Background
Before the court is an application dated 23.9.2025; the court is asked to:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
Before the court is an application dated 23.9.2025; the court is asked to:
Paragraph 1 →The plaintiff states that the applicant has no cause of action against the estate of late Wamburu Kariuki as the issue of land ownership was not sold by the deceased as the legal owner.
Paragraph 19 →The application is dismissed with costs.
Paragraph 69 →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC SUIT NO. 1120 OF 2014
(FORMERLY HCC SUIT NO. 1549 OF 1985)
WAMBURU KARIUKI ………………………………… PLAINTIFF
VERSUS
WAMBUI KOIGI …………….…………………….1ST DEFENDANT
GITHINJI WA CHEGE …………………………….2ND DEFENDANT
Ruling
1. Before the court is an application dated 23.9.2025; the court is asked to:
i. Spent
ii. Joinder of Nduta Mutonga and Ambrose Koigi Wambura in place of Wambura Kariuki (deceased).
iii. Setting aside the judgment delivered on 24.6.2021 and all subsequent orders.
iv. An order restraining the proposed parties from selling or demolishing the interested parties’ structures on Title No. Ngenda /Gatukuyu/T/258.
v. Leave for the interested party to join as a defendant.
vi. Hearing of the matters de novo and on merit.
2. The grounds are set out on the face of the application and in two supporting affidavits of Michael Njega Koigi and George Njuguna Ngare sworn on 23.9.2025.
3. The 1st deponent says that he is the son of Wambui Koigi, the 1st defendant, who is not mentally capable of swearing an affidavit due to sickness and hence has appointed him as guardian ad litem as per order annexed as MNK (1).
4. The 1st deponent says that during the proceedings of this case, his mother was incapable of testifying due to dementia, as was observed on the day she tried to do so, and hence was not heard, contrary to her constitutional rights and due process.
5. The 1st deponent says that the judgment against her was entered without having her and should be set aside so that she can testify through him.
6. The 1st deponent states that his mother and family interest in the Suitland makes the joinder necessary and for him to be heard before the case is finalised.
7. The 2nd deponent says that he occupies and has developed extensively the suit property, which he inherited from his mother, now deceased and built a house therein in 1985, followed by other buildings later on, which currently contain a one-three bedroom, self-contained residential house, where he resides with his family, and five one-bedroom rental rooms.
8. The deponent says he charges ksh 1000/= rent per month and a semi-permanent church which pays him KSh 2,500/= per month; which are all served by solar energy. He says that he has also constructed three pit latrines and two bathrooms used by the tenant.
9. The interested party says that when developing the land, both he and the late mother were under a mistaken belief that they were developing LR No. Ngenda /Katukuyu/T.241 and not the Suitland, and that his mother passed on knowing she had put up a building on the aforesaid parcel, until the unfortunate facts were disclosed to him in 2015, when he applied for electricity from KPLC, who refused to supply power for he was not the owner of the suit land.
10. The interested party says that upon the discovery, he caused a search to locate the same, only to establish further that the 2nd defendant was the one occupying Title No. 241, which he had also mistakenly taken to be Title No. 258, and developed the same.
11. The interested party states that he embarked on engaging and negotiating with the 2nd defendant on how to swap the numbers so that each can take their rightful parcel, with a possibility of compensation for one who had developed his more than the others, for the parcels are of the same size, near each other, even though he has developed his more than the other occupied by the 2nd defendant. He attaches a copy of the mutation as annexure marked GNN (1).
12. The interested party says that unfortunately, the 2nd defendant passed on 28.5.2022, before they could settle, whereafter his late wife took out legal representation as per annexure marked GNN (2)
13. The interested party says that on 5.12.2023, a DCI officer from Kamwangi police station came to the land; he had just finished developing a chicken shaft and told him the land he was occupying belonged to the plaintiff as per the judgment of 24.6.2021, whereafter he filed an application dated 15.1.2024 which this court struck out.
14. The interested party says that upon learning of the death of the plaintiffs, he caused citation proceedings to be mounted against her dependent as per annexure, marked GNN (3).
15. The interested party says that all these occupation and development have been in the knowledge of the deceased plaintiff. The interested party says that it is therefore just and constitutionally right for the prayers sought to be allowed and at least he be heard together with the other parties on merits, for he has a good defence as per annexure marked GNN (4).
16. The interested party says that while he was trying to prosecute the citation, he was shown a title as per annexure GNN (5), indicating that the proposed parties are the joint owners of the land, who have, through the chief, given him 90 days to vacate the land, as per annexure marked GNN (6).
17. The application is opposed by the plaintiff through ground of application dated 29.11.2025 on the ground of inordinate delays of 4 years, for lack of similar prayers by the interested party for awareness of the suit since 1985, for being served and ignoring the orders during the lifetime of the deceased plaintiff, for transfer of the land after the orders of 24.6.2021 to the deceased before passing on 22.1.2023 after which the land was bequeathed to the beneficiaries and conformed on 10.7.2025, for being overtaken by events, bad in law as joinder cannot be done after a decree has been issued, for the court being functus officio making the applicant and the interested party incapable of enjoying review or appeals and lastly for not raising any objection during the succession proceedings.
18. Further, the plaintiff faults the manner in which the 1st & 2nd defendants were substituted and joined without leave of court.
19. The plaintiff states that the applicant has no cause of action against the estate of late Wamburu Kariuki as the issue of land ownership was not sold by the deceased as the legal owner.
20. The plaintiff further states that the applicant has filed Thika ELC No. E 225 of 2025 seeking the same orders hence is on forum shipping exerciser. The plaintiff states that how the applicant acquired this land cannot be determined in a suit whose judgment has been rendered, which he has already sold anyway.
21. The plaintiff states that the applicant built on the land well aware of the suit since 1985 and cannot therefore feign ignorance that he was constructing on land not belonging to him.
22. The applicant relies on written submissions dated 19.1.2026 isolating two issues for determination namely whether there should be joinder, and two whether the judgment should be set aside. It is submitted that the law cited allows for such relief in furtherance of the overriding objective of the court to facilitate the just, expeditious, proportionate and affordable resolution of disputes and for the end of justice to be met.
23. The applicant submits that section 34 of the Civil Procedure Act gives the interested party and the applicant the right to approach its court for redress and to institute a separate suit. The applicant & the interested party submit that there is no evidence that they were aware of the suit since 1985 to its determination now, facing execution against them. Reliance is placed on Ngororo vs Ndutha & Another [1994] eKLR, Tanga Gas Distributors Limited vs Mohamed Salim Said & 2 Others [2014] EA 448, Lillian Wairimu Ngatho & Another vs Moki Savings Cooperative Society Limited & others [2014] eKLR, ELC No. 745 of 2001 (Originating Summons).
24. The applicant & interested party submit that though they had cited the beneficiary on 14.1.2025, they were not served with the succession proceedings before issuance of the letters of administration on 22.4.2025, making the process just like in this suit, served, and an abuse of the court process.
25. The plaintiff relies on written submission dated 29.1.2026 isolating two issues for determination, namely whether the court is functus officio to join the interested party & the intended parties, and if the judgment should be set aside for the case to state de novo. Reliance is placed on Raila Odinga Vs Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 3 others [2013] eKLR ; [2013] KESC 6 (KLR), Kenya Airport Authority vs Mitu Bell Welfare Society & 2 others [2016] eKLR, Civil Appeal No.218 of 2014 (Court of Appeal, Nairobi).
26. In this case, it is submitted that the avenues of review, revision or appeal were not taken up and, as such, the judgment of the court stands, ending the jurisdictional competence of this court.
27. The plaintiff submits that the interested Partys’ applicant was dismissed which he has not appealed against to mitigate the alleged potential loss and that the order sought can only arise during a pending litigation and not after under Order 1 Rule 10(2) Civil Procedure Rule. Reliance is placed on Michael Munene Njogu & 2 Others vs Bernard Githinji & 2 others; Lawrence Wachira Ngiricha & 4 Others (Interested Party) ELC No. 151 of 2013 [2025] KEELC 936 (KLR), Florence Nafula Ayodi & 5 Others vs Jonathan Ayodi Ligure & John Tabalya Mukite & another; Benson Girenge Kidiavai & 67 others [2021] KEELC 1476 (KLR), Leonard Kimeu Mwanthi vs Rukaria M’twerandu M’iringu; Nathaniel Kithinji Ikiugu & 4 others (Intended interested parties ) [2021] eKLR.
28. The plaintiff submits that the judgment was entered after a protracted litigation of 36 years between 1985 & 2021, conclusively addressing the dispute issues over breach of trust resulting in the unlawful transfer of the plaintiffs’ land; therefore, there are no new issues to disturb it after a decree was served in 2022, since litigation must come to an end. The plaintiff submits that the application before the court is not only overtaken by events but also lacks basis because the suit should be reopened.
29. This suit was commenced by a plaint dated 23.5.1985 in which the plaintiff sued the 1st defendant, his brother and the 2nd defendant, a brother-in-law, the latter being the registered owner of the Suitland, initially registered in the name of the 1st defendant as the elder brother to hold in trust for the family and himself.
30. The plaintiff sought retransfer of the land from the 2nd defendant to himself and stoppage of interference with this land by the 2nd defendant. By an order dated 4.11.1991, an injunction was issued against the defendants from interfering with the land.
31. Through an application dated 18.8.1992, the initial 1st defendant was replaced after his demise by Wambui Koigi, a legal representative. Another application dated 29.4.1994 was also filed to invalidate the sale & transfer for the 1st & 2nd defendant and for the register to be rectified afterward the record shows that Wambui Koigi applied through an application dated 31.10.2001 to have the suit struck out for non-prosecution even though in paragraph 5 of the supporting affidavit she was saying that she is not a legal representative of her husband the 1st defendant after he passed on 30.1.1992. She was saying that the plaintiff had failed to amend the plaint to join her.
32. She was also asking for the matter to be referred to a tribunal. The record shows the parties filed agreed issues dated 6.12.2007.
33. On 9.10.2009, the defendant's advocate filed an application seeking to withdraw from acting for lack of instruction from Wambui Koigi. A similar withdrawal notice was also filed, dated 3.3.2011.
34. The record shows that Wambui Koigi also filed a witness statement dated 24.2.2012 explaining the history of the Suitland equally; one Kamau Mburu signed a witness statement dated 1.3.2012 supporting the 1st defendant’s case.
35. By an application dated 6.4.2018, the defendants sought to set aside proceedings & orders issued on 16.11.2017 and for the 1st defendant to give her evidence. The affidavit in support was sworn by Jacinta Wambui Koigi, attaching a medical report dated 22.2.2018. The application was allowed by consent filed on 19.7.2019, and a defence has been given.
36. The record shows that Githinji wa Chege testified as DW1 while Gabriel Kamau testified as DW 2. The record does not indicate why the 1st defendant, despite seeking re-opening of her case, did not attend court to testify in person, though she called DW2.
37. Similarly, the record shows that despite being directed to file written submissions, the 1st defendant did not.
38. At paragraph 6 of the judgment, the court made a finding that the 1st defendant and her witness DW 2 admitted they were to share the land with the deceased plaintiff as a brother.
39. The court made a finding that there was an element of trust and that parcel No. T258 belonged to the plaintiff. On possession between 1958 & 1985, the court made a finding that when the 2nd defendant entered the land and erected rental houses, the plaintiff was in occupation with a house therein.
40. The court also made a finding that the 1st & 2nd defendants breached the trust. On joinder of the Wambui Koiga, the court made a finding that this was due to a chamber summons dated 19.10.1992 which was allowed on 4.12.1992.
41. Following the judgment, an interested party, now the 2nd deponent, filed an application dated 15.1.2024 which, by a ruling dated 19.9.2024, was dismissed. It sought setting aside of the judgment dated 24.6.2021; leave to join as a defendant, and for the suit to start de novo. Similar grounds as in the instrument application were advanced by the 2nd deponent in that application. A draft defence had also been attached as in the instant application.
42. In paragraphs 14, 15, 16, & 17, the court addressed itself on the issue of a cause of adverse possession.
43. It made specific findings inter alia on the independence of the cause of action in this matter, issues of undue delay, lack of knowledge by the mother of the case and alleged occupation since 1985, occupation & developments on the wrong parcel of land, discovery of the mix-up, truthfulness of the 2nd deponent.
44. From the foregoing record of this court, unfortunately, the same law firm which represented the 2nd deponent in the application dated 15.1.2024 seeking similar orders as in the instant suit based on similar facts, grounds and circumstances has opted through the 1st deponent now as the applicant, with the support of the 2nd deponent, who lost in the initial application for joinder as defendant, has come back to court seeking almost similar orders before the same court.
45. The court has looked at the entire record since 1985 to the entry of judgment; the alleged new facts being advanced by the two deponents are at variance with the affidavits and witness statement on record by Wambui Koigi and her witness dated 24.2.2012 and 1.3.2012.
46. The alleged issue of sickness like dementia of the defendant such that she was mentally infirm is strange if not laughable. Her own affidavit sworn on 6.4.2018 seeking re-opening of her defence attached a medical report dated 21.2.2018 which did not disclose dementia but prolonged intravascular coagulation disorder and compound fracture of lower limb. Mental sickness is governed by the Mental Health Act.
47. The grant of guardian ad litem order is recent. There is nothing to show such an incapacity on the part of the defendant in 2017/2018. Court records do not show her then lawyer bringing it to the attention of the court that the 1st defendant was mentally incapacitated, for one to blame the court for denying her constitutional right to a fair hearing. To say that the judgment was entered without her participation is false, as her own witnesses testified on her behalf before the court.
48. The applicant does not say where he was throughout the history of this matter from 1985 to 2024, as he now says he should testify on the defendant’s behalf. The record since 1985 does not support the assertion by the applicant that the land was occupied by someone other than the initial plaintiff and the 2nd defendant.
49. The 1st defendant never expressly and in writing pleaded that she was living on the land with her family. The contents of the affidavit by the 2nd deponent were disbelieved by the court; hence the ruling dated 19.9.2024. That ruling has not been set aside, reviewed or appealed against. A specific finding was also made which the applicant now wants the court to revisit.
50. In Borop Multipurpose Co-operative Society Limited (Interested Party) vs Doune Farm Limited & 6 others [2026]KECA 2082 (KLR) (civil APPEAL) E083 OF 2021, Court of Appeal judgment delivered on 2ND October 2026, the court said that it is not the form in which the suit is framed that determines whether a suit is sub judice; rather, it is the substance, and that there can be no justification on having two suits being head parallel to each other.
51. The court said that an interested party is joined because he has a proximate stake or will suffer prejudice if left out, and if the interested party’s claim requires the court to grant them separate stand-alone reliefs, against the original plaintiff or defendant, that do not naturally arise from the existing pleadings, the court will direct them to file a separate suit.
52. On res judicata, the court said it is trite law that if any judicial tribunal in the exercise of its jurisdiction delivers a judgment or a ruling which in its very nature is final and conclusive, the judgment or ruling is res judicata, and if any subsequent proceedings in the same or any other judgment tribunal, any fact or right which was determined by the earlier judgment is called in question, the defence of res judicata can be raised as an estoppel in the subsequent case.
53. The court said that res judicata is one of the factors limiting the jurisdiction of the court. The court said that the doctrine requires that there should be an end to litigation or conclusiveness of judgment where a court has decided and issued the judgment; hence, parties should not be allowed to litigate over the same issues again, for one decision is ought to avoid many decisions, give finality. The court said that the doctrine can apply to both a question of fact and a question of law.
54. The court cited with approval Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission VS Maina Kiai & 5 others [2017] eKLR, Civil Appeal No 105 of 2017, Court of Appeal at Nairobi, judgment delivered on 23 June,2017, that the rule is that a party must bring his whole case to court; a party cannot be allowed to litigate in instalment and therefore, if he fails to put his best foot forward, he cannot blame the court or seek a second bite at the cherry, otherwise it will amount to an abuse of the court process.
55. In this application, the applicant is saying that if he is joined, his intended defence raises new issues and is also seeking reliefs on matters in the interest of justice requiring consideration by the court. A party cannot evade the doctrine of res judicata by giving a cosmetic lift to an earlier similar suit or application, or through adding new parties.
56. In Gahuri Vs Nyaga & another (Civil Appeal (Application E037 of 2026 [2026] KECA 1571 (KLR) (31ST July 2026) (Ruling), the court cited with approval K. Kemboi vs Isaac K. Marta & another, J.K.Ruto (objector) [2025] KECA 838 (KLR) that no court of law can knowingly grant an order which will serve no utilitarian purpose and that court of law loathe engaging in a futile exercise.
57. The applicants' alleged stake or interest in the suit land, other than mere assertions, is not demonstrated by any tangible or concrete evidence. Inheritance for the 1st defendant is a matter of law. One cannot give what he does not own.
58. The 1st defendant asserted no better title to the Suitland in her statement of defence. She had no capacity to transmit the suit land to the applicant if she never owned it in the first instance. As held in Francis Karioki Muruatetu & another vs Republic & 5 others [2016] KESC 12 (KLR), an interested party must demonstrate a stake. A court may refuse joinder of an interested party if he or she lacks a demonstrable stake.
59. The applicant similarly cannot be heard to urge the 2nd deponent who lost his own fight to be joined as a defendant. As to joinder post-judgment, the same was addressed in Everton Coal Enterprises Limited v Karanja & others [2023] KESC 98 (KLR). The court said that joinder contemplates a situation where proceedings are still pending before the court, in order to enable the court to adjudicate fully upon and settle all the questions involved in a particular proceeding before it. The court declined to join the parties four years after the judgment.
60. The court cited JMK Vs MWM & another [2015] EKLR that it is only when a suit or proceedings is pending that joinder occurs; otherwise, after final disposal, it is nothing more to be done, and the rule becomes inapplicable.
61. Regarding the submission that the court is functus officio, in Kenya Airport Authority vs Mitu-Bell Welfare Society & others (supra), the court pronounced itself on the functus officio doctrine and its elements, which include finality of issues determination.
62. In this matter, the court has already resolved all the contested issues and settled the rights and liabilities of the original parties that were before it, including against the 1st defendant. The 1st defendant has not appealed or applied for review of the judgment. She cannot use proxies to make a collateral attack on the process leading to the judgment in the name of advancing another defence to fill in gaps in the previous defence, which the court made a final determination on the merits, or crafting or attempting such creativity to seek joinder of a party after judgment or seeking to re-open the matter.
63. As held in Bellevue Development Company Limited vs Vinayak Builders Limited & Another [2014] eKLR Civil Case No. 571 of 2011 HCC; in a concluded matter, such an application may not help the applicant.
64. It has been deposed that the applicant has another pending suit in Thika seeking similar prayers as in this application. The doctrine of sub judice bars the court from handling such an application in the circumstances until the first matter to be filed is heard and determined. The application is therefore an abuse of the court process.
65. On whether restraining orders can be granted post-judgment, the rights of the parties in the primary suit have been determined through a regular judgment. The plaintiff now holds title to the land with right under Article 40 of the Constitution and sections 24, 25 & 26 of the Land Registration Act.
66. The title held by the decree holders has not been impeached by the applicant or the judgment debtors. See Dr Joseph N.K Arap Ngok Vs Justice Moijo Ole Keiwua & 5 others [1997] eKLR. The applicant has not met the tests in Giella vs Cassman Brown Company Limited [1973] EA 358. There is nothing belonging to the applicant to preserve. No valuation report or photograph has been attached to show occupation or development on the suit land.
67. The object of an injunction pending appeal or post-judgment is to preserve the subject matter to ensure the appeal, if successful, is not rendered nugatory, as held in Julius Musili Kyunga Vs KCB Ltd & 2 others [2015] eKLR and in Patricia Njeri & others Vs National Museums of Kenya [2004] KEHC 1614 (KLR), Civil Appeal No. 492 of 2004.
68. The applicant has no pending appeal. The court has made a finding that he holds no superior rights or independent claim in this matter worthy of protection.The court has found no merits in the applicant’s application. He cannot purport to reap where he has not sowed.
69. The application is dismissed with costs.
Dated, signed and delivered on this 21st day of October, 2026 in Milimani – Nairobi.
HON JUSTICE C.K NZILI
JUDGE
In the presence of;
Court assistant: Julius
Legal Researcher ; Bevalyn N.