Land law

Briefcase Company Limited v Principal Secretary, State Department of Land & Physical Planning & 9 others [2026] KEELC 6640 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
15 October 2026
Judge(s)
CG Mbogo

Case research

READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

Before this court for determination is the chamber summons dated 24th June, 2025 filed by the applicant, and it is expressed to be brought under Order 53 Rule 1 (1),(2) and (4) of the Civil Procedure Rules and Sections 8 & 9 of the Law Reform Act seeking the following orders:-

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

The 8th and 9th respondents submitted that the applicant has an alternative remedy in an ordinary civil suit before this court. The competing evidence presented by the parties demonstrates that there is a substantial proprietary dispute that requires a full trial. While I do not wish to discredit the public law dimension of this dispute on the premise that private law in terms of proprietorship takes an upper hand, it is my finding…

Paragraph 45 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the certiorari prayers were barred by the six-month statutory limitation; whether Briefcase Company Limited had shown an arguable case warranting leave for judicial review; and whether the land dispute was suitable for judicial review rather than an…

Material facts

Briefcase claimed that LR No. 214/387 (Block 40/160) was public land validly allocated to it through allotment reference 7997/34 after National Land Commission and Nairobi County processes. It alleged that public officers fraudulently processed title-related…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT & LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELCLC NO. E319 OF 2025

BRIEFCASE COMPANY LIMITED ......................…………………….APPLICANT

VERSUS

THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,

STATE DEPARTMENT OF LANDS

& PHYSICAL PLANNING...............................................….1ST RESPONDENT

THE DIRECTORATE OF SURVEY AND MAPPING

STATE DEPARTMENT OF LANDS

& PHYSICAL PLANNING……………………….............….……..2ND RESPONDENT

THE DIRECTOR, LAND ADMINISTRATION

STATE DEPARTMENT OF LANDS

& PHYSICAL PLANNING..……................................………..3RD RESPONDENT

THE CHIEF LAND REGISTRAR……………...............………..4TH RESPONDENT

THE NATIONAL LAND COMMISSION…………..............…..5TH RESPONDENT

HONOURABLE ATTORNEY GENERAL………................….6TH RESPONDENT

NAIROBI COUNTY GOVERNMENT…………...............………7TH RESPONDENT

LOHMON INVESTMENTS COMPANY LIMITED………....…8TH RESPONDENT

JAWHARA KENYA LIMITED……………....................……….9TH RESPONDENT

DIRECTOR CRIMINAL

INVESTIGATION (LAND FRAUD)…...…………………………10TH RESPONDENT

RULING

1. Before this court for determination is the chamber summons dated 24th June, 2025 filed by the applicant, and it is expressed to be brought under Order 53 Rule 1 (1),(2) and (4) of the Civil Procedure Rules and Sections 8 & 9 of the Law Reform Act seeking the following orders:-

1. Spent.

2. The applicant, Briefcase Company Ltd be granted leave to apply for an order of certiorari to remove into this court for the purpose of being quashed the 1st, 3rd and 4th respondent issuance of illegal and irregular provisional certificate of title issued on 28th March, 2025 disguised as 8th October, 2024 and any other or further title document in the portal and expunge the same from the record in respect of LR no. 214/387(bloc 40/160) as issued and indicated in the portal of ardhisasa land registration geospatial data centre (GDC).

3. The applicant, Briefcase Company Ltd be granted leave to apply for an order of certiorari to remove into this honourable court for the purpose of being quashed the 1st,3rd and 4th respondent registration of illegal & irregular provisional certificate of title; power of attorney & deed of indemnity (Rectification) dated 18th July, 2024 & 23rd May, 2024 respectively & expunge the same from the record in respect of LR no. 214/387 (block 40/160) as issued and indicated in the portal of ardhisasa land registration geospatial data centre (GDC).

4. The applicant, Briefcase Company Ltd, be granted leave upon the grant of prayers above to apply for an order of prohibition prohibiting the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, 7th, 8th, 9th and 10th respondents from deliberating, acting upon, taking any proceedings, issuing any directive including but not limited to regularizing illegalities or doing anything in any manner that affects LR no. 214/387 (block 40/160) and directed to defeat allotment ref: 7997/34.

5. The applicant, Briefcase Company Ltd be granted leave upon the grant of prayers above to apply for an order of prohibition prohibiting the 2nd respondent, the directorate of survey and mapping state department of lands & physical planning from amending, subdividing and/or adjusting the registry index map (RIM) in respect of the land title no. LR no. 214/387 (block 40/160) directed to defeat allotment ref: 7997/34.

6. The applicant, Briefcase Company Ltd be granted leave upon the grant of the prayers above to apply for an order of prohibition prohibiting the 1st,3rd,4th,7th and 8th respondents and any 3rd parties(indicated in the fraudulent & illegally registered provisional certificate of title from taking any further action and/or decisions to fence and/or develop, to process any further or illegal & irregular ownership documents directed at defeating the allotment ref: 7007/34 and/or adjusting the registry index map (RIM) in respect of the land title nos. LR no. 214/387 (block 40/160).

7. The applicant, Briefcase Company Ltd be granted leave upon the grant of the prayers above to apply for an order of mandamus compelling the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th and 6th respondents to process ownership documents in respect of allotment ref: 7997/34 unconditionally & without any further delay.

8. The applicant, Briefcase Company Ltd, be granted leave upon the grant of the prayers above to apply for an order of mandamus compelling the 10th respondent to take swift action and arrest the culprits in respect of the fraud and charge them in court.

9. Any other and or further order that the court may deem fit to grant.

10. The grant of leave herein do operate as a stay of the implementation, any action, pursuant or any decision, subdivision, fencing, developing and/or any action pursuant to the decision of the respondents until the determination of this substantive application.

11. Costs of the application be provided for.

2. The grounds on which the application is premised is as stated in the statutory statement and verifying affidavit of Peter K. Langat sworn on even date. He deposed that he is a director of the applicant and authorized by the board to swear the affidavit. It is the applicant’s case that they made an application for allocation which was done on 18th March, 2019 by Voromono Ltd which later dropped its ambition and gave them the opportunity to further make their application which they presented to the National Land Commission (NLC) and the county government of Nairobi as per the regulations and procedures. Upon presenting their application, the county government of Nairobi issued a letter of no objection addressed the same to NLC for processing alongside a due diligence report.

3. Following due diligence conducted by the NLC, their allocation of allotment ref: 7997/34 was successful and gazettement of the same was published without any objection. Before the letter of allotment was issued, the 2nd respondent on 21st January, 2025 wrote a letter to the 3rd and 4th respondents in relation to LR no. 214/87 (block 40/160) directing them to halt reconstruction and expunge from the records the use of documents acquired fraudulently from their offices.

4. The applicant deposed that after receiving the 2nd respondent’s letter, the 3rd respondents directed further investigations. The 3rd respondent failed to stop the illegal process of reconstruction and ignored the caution letter and through its officers proceeded to issue a fraudulent certificate of title on 28th March, 2025 to the 8th respondent. On 29th March 2025, the same was registered to the 9th respondent. Upon requesting for the certification of records, and a copy of the land register calendar, the same showed that the registration to the 8th respondent had been deleted, and the date of issuance of the provisional title to the 9th respondent indicated 8th October, 2024 which was not countersigned.

5. The applicant deposed that they have since discovered that the documents used to process the provisional certificate of title and the entire records are illegal and that the certificate of title purportedly transferred by the county government of Nairobi on 21st July, 1993 is irregular. According to the applicant, the provisional certificate of title has been subjected to fraudulent activities and being aggrieved by the manner in which the 1st, 3rd, 4th and 10th respondents have acted in responding to their notices, they have now moved to court.

6. Regarding the allotment ref 7997/34, the applicant deposed that the same has been blocked for processing, and they are aware that the 7th and 8th respondents are being dragged to own pubic land which they lack the necessary documentation. Further, that the lands officials lack jurisdiction to allocate public land and it is only the 5th respondent that has the mandate to do so. The applicant contends that the actions of the 1st, 3rd, and 4th respondents actions are illegal, null and void, fraudulent and in excess of their jurisdiction. Further, that there is a proper case for the exercise of this court’s jurisdiction in favour of allocation of allotment ref: 7997/34.

7. The 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 6th and 10th respondents filed their replying affidavit sworn on 29th October, 2025 by George Gitonga, the land registrar working in the office of the 4th respondent. He deposed that the applicant has not laid any basis for the grant of leave to apply for the orders of certiorari, prohibition and mandamus. From their records, LR no. 214/387 converted to Nairobi/Block 40/160 is private property with a registered owner. Further, that LR no. 214/387 resulted from a subdivision of LR no. 214/158 measuring 2.54 acres and was first registered to Walter James Wheeler on 21st March, 1948 and later transferred to Kathleen Grace Dale on 17th November, 1951.

8. The 4th respondent deposed that Kathleen subdivided LR no. 214/158 into two portions i.e. 214/386 and 214/387 and transferred 214/387 measuring 1.55 acres to the city council of Nairobi on 3rd February, 1955. Thereafter, a transfer was registered to the 8th respondent on 21st July, 1993 and a deed of rectification dated 23rd May, 2024 was registered on 1st July, 2024. Further, that the 8th respondent applied for conversion of Nairobi/Block 40/160 on 8th October, 2024 and transferred the same to the 9th respondent which transaction was registered on 28th March, 2025. Thus the 9th respondent is the current registered owner of the property.

9. Further, and according to their records, the letter of allotment ref. 7997/34 was irregular and the document is not valid. The 4th respondent deposed that judicial review proceedings is not a forum where ownership disputes are adjudicated owing to the restricted use of affidavits while such disputes require viva voce evidence.

10. The 5th respondent filed its replying affidavit sworn on 9th October, 2025 by Dr. Samuel Mwenje Nthuni. The 5th respondent deposed that having received a letter dated 12th March, 2024 recommending the regularization of LR no. 214/387, it undertook the process of allocation of the suit land in accordance with the law. While discharging its functions, the 5th respondent noted that the suit property is committed to correspondence file no. 52118 which could not be traced due to the ongoing digitization of land records, and following this discovery, it wrote to the ministry of lands to ascertain the status but they are yet to receive any feedback.

11. Further, that on 3rd February 2025, it wrote to the 7th respondent confirming compliance by publishing a notice of intention to allocate the parcel of land. The same was then published on 7th February, 2025 in the daily nation, and there being no objection or comments on the same, it proceeded to issue a letter of allotment to the applicant. The 5th respondent maintained that it followed due process and it is not aware of any illegalities on the suit land as alleged.

12. For the record, the 7th respondent filed a notice of withdrawal dated 10th November, 2025 withdrawing the affidavit sworn on 12th August, 2025 by Isaac Nyoike the director, valuation. Neither of the parties raised an objection as to the withdrawal. The 7th respondent filed its replying affidavit sworn on 5th December, 2025 by Geoffrey Cheruiyot. The 7th respondent deposed that LR no. 214/387 was surrendered to the defunct city council of Nairobi in 1955 by Kathlene Grace Dale, and that the same was never sold, transferred or granted to any individual after its surrender. It was deposed that the land remained public land until the recent regularization by the NLC. The 7th respondent denied allegations of any irregularity and stated that the alleged allocation of the same on 28th March, 2025 was performed without its participation and it is fraud.

13. The 7th respondent further deposed that the purported conveyance dated 9th July, 1993 between the then city council of Nairobi and the 8th respondent is a forgery. They stated that they have no records of any such conveyance. Further, that the power of attorney and the deed of indemnity purporting to transfer the land to the 8th respondent or 9th respondent are entirely fraudulent, and at no point did the county government of Nairobi receive any valid conveyance or other instrument from the 8th respondent. The 7th respondent deposed that by a letter dated 12th March 2024, it provided the NLC with the status report of the land and expressly stated that it did not object to the regularization of the same having found that it had no ownership documents. Again, further clarification was sought vide the letter dated 11th May, 2024 which they responded to on 12th June, 2024.

14. The 7th respondent deposed that NLC followed due process by publishing a gazette notice and there being no objections, a letter of allotment was issued to the applicant.

15. The 8th respondent opposed the instant application vide the replying affidavit of its Director, Abdulgafur Hussein Mohamed Moti sworn on 14th August, 2025. The 8th respondent deposed that there have been three fraudulent schemes made in an attempt to steal the suit property. The first was the fraudulent change of records at the company’s registry. The second one took place at the survey of Kenya where fraudsters attempted to create a separate GLA file in a bid to create confusion in the ownership of the suit property. The third fraudulent scheme is the current one attempted by the applicant together with the 5th and 7th respondents through the letters dated 12th March 2024, and 12th June, 2024. The 8th respondent deposed that the then city council of Nairobi issued a lease, and that all through it has paid its annual rates including the year 2025.

16. The 8th respondent deposed that it obtained an approval to construct a perimeter wall on 21st February, 2023 by the CECM Built Environment and Urban Planning. Further, that the 5th and 7th respondents acted in excess of their powers to manufacture a new allocation on top of an existing grant of a freehold interest to the 8th respondent which acts contravenes its constitutional right to a fair administrative process.

17. With regard to the prayers sought in the instant application, the 8th respondent deposed that no judicial review orders can be sought against private entities thus the same cannot issue. The 8th respondent denied applying for a provisional certificate of title, instead it holds a lawful lease from Nairobi city council and on 8th October 2024, they applied for conversion of the property wherein they were issued with a certificate of title. Further, that the applicant is seeking to quash the certificate of title issued on 8th October, 2024 which is 8 months after the said action, and it is time barred under the law. Further, that the orders of certiorari cannot issue where there is an effective alternative remedy that can handle the claim through an ordinary suit.

18. On prohibition and mandamus, the 8th respondent deposed that the same cannot issue in respect of an act that has already been done more so against private individuals or entities. Further, that no evidence has been tendered to prove that the applicant made a complaint to the 10th respondent and the same has not been acted upon.

19. The 8th respondent filed a supplementary affidavit sworn on 29th May, 2026 by Mohamed Hussein Abdulla Moti, its attorney. The 8th respondent reiterated the contents of its replying affidavit and rubbished the allegations that Mr. Abdulgafur Hussein is deceased as alleged by the applicant. Further, that the said Abdulgafur is a pioneer director and shareholder of the 8th respondent which was incorporated on 11th June, 1987.

20. The 9th respondent filed grounds of opposition dated 11th July, 2025 in opposition to the instant application on the following grounds:

1. That a judicial review is not the right forum in which to determine this dispute as the ex-parte applicant is basically asking the court to determine the ownership of the suit properties between the ex-parte applicant and the 9th respondent who owns the land.

2. That as a matter of law, judicial review proceedings are not a forum where disputes on ownership of land can be adjudicated and determined because it is restricted to affidavit evidence while such disputes require viva voce evidence and cross examination of witnesses.

3. That the present forum causes prejudice to the 9th respondent’s right to be heard as enshrined in Article 50 and is unduly oppressive and prejudicial to the 9th respondent because the 9th respondent is denied its right to interrogatories and all the instruments of defences available in an ordinary civil dispute.

4. That the current application calls upon this court to make a determination in disputed issues of fact relating to the ownership of the suit property, and as such the same is not a suitable case for judicial review.

5. That the present case relates to private rights between the ex parte applicant and the 9th respondent which judicial review is not concerned with.

6. That this application therefore lacks merit, made in bad taste, malicious, gross abuse of the court process and deemed as persuading this court or attempting to waste the courts time and therefore must be dismissed at the first opportunity with costs.

21. The 9th respondent also filed its replying affidavit sworn on 13th October, 2025 by Mahad Ibrahim Hassan. The 9th respondent deposed that it is the registered proprietor of the suit property having purchased the same from the 8th respondent and a title lawfully transferred to it on 28th March, 2025. Further, that no provisional certificate of title exists as alleged. The 9th respondent deposed that the certificate of title issued on 28th March, 2025 was lawfully transferred to it, and there cannot be procedural illegalities over private property. The 9th respondent reiterated that the allotment letter is invalid and an attempt to grab the suit property. Further, that the orders sought in this application cannot issue to an act that has already been done.

22. The 9th respondent also filed a supplementary affidavit sworn on 13th October 2025 by Mohamed Hussein Abdulla Moti who maintained that Mr. Abdulgafur is alive as confirmed in a letter by the department of immigration services dated 12th September, 2025.

23. In response to all the above, the applicant filed numerous affidavits. In reply to the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 6th and 10th respondents, the applicant filed its replying affidavit (sic) sworn on 30th October, 2025 and deposed that they failed to dispel the existence of a deceased person donating the power of attorney. Further, that they failed to address the issue of the varying dates and annex a copy of the white card. While the application for judicial review was filed on 26th June 2025, and where the court finds ambiguity, the court has jurisdiction under Article 47 and 159 (2)(d) of the Constitution to make further orders as it deems fit to grant.

24. The applicant filed its replying affidavit (sic) to the 7th respondent affidavit sworn on 20th May, 2026 and noted that the 7th respondent is not opposed to the application for leave in its entirety and the same should be allowed. In further response to the affidavits and grounds of opposition filed by the 8th and 9th respondents, the applicant filed its replying affidavit (sic) and supplementary affidavit sworn on 25th August 2025, and 21st October, 2025 respectively and began by putting on notice the officer who notarized the document. The applicant further questioned the ownership documents and transfer of the suit property by the 8th and 9th respondents and deposed that there was no collusion by the 7th respondent as alleged.

25. In a further affidavit sworn on 13th October 2025, the applicant deposed that the replying affidavit sworn on 13th October, 2025 by the 9th respondent, and the 8th respondent’s supplementary affidavit sworn on 13th October, 2025 are defective and should be struck off.

26. The application was canvassed through written submissions. The applicant filed its written submissions dated 21st May, 2026. The 7th respondent filed its written submissions dated 30th March 2026, the 8th respondent filed its written submissions dated 23rd September 2026, while the 9th respondent filed its written submissions dated 20th September, 2026.

27. In summary, the applicant seeks leave to commence judicial review proceedings for orders of certiorari, prohibition and mandamus in relation to the property known as LR no. 214/387 (Block 40/160), and further, that the leave, if granted, operate as a stay. The dispute concerns competing claims relating to the status and ownership of the suit property. The applicant maintains that the property is public land which was available for allocation and that, following due process before the NLC and the county government of Nairobi, it was allocated the same under allotment reference no. 7997/34.

28. The applicant contends that notwithstanding the foregoing, certain public officers proceeded to issue and/or register documents in favour of the 8th and subsequently the 9th respondent, including a provisional certificate of title, power of attorney and deed of indemnity, in circumstances which the applicant characterizes as fraudulent, illegal and irregular.

29. The 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 6th and 10th respondents opposed the application. Their position is that the suit property is private property, that the 9th respondent is the registered proprietor, and that the applicant’s allotment was irregular and invalid.

30. The 5th respondent (NLC) takes a somewhat different position. It states that it undertook the allocation process after receiving a recommendation for regularization, published a notice of intention to allocate the property, received no objection and subsequently issued the applicant with a letter of allotment. The 7th respondent similarly maintains that the property had been surrendered to the defunct city council of Nairobi in 1955 and remained public land, and that the conveyance allegedly relied upon by the 8th respondent is a forgery.

31. On the other hand, the 8th and 9th respondents assert that the property was lawfully held and transferred to the 9th respondent. They contend, inter alia, that the dispute is fundamentally one of ownership and therefore cannot properly be determined through judicial review proceedings.

32. From the above, and in my view, the following issues arise for determination:-

i. Whether the prayers for certiorari are barred by the statutory six-month limitation period.

ii. Whether the applicant has established an arguable case warranting leave to commence judicial review proceedings.

iii. Whether the dispute is one which can properly be determined through judicial review.

33. It is trite law that where a party elects to proceed under Order 53 of the Civil Procedure Rules, leave is required before an application for certiorari, prohibition or mandamus can be made. The purpose of leave is not to determine the substantive judicial review application. The court at this stage is required to undertake a preliminary assessment as to whether the applicant has an arguable case which merits consideration at the substantive stage. In Republic v Communications Commission of Kenya (As successor to Managing Director Kenya Posts & Telecommunications Corporation and Kenya Posts & Telecommunications); East Africa Television Network Limited (Ex parte Applicant) [2001] KECA 353 (KLR), the court of appeal restated:-

“On the issue of whether to grant or not to grant leave, this court recently said in the case of In The Matter of an Application by Samuel M W'njuguna & 6 others and in The Matter of The Minister for Agriculture and in The Matter of The Tea Act (Cap 343 Laws of Kenya) and The Tea (Elections) Regulations 2000, Civil Appeal No 144 of 2000 (unreported):“It cannot be denied that leave should be granted, if on the material available, the court considers, without going into the matter in depth, that there is an arguable case for granting leave. The appropriate procedure for challenging such leave subsequently is by an application by the respondent under the inherent jurisdiction of the court, to the judge who granted leave to set aside such leave - see Halsbury's Laws of England, 4th Edition, Volume 1 (1) Paragraph 167 at page 276."”

34. Leave, however, is not automatic. The applicant must demonstrate that the intended proceedings are not frivolous, futile or an abuse of the process of the court and that there has been no unexplained inordinate delay. The court must therefore resist the temptation, at the leave stage, to determine the substantive dispute. At the same time, leave cannot be granted where the proposed proceedings are plainly incompetent or statute-barred. Section 9(3) of the Law Reform Act provides in part, that leave shall not be granted to apply for an order of certiorari unless the application for leave is made not later than six months after the date of the judgment, order, decree, conviction or other proceeding sought to be quashed. Order 53 Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Rules contains a substantially similar limitation.

35. The instant application dated 24th June, 2025 seeks to challenge the alleged issuance of a provisional certificate of title said to have been issued on 28th March 2025, although the applicant disputes the date appearing in the land records and contends that the date of 8th October, 2024 is misleading. Whichever view ultimately prevails, there is, at the very least, an arguable challenge concerning an administrative act said to have culminated in registration of the title on 28th March, 2025. On the face of it, and based on the material placed before this court, the instant application was lodged within six months of that date.

36. With respect to prayer 3, the applicant seeks to quash, among other things, a power of attorney and deed of indemnity dated 18th July, 2024 and 23rd May, 2024 respectively. Looking at the time frame and the date when these instruments were registered, which indicates 2nd August 2024, the six months period has already lapsed and the same cannot issue. The applicant has sought to rely upon the alleged continuing discovery of irregularities and upon the discrepancies in the land records. However, the statutory limitation governing certiorari cannot simply be extended by characterizing a completed act as a continuing grievance. This prayer is therefore time barred.

37. On the second issue, I have evaluated and considered the competing affidavits. There is a striking conflict in the positions taken by the public bodies themselves. On the one hand, the 4th respondent’s evidence is that LR no. 214/387 was private property, originally registered to Walter James Wheeler, subsequently transferred to Kathleen Grace Dale, subdivided, and eventually transferred to the city council of Nairobi in 1955 before subsequent dealings culminating in registration in favour of the 9th respondent.

38. On the other hand, the 7th respondent states that the property was surrendered to the defunct city council of Nairobi in 1955 and was never subsequently sold, transferred or granted to any private individual. It further alleges that the purported conveyance of 9th July, 1993 is a forgery. The 5th respondent, on its part, states that it undertook a process of regularization and allocation after receiving correspondence from the county government of Nairobi and after publishing a notice of intention to allocate the property. It maintains that no objection was received and that the applicant was consequently issued with an allotment letter.

39. Having considered the rival arguments, the following substantial questions arise concerning the suit property:-

1. The legal status of the suit property;

2. The historical chain of title;

3. The legal effect of the 1955 surrender;

4. The authenticity and legal effect of the alleged 1993 conveyance;

5. The authority under which the subsequent title documents were processed;

6. The circumstances in which the 2024 and 2025 entries were made in the land records; and

7. The legality of the subsequent allocation process.

40. At this stage, the court cannot make findings on any of these questions, as that would amount to determining the substantive dispute prematurely. However, the material placed before court is sufficient to demonstrate that the applicant’s complaint is not frivolous. The applicant has raised an arguable question as to whether the public authorities acted lawfully and within the limits of their statutory powers in processing and registering the impugned documents. The existence of such competing positions among public authorities is, in my view, sufficient to cross the relatively low threshold applicable at the leave stage.

41. The respondents have strongly argued that the matter is fundamentally a dispute over ownership. This argument is considerably sound. Judicial review is not ordinarily the appropriate forum for determining competing proprietary claims requiring viva voce evidence, cross-examination and examination of original title documents. Courts have repeatedly emphasized that judicial review should not be converted into a mechanism for determining contested ownership of land. The court of appeal has similarly cautioned that judicial review is not concerned with determining which of competing parties is entitled to ownership of disputed property. See the case of Commissioner of Lands v Kunste Hotel Ltd, Civil Appeal No. 234 of 1995 [1997] eKLR, and Lucy Mirigo & 550 Others v Minister for Lands & 4 Others [2014] eKLR, Civil Appeal No. 277 of 2011.

42. More importantly, a distinction has to be made in determining who owns the land and examining whether a public authority lawfully exercised its statutory powers in arriving at an administrative decision affecting the land. The former is ordinarily a reserve of an ordinary suit while the latter is within the precincts of judicial review. However, in this case, both scenarios are intertwined. The applicant’s complaint, insofar as it challenges the conduct of public authorities in processing and registering documents and in dealing with the competing allocation, raises a public-law question. In my view, it would be a serious miscarriage of justice for the court to grant leave to the applicant proceed and deal with the substantive application while other discrepancies have been raised.

43. The issues discussed above, present a difficult scenario for the orders of mandamus and prohibition to issue simply because of the competing interests by the applicant and the 8th and 9th respondents. The court needs to pronounce itself on the proprietary interests of the suit property as claimed by the applicant on the strength of the letter of allotment and as claimed by the 8th and 9th respondents on the strength of the certificate of title or lease and the alleged provisional title.

44. The applicant further seeks an order of mandamus compelling the 10th respondent to “take swift action and arrest the culprits” and charge them in court. The investigation and prosecution of suspected criminal conduct involve statutory powers and discretion vested in the relevant investigative and prosecutorial authorities. Mandamus may, in an appropriate case, compel performance of a public duty where an authority has unlawfully failed or refused to act, but it is not ordinarily a vehicle for directing that a particular person be arrested or prosecuted. No sufficient material has been placed before this court demonstrating a clear statutory duty on the 10th respondent to arrest and charge specified persons in the manner demanded by the applicant. This prayer is declined.

45. The 8th and 9th respondents submitted that the applicant has an alternative remedy in an ordinary civil suit before this court. The competing evidence presented by the parties demonstrates that there is a substantial proprietary dispute that requires a full trial. While I do not wish to discredit the public law dimension of this dispute on the premise that private law in terms of proprietorship takes an upper hand, it is my finding that an ordinary suit would be suitable to address the main issues.

46. I therefore decline to grant leave to the applicant to file a substantive notice of motion. The applicant should pursue an ordinary suit before this court. The notice of motion dated 24th June, 2026 is hereby dismissed. I make no orders as to costs.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED & DELIVERED VIRTUALLY

THIS 15TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.

HON. MBOGO C.G.

JUDGE

15/10/2026.

In the presence of:

Mr. Benson Agunga - Court assistant

Mr. Langat for the Applicant

Mr. Allan Kamau for the 1st to 4th Respondents and 6th and 10th Respondents

Ms. Nkatha holding brief for Mr. Aden for the 9th Respondent

Mr. Ali for the 8th Respondent

Ms. Njagah holding brief for Ms. Gardale for the 5th Respondent

Mr. Achola for the 7th Respondent

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder