Background
For determination before this Court are two applications; the Advocates’ application dated 30/4/2026 and the Judgment-Debtors application dated 13/7/2026.
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
For determination before this Court are two applications; the Advocates’ application dated 30/4/2026 and the Judgment-Debtors application dated 13/7/2026.
Paragraph 1 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC MISC. APPLICATION NO. E015 OF 2025
E.A. OCHIENG & CO. ADVOCATES -DECREE-HOLDER/ADVOCATE
VS
EUNICE LOLITA LAMBA -1ST JUDGMENT -DEBTOR/CLIENT
PAUL ESSENDI -2ND JUDGMENT –DEBTOR/CLIENT
AND
KENYA COMMERCIAL BANK LIMITED - GARNISHEE
RULING
(In respect of the Advocates’ application dated 30/4/2026 and the Judgment-Debtors application dated 13/7/2026)
1. For determination before this Court are two applications; the Advocates’ application dated 30/4/2026 and the Judgment-Debtors application dated 13/7/2026.
The Advocate’s application
2. The Advocate’s application is said to be anchored under the provisions of Order 23 Rule 1, 2, 8 and 9, Order 50 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, Section 1A, 1B & 3A of the Civil Procedure. In the main the Advocate prays for orders That;
a. This Honourable Court be pleased to make a Garnishee Order that such sums or debts as are sufficient to answer the Decree obtained by the Decree-holder against the Judgment-Debtor, or the unsatisfied part thereof owing or accruing due from the Garnishee, Kenya Commercial Bank, Kipande Branch, to the 1st Judgment-Debtor be attached to answer the Decree passed herein against the 1st Judgment-Debtor together with the interest accrued so far and costs of these Garnishee Proceedings.
b. The Garnishee, M/S Kenya Commercial Bank, Kipande Branch, do attend Court on a date to be fixed to show cause why it should not pay to the Decree-holder the amount of KES. 150,000/- from monies held on behalf of the 1st Judgment-Debtor in account number 1124435395 and any other account held by the Judgment Debtors with the Garnishee or so much thereof as may be sufficient to satisfy the Decree and cost herein;
c. In the alternative, a mandatory injunction do issue compelling the Garnishee to attend this Honourable Court on such a date and time as it might direct and disclose full particulars of the total credits of the Judgment-Debtor’s accounts which disclosure should include but not limited to particulars respecting the dealings of the accounts held by the Judgment-Debtor.
d. The Plaintiff/Decree-holder be at liberty for any such further orders and/or directions as this Honourable Court may deem fit.
e. The costs of this application be borne by the Judgment Debtor.
3. The application is founded on the grounds set out therein and is supported by the affidavit of Elizabeth Ochieng’, dated 30/4/2026. The affidavit states that the applicant holds an unsatisfied Decree issued on 16/2/2026 against the judgment Debtor for Kshs. 150,000/=. The deponent avers that the decretal amount remains unpaid because the Debtor has failed to satisfy the decree despite being aware of it. The applicant has identified an active and adequately funded bank account held by the 1st judgment Debtor at Kenya Commercial Bank, Kipande Branch. Accordingly, the applicant seeks an order freezing the account to recover the amount due, together with costs, through garnishee proceedings.
1st Judgment-Debtor’s Replying Affidavit
4. By reference to the Replying Affidavit dated 30/7/2026, the 1st Judgment-Debtor acknowledges that the Applicant obtained a Judgment and Decree under Section 51(2) of the Advocates Act. She refers to her application, which seeks a stay of execution and garnishee proceedings, the setting aside of the Judgment, and leave to file a Reference out of time. She maintains that substantial questions remain undetermined as to whether an Advocate-Client relationship ever existed between the Applicant and the Judgment Debtors. Specifically, the deponent asserts that they never retained the Applicant Advocate for the conveyancing transaction, never signed a retainer agreement, and never paid legal fees, as the Applicant acted for the purchaser.
5. The deponent further avers that their failure to timely challenge the taxation or satisfy the Decree was not willful or deliberate. She avers that she was diagnosed with cancer and has been undergoing continuous chemotherapy, which significantly impaired her ability to appreciate the legal consequences of the proceedings or seek prompt advice. She denies any intention to dissipate assets or obstruct justice and that the Applicant's claims are speculative and lack factual basis. Consequently, the deponent prays that the Court preserves the status quo and decline to make the Garnishee Order Nisi absolute pending the hearing and determination of the application. She argues that a temporary stay will prevent substantial prejudice and can be compensated by an award of costs.
The 2nd Judgment-Debtor’s Replying Affidavit
6. In his Replying Affidavit, sworn on 30/7/2026, the 2nd Judgment-Debtor also acknowledges the Judgment entered against them and denies the existence of the alleged Advocate-Client relationship between them and the Decree-Holder. He categorically denies retaining, hiring, authorising, or signing any letter of engagement or instructions appointing the Decree-Holder as his Advocate.
7. The deponent states that he was neither a vendor nor a purchaser of the property that was the subject of the conveyancing transaction. He avers that he has no legal, equitable, or beneficial interest in the property. He asserts that his sole involvement was to assist, at the parties’ request, by relaying information and delivering documents between them. He further avers that he was surprised to learn that an Advocate-Client Bill of Costs had been filed against him and that judgment had been entered against him. He denies any indebtedness to the Decree-Holder and accordingly seeks a stay of the garnishee proceedings, as he would suffer substantial prejudice if compelled to satisfy a Decree founded on a disputed Advocate-Client relationship.
The Replying Affidavit of the Garnishee
8. The Garnishee, through its Manager, Service Quality and Compliance, Angeline Sielei, at the Kipande House Branch, confirms that the Judgment Debtor maintains an Account with the Garnishee. As at 9/7/2026, the account did not contain sufficient funds to satisfy the Decree nisi in full, and the Garnishee accordingly attached and locked the available sum of Kshs. 28,908.78, being the funds held in the account. The Garnishee therefore avers that it can only partially comply with the Court order to the extent of the said sum and prays that the Court award it costs of the proceedings against the Judgment Debtor, who occasioned the same.
The Judgment-Debtors’ application
9. The Respondent/Judgment-Debtors’ application is anchored on the provisions of Article 25 (c), 48, 50(1), 159(2)(d) and 259 of the Constitution, Sections 1A, 1B, 3A and 63 (e) of the Civil Procedure Act, Order 22 Rule 22, Order 42 Rule 6, Order 45 Rule 1 and Order 51 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules, Section 51 (2) of the Advocates Act and Paragraph 11(4) of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order. The Judgment- Debtors substantively seeks for orders that: -
a. Pending the hearing and determination of the intended Reference, there be a stay of execution of the Certificate of Taxation dated 20/1/2026, the Judgment entered pursuant thereto and all consequential proceedings.
b. The Judgment entered on 16/2/2026 together with the Decree issued pursuant thereto and all consequential orders be and are hereby set aside.
c. This Honourable Court be pleased to enlarge time under Paragraph 11(4) of the Advocates (Remuneration)Order within which the Judgment Debtors/Applicants may file and serve a Reference challenging the taxation of the Advocate/Client Bill of Costs.
d. Leave be and is hereby granted to the Judgment Debtors/Applicants to file and serve the intended Reference within fourteen (14) days of the Court’s Ruling or within such other period as the Court may direct.
e. Pending the hearing and determination of the Intended Reference, there be a stay of execution and/or enforcement of the Certificate of Taxation, the Judgment, the Decree and all consequential proceedings.
f. The costs of the Application shall abide the outcome of the Intended Reference.
10. The application is based on its face and is supported by the affidavit of Eunice Lolita Lamba, the 1st Judgment Debtor herein, sworn on the same date. The deponent avers that, in 2024, she agreed to sell her property (Nairobi/Block 82/5811) directly to Aaron Mwendwa Musau. She states that she did not at any time retain or instruct the Advocate herein to act on her behalf. She further states that the Advocate acted exclusively for the purchaser and that she never executed a retainer agreement, letter of instruction, or agreement for the payment of legal fees, nor did she receive any funds through the Advocate. In addition, she asserts that the 2nd Judgment Debtor was not a party to the sale transaction in his personal capacity, held no proprietary interest in the property, and merely assisted with the delivery of documents without instructing the Applicant Advocate or authorising the payment of any legal fees.
11. The deponent further states that, shortly after the transaction, she was diagnosed with cancer and has since undergone prolonged chemotherapy, resulting in severe physical weakness and a substantial impairment of her ability to understand the legal consequences or take the necessary procedural steps. She attributes her failure to respond to the initial proceedings to her medical condition and denies any deliberate intent to delay or obstruct justice. She avers that she only recently learned of the Judgment entered against him and the 2nd Judgment Debtor, as well as the Applicant Advocate’s commencement of execution proceedings, including Garnishee Proceedings scheduled for hearing on 16/7/2026.
12. Contending that she has an arguable challenge to both the Judgment and the Certificate of Taxation, the deponent submits that where an advocate-Client relationship is genuinely disputed, the Court must resolve that issue before enforcement. She seeks an extension of time under Paragraph 11 of the Advocates (Remuneration) Order to file a Reference out of time, citing his prolonged illness as sufficient cause. The deponent concludes by urging the Court to stay execution to prevent the intended Reference from being rendered nugatory and to safeguard her constitutional right to a fair hearing. She submits that the Applicant Advocate will suffer no prejudice that cannot be compensated by an award of costs.
The Advocate’s Replying Affidavit
13. With reference to the Replying Affidavit of Elizabeth Akinyi Ochieng’, sworn on 8/8/2026, it is averred that the law firm acted as advocates for the 1st Judgment Debtor in the sale and transfer of land parcel Nairobi/Block 82/5811 to Aaron Mwenda Musau. It is further stated that the firm prepared the Agreement for Sale dated 10/9/2024, which expressly identifies the firm as the Vendor's Advocates. In addition, the tasks itemised in the Advocate-Client Bill of Costs dated 28/1/2025, including the preparation and engrossment of the Sale Agreement and the delivery of completion documents, are consistent with the firm having acted for the vendor. This contradicts the 1st Applicant's averment that the firm acted for the purchaser.
14. She further deposes that the Bill of Costs was served on the Applicants by WhatsApp messages dated 3/9/2025, 4/11/2025, and 11/11/2025. However, neither Judgment Debtor filed a Notice of Objection, attended the taxation hearing, or filed a Reference against the Taxing Officer's ruling. Accordingly, the Bill of Costs was taxed on 8/12/2025 in the amount of Kshs. 150,000/=, as certified in the Certificate of Taxation issued on 20/1/2026. She states that the judgment sum remains wholly unsatisfied, prompting the Applicant/Respondent to commence garnishee proceedings against the 1st Applicant's account held at Kenya Commercial Bank, Kipande Branch.
15. It is deposed that the Applicants did not raise an objection based on capacity until the Application dated 13/7/2026, filed on the eve of the Garnishee hearing and more than seven months after taxation. She avers that, although she sympathises with the 1st Judgment Debtor’s disclosed chemotherapy cycles, the medical records do not establish that he was incapacitated from instructing advocates or responding to legal process. Further, the records do not establish a causal link between the disclosed medical circumstances and the failure to act upon the Bill of Costs, which was taxed before the disclosed hospitalisations. In addition, the 2nd Judgment Debtor does not dispute proper service; however, he has provided no explanation for his failure to defend the cause, as he was not ill.
16. Counsel further submits that the Judgment Debtors have not provided any security for the due performance of the Decree, nor have they particularised any specific, quantified loss they would suffer beyond general assertions. She maintains that the Advocate/Decree Holder would be gravely prejudiced by any further delay in recovering professional fees taxed as long ago as December 2025. Accordingly, it is prayed that the Application be dismissed with costs to the Advocate/Decree Holder and that the Garnishee Application dated 30/4/2026 be allowed as prayed.
Court’s directions
17. The Court directed the parties to file their submissions. The parties complied, and each filed two sets of submissions in respect of the two applications. The Advocate’s submissions are dated 8/8/2026, whereas the Clients’ submissions are dated 8/9/2026. The Court has read and considered both sets of written submissions, which now form part of the Court record.
Analysis and Determination
18. Having carefully considered the rival applications, the supporting and opposing affidavits and the written submissions, the issues commending themselves for determination are:
a. Whether the Client should be granted Leave to file a Reference out of time
b. Whether a garnishee order absolute should issue.
c. Who should bear the costs of the application
Whether the Client should be granted Leave to file a Reference out of time
19. Rule 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order makes provision for the procedure an aggrieved party must adopt. It provides:
1) Should any party object to the decision of the taxing officer, he may within fourteen days after the decision give notice in writing to the taxing officer of the items of taxation to which he objects.
2) The taxing officer shall forthwith record and forward to the objector the reasons for his decision on those items and the objector may within fourteen days from the receipt of the reasons apply to a judge by chamber summons, which shall be served on all the parties concerned, setting out the grounds of his objection.
3) Any person aggrieved by the decision of the judge upon any objection referred to such judge under subsection (2) may, with the leave of the judge but not otherwise, appeal to the Court of Appeal.
4) The High Court shall have power in its discretion by order to enlarge the time fixed by subparagraph (1) or subparagraph (2) for the taking of any step; application for such an order may be made by chamber summons upon giving to every other interested party not less than three clear days’ notice in writing or as the Court may direct, and may be so made notwithstanding that the time sought to be enlarged may have already expired.
20. My understanding of paragraph 11(4) is that when a party is confronted with a limitation of time, it must apply for an extension of time to file a notice of objection or the reference itself out of time. The Court’s power to enlarge the time fixed by subparagraph (1) is discretionary. It is trite that a party seeking the exercise of the Court’s discretion in its favour is obliged to demonstrate valid and reasonable grounds for the Court to exercise that discretion. This principle was clearly established in the Supreme Court case of Nicholas Kiptoo Arap Korir Salat v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 7 others [2014] eKLR.
21. Further, Rule 11(1) requires that a party aggrieved by the decision of a taxing master file and/or lodge a notice of objection to taxation against that decision within 14 days of the date of such taxation. Therefore, filing the notice of objection is mandatory.
22. The notice of objection to taxation must specify the particular items in respect of which the Applicant claims to be aggrieved or dissatisfied. It should not be omnibus. Any omnibus notice would be incompetent and incapable of grounding a Reference.
23. In Machira & Company Advocates -vs- Arthur K. Magugu & Another (2012) eKLR, the Court of Appeal agreed with the findings of Ringera J, who had struck out the reference as incompetent on the basis that there was no written notice of objection under rule 11. The Court held, inter alia,
“Sub-rule (1) requires the party objecting to give notice in writing within 14 days “of the items of taxation to which he objects”. As the trial judge correctly found, the Respondents notice of 1/08/2001 did not comply with that provision. It did not specify the items objected to so that the taxing officer could give his reasons on them.
As we have pointed out the intendment of the Rules Committee in providing for objections to bills of costs to be dealt with by references and not appeal or review was expedition. If vague notices are given taxing officers might be forced to give their reasons for their taxation of each item including even those not objected to. That would of course defeat the purpose of that expeditious procedure. Having not specified the items objected to and sought reasons for their taxation, the Respondents notice of 1/08/2001 was fatally defective. It follows that the Respondents’ reference based on it was incompetent and we agree with counsel for the Appellant that it should have been struck out.
Having not given a proper notice specifying the items objected to and seeking the reasons for their taxation at the figures they were taxed, the issue of when the taxing master’s decision was received is immaterial and does not avail the Respondents. Under sub-rule (2), time stops running from the date a proper notice is filed, which of course must be within 14 days of taxation, until receipt of the taxing master’s reasons for his decision.”
24. In the case of Twiga Motor Limited -vs- Hon. Dalmas Otieno Anyango (2015) eKLR, the Court stated that;
“The time limits in Rule 11 of the Advocates Remuneration Order have been put there for a reason. Failure to adhere to the said time lines would mean that the application would be rendered incompetent in the first instance.” [own emphasis]
25. In the present case, the Client has sought leave only to file the Reference out of time, and not leave to file a Notice of Objection out of time. I have reviewed the record and note that the Client did not file a Notice of Objection, not even an incompetent one. In the absence of a Notice of Objection to taxation that properly identifies the items objected to and was filed within the statutory timeframe, or a request for leave to file such a notice out of time, there can be no competent Reference, even if leave to file a Reference were granted.
26. The Notice of Objection to Taxation is equivalent to a memorandum of appeal, setting out the grounds of appeal. This procedural error cannot be remedied by invoking the oxygen principles or Article 159 of the Constitution. In this regard, I am persuaded by the decision in Chadha (Sued as the Executrix of the Estate of Kulwant Singh Chadha (Now Deceased) -vs- Chaudhri & Associates (2024) e KLR), in which the Learned Judge struck out a Reference for failure to file the requisite Notice of Objection to Taxation.
Whether a garnishee order absolute should issue.
27. Garnishee proceedings are proceedings whereby the judgment-Debtor’s property, or credit in the possession or under the control of, or owing by another, is applied to the payment of a debt to the Decree-holder by proper statutory process against the Debtor and the garnishee. The said proceedings are provided for under Order 23 Rule 1(1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010, which states as follows: -
“A Court may, upon the ex parte application of a Decree-holder, and either before or after an oral examination of the judgment-Debtor, and upon affidavit by the Decree-holder or his advocate, stating that a Decree has been issued and that it is still unsatisfied and to what amount, and that another person is indebted to the judgment-Debtor and is within the jurisdiction, order that all debts (other than the salary or allowance coming within the provisions of Order 22, rule 42 owing from such third person (hereinafter called the “garnishee”) to the judgment-Debtor shall be attached to answer the Decree together with the costs of the garnishee proceedings; and by the same or any subsequent order it may be ordered that the garnishee shall appear before the Court to show cause why he should not pay to the Decree- holder the debt due from him to the judgment-Debtor or so much thereof as may be sufficient to satisfy the Decree together with the costs aforesaid.”
28. In defining what constitutes garnishee proceedings, the Court in Nyandoro & Company Advocates v National Water Conservation & Pipeline Corporation [2021] eKLR; Kenya Commercial Bank Group Limited (Garnishee) [2021] eKLR referred to the Nigerian Supreme Court’s holding in C.B.N. v Auto Import Export [2013] 2 NWLR (Pt. 1337) 80 p. 126 paras. E – F, which offered an explanatory yet concise definition of garnishee proceedings as follows: –
“Garnishee proceedings are special specie of process by which a judgment creditor may attach (or garnishee) debts due in satisfaction of the judgment debt. The debt owed by the third party to the judgment Debtor, on being attached, shall ultimately be paid by him to the judgment creditor on the order of Court. Thus, garnishee proceedings involve the attachment of debt due from a third party to the judgment Debtor, and the use of the amount of that debt in liquidating the judgment debt. In garnishee proceedings, the third party indebted to the judgment Debtor is called the garnishee. The judgment creditor, on the other hand, is referred to as the garnishor.”
29. More often than not, in garnishee proceedings, the garnishee has no objection to the garnishee orders being made absolute, provided there is a discernible debt due and owing from the judgment-Debtor and the garnishee holds or is in possession of sums of money belonging to the judgment-Debtor, sufficient to satisfy the debt due. This Court is empowered under Order 23 Rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010 to order the garnishee to pay directly to the Decree-holder the sums it owes the judgment-Debtor, or so much of them as may be sufficient to satisfy the amount of the judgment and the costs of the garnishee proceedings, if the garnishee does not dispute the debt due to the judgment-Debtor.
30. Order 23 Rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010 states as follows-
“If the garnishee does not dispute the debt due or claimed to be due from him to the judgment-Debtor, or, if he does not appear upon the day of hearing named in an order nisi, then the Court may order execution against the person and goods of the garnishee to levy the amount due from him, or so much thereof as may be sufficient to satisfy the Decree, together with the costs of the garnishee proceedings; and the order absolute shall be in Form No. 17 or 18 of Appendix A, as the case may require.”
31. In this case, the garnishee does not dispute that the 1st Judgment-Debtor maintains an account with it. It however avers that the account holds only Kshs. 28,908.78/=, which funds are insufficient to satisfy the entire decretal sum.
32. Having disallowed the Judgment-Debtors’ intended Reference and noting that the Decree-holder is a successful litigant with the right to reap the fruits of its judgment, I agree with the Decree-Holder that the funds held by the garnishee on behalf of the 1st Judgment-Debtor should be applied to offset part of the said debt. However, the said funds are not sufficient to settle the entire debt.
33. The upshot of my findings is as follows:
a. The Clients/Judgment-Debtors’ application dated 13/7/2026 be and is hereby dismissed.
b. The Advocates’ application dated 30/4/2026 is hereby allowed in the following terms-
i. The Garnishee Order Nisi issued herein is hereby made absolute, specifically for the attachment of the sum of Kshs. Kshs. 28,908.78/=, being the credit amount held by the garnishee in the 1 st Judgment -Debtor’s Bank Account No. 1124435395 Kipande House Branch.
ii. Costs of both applications shall be borne by the Judgment-Debtors.
34. It is so ordered.
DELIVERED, DATED AND SIGNED AT NAIROBI THIS 27TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026 VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS.
J G KEMEI
JUDGE
Delivered online in the presence of:
1. Ms. Chawiyah Jean H/B for Mr. Ochieng for the Applicant
2. Mr. Atito for the Respondents
3. CA – Mr. Oglen