Background
By a Memorandum of Claim dated 18th January 2024 and filed on even date, the Claimant sued the respondent seeking the following reliefs:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Judgment for the Claimant. The summary dismissal was declared unfair and unlawful. He was awarded Kshs. 591,500, subject to statutory deductions: Kshs. 273,000 compensation, Kshs. 91,000 notice pay, Kshs. 182,000 unpaid commission, and Kshs. 45,500 leave pay. The Respondent must issue a certificate of service forthwith and pay costs and interest at court rates from the judgment date.
59. The court has found that the dismissal of the Claimant was unfair and unlawful within the meaning of Section 45 of the Employment Act. The court has further found that the Claimant is entitled to the following reliefs and accordingly to enter judgment for the Claimant as follows:
Paragraph 59 →
Total: Kshs. 591,500
Passage 134 →
h) The Claimant is awarded costs of the suit and interest at court rates from the date of this judgment.
Passage 137 →
Held. Decided for the Claimant. The dismissal was unfair and unlawful: the Respondent did not prove valid and fair reasons for dismissal, including the alleged failure to reconcile distributor accounts and non-attendance at the alleged 6 November meeting. It also failed to follow a fair disciplinary procedure: no show-cause letter or disciplinary hearing was provided, and the 31 October meeting was convened to address the Claimant’s grievances, without prior notice of charges or the right to be accompanied.
Ratio. Under sections 45 and 41 of the Employment Act, an employer must prove valid and fair reasons for dismissal and procedural fairness. For misconduct dismissal, the employee must be informed of the contemplated grounds, afforded an opportunity to respond with a fellow employee or representative of choice, and have those representations considered before the decision. Failure to prove the alleged misconduct and to provide that process makes the dismissal unfair.
Issue
a) Whether summary dismissal was unfair and unlawful.
Passage 58 →
Held
45. Having found that the Respondent failed to produce the policy on weekly reconciliation, failed to produce the email calling for the meeting on 6th November 2023, and failed to rebut the Claimant's evidence that the distributors had confirmed that there were no pending reconciliations, I must hold that the Respondent has failed to prove that the reason for the summary dismissal of the Claimant was valid and fair.
Paragraph 45 →
51. The claimant, RW1 and RW3 confirmed in evidence that no disciplinary hearing was conducted before the summary dismissal of the claimant. They all agreed that the meeting held on 31st October 2023 was to discuss the grievances raised by the claimant on 26th October 2023. The claimant and contended that he was not notified of any charges against him prior to the said meeting and he was not informed of his right to be accompanied to the meeting by an employee of his own choice. RW1 also admitted that there was no prior notice to the Claimant that the distributors’ complaint would be discussed during the meeting of 31st October 2023. Consequently, the court holds that the respondent has failed to prove that the summary dismissal of the claimant was done in accordance with a fair procedure.
Paragraph 51 →
52. Having found that the reasons for the summary dismissal of the claimant were not valid, and that fair procedure was not followed, the court concludes that the dismissal was unfair and unlawful within the meaning of section 45 of the Employment Act.
Paragraph 52 →
Ratio
47. Section 45(2)(c) of the Employment Act the places on the employer the burden of proving that the termination of his employees contract of employment was done in accordance with above procedure. The employer must prove that he explained the reason for intended termination and accorded the employee a fair opportunity to defend himself in an oral hearing. The said proceedings are to be conducted in the presence of another employee of the accused employee’s choice. The representations made in defence must be considered before the decision to terminate is reached.
Paragraph 47 →
“(1) Subject to section 42(1), an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee, on the grounds of misconduct, poor performance or physical incapacity explain to the employee, in a language the employee understands, the reason for which the employer is considering termination and the employee shall be entitled to have another employee or a shop floor union representative of his choice present during this explanation.
Passage 103 →
(2) Notwithstanding any other provision of this Part, an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee or summarily dismissing an employee under section 44(3) or (4) hear and consider any representations which the employee may on the grounds of misconduct or poor performance, and the person, if any, chosen by the employee within subsection (1), make.”
Passage 104 →
Held. Decided substantially for the Claimant. He was entitled to a declaration of unfair and unlawful dismissal; Kshs. 91,000 in lieu of notice; Kshs. 273,000 compensation (three months’ gross salary); Kshs. 182,000 unpaid August and October 2023 commission; Kshs. 45,500 for 15 leave days; and a certificate of service. The aggregate award was Kshs. 591,500, subject to statutory deductions, plus costs and interest at court rates from judgment.
Ratio. Following an unfair termination, the court may award notice pay and compensation under section 49. The compensation amount was set at three months’ salary in view of the Claimant’s senior position, approximately one year of service, and the Respondent’s failure to prove misconduct. The commission and leave claims succeeded because the Respondent did not prove the alleged payments were received.
Issue
b) Whether the Claimant is entitled to the prayers sought.
Passage 59 →
Held
59. The court has found that the dismissal of the Claimant was unfair and unlawful within the meaning of Section 45 of the Employment Act. The court has further found that the Claimant is entitled to the following reliefs and accordingly to enter judgment for the Claimant as follows:
Paragraph 59 →
b) Compensation for unfair termination Kshs. 273,000
Passage 130 →
h) The Claimant is awarded costs of the suit and interest at court rates from the date of this judgment.
Passage 137 →
Ratio
54. The Claimant prayed for compensation of equaling 12 months' gross salary for the unfair termination plus one-month salary in lieu of notice. Clause 10.1 of his employment contract provided for one month termination notice. Consequently, I award him Kshs. 91,000 as payment in lieu of notice.
Paragraph 54 →
55. As regards compensatory damages, I award the claimant 3 months gross salary as compensation for the unfair termination considering the senior position he was serving, the short service of approximately one year, and the fact that the respondent did not prove any misconduct that led to the dismissal. Consequently, he will get Kshs.91,000 x 3 = Khs. 273,000.
Paragraph 55 →
56. The Claimant prayed for unpaid commission for the month of August and October 2023 in the sum of Kshs. 182,000. The Respondent submitted that the Claimant was paid his commission for August and October 2023, as evidenced by the Claimant's final payslip at page 50 of the Respondent's Supplementary List and Bundle of Documents dated 3rd December 2025. The Claimant denied receipt of the sum contained in the payslip of November 2023. Consequently, I award the sum of Kshs. 182,000 as prayed.
Paragraph 56 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
By a Memorandum of Claim dated 18th January 2024 and filed on even date, the Claimant sued the respondent seeking the following reliefs:
Paragraph 1 →Having considered the pleadings, evidence and submissions, it is clear that the claimant was employed by the respondent and he was later summarily dismissed from service for gross misconduct. The main issues for determination are:
Paragraph 33 →Whether the respondent proved valid and fair reasons for summarily dismissing the claimant, whether it followed a fair procedure, and whether the claimant was entitled to the pleaded remedies.
Lincoln Mukogosi Karani was employed as a Sales Representative from about 4 July 2022 on permanent and pensionable terms, earning Kshs. 91,000 monthly plus commissions. After rescinding a June 2023 resignation, he transferred from Nairobi to Kisumu. He raised…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT
NAIROBI
(O N Makau J on 14th October 2026)
CAUSE NO. E049 OF 2024
LINCOLN MUKOGOSI KARANI .………..………………….…….. CLAIMANT
VERSUS
WESTSIDE DISTILLERS AND VITNERS (E.A) LIMITED …..RESPONDENT
JUDGMENT
Introduction
1. By a Memorandum of Claim dated 18th January 2024 and filed on even date, the Claimant sued the respondent seeking the following reliefs:
a) A declaration and finding that the termination of the Claimant's employment with the Respondent was unlawful and unfair.
b) Special damages of Kshs. 1,410,500/- as pleaded in paragraph 20 of the Memorandum of Claim, made up of:
(i) Compensation for unfair termination equaling 12 months’ salary……………………………………………………Kshs.1,092,000
(ii) One month salary in lieu of notice……….…Kshs. 91,000
(iii) Unpaid commission for August and October 2023
being …………………………………………….….Kshs.182,000
(iv) Leave for one year, 2023 ……………………Kshs. 91,000
c) Costs of the suit.
d) Interest on (b) and (c) above at court rates from the date of filing this claim until payment in full.
e) Certificate of service.
f) Any other relief that the Honourable Court may deem fit to grant in the interest of justice.
2. The Respondent filed a Response to the Memorandum of Claim dated 3rd May 2024 in which it admitted that it employed the claimant as a Sales Representative under permanent and pensionable terms earning a gross monthly basic salary of Kshs. 91,000/- with additional benefits and monthly commissions. It further admitted that it dismissed the claimant on 7th November 2023 but averred that the same was fair and lawful, and the claimant is not entitled to the reliefs sought. Therefore it prayed for the suit to be dismissed with costs.
3. The suit went to full hearing where both sides adduced evidence and thereafter filed written submissions.
Facts of the case
4. The Claimant was employed by the Respondent on or about 4th July 2022, as a Sales Representative on permanent and pensionable terms. His gross monthly basic salary was Kshs. 91,000/-, plus additional benefits including performance-based monthly commissions not exceeding his monthly basic salary.
5. The respondent’s name changed from Best Kenya Spirits Limited to Westside Distillers and Vintners (EA) Limited, but the terms of employment for the claimant remained unchanged. The claimant diligently performed his duties and received commissions regularly.
6. On 22nd June 2023, the claimant tendered a resignation to pursue other opportunities, but by another email dated 28th June 2023, he rescinded the resignation. By a letter dated 30th June 2023, the employer accepted the rescission and reinstated the claimant but since the position in Nairobi had been filled after the resignation, he asked to go to Kisumu under the same terms and he accepted.
7. From July to September 2023, the claimant wrote several emails highlighting some grievances including non-payment of relocation allowance following his transfer to Kisumu, failure to approve leave and paternity leave, non-payment of commissions and incentives. On 26th October 2023, he formally registered the above grievances via email and added another grievance of shortage of staffing of the Sales department while increasing performance targets.
8. On 31st October 2023, the claimant was summoned to a meeting to discuss his grievances and some complaints raised against him by some distributors. On 7th November 2023, the respondent summarily dismissed him vide a letter dated 6th November 2023 on allegations of insubordination, negligence and careless and improper performance of duties.
9. Subsequently, the claimant sued the respondent contending that the dismissal was unfair and unlawful as there was no valid reason to justify the same, and he was not accorded fair hearing before the dismissal. He further averred that the dismissal was retaliatory because it was done after he raised grievances about his rights as an employee.
Evidence
10. The Claimant testified as CW1 and stated that he is currently working for Kapa Oil. He then adopted his Witness Statement dated 18th January 2024 as his evidence in chief and produced 18 documents in the List dated 18th January 2024 as exhibits. His evidence aligned with the above facts. He urged the court to grant the reliefs sought in his Memorandum of Claim.
11. On cross-examination he confirmed that he was employed as a Sales Representative at a salary of Kshs. 91,000. He further stated that he had many responsibilities including supporting distributors, monitoring stock levels at the distributors, and doing reconciliations. He stated that reconciliation with distributors was done, but there was no rule that it be done weekly.
12. He confirmed that he resigned after one year to pursue other opportunities, but the resignation was received and he rescinded it. He stated that his resignation was rescinded less than four days after a discussion with his senior. He confirmed that the rescission was accepted and he was posted to Kisumu. He stated that he was entitled to a relocation allowance, and the same was discussed before the relocation.
13. He confirmed that in Kisumu, he was dealing with four distributors and was to do reconciliation with the distributors. He was allocated a vehicle with a tracking system and was to operate in four counties.
14. He further stated that on 26th October 2023 he was in Nairobi and his manager was aware. He had applied for leave in the system and also sent a text to him. He also wrote an email on 26th October 2023 about his flights and went to the office where the CEO told him to surrender the car and the keys.
15. A meeting was fixed for 30th October 2023 but he received the invitation late. He confirmed that he wrote an email on 27th October 2023 confirming that he was aware of a meeting on 30th October 2023, but he never attended the meeting. He contended that he communicated his unavailability by phone. He was then told not to report to Kisumu and his colleague was placed in charge.
16. On 31st October 2023, there was a meeting where some of his grievances were discussed and responses were given. The management never raised any issue against him during the meeting, save for a complaint of reconciliation by Jolijan and Divai distributors. However, he stated that all the reconciliations and leave were done on the company system and he no longer had access.
17. The Claimant further stated that after the meeting on 31st October 2023, he was to hold a meeting with his manager to discuss the said complaint, but on 6th November 2023, he was dismissed. On 15th November 2023, he completed handing over but he was not paid his final dues. He confirmed that his payslip for November 2023, indicated an item for commission.
18. On re-examination, the Claimant stated that the reason for dismissal was failure to do reconciliation with distributors' accounts. He could collect goods from distributors and reconcile later. Some customers could take a week to reconcile. What was important was reconciliation by the end of the month. He contended that there was no issue with reconciliation because he was still dealing with the customers.
19. He clarified that the meeting held on 31st October 2023 was to discuss his grievances but did not constitute a disciplinary hearing. He further clarified that the issue of reconciliation was raised during the meeting, but that was not a disciplinary hearing since he was not accompanied by another employee to discuss the issues raised by the employer. He contended that the meeting on 31st October 2023, did not address his grievances as it turned to giving directions rather than addressing them.
20. The Respondent called three witnesses. RW1 was Fred Muga, the respondent’s National Sales Manager. He adopted his Witness Statement dated 30th January 2025 as his evidence in chief and produced 20 documents in the list dated 11th February 2025 and 2 documents in the list dated 3rd December 2025 as exhibits.
21. On cross-examination he admitted that the Claimant raised grievances on 26th October 2023 and on 28th October 2023, the General Manager invited him for a meeting to discuss his grievances. The meeting was held on 31st October 2023 to discuss the grievances but also a second agenda on distributor weekly reconciliation. The second agenda emanated from complaints by Jolijan and Divai which later formed one of the reasons for the dismissal.
22. He further admitted that there was no prior notice to the Claimant that the distributor complaint would be discussed in the meeting of 31st October 2023. He also admitted that the meeting was not a disciplinary hearing and that is why he was not asked to come with another employee.
23. He confirmed that the complaint from Divai was vide email dated 30th October 2023 on Page 43 of the Respondent's bundle, and it demanded settlement of money owed before the Claimant resigned. Page 52 states that Jolijan and Divai had a complaint of non-reconciliation. He confirmed that there was a rumour about the Claimant's resignation.
24. He admitted that the Claimant's responses during the meeting were never captured in the minutes. He further admitted that what is written there was not from the claimant but his own conclusions. He also admitted that upon clearance, it was confirmed that any unreconciled figures were to be blamed on the marketing department but not the Claimant.
25. On re-examination, RW1 reiterated that the issue of reconciliation was one of the reasons for the Claimant's dismissal. He admitted that the issue of Divai and Jolijan was raised after rumours that the Claimant had resigned and they wanted to be sure that their money was safe.
26. RW2 was Linda Achieng, the respondent’s Human Resource Executive, who adopted her Witness Statement dated 30th January 2025 as her evidence in chief. She also adopted the exhibits already produced by RW1 as part of her evidence.
27. On cross-examination, RW2 stated that she had never met the Claimant since she was not working for the Respondent on 6th November 2023 when he was dismissed. Admitted that she was not involved in the Claimant's disciplinary process and that her evidence was based on what was availed to her by the employer. She confirmed that Human Resource function during the material time, had been outsourced. Finally, she admitted that she had no proof that any disciplinary hearing was conducted for the Claimant.
28. RW3 was Wycliffe Saduma, the Respondent's Managing Director, who was the General Manager during the Claimant's exit. He adopted his Witness Statement dated 30th January 2025 as his evidence in chief. He also relied on the 22 exhibits produced by RW1 as part of his evidence.
29. On cross-examination, he confirmed that one of the reasons for the dismissal of the Claimant was failure to reconcile two distributors' accounts, and the other reason was failure to attend the meeting on 6th November 2023. He contended that there was an email calling the claimant for the meeting on 6th November 2023, but it was not produced as an exhibit. He was not aware whether the Claimant was served with any show cause letter.
30. He further admitted there was no disciplinary hearing accorded to the claimant on the reconciliation complaint by the distributors. He confirmed that the meeting on 31st October 2023 was held to discuss the Claimant's grievances but some agenda for the employer was added. He also admitted that the responses by the Claimant were not captured. He confirmed that he never attended the meeting on 31st October 2023 although his name appeared in the minutes. He contended that he was only briefed on what transpired and got the minutes.
31. He admitted that there were commissions paid to employees who met targets. He confirmed that the Claimant met targets severally and he was paid commission. He stated that the claimant was a top performer while in Nairobi, but when he moved to Kisumu, some distributors complained that the Claimant had collected goods and failed to reconcile the accounts. He contended that they could not just deduct his salary instead of termination. He admitted that the summary dismissal letter refers to a policy on weekly reconciliation, but he had not produced the policy in court.
32. On re-examination, he stated that the Claimant was invited to a meeting by the consultant through a phone call but he missed. RW3 confirmed that he never attended the meeting on 31st October 2023 to discuss the Claimant's grievances. He reiterated that they could not just set off the distributor's complaint from the Claimant's salary because there were many other allegations and issues raised against him.
Issues for determination
33. Having considered the pleadings, evidence and submissions, it is clear that the claimant was employed by the respondent and he was later summarily dismissed from service for gross misconduct. The main issues for determination are:
a) Whether summary dismissal was unfair and unlawful.
b) Whether the Claimant is entitled to the prayers sought.
Unfair and unlawful dismissal
34. The Claimant submitted that the termination of his employment was unfair and unlawful, while the Respondent maintained that the termination was fair and lawful. Section 45 (1) and (2) of the Employment Act provides that:
“(1) No employer shall terminate the employment of an employee unfairly.
(2) A termination of employment by an employer is unfair if the employer fails to prove:
(a) that the reason for the termination is valid;
(b) that the reason for the termination is a fair reason—
(i) related to the employee’s conduct, capacity or compatibility; or
(ii) based on the operational requirements of the employer; and
(c) that the employment was terminated in accordance with fair procedure.”
35. The above provision summarizes the legal threshold of an unfair termination as the employer’s failure to prove a valid reason for justifying termination, and that fair procedure was followed. The provision emanates from the ILO Convention 158 on termination of employment. Article 4 and 7 of the Convention stated as follows:
“Article 4 – the employment of a worker shall not be terminated unless there is a valid reason for such termination connected with the capacity or conduct or the operational requirement requirements of the undertaking, establishment or service.
Article 7 – The employment of a worker shall not be terminated for reason related to the worker’s conduct or performance before he is provided an opportunity to defend himself against the allegations made, unless the employer cannot be expected to provide this opportunity.”
36. Courts in our country have upheld the above International Labour Standard in a legion of decisions. In the case of Pius Machafu Isindu v Lavington Security Guards Limited [2017] KECA 225 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held that:
"There can be no doubt that the Act, which was enacted in 2007, places heavy legal obligations on employers in matters of summary dismissal for breach of employment contract and unfair termination involving breach of statutory law. The employer must prove the reasons for termination/dismissal (section 43); prove the reasons are valid and fair (section 45); prove that the grounds are justified (section 47(5), amongst other provisions. A mandatory and elaborate process is then set up under section 41 requiring notification and hearing before termination. The Act also provides for most of the procedures to be followed thus obviating reliance on the Evidence Act and the Civil Procedure Act/Rules. Finally, the remedies for breach set out under section 49 are also fairly onerous and generous to the employee. But all that accords with the main object of the Act as appears in the preamble: 'to declare and define the fundamental rights of employees, to provide basic conditions of employment of employees.' Those provisions are a mirror image of their constitutional underpinning in Article 41 which governs rights and fairness in labour relations."
Reasons for the claimant’s dismissal
37. The reasons for the dismissal of the claimant was communicated vide the summary dismissal letter dated 6th November 2023 which is copied below:
“6th October, 2023
Lincoln Karani
Nairobi
RE: SUMMARY DISMISSAL
We refer to the meeting held on 31st October, 2023 where you admitted to have not reconciled with the Distributors assigned to you weekly as per the policy following the Distributors complains which is a violation of the responsibility and trust that the company has placed on you in your capacity as a sales representative.
On the same date you were informed to evaluate the customer complaints with the National Sales Manager for closure but left before doing so, subsequently you have been invited for meetings including yesterday 6th November, 2023 to discuss the concerns and close on the matter but you didn’t show up despite not executing roles assigned to you as a Sales Representative since you returned the company car on 26th October, 2023.
After careful consideration of the above, the management has reached the conclusion that this is insubordination, negligent, careless, and improper performance of your duties which is deemed to be gross misconduct.
Based on the above, the company has reached the decision to summarily dismiss you from employment with effect from 7th November, 2023.
Upon clearance and handover of all company property in your possession you will be paid your terminal dues as follows:
(a) Days worked.
(b) Unutilized leave days if any
The above shall be subject to statutory deductions, amounts owed to distributors and any other deductions applicable.
You will also be issued with a certificate of service.
Yours faithfully,
Signed
Wycliffe Saduma
General Manager”
38. The reason cited for the summary dismissal of the claimant was gross misconduct in the form of insubordination, negligence, careless and improper performance of his duties. The claimant denied the alleged misconduct and maintained that he was a staler performer. The respondent agreed that the claimant was an excellent performer and had earned commission severally until he was posted to Kisumu.
39. RW3 testified that one of the reasons for the dismissal was reconciliation of two distributors' accounts, and the other reason was failure by the Claimant to attend the second meeting on 6th November 2023.
40. As regards failure to do weekly reconciliation of distributors accounts, the Claimant denied the allegations and testified that he had a good working relationship with the distributors. He contended that there was no policy for weekly reconciliation and that only monthly reconciliations were required.
41. The Claimant produced email correspondence from Divai Distributors dated 3rd November 2023 (Claimant's Exhibit 11) and email correspondence dated 1st November 2023 (Claimant's Exhibit 13), which confirmed that the accounts were in order. The Claimant also produced the Employee Clearance Form dated 7th November 2023 (Claimant's Exhibit 17), which stated that the sampling stocks for Jolijan Distributors were to be reconciled by the Marketing Department and that the Claimant did not owe marketing anything as at 15th November 2023 when he was released.
42. The respondent’s witnesses confirmed that the complaint of unreconciled accounts by Jolijan and Divai were raised following rumours that the claimant had resigned. The witnesses further did not produce the weekly reconciliation policy referred to in the dismissal letter. RW3 testified that reconciliation of two the distributors' accounts was one of the reasons cited for the dismissal of the claimant. However, considering the evidence by the claimant, specifically exhibit 11, 13 and 17, the court finds that the respondent has failed to prove the alleged negligent, careless and improper performance of duties by the claimant, on a balance of probability.
43. Having considered the evidence on record and the finding above that the Respondent did not produce as an exhibit the policy on weekly reconciliation of distributor accounts, and further failed to produce evidence to prove that the claimant was invited to the meeting he allegedly failed to attend on 6th November 2023, the Court holds that the respondent has failed to prove that the reasons cited for the summary dismissal of the claimant in the letter dated 6th November 2023 were valid.
44. That RW3 admitted that the summary dismissal letter refers to a policy on weekly reconciliation, but he had not filed it. RW1 admitted that the Claimant's responses were never captured in the minutes and that upon clearance, it was confirmed that any unreconciled figures were to be blamed on the marketing department but not the Claimant.
45. Having found that the Respondent failed to produce the policy on weekly reconciliation, failed to produce the email calling for the meeting on 6th November 2023, and failed to rebut the Claimant's evidence that the distributors had confirmed that there were no pending reconciliations, I must hold that the Respondent has failed to prove that the reason for the summary dismissal of the Claimant was valid and fair.
The procedure followed
46. Section 41 of the Employment Act sets out the following mandatory procedure for terminating an employee’s contract of employment:-
“(1) Subject to section 42(1), an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee, on the grounds of misconduct, poor performance or physical incapacity explain to the employee, in a language the employee understands, the reason for which the employer is considering termination and the employee shall be entitled to have another employee or a shop floor union representative of his choice present during this explanation.
(2) Notwithstanding any other provision of this Part, an employer shall, before terminating the employment of an employee or summarily dismissing an employee under section 44(3) or (4) hear and consider any representations which the employee may on the grounds of misconduct or poor performance, and the person, if any, chosen by the employee within subsection (1), make.”
47. Section 45(2)(c) of the Employment Act the places on the employer the burden of proving that the termination of his employees contract of employment was done in accordance with above procedure. The employer must prove that he explained the reason for intended termination and accorded the employee a fair opportunity to defend himself in an oral hearing. The said proceedings are to be conducted in the presence of another employee of the accused employee’s choice. The representations made in defence must be considered before the decision to terminate is reached.
48. In the case of Anthony Mkala Chitavi v Malindi Water & Sewerage Company Ltd [2013] KEELRC 920 (KLR), Justice Stephen Radido elucidated the ingredients of procedural fairness as follows:-
"63. And what does section 41 of the Act require. The first observation is that the responsibility established is upon the shoulders of the employer. In a claim for unfair termination or wrongful dismissal on the grounds of misconduct, poor performance or physical incapacity, the employer is duty bound to comply with the requirements of section 41.
64. The ingredients of procedural fairness as I understand it within the Kenyan situation is that the employer should inform the employee as to what charges the employer is contemplating using to dismiss the employee. This gives a concomitant statutory right to be informed to the employee.
65. Secondly, it would follow naturally that if an employee has a right to be informed of the charges he has a right to a proper opportunity to prepare and to be heard and to present a defence/state his case in person, writing or through a representative or shop floor union representative if possible.
66. Thirdly if it is a case of summary dismissal, there is an obligation on the employer to hear and consider any representations by the employee before making the decision to dismiss or give other sanction."
49. In Postal Corporation of Kenya v Andrew K. Tanui [2019] eKLR the Court of Appeal held as follows:-
“Four elements must thus be discernible for the procedure to pass muster:
(i) an explanation of the grounds of termination in a language understood by the employee;
(ii) the reason for which the employer is considering termination;
(iii) entitlement of an employee to the presence of another employee of his choice when the explanation of grounds of termination is made;
(v) hearing and considering any representations made by the employee and the person chosen by the employee.”
50. In the instant case, the Respondent never issued any Show Cause letter to the Claimant to explain defend himself against the alleged misconduct in writing. The Respondent also never accorded the Claimant a fair disciplinary hearing as contemplated under section 41 of the Employment Act.
51. The claimant, RW1 and RW3 confirmed in evidence that no disciplinary hearing was conducted before the summary dismissal of the claimant. They all agreed that the meeting held on 31st October 2023 was to discuss the grievances raised by the claimant on 26th October 2023. The claimant and contended that he was not notified of any charges against him prior to the said meeting and he was not informed of his right to be accompanied to the meeting by an employee of his own choice. RW1 also admitted that there was no prior notice to the Claimant that the distributors’ complaint would be discussed during the meeting of 31st October 2023. Consequently, the court holds that the respondent has failed to prove that the summary dismissal of the claimant was done in accordance with a fair procedure.
52. Having found that the reasons for the summary dismissal of the claimant were not valid, and that fair procedure was not followed, the court concludes that the dismissal was unfair and unlawful within the meaning of section 45 of the Employment Act.
Reliefs
53. In view of the foregoing conclusion, I find that the claimant is entitled to declaration that the termination of his employment by the respondent was unfair and unlawful. Accordingly, he is entitled to compensatory damages under section 49 of the Employment Act, including salary in lieu of notice and compensation for the unfair termination.
54. The Claimant prayed for compensation of equaling 12 months' gross salary for the unfair termination plus one-month salary in lieu of notice. Clause 10.1 of his employment contract provided for one month termination notice. Consequently, I award him Kshs. 91,000 as payment in lieu of notice.
55. As regards compensatory damages, I award the claimant 3 months gross salary as compensation for the unfair termination considering the senior position he was serving, the short service of approximately one year, and the fact that the respondent did not prove any misconduct that led to the dismissal. Consequently, he will get Kshs.91,000 x 3 = Khs. 273,000.
56. The Claimant prayed for unpaid commission for the month of August and October 2023 in the sum of Kshs. 182,000. The Respondent submitted that the Claimant was paid his commission for August and October 2023, as evidenced by the Claimant's final payslip at page 50 of the Respondent's Supplementary List and Bundle of Documents dated 3rd December 2025. The Claimant denied receipt of the sum contained in the payslip of November 2023. Consequently, I award the sum of Kshs. 182,000 as prayed.
57. The Claimant further prayed for 15 leave days for the year 2023 equaling to Kshs. 45,500. The Respondent submitted that all unutilized leave days were paid to the Claimant as per the Claimant's November 2023 payslip. However, the respondent did not produce any evidence to prove that the claimant received the said payment. Consequently, I award the sum of Kshs.45,500 as prayed.
58. Finally, the Claimant prayed for a certificate of service and the Respondent submitted that it prepared same but the Claimant failed and/or refused to collect. I direct the Respondent do issue the Claimant with the certificate of service forthwith.
Conclusion
59. The court has found that the dismissal of the Claimant was unfair and unlawful within the meaning of Section 45 of the Employment Act. The court has further found that the Claimant is entitled to the following reliefs and accordingly to enter judgment for the Claimant as follows:
a) Declaration that the termination of the claimant’s employment by the respondent was unfair and unlawful.
b) Compensation for unfair termination Kshs. 273,000
c) Payment in lieu of notice being Kshs. 91,000
d) Commission for August and October 2023 Kshs. 182,000
e) Leave of 15 days Kshs. 45,500
Total: Kshs. 591,500
f) The award is subject to statutory deductions.
g) The Respondent shall forthwith issue the Claimant with a certificate of service.
h) The Claimant is awarded costs of the suit and interest at court rates from the date of this judgment.
DATED, SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 14TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
ONESMUS MAKAU
JUDGE
Appearance:
Mutugi for Claimant
Kiragu for Respondent