Land law

Malombo t/a OM Robinson & Company Advocates v Al-Haieee Investments Limited [2026] KEELC 7199 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
27 October 2026
Judge(s)
J G Kemei

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The Applicant filed a Notice of Motion application dated 5/6/2025 pursuant to the provisions of Sections 1A, 3A & 9 of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 51 Rule 1 and Order 22 Rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. The Applicant prays for orders that;

Paragraph 1 →

Decision / orders

In the end, this Court finds that the instant application is merited. It is allowed in the following terms: -

Paragraph 32 →

Reasoning passage

The Court finds that the evidentiary threshold for piercing the corporate veil has not yet been met. Granting this remedy would be premature, as it may be available only if the Directors fail to comply with examination or disclosure orders, or if fraud is subsequently established. In these circumstances, I conclude that this issue should be addressed after the cross-examination of the Respondent Company’s Directors.

Paragraph 31 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the applicant satisfied Order 22 rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules for summons, oral examination of the respondent’s directors, and production of financial documents to aid execution of the decree of 4 April 2025; and whether the respondent’s…

Material facts

A decree arising from a taxed Advocate–Client Bill of Costs awarded the applicant Kshs. 3,063,525, plus costs and interest from 11 March 2024. The applicant stated that it remained unpaid, was neither stayed nor set aside, and that the respondent had no known…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC MISC APPL. NO. E012 OF 2024

__________________________________________________________________

ROBINSON ONYANGO MALOMBO

T/A O.M. ROBINSON & CO. ADVOCATES -ADVOCATE/APPLICANT

VS

AL-HAIEE INVESTMENTS LIMITED -CLIENT/RESPONDENT

RULING

((In respect of the Advocate’s application dated 5/6/2026)

1. The Applicant filed a Notice of Motion application dated 5/6/2025 pursuant to the provisions of Sections 1A, 3A & 9 of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 51 Rule 1 and Order 22 Rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010. The Applicant prays for orders that;

a) Summons be issued by this Honourable Court to the Directors of the Defendant/Judgment- Debtor:

i. Diamond Ali Hasham Lalji Nurani, Director,

Al-Haiee Investments Limited

P.O. Box 59307- City Square

Nairobi

ii. Shahid Diamond Lalji Nurani, Director

Al-Haiee Investments Limited

P.O. Box 59307- City Square

Nairobi

b) To be orally examined as to whether any or what debts are owing to the judgment-debtor and whether the judgment-debtor has any and what property or of satisfying the decree dated 4/4/2025.

c) To attend Court and be examined for the production of the books of audited accounts, statements of accounts, Cheque books and all other documents relating to the financial affairs of the judgment-debtor for the period between January 2022 to date.

2. In default of prayer (1) above this Honourable Court be pleased to lift the corporate veil of the Respondent and the above named Judgment-Debtor’s directors, Diamond Ali Hasham Lalji Nurani and Shahid Diamond Lalji Nurani be held jointly and severally liable to satisfy the decree dated 4/4/2025.

Costs of this application be provided for.

3. The application is premised on the fact that the decree dated 4/4/2025 remains unsatisfied, that no indication has been given of any commitment by the judgment-debtor to pay the decretal sum, and that the decree has neither been set aside nor stayed. It is further premised on the absence of any known attachable assets belonging to the judgment-debtor.

4. The application is supported by an affidavit sworn on the same day by Mr. Robinson Onyango Malombo, an Advocate of the High Court of Kenya and the Managing Partner of the Applicant law firm. Mr. Malombo averred that a decree dated 4/4/2025 was issued in favour of the Applicant against the Respondent for Kshs. 3,063,525/=, together with costs and interest accruing from 11/3/2024 until payment in full. The deponent states that the judgment debtor has failed to satisfy the decretal sum and has no known attachable assets.

5. The application seeks to summon the known directors, Diamond Ali Hasham Lalji Nurani and Shahid Diamond Lalji Nurani, for oral examination concerning their assets and financial means. The deponent respectfully requests that the Court pierce the corporate veil and hold the directors personally liable if they fail to provide a satisfactory account, thereby enabling the deponent to realise the fruits of the judgment.

6. I note that despite service of the application and leave being granted to the Client/Respondent to file a Replying Affidavit on 13/7/2026, within 14 days, the Respondent filed its Replying Affidavit on 23/10/2026 without leave of Court.

Respondent’s Replying Affidavit

7. The Respondent opposes the application by reference to the affidavit of Diamond Hasham Lalji, its Director, sworn on 6/10/2026. The deponent states that the corporate entity was incorporated solely to hold property and assets, and that no financial records exist to indicate otherwise. The Respondent further states that its primary asset (L.R. 209/12071/1) was legally charged to financial institutions and subsequently sold, with the proceeds applied to a secured creditor. Accordingly, the Respondent contends that the Applicant’s claim of "no known attachable assets" is inaccurate and results from a failure to conduct proper inquiries, rather than constituting evidence of fraud, impropriety, or a sham intended to defeat the decree. The Respondent maintains that the mere inability to satisfy a debt due to insolvency does not justify lifting the corporate veil.

8. The deponent asserts that the application to examine the directors is legally untenable because it fails to meet the threshold under Order 22 Rule 35 for establishing "cause to believe" that the directors possess knowledge of hidden assets. The Respondent deposes that there is no allegation or evidence of fraud or improper conduct, and that the directors did not act as "mere puppets" or a "device" to evade obligations. Based on the sworn explanation of the company's affairs and financial circumstances, the Respondent asserts that the application is misconceived and constitutes an abuse of the Court process, and should therefore be dismissed with costs.

Analysis and Determination

9. Having considered the Petition, the Supporting Affidavit thereto, the Replying Affidavit in opposition to the Petition, as well as the rival submissions by the parties, it is my considered view that the issues that arise for determination are as follows.

a. Whether the Applicant has met the conditions for oral examination of the Respondent’s Directors and production of documents under Order 22 Rule 35 Civil Procedure Rules to satisfy the decree issued on 4/4/2025.

b. Whether the Respondent’s corporate veil should be lifted and its Directors held personally liable for the Respondent company’s debt to the Applicant.

Whether the Applicant has met the conditions for oral examination of the Respondent’s Directors and production of documents under Order 22 Rule 35 Civil Procedure Rules to satisfy the decree issued on 4/4/2025

10. Before addressing the first issue, I will consider the Respondent’s Reply Affidavit, which was filed out of time and without leave of the Court. No explanation has been provided for the inordinate delay in filing the response. In principle, the affidavit may be liable to be struck out, as judicial timelines are not mere suggestions. The oxygen principle enshrined in sections 1A and 1B of the Civil Procedure Act is indeed a double-edged sword and cuts both ways. The Applicant did not seek to mitigate his position by tendering evidence when his Advocate apparently failed him.

11. Courts have rightly observed that the "Oxygen Principle" was intended to breathe life into civil cases so they are concluded expeditiously. Further, the substantive justice provided under Article 159 of the Constitution was not intended to amount to the wholesale abandonment of procedural order. As held by the Supreme Court in Raila Odinga & 5 Others v IEBC & 3 Others [2013] eKLR, procedural rules are the handmaidens of justice and must be respected to ensure the orderly administration of the law.

12. It is trite that striking out a pleading is a draconian exercise of discretion which out to be exercised sparingly. In the case of Nicholas Kiptoo Arap Salat v IEBC & 7 Others Civil Appeal No. 228 of 2013 Ouko JA (as he then was) observed:

“Deviations from and lapses in form and procedures which do not go to the jurisdiction of the Court, or to the root of the dispute or which do not at all occasion prejudice or miscarriage of justice to the opposite party ought not be elevated to the level of a criminal offence attracting such heavy punishment of the offending party, who may in many cases be innocent since the rules of procedure are complex and technical. Instead, in such instances the Court should rise to its highest calling to do justice by sparing the parties the draconian approach of striking out pleadings. It is globally established that where a procedural infraction causes no injustice by way of injurious prejudice to a person, such infraction should not have an invalidating effect. Justice must not be sacrificed on the altar of strict adherence to provisions of procedural law which at times create hardship and unfairness.”

13. In line with the principles set out above, this Court acknowledges that striking out pleadings is a drastic measure that should be exercised sparingly and only in exceptional cases. I therefore exercise my discretion and admit the Replying Affidavit in the interests of justice.

14. Turning to the first issue, it is not in dispute that a decree was issued by the Court on 4/4/2025 in favour of the Applicant against the Respondent for a sum of Kshs. 3, 063, 525/=, plus costs and interest, effective from 11/3/2024 until payment in full. The decree arose from a taxed Advocate-Client Bill of Costs. It is also not disputed that, to date, the Respondent has failed to satisfy the said decretal sum and has no known attachable assets.

15. Order 22 Rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, provides that: –

Where a decree is for the payment of money, the decree-holder may apply to the Court for an order that;

a. The judgment debtor;

b. In the case of a corporation, any officer thereof; or

c. Any other person, be orally examined as to whether any or what debts are owing to the judgment-debtor, and whether the judgment-debtor has any and what property or means of satisfying the decree, and the Court may make an order for the attendance and examination of such judgment-debtor or officer, or other person, and for the production of any books or documents.

16. The purpose of the aforesaid provisions is to assist a decree-holder in execution by facilitating the discovery of the judgment debtor’s assets and financial means. Their scope is not limited to circumstances in which property has already been identified; it also extends to inquiries necessary for the effective enforcement of a decree. These provisions were considered in Ultimate Laboratories v Tasha Bio service Limited, NBI HCCC No. 1287 of 2000 (unreported), as cited in Tropical Wood Limited v Samilisinternatinal Investments [2017] KEHC 579 (KLR), in which the Court observed that-

“Two things emerge from the above proposition. One, the power of the Court to summon a person to attend and be examined under Order 22 Rule 35 is circumscribed within the purpose set out in the Rule. That is;

…as to whether any or what debts are owing to the judgment debtor, and whether the judgment debtor has any and what property or means of satisfying the decree.

I therefore, take the view that, as long as the Applicant has shown that the Respondent is in a position to provide information in the nature of discovery… as to whether any or what debts are owing to the judgment debtor, and whether the judgment debtor has any and what property or means of satisfying the decree, the Court should summon the person to attend and be examined in relation to the purpose stated in the Rule.”

17. The underlying objective of a Summons issued under Order 22 Rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules is to assist the Court in ascertaining the actual financial position of a Company against which a decree has been issued. It is essentially an investigative tool designed to shed light on the Company’s means, assets, and liabilities so that the process of execution may be directed appropriately.

18. This is as espoused in the decision in Post Bank Credit Limited (In Liquidation) v Nyamangu Holdings Limited [2015] KEHC 5964 (KLR) where the Court rendered itself thus:

“…person to be summoned under Order 22 Rule 35 (c) of the Civil Procedure Rules, to provide information on the property of the Company…will also be required to produce any relevant documents or copies thereof on the assets of the Company or books of accounts including but not limited to the Judgment Debtor’s annual financial statement, documents of title property of the Company in his possession and which he may have obtained as a director and/or shareholder of the judgment-debtor.”

19. This Court has the power to summon any officer of a judgment-debtor company to be examined on oath regarding the debts owed by the company and to determine whether the company has property or means to satisfy a decree.

20. The purpose of Order 22 Rule 3 is not to intimidate or vex the directors or persons summoned. The objective of the provision is to facilitate a genuine and objective search for persons and places that are probably believed to have useful information which may assist the decree/holder in realising the fruits of his judgment.

21. In his Replying Affidavit, the Respondent’s director avers that the Respondent was incorporated solely to hold property and assets, and that no financial records exist to indicate otherwise. The Respondent avers that the only primary asset (L.R. 209/12071/1) was legally charged to financial institutions and subsequently sold, with the proceeds applied to a secured creditor. He deposes that there is no allegation or evidence of fraud or improper conduct on the part of the Directors.

22. It is evident that the Respondent has no attachable assets. This is confirmed by its Director in his Replying Affidavit. The Respondent has not disclosed when the primary asset was charged and sold to pay the creditor.

23. At this stage, this Court is not called upon to determine whether the alleged conduct amounts to fraud. The threshold under Order 22 Rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, is not proof of fraud or improper conduct, but whether the intended examinees are in a position to provide information relating to the judgment-debtor’s assets and means. Who can provide such information if not the Respondent’s Directors? I am therefore satisfied that the Respondent’s Directors, as the controlling minds of the Respondent company, are best placed to provide information regarding the company’s assets, financial dealings, and ability to satisfy the decree herein.

24. This Court therefore finds that the Applicant has demonstrated sufficient grounds to warrant the summoning of the Respondent’s Directors for examination on oath and the production of the company’s books of account and relevant documents concerning its assets and means.

Whether the Respondent’s corporate veil should be lifted and its Directors held personally liable for the Respondent company’s debt to the Applicant.

25. Moving on to the next issue, the doctrine of corporate personality was laid down in the case of Salomon Co. Ltd v Salomon [1897] AC 78, where the House of Lords held that a company is in law a separate person from its members. The Court of Appeal in Victor Mabachi & Another v Nurturn Bates Ltd. [2013] eKLR, supported this position and held that: -

“A company as a body corporate, is a persona jurisdica, with separate independent identity in law, distinct from its shareholders, directors and agents unless there are factors warranting a lifting of the veil.”

26. The Salomon case (supra) affirmed that a company is a separate legal entity from its shareholders and directors. However, to prevent misuse of this principle, the law has since evolved to permit the lifting or piercing of the corporate veil in appropriate circumstances.

27. Lifting the corporate veil allows Courts, in suitable cases, to hold those controlling a company personally liable for its debts. Where justified, a director may be ordered to satisfy the company’s obligations personally. In the case of Multichoice Kenya Ltd v Mainkam Ltd & Anor. [2013] eKLR, Mabeya J held as follows: -

“I agree that directors are generally not personally liable on contracts purporting to bind their company. If the directors have authority to make a contract, then only the company is liable on it. To my mind, there is no doubt that ever since famous case of Salomon v Salomon [1897] A.C. 22 Courts have applied the principle of corporate personality strictly. But exceptions to the principle have also been made where it is too flagrantly oppose to justice or convenience. Other instances include when a fraudulent and improper design by scheming directors or shareholders is imputed. In such exceptional cases, the law either goes behind the corporate personality to the individual members or regards the subsidiary and its holding company as one entity.”

28. Further in Kolaba Enterprise Ltd –vs- Shamsudin Hussein Varvani & Another [2014] eKLR Gikonyo J rendered himself thus: -

“…[the] separate legal personality of a company can never be departed from except in instances where the statute of the law provides for the lifting or piercing of the corporate veil, say when the directors or members of the company are using the company as a vehicle to commit fraud or other criminal activities.”

29. The Respondent alleges that the company’s failure to pay its debt does not warrant lifting the corporate veil. Lifting the corporate veil is an exceptional measure reserved for instances of fraud, dishonesty, or misuse of the corporate structure. A determination of whether the Respondent's Directors should be held personally liable for the Respondent company’s debt should be preceded by a determination of whether there are sufficient grounds to pierce or lift the Respondent’s corporate veil. This determination can only properly be made after the Respondent Company’s Directors are examined on oath, the company’s financial records are produced, the means of satisfying the decretal sum owing to the Applicant are shown, and the said Directors produce relevant financial documents for the period in dispute.

30. Given that lifting the corporate veil is an extraordinary remedy, it would be premature to do so without first examining the Company's business affairs, as emphasised in cases requiring sequential enforcement steps. Default without just cause would substantiate abuse, thereby justifying further consideration of personal liability, but only upon proof of fraud after default.

31. The Court finds that the evidentiary threshold for piercing the corporate veil has not yet been met. Granting this remedy would be premature, as it may be available only if the Directors fail to comply with examination or disclosure orders, or if fraud is subsequently established. In these circumstances, I conclude that this issue should be addressed after the cross-examination of the Respondent Company’s Directors.

32. In the end, this Court finds that the instant application is merited. It is allowed in the following terms: -

a. I hereby issue Summons to the Respondent Company’s Directors, namely, Diamond Ali Hasham Lalji Nurani and Shahid Diamond Lalji Nurani, to attend Court for oral examination under oath regarding the Respondent’s assets, liabilities and/or means of satisfying the decretal sum herein;

b. An order is hereby issued directing the Respondent Company’s Directors, namely Ali Hasham Lalji Nurani and Shahid Diamond Lalji Nurani, to produce the Respondent Company’s audited books of account, statements of account, cheque books, and all other documents relating to the financial affairs of the judgment-debtor for the period from January 2022 to date.

c. The aforesaid Directors shall be examined on the contents of the said documents/records on a date to be set by the Court;

d. Prayer (2) of the instant application is hereby held in abeyance and shall be determined after the Respondent’s Directors are examined on oath and the Respondent’s financial records are produced; and

e. Costs shall be in the cause.

33. It is so ordered.

DELIVERED, DATED AND SIGNED AT NAIROBI THIS 27TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026 VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS.

J G KEMEI

JUDGE

Delivered online in the presence of:

1. N/A for the Applicant

2. Mr. Wepoh for the Respondent

CA – Mr. Oglen

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder