Land law

Githenji & another v Kihingo Village (Waridi Gardens) Management Limited & another [2026] KEELC 7156 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Petition E076 of 2024
Judgment date
28 October 2026
Judge(s)
C.K. Nzili

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this court for determination is the respondent’s preliminary Objection dated 24.10.2024. The preliminary objection is to the petition and Notice of Motion dated 23.9.2024 seeking to have the same struck out in limine with costs on a full indemnity basis on grounds that:

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

The petition is fatally and incurably defective and does not raise any constitutional issue for determination by this Honourable Court pursuant to the doctrine of Constitutional avoidance as held by the Court of Appeal in Sumayya Athmani Hassan v Paul Masinde Simidi & another [2019] eKLR:

Paragraph 2 →

Reasoning passage

[17] In conclusion, we find that the alleged unlawful interdiction and termination of a contract of employment was not a constitutional issue and thus the petition did not disclose a cause of action anchored on the Constitution. Accordingly, the petition being incompetent, the court acted in excess of jurisdiction and erred in law in determining the petition. That finding disposes of the entire appeal, including the cross-appeal filed…

Paragraph 5 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

MILIMANI LAW COURTS

ELC PETITION NO. E076 OF 2024

IN THE MATTER OF ARTICLES 22(1), 23(1&3), 31,40,43,165 & 258 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA 2010

AND

IN THE MATTER OF ALLEGED CONTRAVENTION OF ARTICLES 31,40,& 43 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA, 2010

BETWEEN

NDUNG’U GITHENJI………………………………………….…………1ST PETITIONER

NEFERSET HOLDING LIMITED…………………………….………..2ND PETITIONER

AND

KIHINGO VILLAGE (WARIDI GARDENS)

MANAGEMENT LIMITED…………………………….……………….1ST RESPONDENT

FAPCL GROUP LIMITED……………………………………………..2ND RESPONDENT

RULING

1. Before this court for determination is the respondent’s preliminary Objection dated 24.10.2024. The preliminary objection is to the petition and Notice of Motion dated 23.9.2024 seeking to have the same struck out in limine with costs on a full indemnity basis on grounds that:

2. The petition is fatally and incurably defective and does not raise any constitutional issue for determination by this Honourable Court pursuant to the doctrine of Constitutional avoidance as held by the Court of Appeal in Sumayya Athmani Hassan v Paul Masinde Simidi & another [2019] eKLR:

3. The 1st respondent filed a petition directly relying on the provisions of the Constitution for enforcement of contractual rights governed by the Employment Act without seeking a declaration of invalidity of the provisions of the Employment Act or alleging that the remedies provided therein are inadequate. The petition did not raise any question of the interpretation or application of the Constitution.

4. We adopt and uphold the general principle in the persuasive authority in Barbara De Klerk (supra) that where a legislation has been enacted to give effect to a constitutional right, it is not permissible for a litigant to found a cause of action directly on the Constitution without challenging the legislation in question. That principle has been reinforced by the Supreme Court in the Communications Commission case (supra).

5. [17] In conclusion, we find that the alleged unlawful interdiction and termination of a contract of employment was not a constitutional issue and thus the petition did not disclose a cause of action anchored on the Constitution. Accordingly, the petition being incompetent, the court acted in excess of jurisdiction and erred in law in determining the petition. That finding disposes of the entire appeal, including the cross-appeal filed by the 2nd respondent.

6. The petitioners claim is premised on the Land Act, the Sectional Properties Act and Registration Act, 2012 and the same has no constitutional underpinning. The Petitioner is alleged to be guilty of converting a land dispute into a constitutional question, as held in the case of CNM v WM G [2018] eKLR:

7. Courts abhor the practice of parties converting every issue into a constitutional question and filing suits disguised as constitutional Petitions when, in fact, they do not fall anywhere close to a violation of constitutional Rights.

8. Further to the above, the Land Act, Land Registration Act and Sectional Properties Act provide sufficient mechanisms to resolve the dispute in respect of the subject matter.

9. The petition offends and contravenes the provisions of the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules, 2013 and does not meet the test/principle in Anarita Karimi Njeru v The Republic (1976-1980) KLR 1272. The petition has not particularised how the Respondents infringed on his alleged constitutional rights.

10. The court, having been approached as a constitutional court, lacks jurisdiction to hear and determine the Petition as framed, as the same does not disclose any constitutional issues.

11. The petition and the Notice of Motion are scandalous, vexatious, frivolous and an abuse of the Court process. Bullen & Leake and Jacobs Precedents of pleading (12th Edition) at 145 defines frivolous actions as:

“a pleading or action is frivolous when it is without substance or groundless or fanciful and is vexatious when it lacks bona fides and is hopeless or offensive and tends to cause the opposite party unnecessary anxiety, trouble and expense.”

12. Further, the court in Ngokonyo & 2 others v Kenya Posts & Telecommunication Corporation [1992] KLR 567 defined the terms frivolous, vexatious, scandalous and abuse of court process to include;

“Scandalous implies a pleading, which is merely made for the purpose of abusing, or prejudicing the opposite party’s case.... indecent or offensive matters are scandalous and so are words or allegations, which are unnecessary but merely intended.....to slight the opposite party ... frivolous implies petty or lacking in bona fides. Allegations touching on good faith require evidence to establish.... The applicants have also alleged that the defences filed by the respondents are vexatious, that is to say intended to annoy them ...in general terms, abuse of the process of the court by a party arises where the party is guilty of misrepresentation, fraud or by the gaining of an unfair advantage by the use of a rule of procedure. There could be other acts.”

13. Before determining the Preliminary Objection, it is necessary for the Court to first examine the Petition.

14. The background to the present petition is that the 2nd Petitioner is the registered proprietor of House No. 5 situated within Kihingo Village, on land known as L.R. No. 27754, along Kirawa Road, Kitusuru, Nairobi County. The 1st petitioner is a director of the 2nd petitioner and resides in the said house together with his family.

15. The Petitioners contend that, without any lawful justification and in what they describe as an act of impunity and victimisation, the 1st and 2nd respondents have infringed and violated their socio-economic rights, as well as those of the 1st petitioner’s family, guaranteed under Article 43 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010. They allege that the respondents have deliberately withdrawn essential services, including water, sewerage, LPG gas, internet connectivity and gardening services, which are necessary for the peaceful occupation, use and enjoyment of House No. 5.

16. The petitioners further contend that the aforementioned actions by the 1st and 2nd respondents are unlawful and adversely affect the daily subsistence, welfare and general well-being of the 1st petitioner and the other occupants of House No. 5.

17. The petitioners further allege that, in addition to the foregoing, the 1st and 2nd respondents have stationed individuals described as goons, masquerading as “security guards,” at the entrance to Kihingo Village. These individuals allegedly subject the 1st petitioner, his family members, and their vehicles to intrusive searches whenever they enter or leave their residence.

18. It is the petitioners’ contention that the said conduct amounts to intimidation and constitutes a violation of the right to privacy enjoyed by the 1st Petitioner and his family under Article 31 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010.

19. The petitioners further aver that the actions of the 1st and 2nd respondents are calculated to frustrate and exert undue pressure on them in retaliation for their involvement in the protracted court disputes concerning the management and control of the 1st respondent, which is the management company. They contend that the dispute remains pending determination in Judicial Review Case No. 169 of 2023, in which the Petitioners are actively involved.

20. The petitioners seek the following reliefs from this court:

a. A declaration be and is hereby issued that the 1st and 2nd respondents' actions of authorizing the conducting of intrusive personal searches on the person of the 1st Petitioner, members of his family, their vehicles, and visitors attending House Number 5 amounts to a violation of the petitioners’ right to privacy under Article 31 of the Constitution of Kenya,2010.

b. A declaration be and is hereby issued that the 1st and 2nd respondents' actions of cutting off the supply of clean and healthy water from House Number 5, Kihingo Village, and further declining to offer the Petitioners sanitation services, internet services, sewerage services, LPG gas connection, internet connection, and gardening services, which services are crucial for the peaceful use and enjoyment of House Number 5, amount to a violation of the Petitioners’ socio-economic rights under Article 43 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010.

c. A declaration be and is hereby issued that the 1st and 2nd respondents' actions complained of in this Petition violate the

d. petitioners’ right to peaceful use and enjoyment of property and violate Article 40 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010.

e. The 1st and 2nd respondents be and are hereby ordered to pay damages to the Petitioners on account of the violations of the petitioners’ rights to privacy under Article 31, right to property under Article 40, and socio-economic rights under Article 43 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010.

f. An order of prohibition be and is hereby issued prohibiting the 1st and 2nd respondents herein whether by themselves or their employees/agents from in any manner whatsoever harassing/intimidating the 1st Petitioner and his family members by effecting any searches whatsoever on the person of the 1st petitioner, members of his family, their motor vehicles, the 1st petitioner’s workers and visitors of House Number 5 situate at “Kihingo Village” situate at Property LR No. 27754 at Kirawa Road, Kitusuru within Nairobi County.

21. The petitioners relies on articles 31, 40 and 43 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010.

22. In response to the petition, the Respondents filed a replying affidavit sworn by Martin Dias on 29.10.2024.

23. The deponent avers that he is the Group Chief Executive Officer of FAPCL Group and is therefore competent and duly authorised by the 2nd Respondent to swear the affidavit on its behalf.

24. It is deposed that the 2nd Respondent was appointed as the Estate Agent for Kihingo Village (Waridi Gardens) Estate pursuant to a decree issued by the Court following the determination of High Court ELC No. 1225 of 2013, Kifaru Investment Ltd & Others v Kihingo Village (Waridi Gardens) Ltd & Another. A copy of the decree is annexed at pages 1–3, while the Property Management Agreement is exhibited at pages 4–17.

25. It is deposed that the dispute between the Petitioners and the Respondents arises from the Petitioners’ alleged failure to pay service charges in respect of House No. 5 within Kihingo Village (Waridi Gardens) Estate, which allegedly resulted in the disconnection of essential services.

26. It is further deposed that Kihingo Village (Waridi Gardens) Estate comprises 55 shareholders/lessees, all of whom pay the requisite service charges except the Applicants herein. The deponent expresses dismay that, out of the 55 shareholders/lessees in the Estate, the Applicants are the only ones who have failed to pay the service charges.

27. It is further deposed that, following the 2nd Petitioner’s failure and neglect to settle the outstanding service charges, the 2nd Respondent instituted Milimani MCELC No. E261 of 2021, FAPCL Limited v. Neferset Holdings Limited, seeking recovery of the outstanding service charge arrears.

28. It is deposed that the 2nd Petitioner’s Statement of Defence in the said suit was struck out by a ruling delivered on 12.4.2024, and the matter was thereafter scheduled for formal proof on 29.10.2024.

29. It is further deposed that, owing to the 2nd Petitioner’s persistent failure to pay service charges in respect of House No. SL at Kihingo Village (Waridi Gardens) Estate, Kihingo Village (Waridi Gardens) Management Ltd, by a letter dated 4.9.2024, demanded payment of the outstanding service charge arrears. The letter warned that failure to settle the arrears would result in the disconnection or withholding of essential services, including water, internet and electricity. A copy of the said letter is annexed at page 18 of the affidavit.

30. It is deposed that the Management Company of Kihingo Village (Waridi Gardens) Estate is vested with managerial authority to withhold the provision of services to any lessee who fails to pay the charges levied for the services rendered.

31. It is further deposed that, upon the 2nd Petitioner’s failure to comply with the demand notice, the Management Company exercised its managerial authority by disconnecting the electricity, internet, and water supply to House No. SL at Kihingo Village.

32. It is deposed that following the disconnection of essential services, the 1st Petitioner became a nuisance to the residents of Kihingo Village Estate and the Management.

33. It is deposed that the 1st Petitioner brought in goons in his car who were used to break the padlock on the safe box and harass the security at the gate.

34. It is alleged that the 1st Petitioner installed a generator and placed it between House No. 5 and 4, which was used non-stop, emitting excessive noise and smoke (pollutants), thus hindering and affecting the enjoyment of a quiet, clean, healthy and peaceful environment for the Residents of Kihingo Village Estate.

35. It is deposed that the other residents of Kihingo Village (Waridi Gardens) Estate registered their complaints against the 1st petitioner and asked the respondents that an action be taken against him as they could not withstand the noise and the disturbance caused by him. A copy of the complaint is exhibited at page 19.

36. It is deposed that the 2nd respondent, by a letter dated 19.9.2024 addressed to the 2nd petitioner, demanded that the 1st petitioner stop the noise and air pollution within Kihingo Village and adhere to the terms of the lease. A copy of the letter is exhibited at pages 20-21.

37. It is deposed that the 1st Petitioner continued to cause noise and air pollution, prompting the Management to lodge a complaint with the National Environment Management Authority (NEMA) seeking an investigation into the extent of the pollution and appropriate action against the 1st Petitioner. A copy of the complaint dated 26.9.2024 is exhibited at pages 22–25.

38. It is deposed that NEMA acknowledged receipt of the complaint on 3.10.2024 and proceeded to investigate the matter. However, the 1st Respondent allegedly threatened NEMA officers who had visited the Village to investigate the complaint. A copy of NEMA’s acknowledgment letter is exhibited at page 26.

39. It is deposed that the petitioners subsequently approached the Management with a view to proposing a settlement of the outstanding service charge arrears in order to facilitate the restoration of essential services. A copy of the Petitioners’ letter dated 29.9.2024 is exhibited at page 27.

40. It is deposed that the petitioners and the respondents thereafter reached an agreement pursuant to which the Petitioners paid Kshs. 1,856,154/- as part settlement of the outstanding service charge arrears. Copies of the relevant correspondence are exhibited at page 28, while a copy of the cheque and the deposit slip issued by the 1st Petitioner are exhibited at pages 29–30.

41. It is deposed that the essential services were provisionally restored upon payment of the agreed amount, on the condition that the outstanding balance would be settled on or before 31st October 2024, failing which the services would be disconnected again.

42. It is deposed that the petitioner’s allegation that the withdrawal of essential services in respect of House No. 5 was effected without valid reason is false.

43. It is deposed that the disconnection of essential services to House No. 5 resulted from the non-payment of service charges, as explained in the preceding paragraphs.

44. It is deposed that the respondents are responsible for providing security within Kihingo Village (Waridi Gardens) Estate and have, in discharge of this responsibility, consistently engaged security service providers.

45. It is deposed that the 2nd respondent has, among other responsibilities, the duty to ensure the provision of preventive security within the estate, including the protection of sensitive equipment. This responsibility includes procuring additional Tier One security guards and engaging independent security service providers, as may be necessary, to enhance security within the estate.

46. It is deposed that, in the discharge of its duties, the 2nd respondent engaged a private, independent security team to provide security services within Kihingo Village Estate. Copies of identification cards and licences belonging to some of the security personnel are annexed hereto and marked at pages 31–36.

47. It is deposed that the petitioners’ allegation that the respondents have deployed goons within the Estate is wholly unfounded, untrue, and intended to mislead this Honourable Court.

48. It is deposed that Kihingo Village (Waridi Gardens) Estate is an upscale residential estate characterised by high-value properties and established rules and regulations. Accordingly, the deployment of goons within the Estate, as alleged by the petitioners, is inconsistent with the Estate’s established standards and regulations.

49. It is deposed that the 1st petitioner, like all other residents of Kihingo Village Estate, together with their vehicles, is subject to security checks at the entrance gate in accordance with the rules and regulations governing the Estate. Such checks are conducted for the purpose of safeguarding the Estate and ensuring the safety and security of its residents.

50. It is deposed that, at no time has the 1st petitioner or any member of his family been subjected to intimidation by the security personnel, and that they are subjected to the same security procedures applicable to all other residents of the Estate.

51. The deponent deposes that he is aware that the 2nd petitioner filed two other applications in the Chief Magistrates Court at Milimani and at the Environment and Land Court as follows:

a. The 2nd Petitioner filed a Notice of Motion dated 5.9.2024 seeking, among others, a temporary injunction stopping the 2nd respondent from stopping or withdrawing the provision of services at House No. 5 at Kihingo Village (Waridi Gardens) Estate. A copy of the said application and the directions of the Court are exhibited at pages 37-41.

b. The 2nd respondenthas filed Grounds of Objection dated 20.9.2024 and a replying affidavit dated 19.9.2024. Copies of the said Responses are exhibited at pages 42-47.

c. Noting the 2nd Respondent's response to the application dated 5.9.2024, the 2nd Petitioner herein withdrew the said notice of motion on 23.9.2024 when the same came up for hearing before Hon. Lucy Njora. A printout of the Court tracking System is exhibited at pages 48-49

d. The 2nd petitioner also filed a Notice of Motion dated 19.9.2024 in Milimani ELCLA/E137/2024-Neferest Holdings Limited VS FAPCL Limited seeking an order directing the 2nd respondent herein to restore all essential services including water, electricity and internet at House No.5 Kihingo Village and to grant the occupants of House No. 5 unrestricted access to the clubhouse. A copy of the application is exhibited at pages 50-53

e. The court certified the application as urgent but did not issue any interim orders and directed the 2nd Respondent herein to respond to the application. A copy of the Court order is exhibited at page 54

f. The 2nd Respondent filed a Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 24.9.2024 and the replying affidavit dated 27.9.2024. Copies of the same are exhibited at pages 55-60.

g. The 2nd petitioner, having perused the preliminary objection and the replying affidavit, withdrew, on 3.10.2024, the appeal and the notice of motion. Hon. Justice Oguttu Mboya allowed the application for withdrawal with costs. A printout of the Court Tracking System is exhibited at page 61.

52. It is deposed that the petition is fatally and incurably defective and does not raise any constitutional issue for determination by this Honourable Court pursuant to the doctrine of Constitutional avoidance.

53. It is deposed that the Petitioners’ claim is founded on the Land Act, the Sectional Properties Act and the Land Registration Act, 2012, and does not raise any constitutional issues.

54. It is deposed that the Land Act, the Land Registration Act and the Sectional Properties Act provide adequate legal mechanisms for resolving the dispute relating to the subject matter herein.

55. It is deposed that a perusal of the 2nd petitioner’s Notices of Motion filed before the Chief Magistrate’s Court and the Environment and Land Court, together with the reliefs sought therein, demonstrates that the dispute concerns land, payment of service charges and the disconnection of services arising from non-payment of the said charges, none of which, in the circumstances, raises a constitutional issue.

56. It is deposed that this Honourable Court, having been moved in its capacity as a constitutional court, lacks jurisdiction to hear and determine the Notice of Motion and the Petition as framed, as the pleadings do not disclose any constitutional issues warranting the court’s intervention.

57. It is deposed that the petitioners are vexatious litigants who are likely to persist with multiple applications unless restrained by this Honourable Court, particularly noting that the 2nd petitioner has filed three applications within a period of less than eighteen (18) days.

58. It is deposed that the petition and the Notice of Motion are an afterthought, having been instituted with the intention of stealing a march on the respondents, particularly when the petitioners are required to pay Kshs. 1,427,241 on or before 31st October 2024, failing which the services shall be disconnected again in accordance with the agreement dated 1.10.2024.

59. It is deposed that the applicants have approached this Honourable Court with unclean hands and are therefore undeserving of the orders sought, in keeping with the equitable principle that he who comes to equity must do equity.

60. It is deposed that the 1st applicant, being a resident of Kihingo Village (Waridi Gardens) Estate, is bound by the rules and regulations governing the Estate, including the requirement for security checks at the gate.

61. It is deposed that the petitioners cannot expect to continue enjoying the services provided by the respondents without paying for the same, as is the practice among the other 54 residents and lessees of the Estate.

62. It is deposed that the dispute herein concerns land matters relating to the rights, duties and obligations of a lessor, lessee and estate agent, and does not raise any constitutional issues. Consequently, the constitutional remedies sought by the Petitioners are unavailable in the circumstances.

63. This court has taken judicial notice of the previous proceedings and notes that, on 9.10.2024, when the matter came before Hon.Lady Justice Amollo for the hearing of an application dated 23.9.2024. On 20.11.2024, the said application was marked as overtaken by events and/or spent. Thereafter, counsel for the respondents informed the court of his intention to rely on the replying affidavit sworn by Martin Diaz on 24.10.2024 as a response to the petition. Counsel further requested that the Preliminary Objection and the petition be heard together.

64. Court orders are not made in vain. It was not in order for a party to appear ex parte and mislead this court yet there are orders in place made on 9.10.2024 for both the preliminary objection and the petition be canvassed together.

65. Consequently the court declines to determine the preliminary objection separately . Parties are hereby to put in written submission for both the petition and the responses of the preliminary objection by 15.12.2026. Judgment on 20.1.2027.

DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 28th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026.

….………………..

HON. JUSTICE C.K. NZILI

JUDGE

Delivered In the Presence of:

Mr.Mhhizi for the respondents

Mr. Isaac Rene for the petitioners

Julius-CA

Bevalyn N. -Legal Researcher

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder