General

Truckers Association of Kenya v Attorney General & 2 others [2026] KEHC 16857 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
High Court of Kenya At Machakos
Case number
Constitutional Petition E007 of 2025
Judgment date
26 October 2026
Judge(s)
J W W Mongare

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

What is before the court for determination is a Petition dated 25th February 2025 filed by the Petitioner challenging the Environmental Management and Co-ordination (Sand Harvesting) Regulations, 2024 gazetted on 4th November 2024(“the Regulations”) and a subsequent Notice dated 18th February 2025(“the Notice”) requiring all sand transporters to obtain a sand transportation permit from NEMA.

Paragraph 1 →

Decision / orders

As I have found that this court has no jurisdiction to entertain this matter, I am bound by the Court of Appeal decision in Phoenix of E.A. Assurance Company Limited v S. M. Thiga t/a Newspaper Service [2019] KECA 767 (KLR) that where a matter is a nullity ab initio for want of jurisdiction, the proper and lawful course is to strike it out and there is no legal room for ordering a transfer to the appropriate court. Therefore, the…

Paragraph 18 →

Reasoning passage

While I can agree that this court does have jurisdiction to interpret the Constitution and determine if a law is inconsistent with it under Article 165(3)(d), I note that the ELC in Muthui(supra) also explicitly dealt with similar claims lack of public participation and the ELC still took jurisdiction because the core dispute related to the right to a clean and healthy environment under Article 42 and sustainable development. Given…

Paragraph 17 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the High Court had jurisdiction to determine a constitutional petition challenging the Environmental Management and Co-ordination (Sand Harvesting) Regulations, 2024 and NEMA’s notice requiring sand transporters to obtain transportation permits, or…

Material facts

Truckers Association of Kenya challenged Regulations gazetted on 4 November 2024 and a 18 February 2025 notice on NEMA sand transportation permits. It alleged inadequate public participation, unconstitutional intrusion into county functions, double taxation…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS

CONSTITUTIONAL PETITION NO. E007 OF 2025

BETWEEN

TRUCKERS ASSOCIATION OF KENYA…………………..…………..PETITIONER

AND

THE ATTORNEY GENERAL………….……………...…………….1ST RESPONDENT

CABINET SECRETARY,

MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT,

CLIMATE CHANGE AND FORESTRY………………..………….2ND RESPONDENT

NATIONAL ENVIRONMENT

MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY (NEMA)……………..…………3RD RESPONDENT

JUDGMENT

Introduction & Background

1. What is before the court for determination is a Petition dated 25th February 2025 filed by the Petitioner challenging the Environmental Management and Co-ordination (Sand Harvesting) Regulations, 2024 gazetted on 4th November 2024(“the Regulations”) and a subsequent Notice dated 18th February 2025(“the Notice”) requiring all sand transporters to obtain a sand transportation permit from NEMA.

2. The Petitioner avers that the Regulations and the Notice are unconstitutional, illegal, null and void for reasons that the Regulations were promulgated without adequate public participation, that there was no sufficient notice in all relevant languages, nor was adequate time given for the public and stakeholders to understand and give input on the Regulations before they were enacted. The Petitioner states that this violates Article 10 of the Constitution on national values and principles of governance, including participation of the people.

3. The Petitioner states that the Regulations and the Notice are illegal because they mandate NEMA to implement and enforce sand harvesting regulations, including issuing permits and yet under the Part 2 of the Fourth Schedule of the Constitution, county governments are responsible for implementing specific government policies on natural resources and environmental conservation and therefore, it is unconstitutional for NEMA to take over this role. That the Regulations and the Notice impose an undue burden on sand transporters by requiring them to apply and pay for sand transportation permits from both NEMA and county governments and that this, the Petitioner contends, amounts to double taxation and is illegal.

4. The Petitioner challenges specific Regulations therein including Regulation 6 which creates Ward Sand Harvesting Committees and that requiring a representative of sand dealers is vague and overbroad as it does not specify how this representative is selected, leaving it to the subjective discretion of the Governor. That Regulation 12(1) mandating County Environment Committees to set minimum pricing guidelines is unconstitutional as it creates market uncertainty, limits the discretion of buyers and sellers and ignores factors of production and processing. Further, that Regulation 12(4) requiring County Environment Committees to set minimum wages for sand loaders is unreasonable as it does not account for regional economic differences and factors of production, violating the rule of law and certainty.

5. The Petitioner adds that Regulation 13 is offensive as the conditions for obtaining permits are illegal as they usurp the roles reserved for County Governments under the Constitution and that Regulation 13(9) restricting sand transportation to between 6:00 a.m. and 6:00 p.m. is discriminatory and it curtails the freedom of movement and the right to livelihood of sand transporters, unlike people in other businesses. Further, that it also ignores real-world factors like traffic jams and will lead to increased sand prices. The Petitioner faults Regulation 16(3) as prohibiting sand harvesting from permanent river sources is unconstitutional as it limits and takes away the right to harvest sand without justification, contrary to Article 24 of the Constitution and that as per the First Schedule, the requirement for sand transporters to provide details on the "Transport of Sand Source" is unreasonable and creates uncertainty. The Petitioner claims that transporters are often not the harvesters and may transport sand from various counties, making it unclear if they need a new permit for every trip.

6. The Petitioner contends that the Regulations are illegal and contrary to sections 5, 7, 8, 11, and 12 of the Statutory Instruments Act due to the lack of public participation and the failure to table the Regulations in Parliament for scrutiny within the required statutory timelines. That the implementation of the Regulations has caused grave hardship and violated the Petitioner's members' fundamental rights, including the right to equal protection of the law under Article 27, the right to fair administrative action under Article 47 and the right to life and livelihood under Articles 26 and 43 of the Constitution. For these reasons, the Petitioner is seeking the declaratory orders that the Regulations and the Notice are unconstitutional and contrary to Articles 10, 21, 24, 26, 27, 43, 47, and 232 of the Constitution, that they are illegal, null and void and that the requirement to obtain permits from both NEMA and County Governments amounts to illegal double taxation.

7. The 1st and 2nd Respondents responded to the Petition through the Grounds of Opposition dated 14th January 2026 whereas NEMA responded through the replying affidavit of its Director, Environmental Compliance, David On’gare sworn on 17th March 2026. They state that this Court lacks the jurisdiction to hear this matter as the issues raised relate to the regulation, management and conservation of natural resources, that is, sand harvesting. That under Article 165(5)(b) and Article 162(2) of the Constitution, the High Court's jurisdiction is ousted for matters falling within the specialized jurisdiction of the Environment and Land Court (ELC) and that the substance of the Petition concerns the legality and application of environmental regulations, making it a matter for the ELC and therefore, this court should decline jurisdiction.

8. The Respondents urge that the Petition is fatally defective and they claim it does not meet the threshold for specificity in drafting constitutional petitions, as established in the case of Anarita Karimi Njeru v Republic [1979] KEHC 30 (KLR) and reiterated by the Court of Appeal in Matemu v Trusted Society of Human Rights Alliance & 5 others [2013] KECA 445 (KLR). That the Petition fails to meet the basic requirements set out in Rule 10 of the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules (“the Mutunga Rules”) and that the orders sought are vague and ambiguous, making them incapable of being granted.

9. On the merits of the Petition, the Respondents state that the Regulations were promulgated out of a compelling state interest to address widespread environmental degradation caused by unregulated sand harvesting. That the previous 2007 guidelines lacked the force of law to ensure compliance and the Regulations are intended to provide a unified national standard, acting as a safety net for counties that have not enacted their own legislation. They assert that the Regulations do not usurp county functions but are indispensable to NEMA's constitutional mandate under Article 69 to sustainably manage natural resources and monitor sand sources throughout their lifecycle. They state that the Regulations were gazetted on 4th November 2024, under Legal Notice No. 179 of 2024 and were to take effect on 4th February 2025. NEMA depones that it complied with section 11 of the Statutory Instruments Act by dispatching the final draft to the Cabinet Secretary for onward transmission to Parliament.

10. NEMA adds that it conducted a comprehensive public participation process which included public notices in print media and on their website inviting comments on the draft Regulations and a Regulatory Impact Assessment. That it held stakeholder engagement forums in several counties, including Kitui on 31st October 2022, Homa Bay on 14th November 2022 and Taita Taveta on 27th April 2023 where stakeholders were given the opportunity to present their views, which were recorded and substantively considered, resulting in revisions to the draft Regulations before gazettement. They aver that the Petitioner's claim of exclusion is misleading, as they failed to utilize the ample opportunities provided.

11. On the contents of the Regulations, they state that Regulation 6 provides for Sub-Regulations (4) and (5) provide for a consultative and transparent appointment process, ensuring fair representation, that the power under Regulation 12 to set minimum pricing is a fettered discretion meant to align with fair competition laws and that wage guidelines were included to address public concerns about the exploitation of local laborers, aligning with Article 41 of the Constitution. On Regulation 13(9), they contend that the restriction of sand transportation to daylight hours is a critical enforcement and security measure and that it was specifically advocated for by the public during the Homa Bay forum to address noise, security hazards and illegal night harvesting. On Regulation 16(3), they state that the prohibition of harvesting from permanent river sources is a vital ecological safeguard for national water towers, which NEMA is constitutionally obligated to prioritize. The Respondents deny the claim that permits are required for every trip and that the Sand Transportation Permit under the Second Schedule is valid for three (3) months, providing administrative predictability.

12. For these reasons, the Respondents pray that the Petition be dismissed in its entirety with costs awarded to them, as it is premised on a misapprehension of the law and is an effort to subvert NEMA's statutory and constitutional mandate to protect the environment. The Petition was canvassed by way of written and oral submissions which are a mirror of the positions taken by the parties above, therefore, I will not highlight the same but I make relevant references in my analysis and determination below.

Analysis and Determination

13. I propose to first deal with the jurisdictional challenge raised by the Respondents on whether this matter ought to have been filed before the ELC. Having gone through the Petition, I am inclined to agree with them that while the Petitioner frames the issue as a constitutional challenge because of lack of public participation and double taxation, the substance of the dispute is fundamentally about the regulation, management and conservation of sand as a natural resource, which in my view, is a matter exclusively reserved for the ELC under Article 162(2)(b) of the Constitution.

14. I am persuaded by the decision in Muthui & 19 others v County Government of Kitui & 7 others [2023] KEELC 15930 (KLR) where the ELC explicitly asserted its jurisdiction over sand harvesting disputes, stating that it is the ELC and not the National Environmental Tribunal or this court for that matter that has the mandate to determine if rights under Articles 42, 69, and 70 of the Constitution have been infringed by sand harvesting activities. The court held that because the petitioners were challenging the infringement of their environmental rights rather than a specific NEMA decision, the ELC was the proper forum. Similarly, in Akuku & another v County Government of Siaya & 3 others [2024] KEELC 3571 (KLR), the ELC confirmed that section 13 of the Environment and Land Court Act donates it with the jurisdiction to hear applications for redress of violations of rights relating to the environment. The court specifically dealt with the constitutionality and legality of sand harvesting activities under the repealed National Sand Harvesting Guidelines, 2007, demonstrating that the ELC is the natural forum for these issues.

15. I agree with NEMA’s deposition that this Court’s jurisdiction is ousted by Article 165(5)(b) of the Constitution for matters falling within the ELC’s jurisdiction and that the Petitioner’s framing of the suit as a constitutional petition does not change the underlying reality. The Court of Appeal in Kibos Distillers Limited & 4 others v Benson Ambuti Adega & 3 others [2020] KECA 875 (KLR) established that courts must look at the substance of the claim and not just the label. The Petitioner’s grievances regarding transportation permits, EIA licenses for sand sources and the prohibition of harvesting from permanent rivers are all operational aspects of the Regulations which are quintessential environmental governance issues.

16. Further, it is not lost to the court that the ELC is a specialized court and it is constitutionally mandated to handle the technical and scientific evidence often required in environmental disputes. For instance, in Akuku (supra), the ELC dismissed the petition because the petitioners failed to provide expert scientific evidence to prove environmental degradation, noting the Court of Appeal’s position in Kibos (supra) that "pollution is primarily proved by empirical, technical and scientific evidence…". This demonstrates that the ELC is the appropriate court to evaluate the technical merits of sand harvesting regulations, including whether the depth limits, buffer zones and permit conditions are scientifically sound, which are matters that this court is less equipped to adjudicate.

17. While I can agree that this court does have jurisdiction to interpret the Constitution and determine if a law is inconsistent with it under Article 165(3)(d), I note that the ELC in Muthui(supra) also explicitly dealt with similar claims lack of public participation and the ELC still took jurisdiction because the core dispute related to the right to a clean and healthy environment under Article 42 and sustainable development. Given that the Petitioner’s specific complaints on double taxation, permit validity and transportation hours are operational challenges to an environmental regulation and the ELC has established precedent in handling sand harvesting disputes, I find that the proper forum for the Petitioner is to seek redress in the ELC, which can comprehensively address both the constitutional and environmental aspects of the Regulations.

Conclusion & Disposition

18. As I have found that this court has no jurisdiction to entertain this matter, I am bound by the Court of Appeal decision in Phoenix of E.A. Assurance Company Limited v S. M. Thiga t/a Newspaper Service [2019] KECA 767 (KLR) that where a matter is a nullity ab initio for want of jurisdiction, the proper and lawful course is to strike it out and there is no legal room for ordering a transfer to the appropriate court. Therefore, the Petition is struck out but with no order as to costs.

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED virtually this 26th DAY OF OCTOBER

2026

............................................................................

J W W MONGARE

JUDGE

In the presence of;

1. Mr. Mudanya for the Applicant

2. Ms. Mumo for the Respondents

3. Abdisalan- Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder