Background
What is before the Court for determination is the Applicants’ Notice of Motion application dated 5th March 2026 in which they seek the following Orders:
Paragraph 1 →Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in
The court upheld the 2nd Respondent’s preliminary objection, found the miscellaneous cause incompetent because the substantive land-ownership and trespass dispute, including the injunction requests, had to be commenced by plaint rather than through a miscellaneous cause, and struck out the cause with costs to the 2nd Respondent.
23. In the circumstances, I find the Notice of Preliminary Objection merited and hold that this miscellaneous cause as it stands is incompetent and will proceed to strike it out with costs to the 2nd Respondent.
Paragraph 23 →
22. Based on the facts as presented while relying on the legal provisions cited including associating myself with the decisions quoted, I find that since the issues raised by the Applicants are substantive in nature, noting that Order 40 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules is clear in instances where a party can seek an order of injunction and it has to be in a Suit, I opine that this claim ought to have been commenced by way of a Plaint and not a miscellaneous cause.
Paragraph 22 →
Held. No injunction was available in this miscellaneous cause. The court held that interlocutory and mandatory injunctions must be sought within a substantive suit commenced by plaint or originating summons; the ownership and trespass dispute required viva voce evidence. It also found no special circumstances warranting a mandatory injunction.
Ratio. An interlocutory or mandatory injunction must be anchored in a substantive suit commenced through the prescribed originating process. A miscellaneous cause is not an originating process capable of determining a substantive land dispute, and injunction prayers cannot be issued in isolation where doing so would effectively determine the dispute.
Issue
a) Whether the Applicants have satisfied the legal threshold for the grant of temporary and mandatory injunctions.
Passage 31 →
Held
20. From perusal of the instant Notice of Motion application herein including the annexures, noting that the Applicants’ claim revolves around ownership and trespass over land registered in the name of the Applicants, I find that the dispute will require proof through viva voce evidence. Further, the Applicants have sought interlocutory as well as mandatory injunction in this miscellaneous cause. It is trite that an injunction whether interlocutory or mandatory must be within a substantive suit commenced by plaint or originating summons. Under the Civil Procedure Rules, a miscellaneous cause is not considered as an originating process that can determine a dispute. Further, there are no special circumstances that are demonstrated in the instant miscellaneous cause to warrant the granting of a mandatory injunction.
Paragraph 20 →
21. I opine that the prayers being sought herein cannot be issued in isolation because once they are issued the suit is determined and there is no dispute to deal with. Insofar as the Applicants have claimed the issue being raised by the 2nd Respondent is a curable procedural defect as the 2nd Respondent has suffered no prejudice and have urged the Court to grant them leave to regularize the omission, at this juncture, I find that the said defect is not curable through any form of regularization.
Paragraph 21 →
Ratio
20. From perusal of the instant Notice of Motion application herein including the annexures, noting that the Applicants’ claim revolves around ownership and trespass over land registered in the name of the Applicants, I find that the dispute will require proof through viva voce evidence. Further, the Applicants have sought interlocutory as well as mandatory injunction in this miscellaneous cause. It is trite that an injunction whether interlocutory or mandatory must be within a substantive suit commenced by plaint or originating summons. Under the Civil Procedure Rules, a miscellaneous cause is not considered as an originating process that can determine a dispute. Further, there are no special circumstances that are demonstrated in the instant miscellaneous cause to warrant the granting of a mandatory injunction.
Paragraph 20 →
22. Based on the facts as presented while relying on the legal provisions cited including associating myself with the decisions quoted, I find that since the issues raised by the Applicants are substantive in nature, noting that Order 40 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules is clear in instances where a party can seek an order of injunction and it has to be in a Suit, I opine that this claim ought to have been commenced by way of a Plaint and not a miscellaneous cause.
Paragraph 22 →
Not reached
Held. Not reached. The court struck out the entire miscellaneous cause as incompetent after upholding the preliminary objection, without separately deciding whether the 2nd Respondent had been wrongly joined or whether his name should be struck out.
Ratio. This issue was not decided. The dispositive finding that the whole miscellaneous cause was incompetent made a separate joinder determination unnecessary.
Issue
b) Whether the 2nd Respondent’s name ought to be struck off the suit.
Passage 32 →
Held
23. In the circumstances, I find the Notice of Preliminary Objection merited and hold that this miscellaneous cause as it stands is incompetent and will proceed to strike it out with costs to the 2nd Respondent.
Paragraph 23 →
Held. Yes. The preliminary objection was merited because the Applicants pursued substantive ownership and trespass claims, and interlocutory and mandatory injunctions, through a miscellaneous cause rather than a substantive suit commenced by plaint. The defect was not curable by regularization. The court struck out the miscellaneous cause with costs to the 2nd Respondent.
Ratio. A preliminary objection may succeed where the application is procedurally incompetent on a pure legal point. Substantive civil claims and injunctive relief under Order 40 Rule 1 must be brought in a suit commenced in the prescribed manner; a miscellaneous cause cannot be regularized into such a suit.
Issue
c) Whether the 2nd Respondent’s Preliminary Objection is merited.
Passage 33 →
Held
23. In the circumstances, I find the Notice of Preliminary Objection merited and hold that this miscellaneous cause as it stands is incompetent and will proceed to strike it out with costs to the 2nd Respondent.
Paragraph 23 →
Ratio
13. It is trite, as held in Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] E.A. 696, that a Preliminary Objection ought to raise a pure point of law.
Paragraph 13 →
21. I opine that the prayers being sought herein cannot be issued in isolation because once they are issued the suit is determined and there is no dispute to deal with. Insofar as the Applicants have claimed the issue being raised by the 2nd Respondent is a curable procedural defect as the 2nd Respondent has suffered no prejudice and have urged the Court to grant them leave to regularize the omission, at this juncture, I find that the said defect is not curable through any form of regularization.
Paragraph 21 →
22. Based on the facts as presented while relying on the legal provisions cited including associating myself with the decisions quoted, I find that since the issues raised by the Applicants are substantive in nature, noting that Order 40 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules is clear in instances where a party can seek an order of injunction and it has to be in a Suit, I opine that this claim ought to have been commenced by way of a Plaint and not a miscellaneous cause.
Paragraph 22 →
Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.
What is before the Court for determination is the Applicants’ Notice of Motion application dated 5th March 2026 in which they seek the following Orders:
Paragraph 1 →From perusal of the instant Notice of Motion application herein including the annexures, noting that the Applicants’ claim revolves around ownership and trespass over land registered in the name of the Applicants, I find that the dispute will require proof through viva voce evidence. Further, the Applicants have sought interlocutory as well as mandatory injunction in this miscellaneous cause. It is trite that an injunction whether…
Paragraph 20 →Whether the Applicants had met the threshold for temporary and mandatory injunctions; whether the 2nd Respondent should be struck off for alleged misjoinder; and whether his preliminary objection, founded principally on the absence of a plaint, was merited.…
The Applicants stated that they were registered proprietors of Land Reference Number 9363/106 in Ruai, Nairobi County, and had possessed it peacefully until unknown persons allegedly trespassed and began constructing structures without consent. They sought…
Get the complete brief with membership →REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC L MISC. NO. E072 OF 2026
ANNAH NJERI GICHURU ……………………………... 1ST APPLICANT
RACHEL WAIRIMU NJUGUNA …....................... 2ND APPLICANT
DAVID MWANGI NJUGUNA …………………….…… 3RD APPLICANT
JANE WANJIRU NJUGUNA …………………………… 4TH APPLICANT
VERSUS
PATRICK MWANGI GITHINJI ………………….… 1ST RESPONDENT
HARRISON GITHAIGA MURIITHI …………….. 2ND RESPONDENT
RULING
1. What is before the Court for determination is the Applicants’ Notice of Motion application dated 5th March 2026 in which they seek the following Orders:
a) Spent.
b) That a temporary injunction be in favour of the 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th Applicants granted against the 1st and 2nd Respondents jointly or severally either by themselves, their servants, agents and/or employees be restrained from entering, trespassing, encroaching, constructing structures on, or in any manner whatsoever interfering with the Applicant’s ownership, possession and quiet enjoyment of Land Reference Number 9363/106 situated in Ruai, Nairobi County pending the hearing and determination of this application.
c) That a Mandatory injunction be in favour of the 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th Applicants granted against the 1st and 2nd Respondents jointly or severally either by themselves, their servants, agents and/or employees be restrained from entering, trespassing, encroaching, constructing structures on, or in any manner whatsoever interfering with the Applicant’s ownership, possession and quiet enjoyment of Land Reference Number 9363/106 situated in Ruai, Nairobi County pending the hearing and determination of this application.
d) That Officer Commanding the police Division (OCPD), Ruai and Officer in charge of Police Station (OCS) Ruai to ensure maximum compliance of the Court order.
e) That the costs herein be in the cause.
2. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the 1st
Applicant’s supporting affidavit. She avers that the Applicants are
registered proprietors of Land Reference Number 9363/106 and that they have had quiet possession since acquiring the same. They claim that persons unknown to them recently unlawfully trespassed thereon and commenced erecting structures without their consent.
Response
3. The application is opposed by the 2nd Respondent who filed a Notice of Preliminary Objection, contending that the application is non suited thus it is an abuse of Court process. He also filed a replying affidavit in opposition. He avers that he is wrongly sued and terms the suit a case of mistaken identity and misjoinder. He contends that he does not know the Applicants and the 1st Respondent and denies trespassing on Land Reference No. 9363/106 or erecting structures thereon as alleged. He confirms that he lives in Karatina Town and has never been to Ruai as a resident or visitor. He insists that the last time he was in Nairobi was in 2024. He claims that due to misjoinder, his name has been put into disrepute, and the Applicants ought to refund him kshs.60,000/= paid to his advocates towards defending the suit. He urges the Court to strike out the suit against him.
4. The 1st Respondent did not file a response. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions.
Submissions
5. The Applicants submit that the 2nd Respondent’s Preliminary Objection does not meet the threshold of a Preliminary point as espoused in the case of Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] EA 696, as it calls the Court to ascertain facts. Further, that while the 2nd Respondent alleges absence of a Plaint, even if the absence of it, is an irregularity, it is a curable procedural defect as the 2nd Respondent has suffered no prejudice. They urge the Court to grant them leave to regularize the omission.
6. They also submit that they have met the threshold for grant of injunctions sought, having demonstrated a prima facie case by exhibiting a Certificate of Title for Land Reference Number 9363/106, which they are in possession of and the Respondents’ unauthorised entry, which evidence is not controverted. Further, that they stand to suffer irreparable injury as land has unique value, which cannot be compensated by damages, adding that the balance of convenience favours them since they are the registered proprietors in possession.
7. On his part, the 2nd Respondent submits that his Preliminary Objection is merited as under Order 14 Rule 1 (1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, all suits unless otherwise provided under the rules are supposed to originate by way of a Plaint. Further, that under Order 40 Rule (1) of the Civil Procedure Rules, injunctions can only be granted where a Plaint has been filed. He also argues that Article 159 of the Constitution cannot cure the defect as it does not confer any jurisdiction, but it merely provides for how justice shall be dispensed by the Courts.
8. He reiterates his averments and submits that there is no cause of action against him and urges the Court to find that he is wrongly sued and proceed to strike out his name as a party to this suit.
Analysis and Determination
9. Upon consideration of the instant Notice of Motion application including the Preliminary Objection, affidavits and submissions, the following are the issues for determination:
a) Whether the Applicants have satisfied the legal threshold for the grant of temporary and mandatory injunctions.
b) Whether the 2nd Respondent’s name ought to be struck off the suit.
c) Whether the 2nd Respondent’s Preliminary Objection is merited.
10. The Applicants contend that they are the registered proprietors of the suit property and that unknown persons unlawfully trespassed thereon and commenced erecting structures without their consent. They therefore seek to restrain the Respondents on allegations that they have trespassed on the suit property.
11. The 2nd Respondent raised a Preliminary Objection to the Applicants’ application on the basis that the suit against him is incompetent for want of a Plaint. He insists that he has been wrongly joined in this suit. He denies any knowledge of the Applicants or the 1st Respondent, as well as any involvement in the alleged trespass on the suit property and seeks that his name be struck off the suit.
12. The 2nd Respondent’s objection is founded on the alleged absence of a
Plaint. On their part, the Applicants contend that the 2nd Respondent’s Preliminary Objection is not merited. In their submissions, they insist that failure to file a Plaint is a curable procedural defect and urged the Court to grant them leave to regularize the omission.
13. It is trite, as held in Mukisa Biscuit Manufacturing Co. Ltd v West End Distributors Ltd [1969] E.A. 696, that a Preliminary Objection ought to raise a pure point of law.
14. The Applicants have sought for orders of interlocutory injunction through this miscellaneous cause. The legal provisions governing applications for injunction are contained in Order 40 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules which stipulates thus:
‘Where in any suit it is proved by affidavit or otherwise— (a) that any property in dispute in a suit is in danger of being wasted, damaged, or alienated by any party to the suit, or wrongfully sold in execution of a decree; Or (b) that the defendant threatens or intends to remove or dispose of his property in circumstances affording reasonable probability that the plaintiff will or may be obstructed or delayed in the execution of any decree that may be passed against the defendant in the suit, the court may by order grant a temporary injunction to restrain such act, or make such other order for the purpose of staying and preventing the wasting, damaging, alienation, sale, removal, or disposition of the property as the court thinks fit until the disposal of the suit or until further orders.’
15. Section 2 of the Civil Procedure Act defines a Suit as follows:
‘All civil proceedings commenced in any manner prescribed.’
16. On institution of suits, Section 19 of the Civil Procedure Act states inter alia:
‘Every suit shall be instituted in such manner as may be prescribed by rules.’
17. In the case of Joseph Kibowen Chemor Vs William C Kasera (2013) eKLR the Court defined a Suit as follows:
‘The word “suit” has several meanings. Black’s Law Dictionary defines “suit” as any proceedings by a party or parties against another in a court of law. Suit of a civil nature is defined to be a civil action. A civil action is an action brought to enforce, redress, or protect a private or civil right. Rules means rules and forms made by the Rules Committee to regulate the procedure of courts. Pleadings include a petition or summons and the statements in writing of the claim or demand of any Plaintiff and of the defence of any Defendant thereto, and of the reply of the Plaintiff any defence or counter claim of a Defendant. Section 2 of the Civil Procedure Act defines “suit” as all civil proceedings commenced in any manner prescribed under section 2 means prescribed rules. Under section 19 of the Civil Procedure Act, every suit shall be instituted in such manner as may be prescribed by the rules. It will be observed that section 19 does not pretend that the Civil Procedure Rules have a monopoly on how suits may be instituted. It provides that suits may be instituted in the manner prescribed by the rules. There could be rules in other statutes on how proceedings may be commenced. For example, Probate & Administration Rules under the Succession Act prescribe how matters touching on succession of estates of deceased persons need to be instituted. It means therefore that where a person is commencing a civil suit to enforce a civil action he needs to follow the prescribed rules.’
18. While in the case of Tatecoh Housing and Co-op Sacco Ltd Vs Qwetu Sacco Ltd (2021) eKLR the Court held that:
“Without much ado, I will agree with the position of the respondent ……that the appellant cannot seek the orders sought in the miscellaneous application without going through the process of filing suit. It will be observed that among the orders sought are orders of eviction. One will ordinarily only obtain an order of eviction after a full hearing of the case. What the appellant needed to do was therefore to file a substantive suit for eviction through a plaint. It is upon the hearing of such suit and If successful, that an order of eviction would issue.” Emphasis Mine
19. See also the case of Kalyonge v Karanja (Miscellaneous Application E070 of 2021) [2022] KEHC 16174 (KLR) (Commercial and Tax) (9 December 2022) (Ruling).
20. From perusal of the instant Notice of Motion application herein including the annexures, noting that the Applicants’ claim revolves around ownership and trespass over land registered in the name of the Applicants, I find that the dispute will require proof through viva voce evidence. Further, the Applicants have sought interlocutory as well as mandatory injunction in this miscellaneous cause. It is trite that an injunction whether interlocutory or mandatory must be within a substantive suit commenced by plaint or originating summons. Under the Civil Procedure Rules, a miscellaneous cause is not considered as an originating process that can determine a dispute. Further, there are no special circumstances that are demonstrated in the instant miscellaneous cause to warrant the granting of a mandatory injunction.
21. I opine that the prayers being sought herein cannot be issued in isolation because once they are issued the suit is determined and there is no dispute to deal with. Insofar as the Applicants have claimed the issue being raised by the 2nd Respondent is a curable procedural defect as the 2nd Respondent has suffered no prejudice and have urged the Court to grant them leave to regularize the omission, at this juncture, I find that the said defect is not curable through any form of regularization.
22. Based on the facts as presented while relying on the legal provisions cited including associating myself with the decisions quoted, I find that since the issues raised by the Applicants are substantive in nature, noting that Order 40 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Rules is clear in instances where a party can seek an order of injunction and it has to be in a Suit, I opine that this claim ought to have been commenced by way of a Plaint and not a miscellaneous cause.
23. In the circumstances, I find the Notice of Preliminary Objection merited and hold that this miscellaneous cause as it stands is incompetent and will proceed to strike it out with costs to the 2nd Respondent.
DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 21ST DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
CHRISTINE OCHIENG
JUDGE
In the presence of:
Ms Njeri for Applicants
Gatundu for 2nd Respondent
Court Assistant: Joan