Background
The 5th respondent filed the notice of preliminary objection dated 24th March, 2026 challenging the jurisdiction of this court to hear and determine the petition on the following grounds:-
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
The court dismissed the 5th respondent’s notice of preliminary objection dated 24 March 2026 for lack of merit because it did not raise pure points of law capable of disposing of the petition. Costs were ordered to be in the cause.
11. From the above, I find the preliminary objection poorly thought out as it does not raise pure points of law that is capable of disposing the petition. The notice of preliminary objection dated 24th March, 2026 lacks merit and it is hereby dismissed. Costs in the cause.
Paragraph 11 →
Held. No. The grounds concerning res judicata, the petitioners’ alleged need to seek joinder in appellate proceedings, their proprietary interest, and the validity or nullity of the title required factual and documentary investigation. They therefore could not be resolved through a preliminary objection. The court also held that the petitioners, as officials and representatives of the association, had locus to prosecute the petition.
Ratio. A preliminary objection must be founded on an undisputed pure point of law arising from the pleadings and capable of disposing of the matter without trial. In particular, the court cannot summarily declare a registered title a nullity merely on an assertion in a preliminary objection where doing so requires examination of the evidence concerning its issuance and legal consequences.
Issue
6. From the above cited authorities, it is clear that for a preliminary objection to succeed, the same must consist of a pure point of law, with the facts not disputed by the opposing party. Also, a preliminary objection should possess the ability to dispose off the issue that is before court without going to trial and lastly, the same ought to stem from and not outside of pleadings. Having carefully evaluated the grounds of the preliminary objection, I am not satisfied that the grounds in the preliminary objection raise pure points of law for the reasons discussed below.
Paragraph 6 →
Held
7. To begin with, a preliminary objection is not the most appropriate tool to determine whether this petition is barred by the doctrine of res judicata. For the court to establish that indeed this matter is res judicata owing to ELC no. 939 of 2014 and court of appeal no. COACA/E034/2025, there is need to comb through evidence to ascertain the same as this does not form part of the instant pleadings. This ground therefore fails. The 5th respondent further contends that the petitioners ought to have applied to be joined in the pending court of appeal proceedings. The question whether a person ought to be joined in existing proceedings ordinarily depends on the person's interest in the subject matter, the nature of the relief sought and the circumstances of the particular proceedings. It is not, by itself, a jurisdictional bar to an independently instituted constitutional petition. More importantly, the failure to seek joinder in another proceeding does not automatically establish res judicata.
Passage 36 →
10. On whether the petitioners’ title is a nullity is a issue that cannot be resolved summarily as it will require the court to test the evidence on record. This ground suffers the same rejection as grounds 1, 2 and 4. The court cannot, merely on the assertion contained in a preliminary objection, pronounce a registered title a nullity without interrogating the evidence upon which the title was issued and the legal consequences flowing from that evidence. The body of the petition is clear that the petitioners are suing as officials and representatives of Servivors Jua Kali Association Group of Nairobi. The petitioners have the requisite locus to prosecute this petition. I will say no more.
Paragraph 10 →
Ratio
9. The 5th respondent’s argument that the petitioners’ title is invalid because it was acquired in 1995 before registration cannot properly be determined in a preliminary objection unless they are matters admitted or indisputable from the record. The validity or otherwise of a registered interest in land ordinarily requires consideration of the documentary evidence on record.
Paragraph 9 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The 5th respondent filed the notice of preliminary objection dated 24th March, 2026 challenging the jurisdiction of this court to hear and determine the petition on the following grounds:-
Paragraph 1 →The preliminary objection was canvassed through written submissions. The 5th respondent filed written submissions dated 31st July, 2026 and 10th September 2026, while the 6th respondents filed written submissions dated 7th September, 2026. I have considered the notice of preliminary objection, and the written submissions filed. The issue for determination is whether it raises pure points of law.
Paragraph 2 →From the above, I find the preliminary objection poorly thought out as it does not raise pure points of law that is capable of disposing the petition. The notice of preliminary objection dated 24th March, 2026 lacks merit and it is hereby dismissed. Costs in the cause.
Paragraph 11 →Whether the 5th respondent’s notice of preliminary objection dated 24 March 2026 raised pure points of law capable of disposing of the petition, including objections founded on res judicata, alleged lack of Article 40 property rights, the petitioners’…
The four petitioners sued as officials and representatives of Servivors Jua Kali Association Group of Nairobi. The 5th respondent, Regnol Oil (K) Limited, objected that the petition was res judicata because of ELC No. 939 of 2014 and Court of Appeal No.…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELCLPET NO. E049 OF 2025
JOHN KIMUNYI KARIUKI,
AUGOSTIBNO MACHAKI NJERU,
JENNIFER MUTHONI MURIGI,
JOHN THUMBI NDUMIA (suing as the
officials and representatives of
SERVIVORS JUA KALI ASSOCIATION GROUP OF NAIROBI)......PETITIONERS
VERSUS
THE CHIEF LAND REGISTRAR……….……......................…….…1ST RESPONDENT
THE COUNTY LAND REGISTRAR,
NAIROBI COUNTY………………………......................……………...2ND RESPONDENT
DIRECTOR OF CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS….....................3RD RESPONDENT
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL………………………......................….4TH RESPONDENT
THE NATIONAL LAND COMMISSION………...................……..5TH RESPONDENT
REGNOL OIL (K) LIMITED ……………............……………………..6TH RESPONDENT
DIAMOND HASHAM LALJI………………….....................………..7TH RESPONDENT
RULING
1. The 5th respondent filed the notice of preliminary objection dated 24th March, 2026 challenging the jurisdiction of this court to hear and determine the petition on the following grounds:-
1. The petition is barred by the doctrine of res judicata under Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act, as the issues raised in the petition were directly and substantially in issue in ELC no. 939 of 2014 and court of appeal no. COACA/E034/2025.
2. The petitioners ought to have applied to be enjoined as a party in the pending matter before the court of appeal.
3. The petitioners have no right to property recognized under Article 40 of the Constitution and without it the petition is an abuse of the court process.
4. The petition does not disclose a constitutional right capable of being protected by this honourable court since an unincorporated body lacks juristic personality and cannot in its name acquire, own or transfer immovable property.
5. The petitioners’ purported title is legally a nullity having been obtained in 1995 long before Servivors Jua Kali Association Group of Nairobi was registered as an association which at any rate is not a juridical body that can own property.
6. The petition is a gross abuse of the court process for being an attempt to circumvent Section 7 of the Limitations of Actions Act which bars the institution of a suit for recovery of land after 20 years of the cause of action.
7. The Limitation of Actions Act is one of the Acts envisaged under Article 24 of the Constitution as limiting a right or fundamental freedom.
2. The preliminary objection was canvassed through written submissions. The 5th respondent filed written submissions dated 31st July, 2026 and 10th September 2026, while the 6th respondents filed written submissions dated 7th September, 2026. I have considered the notice of preliminary objection, and the written submissions filed. The issue for determination is whether it raises pure points of law.
3. Law, J.A. in Mukisa Biscuits Manufacturing Company Limited -vs- West End Distributors (1969) EA 696 stated as follows:-
“So far as I am aware, a preliminary objection consists of a point of law which has been pleaded or which arises by clear implication out of pleadings, and which if argued as a preliminary point, will dispose of the suit. Examples are an objection to jurisdiction of the court, a plea of limitation or a submission that the parties are bound by the contract giving rise to the suit to refer the matter to arbitration...”
4. Also, in the case of John Musakali vs. Speaker County of Bungoma & 4 others (2015) eKLR, it was held that:-
“The position in law is that a preliminary objection should arise from the pleadings and on the basis that facts are agreed by both sides. Once raised the preliminary objection should have the potential to disposing of the suit at that point without the need to go for trial. If, however, facts are disputed and remain to be ascertained, that would not be a suitable preliminary objection on a point of law.”
5. Further, Ojwang J (As he then was) in Oraro -vs- Mbaja (2005) KLR 141 where after quoting the statement of Law, JA. in the Mukisa Biscuits case (supra) went on to state that:-
“A 'preliminary objection' correctly understood is now well defined as and declared to be a point of law which must not be blurred by factual details liable to be contested and in any event, to be proved through the process of evidence. Any assertion which claims to be a preliminary objection, yet it bears factual aspects calling for proof, or seeks to adduce evidence for its authentication is not, as a matter of legal principle, a true preliminary objection which the court should allow to proceed. Where a court needs to investigate facts, a matter cannot be raised as a preliminary point....Anything that purports to be a preliminary objection must not deal with disputed facts, and it must not itself derive its foundation from factual information which stands to be tested by normal rules of evidence...”
6. From the above cited authorities, it is clear that for a preliminary objection to succeed, the same must consist of a pure point of law, with the facts not disputed by the opposing party. Also, a preliminary objection should possess the ability to dispose off the issue that is before court without going to trial and lastly, the same ought to stem from and not outside of pleadings. Having carefully evaluated the grounds of the preliminary objection, I am not satisfied that the grounds in the preliminary objection raise pure points of law for the reasons discussed below.
7. To begin with, a preliminary objection is not the most appropriate tool to determine whether this petition is barred by the doctrine of res judicata. For the court to establish that indeed this matter is res judicata owing to ELC no. 939 of 2014 and court of appeal no. COACA/E034/2025, there is need to comb through evidence to ascertain the same as this does not form part of the instant pleadings. This ground therefore fails. The 5th respondent further contends that the petitioners ought to have applied to be joined in the pending court of appeal proceedings. The question whether a person ought to be joined in existing proceedings ordinarily depends on the person's interest in the subject matter, the nature of the relief sought and the circumstances of the particular proceedings. It is not, by itself, a jurisdictional bar to an independently instituted constitutional petition. More importantly, the failure to seek joinder in another proceeding does not automatically establish res judicata.
8. The 5th respondent contends that the petitioners have no right to protect their property under Article 40 of the Constitution. Article 40(1) provides that every person has the right, either individually or in association with others, to acquire and own property of any description and in any part of Kenya. Constitutional protection of property is therefore available where the claimant establishes the requisite proprietary interest recognized by law. Whether the petitioners have a valid proprietary interest is, however, dependent on the facts and evidence concerning the acquisition, registration, nature and validity of the alleged title.
9. The 5th respondent’s argument that the petitioners’ title is invalid because it was acquired in 1995 before registration cannot properly be determined in a preliminary objection unless they are matters admitted or indisputable from the record. The validity or otherwise of a registered interest in land ordinarily requires consideration of the documentary evidence on record.
10. On whether the petitioners’ title is a nullity is a issue that cannot be resolved summarily as it will require the court to test the evidence on record. This ground suffers the same rejection as grounds 1, 2 and 4. The court cannot, merely on the assertion contained in a preliminary objection, pronounce a registered title a nullity without interrogating the evidence upon which the title was issued and the legal consequences flowing from that evidence. The body of the petition is clear that the petitioners are suing as officials and representatives of Servivors Jua Kali Association Group of Nairobi. The petitioners have the requisite locus to prosecute this petition. I will say no more.
11. From the above, I find the preliminary objection poorly thought out as it does not raise pure points of law that is capable of disposing the petition. The notice of preliminary objection dated 24th March, 2026 lacks merit and it is hereby dismissed. Costs in the cause.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED VIRTUALLY
THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
HON. MBOGO C.G.
JUDGE
15/10/2026.
In the presence of:
Mr. Benson Agunga - Court assistant
Mr. Adalo for the 5th Respondent
Mr. Ogada for the Petitioners