REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT NAIROBI
ELRC APPEAL NO. E095 OF 2025
(Before D. K. N. Marete)
STEPHEN KINYANJUI WAINAINA ………………………… APPELLANT/RESPONDENT
VERSUS
JACRIDGE SCHOOL LIMITED ……………………………… RESPONDENT/APPLICANT
(Being an appeal from the Judgment of Hon. Charles Mwaniki delivered on 13th March 2025 in the Chief Magistrate’s Court at Ruiru in MCELRC No. E063 of 2024)
RULING
This is an application by way of a Notice of Motion dated 16th February, 2026 seeking a review of the judgment of this court delivered on 23rd January, 2026 and a stay of execution of that judgment pending the determination of the Application.
By its Judgment dated 23rd January, 2026 this court partially allowed the appeal filed by the Appellant/Respondent against the trial court’s judgment. The judgment of court made the following awards to the Appellant/Respondent;
(i) Notice pay of Kshs. 32,280.75;
(ii) Overtime of Kshs. 389,119.50;
(iii) Underpayment of Kshs. 102,845.25;
(iv) A total sum of Kshs. 524,245.50, payable with interest at court rates from the date of judgment; and
(v) Costs of the suit.
Dissatisfied with the manner in which overtime was computed, the Respondent/Applicant filed the present Application under Article 50 of the Constitution, Section 16 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act and Rules 73 and 74 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024, seeking review of the overtime award on the ground that it contains an error apparent on the face of the record and additionally seeking a 45-day stay of execution of the judgment to allow the parties to negotiate and settle the matter.
The Application is supported by the affidavit of Teresia Wamaitha, advocate on record for the Respondent/Applicant, sworn on 16th February, 2026 and by written submissions dated 26th March, 2026.
On 19th February, 2026 when the parties appeared before the court for directions, counsel for the Appellant/Respondent indicated that he did not wish to negotiate a settlement. The prayer for a 45-day stay pending negotiation accordingly fell away and the Application proceeded to be canvassed on the review of the overtime computation.
The Appellant/Respondent opposed the Application through a Replying Affidavit sworn on 27th March, 2026 and written submissions dated 13th May, 2026.
The Respondent/Applicant’s case, as set out in the application, the supporting affidavit and the submissions, comes out thus: At paragraph 35 of the judgment, having found that the Appellant/Respondent was entitled to overtime, the court computed the overtime award by applying, throughout the entire period, the hourly rate of Kshs. 291.80 prescribed by the Regulation of Wages (General) (Amendment) Order, 2022 which yielded a payable rate of Kshs. 33.69 per hour under the court’s own formula.
The Respondent/Applicant contends that this is an error apparent on the face of the record because, at paragraph 39 of the judgment, the court acknowledged that different wage orders were applicable across different periods of the employment relationship. Applying the court’s own formula but substituting the rate applicable in each respective period, the Respondent/Applicant submits, the correct overtime figure would be materially lower. The Respondent/Applicant maintains that it does not seek to reargue the appeal or invite the court to sit on appeal from its own decision.
The Appellant/Respondent’s case is that the entitlement to overtime was pleaded, canvassed and determined both at trial and at the appeal stage. The Respondent/Applicant never raised the alternative year-by-year computation now advanced, nor tendered the wage orders it now relies upon, at either stage, despite these being public documents available through and through. The Appellant/Respondent submits that the Application amounts to an invitation to re-open a contested issue dressed up as a review application. The Appellant/Respondent additionally takes issue with the propriety of the supporting affidavit, noting that it was sworn by the advocate on record rather than by the Respondent/Applicant itself and that the advocate had no personal knowledge of the underlying employment facts.
This application raises two issues for determination. The first is whether the Respondent/Applicant has met the threshold for review of the judgment on the basis of error apparent on the face of the record and secondly, whether the prayer for a stay of execution should be entertained.
On the 1st issue, the court’s review jurisdiction is donated by Section 16 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court Act and Rule 74 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024. It is well settled that an error apparent on the face of the record is one that is self-evident and does not require argument or further investigation to identify. As held in National Bank of Kenya Ltd v Ndungu Njau [1997] eKLR, such an error must be self-evident and should not require an elaborate argument to be established. Similarly the authority of Nyamogo & Nyamogo v Kogo [2001] EA 170 draws a real distinction between a mere erroneous decision and an error apparent on the face of the record, holding that an error requiring a long-drawn process of reasoning, on points where two opinions are conceivable, does not qualify. It is correct, as the Respondent/Applicant points out, that there is a facial tension within the judgment. Paragraph 35 applies a single rate while paragraph 39 acknowledges differing rates across different periods.
What cannot be said to be self-evident, however, is the correction the Respondent/Applicant asks the court to make. The specific wage orders applicable in each period, the rates they prescribe and the arithmetic consequence of applying those rates, are not immediately apparent from the face of the judgment alone. They require reference to external documents and further argument. That is not the character of an error apparent on the face of the record. Indeed, the Respondent/Applicant found it necessary to annex some 34 pages of gazette notices to its submissions to make the point, which is itself telling. An error that is truly apparent on the face of the record does not require importation of that quantity of extrinsic material to initiate visibility. The difficulty is compounded by the fact that the wage orders now relied upon are public documents that were available to be placed before the court at the appeal stage, if the computation methodology was itself in issue.
Besides, the court is also not persuaded that the manner in which the Application has been supported, by an advocate’s affidavit rather than one from the Respondent/Applicant, assists. The advocate has to a large extent no personal knowledge of the employment arrangements from which the claim arises.
On the 2nd issue, the prayer for a 45-day stay pending negotiation is spent, the Respondent/Applicant itself acknowledging in its submissions that this fell away once counsel for the Appellant/Respondent declined to negotiate. In any event, no substantial loss was demonstrated and no security was offered in support of the prayer for stay. In the authority of Kenya Shell Limited v Benjamin Karuga Kibiru & Another [1986] eKLR, the Court of Appeal held that a demonstrated risk of substantial loss is the cornerstone of the jurisdiction to grant a stay of execution. The prayer for stay is therefore declined.
I am therefore inclined to dismiss the Application and order as follows;
i. The Notice of Motion Application dated 16th February, 2026 be and is hereby dismissed.
ii. The prayer for a stay of execution is declined.
iii. The judgment and decree of this court delivered on 23rd January, 2026 shall reign, stand and remain undisturbed in entirety.
iv. The costs of this Application shall be borne by the Appellant/Respondent.
Delivered, dated and signed this 13th day of October 2026.
D. K. Njagi Marete
JUDGE
Appearances:
1. Mr. Wandera instructed by Nambalu Wamaitha & Okinyi Advocates LLP for the Respondent/Applicant.
2. Miss Mwenda instructed by Wanjiru Mwenda & Company Advocates for the Appellant/Respondent.