REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND LAND COURT AT NAIROBI
ELC CASE NO. 152 OF 2018
CIRTEX KENYA LIMITED…………..…. PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT
VERSUS
PETER DAVID LEPARAKWO .........1ST DEFENDANT/APPLICANT
THE CHIEF
LAND REGISTRAR ………………...2NDDEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
THE DIRECTOR OF
SURVEY KENYA …………….….....3RD DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
THE DIRECTOR, LAND
ADMINISTRATION……….….…...4TH DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
AS CONSOLIDATED WITH ELC NO. 691 OF 2011
NATIONAL HOSPITAL INSURANCE
FUND BOARD OF MANAGEMENT…..PLAINTIFF/RESPONDENT
VERSUS
CROWNLINE FREIGHTS……..…..1st DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
KASKAZI TRADERS LIMITED.…2nd DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL……..3rd DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
RULING
1. The present ruling addresses objections raised on 13th October, 2025, during the testimony of PW1, to the production of documents contained in the bundle dated 21st October, 2022. Mr Munyuri, appearing for the Plaintiff in ELC No. 691 of 2011 conceded to the initial bundle but submitted that the documents contained in the bundle dated 21st October, 2022 were not supported by the witness statement.
2. In particular, his objection concerned documents numbered 17, 18, 19, 20, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 33, 36, 47, 48, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 59, 63, 64, 65, 69, 70 and 71.
3. Mr Allan Kamau, appearing for the Attorney General, similarly raised no objection to the initial list of documents. Regarding the supplementary bundle, he objected to document 48, appearing at pages 90–92, on the ground that it comprised correspondence between the Directorate of Criminal Investigations and the Chief Land Registrar, of which the witness was not the author.
4. Counsel also objected to document 53 at page 104 and documents 54, 55 and 56, describing them as internal correspondence between the National Land Commission and the Ministry responsible for lands. He further objected to document 57, being a survey report and its appendices prepared by the National Land Commission.
5. As regards documents 63, 64 and 65, Mr Kamau submitted that these comprised correspondence between the Attorney General’s office and its client, including instructions to the Land Registrar. He also objected to document 70. His position was that the witness was neither the author of, nor a party to, the correspondence and could not properly produce it.
6. Ms Omambia, appearing for the 1st Defendant in ELC No. 152 of 2015, associated herself with Mr Kamau’s submissions and extended the objection to documents 73, 74 and 75.
7. Mr Ogembo, appearing for the 2nd Defendant in ELC No. 691 of 2011, submitted that a proper foundation had to be laid for the production of the disputed documents. He argued that the witness could not meaningfully be cross-examined on documents authored by other persons and urged that their makers be called to produce them.
8. In response, Ms Asli submitted that the disputed documents had been forwarded by government offices in response to correspondence from the Plaintiff or its advocates. In particular, she stated that document 57, being the report and appendices appearing at pages 109–136, had been forwarded to the Plaintiff’s advocates through a letter dated 18th July, 2022, appearing at page 102.
9. Counsel submitted that the forwarding letter referred to the letter dated 23rd November, 2021, which was document 47 at page 88, as well as the correspondence appearing at pages 104, 105 and 107, being documents 53, 54 and 56 respectively. She maintained that the documents were connected through the references contained in the forwarding correspondence.
10. Regarding document 47, Ms Asli explained that it was a letter written by the Plaintiff’s advocates to the National Land Commission seeking clarification. She further submitted that the report had been forwarded to the Directorate of Criminal Investigations by the advocates and referred to the correspondence appearing at pages 90–92.
11. Counsel also referred to a letter at page 36 addressed to the Plaintiff’s advocates. She submitted that documents 24 and 25 were addressed to the Plaintiff’s counsel, while document 26 had been written by the Plaintiff. As regards document 17 at page 29 and the ensuing letters at pages 30–32, she stated that these formed part of the correspondence between the Plaintiff’s advocates and the Director of Surveys. She further stated that documents 77 and 78 were addressed to her firm.
12. Ms Asli conceded that documents 63, 64 and 65 could be expunged. She similarly stated that documents 73, 74 and 75, comprising correspondence between the 1st Defendant and Nairobi City County, formed part of the 1st Defendant’s documents and could be expunged.
13. In rejoinder, Mr Munyuri maintained that the witness could only produce correspondence addressed to the witness’s advocates.
14. Mr Kamau reiterated that document 17 at page 29 did not comprise correspondence between the Plaintiff and the Ministry responsible for lands. He further submitted that document 52 referred to letters dated 23rd November, 2021, 25th April, 2022 and 18th May, 2022. According to counsel, the letters dated 15th December, 2021 at page 104 and 18th April, 2023 at page 105 were not referenced in the forwarding letter dated 18th July, 2022. He maintained that documents 18–20, which were addressed to B.M. Okumu, a surveyor, could only be marked for identification.
Analysis and Determination
15. Upon considering the objections and responses, the sole issue for determination is whether the objections to the production of the disputed documents are merited?
16. The contention here regards admissibility of documents. Section 35 of the Evidence Act addresses the admissibility of documentary evidence concerning facts in issue. It states as follows:
“(1) In any civil proceedings where direct oral evidence of a fact would be admissible, any statement made by a person in a document and tending to establish that fact shall, on production of the original document, be admissible as evidence of that fact if the following conditions are satisfied, that is to say—
a.if the maker of the statement either—
(i) Had personal knowledge of the matters dealt with by the statement; or
(ii) Where the document in question is or forms part of a record purporting to be a continuous record, made the statement (in so far as the matters dealt with thereby are not within his personal knowledge) in the performance of a duty to record information supplied to him by a person who had, or might reasonably be supposed to have, personal knowledge of those matters; and
b.If the maker of the statement is called as a witness in the proceedings: Provided that the condition that the maker of the statement shall be called as a witness need not be satisfied if he is dead, or cannot be found, or is incapable of giving evidence, or if his attendance cannot be procured without an amount of delay or expense which in the circumstances of the case appears to the court unreasonable.
(2)In any civil proceedings, the court may at any stage of the proceedings, if having regard to all the circumstances of the case it is satisfied that undue delay or expense would otherwise be caused, order that such a statement as is mentioned in subsection (1) of this section shall be admissible or may, without any such order having been made, admit such a statement in evidence—(a)notwithstanding that the maker of the statement is available but is not called as a witness;(b)notwithstanding that the original document is not produced, if in lieu thereof there is produced a copy of the original document or of the material part thereof certified to be a true copy in such manner as may be specified in the order or the court may approve, as the case may be.
(3) Nothing in this section shall render admissible any statement made by a person interested at a time when proceedings were pending or anticipated involving a dispute as to any fact which the statement might tend to establish.”
17. Speaking to the parameters thereof, the court in Njuguna & another vs Njuguna & another (Environment and Land Appeal E095 of 2025) [2025] KEELC 8268 (KLR) (25 November 2025) (Judgment) persuasively stated as follows:
“A witness should produce documents of which they have personal knowledge or, in circumstances where the witness, while performing a duty, recorded information in the document supplied by a person with knowledge of it. Therefore, there should be some reasonable connection between the witness and the document sought to be produced. When there is a dispute over whether the document was truly authored by the person stated and regarding its authenticity, even if the witness claims to be the recipient or addressee, fairness demands that the maker of the document produce it, provided that such production does not cause unreasonable delay or expense. Fairness and procedural justice should guide the admission of documents to prevent one party from being prejudiced by the opposing party’s production of such documents.”
18. The court is so guided.
19. To begin with, Ms Asli expressly conceded the objection to documents 63, 64 and 65, as well as documents 73, 74 and 75. The objection to those documents is allowed, and they are expunged from the bundle tendered by PW1.
20. Documents 17, 18, 19 and 20 concern the processing and forwarding of deed plans and correspondence involving B.M. Okumu and the relevant lands and survey offices. A sufficient foundation has not been established for their production through PW1. If B.M. Okumu acted as the Plaintiff’s surveyor as alleged, nothing precludes the Plaintiff from calling him to produce the correspondence he authored or received and explain his involvement.
21. The objection to the production of the said documents by PW1 is therefore upheld, and the documents shall be marked for identification pending proper production by either the maker or recipient of the same.
22. Document 24 was addressed to the Plaintiff’s advocates, document 25 was addressed to its previous counsel, and document 26 emanated from its counsel. Their connection to the Plaintiff is established through the advocates acting on its behalf. The objection founded solely on PW1 not being their author is overruled, and the documents may be produced by PW1 as correspondence sent or received on the Plaintiff’s behalf.
23. Documents 27 and 28 must be considered alongside document 26. Document 27 is the letter dated 16th January, 2018 addressed to Anya Kalwa Advocates and enclosed with document 26, through which Ahmednassir Advocates requested the Principal Secretary to confirm its authenticity.
24. As the attachment forming the subject of that request, document 27 is integral to document 26 and cannot be separated from it without rendering the correspondence incomplete. Its production by PW1 is therefore allowed as part of document 26.
25. Document 28, however, is separately addressed to Anya Kalwa Advocates, whose connection to the Plaintiff has not been established. A foundation must therefore be laid for its production through PW1. Accordingly, the objection to document 27 is overruled, while document 28 shall be marked for identification pending the establishment of a proper basis for its production.
26. Documents 29, 30, 31, 33 and 36 comprise correspondence emanating from C. G. Waithima & Co. Advocates. The correspondence establishes that the firm acted for the Plaintiff in relation to the dispute, thereby demonstrating the documents’ connection to the Plaintiff. Accordingly, the objection founded solely on PW1 not being their maker is overruled, and the documents may be produced by PW1 as correspondence undertaken by the Plaintiff’s former advocates on its behalf.
27. Document 47 is a letter dated 23rd November, 2021 from Daniel Orenge & Co. Advocates to the National Land Commission, expressly stating that it was written on the instructions of the Plaintiff, Cirtex Kenya. Document 52 is the Commission’s response dated 18th July, 2022. Both documents therefore form part of correspondence undertaken on the Plaintiff’s behalf, and the objection to their production is accordingly overruled.
28. Document 48 is a letter from the Directorate of Criminal Investigations to the Chief Land Registrar. It was not copied to the Plaintiff or his advocate. No basis has been established for its production by PW1. The fact that the Plaintiff’s advocates had communicated with the Directorate does not, without more, establish the witness’s competence to produce correspondence exchanged between that office and the Chief Land Registrar. The objection is upheld, and document 48 shall be marked for identification pending proper production.
29. Documents 53 and 54 comprise letters from the National Land Commission to the Chief Land Registrar and the Director of Surveys respectively, seeking information on the validity of the disputed deed plans, while document 55 is a response from the Director of Surveys. Although these letters concern investigations arising from the Plaintiff’s complaint, that connection does not, by itself, establish PW1’s competence to produce them. Of documents 53–56, document 52 expressly refers only to document 56, being the Director of Surveys’ letter dated 18th May, 2022.
30. However, document 52 states that the Commission prepared and forwarded a report based on the information received. It does not expressly identify document 56 as an enclosure. Mere reference to that letter does not establish that it was supplied to the Plaintiff or lay a sufficient foundation for PW1 to produce it as evidence of its contents. Accordingly, the objections to the production of documents 53, 54, 55 and 56 by PW1 are upheld, and the documents shall be marked for identification pending proper production.
31. Document 57 comprises the National Land Commission survey report and appendices at pages 109–136. The letter dated 18th July, 2022 at page 102 establishes that the report was forwarded to Daniel Orenge & Co. Advocates in response to their letter dated 23rd November, 2021, being document 47. Its provenance and receipt through the Plaintiff’s advocates are thus explained. It can be produced by PW1 as the report received by the Plaintiff through its advocates.
32. Document 59 comprises correspondence from Geomeasure Surveyors Limited to the Director of Surveys. No sufficient foundation has been laid for its production by PW1. The objection to its production by PW1 is upheld.
33. Document 69, however, is a letter from the Directorate of Criminal Investigations to the Principal Secretary responsible for lands, copied to several parties, including Fredrick Kimani, a director of the Plaintiff. Its connection to the Plaintiff is therefore established, and the objection to its production is overruled.
34. Document 70 is correspondence from the Chief Land Registrar to the Director of Surveys, while document 71 is a letter from Peter Leparakwo to the Director of Planning and Compliance. No basis has been established explaining how the Plaintiff obtained these documents or demonstrating PW1’s competence to produce them. Accordingly, the objections to production of documents 70 and 71 by PW1 are upheld.
35. Consequently, the objection to the production of documents in the bundle of documents dated 21st October, 2022 by PW1 partly succeeds in respect of documents 17, 18, 19, 20, 28, 48, 53, 54, 55, 56, 59, 63, 64, 65, 70, 71, 73, 74 and 75. Documents 63, 64, 65, 73, 74 and 75 are expunged in accordance with counsel’s concession. As regards documents 17, 18, 19, 20, 28, 48, 53, 54, 55, 56, 59, 70 and 71, given that the trial has just begun, they shall be marked for identification, with the Plaintiff being afforded an opportunity to call their makers or recipients.
36. Costs shall be in the cause.
Dated, signed and delivered virtually in Nairobi this 29th day of October, 2026.
O. A. Angote
Judge
In the presence of;
Ms Asli for Plaintiff
Mr. Allan Kamau for 2nd, 3rd and 4th Defendants
Ms Omambia for Defendant in ELC 152/2018
Mr. Ogembo for 2nd Defendant in ELC 691/2011
Ms Mose for Plaintiff in ELC 691/2011
Court Assistant: Tracy