General

Republic v County Government of Machakos; Mutua & another (Ex parte Applicant) [2026] KEHC 16868 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
High Court of Kenya At Machakos
Case number
Judicial Review Application E034 of 2024
Judgment date
26 October 2026
Judge(s)
J W W Mongare

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Pursuant to leave granted by the court on 29th May 2025, the Ex Parte Applicants (“the Applicants”) filed a substantive Judicial Review Application dated 28th July 2025 against the Respondent. The Applicants contend that the Respondent acted unlawfully, irrationally and ultra vires by entering the names of four individuals; Bernard Masingi Maluki, Alphonce Mbatha Kisyula, Joshua Muteti Kilonzo and David Osano Ragira into the Valuation…

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

I have gone through the Applicants’ pleadings and submissions. Before delving into the issues for determination, I think it is appropriate to set out the jurisdiction and scope of the court when it comes to judicial review matters. Superior courts, more so our Supreme Court, have circumscribed the limits of traditional judicial review. In Saisi & 7 others v Director of Public Prosecutions & 2 others [2023] KESC 6 (KLR), the apex court…

Paragraph 5 →

Reasoning passage

For these reasons, I find merit in the Applicants’ application dated 28th July 2025 and proceed to issue the following dispositive orders:

Paragraph 21 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the County Government of Machakos acted illegally, ultra vires, irrationally, or unfairly in recording Bernard Masingi Maluki, Alphonce Mbatha Kisyula, Joshua Muteti Kilonzo and David Osano Ragira as rateable owners of LR No. 29666 in the Valuation…

Material facts

John Kioko Mutua and Sarah Mutua, acting for themselves and the family estates identified in the title, asserted ownership of LR No. 29666 (original LR No. 13208/2), held under a 99-year lease from 1 August 2008. They relied on Certificate of Title IR…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KENYA AT MACHAKOS

JUDICIAL REVIEW DIVISION

JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATION NO. E034 OF 2024

IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION FOR ORDERS OF CERTIORARI, MANDAMUS AND PROHIBITION

BETWEEN

REPUBLIC…………………………………..……………………………..APPLICANT

AND

COUNTY GOVERNMENT OF MACHAKOS……………………..…RESPONDENT

AND

JOHN KIOKO MUTUA & SARAH MUTUA…………….…EX PARTE APPLICANTS

JUDGMENT

Introduction and Background

1. Pursuant to leave granted by the court on 29th May 2025, the Ex Parte Applicants (“the Applicants”) filed a substantive Judicial Review Application dated 28th July 2025 against the Respondent. The Applicants contend that the Respondent acted unlawfully, irrationally and ultra vires by entering the names of four individuals; Bernard Masingi Maluki, Alphonce Mbatha Kisyula, Joshua Muteti Kilonzo and David Osano Ragira into the Valuation Roll as the rateable owners of land known as L.R. No. 29666 (Original No. L.R. 13208/2), measuring approximately 370.9 hectares in Mavoko Sub-County.

2. The Applicants further contend that alongside other family members as administrators and tenants in common, they hold valid leasehold titles from the Government for a 99-year term from 1st August 2008. That they have successfully established their ownership through multiple court judgments, including Machakos ELC Case No. 62 of 2018 and Machakos ELC Consolidated Petition No. 7 of 2019, where the court affirmed them as the lawful registered proprietors. Furthermore, that the individuals listed by the Respondent have been charged in criminal proceedings in Kiambu Criminal Case No. 121/21/2020 for forgery and uttering false documents regarding this property.

3. As such, the Applicants seek the following reliefs from the court:

1) An order of Certiorari to remove into the Honourable Court and quash the decision of the County Government of Machakos entering the names of BERNARD MASINGI MALUKI, ALPHONCE MBATHA KISYULA, JOSHUA MUTETI KILONZO and DAVID OSANO RAGIRA in the Valuation Roll as the rateable owners of the parcel of land known as LR 29666 (original No. LR No. 13208/2) measuring 370.9 Hectares, situated in Mavoko Sub-County of Machakos County

2) An Order of Mandamus directing the County Government of Machakos to alter and correct its records in the Valuation Roll by deleting the names of BERNARD MASINGI MALUKI, ALPHONCE MBATHA KISYULA, JOSHUA MUTETI KILONZO and DAVID OSANO RAGIRA rateable owners Of the parcel of land known as LR 29666 (original No. LR No. 13208/2) measuring 370.9 Hectares, situated in Mavoko Sub-County of Machakos County and recording in the Valuation Roll the names of John Kioko Mutua and Sarah Nzembi Mutua as the rateable owners of the parcel of land known as LR 29666 (original No. LR No. 13208/2) measuring 370.9 Hectares, situated in Mavoko Sub-County of Machakos County

3) Spent*

4) The costs of this Application be provided for.

4. This application is grounded and supported by the Statutory Statement dated 19th August 2024 and the verifying affidavit of John Kioko Mutua sworn on 5th August 2024. The Applicants also supplemented their arguments by filing written submissions. Despite service, the Respondent neither entered appearance nor filed any response to the application.

Analysis and Determination

5. I have gone through the Applicants’ pleadings and submissions. Before delving into the issues for determination, I think it is appropriate to set out the jurisdiction and scope of the court when it comes to judicial review matters. Superior courts, more so our Supreme Court, have circumscribed the limits of traditional judicial review. In Saisi & 7 others v Director of Public Prosecutions & 2 others [2023] KESC 6 (KLR), the apex court stated as follows:

[76] Be that as it may, it is the Court’s firm view that the intention was never to transform judicial review into to full-fledged inquiry into the merits of a matter. Neither was the intention to convert a judicial review court into an appellate court. We say this for several reasons. First, the nature of evidence in judicial review proceedings is based on affidavit evidence. This may not be the best suited form of evidence for a court to try disputed facts or issues and then pronounce itself on the merits or demerits of a case. More so on technical or specialized issues, as the specialised institutions are better placed to so. Second, the courts are limited in the nature of reliefs that they may grant to those set out in Section 11 (1) and (2) of the Fair Administrative Actions Act. Third, the Court may not substitute the decision it is reviewing with one of its own. The court may not set about forming its own preferred view of the evidence, rather it may only quash an impugned decision. This is codified in Section 11(1)(e) and (h) of the Fair Administrative Action Act. The merits of a case are best analyzed in a trial or on appeal after hearing testimony, cross-examination of witnesses and examining evidence adduced. Finally, as this Court held in the case of Kenya Vision 2030 Delivery Board v. The Commission on Administrative Justice, the Attorney General and Eng. Judah Abekah, SC Petition 42 of 2019; [2021] eKLR, in matters involving the exercise of judgment and discretion, a public officer or public agency can only be directed to take action; it cannot be directed in the manner or the particular way the discretion is to be exercised.

6. In Dande & 3 others v Inspector General, National Police Service & 5 others (Petition 6 (E007), 4 (E005) & 8 (E010) of 2022 (Consolidated)) [2023] KESC 40 (KLR) the apex court stated that when a party approaches a court under the provisions of the Constitution then the court ought to carry out a merit review of the case. However, if a party files a suit under the provisions of Order 53 of the Civil Procedure Rules and does not claim any violation of rights or even violation of the Constitution, then the Court can only limit itself to the process and manner in which the decision complained of was reached or action taken and not the merits of the decision per se

7. With the above principles and guidelines in mind, I now turn to the substance of the application. It is not lost that the Applicants’ application is anchored under Order 53 of the Rules and alleged violations of the Constitution meaning that the court will interrogate both a process-based and merit review of their application to the extent necessary to determine whether the constitutional violations occurred. As such, I am in agreement with the Applicants’ submissions that the court will determine the following issues:

a) Whether the decision by the County Government of Machakos to enter the names of Bernard Masingi Maluki, Alphonce Mbatha Kisyula, Joshua Muteti Kilonzo and David Osano Ragira in the Valuation Roll was illegal, ultra vires, irrational and procedurally unfair

b) Whether the impugned decision violated the Applicants’ constitutional rights and the Respondent’s constitutional obligations under Articles 10,40,47 201 and 209 of the Constitution

c) Whether the Applicants have satisfied the legal threshold for the grant of orders of Certiorari

8. The Applicants case is that they are the administrators of the estate of the late James Kasyula Mutua and other deceased family members and are holders of a Specific Power of Attorney over the suit property. They aver that bring this application on their own behalf and on behalf of the family of the late James Kasyula Mutua. They aver that the suit property is registered in the names of the Applicants and other family members as tenants in common in equal shares, as lessees from the Government of the Republic of Kenya for a term of 99 years from 1st August 2008.

9. They contend that the history of the suit property dates back to the original grant of lease over LR No. 13208 (original numbers 8529/3 and 10501/1) measuring 412 hectares, made by the President of the Republic of Kenya to D.C.K. Athi Limited for a term of 934 years and 10 months from 1st January 1974 and that this lease was transferred to the Applicants' family members on 12th November 1976. That in 2007, the family successfully applied to subdivide LR No. 13208 into three parcels: LR No. 28055 (8.093 hectares), LR No. 28056 (4.040 hectares), and LR No. 13208/2 (357.70–370.9 hectares) and the three new leases were for a shorter term of 99 years from 1st August 2008.

10. The Applicants depone that LR No. 13208/2 was later given a new number, LR No. 29666, after approval of the application for change of user and subdivision and that they complied with all conditions, including payment of Kshs. 2,343,800.00 on 20th September 2016 for change of user and approval fees, surrender of the original title for LR No. 13208/2, and execution of a Deed of Surrender on 7th February 2018. That on 17th January 2020, the Applicants were issued with a Certificate of Title IR 214142/1 for LR No. 29666, registered in the names of Sarah Nzembi Mutua, John Kioko Mutua, Simon Mutua, Moses Wambua, Peter Mweu, and Sarah Nzembi Mutua and John Kioko Mutua as Administrators of the Estate of James Kasyula Mutua, Ruth Kalekye Mutua, Anne Nduku Mutua and David Mutua Kasyula (deceased) , as tenants in common in equal shares. That on 16th January 2020, a lease of LR No. 29666 measuring 357.70 hectares was granted to the Applicants' family by the County Government of Machakos pursuant to a surrender, for a term of 99 years from 1st August 2008 for mixed-use development.

11. The Applicants claim that despite the Applicants' lawful ownership, the Respondent, in collusion with Bernard Masingi Maluki, Alphonce Mbatha Kisyula, Joshua Muteti Kilonzo and David Osano Ragira, proceeded to enter the names of these four individuals in the Valuation Roll as the rateable owners of the suit property. They assert that the four individuals are in possession of a forged Certificate of Title IR No. 203477 and have been charged with eight counts of making false documents, forgery, uttering false documents and conspiracy to defraud in Kiambu Criminal Case No. 121/21/2020 and they are out on bond awaiting trial. They contend that several competent courts have affirmed the Applicants as the lawful registered proprietors of the suit property including Machakos ELC No. 62 of 2018 where judgment was delivered on 15th February 2019 declaring the Applicants the lawful registered proprietors of LR No. 13208/2 (now LR No. 29666) and Machakos ELC Petition No. 7 of 2019 (consolidated with Machakos ELC No. 116 of 2019) where judgment was delivered on 14th November 2022 upholding the Applicants' title and quashing the notice of intent to subdivide and change user issued at the behest of the four individuals. They add that in Machakos ELC No. 27 of 2020, a ruling was delivered on 15th November 2022 setting aside a consent order obtained by the four individuals and issuing an injunction in favour of the Applicants.

12. The Applicants state that the Respondent was a party to Machakos ELC Petition No. 7 of 2019 and was fully aware of the judgments affirming the Applicants' title and that despite this knowledge, the Respondent proceeded to enter the four individuals' names in the Valuation Roll. That the Respondent's decision to enter the four individuals' names in the Valuation Roll was illegal, irrational and procedurally improper and violated the Applicants' constitutional rights under Articles 10, 201, 209(3) and (9), 35, 40, and 47 of the Constitution.

13. In their submissions the Applicants reiterate the above facts and submit that the Respondent's decision was ultra vires the National Rating Act(chapter 267 of the Laws of Kenya) and the valuation for the Rating Act (Chapter 266 of the Laws of Kenya), as the four individuals are not the lawful owners of the suit property. They submit that the Respondent's decision was irrational and unreasonable as no reasonable authority, possessed of this court and Environment and Land Court judgments affirming the Applicants' title and aware of the pending criminal charges against the four individuals for forgery, would have entered their names in the Valuation Roll. That the Respondent's decision was procedurally improper and violated the rules of natural justice, as the Applicants were never notified or given an opportunity to be heard before the four individuals' names were entered in the Valuation Roll and that the Respondent failed to take into account relevant considerations, including the judgments of the superior courts, the Certificate of Title IR 214142/1 issued to the Applicants, the pending criminal case and the Applicants' payment of land rates and rent.

14. The Applicants add that the Respondent's decision violated Articles 10, 201, 209(3) and (9), 35, 40, and 47 of the Constitution as well as sections 5, 6 and 131 of the County Governments Act(Chapter 265 of the Laws of Kenya) and sections 102 and 104 of the Public Finance Management Act, Chapter 412A of the Laws of Kenya). They also submit that the Respondent's failure to enter appearance or file a response means that the Applicants' evidence stands uncontroverted and the Court should rely on the Applicants' affidavit evidence as establishing the facts.

15. As stated in the introductory part, the Respondent was duly served with the application, the statutory statement, and the verifying affidavit but despite service, the Respondent did not enter appearance or file any response to the application. Even so, the Applicants still have a duty to prove their case on a balance of probabilities as is required by law. This was held by the Court of Appeal in Karugi & another v Kabiya & 3 others [1983] KECA 38 (KLR) where it was stated that, “The burden was always on the Plaintiff to prove his case on a balance of probabilities even if the case was heard as formal proof”. Likewise, failure by a defendant to contest the case does not absolve a plaintiff of the duty to prove the case to the required standard hence in Gichinga Kibutha v Caroline Nduku [2018] KEELC 3981 (KLR) the Court held that, “It is not automatic that instances where the evidence is not controverted the Claimants shall have his way in Court. He must discharge the burden of proof. He must prove his case however much the opponent has not made a presence in the contest.” In any event, the Respondent's conduct in failing to respond to the application, despite being served, is itself indicative of a lack of seriousness and suggests that the Respondent has no defence to the allegations of impropriety.

16. The impugned decision is the entry of the four individuals' names in the Valuation Roll as rateable owners of LR No. 29666. There is no contest that this was an administrative act by the Respondent under the repealed Rating Act and the repealed Valuation for Rating Act. The Valuation Roll is a public record of rateable owners and for a County Government to enter names in the Valuation Roll, it must be satisfied that the persons named are the owners of the rateable property. From the evidence, I find that the Applicants have demonstrated that they are the owners through the Certificate of Title IR 214142/1 issued on 17th January 2020 in the names of the Applicants and other family members, the Judgment in Machakos ELC No. 62 of 2018 declaring the Applicants the lawful registered proprietors, the judgment in Machakos ELC Petition No. 7 of 2019 upholding the Applicants' title and quashing the notice of intent to subdivide/change user issued at the behest of the four individuals and the Ruling in Machakos ELC No. 27 of 2020 setting aside a consent order obtained by the four individuals and issuing an injunction in favour of the Applicants.

17. The four individuals have never produced any valid title and their purported title (IR No. 203477) is the subject of criminal proceedings for forgery in Kiambu Criminal Case No. 121/21/2020. The Respondent, being aware of these judgments and the pending criminal case, nonetheless entered the four individuals' names in the Valuation Roll which in my view constitutes an error of law and a failure to comply with the legal framework governing the Valuation Roll. The Respondent clearly acted ultra vires its powers under the repealed Acts by recognizing persons who are not the lawful owners.

18. I am in agreement with the Applicants that the decision to enter the four individuals' names in the Valuation Roll is irrational and no reasonable authority, possessed of the judgments of this court and the ELC affirming the Applicants' title and aware of the pending criminal charges against the four individuals for forgery, would have entered the four individuals' names as rateable owners. Yet, despite the subsequent court verdicts in favour of the Applicants, the Respondent proceeded to enter the four individuals' names in the Valuation Roll which is a clear case of inconsistency and irrationality. There is no evidence that the Applicants were notified or given an opportunity to be heard before the four individuals' names were entered in the Valuation Roll. The hasty approval of change of user and subdivision on 14th August 2019, despite the pending court case and the objection raised by the Applicants, the publication of the notice in the Star Newspaper of 12th April 2019, which the Applicants only discovered through their own means and the refusal by the Respondent’s Chief Officer to divulge the identities of the applicants for change of user, despite the Applicants' advocates' letter dated 1st May 2019, imputes improper motives on the part of the Respondent.

19. It is also this court’s finding that the Respondent's decision to enter the four individuals' names in the Valuation Roll, despite court judgments affirming the Applicants' title, violates the principles of good governance, integrity, transparency, and accountability as set out under Article 10 of the Constitution.The decision violates the principles of public finance under Article 201 of the Constitution including openness, accountability, and public participation as the Applicants were never consulted or heard before the decision was made. It is also not lost to me that the power to impose land rates is subject to constitutional principles and the Respondent cannot impose rates on persons who are not the lawful owners, nor can it recognize alleged forged title holders as rateable owners. Further, I find that the decision violates the Applicants' right to property under Article 40 of the Constitution by recognizing third parties as owners of their land.

20. Having found that the Respondent's decision was illegal, irrational and procedurally improper and that it violated the Applicants' constitutional rights, the Court finds that the Applicants are entitled to the orders sought. As submitted by the Applicants, Certiorari is available to quash a decision that is ultra vires, irrational, or procedurally improper. The decision of the Respondent to enter the four individuals' names in the Valuation Roll meets these thresholds. Mandamus lies to compel the performance of a public duty. The Respondent has a duty under the National Rating Act, 2024 to maintain an accurate Valuation Roll but it has failed to perform this duty by recording the wrong persons as rateable owners. The Court now compels the Respondent to correct its records.

Conclusion and Disposition

21. For these reasons, I find merit in the Applicants’ application dated 28th July 2025 and proceed to issue the following dispositive orders:

1) An order of Certiorari is hereby issued to remove into this Court and quash the decision of the County Government of Machakos entering the names of Bernard Masingi Maluki, Alphonce Mbatha Kisyula, Joshua Muteti Kilonzo and David Osano Ragira in the Valuation Roll as the rateable owners of the parcel of land known as LR No. 29666 (Original No. LR No. 13208/2) measuring approximately 357.70–370.9 Hectares, situated in Mavoko Sub-County of Machakos County.

2)  An order of Mandamus is hereby issued directing the County Government of Machakos to alter and correct its records in the Valuation Roll by deleting the names of Bernard Masingi Maluki, Alphonce Mbatha Kisyula, Joshua Muteti Kilonzo and David Osano Ragira as rateable owners of the parcel of land known as LR No. 29666 (Original No. LR No. 13208/2) measuring approximately 357.70–370.9 Hectares, situated in Mavoko Sub-County of Machakos County, and recording in the Valuation Roll the names of John Kioko Mutua and Sarah Nzembi Mutua as the rateable owners of the said parcel of land.

3) There are no orders as to costs

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED virtually this 26th DAY OF OCTOBER

2026.

............................................................................

J W W MONGARE

JUDGE

In the presence of;

1. Ms. Muthoki holding brief for Mr. Mutinda for the Appellant

2. N/A for the Respondent

3. Abdisalan- Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder