Land law

Mbatha & another v Nyaga & 2 others [2026] KEELC 6971 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Environment and Land Case E041 of 2026
Judgment date
21 October 2026
Judge(s)
C.K Nzili

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The preliminary objection was rejected. The court granted a temporary mandatory injunction compelling the 1st respondent to verify on the Business Registration Services portal the transfer of the 2nd respondent’s shares relating to House No. 11 on LR No. 1338/45 to the applicants. In default, the 3rd respondent was directed to dispense with the 1st respondent’s verification and register the transfer; alternatively, the Deputy Registrar was authorized to execute, verify or sign the necessary documents or electronic confirmations. Costs of the application were awarded to the applicants.

Supporting judgment passages

110. The law and the Justice of the matter call for the issuance of the relief sought in terms of;

Paragraph 110 →

i. Temporary mandatory injunction compelling the 1st respondent to verify through the Business Registration Services portal the transfer of the shares of the 2nd respondent relating to house No.11 erected on LR No. 1338/45 in favor of the applicants.

Passage 127 →

111. Costs of the application to the applicants.

Paragraph 111 →
Issue 1Whether the Environment and Land Court had jurisdiction over the dispute concerning verification and transfer of management-company shares associated with the applicants’ sectional-property unit, and whether the preliminary objection should succeed.

Held. Decided. The court held that the preliminary objection was misconceived, frivolous and without merit. The dispute concerned rights arising from sectional-property ownership: membership and management rights in the relevant corporation were integral to ownership and enjoyment of the unit, rather than an ordinary independent Companies Act share-transfer dispute. The ELC therefore had jurisdiction.

Ratio. Under the Sectional Properties Act, the applicable court for disputes concerning sectional-property corporations is the ELC, and the Companies Act does not govern management of common areas under that statutory scheme. Membership or shares associated with the corporation are an integral incident of unit ownership, not conventional company shares; a dispute over their transfer to a new unit owner is consequently a land/sectional-property dispute within the ELC’s remit.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

66. The real controversy before this court is whether or not the applicant accrued a right to ownership of land lawfully following the transfer and registration being lawfully impeded by the 1st respondent by failing to verify the onboarded documents at the BRS portal so that the applicant can formally assume shareholding rights which are consequential under the law for the newly registered land owners in the unit.

Paragraph 66 →

94. From the foregoing, it is quite evident that the preliminary objection raised by the 1st respondent does not satisfy the requirements of a preliminary objection under Mukisa Biscuits Manufacturing Company Limited Vs West End Distributors Limited [1969] EA 696, Amondi versus Airtel Network Kenya Limited and others, or in Njagi versus Muchiri and another (Supra).

Paragraph 94 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

94. From the foregoing, it is quite evident that the preliminary objection raised by the 1st respondent does not satisfy the requirements of a preliminary objection under Mukisa Biscuits Manufacturing Company Limited Vs West End Distributors Limited [1969] EA 696, Amondi versus Airtel Network Kenya Limited and others, or in Njagi versus Muchiri and another (Supra).

Paragraph 94 →

99. The jurisdiction to hear and determine those disputes under the sectional properties is not in this court and not in the High Court. The preliminary objection is misconceived, frivolous and lacks merit.

Paragraph 99 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

95. The jurisdiction to hear and determine disputes under the Sectional Properties Act 2020 is the ELC. The SPA excludes the operation of the Companies Act Cap 486 in the management of common areas under the SPA.

Paragraph 95 →

91. The corporation and its membership through shares earned by the unit owners is therefore an integral incident of sectional ownership but not an optional residential association which owners may elect to form or refuse to join. The shareholders have no conventional share capital or shares since the unit owners are the members by virtue of ownership of the units.

Paragraph 91 →

92. The share transfer therefore is different from shares in the company, as provided under the Companies Act 2015.

Paragraph 92 →
Issue 2Whether the applicants were entitled to a temporary mandatory injunction requiring verification and completion of the share transfer associated with their unit.

Held. Decided. The applicants satisfied the threshold for a mandatory injunction. The 1st respondent had signed the share-transfer documents, the applicants’ title and acquisition of the unit were unchallenged, and the 1st respondent supplied no legal justification for failing to verify the BRS-portal documents. The court ordered verification of the transfer, with default and alternative mechanisms for registration or execution by the 3rd respondent or Deputy Registrar, and awarded costs to the applicants.

Ratio. An interlocutory mandatory injunction is available only in special circumstances and clear cases. This was such a case because the applicants held unchallenged title, the 1st respondent had already signed the transfer, and withholding the final verification would frustrate accrued ownership and consequential management rights. Equity does not permit a party to frustrate rights arising from that party’s own completed act.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

100. As to the relief sought, in Sharif Abdi Hassan versus Napoli Jama Adam 2006 EK LR, the court cited with approval loca bail in International Finance Limited Vs Agro- exports and another [1986] 1 ALLER 901, that a mandatory injunction is not to be granted on an interlocutory application unless there are special circumstances and only in clear cases.

Paragraph 100 →

103. In this matter, the 1st respondent has already signed the transfer of shares in favor of the applicant, who holds title to the suit property. He has not given any legal justification why since 2025 has not verified the documents in the BRS portal.

Paragraph 103 →

104. He owes the applicant an obligation to approve, verify, and effect the transfer of shares while he pursues other remedies, as there are no rival orders in place barring the applicant from enjoying their full ownership rights, including management rights in the 2nd respondent, which rights are central in sectional property law.

Paragraph 104 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

110. The law and the Justice of the matter call for the issuance of the relief sought in terms of;

Paragraph 110 →

i. Temporary mandatory injunction compelling the 1st respondent to verify through the Business Registration Services portal the transfer of the shares of the 2nd respondent relating to house No.11 erected on LR No. 1338/45 in favor of the applicants.

Passage 127 →

111. Costs of the application to the applicants.

Paragraph 111 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

100. As to the relief sought, in Sharif Abdi Hassan versus Napoli Jama Adam 2006 EK LR, the court cited with approval loca bail in International Finance Limited Vs Agro- exports and another [1986] 1 ALLER 901, that a mandatory injunction is not to be granted on an interlocutory application unless there are special circumstances and only in clear cases.

Paragraph 100 →

104. He owes the applicant an obligation to approve, verify, and effect the transfer of shares while he pursues other remedies, as there are no rival orders in place barring the applicant from enjoying their full ownership rights, including management rights in the 2nd respondent, which rights are central in sectional property law.

Paragraph 104 →

107. Equity will not permit the 1st respondent to frustrate the accrued and registered rights of the Applicants. Equity will suffer no wrong without a remedy. A man shall not benefit from his own wrongdoing. As held in Macharia Mwanja Maina and others Vs David [2014] EKLR, equity detests unjust enrichment.

Paragraph 107 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

What is before the court is a Notice of Motion dated 13.7. 2026 and a preliminary objection dated 15. 9. 2026.

Paragraph 1 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

The court considered whether the Environment and Land Court had jurisdiction over a dispute concerning transfer and registration of management-company shares connected to House No. 11 on LR No. 1338/45; whether the respondents’ jurisdictional preliminary…

Material facts

The applicants said they became registered proprietors of House No. 11 after a chargee’s public auction and registered transfer. They contended that shares and membership rights in Estates Residences Limited, the management company, accompanied ownership of…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC NO E041 OF 2026

WILLIAM KIVUVANI MBATHA …………………… 1ST APPLICANT

DIANA WALKER KIVUVANI …………………….. 2ND APPLICANT

VERSUS

JOHN MUTURI NYAGA…………………………1ST RESPONDENT

ESTATES RESIDENCES LIMITED………………… 2ND RESPONDENT

THE REGISTRAR OF COMPANIES ……………. 3RD RESPONDENT

RULING

1. What is before the court is a Notice of Motion dated 13.7. 2026 and a preliminary objection dated 15. 9. 2026.

2. In the application, the court is asked, pending hearing and determination of the originating summons dated 29.6.2026, to issue;

1) Spent

2) Temporary mandatory injunction compelling the 1st respondent to verify through the Business Registration Services (BRS) portal the transfer of the shares of the 2nd respondent relating to house No.11 erected on LR No. 1338/45 in favor of the applicants.

3) Mandatory injunction compelling the 1st respondent to complete electronic verification of the transfer of the said shares through the BRS portal within 7 days or any other period the court may direct.

4) In default of compliance with prayer 3, the court to issue an order directing the third respondent to dispense with the very vacation by the 1st respondents and proceed to register the transfer of shares in favor of the Applicants on the BRS Portal.

5) In the alternative to the prayer above, the court is to authorize the Deputy Registrar of the court to execute, verify and/or sign documents, electronic confirmations or instruments necessary to complete the transfer and registration of the said shares in favor of the applicants.

3. The grounds are set out on the face of the application and in a supporting affidavit of Diana Walker Kevuvani, the 2nd applicant, sworn on 13.7.2026. The deponents contend that the Applicants are the registered proprietors of house No.11 erected on LR No.7338/45 following a public auction conducted pursuant to the exercise of this statutory power of sale by the interested party.

4. The applicant states that the registration of the transfer extinguished the 1st respondent's equity of redemption and all proprietary interest in the suit property.

5. The Applicant deposes that the shares in the 2nd respondent constitute an incident of ownership of the suit property and are intended to accompany the proprietary interest already vested in the applicants.

6. Through the share transfer instruments I've already been duly executed and lodged through the Business Registration Service, BPRS Portal, the only outstanding step is the electronic verification of the transfer by the 1st respondent, which is purely a ministerial and consequential act intended to perfect a transaction that has already been concluded.

7. The Applicants depose that without any lawful justification the 1st respondent has refused and/or neglected to complete the exercise thereby frustrating the applicants' accrued proprietary right.

8. The Applicants depose that equity will not permit the 1st respondent to derogate from its own act or to approbate and reprobate by executing the transfer documents while refusing to complete the administrative process necessary to perfect the transfer, and therefore urge the court to intervene.

9. The applicants have attached a copy of the registered lease, a copy of the registered transfer by the chargee following the auction, a screenshot of the BPRS evidencing commencement of transfer process, and copies of uploaded documents as annexures marked WKM 1, 2, 3 and 4.

10. The applicant depose that despite numerous request and or follow ups the 1st respondent has refused to approve, facilitate and or complete the process without any lawful bases whatsoever.

11. The applicant states that unless the court intervenes, they risk continued denial of the full incidence of ownership associated with the suit property.

12. The Applicants state that the ownership structure governing the development entitles them to the transfer, and registration shares and membership rights in the 2nd respondent, which are incidental and appurtenant to ownership of the suit property; hence the act of the respondent prevents them from being shareholders of the 2nd respondent.

13. The application is opposed through a preliminary objection dated 24.7.2026 that this is a matter involving transfer of shares, which this court lacks jurisdiction to handle. The applicant relies on written submissions dated 27.7.2026 and 10.9.2026, isolating the issues for the court's determination.

14. On a prima facie case, the applicant submits that they have met the test of reliance as placed on Mrao versus First American Bank of Kenya Limited and others [2003] KLR 175, Kamau versus Karanja (ELC No. 030 of 2022) [2022] KEELC 14425 (KLR)

15. The Applicants submit that they have bought the land, transfer of charge has been applied, registration share transfer documents were duly executed by the parties and uploaded to the BPRS portal, and despite all these, the 2nd respondent has denied or neglected to effect the complete process, preventing them from being shareholders of the 2nd respondent.

16. The Applicants submit that the respondent has not challenged the validity, nor alleged fraud, illegality, or raised any ground to impeach the title under section 26 of the L.R.A or advanced any lawful justification for withholding or for not completing the ministerial or administrative process.

17. On mandatory injunction, the applicant submits that there are exceptional circumstances, as this is one of the clearest cases for issuance of such an order. Since the electronic verification sought is neither discretionary nor complex, as it is the final administrative step required to align the register of members of the 2nd respondent with the legal reality created by the registered transfer by chargee.

18. Reliance is placed on Kenya breweries limited & another Versus Washington O. Okeyo [2002]KECA 284(KLR); Civil Appeal No. 332 of 2000;[2002] 1 EA 109 adopting the principle in Locabail International Finance Limited Vs Agroexport & Atlanta(UK) Ltd [1986] 1 ALL ER 901 on mandatory injunction unlike probatory injunction the applicant submit that it aims to compel a performance of a positive act as held in Patrick Roy Onyinsi Vs Rose Vugusta Lunda & another [2018]eKLR, ELC No. 253 of 2017.

19. The applicants submit that the present matter has all four elements required for issuance of such orders, namely special circumstances warranting immediate intervention since all the necessary steps save for the last ministerial step have been completed with no dispute as to land ownership or validity of the transfer instruments; the applicants only seek the court to compel a purely ministerial step after their ownership rights accrued immediately upon registration of the transfer by the charge, execution and lodging of the share transfer has happened and only what remains is for the verification so that the registration of the transaction can be completed.

20. The applicant submit that the orders sought don't require or compel the 1st respondent to enter into a transaction or to execute any fresh documents, which remain act is precisely the type of a simple and or summary act.

21. The applicant submits that the 1st respondent cannot rely upon an administrative process to defeat accrued proprietary rights since sections 24, 25 and 26 of the L.R.A recognize registration as the operative act through which proprietary rights vest and become indefeasible, subject only to statutory exception.

22. The applicants submit that after the transfer by chargee was affected ownership no longer vested in the 1st respondent, his equity of redemption was extinguished and hence retain no proprietary interest capable of instituting his refusal to verify the transfer of the shares associated with the suit property.

23. The applicants submit that to permit the 1st respondent to withhold electronic verification would enable him to use a procedural requirement within the BPRS platform to defeat rights that have already vested by operation of statute, contrary to sections 24, 25 and 26 of the LRA.

24. The applicant submits that section 507 of the Companies Act contemplates that upon presentation of a proper instrument of transfer, the company should register the transfer or communicate lawful reasons for refusing registration.

25. The Applicant submits that, under registration 80 and 81 of the Companies (General) Registration Act, the procedure for effective share transfer, it is submitted that the legal framework does not envisage a transfer frustrating that process by refusing to perform an administrative verification after execution of the transfer documents.

26. The applicants submit that the administrative mechanism established to facilitate compliance with the Companies Act cannot enlarge the proprietary rights of a transferor nor can it create it substantively, where none exists under the statute, making the respondents' refusal to verify the transfer, lacking legal foundation.

27. The applicant submits that equity will not permit the 1st respondent to frustrate his own completed acts, since it regards as done that which ought to be done, or require approbation and reprobation, or to derogate from his own acts.

28. Having voluntarily executed the share transfer instruments and thereby acknowledged the transfer of shares, it is submitted that the 1st respondent cannot refuse to perform the remaining step necessary to complete the transfer, and the court shall not allow procedural formalities to defeat the substantive right already vested in the applicant.

29. The applicant submits that if the orders issued, at this stage can approach the final hearing with a high degree of assurance that the mandatory orders issued will be vindicated given the documents availed and lack of lawful justification to refuse the verification.

30. The Applicant submits that, given the completed documentation and accrued proprietary rights upon registration of transfer by the chargee, the court's jurisdiction to intervene is necessary for the right attendant to ownership of the suit property to include the corresponding membership right to the 2nd respondent.

31. In this case, the title held by the Applicant has not been impeached in law by the respondent, and therefore the corporate record should now reflect that legal entity without the 1st respondent indefinitely frustrating the completion process.

32. The applicant submits that section 103 of the Companies Act empowers the court to order rectification of the register and to deal with all questions necessary or expedient to decide in connection with rectification, and in this case the only reason why the applicant names are missing in the register of members of the 2nd respondent is because of the withholding of verification by the 1st respondent. Reliance is placed on Sabljak Vs Business Registration Service (Misc App E124 of 2018)[2025]KEHC 3559 (KLR).

33. On the preliminary objection, the applicant submits that the case before the court is not founded on an independent dispute concerning the internal management, governance, directorship or affairs of the 2nd respondent.

34. It is submitted that the dispute arises from the applicants and registered ownership of the suit property and the consequential transfer of the shares in the management company which are attached to and arise from the ownership of this said property.

35. The applicants submit that the central question is therefore whether the 1st respondent, having lost ownership of the suit property following a lawful exercise of the chargee’s statutory power of sale and registration of the transfer by the chargee in favor of the applicants, may thereafter frustrate the applicants' acquisition of the corresponding shares and membership right attached to the suit property by refusing to complete the electronic verification required through the BRS portal. The Applicants submit that the question solely lies within the jurisdiction of this court.

36. The applicant submits that, through the respondent's counsel, the preliminary objection was orally raised on 15.9.2026; none has been filed in accordance with Order 51 Rule 14 CPR. That, notwithstanding the applicant submit that a prayer Preliminary objection property raises must accord with Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co.Ltd Vs West End Distributors Ltd [1969]EA 696, Njagi Vs Muchiri & Another [2024] KEELC 1812 (KLR), and Amondi Vs AIRTEL Network (K) Ltd & Others [2025] KEHC 11893(KLR).

37. The applicant submits that the orally intimated preliminary objection cannot be determined without considering the factual and legal relationship between the suit property, the applicant's registered title, management company, the shares attached to ownership of the suit property, the executed share transfer document, and the electronic verification required on the BRS Portal.

38. Therefore, it is submitted that the courts will have to examine the nature and substance of the applicant's claim before determining whether it is a land dispute, an independent company law dispute, or, in this case, goods concerning interest in land within section 13 of the ELC Act.

39. The applicant submits that the so-called preliminary objection cannot be determined by merely looking at the label “shares” and concluding that the court has no jurisdiction. The applicant submits that the proper approach is to examine the substance of the dispute and the relief sought.

40. In doing so, the applicant submits that the premise of the preliminary objection is faulty in that it is assumed that, because the applicant seeks, among other relief, an order relating to transfer and or registration of their shares in the 2nd respondents land dispute is thereby converted into a purely cooperate matter falling outside the jurisdiction of this court.

41. The applicant submits that the said proposition misconstrues both the nature of the applicant's claim and the breadth of the jurisdiction of the court as defined in Article 162 (2) (b) of the Constitution and section 13 of the ELC Act.

42. The applicant submits that the proper approach is to consider the substance and the dominant character of the dispute rather than isolating one consequential prayer from its circumstances giving rise to the proceedings.

43. The applicant submits that the circumstances leading to the dispute pursuant to its public auction, transfer by the chargee, execution and uploading of the share transfer automatically make the shareholding in question not an independent investment detached from the land, but a consequential step arising from and connected to the applicant's registered ownership of the subject property with the developments.

44. The applicant submits that their case would not exist but for their acquisition and registration as proprietor of the suit property. The applicant submits that the dispute is fraudulently rooted in their proprietary right in land and the consequential rights and incidents attaching to such ownership. The applicant submits that the fact that the implementation of those rights requires an entry to be made in the record of the management company does not, without more, directly confer jurisdiction on this court over the dispute. The applicant submits that section 103 of the Companies Act does not oust the jurisdiction of this court.

45. The applicant submits that the question for determination is not whether the present dispute has a corporate element but rather what is the predominant issue in the dispute and whether the issue relates to the use, occupation of/or title to land. Reliance is placed on Mediratta & 17 others Vs Karen Hills Limited & 2 others [2026] KEELC 684 (KLR) ELC No. E047 OF 2021, on the predominant purpose test.

46. In Owners of Motor Vessel “Lillian S” VS Caltex Oil (Kenya) Limited[1989]KLR 1;[1989]KECA 48 (KLR), the court said that jurisdiction is everything. What if a court of law puts down its tools? When a question of jurisdiction is raised, a court of law has to determine it in limine. See S.K Macharia & another Vs Kenya Commercial Bank Limited & 2 others [2012] KESC 8 (KLR) cannot arrogate to itself jurisdiction exceeding which is contested upon it by statute, constitution or both.

47. The jurisdiction remit of this court is governed by Article 162 (2) (b) of the Constitution as read together with section 13 of the ELC Act.

48. The oral objection raised by the respondent counsel makes it clear that the dispute before this court has nothing to do with land but transfer of shares, which fall within the jurisdiction of the High Court.

49. The applicant object on the same on the basis that the court should look at and apply the predominant issue test as that applicant shareholding in the 2nd respondent is in the circumstances of the present case, intranasally & connected to the ownership of the object matter.

50. Further, the court is told that the applicants are seeking to acquire shares in the 1st respondent as independent commercial investment; rather, the transfer of the relevant shareholding is a consequential step arising from their acquisition of the property and is intended to place them in the position ordinarily attaching to ownership of a unit within the developments.

51. The applicant submits that its complaint is that, notwithstanding their completed acquisition and registration as property owners, the 1st respondent has withheld their outstanding verification required for the completion of the transfer of the corresponding shareholding.

52. The applicant submits that aside the alleged obstruction is not as isolated dispute but concern that applicants ability to enjoy and perfect the right consequential upon their registered ownership of the property, placing the dispute squarely under the jurisdiction of this court.

53. The applicant submits that declining jurisdiction would result in fragmented adjudication of a single transaction, hence requiring parties to litigate different aspects of the same dispute before different forums.

54. The applicant submit that to hold that the courts has jurisdiction to determine proprietary right had not to grant the consequential relief necessary to give practical effect to those rights would effectively require them to commence separate proceeding before another forum in respect of the same transaction, hence occasion unnecessary duplication of proceedings, costs, evidence and exparte parties to it inconsistent determination on issues arising for the same factual and legal matrix as held in Bamboo Twist Limited Vs Tember & 14 others NLC (IP)[202]KEELC 13942(LR), Kenyan National Commission on Human Rights Vs Attorney General; IEBC and 16 others [2020] KESC 54 (KLR).

55. One way of looking at whether the court’s jurisdiction has properly been invoked is to look at the pleadings filed. The Originating Summons dated 29. 6. 2026 asks the court to answer 6 questions, among them;

• Whether the application having lawfully acquired the suit property through unreasonable and contrary to the applicant proprietary rights and if he declines, whether the courts can grant the five reliefs sought therein.

56. The law governing units of this nature is the Sectional Property Act 2020, and its Rules of 2021, to align with the Constitution, the Land Act, the Land Registration Act and the National Land Commission and registration of transfer pursuant to a statutory power of sale exercised by the interested party are entitled to transfer and registration of the corresponding share and or membership interest associated with the said property in the 2nd respondents and whether the refusal and/or failure of the 1st respondent to approve and or facility the said transfers is unlawful.

57. It is an Act of Parliament to provide for the division of buildings into units, the use and management of the units and common property. It aimed to simplify the process of registering sectional properties in Kenya. The Act provides for, inter alia, the division of buildings into units to be owned by individual proprietors.

58. The Act applies to apartments, flats, mansionettes, townhouses, or offices. Section 17 of the Act provides for registration and mandate of management companies by the owners that are not subject to the Companies Act 2015, as per section 17(6). The company consists of all those persons who are the owners of the units in the parcel.

59. The Act defines the court applicable as the ELC court. The duties and powers of the corporation are set out in sections 20 and 21 of the Act. Voting rights of the owner are governed by section 24 thereof.

60. The management corporation is responsible for maintaining shared SPAces to which unit owners, as shareholders, contribute through service charges. The unit holders have a distinct share in the common property. Once a sectional plan in any development is registered, the registrar is required to constitute the respective owners of the units into a corporation.

61. The corporation has several functions, including maintenance of common areas, insurance of the common property, administration of the by-laws of the concerned development, enforcement of the terms and conditions relating to the land on which the development is erected, and the establishment and maintenance of a fund for the corporation's expenses. Voting rights of the unit members are exercised during the AGM to elect a board of management.

62. The corporation is also an integral party in any tenancy arrangement involving a unit. The management can evict any tenant who contravenes the bylaws.

63. Section 54 (5) of the Land Registration Act, read together with section 13 (4) of the Sectional Properties Act, requires all long-term leases registered before the SPA to be geo-represented and registered in line with the SPA.

64. In this matter, the consent of the chargee to transfer the land to the applicant after the exercise of statutory power of sale and the transfer is not disputed by the respondent.

65. The lawfulness of the processes leading to the registration of the applicant as new owners of the unit is not challenged before this court by the 1st respondent. The same applies to whether the signing and uploading of the share transfer form by the 1st respondent in favor of the applicants as the new shareholders of the 2nd respondent, which is the management company envisaged by section 17 of the Sectional Properties Act 2020.

66. The real controversy before this court is whether or not the applicant accrued a right to ownership of land lawfully following the transfer and registration being lawfully impeded by the 1st respondent by failing to verify the onboarded documents at the BRS portal so that the applicant can formally assume shareholding rights which are consequential under the law for the newly registered land owners in the unit.

67. Under Rule 21 of the Sectional Properties Registration 2021, a management company, in respect of having term leases subject to conversion, has to wind up from the date of registration of the corporation.

68. Rule 24 relates to the registration of a corporation by the owners of the unit by filling Form SP-7 set out in the first schedule. The Registrar shall register the corporation and issue a certificate in Form No.SP-10.

69. In Khalid Hussein Rehman Versus Ahmed Jan Mohamed Suleiman Luhar[2022]KEELC 13714 (KLR), the court reasoned that when a person is purchasing an individual unit, he is expected to be made aware of the plan that was approved, the particular unit within the plan being sold and what would constitute common areas by the developer under section 43 of SPA otherwise to commence development otherwise than what the purchaser was shown would be illegal and unless with the consensus of its purchases of a unity who would stand to be affected by the new development.

70. On the management company, being unavailable to manage the common areas, the court said that the developer cannot be allowed to take advantage of the lapse to prejudice the purchaser of the existing units.

71. The court stopped the development until compliance with the SPA and therefore established a management company to make decisions on common areas. The decision affirms and underscores the protection of a communal property right in development involving sectional properties, the expectation and legal right of unit owners. See Damaris Nduta Gitau versus Harju Karsah Kanji [2007]eKLR Civil Case No. 1316 of 2002.

72. From the pleadings filed, there is no dispute that what remains at the tail end is the verification by the 1st respondent of the document he has signed to effect the transfer of shares to the management company, the 2nd respondent, after he has formally relinquished his proprietary rights through Form No. LR A (9) and Form No. LR A (6).

73. The record shows that the transfer of shares or stock in favor of the applicant was extended by the 1st respondent on 8.7.2025 and lodged with the collector of stamp duty on 10 .7. 2025 in terms of Form D.

74. Board resolution dated 16.6.2025 from the 2nd respondent accompanied the said transfer form. The 1st respondent does not dispute signing the transfer of shares form to transfer the certificate of shares issued by the 2nd respondent dated 10.12.2026.

75. Appurtenance under Black Laws Dictionary means belonging to, accessory or incident to, adjunct, appointed or annexed to. It refers to something that, while technically detachable, is so fundamental to something else that it should be regarded as part of it.

76. Appurtenance is in the context of property and means privileges or improvements that belong to and pass with real property. The distinction between the Sectional Properties Act 2020 and the old 1987 edition lies in the governance structure; the latter does not mandate the formation of a corporation.

77. Previously, the property management was entrusted to management companies whose responsibilities included payment of statutory outgoings, management of common areas, and provision of common services.

78. Due to the dispute over control, financial management, and weak enforcement mechanisms, the SPA 2020 has clearly defined the mandate of the corporation so as to protect the individual unit owners. Previously, a manager would be appointed to manage the property, manage common areas, collect service charges, resolve disputes among owners, enforce the bylaws, repair & maintain the property, and offer essential services such as security, waste management, and utilities.

79. Under the SPA, managers are appointed at the discretion of the Board. The general responsibility of management is now left with the Board of Directors. This increases accountability, ensures compliance with bylaws, and ensures statutory compliance.

80. The SPA provides a faster, cost-effective, and less adversarial dispute resolution mechanism, as it establishes an internal dispute resolution committee whose decisions are now applicable to the ELC and not to the Business Premises Rents Tribunal. Previously, management companies took advantage of dealing with common areas without involving unit owners. The SPA now prevents unilateral decisions by the management companies and ensures that decisions affecting common areas are made in accordance with the bylaw.

81. The Act requires the court to approve any material change in the use or density of the common property or areas. The SPA expressly permits the corporation to integrate technology into its operations, including digital voting and communication to enhance efficiency, transparency, and accessibility. Active participation of unit owners in Kenya is in line with Article 10 of the Constitution.

82. The key characteristics of Sectional Property are individual ownership, shared ownership of common property, and registration of sectional title. Unit owners have collective share and management of common areas such as lifts, gardens, parking lots, corridors, and recreation facilities.

83. Owners have the right to participate in decision-making regarding the use, maintenance, and improvement of the shared areas. Voting rights in the homeowners association ensure that there is equitable participation in management decisions, inter alia, on management fees, repairs, and the overall building management through the management committee, so as to enable transparency and fair allocation of resources for the common property upkeep.

84. The sectional properties resolution 2021 was also brought by legal notice No. 236 of 2021. They cover the corporation creation, board of governors disputes resolution, and penalties.

85. It is the management corporation that manages common property on behalf of all unit owners under section 6 of the SPA share certificate. The registrar, on opening a register for a unit under section 5 of the SPA, has to include, in that register, the share in the common property apportioned to the owner of that unit on the title deed for the sectional property issued in respect of the unit.

86. The common property comprised in the sectional plan shall be held by the owners of all the units as tenants in common in share proportional to the unit factors for their respective units.

87. Unlike a company registered under the Companies Act, a corporation under SPA does not carry out commercial business to generate profits. Its mandate is strictly to manage, administer, and maintain the common property for the mutual benefit of all unit owners.

88. The corporation is founded and governed under sections 17 to 42 of the SPA as read together with the 2021 registration. Section 17(1) of the SPA says that the corporation is constituted on registration under section 43 of the sectional plan.

89. It is therefore not formed through an ordinary company. The incorporation process under the Companies Act, Form SPA, requires that a licensed surveyor prepare the sectional plan, identify the units, present the application for registration of the corporation, list of owners, close the register of the mother title, open a separate register, and issue a certificate of title or lease for each unit and simultaneously issue a certificate of registration of the corporation in Form SP-10.

90. Once registered, the corporation is automatically governed by the standard bylaws set out in the rules. Under section 17(1) of the Act, the corporation is therefore statutory rather than contractual.

91. The corporation and its membership through shares earned by the unit owners is therefore an integral incident of sectional ownership but not an optional residential association which owners may elect to form or refuse to join. The shareholders have no conventional share capital or shares since the unit owners are the members by virtue of ownership of the units.

92. The share transfer therefore is different from shares in the company, as provided under the Companies Act 2015.

93. In the set up of the Memorandum of Association and Articles of Association under section 323, 499, 503 as read together with the Companies (General) Regulations 2015.

94. From the foregoing, it is quite evident that the preliminary objection raised by the 1st respondent does not satisfy the requirements of a preliminary objection under Mukisa Biscuits Manufacturing Company Limited Vs West End Distributors Limited [1969] EA 696, Amondi versus Airtel Network Kenya Limited and others, or in Njagi versus Muchiri and another (Supra).

95. The jurisdiction to hear and determine disputes under the Sectional Properties Act 2020 is the ELC. The SPA excludes the operation of the Companies Act Cap 486 in the management of common areas under the SPA.

96. In the Medirrata case (Supra), the courts held that the dispute, issue, and the relief sought flew from and were incidental to the leasehold arrangement. The court cited with approval Pumwani Rigadhi Mosque Committee and another Vs the Gikomba Business Center Limited [2025] KECA 257 KLR, which held that a dispute arising from a lease agreement constitutes a matter relating to the use of land within the meaning of Article 162 (2) (b) of the Constitution.

97. In this matter, the concept of management rights, shares in the management corporation, and share certificate transfer in sectional property require, in my view, facts within the concept of property as a bundle of sticks, conferring on unit owners not only the right of possession, occupation, use, exclusive transfer, and enjoyment but also ownership and management of common areas.

98. Articles 40 and 60 1 a,b,c,d and e and of the constitution cover those bundle of rights. The right to belong to a management corporation within the context of sectional property law makes the transfer of the shares to a new unit owner central and not incidental or appurtenant to the full use & enjoyment of ownership of the property.

99. The jurisdiction to hear and determine those disputes under the sectional properties is not in this court and not in the High Court. The preliminary objection is misconceived, frivolous and lacks merit.

100. As to the relief sought, in Sharif Abdi Hassan versus Napoli Jama Adam 2006 EK LR, the court cited with approval loca bail in International Finance Limited Vs Agro- exports and another [1986] 1 ALLER 901, that a mandatory injunction is not to be granted on an interlocutory application unless there are special circumstances and only in clear cases.

101. In Kenya Breweries Limited Vs Washington Ok Okego [2002] EKLR, the court said that it can be granted if the defendant attempted to steal a match from the plaintiff. In Mudhyan Versus Wema Transporters and others [2025] KESCA 1152 (KLR), the appellant had not disputed his obligation to the 4th and 5th respondents who held title to the suit property.

102. The court said that it was the appellant's obligation to vacate the land once it was sold at the fall of the hammer and was transferred to third parties. The court said that it was not prudent to allow the appellant to steal a match against the 4th and 5th respondents simply because he disputed the sale.

103. In this matter, the 1st respondent has already signed the transfer of shares in favor of the applicant, who holds title to the suit property. He has not given any legal justification why since 2025 has not verified the documents in the BRS portal.

104. He owes the applicant an obligation to approve, verify, and effect the transfer of shares while he pursues other remedies, as there are no rival orders in place barring the applicant from enjoying their full ownership rights, including management rights in the 2nd respondent, which rights are central in sectional property law.

105. The applicant has met the threshold in Mrao Limited Vs First American Bank of Kenya Limited & others [2013] 5 KLR and in Nguruman Limited Vs Jan Nielsen and others [2014] KLR.

106. The property title they hold has not been challenged under section 26(6) of the Land Registration Act. As bona fide purchasers, they are covered by section 99 of the Land Registration Act.

107. Equity will not permit the 1st respondent to frustrate the accrued and registered rights of the Applicants. Equity will suffer no wrong without a remedy. A man shall not benefit from his own wrongdoing. As held in Macharia Mwanja Maina and others Vs David [2014] EKLR, equity detests unjust enrichment.

108. The principles of equity as held in Sha and others vS Mombasa Bricking Limited are part of Kenyan law. They anchor the principle that equity treats as done that which ought to have been done. In Kiptum Vs Borir and another [2023] case a 484 KLR the courts issued a mandatory order directing the transfer to the appellant failure of which the transfer shall be effected by the Dr of the ELC.

109. The 1st respondent, under the doctrine of proprietary estoppel and constructive trust, cannot rely on the earlier representation when signing the transfer of shares. He cannot be allowed to disavow the premise and frustrate the transfer at its tail end. He cannot be heard to assert something contrary to what is implied by his previous action or statement in signing the transfer. The court cannot aid a mischief-maker or a contract breaker. As held in Hannah Mugure Karago Peter Vs Karuru Waweru and another [2016] KLR, the court should not provide judicial approval to a dishonest person lacking integrity or to approve plainly unjust acts. In the face of an injustice such as shown by the act of the 1st respondent, the court opts not to wring its hands and emit important signs in the face of such an injustice.

110. The law and the Justice of the matter call for the issuance of the relief sought in terms of;

i. Temporary mandatory injunction compelling the 1st respondent to verify through the Business Registration Services portal the transfer of the shares of the 2nd respondent relating to house No.11 erected on LR No. 1338/45 in favor of the applicants.

ii. In default of compliance with prayer 3, the court to issue an order directing the third respondent to dispense with the very vacation by the 1st respondents and proceed to register the transfer of shares in favor of the Applicants on the Business Registration Services Portal.

iii. In the alternative to the prayer above, the court is prayed to authorize the Deputy Registrar of the court to execute, verify and/or sign documents, electronic confirmations or instruments necessary to complete the transfer and registration of the said shares in favor of the applicants.

111. Costs of the application to the applicants.

112. Orders accordingly

Dated, signed and delivered this 21ST day of October,2026 at Milimani, Nairobi.

Hon.Justice C.K Nzili

Judge

In the presence of;

Mr. Akumu for the plaintiff

Court Assistant: Julius

Legal Researcher: Bevalyn N.

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder