Land law

Njenga v Ndobi [2026] KEELC 6768 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Judgment date
19 October 2026
Judge(s)
MN Kullow

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The Environment and Land Court dismissed the appellant’s Notice of Motion seeking extension of time to file the record of appeal and contempt orders. The application was held incompetent and without merit; there was no order as to costs.

Supporting judgment passages

17. The upshot of the foregoing is that the notice of motion application dated 13th May 2026 and amended on the same date is without merit and is hereby dismissed with no order as to costs.

Paragraph 17 →

16. Flowing from the foregoing, what becomes apparent is that theapplication herein is incompetent and therefore fails.

Paragraph 16 →
Issue 1Whether the appellant was entitled to an extension of time to file the record of appeal after expiry of the 30-day period directed by the court.

Held. No. The appellant had not shown sufficient cause for the delay. Although she attributed the failure to obtain typed proceedings to the respondent and lower-court staff, she produced no proof of meaningful follow-up. The purported reminder letters were received only after the court’s direction, and her conduct over approximately 19 months showed indolence rather than diligent prosecution of the appeal. The request for more time therefore failed.

Ratio. A party seeking discretionary enlargement of time must demonstrate sufficient cause and prosecute the matter proactively and diligently. A litigant cannot simply await typed proceedings without active follow-up, nor disregard court directions and invoke equitable or overriding considerations; equity aids the vigilant, not the indolent.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

9. The applicant is seeking for more time to file the record of appeal after the 30 days given by the court had lapsed. It is her assertion that the delay in procuring proceedings from the lower court have prevented her from filing the appeal. I do note that the applicant filed her memorandum of appeal on the 20th January 2025 and since then there has been no effort from her end to prosecute the same appeal as she never filed a record of appeal. This court gave her 30 days to do so on 10th April 2026 within 30 days and has still failed to do so.

Paragraph 9 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

10. The apppealnt has not given any valid grounds why there has been a delay of close to 19 months now on why the record of appeal has not been filed. The applicant’s case is that she has not been supplied with typed proceedings in the case but has not attached any documentation to indicate she has done follow up. The appellant seeks to rely on letters dated 6th December 2024, 7th April 2025 and 11th April 2026 as prove she did reminder to the relevant persons in the lower court for proceedings. These all have a receiving stamp of the 13th April 2026 indicating the applicant only filed these documents on the 13th April 2026 after the court gave the directions on the 10th April 2026 for her to file record of appeal. Having perused the above-mentioned letters, I have no hesitation that these are actions of an indolent litigant and I am persuaded that the Appellant was not actively following for the proceedings.

Paragraph 10 →

14. Other than the foregoing decision, it is also important to highlight that parties to court proceedings, the applicant included, are called upon to conduct the business of the court in a manner that accords with the provisions of Article 159 (2)(b)of the Constitution, 2010. In short, I am not persuaded that the applicant has established and demonstrated sufficient cause. On the contrary, the conduct of the Applicant is one that cannot attract the intervention of Equity. Notably, equity aids the vigilant and not the indolent.

Paragraph 14 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

11. Thus, a proactive, diligent and an appellant keen to be heard on the appeal will engage the court within the allocated timelines. Sitting back with the view that one applied for typed proceedings and these have not been supplied, is being indolent. This does not aid justice.

Paragraph 11 →

12. Moreover, there is no gainsaying that court orders including the directions issued on the 10th April 2026 must be obeyed. Furthermore, it is common ground that where the orders of the court are not obeyed, the defaulting party must bear the consequences of such failure or neglect.

Paragraph 12 →

14. Other than the foregoing decision, it is also important to highlight that parties to court proceedings, the applicant included, are called upon to conduct the business of the court in a manner that accords with the provisions of Article 159 (2)(b)of the Constitution, 2010. In short, I am not persuaded that the applicant has established and demonstrated sufficient cause. On the contrary, the conduct of the Applicant is one that cannot attract the intervention of Equity. Notably, equity aids the vigilant and not the indolent.

Paragraph 14 →
Issue 2Whether the respondent should be held in contempt for allegedly frustrating the appellant’s access to typed proceedings and thereby preventing filing of the record of appeal.

Held. No. The contempt request was misplaced because the appellant did not identify a clear order served on the respondent that she wilfully disobeyed. The allegations that the respondent frustrated issuance of typed proceedings were unsubstantiated, and no connection was shown between any court order, its alleged disobedience, and the failure to file the record of appeal.

Ratio. Contempt requires proof of a clear court order applicable to the alleged contemnor and wilful disobedience of that order. Unsupported allegations, without a demonstrated nexus between the order and the alleged disobedience, cannot sustain contempt.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

15. On the issue of contempt, it goes without saying that the orders for contempt are misplaced. There is no order that was served on the respondent in relation to this appeal that the respondent has wilfully disobeyed as the allegation of her frustrating the issuance of typed proceedings are just not substantiated and even if they were, the applicant has not demonstrated what clear order of the court was disobeyed. There is no correlation to any court order issued and the disobedience of the same and how they have prevented the filing of the record of appeal.

Paragraph 15 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

15. On the issue of contempt, it goes without saying that the orders for contempt are misplaced. There is no order that was served on the respondent in relation to this appeal that the respondent has wilfully disobeyed as the allegation of her frustrating the issuance of typed proceedings are just not substantiated and even if they were, the applicant has not demonstrated what clear order of the court was disobeyed. There is no correlation to any court order issued and the disobedience of the same and how they have prevented the filing of the record of appeal.

Paragraph 15 →

17. The upshot of the foregoing is that the notice of motion application dated 13th May 2026 and amended on the same date is without merit and is hereby dismissed with no order as to costs.

Paragraph 17 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

15. On the issue of contempt, it goes without saying that the orders for contempt are misplaced. There is no order that was served on the respondent in relation to this appeal that the respondent has wilfully disobeyed as the allegation of her frustrating the issuance of typed proceedings are just not substantiated and even if they were, the applicant has not demonstrated what clear order of the court was disobeyed. There is no correlation to any court order issued and the disobedience of the same and how they have prevented the filing of the record of appeal.

Paragraph 15 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

The matter is coming up for determination on the Appellant’s Notice of Motion dated 13th May 2025 and amended on an even date seeking for orders that that the court do extend time for filing the record of appeal and hold the respondent in contempt of court.

Paragraph 1 →

Question before the court

Having considered the Notice of motion application and the replying affidavit filed the only substantial issue for determination is whether the application is merited.

Paragraph 8 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the appellant had shown sufficient cause to obtain an extension of time to file the record of appeal after the 30-day period directed by the court on 10 April 2026 had lapsed; and whether the respondent should be held in contempt for allegedly…

Material facts

Judith Nguhi Njenga filed a memorandum of appeal on 20 January 2025 but did not file a record of appeal. She sought more time, asserting that Peninah Njeri Ndobi, allegedly acting with a lower-court judicial officer identified as Sherry, frustrated her…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT

AT MILIMANI LAW COURTS, NAIROBI

ELCLA E009 OF 2025

JUDITH NGUHI NJENGA…………….………………..…..… APPLICANT/APPELLANT

-VERSUS-

PENINAH NJERI NDOBI………..……….….………………………….….RESPONDENT

RULING

Introduction

1. The matter is coming up for determination on the Appellant’s Notice of Motion dated 13th May 2025 and amended on an even date seeking for orders that that the court do extend time for filing the record of appeal and hold the respondent in contempt of court.

2. The application was premised on grounds that the appellant that failed to file her record of appeal within the 30 days as instructed by the court on the 10th April 2026 due to the fact that the respondent in coalition with one of the judicial officers maned Sherry from the lower court had frustrated her efforts of getting typed proceedings hence she could not have filed within time.

3. That the applicant has been requesting for the said proceedings since 2024 but the same has not been availed to her due to the actions of the respondent hence need to hold her in contempt for standing in the way of orders issued by the court which was for her to file the record of appeal.

4. The respondent opposed the application by a replying affidavit sworn on the 9th September 2026.She deponed the application was frivolous and an abuse of the court process pointing out to the fact that the appellant had been indolent in prosecuting her appeal. That the responsibility of filing the record of appeal was on the appellant and not her and she cannot fault her for delaying to file her appeal on unsubstantiated claims.

5. That the applicant has made amendments to the application to introduce a third party whom she accuses of conspiring with the respondent to prevent her from accessing the proceedings. That these allegations have been brought in an affidavit without any substantial proof and hence the affidavit ought to be struck out .

6. She further deponed that the applicant had not demonstrated contempt on her part.

7. None of the parties have filed their submissions despite the court directing so.

Analysis and determination

8. Having considered the Notice of motion application and the replying affidavit filed the only substantial issue for determination is whether the application is merited.

9. The applicant is seeking for more time to file the record of appeal after the 30 days given by the court had lapsed. It is her assertion that the delay in procuring proceedings from the lower court have prevented her from filing the appeal. I do note that the applicant filed her memorandum of appeal on the 20th January 2025 and since then there has been no effort from her end to prosecute the same appeal as she never filed a record of appeal. This court gave her 30 days to do so on 10th April 2026 within 30 days and has still failed to do so.

10. The apppealnt has not given any valid grounds why there has been a delay of close to 19 months now on why the record of appeal has not been filed. The applicant’s case is that she has not been supplied with typed proceedings in the case but has not attached any documentation to indicate she has done follow up. The appellant seeks to rely on letters dated 6th December 2024, 7th April 2025 and 11th April 2026 as prove she did reminder to the relevant persons in the lower court for proceedings. These all have a receiving stamp of the 13th April 2026 indicating the applicant only filed these documents on the 13th April 2026 after the court gave the directions on the 10th April 2026 for her to file record of appeal. Having perused the above-mentioned letters, I have no hesitation that these are actions of an indolent litigant and I am persuaded that the Appellant was not actively following for the proceedings.

11. Thus, a proactive, diligent and an appellant keen to be heard on the appeal will engage the court within the allocated timelines. Sitting back with the view that one applied for typed proceedings and these have not been supplied, is being indolent. This does not aid justice.

12. Moreover, there is no gainsaying that court orders including the directions issued on the 10th April 2026 must be obeyed. Furthermore, it is common ground that where the orders of the court are not obeyed, the defaulting party must bear the consequences of such failure or neglect.

13. In the case of Tana Teachers’ Cooperative and Credit Society Limited Vs Andriano Muchiri [2018] KECA 192 (KLR), the Court of Appeal highlighted the consequences of failing to comply with or abide by the directions/orders of the court.The court stated thus: Although parties are always in haste to invoke the “overriding principle” when seeking favourable exercise of discretion by the courts or covering up for some infractions they may have committed, they tend to forget that Section 1A (3) Civil Procedure Act as well as section 3A Appellate Jurisdiction Act enjoins them to assist the court in ensuring that court directions are complied with and that justice is dispensed expeditiously. A party cannot egregiously fail or refuse to comply with directions of the court claiming that the said directions were salutary and not accompanied by any sanctions and hope to seek refuge in the overriding principle. That in our view amounts to gross abuse of court process. There must be an end to litigation and it behoves this Court to tell the appellant that its journey ends at this point.’’

14. Other than the foregoing decision, it is also important to highlight that parties to court proceedings, the applicant included, are called upon to conduct the business of the court in a manner that accords with the provisions of Article 159 (2)(b)of the Constitution, 2010. In short, I am not persuaded that the applicant has established and demonstrated sufficient cause. On the contrary, the conduct of the Applicant is one that cannot attract the intervention of Equity. Notably, equity aids the vigilant and not the indolent.

15. On the issue of contempt, it goes without saying that the orders for contempt are misplaced. There is no order that was served on the respondent in relation to this appeal that the respondent has wilfully disobeyed as the allegation of her frustrating the issuance of typed proceedings are just not substantiated and even if they were, the applicant has not demonstrated what clear order of the court was disobeyed. There is no correlation to any court order issued and the disobedience of the same and how they have prevented the filing of the record of appeal.

16. Flowing from the foregoing, what becomes apparent is that theapplication herein is incompetent and therefore fails.

17. The upshot of the foregoing is that the notice of motion application dated 13th May 2026 and amended on the same date is without merit and is hereby dismissed with no order as to costs.

It is so ordered.

DATED, SIGNED and DELIVERED virtually at NAIROBI on this 19th day of October 2026.

MOHAMMED N. KULLOW

JUDGE

Ruling delivered in the presence of: -

Mr. Munyori for the Appellant/Applicant

Mr. Alekeen for the Respondent

Ms. Mwangi Court Assistant

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder