Land law

Chege v Nyamweru & 3 others [2026] KEELC 7063 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc L Case E070 of 2026
Judgment date
28 October 2026
Judge(s)
Christine Ochieng

Case research

Open case research →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

What is before the Court for determination is the proposed 3rd and 4th Defendants’ Notice of Motion application dated the 5th February 2026 in which they seek the following Orders:

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

Based on the facts before me, while associating myself with the decisions quoted, I find that the Defendants in this suit were duly served hence the Judgement entered herein was regular. Further, since the parties who were in the suit failed to file their respective defences so as to defend the suit and deny ownership of the suit plots, I opine that there was no error apparent on the face of record committed by the Judge in entering…

Paragraph 22 →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC L CASE NO. E070 OF 2026
FORMERLY HCCC NO. 1412 OF 2005 (O.S).

DAVID CHEGE .......................................................... PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

GRACE WANGECHI NYAMWERU ..................... 1ST DEFENDANT

NYONIA GIAKWA HOLDINGS LIMITED .......... 2ND DEFENDANT

AND

MARGARET WANJIRU ONYIMBO &

SIMON WAHINYA ONYIMBO

As the Administrators of the Estate of JACKTONE O.

ANDERA ONYIMBO (DECEASED)..PROPOSED 3RD DEFENDANT

MARGARET WANJIRU ONYIMBO.PROPOSED 4TH DEFENDANT

RULING

1. What is before the Court for determination is the proposed 3rd and 4th Defendants’ Notice of Motion application dated the 5th February 2026 in which they seek the following Orders:

a) Spent.

b) Spent.

c) Spent.

d) That the Judgment of this Honourable Court entered on 30.03.2012 be and is hereby reviewed to the effect that the said Judgment together with all consequential orders be and are hereby set aside/vacated in their entirety.

e) That leave be granted to the Applicants to be joined in these proceedings as the 3rd and 4th Defendants/ Respondents respectively.

f) That this court be pleased to re-open this matter for hearing de-novo and grant unconditional leave to the Applicants to defend this suit.

2. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the proposed 4th Defendant’s supporting affidavit. She avers that she is one of the Administrators of the Estate of her late husband, Jacktone O. Andera Onyimbo, herein referred to as the ‘deceased’, who passed away on 23rd December 1997. She claims that the deceased had acquired the suit plots from the 1st Defendant vide an Agreement for Sale dated 4th April 1996, but his estate was condemned unheard in the suit, contrary to the dictates of natural justice as the Court proceeded with hearing of the matter under the wrong assumption that the suit properties belonged to the 1st Defendant.

3. She contends that in her capacity as an administrator of the deceased’s estate, she undertook the processing of Plot allocation certificates for the suit plots, Plot No. New 130 (Old 147) and Plot No. New 137 & Old 148 in R. No. 8469/4 with the offices of the 2nd Defendant who transferred the suit properties in her name and issued her with two Plot allocation certificates on 28th May 2015 and all that while, she was unaware of these proceedings, thus she began the process of securing Certificates of Title to the suit properties and was issued with two Subdivision Scheme Approval Letters dated 5th November, 2018 from the Director of Land Administration identifying the suit properties as Title Number Nairobi/Block 170/580 and Title Number Nairobi/Block 170/581, arising from a government approval of a subdivision scheme relating to L.R. No. 8459/5 and 6 and subsequently procured Certificates of Lease for the suit plots.

4. She claims that the Plaintiff has filed a fresh suit being Milimani MC ELC E963 of 2025 which seeks, among others, to have the Certificates of title held by the proposed 3rd Defendant and herself cancelled on the strength of the ex parte judgment delivered by the Court in this matter on 30th March 2012. She contends that regardless of the validity of the defense they may have, the ex parte Judgment delivered by this Court prevents them from re-litigating the case thus she urges the Court to vacate it, in its entirety and the proposed Defendants be joined in this suit and allowed to defend the same on merit.

5. She asserts that even though the delay in filing their application may appear inordinate on the face of it, the same is inadvertent and justifiable on account of the fact that they were not aware of the existence of the Judgment in this matter until after they were served with the pleadings in Milimani MC ELC E963 of 2025 in late 2025.

Response

6. The application is opposed by the Plaintiff vide his replying affidavit. He contends that the impugned judgment was lawful and on merit and points out that the proposed 3rd and 4th Defendants were not necessary parties as the ownership of the suit plots did not reflect the deceased’s name and he had no possession/control of the suit plots. Further, that the alleged Certificates of Lease are fraudulent, having been issued in absence of a Certificate of Confirmed Grant and in any case, they did not form part of the assets of the deceased in succession Cause No. 2817 of 1998.

7. He also contends that the 4th and 5th proposed Defendants should not be allowed and neither should a suit that was completed over eleven (11) years ago be revived, as delay defeats justice. He points out that the proposed 4th and 5th Defendants had knowledge of the judgement having filed a plethora of suits that highlighted and made reference to this case including; ELC 9201 OF 2018 (Previously ELC 318 OF 2017-Nairobi, ELC MISC APP 276 OF 2026 –Nairobi, Civil Suit 6627 OF 2015. He urges the Court to consider that he is elderly, about 80 years old and has lived on the suit plots since 1985 while the proposed 4th and 5th Defendants have never had possession.

8. The proposed 4th Defendant filed a further affidavit in response to the Plaintiff’s reply. She reiterates that instead of the Plaintiff suing the deceased as the 1st Defendant in the suit, he sued her sister, the 1st Defendant who had relinquished her interest to him even before the suit was filed thus he is not entitled to an order of adverse possession having sued a party not entitled to possession. She insists that they were not served with summons, pleadings, notice of entry of judgement or decree in the matter.

9. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions.

Submissions

10. The proposed 3rd and 4th Defendants submit that the judgement delivered on 30th March 2012 is irregular as it had the effect of depriving the suit property from its rightful owners without a fair hearing as the estate of the deceased was never joined in the suit as a party. Further, that the 1st Defendant named by the Plaintiff had no interest in the suit plots at the time the suit was instituted thus a claim for adverse possession could not be established against her and therefore the adverse possession proceedings were irregular as the Court committed an error apparent on the face of the record. Further, that the impugned judgment is also irregular by reason of non-joinder which resulted in the deceased’s estate being denied a chance to be heard. They insist that the impugned judgement ought to be set aside as of right, and that the application meets the conditions set out at Order 45 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

11. To buttress their averments, they relied on the following decisions: Mbui v Maranya [1993] KEHC 161(KLR); James Kiiru Mwangi v Gibson Kimaru Mwangi & another [2021] eKLR; Macfoy v United Africa Co. Ltd [1961] 3 ALL ER, 1169; Mungai v Gachui & another [2005] KEHC 3023 (KLR); GO tv Kenya Ltd v Roya Media Services Ltd & 2 others [2015] eKLR; National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Ndungu Njau [1997] eKLR; and James Kanyiita Nderitu & another v Marios Philotas Ghikas & another [2016] KECA 470 (KLR).

12. On his part, the Plaintiff submits that the impugned judgement was merited, he pursued an adverse possession claim against the registered owner named who was the 1st Defendant. Further, that a Certificate of title was irregularly issued to the deceased in 2005 yet he passed away 1997, adding that no Certificate of Grant was exhibited to show the suit plots formed parts of the assets of the deceased. He also reiterates that the proposed Defendants had knowledge of the impugned judgement but failed to take necessary steps to set it aside and having slept on their rights, they cannot come to equity as it aids the vigilant not the indolent. Further, that having delivered judgement in the suit, the Court is functus officio.

13. To buttress his averments the Plaintiff relied on the following authorities: Dina management Limited v County Government of Mombasa & 4 others [2021] eKLR; Criticos v Attorney General & 7 others (Civil Application 276 of 2020) [2026] KECA 249; Leading way consultants Ltd v Saab [2025] EWCA CIV 582; Grieve v County Government of Machakos [2023] eKLR, and Kenya Broadcasting Corporation v Geoffrey Wakio [2019] eKLR.

Analysis and Determination

14. Upon consideration of the instant Notice of Motion application including the respective affidavits as well as the rivalling submissions, the issue for determination is whether the proposed 3rd and 4th Defendants have demonstrated sufficient cause for setting aside/review of this Court’s judgement of 30th March 2012 and if they should be joined in the suit.

15. Judgement was entered in this suit on 30th March 2012 by Hon. Lady Justice Martha Koome, (as she then was), for the Plaintiff herein who had sought ownership of Plot numbers 130 and 137 being part of land formerly known as LR No. 8469/4 and of title no. LR No. 36766 through adverse possession. The proposed 3rd and 4th Defendants contend that the said judgement is irregular and ought to be reviewed and set aside for having been entered without affording them an opportunity to be heard, contrary to the principles of natural justice. They further contend that the said judgement was entered in error on the face of the record as the deceased acquired the suit plots from the 1st Defendant through sale agreements dated 4th April 1996, even bef0re the suit was instituted thus the Plaintiff’s claim for adverse possession against the 1st Defendant was improperly instituted. They insist that the proposed 4th Defendant obtained Allocation Certificates and Certificates of Lease over the suit properties in her capacity as an administrator of the deceased’s estate and that all this time, they were unaware of the proceedings and the resultant judgment until late 2025, when they were served with pleadings in Milimani MC ELC E963 of 2025, in which the Plaintiff seeks cancellation of their titles on the strength of the impugned judgment. They argue that the impugned judgment contains an error apparent on the face of the record, warranting review. They also seek to be joined as Defendants, and the reopening of the suit for hearing de novo.

16. On his part, the Plaintiff insists that the impugned judgment was merited, having arisen from a claim for adverse possession instituted against the 1st Defendant, who was the registered owner of the suit plots. Further, that the proposed Defendants were not necessary parties to the proceedings since the deceased neither held title to nor had possession of the suit plots. He also avers that the Certificates of Lease allegedly issued to the proposed Defendants were fraudulently obtained without a Certificate of Confirmed Grant and that they were not listed among the deceased’s assets. He also claims that the proposed Defendants had knowledge of the suit and that he has been in occupation of the suit properties since 1985 and argues that the Court is functus officio, and there is no justification for reopening a concluded suit.

17. On the first issue, the proposed Defendants contend that the impugned judgement is irregular as they were not accorded an opportunity to be heard, thus it should be set aside as of right. The Plaintiff has argued that they were not parties in the suit thus they cannot claim to have been excluded. The Court of Appeal in James Kanyiita Nderitu & Another vs Ghikas & Anor (Civil Appeal 6 of 2015) [2016] KECA 470 (KLR) 17 June 2016) (Judgement), stated that:

“……In an irregular default judgment, on the other hand; judgment will have been entered against a defendant who has not been served or properly served with summons to enter appearance. In such a situation, the default judgment is set aside ex debito justiae, as a matter of right. The court does not even have to be moved by a party once it comes to its notice that the judgment is irregular; it can set aside the default judgment on its own motion….”

18. On setting aside of a judgement, in the case of Shah v Mbogo and Another [1967] EA 116 it was held that:

“This discretion is intended to be exercised to avoid injustice or hardship resulting from accident, inadvertence, or excusable mistake or error, but is not designed to assist a person who has deliberately sought, whether by evasion or otherwise, to obstruct or delay the course of justice.”

19. Further, in the case of Wachira Karani v Bildad Wachira [2016] eKLR Mativo J (as he then was) held that:

“Sufficient cause is thus the cause for which the defendant could not be blamed for his absence. Sufficient cause is a question of fact and the court has to exercise its discretion in the varied and special circumstances in the case at hand. There cannot be a straight-jacket formula of universal application. Thus, the defendant must demonstrate that he was prevented from attending court by a sufficient cause...”

20. While in the case of CMC Holdings Limited -vs- Nzioki [2004] 1 KLR 173, it was held that:

“In law, the discretion that a Court of law has, in

deciding whether or not to set aside ex-parte order was meant to ensure that a litigant does not suffer injustice or hardship as a result of among other things an excusable mistake or error.  It would not be proper use of such a discretion if the Court turns its back to a litigant who clearly demonstrates such an excusable mistake, inadvertence, accident or error.’

21. It is trite that setting aside of judgement is discretionary but the Court has to consider sufficient cause proffered by the Applicant, before proceeding to do so. On perusal of the Court record, I note on the 27th November, 2009, the 1st Defendant appeared in Court and sought for time to file her response to the Originating Summons but she failed to do so hence the matter proceeded for hearing and ex parte judgement was entered against the Defendants on the 30th March, 2012. The Applicants have not denied that they had filed previous suits in respect to the suit plots.

22. Based on the facts before me, while associating myself with the decisions quoted, I find that the Defendants in this suit were duly served hence the Judgement entered herein was regular. Further, since the parties who were in the suit failed to file their respective defences so as to defend the suit and deny ownership of the suit plots, I opine that there was no error apparent on the face of record committed by the Judge in entering judgement in favour of the Plaintiff.

23. I note the proposed Defendants have not even availed an affidavit from the 2nd Defendant to confirm that the deceased owned the suit plots emanating from the mother title which was in their name. In my view, since the Plaintiff has been in occupation of the suit plots from 1985 and with a claim on adverse possession being tied to land, noting that the impugned judgement sought to be set aside was delivered fourteen (14) years ago, I opine that the proposed Defendants can file a suit to claim their rights as against the Plaintiff instead of seeking to set aside a judgement too late in the day. Further, I find that were was no error apparent on the face of record, to warrant review as envisaged under section 80 and Order 45 of the Civil Procedure Rules. It is my considered view that they have not offered plausible reasons to warrant the setting aside of the impugned Judgement. In the foregoing, I will decline to set aside the said judgement.

24. On joinder of the proposed Defendants to this suit post judgement, I wish to make reference to Order 1 Rule 10 (2) of the Civil Procedure Rules which gives this Court discretion to join a party. In Everton Coal Enterprises Limited v Karanja & 5 others (Application E026 of 2023) [2023] KESC 98 (KLR) (10 November 2023) (Ruling), the Supreme Court while dealing with the issue of joinder post judgement, held that:

“Strictly speaking, though joined, the applicant was not a party to “the proceedings” in the Court of Appeal having been joined post-judgment, yet a joinder contemplates a situation where proceedings are still pending before the court and in terms of rule 5(d)(ii) of the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules, 2013 (Mutunga Rules) which is in pari materia with order 1 rule 10(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules, a party will only be added to on-going proceedings in order to enable the court adjudicate fully upon and settle all the questions involved in the particular proceedings before it. 26. Noting that the original dispute between the 1st to 4th respondents and the 5th and 6th respondents having been settled in a judgment rendered on July 29, 2016, there were no proceedings to which the applicant could properly join four years later on June 5, 2020, when the ruling by the first bench of the Court of Appeal was rendered. This question has been settled in a long thread of past decisions. For example, in JMK v MWM & another [2015] eKLR, the court stressed that; “…an application for joinder of parties can be filed only in pending proceedings; that the power of the court to add a party to proceedings can be exercised at any stage of the proceedings, either before, or during the trial; and that it is only when a suit or proceeding has been finally disposed of and there is nothing more to be done that the rule becomes inapplicable”. See also the Court of Appeal judgment in Kenya Airport Authority v Mitu- Bell Welfare Society & 2 others [2016] eKLR on the finality of a judgment as a decision of a court resolving all the contested issues and settling the rights and liabilities of the parties before it and our decision in University of Eldoret & another v Hosea Sitienei & 3 others, SC Application No 8 of 2020; [2020] eKLR emphasizing the finality of the litigation process. Emphasis mine

25. Based on the facts as presented while relying on the Supreme Court decision that is binding on this Court, I find that since the proposed Defendants did not participate in the proceedings culminating in the impugned judgement sought to be set aside, even if they had a stake in the matter, noting that there are already pending proceedings in respect to the disputed plots in the lower Court, it has come too late in the day. I opine that it should advance the arguments raised herein in the pending proceedings in the subordinate Court. Further, it is trite that a party can only be joined to on-going proceedings to enable the Court adjudicate fully upon and settle all the questions involved in proceedings before it, which is not the position herein. In the foregoing, I am unable to join them in these proceedings.

26. In the foregoing, I find the instant Notice of Motion application dated 5th February 2026 unmerited and will dismiss it but make no Order as to costs.

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 28TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026

CHRISTINE OCHIENG

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Mwaura for Plaintiff/Respondent

Wachira for Proposed 3rd & 4th Defendants Applicants

Court Assistant: Joan

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder