Land law

Kung’u & 2 others v Kung’u & 2 others [2026] KEELC 6620 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Land Case E433 of 2025
Judgment date
15 October 2026
Judge(s)
CG Mbogo

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The court allowed the 2nd defendant/applicant’s notice of motion, struck out the plaint dated 28 August 2025, and awarded costs to the 2nd defendant/applicant. It found that the plaintiffs lacked standing to sue for the estate and that the suit was res judicata.

Supporting judgment passages

29. The upshot of the above is that I find merit in the notice of motion dated 10th December, 2025. The plaint dated 28th August, 2025 is hereby struck out with costs to the 2nd defendant/applicant.

Paragraph 29 →
Issue 1Whether the plaintiffs/respondents had the requisite locus standi to institute proceedings on behalf of the deceased’s estate.

Held. No. The plaintiffs sought to enforce rights belonging to their late father’s estate and did not plead individual proprietary claims. The 1st defendant, their mother, was the sole executrix of the estate. Being beneficiaries under the will did not make the plaintiffs personal representatives, so they lacked locus standi to bring the suit for the estate.

Ratio. Property of a deceased person vests in the personal representative, who has power to enforce causes of action surviving the deceased. Beneficiary status alone does not confer the powers of an executor or administrator.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

12. On the first issue, Section 82(a) of the Law of Succession Act provides:-

Paragraph 12 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

16. In the present case, the plaintiffs/respondents have not pleaded that they are suing in their individual proprietary capacities. On the contrary, and in view of Section 82(a) of the Law of Succession Act, paragraph 4 of the plaint makes it clear that the 1st defendant who is their mother is the sole executrix of the estate of their father. This means that it is only the 1st defendant who has the capacity to bring forth this suit. The fact that the plaintiffs/respondents are beneficiaries under the will does not, confer upon them the powers of personal representatives. A beneficiary does not become an executor or administrator merely by reason of being named as a beneficiary in a will. I find that the plaintiffs/respondents lack the requisite locus standi to institute the present proceedings on behalf of the estate.

Paragraph 16 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

15. Section 79 of the Law of Succession Act provides that the property of a deceased person vests in his personal representatives, while Section 82(a) supra provides that personal representatives, subject to the limitations imposed by their grant, have power to enforce by suit or otherwise causes of action which survive the deceased.

Paragraph 15 →
Issue 2Whether the present suit was barred by res judicata.

Held. Yes. The validity of the 26 May 2011 sale agreement had been determined in ELC Case No. 1577 of 2014 and affirmed on appeal. The present suit sought to invalidate that same agreement, including by raising the 1st defendant’s alleged ill health, and was therefore res judicata despite the plaintiffs not having been parties to the earlier proceedings.

Ratio. A fresh suit cannot be used as a collateral means to undo a decree of a competent court or as a substitute for an appeal. The introduction of different parties or a new dimension to challenge the same transaction does not avoid res judicata where the prior proceedings conclusively determined the agreement’s validity.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

17. On the second issue, the test for determining the application of the doctrine of res-judicata in any given case is spelt out under Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act, which provides that:

Paragraph 17 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

28. From the above, the defects in this suit are overwhelming both to the extent that the plaintiffs/respondents lack the locus standi to institute these proceedings, and secondly, the validity of the sale agreement between the 1st and 2nd defendants has already been determined both by this court and the appellate court. Thus, this present suit is res judicata.

Paragraph 28 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

25. Further, the subject matter in both suits is the same, which is the validity of the sale agreement dated 26th May, 2011 culminating to the sale of the suit property herein. As I perceive it, the plaintiffs/respondents are now trying to invalidate the sale agreement by introducing a new dimension citing ill health of the 1st defendant. Ideally, what is sought in the present suit is to undo the execution of a decree issued in the former suit which this court cannot allow. A fresh suit, albeit instituted by different parties as it is in this case, cannot properly be used as a substitute for an appeal or as a collateral means of setting aside a decree already issued by a competent court.

Paragraph 25 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this court is the notice of motion dated 10th December, 2025 filed by the 2nd defendant/applicant and it is expressed to be brought under Order 2 rule 15(a), (b) and (d) of the Civil Procedure Rules seeking the following orders:-

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

In the present case, the plaintiffs/respondents have not pleaded that they are suing in their individual proprietary capacities. On the contrary, and in view of Section 82(a) of the Law of Succession Act, paragraph 4 of the plaint makes it clear that the 1st defendant who is their mother is the sole executrix of the estate of their father. This means that it is only the 1st defendant who has the capacity to bring forth this suit. The…

Paragraph 16 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the plaintiffs, as beneficiaries of their late father’s estate, had locus standi to sue to protect estate property; whether the suit challenging the 26 May 2011 sale agreement for LR No. 7741/422 was barred by res judicata; and what orders should…

Material facts

The plaintiffs asserted that LR No. 7741/422, carved from LR No. 7741/163, formed part of their late father’s estate. They challenged a 26 May 2011 sale agreement between the 1st defendant, their mother and sole executrix, and the 2nd defendant, alleging that…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELCLC NO. E433 OF 2025

DAVID NJOROGE KUNG’U.......................1ST PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT

WENDY WAMUCII……………….........………2ND PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT

WINNIFRED NYAMBURA…………........….3RD PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT

VERSUS

DOROTHY MARGARET WANJIKU KUNG’U………….......1ST DEFENDANT

AKASH HIMATLAL DODHIA....................2ND DEFENDANT/APPLICANT

CHIEF LAND REGISTRAR………………...........……………..3RD DEFENDANT

RULING

1. Before this court is the notice of motion dated 10th December, 2025 filed by the 2nd defendant/applicant and it is expressed to be brought under Order 2 rule 15(a), (b) and (d) of the Civil Procedure Rules seeking the following orders:-

a. The plaint be struck out.

b. The costs of this application and of the suit be borne by the plaintiffs.

2. The application is premised on the grounds on its face. It is further supported by the affidavit of the 2nd defendant/applicant sworn on even date. He deposed that the issues raised in this suit ought to have been raised in ELC case no. 1577 of 2014 and ELC no 590 of 2013 for the court to determine them once and for all. In a judgment delivered on 12th October 2017 in ELC case no. 1577 of 2014, the court determined that there existed a valid and enforceable agreement between himself and the 1st defendant and dismissed the claims on capacity and mistake of the 1st defendant to enter into an agreement. Further, that the court of appeal upheld these findings.

3. The 2nd defendant/applicant deposed that this suit constitutes a collateral attack of the judgment and decree of the court made in ELC case no. 1577 of 2014, and it is intended to re-open issues that were fully heard and determined both during trial and on appeal. Further, that the same is frivolous pursuant to Section 82 (a) of the Law of Succession Act which vests power on personal representatives of the estate of the deceased as opposed to beneficiaries, hence the plaintiffs/applicants lack locus standi to institute these proceedings.

4. In response to the application, the 1st plaintiff/respondent filed his replying affidavit sworn on 16th March, 2026. He deposed that together with the 2nd and 3rd plaintiffs/respondents, they were not parties to the sale agreement and hence their cause of action against the defendants cannot be said to have arisen on 26th May, 2011. Secondly, that discovery of misrepresentation and fraud is not barred by statutory limitations as they were kept in the dark concerning the transaction despite being the beneficiaries of the estate. Further, that they are praying for other reliefs that do not have anything to do with the transaction between the 1st and 2nd defendants.

5. The 1st plaintiff/respondent deposed that the 2nd defendant/applicant failed to prove the elements of res judicata and the instant suit cannot be extinguished merely because these issues ought to have been raised in the former suits. He deposed that together with the 2nd and 3rd plaintiffs/respondents, they were not aware of the cases mentioned and only knew of their existence when the 1st defendant was served with court orders while she was too sick to receive the same. The 1st plaintiff/applicant deposed that they are entitled to pursue a claim in court however implausible, hence the instant application lacks merit.

6. On locus standi, the 1st plaintiff/respondent deposed that beneficiaries of an estate may gain standing not to pursue personal claims or interests but to protect the estate. He reiterated that they have filed the instant proceedings solely to protect the estate of their late father against the impugned sale of LR no. 7741/422.

7. In further response, the 2nd defendant/applicant filed a further affidavit sworn on 27th April, 2026. He deposed that Brian Kung’u testified on 2nd May, 2017 and stated that the 1st defendant was the executrix of his father’s will which she produced and listed the plaintiffs/respondents as beneficiaries under the will.

11. The application was canvassed through written submissions. The 2nd defendant/applicant filed written submissions dated 27th April, 2026. The plaintiffs/respondents filed their written submissions dated 12th May, 2026. I have considered the application, the replies thereof and the written submissions filed. In my view, the following issues arise for determination:-

a. Whether the plaintiffs/respondents have the requisite locus standi to institute this suit on behalf of the estate of the deceased.

b. Whether the present suit is barred by the doctrine of res judicata.

c. What orders should issue.

8. The 2nd defendant’s/applicant’s case, in summary, is that the issues raised in the present suit ought to have been raised in ELC case no. 1577 of 2014 and ELC case no. 590 of 2013. He contended that in the judgment delivered on 12th October, 2017 in ELC case no. 1577 of 2014, the court determined that there existed a valid and enforceable agreement between him and the 1st defendant and dismissed the claims founded on the alleged incapacity and mistake of the 1st defendant. The court’s decision was subsequently upheld on appeal.

9. The 2nd defendant/applicant therefore contends that the present suit constitutes a collateral attack upon the judgment and decree in ELC case no. 1577 of 2014 and seeks to reopen matters which have already been conclusively determined. The 2nd defendant/applicant further challenges the locus standi of the plaintiffs/respondents. He argued that, by virtue of Section 82(a) of the Law of Succession Act, the power to enforce causes of action which survive a deceased person vests in the personal representatives of the estate and not in beneficiaries.

10. In opposition, the plaintiffs/respondents maintained that they were not parties to the sale agreement, and that their cause of action against the defendants could not be said to have arisen against them on the date of the agreement. The plaintiffs/respondents further contend that they only discovered the alleged misrepresentation and fraud later and that they are entitled to pursue the present claim because they are beneficiaries of the estate. They stated that some of the reliefs sought do not arise from the transaction between the 1st and 2nd defendants.

11. On locus standi, the plaintiffs’/respondents’ position is that beneficiaries of an estate may institute proceedings for the purpose of protecting the estate, and that the present proceedings have been instituted for the sole purpose of protecting the estate of their late father from the impugned sale of LR No. 7741/422.

12. On the first issue, Section 82(a) of the Law of Succession Act provides:-

“Personal representatives shall, subject only to any limitation imposed by their grant, have the following powers-To enforce, by suit or otherwise, all causes of action which, by virtue of any law, survive the deceased or arising out of his death for his personal representative.”

13. In Trouistik Union International & another v Jane Mbeyu & another [1993] eKLR, the court of appeal rendered itself thus:-

“To determine who may agitate by suit any cause of action vested in him at the time of his death, one must turn to section 82 (a) of the Law of Succession Act. That section confers that power on personal representatives and on them alone. As to who are personal representatives within the contemplation of the Act, section 3, the interpretative section, provides an all- inclusive answer. It says “personal representative means executor or administrator of a deceased person”.” 

14. The plaintiffs/respondents’ suit is substantially founded upon their contention that LR no. 7741/422, which was curved out of LR no. 7741/163, formed part of the estate of their late father and that the transaction entered into between the 1st and 2nd defendants on 26th May, 2011 was invalid. They seek, among other orders, declarations invalidating the sale agreement, cancellation of the transfer of the suit property, cancellation of the title issued to the 2nd defendant/applicant, refund of the purchase deposit and a permanent injunction restraining any dealings with the property. It is apparent from the plaint whose prayers are reproduced in the paragraphs below that the rights which the plaintiffs/respondents seek to enforce are rights which they assert belong to the estate of the deceased. Their own case is that they have approached the court to protect the estate against the impugned transaction.

15. Section 79 of the Law of Succession Act provides that the property of a deceased person vests in his personal representatives, while Section 82(a) supra provides that personal representatives, subject to the limitations imposed by their grant, have power to enforce by suit or otherwise causes of action which survive the deceased.

16. In the present case, the plaintiffs/respondents have not pleaded that they are suing in their individual proprietary capacities. On the contrary, and in view of Section 82(a) of the Law of Succession Act, paragraph 4 of the plaint makes it clear that the 1st defendant who is their mother is the sole executrix of the estate of their father. This means that it is only the 1st defendant who has the capacity to bring forth this suit. The fact that the plaintiffs/respondents are beneficiaries under the will does not, confer upon them the powers of personal representatives. A beneficiary does not become an executor or administrator merely by reason of being named as a beneficiary in a will. I find that the plaintiffs/respondents lack the requisite locus standi to institute the present proceedings on behalf of the estate.

17. On the second issue, the test for determining the application of the doctrine of res-judicata in any given case is spelt out under Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act, which provides that:

“No court shall try any suit or issue in which the matter directly and substantially in issue has been directly and substantially in issue in a former suit between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title, in a court competent to try such subsequent suit or the suit in which such issue has been subsequently raised, and has been heard and finally decided by such court.”

18. The Civil Procedure Act also provides explanations with respect to the application of the res judicata rule. Explanation 1 to 6 are in the following terms:-

“Explanation (1) — The expression “former suit” means a suit which has been decided before the suit in question whether or not it was instituted before it.

Explanation (2) — For the purposes of this section, the competence of a court shall be determined irrespective of any provision as to right of appeal from the decision of that court.

Explanation (3) — The matter above referred to must in the former suit have been alleged by one party and either denied or admitted, expressly or impliedly, by the other.

Explanation (4) — Any matter which might and ought to have been made ground of defence or attack in such former suit shall be deemed to have been a matter directly and substantially in issue in such suit.

Explanation (5) — Any relief claimed in a suit, which is not expressly granted by the decree shall, for the purposes of this section, be deemed to have been refused.

Explanation (6) — Where persons litigate bona fide in respect of a public right or of a private right claimed in common for themselves and others, all persons interested in such right shall, for the purposes of this section, be deemed to claim under the persons so litigating.”

19. In Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission vs Maina Kiai & 5 Others [2017] eKLR, the supreme court while considering the said provision held that all the elements outlined thereunder must be satisfied conjunctively for the doctrine to be invoked. That is:-

“(a)  The suit or issue was directly and substantially in issue in the former suit.

(b) That former suit was between the same parties or parties under whom they or any of them claim.

(c) Those parties were litigating under the same title.

(d) The issue was heard and finally determined in the former suit.

(e) The court that formerly heard and determined the issue was competent to try the subsequent suit or the suit in which the issue is raised.”

20. The 2nd defendant/applicant contended that the present suit is res judicata and constitutes a collateral attack upon the judgment and decree in ELC case no. 1577 of 2014. To establish whether this suit is res judicata, there is need to look at the plaint against the decisions of the court in ELC case no. 1577 of 2014 and the court of appeal in civil appeal no. 67 of 2018.

21. The plaintiffs/respondents filed the plaint dated 28th August, 2025 seeking the following prayers:-

a. A declaration that the transaction between the 1st and 2nd defendants herein by way of the sale agreement dated 26th May, 2011 for the sale and purchase of land parcel known as LR no. 7741/422 is invalid, null and void ab initio.

b. A declaration that the sale agreement dated 26th May, 2011 between the defendants herein for the sale and purchase of LR no. 7741/422 is a nullity and hence unenforceable.

c. An order that the transfer of the suit property, being LR no. 7741/422, by the deputy registrar of this honourable court on 23rd October, 2024 pursuant to the decree ssued on 14th February, 2018 be and is hereby cancelled, withdrawn, and/or vacated.

d. An order that the certificate of title number IR. 277689 issued to the 2nd defendant herein by the registrar of titles on 22nd January, 2025 be and is hereby cancelled and/or vacated.

e. An order directing the 1st defendant herein to forthwith refund the 2nd defendant the Kshs. 2,000,000/- paid as deposit under the sale agreement dated 26th May, 2011 with no accrued interest thereon.

f. An order directing and compelling the 2nd and 3rd defendants herein to remove the caveat placed and/or registered on 17th August 2011 against land parcel LR no. 7741/163.

g. An order of permanent injunction restraining the 2nd defendant herein either by himself, servants, or agents from selling, transferring, alienating, developing or whatsoever dealing with the suit property being LR no. 7741/422.

h. Costs of the suit.

i. Interest on (h) above.

j. Any other relief which this honourable court deems fi and just to grant in the circumstances.

22. In summary, the plaintiffs/respondents pleaded that LR no. 7741/422 curved out of LR no. 7741/163 measuring approximately 2.05 hectares formed part of the estate of Ndung’u. They challenge the sale agreement entered into between the 1st and 2nd defendants dated 26th May, 2011 on grounds that at the time of execution of the sale agreement, the 1st defendant was suffering from Alzheimer’s disorder which she was diagnosed with way before the said parties entered into the sale.

23. From the judgment delivered by the court in ELC case no. 1577 of 2014, the same was instituted by the 2nd defendant/applicant against the 1st defendant and the chief land registrar. In that suit, the 2nd defendant/applicant was seeking a declaratory order as to the validity of the sale agreement dated 26th May 2011, and a permanent injunction restraining any dealings on LR no. 7741/422 being a subdivision of LR no. 7741/163. In paragraph 40 of the judgment, the court found the agreement between the 1st and 2nd defendants valid. The findings of this court were subsequently upheld by the court of appeal in a judgment delivered on 29th January, 2020 as clearly elaborated in paragraphs 15 to 20 therein.

24. In both suits and the appeal, it is clear that the plaintiffs/respondents were not parties to the former suit. However, and with all due respect, the 1st plaintiff/respondent is attempting to hood wink this court by claiming that they were not aware of the existence of the former suit. From the record, and in the former suit, his brother testified on behalf of their mother. Secondly, while the plaintiffs/respondents argue that the 1st defendant/applicant suffers from Alzheimer’s disease which she was diagnosed with prior to the sale agreement, it is my view that if at all this claim was genuine, the same would have been raised during trial in 1577 of 2014.

25. Further, the subject matter in both suits is the same, which is the validity of the sale agreement dated 26th May, 2011 culminating to the sale of the suit property herein. As I perceive it, the plaintiffs/respondents are now trying to invalidate the sale agreement by introducing a new dimension citing ill health of the 1st defendant. Ideally, what is sought in the present suit is to undo the execution of a decree issued in the former suit which this court cannot allow. A fresh suit, albeit instituted by different parties as it is in this case, cannot properly be used as a substitute for an appeal or as a collateral means of setting aside a decree already issued by a competent court.

26. In Gladys Nduku Nthuki v Letshego Kenya Limited; Mueni Charles Maingi (Intended Plaintiff) [2022] eKLR, Odunga, J. (as he then was) held that:-

“42. However, it is trite that the mere addition of parties in a subsequent suit does not necessarily render the doctrine of res judicata inapplicable since a party cannot escape the said doctrine by simply undertaking a cosmetic surgery to his pleadings. If the added parties peg their claim under the same title as the parties in the earlier suit, the doctrine will still be invoked since the addition of the party would in that case be for the sole purpose of decoration and dressing and nothing else…45.It is therefore clear that parties are not to evade the application of res judicata by simply conjuring up parties or issues with a view to giving the case a different complexion from the one that was given to the former suit.”

27. Similarly, in Bank of Africa Kenya Limited & another v TSS Investment Limited & 2 others [2024] KECA 410 (KLR), the court of appeal stated:-

“To our mind, it matters not that the 1st and 2nd respondents were not party to the suits aforesaid. The fact that those suits and motions raised issues similar to those in contention between the appellants and the respondents herein, and over the same subject matter, and on the same cause of action, rendered them res judicata.”

28. From the above, the defects in this suit are overwhelming both to the extent that the plaintiffs/respondents lack the locus standi to institute these proceedings, and secondly, the validity of the sale agreement between the 1st and 2nd defendants has already been determined both by this court and the appellate court. Thus, this present suit is res judicata.

29. The upshot of the above is that I find merit in the notice of motion dated 10th December, 2025. The plaint dated 28th August, 2025 is hereby struck out with costs to the 2nd defendant/applicant.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED VIRTUALLY

THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

HON. MBOGO C.G.

JUDGE

15/10/2026.

In the presence of:

Mr. Benson Agunga - Court assistant

Mr. Oginga for the Plaintiffs

Mr. Ochieng together with Mr. Amwayi for the 2nd Defendant

Mr. Wabwire for the 3rd Defendant

Mr. Kabebe for the 1st Defendant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder