026.

Rule 4 of the Interested Parties Constitution, 2011 provides for amendments to the Constitution through notice issued not later than 2 weeks before the date of the conference.

Rule 4 of the Interested Parties Constitution cannot be read in isolation. Rule 8 gives the quinquennial conference supreme authority within the interested party. The union's power lies within it. The petitioner is the chairperson, and the 1st respondent has authority to communicate interested-party decisions. Rule 12(a) therefore gives the power to preside over interested-party meetings and conferences to the chairman, a position held by the petitioner.

The petitioner therefore cannot turn back on the meetings he presided over and assert that illegalities were committed. Such would render him tainted and with unclean hands to seek in equity. Under his leadership and chairmanship, the quinquennial conference was held on 22 January 2026, and part of the resolution registered with the 2nd respondent was through a Form J dated 22 January 2026, seeking amendments to the interested party constitution.

As the person chairing the quinquennial conference on 22 January 2026, when the agenda for the amendments to the constitution arose, the petitioner did not address it. He proceeded and sat back until 22 April 2026, exactly 90 days after presiding over the quinquennial conference.

The petition seeking to find that the 2nd respondent failed to exercise the powers under section 27(4) of the LRA to refuse the proposed amendments to the interested party constitution is unjustified. The 2nd respondent's mandate was to issue a 21-day notice in the Gazette inviting objections to the proposed changes. The next step was for the 2nd respondent to investigate any complaints and grounds relied upon and may then refer the matter to this Court, refuse to accept the changes, or make any orders he may deem fit in the circumstances.

Hence, under section 27(4)(a) to (c), the 2nd respondent has the latitude to investigate the objections/complaint and may refer the matter to court, refuse to accept the changes or make any orders that may be deemed fit in the circumstances.

In this case, the 2nd respondent has since caused the interested party constitution to be registered with the amendments. This is permissible under section 27 of the LRA. Section 27(5) of the LRA allow the 2nd respondent:

(5) The Registrar may approve a change of name or to the constitution if the applicable requirements of registration of a trade union, employer’s organisation or federation are met.

Therefore, the 2nd respondent's actions under section 27 of the LRA are, to the extent that this is just. Still, the office is to receive proposed constitutional amendments, including those from the interested party. The allegation that the 2nd respondent should have refused to accept the proposed amendments would be an abdication of duty.

Form J to the LRA schedule emanates from the subject trade union and not the 2nd respondent. In this case, several interested party members filed and signed Form J with the 1st respondent's approval. Under section 41(1) and (4) of the Constitution, the case that the petitioner or the interested party was not allowed to determine its own administration, programme and activities cannot stand. Upon being moved, the 2nd respondent executed the office's legal mandate as necessary.

The Court finds no violation of Article 41 of the Constitution.

Quashing Gazette Notice No. 6021 in the Kenya Gazette V.CXXVIII of 24 April 2026 would be unjustified, as it was issued to invite objections and allow the petitioner the right to state his case and complaint. The 2nd respondent discharged its lawful mandate, which it did.

The petition is therefore without merit and is hereby dismissed. Costs to the 1st respondent and the interested party.

Dated this 15th Day of October 2026

M. MBARU

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Court Assistant: Mohammed Ali

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder