Land law

Issack v Ai-Fardoos Flats Management Ltd & another [2026] KEELC 7537 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elclc Case E550 of 2025
Judgment date
27 October 2026
Judge(s)
T. Murigi

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

By a Notice of Motion dated 6th July, 2026, the Defendants’/Applicants’ seek the following Orders:

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The Defendants/Applicants filed their Submissions dated 25th August, 2026. On behalf of the Applicants, Counsel outlined the following issues for the Court's determination:

Paragraph 14 →

Reasoning passage

Regarding the prayer for an injunction, the record shows that the Applicants had previously sought similar injunctive relief, culminating in the orders dated 29th June 2026. To the extent that the present prayer seeks substantially the same relief previously considered and determined by this Court, the Applicants cannot seek to reopen that determination by a subsequent application. Accordingly, I find that the prayer for a further…

Paragraph 31 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the 6 July 2026 motion was barred by res judicata; whether police assistance should issue to facilitate compliance with the 29 June 2026 orders concerning Al-Fardoos Plaza; whether alleged disobedience should be decided as contempt in this motion; and…

Material facts

The defendants said that the 29 June 2026 orders restrained the plaintiff from interfering with their existing occupation and use of the basement floor pending arbitration, but that he and unidentified persons attempted forcibly to take over the basement on 5…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELCLC CASE NO. E550 OF 2025

YUSSUF SHARIFF ISSACK ………………………………………….…PLAINTIFF

=VERSUS=

AI-FARDOOS FLATS MANAGEMENT LIMITED ................... 1ST DEFENDANT

UBDI YAHYE HAJI ……………………………………………2ND DEFENDANT

RULING

1. By a Notice of Motion dated 6th July, 2026, the Defendants’/Applicants’ seek the following Orders:

a) Spent.

b) THAT pending the hearing and determination of this application, this Honourable Court be pleased to issue an order directing the Officer Commanding Eastleigh North Police Station to supervise and ensure compliance with the orders of Honourable T. Murigi issued on 29th June 2026, restraining the Plaintiff/Respondents, whether by himself, his agents, servants, or assigns, from interfering with the existing occupation and use of the basement floor of Al-Fardoos Plaza pending the arbitration proceedings.

c) THAT pending the hearing and determination of the intended arbitral proceedings, this Honourable Court be pleased to issue a temporary injunction restraining the Plaintiff/Respondents, whether by himself, his agents, servants, or assigns, from interfering with the existing occupation and use of the basement floor of Al-Fardoos Plaza and the officer commanding Eastleigh North Police Station to ensure compliance.

d) THAT the costs of this Application be provided for.

2. The Application is based on the grounds appearing on its face together with the supporting affidavit of Ubdi Yahye Haji, a Director of the 1st Defendant, sworn on even date.

THE APPLICANTS CASE

3. The deponent averred that, by a ruling delivered on 29th June 2026 in the presence of Counsel for both parties, the Plaintiff/Respondent was restrained from interfering with the occupation or use of the basement floor of Al-Fardoos Plaza pending the arbitration proceedings.

4. She further averred that, despite this unambiguous order, the Plaintiff, accompanied by unidentified individuals, attempted to forcibly take over the premises on 5th July 2026, prompting patrolling police officers to intervene and restore order. She further averred that, after she reported the incident to Eastleigh North Police Station, the Officer Commanding Station advised her to obtain express orders authorizing police supervision of the enforcement of the orders.

5. In conclusion, the deponent urged the Court to allow the application as prayed.

THE PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT’S CASE

6. The Plaintiff filed a Replying Affidavit sworn on 15th July 2026 in opposition to the application.

7. The Plaintiff averred that the Defendants’ allegations were unfounded and maintained that the Orders required the status quo to be maintained in respect of the parking lots and common areas of Al-Fardoos Plaza, pending the arbitration proceedings. He further averred that the Orders restrained the Plaintiff from interfering with the existing occupation and use of the basement floor of Al-Fardoos Plaza.

8. He contended that the Defendants had failed to disclose material facts and sought to enforce Order No. 2 while contravening Order No. 1 by carrying out construction at night in the common areas. He further contended that the Applicants had unlawfully cordoned off common areas, including garbage collection points, washing areas, and electricity control centres, thereby causing serious health risks and hardship. He deposed that construction was proceeding without the requisite development approvals from the County Government in contravention of the Physical and Land Use Planning Act, 2019.

9. Consequently, the Plaintiff urged the Court to dismiss the application with costs on the grounds that it is fundamentally defective, is barred by the doctrine of res judicata and constitutes an abusive attempt to fraudulently acquire the parking bays and common areas.

THE DEFENDANTS RESPONSE

10. In a Further Affidavit dated 25th August 2026, the deponent reiterated that on 5th July 2026 the Respondent, accompanied by unidentified persons, entered the basement floor of Al-Fardoos Plaza and attempted to take forcible possession of the suit premises, thereby violating the Court orders dated 29th June 2026.

11. She denied the Respondent’s allegations, asserting that the claims that the Applicants had undertaken unapproved nighttime construction and obstructed access to common areas were false and misleading. She stated that these claims were unsupported by credible evidence and were intended to unfairly portray the Applicants as having breached the Court’s orders. She further stated that the request for police assistance was not prompted by any default on the part of the Applicants, but was necessitated solely by the Respondent’s repeated attempts to unlawfully interfere with their occupation of the premises.

12. She further averred that the Respondent cannot contend that the Applicants are in breach merely because they have sought to enforce the Court’s orders. Nor may the Respondent conflate the enforcement application with its own non-compliance to divert attention from its failure to comply with those orders. She deposed that the application is not res judicata, as this specific request for enforcement has not been heard or finally determined by a Court of competent jurisdiction.

13. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions.

THE DEFENDANTS/APPLICANTS SUBMISSIONS

14. The Defendants/Applicants filed their Submissions dated 25th August, 2026. On behalf of the Applicants, Counsel outlined the following issues for the Court's determination:

a) Whether this Honourable Court should issue police enforcement orders for the orders issued on 29th June, 2026 against the Respondent; and

b) Whether the present application is res judicata.

15. Regarding the first issue, Counsel submitted that Court orders are binding and must be obeyed unless lawfully varied or set aside. Relying on Claire Adamba Okanga v Godfrey Gichuhi Waiharo [2013] eKLR and Namu Wachira & 2 Others v Njeru Wachira [2015] eKLR, Counsel further submitted that, although Section 24 of the National Police Service Act does not expressly provide for police enforcement, the police’s mandate to maintain law, order, and peace includes assisting in the execution of Court orders.

16. Counsel submitted that, notwithstanding the express orders issued on 29th June 2026 prohibiting interference with the basement floor of Al-Fardoos Plaza, the Respondent continued to deploy armed individuals to forcibly enter the premises and threaten the Applicants’ possession. Counsel further submitted that the Officer Commanding of Eastleigh North Police Station advised the Applicants to obtain appropriate orders from this Honourable Court authorizing police supervision before any intervention. Counsel maintained that police supervision is necessary to uphold the rule of law, prevent disorder, and ensure compliance pending the arbitration proceedings.

17. Regarding the second issue, Counsel submitted that the application is not barred by Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act. Counsel relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in Kenya Commercial Bank Limited v Muiri Coffee Estate Limited & another [2016], which set out the principle of res judicata. Counsel further relied on John Francis Maritime Services Limited vs CS Transport and Infrastructure & 3 others (2021) KESC 39 (KLR), which set out the elements of res judicata.

18. Counsel further submitted that the present application is not barred by res judicata, as it seeks police enforcement of the orders issued on 29th June 2026, an issue that has neither been heard nor finally determined by any court of competent jurisdiction. In conclusion, Counsel urged the Court to allow the application as prayed.

THE PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS

19. The Plaintiff filed his submissions on 25th August 2026.

20. Counsel submitted that the Plaintiff owns Flat No. GF1, situated on the property known as Al-Fardoos Plaza, L.R. No. 26/VIII/103 (original No. 27/3), Eastleigh, Nairobi. Counsel further submitted that the Defendants seek to enforce selectively Order No. 2, issued by this Court on 29th June 2026, while having no intention of enforcing Order No. 1, which they are in complete breach of.

21. Counsel submitted that the allegations of breach were false, unverified, and made in bad faith. Counsel further submitted that any genuine breach should have been addressed through a contempt application rather than an unsubstantiated motion under Order 40, Rules 1 and 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

22. Counsel further submitted that the Defendants are actively violating court orders and statutory provisions under the Physical and Land Use Planning Act, 2019, by undertaking unapproved construction at night and unlawfully cordoning off essential common areas, including the washing area, garbage disposal points, and the electricity control centre. Counsel contended that these actions have caused the Plaintiff hardship and exposed him to health risks.

23. Counsel submitted that the Defendants were seeking to relitigate an issue previously determined by a Court of competent jurisdiction. Accordingly, Counsel submitted that the application is barred by the doctrine of res judicata and constitutes an abuse of the Court's process.

24. Counsel relied on Mutitika v Baharini Farm Limited [1985] KLR 227, Samuel M. N. Mweru v National Land Commission & 2 others [2020] eKLR, Sum v Koech (Civil Suit E077 of 2024) [2024] KEHC 14276 (KLR), and Perna v Foss to submit that specific elements must be established to prove contempt, noting that contempt proceedings are quasi-criminal in nature. Counsel further submitted that the applicable standard of proof in contempt proceedings is higher than the balance of probabilities but lower than proof beyond a reasonable doubt. Counsel contended that the Applicant failed to meet the threshold for establishing contempt of court against the Plaintiff. Accordingly, Counsel urged the Court to dismiss the application with costs.

ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION

25. Having considered the application, the respective affidavits and the rival submissions, the following issues arise for determination:

a. Whether the application is barred by the doctrine of res judicata;

b. Whether the Applicants have established a basis for an order directing the police to facilitate compliance with the orders issued on 29th June 2026; and

c. Whether the allegations of contempt should be determined in the present application.

WHETHER THE APPLICATION IS BARRED BY THE DOCTRINE OF RES JUDICATA

26. The Plaintiff contends that the application dated 6th July 2026 is barred by the doctrine of res judicata under Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act. The Applicants dispute this contention, maintaining that the present application seeks police assistance to ensure compliance with the orders dated 29th June 2026.

27. The doctrine of res judicata is set out in Section 7 of the Civil Procedure Act as follows:

“No court shall try any suit or issue in which the matter directly and substantially in issue has been directly and substantially in issue in a former suit between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title, in a court competent to try such subsequent suit or the suit in which such issue has been subsequently raised, and has been heard and finally decided by such court.”

28. The Supreme Court restated the rationale and elements of the doctrine in John Florence Maritime Services Limited & another versus Cabinet Secretary for Transport and Infrastructure & 3 Others [2021] eKLR as follows:

“We reaffirm our position, as in the Muiri Coffee case, that the doctrine of res judicata is based on the principle of finality, which is a matter of public policy. The principle of finality is one of the pillars upon which our judicial system is founded and the doctrine of res judicata prevents a multiplicity of suits, which would ordinarily clog the courts, apart from occasioning unnecessary costs to the parties; and it ensures that litigation comes to an end, and the verdict duly translates into fruit for one party, and liability for another party, conclusively.”

For res judicata to be invoked in a civil matter, the following elements must be demonstrated:

a) There is a former Judgment or order which was final;

b) The Judgment or order was on merit;

c) The Judgment or order was rendered by a court having jurisdiction over the subject matter and the parties; and

d)There must be between the first and the second action identical parties, subject matter and cause of action. (See Uhuru Highway Developers Limited v Central Bank of Kenya & others [1999] eKLR and see the decision of the Court of Appeal in Nicholas Njeru v Attorney General & 8 others Civil Appeal 110 of 2011 (2013) eKLR).

29. For the doctrine to apply, it must be shown that there was a previous final decision on the merits, issued by a court of competent jurisdiction, and that the subsequent suit involves the same parties, or parties litigating under the same title, over the same subject matter and the same cause of action. The doctrine is intended to promote the finality of litigation and to prevent parties from reopening matters conclusively determined.

30. In the matter at hand, the Applicants seek an order directing the Officer Commanding Eastleigh North Police Station to ensure compliance with the orders issued on 29th June 2026 and an injunction restraining the Plaintiff from interfering with the Applicants’ occupation and use of the basement floor of Al-Fardoos Plaza pending the arbitral proceedings.

31. Regarding the prayer for an injunction, the record shows that the Applicants had previously sought similar injunctive relief, culminating in the orders dated 29th June 2026. To the extent that the present prayer seeks substantially the same relief previously considered and determined by this Court, the Applicants cannot seek to reopen that determination by a subsequent application. Accordingly, I find that the prayer for a further injunction is declined to the extent that it duplicates the injunctive relief already determined by this Court on 29th June 2026.

32. Regarding the prayer for police assistance, the Applicants contend that this application became necessary because of subsequent interference with their occupation, which allegedly occurred on 5th July 2026. The application seeks police assistance to ensure compliance with the orders issued on 29th June 2026. The Plaintiff has not demonstrated that the specific request for police assistance now before the Court was previously heard and finally determined by a competent Court. On the material presented, I find that the prayer for police assistance is not barred by res judicata.

WHETHER THE APPLICANTS HAVE ESTABLISHED A BASIS FOR POLICE ASSISTANCE

33. The principal issue is whether the Applicants have established a sufficient basis for directing the Officer Commanding Eastleigh North Police Station to ensure compliance with the orders issued on 29th June 2026.

34. Court orders must be complied with for as long as they remain in force. A party against whom an order has been made may not disregard it merely because they consider it erroneous or inconvenient. Similarly, a party seeking enforcement must act within the terms of the order and may not use enforcement proceedings to obtain relief that the Court did not grant.

35. The Applicants allege that, notwithstanding the subsisting orders, the Plaintiff attempted to assume control of the basement floor. They contend that police intervention was necessary to restore order. They further contend that the Officer Commanding Eastleigh North Police Station advised them to obtain appropriate orders from the Court before providing further assistance.

36. The Plaintiff disputes these allegations and asserts that the Applicants have breached the orders by undertaking unauthorized construction and obstructing access to common areas. The Plaintiff further contends that the Applicants are seeking to enforce the orders selectively.

37. The competing allegations raise two distinct questions. First, whether police assistance is necessary to ensure compliance with the existing orders and maintain peace. Second, whether either party has wilfully disobeyed those orders. These questions should not be conflated.

38. In considering the application, the Court must also bear in mind that the orders dated 29th June 2026 should be read as a whole. As described by the parties, those orders preserved the status quo in respect of the parking lots and common areas of Al-Fardoos Plaza and restrained the Plaintiff from interfering with the existing occupation and use of the basement floor pending arbitration.

39. It follows that the Applicants may not rely on the protection afforded to their occupation of the basement floor as authority to alter the status quo in the common areas. Similarly, the Plaintiff may not rely on alleged violations by the Applicants to justify disregarding the order restraining interference with their occupation. The obligation to comply with the orders dated 29th June 2026 applies to both parties insofar as those orders impose obligations on them.

40. The purpose of police assistance, where warranted, is to maintain law and order and facilitate compliance with a lawful court order. It is not intended to determine the parties’ competing rights in the suit property, authorize changes to the existing occupation, or confer upon either party any rights not granted by the Court.

41. In the circumstances, any order for police assistance should be limited to what is reasonably necessary to facilitate compliance with the orders dated 29th June 2026 and to maintain public order. The police should not be authorised to determine entitlement to occupy the basement floor, parking bays, or common areas, or to undertake any eviction or dispossession, unless expressly authorised by a Court order.

42. I am therefore satisfied that the request for police assistance should be granted to the limited extent necessary to facilitate compliance with the existing orders and to preserve the peace.

WHETHER THE ALLEGATIONS OF CONTEMPT SHOULD BE DETERMINED IN THE PRESENT APPLICATION

43. The Plaintiff contends that the Applicants breached the orders by carrying out unauthorised construction and obstructing access to common areas. Conversely, the Applicants contend that the Plaintiff attempted to interfere with their occupation of the basement floor, thereby breaching the orders.

44. Where a party seeks to have another party held in contempt, the alleged disobedience must be raised through the appropriate proceedings.

45. In the present application, the principal relief sought is police assistance to ensure compliance with the orders dated 29th June 2026. The Court is not being asked to punish contempt. Accordingly, it is unnecessary to determine the parties’ competing allegations of disobedience as if contempt proceedings were before the Court.

46. Accordingly, I decline to find either party in contempt in these proceedings. This does not absolve either party of the obligation to comply with the subsisting orders, nor does it prevent an aggrieved party from instituting appropriate contempt proceedings if there is a proper basis to do so.

WHETHER A FURTHER INJUNCTION SHOULD ISSUE

47. The Applicants have also sought a temporary injunction to restrain the Plaintiff from interfering with their existing occupation and use of the basement floor pending the intended arbitral proceedings.

48. In the absence of a demonstrated need to vary or supplement the orders issued on 29th June 2026, a further injunction in substantially similar terms would be duplicative. I therefore decline to grant a further substantive injunction on the terms sought. The orders of 29th June 2026 shall remain in force in accordance with their terms, subject to any lawful variation by the Court.

49. In the result, I make the following orders:

a. The Plaintiff’s objection that the application dated 6th July 2026 is barred by the doctrine of res judicata is hereby dismissed.

b. The Defendants’/Applicants’ prayer for police assistance is allowed to the limited extent that the Officer Commanding Eastleigh North Police Station shall, upon request and where reasonably necessary, provide assistance to maintain law and order and facilitate compliance with the orders issued by this Court on 29th June 2026.

c. Accordingly, the Officer Commanding Eastleigh North Police Station, upon request and where reasonably necessary, to provide such assistance as may be required to maintain peace and facilitate compliance with the orders of 29th June 2026.

d. For the avoidance of doubt, the order shall apply to both parties.

e. Each party to bear its own costs.

RULING SIGNED, DATED, AND DELIVERED VIA MICROSOFT TEAMS THIS 27TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2026

…………………………………….

HON. T. MURIGI

JUDGE

IN THE PRESENCE OF:

Moshe holding brief for Kiprop, the Defendants' applicants

Malelu for the Plaintiff

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder