Land law

Nguru v Joreth Ltd & 4 others [2026] KEELC 7011 (KLR)

Included with active membership. View daily and monthly plans · Sign in

Court
Environment and Land Court at Nairobi
Case number
Elc Case 1492 of 2014
Judgment date
27 October 2026
Judge(s)
Christine Ochieng

Case research

What the court decided

Overall outcome and orders

The Notice of Motion was disallowed as premature, with no order as to costs. The court declined to lift the 1st Defendant’s corporate veil or impose personal liability on its directors, but directed that an official of the 1st Defendant attend court to confirm how the outstanding decretal sum would be settled.

Supporting judgment passages

19. In the circumstances, I find the Plaintiff’s instant Notice of Motion application premature and will disallow it and make no order as to costs.

Paragraph 19 →

18. In relying on the aforementioned legal provisions, I find that the 1st Defendant’s directors can be still be summoned for cross-examination without lifting its corporate veil. In the foregoing, I will proceed to direct that an official from the 1st Defendant do attend Court to confirm how the outstanding decretal sum will be settled.

Paragraph 18 →

17. From the foregoing, I opine that the lifting of the 1st Defendant’s corporate veil sought by the Plaintiff is hence premature and cannot be taken lightly. I find that there are no special circumstances to demonstrate improper conduct, fraud or that the 1st Defendant is a sham. I note the 1st Defendant had commenced settling the decretal sum and promised to finalize in six (6) months. I will hence decline to lift the 1st Defendant’s corporate veil. However, since there is an outstanding decretal sum to be settled, I wish to make reference to the provisions of Order 22 rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules which stipulates inter alia:

Paragraph 17 →
Issue 1Whether the Plaintiff has demonstrated sufficient cause to warrant lifting the 1st Defendant’s corporate veil and to cross-examine its directors.

Held. No sufficient cause was shown to lift the corporate veil. The Plaintiff established only non-payment of part of the decree, not that the company was fictitious, a sham, fraudulent, or that its directors had commingled company funds. The request to pierce the veil was therefore premature and was declined. However, an officer of the corporate judgment-debtor could be summoned and examined regarding the means and plan for satisfying the outstanding decree without lifting the veil; the court directed an official of the 1st Defendant to attend for that purpose.

Ratio. Piercing the corporate veil is exceptional and should not be undertaken lightly. It requires special circumstances, including improper conduct, fraud, sham status, or facts showing that maintaining separate corporate personality would sanction fraud or injustice. An unpaid decree alone did not meet that threshold here. Separately, under Order 22 rule 35, an officer of a corporate judgment-debtor may be ordered to attend and be examined about the corporation’s debts, property, and means of satisfying a money decree; that examination does not require piercing the veil.

Supporting passages

Issue

Supporting judgment passages

including the respective affidavits and submissions, the only issue for determination is whether the Plaintiff has demonstrated sufficient cause to warrant lifting the 1st Defendant’s corporate veil and to cross-examine its directors.

Passage 31 →

Held

Supporting judgment passages

17. From the foregoing, I opine that the lifting of the 1st Defendant’s corporate veil sought by the Plaintiff is hence premature and cannot be taken lightly. I find that there are no special circumstances to demonstrate improper conduct, fraud or that the 1st Defendant is a sham. I note the 1st Defendant had commenced settling the decretal sum and promised to finalize in six (6) months. I will hence decline to lift the 1st Defendant’s corporate veil. However, since there is an outstanding decretal sum to be settled, I wish to make reference to the provisions of Order 22 rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules which stipulates inter alia:

Paragraph 17 →

18. In relying on the aforementioned legal provisions, I find that the 1st Defendant’s directors can be still be summoned for cross-examination without lifting its corporate veil. In the foregoing, I will proceed to direct that an official from the 1st Defendant do attend Court to confirm how the outstanding decretal sum will be settled.

Paragraph 18 →

Ratio

Supporting judgment passages

“The Court may lift the corporate veil in exercising its inherent jurisdiction to do justice and fairness for the ends of justice. This jurisdiction may be exercised only in special circumstances where the Court finds improper conduct, fraud or when a company is a sham, acting as an agent of the shareholders or evading tax revenues.” Emphasis added

Passage 35 →

b. Second, the facts must be such that adherence to the fiction of separate entity would, under the circumstances, sanction a fraud or promote injustice.

Passage 40 →

(c) Any other person, be orally examined as to whether any or what debts are owing to the judgment-debtor, and whether the judgment-debtor has any and what property or means of satisfying the decree, and the court may make an order for the attendance and examination of such judgment-debtor or officer, or other person, and for the production of any books or documents.”

Passage 52 →
READ THE DECISION FASTER

Case at a glance

Read the full text ↓

Selected passages from the judgment. Follow each paragraph link to read the full context.

Background

What is before the Court for determination is the Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion Application dated 30th January 2026 in which he seeks the following Orders:

Paragraph 1 →

Reasoning passage

From the foregoing, I opine that the lifting of the 1st Defendant’s corporate veil sought by the Plaintiff is hence premature and cannot be taken lightly. I find that there are no special circumstances to demonstrate improper conduct, fraud or that the 1st Defendant is a sham. I note the 1st Defendant had commenced settling the decretal sum and promised to finalize in six (6) months. I will hence decline to lift the 1st Defendant’s…

Paragraph 17 →
SHERIAPLEX EDITORIAL BRIEF

Preview the case brief

Questions presented

Whether the Plaintiff had shown sufficient cause to lift the corporate veil of Joreth Limited and join its directors, Duncan Nderitu Ndegwa and Margaret Wairimu Magugu, as personally liable for the decretal amount; and whether the directors could be summoned…

Material facts

Joseph Muriuki Nguru obtained a decree requiring the Defendants to compensate him Kshs.19.5 million concerning LR No. 13330/237. The Plaintiff stated that Joreth Limited paid Kshs.2.65 million in March 2025 and Kshs.500,000 in September 2025, leaving…

Get the complete brief with membership →

Full judgment

REPUBLIC OF KENYA

IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI

ELC CASE NO. 1492 OF 2014

JOSEPH MURIUKI NGURU ………………..…………..…… PLAINTIFF

VERSUS

JORETH LIMITED …………………………………..…… 1ST DEFENDANT

ONESMUS MUCIRI MAINA ………………..…….. 2ND DEFENDANT

MARY NYAMBURA MUCHIRI ……………..………. 3RD DEFENDANT

AND

DUNCAN NDERITU NDEGWA ……………..………………. DIRECTOR

MARGARET WAIRIMU MAGUGU……………………….... DIRECTOR

RULING

1. What is before the Court for determination is the Plaintiff’s Notice of Motion Application dated 30th January 2026 in which he seeks the following Orders:

a) That the 1st Defendant/Judgement Debtor Corporate veil be lifted.

b) That the directors of the 1st Defendant/ Judgement debtors Duncan Nderitu Ndegwa and Margaret Wairimu Magugu be impleaded and joined in this matter as personally liable directors for the satisfaction and payment of the amounts decreed by this court against the 1st Defendant pursuant to the judgement and decree given in favour of the Plaintiff/decree holder on the 28th June 2024.

c) That the said directors Duncan Nderitu Ndegwa and Margaret Wairimu Magugu be summoned to court for examination on the assets and property of the 1st Defendant.

d) That costs of this application be provided for.

2. The application is premised on grounds on its face and on the Plaintiff’s supporting affidavit. He avers that he commenced this suit in 2014 seeking among other prayers, full compensation for his plot LR No. 13330/237 which was transferred by the 1st Defendant to the 2nd and 3rd Defendants and vide this Court’s judgement of 29th June 2024, the Defendants were ordered to pay him compensation in the sum of kshs.19.5 million. Subsequently, his advocates served the 1st Defendant with the decree herein, and made proposals for settlement of the said decretal amount and they came into agreement that the 1st Defendant would make an initial payment of kshs.2,650,000/= towards settlement of the principal sum as well as a further sum of kshs.1,645,000/= being party and party costs and then pay the balance within six (6) months. He points out that in compliance with the said agreement, the 1st Defendant’s directors paid kshs.2,650,000/= at the end of March 2025 and made further payment of shs.500,000/= in September 2025, but they have neglected to pay the balance of kshs.16,350,000 /=.

3. He claims that the directors of the 1st Defendant have been actively carrying on the business of the 1st Defendant while hiding behind its incorporation as a company to evade paying liabilities. Further, that they have shielded the 1st Defendant from meeting its legal obligations by operating the company’s affairs through an intermediary known as Apex Depla Limited thus to uphold the dignity and authority of the Court, it is necessary to pierce the corporate veil of the 1st Defendant so that its directors are held personally liable.

Response

4. In opposition, the 1st Defendant filed a replying affidavit sworn by Dr. Jonathan Ciano, its manager. He avers that it was agreed between the Plaintiff and the 1st Defendant that the outstanding balance of the decretal sum would be settled by way of six (6) monthly installments subject to enlargement of the same period for a further six (6) months, and points out that the 1st Defendant remitted Kshs.4,945,000/= and kshs.500,000/= in the month of September 2025. Further, that it continues to pay installments, and any delay has not been malicious/in bad faith, as it arose from ongoing efforts to restructure the 1st Defendant’s financial obligations owed to creditors so as to facilitate the orderly settlement of its debts. He affirms that the 1st Defendant remains willing and able to settle the amount due to the Plaintiff.

5. He insists that the 1st Defendant is a separate and distinct legal entity from its directors thus they cannot be held personally, jointly/severally liable for the company’s obligations. He asserts that the veil of a company may only be lifted upon clear evidence of fraud, impropriety, or abuse of corporate personality yet there is none. Further, that the 1st Defendant has not demonstrated inability/unwillingness to satisfy its obligations under the decree.

6. The plaintiff filed a further affidavit in response. He confirms that Kshs.15,850,000/= out of the decree of kshs.19,500,000/= remains unpaid and denies that there was provision for enlargement of the six (6) months payment period as alleged by the 1st Defendant. He also avers that the reasons given for default are an afterthought and demonstrate abuse of the corporate veil and that 1st Defendant’s allegations that it is ready and willing to pay the decree, are not matched by action.

7. The application was canvassed by way of written submissions but the Plaintiff did not file his.

Submissions

8. The 1st Defendant submits that as per the holding is Salomon v Salomon & co (1987) AC 22, a limited liability company is a separate and distinct legal person from its shareholders and directors thus they are not personally liable for debts of a company. Further, that there is no evidence that the 1st Defendant has sought to evade its lawful obligations, that its directors have diverted corporate assets with a view to defeating execution, that the company is a mere sham designed to perpetrate fraud, or that there has been any fraudulent transfer or dissipation of its assets, which are the statutory grounds that would warrant lifting the corporate veil.

9. It also submits that the law provides structured and well-defined mechanisms for the enforcement of decrees through execution, and any failure by the decree-holder to exhaust those mechanisms cannot form a lawful basis for imposing personal liability upon the directors of a limited liability company. It contends that the Plaintiff has not demonstrated any effort towards executing the impugned decree against it, before resorting to lift its corporate veil. It maintains that it is fully operational, financially sound and capable of meeting its financial obligations as they fall due.

10. To buttress its averments, the 1st Defendant relied on the following decisions: Corporate Insurance Company Ltd v Savemax Insurance Brokers Ltd [2002] 1 E1 41; Aster Holdings Limited v City Council of Nairobi & 4 others [2019] eKLR; Cape Holdings Limited (Under Administration) v Synergy Industrial Credit Limited; Sanghrajka (Interested Party); I&M Bank Limited (Objector) [2026] KEHC 2664 (KLR), Ellat-Agua Limited v Armstrong & another [2026] KEHC 2804 (KLR); and Kolaba Enterprises Ltd v Shamsudin Hussein Varvani & another [2014] eKLR.

Analysis and Determination

11. Upon consideration of the instant Notice of Motion application

including the respective affidavits and submissions, the only issue for determination is whether the Plaintiff has demonstrated sufficient cause to warrant lifting the 1st Defendant’s corporate veil and to cross-examine its directors.

12. The Plaintiff’s case is that the directors of the 1st Defendant are hiding behind its corporate veil and shielding it from paying an outstanding Kshs.15,850,000/= out of this Court’s decree of Kshs.19,500,000/=.

13. On its part, the 1st Defendant contends that there exists no legal basis upon which its directors may be subjected to personal liability and that there is no legitimate basis to summon them for cross-examination beyond the mere existence of an unsatisfied decree. It also asserts that it is ready and willing to satisfy the decree and that it has the means to do so.

14. On lifting corperate veil, the Court of Appeal stated as follows in the case of Riccatti Business College of East Africa Limited v Kyanzavi Farmers Company Limited [2016] KECA 763 (KLR):

“The Court may lift the corporate veil in exercising its inherent jurisdiction to do justice and fairness for the ends of justice. This jurisdiction may be exercised only in special circumstances where the Court finds improper conduct, fraud or when a company is a sham, acting as an agent of the shareholders or evading tax revenues.” Emphasis added

15. Further, in the case of Lucy Mukembura Kimani v Nzuri Feeds Suppliers Ltd [2021] KEHC 6552 (KLR), Joel Ngugi J (as he then was) stated that:

“9. In Kenya, courts have a strong presumption against piercing the corporate veil, and will only do so if there has been serious misconduct or if the Company, shareholders or directors who are asserted to be the Company’s alter egos have acted in fairly egregious manner. This is because Courts understand the benefits of limited liability as expressed in the statute.

10. In general, therefore, Courts in Kenya will only allow for the piercing of the corporate veil when two requirements are met:

a. First, the company is a mere instrumentality or alter ego of the shareholder or director in question such that there is such unity of interest and ownership that one is inseparable from the other; and

b. Second, the facts must be such that adherence to the fiction of separate entity would, under the circumstances, sanction a fraud or promote injustice.

11. Some of the factors the Court would like at to determine if the two requirements have been met include the following:

a. Whether the company is adequately capitalized;

b. Whether there is a failure to maintain adequate corporate records or to comply with corporate formalities;

c. Whether there has been demonstrated commingling of funds or assets between the company and the asserted alter ego;

d. Whether the alter ego has treated the assets or finances of the corporation as his own.”

16. In this instance, I note the Plaintiff except for explaining that the 1st Defendant have failed to settle the full decretal sum, did not demonstrate whether the 1st Defendant is a fictious company that has committed fraud or that its directors have commingled funds with the company. In the case of Post Bank Credit Limited (In Liquidation) v Nyamangu Holdings Limited [2015] KEHC 5964 (KLR), it was held as follows:

“However, despite the jurisdiction the court, the decision to lift the corporate veil should not be undertaken lightly as it opens the directors or members of the company to personal liability.”

17. From the foregoing, I opine that the lifting of the 1st Defendant’s corporate veil sought by the Plaintiff is hence premature and cannot be taken lightly. I find that there are no special circumstances to demonstrate improper conduct, fraud or that the 1st Defendant is a sham. I note the 1st Defendant had commenced settling the decretal sum and promised to finalize in six (6) months. I will hence decline to lift the 1st Defendant’s corporate veil. However, since there is an outstanding decretal sum to be settled, I wish to make reference to the provisions of Order 22 rule 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules which stipulates inter alia:

“Where a decree is for the payment of money, the decree-holder may apply to the court for an order that—

(a) The judgment-debtor;

(b) In the case of a corporation, any officer thereof; or

(c) Any other person, be orally examined as to whether any or what debts are owing to the judgment-debtor, and whether the judgment-debtor has any and what property or means of satisfying the decree, and the court may make an order for the attendance and examination of such judgment-debtor or officer, or other person, and for the production of any books or documents.”

18. In relying on the aforementioned legal provisions, I find that the 1st Defendant’s directors can be still be summoned for cross-examination without lifting its corporate veil. In the foregoing, I will proceed to direct that an official from the 1st Defendant do attend Court to confirm how the outstanding decretal sum will be settled.

19. In the circumstances, I find the Plaintiff’s instant Notice of Motion application premature and will disallow it and make no order as to costs.

DATED SIGNED AND DELIVERED AT NAIROBI THIS 27TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026

CHRISTINE OCHIENG

JUDGE

In the presence of:

Waweru for Kingara for Plaintiff/Decree holder

Omondi for 1st Defendant

Court Assistant: Joan

KEEP THE USEFUL PART

Save to My Research

Create a new folder