General

Njoroge v Mutiso (Sued as the legal representative of the Estate of Benard Mutua) & another [2026] KEHC 15892 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
High Court of Kenya At Machakos
Judgment date
7 October 2026
Judge(s)
Noel I. Adagi
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Question before the court

I have considered the application, the supporting affidavit, the replying affidavit and the rival submissions filed by the Parties’ counsel as well as the judicial decisions relied upon. In my view, the issues for determination are as follows:-

Paragraph 13 →

Decision / orders

Save for the Respondent being delayed and or denied the enjoyment of fruits of his judgement delivered by the subordinate court, there is no prejudice and none has been exhibited by the Respondent, that is likely to be occasioned to him if leave to appeal is granted at this point.

Paragraph 26 →

Reasoning passage

In this case, the Respondent has averred that the Applicant's Insurer acknowledged that the Applicant actually did refer the matter to them and they subsequently took up the matter by hiring the law firm of Ombuna Ongeri & Company Advocates to act for the Applicant in the Primary Suit as evidence by a Copy of Memorandum of Appearance marked “SMM-1”. This averment is not disputed by the Applicant and therefore, this court finds that the…

Paragraph 21 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the High Court should extend time for Jackline Wanjiru Njoroge to appeal the 17 July 2025 judgment in Mavoko CMCC E030 of 2024, and whether execution should be stayed pending the intended appeal.

Material facts

The subordinate court entered judgment jointly and severally against the Applicant and the 2nd Respondent for Kshs.4,450,000, plus costs and interest. The Applicant said her insurer-appointed advocates had not involved her in the proceedings and that she…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS

HCMISC NO. E343 OF 2025

JACKLINE WANJIRU NJOROGE ...........................................APPLICANT

-VERSUS-

STANLEY MUTUA MUTISO Sued as the Legal Representative of the Estate of BENARD MUTUA.........................................1ST RESPONDENT

RAPHAEL MULINGE.................................................2ND RESPONDENT

RULING

1. This ruling is on the Applicant’s Notice of Motion application dated 4th November, 2025 seeking for the following Orders:

a) Spent

b) THAT pending the hearing and determination this application inter-partes, the Honourable Court be pleased to stay the execution of the judgment entered on the 17th July 2025 in Mavoko CMCC E030 OF 2024.

c) THAT the Applicant be granted leave to file an appeal against the Judgment and decree of the Honourable Magistrate in Mavoko CMCC E030 OF 2024 delivered on 17th July 2025 in terms of the attached draft Memorandum of Appeal out of time.

d) THAT pending the hearing and determination of the intended appeal, there be stay of execution of the Decree emanating from the judgment delivered in Mavoko CMCC E030 OF 2024 on 17th July 2025.

e) Spent.

f) THAT costs of this application be in the cause.

2. The application is supported by the affidavit of Jackline Wanjiru Njoroge, the Applicant sworn on 4th November 2025 and is based on the following grounds :-

a. Vide a judgment of the Court delivered on the 17th July 2025, the Honourable Court entered judgment against the applicant and 2nd Respondent, jointly and severally to the tune of Kshs.4,450,000 plus cost and interests.

b. At all material times to the suit, the Applicant was never involved nor informed of the proceedings in the matter as the same were handled by advocates appointed by the insurance company Corporate Insurance.

c. In fact, neither the Applicant nor the 2nd Respondent ever recorded witness statements or attended court in the defence of the said suit as there was no communication form the Insurance lawyer.

d. It was only until the 27th of October 2025, when the Applicant was served with Warrants of Attachment and a proclamation notice dated the 23rd of October 2025 that she conducted due diligence and got a hold of the judgment and decree against her.

e. The delay in instituting the Appeal is solely the mistake of the advocates previously on record and their failure to exercise diligence in the matter and involve the Applicant in the prosecution of the matter.

f. The Applicant is now keen to appeal the said judgment on the grounds listed in the attached Memorandum of Appeal, which appeal is arguable and has a high chance to succeed. With the said judgment, the Respondent is keen on executing against the Applicant, currently for the sum of Kshs.4,862,662.83 yet the Appeal is arguable and has a high likelihood of success.

g. The Applicant thus hastily moves to this court seeking a stay of execution of the judgment and decree and leave to appeal the judgment out of time.

h. The application has been filed without any delay.

i. That the Applicant undertakes to lodge the intended appeal expeditiously within such time as this Honourable Appellate Court may order.

j. That it is therefore in the interest of justice and fairness that the Application herein be certified urgent and the prayers sought in the Application be granted.

k. That the Applicant is able, ready and willing to comply with any orders that the Honourable Court shall make with regards to the prayers sought.

3. The application is opposed by Stanley Mutua Mutiso, the Respondent vide his replying affidavit sworn on 9th February 2026. The Respondent in response and in objection to the application, avers that the application is bad in law, incompetent, mischievous, frivolous, vexatious and amounts to an abuse of court process and hence the same ought to be dismissed in the first instance. That the Applicant was properly served with the Demand Letter and subsequently Summons to Enter Appearance and Plaint and therefore she had full knowledge of these Proceedings in the Primary Suit from the outset.

4. The Respondent states that the Applicant was properly represented by her Insurer's Advocates, who duly entered appearance on her behalf and she had the opportunity to monitor or participate in the proceedings.

5. That the Applicant's Insurer acknowledged that the Applicant actually did refer the matter to them and they subsequently took up the matter by hiring the law firm of Ombuna Ongeri & Company Advocates to act for the Applicant in the Primary Suit as evidence by a Copy of Memorandum of Appearance marked “SMM-1”.

6. The Respondent avers that Judgment was delivered in his favour on the 17/7/2025 in the sum of Kenya Shillings Four Million Four Hundred and Fifty Thousand Kshs.4,450,000/= together with Costs of Kshs.268,250/= and Interest of Kshs.141,912.33/= as per the Copy of Decree & Certificate of Assessed Costs marked “SMM-2”.

7. That subsequently, the Applicant's Insurer made a settlement proposal for monthly instalments of Kenya Shillings Two Hundred Thousand (Kshs.200,000/=) on the basis of their Policy Limit of Kenya Shillings Three Million (Kshs.3,000,000/=) as per the letter marked "SMM-3".

8. That the Applicant has not filed any Appeal and now seeks to file an Appeal out of time, without reasonable explanation of her inaction for Four (4) Months since judgment. The filing of the application, only after execution proceedings commenced, demonstrates tactical manoeuvring intended to delay enforcement, not genuine grievance.

9. It is stated that the Applicant has failed to offer a convincing explanation for the inordinate delay and demonstrate sufficient cause for the extension of time. That negligence, overreliance on her Insurer and/or failure to monitor proceedings cannot constitute sufficient cause.

10. It is further stated that the Applicant has not demonstrated substantial loss that she stands to suffer if execution proceeds. The mere filing of an Intended Memorandum of Appeal should not operate as a Stay of Execution.

11. That the Judgment herein was delivered after a full hearing on merits and there are no exceptional circumstances warranting stay of execution but in in the event that the Court is inclined to grant any orders sought by the Applicant, then in the interest of justice and fairness, the Court should order the Applicant to deposit the entire decretal sum of Kshs.4,862,662.33/= in a Joint Interest-earning account in the names of both Advocates as a condition precedent.

12. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions and both parties filed their respective submissions. Those submissions replicate the summary above and I wish not to duplicate the same here.

Analysis and determination

13. I have considered the application, the supporting affidavit, the replying affidavit and the rival submissions filed by the Parties’ counsel as well as the judicial decisions relied upon. In my view, the issues for determination are as follows:-

a. Whether the court should exercise its discretion to grant the applicant leave to file her appeal out of time;

b. Whether the Applicant has met the prerequisite for grant of stay of execution pending appeal;

a. Whether the court should exercise its discretion to grant the Applicant leave to file her appeal out of time;

14. It is trite law that an appeal from the subordinate Court to the High Court may be admitted out of time as far as the Applicant satisfies the Court that she had good and sufficient cause for not filing the appeal in time.

15. Section 79G of the Civil Procedure Act states: -

“Every appeal from a subordinate court to the High Court shall be filed within a period of thirty days from the date of the decree or order appealed against, excluding from such period any time which the lower court may certify as having been requisite for the preparation and delivery of a copy of the decree or order:

Provided that an appeal may be admitted out of time if the appellant satisfies the court that he had good and sufficient cause for not filing the appeal in time.

16. It is clear from the wording of Section 79G of the Civil Procedure Act that before the court considers extension of time, the Applicant must satisfy the court that that she has good and sufficient cause for filing the appeal out of time. This principle was enunciated in the case of Diplack Kenya Limited vs William Muthama Kitonyi [2018] eKLR that an Applicant seeking enlargement of time to file an appeal or admission of an already filed appeal must show that he/she has a good cause for doing so.

17. The Supreme Court in the case of Nicholas Kiptoo Korir Arap Salat vs IEBC & 7 Others [2014] eKLR enunciated the principles applicable in an application for leave to appeal out of time. The court stated inter alia that:-

“The underlying principles a court should consider in exercise of such discretion should include:-

a. Extension of time is not a right of any party. It is an equitable remedy that is only available to a deserving party at the discretion of the court;

b. A party who seeks for extension of time has the burden of laying a basis to the satisfaction of the court;

c. Whether the court should exercise the discretion to extend time, is a consideration to be made on a case-by-case basis;

d. Whether there is a reasonable reason for the delay. The delay should be explained to the satisfaction of the court;

e. Whether there will be any prejudice suffered by the respondent if the extension is granted;

f. Whether the application has been brought without undue delay.

18. Similarly in the case of Paul Musili Wambua vs Attorney General & 2 Others [2015] eKLR, the Court of Appeal in considering an application for extension of time and leave to file the Notice of Appeal out of time stated the following:-

“…….it is now settled by a long line of authorities by this court that the decision of whether or not to extend the time for filing an appeal the Judge exercises unfettered discretion. However, in the exercise of such discretion, the court must act upon reason(s) not based on whim or caprice. In general, the matters which a court takes into account in deciding whether or not to grant an extension of time are; the length of delay, the reason for the delay, the chances of the appeal succeeding if the application is granted, the degree of prejudice to the respondent if the application is granted.”

19. Applying the above principles to the present case, the judgment herein was delivered on 17.07.2025 and the appeal ought to have been filed by 17.08.2025. The Applicant filed the current application dated 04.11.2025 together with the annexed Memorandum of Appeal on 05.11.2025 which were filed almost four months after the lapse of the appeal window. The Applicant has attributed the delay in filing her appeal solely to the mistake of the advocates previously on record and their failure to exercise diligence in the matter and involve the Applicant in the prosecution of the matter.

20. In Itute Ngui & Anor vs. Isumail Mwakavi Mwendwa Civil Application No. Nai. 166 of 1997, Omolo, JA held that whereas advocate’s bona fide error is a special reason for extension of time within which to appeal, the nature and quality of the mistake must be considered. It is therefore clear that whereas inadvertence may be a ground for extension of time, the nature and quality of the inadvertence must be disclosed for consideration by the Court.

21. In this case, the Respondent has averred that the Applicant's Insurer acknowledged that the Applicant actually did refer the matter to them and they subsequently took up the matter by hiring the law firm of Ombuna Ongeri & Company Advocates to act for the Applicant in the Primary Suit as evidence by a Copy of Memorandum of Appearance marked “SMM-1”. This averment is not disputed by the Applicant and therefore, this court finds that the Applicant was well aware of the existence of the suit and had a duty as party to it to keenly follow up on the same at every stage of the proceedings. It is my position that nothing stopped the Applicant from following up with her Insurer to find out what action they had taken after she presented the Court Summons to them. The mistake alluded to of the advocates previously on record for the Applicant in their failure to exercise diligence in the matter and involve the Applicant in the prosecution of the matter does not therefore hold any water and the same is misconceived.

22. On the foregoing, this court considers the four (4) months delay to be inordinate delay and finds the reason for the delay not to have been satisfactorily explained and convincing to this court as required by the law. In my view, the Applicant has not given any plausible reasons for the delay in filing the appeal.

23. I have perused the draft Memorandum of Appeal dated 4th November 2025 and the judgment of the trial court delivered on 17th July 2025 and noted that the appeal faults the trial court on several grounds including whether the 2nd Respondent was acting in the course and scope of employment when he ferried the deceased, an authorised passenger to amount to vicarious liability, whether the trial court was right to find the Applicant 100% liable yet no eye witness was brought before court to give a clear and true account of the circumstances of the accident, when exactly the deceased died after the accident on assessment of damages for pain and suffering, whether the trial court erred in using the gross salary as the multiplicand instead of the net salary in awarding damages for loss of dependency and lastly whether the special damages were specifically pleaded and strictly proved.

24. All the above identified grounds in the Applicant’s Memorandum of Appeal point to an arguable appeal. As such, the appeal cannot be said to be without merit although at this juncture, I will restrain from delving into the merits of the appeal

25. In Factory Guards Limited v Abel Vundi Kitungi 2014KEHC879 (KLR) it was stated as follows;

“The policy for this court is to apply the principle of the rule of law and exercise latitude in its interpretation of the rules so as to facilitate just determination of disputes on merit and thus facilitate access to justice for all by ensuring that deserving litigants are not shut out of the judgment seat.

26. Save for the Respondent being delayed and or denied the enjoyment of fruits of his judgement delivered by the subordinate court, there is no prejudice and none has been exhibited by the Respondent, that is likely to be occasioned to him if leave to appeal is granted at this point.

27. It is my considered view that the Applicant ought to be given a chance to file her appeal out of time and prosecute it on merits.

b. Whether the Applicant has met the prerequisite for grant of stay of execution pending appeal;

28. It is trite law that an appeal does not operate as an automatic stay of execution. The conditions which a party must establish in order for the court to order stay of execution are provided for under Order 42 Rule 6(2) Civil Procedure Rules. Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules stipulates:-

1.“No appeal or second appeal shall operate as a stay of execution or proceedings under a decree or order appealed from except in so far as the court appealed from may order but the court appealed from may for sufficient cause order stay of execution of such decree or order and whether the application for such stay shall have been granted or refused by the court appealed from the court to which such appeal is preferred shall be at liberty on application being made to consider such application and to make such order thereon as may to it seem just and any person aggrieved by an order of stay made by the court from whose decision the Appeal is preferred may apply to the appellate court to have such orders set aside.

2. No order for stay of execution shall be made under sub rule 1 unless:-

a. The Court is satisfied that substantial loss may result to the 1st Applicant unless the order is made and that the application has been made without unreasonable delay; and

b. Such security as the Court orders for the due performance of such decree or order as may ultimately be binding on him has been given by the Applicant.

29. Thus, under Order 42 Rule 6(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules, an applicant should satisfy the court that:

1. Substantial loss may result to him/her unless the order is made;

2. That the application has been made without unreasonable delay; and

3. The applicant has given such security as the court orders for the due performance of such decree or order as may ultimately be binding on him.

30. Substantial loss was clearly explained in the case of James Wangalwa & Another vs Agnes Naliaka Cheseto [2012] eKLR:-

“No doubt in law, the fact that the process of execution has been put in motion, or is likely to be put in motion, by itself, does not amount to substantial loss. Even when execution has been levied and completed, that is to say, the attached properties have been sold, as is the case here does not in itself amount to substantial loss under Order 42 Rule 6 of the CPR. This is so because execution is a lawful process. The applicant must establish other factors which show that the execution will create a state of affairs that will irreparably affect or negate the very essential core of the applicant as the successful party in the appeal…the issue of substantial loss is the cornerstone of both jurisdictions. Substantial loss is what has to be prevented by preserving the status quo because such loss would render the appeal nugatory”

31. This court is alive to the fact that execution is a lawful process and it is not a ground for granting stay of execution. The Applicant is required to show the manner in which execution will irreparably affect her or will alter the status quo to her detriment therefore rendering the appeal nugatory.

32. The Applicant states that the Respondent is keen on executing against her the sum of Kshs.4,862,662.83 yet the appeal is arguable and has high likelihood of success. The Applicant has not demonstrated that she stands to suffer a substantial and irreparable loss and damage if stay of execution is denied. In any event, the judgement herein is a money decree and any loss to be suffered can adequately be compensated by an award in assessable damages.

33. On the issue of security for costs, the purpose of security was explained in the case of Arun C. Sharma vs Ashana Raikundalia t/a Raikundalia & Co. Advocates & 2 Others [2014] eKLR the court stated:-

“The purpose of the security needed under Order 42 is to guarantee the due performance of such decree or order as may ultimately be binding on the applicant. It is not to punish the judgment debtor…..Civil process is quite different because in civil process the judgment is like a debt hence the applicants become and are judgment debtors in relation to the respondent. That is why any security given under Order 42 Rule 6 of the Civil Procedure Rules acts as security for the due performance of such decree or order as may ultimately be binding on the applicants. I presume the security must be one which can serve that purpose.

34. Evidently, the issue of security is discretionary and it is upon the court to determine it and set its terms. The Applicant has categorically stated that she is able, ready and willing to comply with any orders that this court shall make with regard to the prayers sought.

35. Unfortunately, this court has not been told whether the Applicant Insurer’s settlement proposal for monthly instalments of Kenya Shillings Two Hundred Thousand (Kshs.200,000/=) on the basis of their Policy Limit of Kenya Shillings Three Million (Kshs.3,000,000/=) as per the letter marked "SMM-3" as averred by the Respondent was ever effected and if so, how much of the decretal sum is outstanding at this point.

36. It is imperative that the right of appeal must be balanced against an equally weighty rigid right of the plaintiff/claimant to enjoy the fruits of the judgment delivered in his/her favour. In the case of Samvir Trustee Limited vs Guardian Bank Limited [2007] eKLR the court stated:-

“The Court in considering whether to grant or refuse an application for stay is empowered to see whether there exist any special circumstances which can sway the discretion of the court in a particular manner. But the yardstick is for the court to balance or weigh the scales of justice by ensuring that an appeal is not rendered nugatory while at the same time ensuring that a successful party is not impeded from the enjoyment of the fruits of his judgment. It is a fundamental factor to bear in mind that a successful party is prima facie entitled to fruits of his judgment; hence the consequence of a judgment is that it has defined the rights of a party with definitive conclusion.”

37. Consequently, I do find that the Applicant is entitled to leave to appeal out of time and to pursue the appeal on merit. I do allow the application dated 4th November 2025 and make the following orders:-

a. Leave be and is hereby granted to the Applicant/Intended Appellant to file appeal out of time against the judgment and decree of the Honourable Magistrate in Mavoko CMCC E030 OF 2024 delivered on 17th July 2025 in terms of the attached draft Memorandum of Appeal dated 4th November 2025.

b. The Applicant/Intended Appellant shall file and serve her Memorandum of Appeal as per the attached draft within Seven (7) days hereof and thereafter to compile, file and serve the Record of Appeal within Forty-Five (45) days of this ruling in default, appropriate directions shall be given on the matter including dismissal of the appeal.

c. Execution of the judgment and decree of the Honourable Magistrate in Mavoko CMCC E030 OF 2024 delivered on 17th July 2025 is hereby stayed pending the hearing and determination of the appeal on condition that the Applicant/Intended Appellant shall deposit Kenya Shillings Three Million (Kshs.3,000,000) into court OR into a joint interest earning Bank Account to be opened in a reputable commercial Bank in the law firm names of the Advocates for the Parties herein within forty five (45) days hereof in default the Respondent will be at liberty to execute.

d. The costs of the application shall be in the appeal.

e. A mention date to be fixed to confirm compliance with order a, b and c above and for further directions.

38. This Miscellaneous file will be closed on the next mention date.

39. It is hereby so ordered.

RULING DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED ON VIRTUAL TEAMS AT MACHAKOS THIS 7TH OCTOBER 2026

NOEL I. ADAGI

JUDGE