Background
The application before this court is the one dated 3rd November 2025 by the Appellants which seeks the following orders;
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
The Notice of Motion dated 3 November 2025 was dismissed because it was sub judice. Costs were ordered to abide the outcome of the appeal.
i. The Notice of Motion application dated 3rd November 2025 is hereby dismissed for being sub judice.
Passage 54 →
ii. Costs will abide the outcome of the appeal.
Passage 55 →
Held. Yes. The application was sub judice because the pending High Court judicial-review matter involved the same parties litigating under the same title and directly and substantially the same matters in issue: challenges to the commercial magistrate’s rulings, including the contempt ruling, and prevention of further lower-court proceedings including sentencing. The motion was therefore dismissed.
Ratio. Under section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act, a court cannot proceed where a previously instituted pending proceeding between the same parties (or parties litigating under the same title) places directly and substantially the same matter in issue before a competent court. The substance of the dispute, rather than the formal judicial-review character or the wording of the prayers, governs the sub judice assessment.
Issue
i. Whether the application is sub judice.
Passage 37 →
Held
24. In the circumstances, notwithstanding the form in which the high court application is cast as a judicial review application, the substance of the dispute remains the same, as in this current application. The current application is caught by the doctrine of sub judice within the meaning of Section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act.
Paragraph 24 →
i. The Notice of Motion application dated 3rd November 2025 is hereby dismissed for being sub judice.
Passage 54 →
Ratio
16. The doctrine of sub-judice prevents a court from proceeding with the trial of any suit in which the matter in issue is directly and substantially the same with that in a previously instituted suit between the same parties pending before the same or another court of competent jurisdiction. The doctrine is enshrined under Section 6 of Civil Procedure Act which defines the doctrine as follows;
Paragraph 16 →
23. In applying the sub-judice rule, a court must be satisfied that the matter in issue is directly and substantially in issue in the previous suit. From the above analysis it is clear that the matters in issue the same.
Paragraph 23 →
24. In the circumstances, notwithstanding the form in which the high court application is cast as a judicial review application, the substance of the dispute remains the same, as in this current application. The current application is caught by the doctrine of sub judice within the meaning of Section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act.
Paragraph 24 →
Not reached
Held. Not reached. Having found the motion sub judice, the court dismissed it and did not separately determine whether the requirements for stay of execution or stay of proceedings were met.
Ratio. This issue was not decided. The dismissal for sub judice disposed of the motion before the requested stays were substantively assessed.
Issue
ii. Whether the Appellants are entitled to the stay of execution and proceedings order in the application.
Passage 38 →
Held
26. Accordingly, I find application herein as sub-judice and in the foregoing I make the following orders;
Paragraph 26 →
i. The Notice of Motion application dated 3rd November 2025 is hereby dismissed for being sub judice.
Passage 54 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
The application before this court is the one dated 3rd November 2025 by the Appellants which seeks the following orders;
Paragraph 1 →I have reviewed and considered the application, the Supporting Affidavit and the Replying Affidavit and I have also considered the submissions made on behalf of the parties and find the following issues for determination.
Paragraph 15 →Accordingly, I find application herein as sub-judice and in the foregoing I make the following orders;
Paragraph 26 →Whether the appellants’ Notice of Motion dated 3 November 2025 was barred by the doctrine of sub judice because of pending judicial-review proceedings; and, if not, whether the appellants were entitled to stay execution, further proceedings, and their…
Uchumi Supermarkets Limited, Lawrence Ngao, Michael Kamotho and James Muiruri sought to halt proceedings and sentencing following a ruling of 9 October 2025 in Milimani Commercial Suit No E1983 of 2024 that cited them for contempt. They contended that the…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT
AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI
ELCLA E217 OF 2025
UCHUMI SUPERMARKETS LIMITED ..………..…...………......……..…1ST APPELLANT
LAWRENCE NGAO……………………………………………………….2ND APPELANT
MICHAEL KAMOTHO……………………………………………………3RD APPELANT
JAMES MUIRURI………………………………………………………….4TH APPELANT
-VERSUS-
HOT SPOT COFFEE LOUNGE…………………………………………...RESPONDENT
RULING
Introduction
1. The application before this court is the one dated 3rd November 2025 by the Appellants which seeks the following orders;
a) Spent
b) THAT this Honourable Court be pleased to stay any further proceedings in Milimani Commercial suit no E1983 of 2024 between the Appellants and the Respondents pending the hearing and determination of this application inter partes
c) THAT the honourable court be pleased to stay the execution of the ruling obtained in Milimani Commercial suit no E1983 of 2024 pending the hearing and determination of this application inter partes.
d) THAT the honourable court be pleased to stay the sentencing of the Appellants on 2nd December 2025 as a result of the ruling obtained in Milimani Commercial Suit No E1983 of 2024 pending hearing and determination by this honourable court of appeal number E217 of 2025 against the ruling and order of the Milimani Commercial Suit No E1983 made on 9th October 2025.
e) THAT the costs of this application be provided for.
2. The Motion is based on the grounds outlined on the face of it and the Supporting Affidavit sworn by Lawrence Ngao. He deponed that the commercial court had proceeded to hear an application citing the Appellants for contempt and allowed the same thereby scheduling for sentencing despite not having the request jurisdiction to do entertain the matter and therefore any application arising from it.
3. He further deponed that the Appellants had been condemned unheard in the said application which prompted the filing of this appeal which raises arguable points hence need to stay the execution of the sentencing and further proceedings of the lower court.
4. The application was opposed by the Respondent who filed grounds of opposition and a replying affidavit sworn on the 20th November 2025.
5. He deponed that the application was sub judice as the Appellants had instituted judicial review proceedings in HCJR/MISCE137 of 2025 seeking for stay of proceedings offending the provisions of section 6 of the civil procedure Act as the application was still pending before the trial court.
6. He further deponed that the commercial court had the jurisdiction to entertain the application as it did as per Section 26(3) of the Environment and Land Court Act.
7. Counsel further submitted that the ruling of 20th September 2026 had not be appealed against and the Appellants were in breach of the same making the contempt orders valid as they the Appellants were fully aware of the proceedings and participated in the same.
8. The application was canvassed by way of Written Submissions. The Applicants submissions are dated 21st April 2026 while those of the Respondents are dated 29th April 2026.
Appellant’s submissions
9. The Appellant in support of his application submitted that they raised an arguable appeal which was a ground necessary to issue stay of execution. That the issues of jurisdiction having been raised, it went into the root of the decisions emanating from them which such decision was the issuance of contempt orders and the intended sentencing then it meant that any decision that had been rendered by the commercial court was not binding as without jurisdiction the court should not have entertained any application relying on Motor Vessel “Lillian S” v Caltex Oil (Kenya) Ltd.
10. Counsel further submitted that the rights of the Appellant to be heard had been violated as the replying affidavits of the Appellants were not considered.
11. It was further submitted that the application had been made without undue delay.
That substantial loss had also been established being that the orders for sentencing had severe consequences of depriving the Applicants of their liberty. This they argued that was a loss that cannot be compensated or remedied through subsequent proceedings and hence was necessary to have stay orders in force so as not to have the appeal nugatory relying on what was stated in RWW vs EKW(2019) Eklr.
Respondent’s submissions
12. The Respondent submitted that the Applicant had not met the threshold required for stay of execution as in order 42 rule 6. That no substantial loss had been demonstrated by the Appellants and that the mere fact that execution was to happen did not amount to substantial loss to be able to stay the execution.
13. Counsel further submitted that the Appellants and also not substantiated the orders for stay of proceedings which held a much higher standard of proof relying in the case of William Odhiambo Ramogi & 3 others Vs Attorney General & 6 others; Muslim for Human Rights & 2 others (Interested Parties) (2020) eKLR.
14. That the Appellant had also not demonstrated that their appeal raised substantial issues that were arguable and would render the said appeal nugatory if the stay of proceedings are not granted.
Analysis and determination
15. I have reviewed and considered the application, the Supporting Affidavit and the Replying Affidavit and I have also considered the submissions made on behalf of the parties and find the following issues for determination.
i. Whether the application is sub judice.
ii. Whether the Appellants are entitled to the stay of execution and proceedings order in the application.
16. The doctrine of sub-judice prevents a court from proceeding with the trial of any suit in which the matter in issue is directly and substantially the same with that in a previously instituted suit between the same parties pending before the same or another court of competent jurisdiction. The doctrine is enshrined under Section 6 of Civil Procedure Act which defines the doctrine as follows;
“6. Stay of suit.
‘‘No court shall proceed with the trial of any suit or proceedings in which the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit or proceeding between the same parties or between parties under whom they or any of them claim litigating under the same title, where such suit or proceeding is pending in the same court or any other court having jurisdiction in Kenya to grant the relief claimed’’
17. The rule is meant to prevent a duplication of the reliefs or a conflict thereof, to avoid confusion and chaos and ensure order in the legal system. In Republic vs Paul Kihara Kariuki, Attorney General & 2 others Ex parte Law Society of Kenya (2020) eKLR, Justice Mativo discussed the concept sub judice as follows:-
“…there exists the concept of sub judice which in Latin means “under Judgement.” It denotes that a matter is being considered by a court or judge. The concept of sub judice that where an issue is pending in a court of law for adjudication between the same parties, any other court is barred from trying that issue so long as the first suit goes on. In such a situation, order is passed by the subsequent court to stay the proceeding and such order can be made at any stage.”
18. This is because since the issues in the two suits are similar, it is presumed that a determination of either of them will obviously render the other spent and of no further use, and a continuation of those proceedings would amount to res judicata.
19. Having looked at the annexure to the Respondent’s replying affidavit marked as ‘NMHA-2’, there is no doubt that there are two suits pending before the courts, being this appeal and judicial review Miscellaneous application E137 of 2025. The parties herein being the 1st and 2nd Appellants and the Respondent are the same parties in the judicial review application. The parties herein have an interest in the said application and are litigating under the same title as those in the Judicial review application. The jurisdiction of the high court is not disputed as it derives its jurisdiction from Article 165(6) of the Constitution as a supervisory court over subordinate court.
20. This brings me to the question of whether the subject matter in the two suits is similar. Notably, Section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act uses the term “matter in issue” as opposed to subject matter. This distinction was explained in the case of Kenya Bankers Association versus Kenya Revenue Authority (2019) eKLR, where the court held that:-
“A cursory look at the prayers sought in this case show that they relate to the same subject matter. However, the principle of sub judice does not talk about the “prayers sought” but rather “the matter in issue” I find that the matters in issue in the suits are substantially the same
21. The matter in the high court relates to seeking of leave to institute the judicial review proceedings of seeking for orders of certiorari, prohibition and mandamus. The said orders are sought to quash all the rulings and order emanating from the proceedings of Milimani Commercial Magistrate’s No E1893 of 2024, which orders include the impugned ruling delivered on 9th October 2025 citing the Appellants for contempt.
22. The Applicant in the high court is also seeking to prohibit the lower court from proceeding with the determination of the matter and issuance of any other order, which is also what this application is seeking thus stay of the proceedings in the lower court specifically the sentencing of the Applicant.
23. In applying the sub-judice rule, a court must be satisfied that the matter in issue is directly and substantially in issue in the previous suit. From the above analysis it is clear that the matters in issue the same.
24. In the circumstances, notwithstanding the form in which the high court application is cast as a judicial review application, the substance of the dispute remains the same, as in this current application. The current application is caught by the doctrine of sub judice within the meaning of Section 6 of the Civil Procedure Act.
25. That a determination on the high court matter would render this instant application res judicata as the issues raised in this application will have been conclusively dealt with to conclusion in the high court matter.
26. Accordingly, I find application herein as sub-judice and in the foregoing I make the following orders;
i. The Notice of Motion application dated 3rd November 2025 is hereby dismissed for being sub judice.
ii. Costs will abide the outcome of the appeal.
It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 29th day of
October 2026.
MOHAMMED N. KULLOW
JUDGE
Ruling delivered in the presence of: -
Ms. Wahome for the Appellants
Ms. Sheunda for the Respondent
Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant