Meet Sheriaplex AI. Research, draft and review with tools for Kenyan legal work.

Try AI chat ↗Explore AI Tools →
Employment law

Union of Kenya Civil Servants v Public Service Commission & another [2026] KEELRC 4676 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Employment and Labour Relations Court at Nairobi
Case number
Petition E225 of 2026
Judgment date
15 October 2026
Judge(s)
M. Mbaru

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The application dated 7 July 2026 for blanket conservatory orders restraining the Public Service Commission (PSC) from promotions, recruitment, confirmations and related human-resource actions was declined. The petition is to be heard on a priority basis, with immediate hearing directions; costs will abide the petition’s outcome.

Supporting judgment passages

The upshot is that the application of 7 July 2026 shall not be issued as prayed; the Petitioner shall be heard on a priority basis; hearing directions shall issue instantly. Costs shall abide the outcome of the Petition.

Passage 52 →
Issue 1Whether conservatory orders should issue pending determination of the petition to restrain the PSC from conducting promotions, recruitment, confirmations and related human-resource actions, and from interfering with Principal Secretaries’ day-to-day human-resource administration and career-progression functions.

Held. Decided: No. The Court declined the requested conservatory orders. The petitioner had not precisely identified the allegedly unqualified persons promoted, eligible officers omitted, external entrants, or irregular promotions. Determining those allegations required evidence at the substantive hearing. A blanket restraint would stop the PSC’s constitutional mandate and would conflate rather than facilitate orderly public-service functioning. On the balance of convenience, any meritorious career-stagnation claims could later be corrected through orders concerning promotions and recruitment, including back pay for affected union members.

Ratio. At the interlocutory stage, conservatory orders under Article 23 require a prima facie case and real prejudice, without definitive findings on the petition’s facts or law. Such orders preserve the subject matter and, in public-law disputes, must be assessed by their inherent merit, public interest, constitutional values, and proportionality. A sweeping order halting the PSC’s constitutional functions was not justified on unparticularised allegations requiring trial evidence, particularly where effective corrective relief remained available after trial.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

At the core of the petitioner’s application is the grant of a conservatory order restraining the PSC from proceeding with Promotions, recruitments, confirmations and related human resource actions. Additionally, the Petitioner seeks to restrain the PSC from interfering with the day-to-day human resource administration and career progression mandates held by the Principal Secretaries within State Departments under their respective schemes of service, and any other lawful authority in the National Government.

Passage 40 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

The import of Articles 234, 155(2) and 232 of the Constitution will therefore be lost in issuing a conservatory order as herein sought by the petitioner or stopping the PSC from undertaking its constitutional mandate pending the hearing and determination of the petition. Fundamentally, at this stage, the petitioner has not precisely identified the persons who were systematically promoted despite being unqualified, those eligible officers omitted from rightful promotions, external entrants introduced into cadres strictly reserved for internal progression, or irregular promotions effected throughout the public service. This calls for evidence and a hearing on the petition on its merits before any orders are issued.

Passage 47 →

The issues relating to the alleged arbitrary recruitments and promotions by the PSC relate to and affect numerous employees across the public service, including State Departments, with the recruitment and promotions being continuing processes. Grant of conservatory orders at this stage would conflate, rather than facilitate, ordered functioning within the public service.

Passage 50 →

The upshot is that the application of 7 July 2026 shall not be issued as prayed; the Petitioner shall be heard on a priority basis; hearing directions shall issue instantly. Costs shall abide the outcome of the Petition.

Passage 52 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

The rule of law so understood on the grant of conservatory orders is that the Court will only grant the same within the framework of Article 23 of the Constitution at the interlocutory stage if a prima facie case is made out, and there will be real prejudice suffered in the absence of the orders sought as per the Board of Management of Uhuru Secondary School v City County Director of Education & 2 others (Petition 359 of 2015) [2015] eKLR. The jurisdiction does not accordingly require the Court to make a definitive finding of fact or law that will later inform the judgment on the main petition.

Passage 41 →

“Conservatory orders” bear a more decided public-law connotation: for these are orders to facilitate ordered functioning within public agencies, as well as to uphold the adjudicatory authority of the Court, in the public interest. Conservatory orders, therefore, are not, unlike interlocutory injunctions, linked to such private-party issues as “the prospects of irreparable harm” occurring during the pendency of a case; or “high probability of success” in the supplicant’s case for orders of stay. Conservatory orders, consequently, should be granted on the inherent merit of a case, bearing in mind the public interest, the constitutional values, and the proportionate magnitudes, and priority levels attributable to the relevant causes.”

Passage 49 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether, pending determination of the petition, the court should issue conservatory orders stopping the Public Service Commission (PSC) from advertisements, recruitment, promotions, confirmations and related human-resource actions across National Government…

Material facts

The union alleged that the PSC had unilaterally assumed administration of schemes of service, applied them arbitrarily, promoted unqualified persons, bypassed eligible officers, and introduced external entrants into cadres reserved for internal progression.…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI

PETITION NO. E225 OF 2026

THE UNION OF KENYA CIVIL SERVANTS PETITIONER

VERSUS

THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION 1ST RESPONDENT

THE HONOURABLE ATTORNEY GENERAL 2ND RESPONDENT

RULING

The Petitioner filed an application dated the 7 July 2026 under the provisions of Articles 23 (3) and 159(2) of the Constitution of Kenya, Rules 22 and 23 of the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms) Practice and Procedure Rules, 2013; the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules 10, 44, Section 1A, 1B & 3A of the Civil Procedure Act, seeking orders:

1. Spent

2. Pending hearing and inter parties’ determination of this application and the Petition, this Court be pleased to issue a Conservatory order staying all advertisements, shortlisting, interviews for, promotions, and other related promotional appointments, and/ or personnel actions by the 1st Respondent regarding promotions within State departments and bodies in the national government.

3. Pending hearing and determination of this application and the Petition, a Conservatory Order do issue staying all execution, processing, and implementation of promotions and promotional appointments by the 1st Respondent, and strictly restraining its agents or servants from executing administrative functions under the Schemes of Service or any other related functions outside its overall, macro-regulatory, non-executive mandate within State Departments and bodies in the national government.

4. Pending hearing and inter parties’ determination of this application and the main Petition, a Conservatory Order be issued restraining the 1st Respondent, by itself, its agents, agents, servants or any person acting on its behalf, from publishing any further advertisements, shortlisting candidates, calling for or conducting interviews, or issuing promotional appointment/promotional letters for positions within State Departments and other National Government bodies

5. Pending the hearing and inter-parties’ determination of this Application and the main Petition, a Conservatory Order of Stay be issued staying all ongoing promotions, recruitment processes regarding processing of promotional appointments, and/ or any related actions initiated by the 1st Respondent Public Service Commission in respect of vacancies falling under any scheme of service within State Departments and bodies within the National Government.

6. Pending hearing and inter parties’ determination of this application and the main Petition, a Conservatory Order of Stay be issued staying all ongoing and planned promotions, related processes, processing of promotions, and any related human resource actions initiated by the 1st Respondent, and further restraining the 1st Respondent, its Commissioners, agents, or servants from interfering with, or usurping, or overriding the executive administration of scheme of service within the State Department and National Government bodies.

7. Pending the hearing and determination of this Application and the main Petition, a Conservatory Order do issue restraining the 1st Respondent from interfering with, overriding, impeding, unlawfully hindering, obstructing, delaying, or stopping, or usurping the functions of and/or the day to day human resource administration and career progression mandates held by Principal Secretaries within State Departments under their respective Schemes of Service or any other lawful authority in the National Government

8. Costs of the Application.

The application is supported by the affidavit of Lawrence Nyaguti Ochieng, the secretary general of the petitioner, who avers that the members of the petitioner Union are aggrieved by the manner in which the 1st Respondent, the Public Service Commission (PSC), has unilaterally taken over the administration of Schemes of Service from Principal Secretaries, contrary to the constitutional and statutory mandates. This has been accompanied by the PSC’s arbitrary application of schemes to recruitments and promotions.

As a result of this arbitrary application, career progression has stagnated, and long-serving officers have been discriminated against, losing seniority and rank and being surpassed by juniors, causing active, continuing professional regression and psychological distress. The petitioner members have sought remedy from the PSC for years, with no resolution in sight, forcing them to seek intervention from the Applicant union and, in some extreme instances, the Court, with no remedy forthcoming. The internal progression and appeal structures have been paralysed as the PSC continues to impose and bypass internal structures governed by schemes of service.

Unless restrained, the 1st Respondent’s actions will perpetuate irregularities in human resource management, causing grave and irreparable injury to civil servants and the public service at large. Permitting the PSC to act on provisions and/or practices that patently offend the constitutional boundaries constitutes a continuing violation of the Constitution.

In his affidavit, Munguti avers that the public interest overwhelmingly favours the issuance of conservatory orders to ensure public service appointments and/or promotions remain strictly within the constitutional structures of Articles 232 and 234, rather than ultra vires mechanisms that unlawfully consolidate administrative power within the 1st respondent. Unless stopped by conservatory orders, the 1st respondent will proceed to fill positions and effect promotions illegally, which will irreversibly prejudice qualified public officers and taint the integrity of the public service. The public service faces a real imminent harm that is irreversible and not compensable by way of damages.

In reply, the PSC filed the Replying Affidavit of Paul Famba, the Secretary/Chief Executive Officer, who avers that the Human resource functions delegated to the Principal Secretary as set out in Clause 3.1.4 and 4.2 of the Delegation Instrument are functions and powers of the PSC under Article 234 of the Constitution, which, in the exercise of its constitutional discretion, chose to delegate to Principal Secretaries pursuant to Article 234(5). This delegation the Commission may at any time review, vary or withdraw as is expressly reserved under clauses 2.1, 23.0, 27.0 and 28.0 of the Delegation Instrument.

The Principal Secretaries are, and still remain, fully involved in the recruitment processes as the PSC, among other things, does not undertake any recruitment without a declaration of vacancies from the Principal Secretary. The PSC does issue a circular every year requiring Principal Secretaries to submit their annual recruitment plans. The Commission also does not unilaterally advertise or undertake any recruitment process without a request and submission of an indent by the Principal Secretary for any vacant position for fresh appointment or promotion by the Commission.

The Commission, in every instance where it conducts shortlisting or interviews for positions within a given State Department, invites the Principal Secretary of that State Department, or their duly authorised representative, to attend, or to send a representative to attend and participate in, such shortlisting and/or interview panels. This is done to ensure that the institutional Knowledge, operational requirements and input of the State Department concerned are taken into account.

Famba avers that, to the extent that any person or public officer has a specific grievance regarding promotion, confirmation, or re-designation decision, the proper and constitutionally appropriate avenue for ventilating such grievance is through the internal review and internal appeal mechanisms provided for under the Delegation Instrument, the PSC and the Public Service Commission Regulations, 2020 and not through sweeping constitutional challenge seeking to strip the Commission of its mandate.

The grant of conservatory orders sought would occasion grave and irreparable prejudice to the public service as a whole, given that promotions, recruitment, confirmations and related human resource actions are continuous processes necessary for the effective and efficient functioning of Government, and blanket order staying all such processes nationally would paralyze the public service, delay service delivery to the public, and occasion far greater harm than the Petitioner alleges it seeks to avoid. The Petitioner has not demonstrated a prima facie case with likelihood of success.

Famba avers that the balance of convenience tilts in favour of the Commission and the wider public interest in the continued, orderly and uninterrupted functioning of the public service, and that the orders sought, if granted, would not preserve the status quo but would instead disrupt ongoing, lawful, and properly delegated human resource processes to the detriment of thousands of public officers across the country who are awaiting confirmation, promotion, or appointment through processes already underway.

On the application, the petitioner submitted that in County Government of Machakos v Kenya Union of Clinical Officers Petition E005 of 2024 KEELRC 13567 KLR the court held that failure to honour previous agreements in respect of promotions and re-designations constitutes a violation of the right to fair administrative action under Article 47 of the Constitution and that failure to effect promotions and re-designations as provided for in the PSC human resource policies and procedure manual is a valid grievance.

The 1st Respondent’s unilateral actions in advertising vacancies that should ordinarily be filled through internal promotions, promoting unqualified persons, and introducing external entrants into cadres reserved for internal progression have frustrated the Petitioner’s legitimate expectation. The impugned actions are causing ongoing and irreparable harm to the civil servants including 1800 of the Applicants members and other civil servants including 1800 of the applicants’ members and other public servants who have suffered career stagnation due to the PSC’s irregular actions. The harm is irreparable and continuing. The violations are continuing and will persist unless the Court intervenes.

In Munya v Kithinji & 2 Others (Application 5 of 2014) [2014] KESC 30 (KLR) the court held that Conservatory orders ought to be granted on the inherent merit of the case, bearing in mind the public interest, the constitutional values, and proportionate magnitudes, and priority levels attributable to the relevant causes to urge that is in the interests of justice for the court to uphold and protect the law by restraining the 1st respondent from continuing with a process that is clearly in violation of the constitution and the law.

The PSC submitted and relied on case of Board of Management of Uhuru Secondary School v City County Director of Education & 2 others (Petition 359 of 2015) [2015] e KLR where the court outlined the principles for grant of conservatory orders requires that the applicant demonstrate:

(a) a prima facie case with a probability of success, and that in the absence of the orders sought, real prejudice will be suffered;

(b) That the grant of the orders will enhance the constitutional values in issue;

(c) That in the absence of the orders, the petition or its substratum will be rendered nugatory; and (d) that the public interest favours the grant of the orders.

In Nairobi Civil Appeal 151 of 2011 of 2011 Invesco Assurance Co. Ltd v MW (Minor suing thro’ next friend and mother (HW) [2016] e KLR the court held that a conservatory order is an order for the preservation of the status quo, and the current status quo is that the PSC is the Constitutional State organ responsible for appointment and promotion of public officers with the function either being exercised directly or through delegation to other officers, bodies or authorities in the public service pursuant to Article 234 (5 ) of the Constitution.

The respondent submitted that any prejudice the Petitioner’s members may have suffered is an ordinary employment grievance capable of being addressed through the Commission’s internal review and appeal mechanisms. Any officer aggrieved by a specific promotion decision retains an avenue of internal appeal to the Commission, and, ultimately, recourse to this Court in respect of that specific decision. The proper and constitutionally appropriate avenue for individual grievances of this kind is not a sweeping order suspending the Commission’s entire constitutional mandate over the national government, on the basis of isolated allegations. Any grievance suffered by any member of the petitioner is capable of compensation by way of damages and, where possible, backdated promotions.

Granting the conservatory orders sought would occasion grave irreparable prejudice to the public service as a whole. Promotions, recruitments, confirmations and related human resource actions are continuous processes necessary for the effective and efficient functioning of the government. A blanket order staying all such processes nationally would paralyze the public service, delay service delivery to the public, and occasion far greater harm than the harm the petitioner alleges it seeks to avoid.

The PSC submitted that any public interest, properly understood, favours the continued and orderly exercise by the Commission of its express constitutional mandate under Article 234, subject to its own internal safeguards and the court’s ultimate supervisory jurisdiction to correct any specific, proven irregularity, rather than wholesale suspension of that mandate on the basis of general and unparticularized allegations.

Determination

At the core of the petitioner’s application is the grant of a conservatory order restraining the PSC from proceeding with Promotions, recruitments, confirmations and related human resource actions. Additionally, the Petitioner seeks to restrain the PSC from interfering with the day-to-day human resource administration and career progression mandates held by the Principal Secretaries within State Departments under their respective schemes of service, and any other lawful authority in the National Government.

The rule of law so understood on the grant of conservatory orders is that the Court will only grant the same within the framework of Article 23 of the Constitution at the interlocutory stage if a prima facie case is made out, and there will be real prejudice suffered in the absence of the orders sought as per the Board of Management of Uhuru Secondary School v City County Director of Education & 2 others (Petition 359 of 2015) [2015] eKLR. The jurisdiction does not accordingly require the Court to make a definitive finding of fact or law that will later inform the judgment on the main petition.

As correctly submitted by the PSC in Nairobi Civil Appeal 151 of 2011 Invesco Assurance Co Ltd v MW (Minor suing thro’ next friend mother (HW) [2016] eKLR, a conservatory order in itself is an order of status quo, that is a judicial remedy granted by the court for the preservation of the subject matter.

In this case, the petitioner asserts that the PSC has systematically promoted unqualified persons, omitted eligible officers from rightful promotions, introduced external entrants into cadres strictly reserved for internal progression and effected irregular promotions throughout the public service. The petitioner’s case is that the PSC has effectively taken over the lawful mandate to administer Schemes of Service from Principal Secretaries, contrary to the Constitution and the law.

On its part, the PSC’s case is that it is the constitutional body mandated to ensure the public service is properly established by ensuring the establishment and abolition of offices in the public service, to appoint persons to hold or act in offices in the public service, including confirming appointments in the public service or removal from office.

In undertaking this mandate, the PSC must uphold the values under Article 10 and 232 of the Constitution. To ensure it applies its mandate objectively, the PSC has developed various instruments. The Human resource functions delegated to the Principal Secretary, as set out in Clause 3.1.4 and 4.2 of the Delegation Instrument, are functions and powers of the PSC under Article 234 of the Constitution, which, in exercising its constitutional discretion, has delegated to Principal Secretaries pursuant to Article 234(5). This delegation is not absolute. It is subject to review, variation or withdrawal as necessary and appropriate. In this case, clauses 2.1, 23.0, 27.0, and 28.0 of the PSC Delegation Instrument allow for review, variation, and withdrawal.

Ultimately, the values under Article 10 and 232 of the Constitution are binding on the PSC in discharging its constitutional mandate to those in the public service and all those seeking to join the public service.

The import of Articles 234, 155(2) and 232 of the Constitution will therefore be lost in issuing a conservatory order as herein sought by the petitioner or stopping the PSC from undertaking its constitutional mandate pending the hearing and determination of the petition. Fundamentally, at this stage, the petitioner has not precisely identified the persons who were systematically promoted despite being unqualified, those eligible officers omitted from rightful promotions, external entrants introduced into cadres strictly reserved for internal progression, or irregular promotions effected throughout the public service. This calls for evidence and a hearing on the petition on its merits before any orders are issued.

This view is aptly captured in Gatirau Peter Munya v Dickson Mwenda Kithinji & 2 others [2014] eKLR

“Conservatory orders” bear a more decided public-law connotation: for these are orders to facilitate ordered functioning within public agencies, as well as to uphold the adjudicatory authority of the Court, in the public interest. Conservatory orders, therefore, are not, unlike interlocutory injunctions, linked to such private-party issues as “the prospects of irreparable harm” occurring during the pendency of a case; or “high probability of success” in the supplicant’s case for orders of stay. Conservatory orders, consequently, should be granted on the inherent merit of a case, bearing in mind the public interest, the constitutional values, and the proportionate magnitudes, and priority levels attributable to the relevant causes.”

The issues relating to the alleged arbitrary recruitments and promotions by the PSC relate to and affect numerous employees across the public service, including State Departments, with the recruitment and promotions being continuing processes. Grant of conservatory orders at this stage would conflate, rather than facilitate, ordered functioning within the public service.

Considering the balance of convenience, the main complaint of the petitioner relating to stagnation in the career progression of the civil servants as a result of the actions of the PSC, if found to be with merit at trial, can still be remedied by this Court by necessary corrective orders on the promotions and recruitments together with back pay for the members of the union who are affected by any arbitrary application of the schemes.

The upshot is that the application of 7 July 2026 shall not be issued as prayed; the Petitioner shall be heard on a priority basis; hearing directions shall issue instantly. Costs shall abide the outcome of the Petition.

Dated this 15th Day of October 2026

M. MBARU

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Court Assistant: Mohammed Ali

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder