REPUBLIC OF KENYA
IN THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT AT MACHAKOS
CONSTITUTIONAL PETITION NO. E008 OF 2026
IN THE MATTER OF ARTICLES 2, 3, 10, 20, 21, 22, 23, 27, 36, 41, 47, 258 AND 259 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA 2010
AND
IN THE MATTER OF THE ALLEGED CONTRAVENTION OF RIGHTS AND FUNDAMENTAL FREEDOMS IN ARTICLES 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 27, 36(1), 41(1) & 41(2)(c), 47 (1) & 47(2) OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA, 2010
AND
IN THE MATTER OF THE ALLEGED CONTRAVENTION OF SECTIONS 4, AND 6 OF THE FAIR ADMINISTRATIVE ACTION ACT
AND
IN THE MATTER OF SECTIONS 4 AND 34 OF THE LABOUR RELATIONS ACT, NO. 14 OF 2007
AND
IN THE MATTER OF SECTION 12 OF THE EMPLOYMENT AND LABOUR RELATIONS COURT ACT
AND
IN THE MATTER OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA (PROTECTION OF RIGHTS AND FUNDAMENTAL FREEDOMS) PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE RULES, 2013
AND
IN THE MATTER OF THE KNUT CONSTITUTION
AND
IN THE MATTER OF MWINGI KNUT BRANCH ELECTION HELD ON 28TH FEBRUARY 2026
BETWEEN
ROBERT KYALO MUVENGEI………………..………………………………………………..……1ST PETITIONER
EMMANUEL SAVULI………………..…………….…………..…………………………………....…2ND PETITIONER
-VERSUS-
KENYA NATIONAL UNION OF TEACHERS (KNUT)….....……………………...……..1ST RESPONDENT
REGISTRAR OF TRADE UNIONS………………………………………………………………2ND RESPONDENT
COUNTY LABOUR OFFICER, KITUI COUNTY………………………………..………...3RD RESPONDENT
MIRRIAM KITUU…………………..……………………..…………………………………….…...4TH RESPONDENT
CORAM
Before Lady Justice Jemimah Keli
C/A Otieno
JUDGMENT
1. The Petitioners were paid-up members of the 1st Respondent. They were barred from contesting in the KNUT Mwingi branch elections held on 28th February 2026 by the 1st respondent on basis of allegations of pending disciplinary issues. They jointly commenced this suit by a Petition dated 6th March 2026, seeking:-
a) A declaration that the 1st Respondent’s decision to bar the Petitioners from contesting in the KNUT Mwingi Branch elections held on 28th February 2026 was unlawful, null and void and in contravention of their rights under Articles 36, 41 and 47 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010.
b) A declaration that the decision by the 1st Respondent to declare the Petitioners ineligible to contest in the KNUT Mwingi Branch elections held on 28th February 2026 violated their right to freedom of association and right to participate in the activities and programs of their trade union contrary to Articles 36(1), and 41(1) & (2) of the Constitution of Kenya 2010.
c) A declaration that the decision of the 1st Respondent to declare the Petitioners ineligible to contest in the KNUT Mwingi Branch elections held on 28th February 2026 without giving them an opportunity to be heard was discriminatory and in violation of Articles 27, and 47(1) & (2) of the Constitution of Kenya 2010.
d) A declaration that the Petitioners were eligible to vie and contest for the office of the KNUT Mwingi Branch Chairman in the elections held on 28th February 2026.
e) A declaration that no valid nominations and elections of the KNUT Mwingi Branch for the office of the Branch Chairman were conducted on 28th February 2026 and that the results thereof are null and void.
f) An order nullifying the election of the 4th Respondent as the KNUT Mwingi Branch Chairman.
g) An order directing the 2nd Respondent to forthwith deregister the returns of the 1st Respondent's Mwingi Branch election held on 28th February 2026 with respect to the office of the Branch Chairman.
h) An order directing the 1st Respondent to organize and carry out fresh nominations and elections for the office of the KNUT Mwingi Branch Chairman in accordance with the Constitution of Kenya 2010 and the KNUT Constitution.
i) An award of general damages to the Petitioners for violation of their constitutional rights.
j) Costs of the Petition.
2. The Petition was filed alongside the Petitioner’s Supporting Affidavit sworn on 6th March 2026, and the documents annexed in support of the Petition. The Petitioner also filed witness statements of the 1st and 2nd Petitioners both dated 22nd March 2026; a list of witnesses of even date; and a list of documents of even date.
3. In response to the Petition, the 1st to 4th Respondents filed a Notice of Preliminary Objection dated 28th May 2026; and a Replying Affidavit sworn by COLLINS HENRY OYUU on 11th June 2026.
Hearing and evidence
4. The petitioners’ case was heard on the 12th June 2026 with the 2 petitioners testifying on oath, adopting their affidavits and witness statements and being cross-examined by the counsel for the 1st and 4th respondents. The respondents filed their replying affidavit on 11th June 2026 on the eve of the hearing; thus, it was not available at the hearing. The court granted the petitioners leave to file a further affidavit, which they did.
5. The 1st and 4th respondents relied on the notice of preliminary objection and replying affidavit filed by Collins Oyoo Sworn on the 11th June 2026 and closed their case.
The Petitioner’s case in summary
6. The Petitioners are teachers registered with the Teachers Service Commission (TSC) under TSC Nos. 506863 and 470821 respectively both working in Kitui County. The Petitioners are also paid up members of the 1st Respondent, the Kenya National Union of Teachers (KNUT), with the second Petitioner being the outgoing KNUT Mwingi Branch Assistant Treasurer who has held the position since 2021 and 2025.
7. The genesis of the present dispute is that the 2nd Respondent, the Registrar of Trade Unions, vide a letter Ref. ML&SP/TU/ELECTION/2026 dated 25th September 2025 directed all trade unions, employer's organizations, and federations, to hold branch elections between 5th January 2026 and 31st March 2026. In compliance with the directive, the 1st Respondent, KNUT, issued a circular
8. Ref. KNUT/CIRC/122/27/2025 of 13th October 2025 notifying its 110 Branches across the country that KNUT Branch elections were to be held between 5th January 2026 and 31st March 2026. They subsequently issued a schedule dated 17th December 2025 within which the specific election dates for branch officials across the country were set. In particular, the elections for KNUT Mwingi Branch were set for 28th February 2026.
9. It is averred that the requirements for all contestants and voters taking part in the upcoming branch elections were indicated by the 1st Respondent in a circular Ref KNUT MWINGI BRANCHCIR.ELE/2026 of 12th February 2026 addressed to all KNUT Mwingi Branch members. Guidelines were also provided on how the elections were to be conducted. The said circular indicated that to qualify to contest for any of the available seats, a candidate was required to meet the requirements as stated in ArticleX(C)(3)of the KNUT Constitution, namely: Must be a fully paid up member of the Union (Not agency fee); must produce proof of membership through a current payslip; and their name must appear in the members register. The same circular set the date of nominations as 27th February 2026 at Mwingi Town Resource Centre and reiterated that the elections would be held on 28th February 2026 at the same venue.
10. The Petitioners aver that being registered members of the 1st Respondent in good standing and having met all the qualifications and requirements for candidature as per the 1st Respondent's Constitution, they expressed their intention to vie for the position of KNUT Mwingi Branch Chairman, which position attracted three (3) candidates: the two Petitioners and the 4th Respondent. The Petitioner’s contend that they embarked on extensive campaigns all across the KNUT Mwingi branch region, but on 27th February 2026, which was the date when the nomination of candidates was to be carried out, the 1st Respondent unilaterally and without notice changed the nomination venue from Mwingi Town Resource Centre to Legacy Hotel in Mwingi Town. The Petitioners complain that they only became aware of the change at 3:00 p.m., whereupon they proceeded to the nomination venue accompanied by their proposers and seconders who were also paid-up members of the 1st Respondent in good standing.
11. It is the Petitioner’s case that upon arriving at the nomination venue, the 1st Petitioner was served with a letter dated 27th February 2026 authored by the 1st Respondent's National Elections Board notifying him of an alleged professional misconduct allegation in that he was accused of the publication and/or dissemination of information that was prejudicial to the interests of the Union and inconsistent with its core values of professionalism, integrity, solidarity and teamwork, on social media platforms. The letter declared the 1st Petitioner ineligible to contest in the branch elections. The 1st Petitioner indicates that he had not been notified of any allegations of professional misconduct prior to this date and no disciplinary proceedings had been commenced against me to warrant the action taken by the 1st Respondent. He further points out that the letter did not indicate the publications he was alleged to have made on social media platforms. Similarly, the 2nd Petitioner was served with a letter dated 25th February 2026 authored by the 1st Respondent's National Elections Board barring him from contesting for the position of Chairman, KNUT Mwingi Branch, on the basis that he was under suspension pursuant to another letter dated 1st August 2024 which states he had not received and was not aware of. The letter of suspension dated 1st August 2024 was actually handed to the 2nd Petitioner on the election date, i.e. 28th February 2026. It is also averred that the 2nd Petitioner was not aware of the said suspension or the grounds thereof as no Branch General Meeting had been convened to vote on the suspension in accordance with Article X(C)(6)(L) of the KNUT Constitution. The Petitioners argue that the were not given notice of the allegations and proceedings against them and/or an opportunity to be heard before being declared ineligible to vie. Further, they had not been suspended prior to the nomination date.
12. The Petitioners state that their objections and protests against the 1st Respondent’s decision to bar them from contested and their demands for explanations were ignored, and the 1st Respondent proceeded to hold its branch elections on 28th February 2026 as scheduled without their participation. The Petitioners take the view that their exclusion from contesting in the KNUT Mwingi Branch elections was premised on spurious and manufactured grounds, and did not apply the eligibility criteria provided for under Article X(C)(3) of the KNUT Constitution. They also contend that it was part of a calculated, deliberate and premeditated scheme by certain officials of the 1st Respondent to exclude the Petitioners from participating in the Union branch elections in favour of the 4th Respondent who was declared the winner unopposed. At the time of filing the Petition, they stated that the 2nd Respondent was in the process of registering returns from the said elections thereby acknowledging the 4th Respondent as the duly elected Chairman of the KNUT Mwingi Branch and permitting her to assume office, despite the flawed and unfair election exercise. The Petitioners urge the Court to intervene to prevent the 4th Respondent’s unlawful access to, control, and benefit from union and public funds, and the exposure of the union and its members to irreversible financial and administrative consequences.
13. The Petitioner’s case is that the 1st Respondent’s decision to bar them from participating in the branch elections was arbitrary, unlawful and in violation of their fundamental rights and freedoms under the Constitution specifically Article 27 on non-discrimination; Article 36(1) on freedom of association including the right to form, join or participate in the activities of an association of any kind; Article 41 on fair labour practices including the right to participate in trade union activities; and Article 47 on fair administrative action, and the KNUT Constitution. Additionally, the Petitioners argue that they had a legitimate expectation of free and fair elections carried out in a manner embracing democratic ideals enshrined in the KNUT Constitution and the Constitution of Kenya. Owing to the actions of the 1st Respondent, the Petitioners challenge the legitimacy of the KNUT Mwingi Branch elections for the branch Chairman position.
14. On exhaustion of internal remedies, the Petitioners contend that the 1st Respondent's Constitution does not provide a clear mechanism for resolution of grievances touching on violation of the rights and fundamental freedoms in the Bill of Rights, and the reliefs sought in the Petition are not within the purview of the bodies established under the KNUT Constitution. The Petitioners also categorize the 1st Respondent’s internal dispute resolution mechanisms as unavailable, inaccessible, inadequate, and unable to effectively address violations of their Constitutional rights. The Petitioners emphasize that their grievance is not electoral but constitutional; hence, they deny that the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Trade Union Election Disputes) Procedure and Practice Directions are applicable.
1st to 4th Respondents’ case in brief
15. The Respondents challenge the Petition for the reason that it offends the mandatory filing procedures provided for under Direction 5(2), 6 and 8 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Trade Union Election Disputes) Procedure and Practice Directions, 2025 as it does not state the name the venue where the elections were held, the results of the election disputed and the results however declared; and does not provide for security for the prompt payment of costs which may become payable by the petitioner. In addition to the foregoing, the Respondents contend that the 3rd Respondent is neither a legal entity nor a natural person and is therefore incapable of suing or being sued as such.
16. The response is further that, contrary to the averments by the Petitioner, the Petitioners had been suspended from office prior to the elections, which was communicated to them through letters dated 27th February, 2026 and 25th February, 2026. (Annexed hereto and marked "CH0la, b and c" are copies of the letters and notices issued to the Petitioners.) "
17. THAT I know of my own knowledge that despite their suspension, the Petitioners failed to follow procedure to ensure their suspension from office was lifted. The Petitioners ought to have gone through Internal Dispute Resolution Mechanisms to have their suspension lifted. The suspension of the Petitioners had ramifications on the eligibility to run for elections. The the Petitioners were bound by Article 3(11) of the KNUT Constitution which provides that a member who is subjected to disciplinary action forfeits all the rights during the subsistence of such disciplinary status. I know of my own knowledge that the Petitioners did not exhaust all mechanisms available to deal with their cases of suspension. The disciplinary issues the Petitioners are facing cannot be mixed with political issues relating to elections
DETERMINATION
18. Following directions by the court that it would determine the Petition through written submissions, the parties filed their respective submissions.
Issues for determination
19. The Petitioners distilled the following issues for determination in their submissions dated 9th July 2026:
i. Whether the preliminary objection is merited.
ii. Whether the Petition offends the doctrine of exhaustion of statutory dispute resolution mechanism.
iii. Whether the Petitioners’ rights were violated.
iv. Whether the Petitioners are entitled to the orders sought.
20. The Respondents filed submissions dated 31st July 2026, where they identified the following issues:-
i. Whether the Petitioners have exhausted the internal dispute resolution mechanisms.
ii. Whether the prayers sought in the Petition ought to be granted.
21. The court, having perused the pleadings and submissions, agreed with the issues identified by the parties for determination to be –
i. Whether the preliminary objection is merited.
ii. Whether the Petition offends the doctrine of exhaustion of statutory dispute resolution mechanism.
iii. Whether the Petitioners’ constitutional rights were violated.
iv. Whether the Petitioners are entitled to the orders sought.
The law
22. Articles 19,20,21,22,23,27,36(1) 41(1) ,41(2)(c),47(1)& (47(2) of the Constitution of Kenya
23. The Employment and Labour Relations Court (Trade Union Election Disputes) Procedure and Practice Directions, 2025.
Whether the preliminary objection by the 1st and 4th respondents is merited.
24. The respondent filed notice of preliminary objection dated 28th May 2026 to the effect that the Petition dated 6th March, 2026 is defective as it offends mandatory filing procedures set out under the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Trade Union Election Disputes) Procedure and Practice Directions, 2025, particularly direction 5(2).
25. During cross-examination, the petitioner told the court that he had filed a constitutional petition alleging a violation of his rights. The petition sought the following orders-
i. An order nullifying the election of the 4th Respondent as the KNUT Mwingi Branch Chairman.
ii. An order directing the 2nd Respondent to forthwith deregister the returns of the 1st Respondent's Mwingi Branch election held on 28th February 2026 with respect to the office of the Branch Chairman.
iii. An order directing the 1st Respondent to organize and carry out fresh nominations and elections for the office of the KNUT Mwingi Branch Chairman in accordance with the Constitution of Kenya 2010 and the KNUT Constitution.
iv. An award of general damages to the Petitioners for violation of their constitutional rights.
26. Regulations 5(2) states -
‘(2) In addition to provisions of the Rules on the title, a person filing the election petition shall title it as such by providing for the number and year of filing at the top thus “Election Petition No. ... of ...(year)”.
27. The instant petition was just indicated as a petition, and indeed the petitioners told the court at the hearing that theirs was a constitutional petition.
28. The court found that, ideally, this was a case challenging the election process, as the petitioners alleged they had been suspended on the eve of the nomination and thus barred from contesting and voting in the election. They alleged denial of the right to participate in the elections by the last-minute issuance of a suspension just before the nomination, yet they had been campaigning to be elected. The cause of action was what is described by the rules under clause 2 –
‘2) A petition about a trade union election dispute is essentially for enforcement of the right to fair labour relations as provided in Article 41 and the other relevant provisions of the Bill of Rights in the Constitution and shall be instituted in accordance with the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Fundamental Freedoms and Enforcement of the Constitution) Practice and Procedure Rules as provided for in rule 10 of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (Procedure) Rules, 2024.’
29. The right to participate in union elections is a constitutional right under Article 41 of the Constitution to wit-
‘41. Labour relations
(1)Every person has the right to fair labour practices.
(2)Every worker has the right-
(c)to form, join or participate in the activities and programmes of a trade union;’(emphasis given).
30. The court finds that the petitioner cannot challenge the elections outside the rules and thus the orders sought as relates to the said elections are not available.
31. The court finds that the regulations cannot fetter the constitutional right under Article 22 to seek a remedy for a violation of the Constitution, as the Constitution is supreme. The right to participate in union elections is a constitutional right under Article 41(2) of the Constitution. The petitioner sought compensation for the violation of his constitutional right to participate in elections; thus, the petition still has a leg to stand on. I relied on the criteria for a competent petition as pronounced in Muthinja & another v Henry & 1756 others [2015] KECA 304 (KLR-
‘The jurisprudence of this jurisdiction in this regard has been settled for a long time that a petitioner should be specific as to the right violated and give particulars of it. It is a rule of good sense that aids in the crystallization of issues before the court and, moreover, gives opportunity to the other party to know the exact nature of the complaint leveled against him and therefore be in a position to give an appropriate answer. It provides structure, sense and symmetry to the litigation and prevents it from being an unruly free-for-all. The Anarita Karimi Njeru And Matemu cases (Supra) are clear and authoritative expositors of that position. Indeed, the Constitution of Kenya (Protection of Rights and Procedure Rules, 2013) reflect that thinking in requiring under Rule 10(2) that constitution petitions must contain, inter alia,(i)The facts relied upon,(ii)The constitutional provision violated,(iii)The nature of injury caused or likely to be caused,(iv)The relief sought.’
32. I decline to allow the preliminary objection on that basis.
Whether the Petition offends the doctrine of exhaustion of statutory dispute resolution mechanism.
33. The respondent submitted that -Jurisdiction is everything in Owners of the Motor Vessel "Lillian S" v Caltex Oil (Kenya) Ltd [1989] KLR 1, the Court stated that-
"Jurisdiction is everything. Without it, a court has no power to make one more step..."
34. The respondent submitted that this Court does not have jurisdiction to deal with a disciplinary issue disguised as an election petition. The respondent in replying affidavit of Collins Oyoo stated- ‘ THAT I know of my own knowledge that despite their suspension, the Petitioners failed to follow procedure to ensure their suspension from office was lifted. The Petitioners ought to have gone through Internal Dispute Resolution Mechanisms to have their suspension lifted. The suspension of the Petitioners had ramifications on the eligibility to run for elections. The Petitioners were bound by Article 3(11) of the KNUT Constitution which provides that a member who is subjected to disciplinary action forfeits all the rights during the subsistence of such disciplinary status. I know of my own knowledge that the Petitioners did not exhaust all mechanisms available to deal with their cases of suspension. The disciplinary issues the Petitioners are facing cannot be mixed with political issues relating to elections ‘
35. The respondent relied on the landmark case in Speaker of the National Assembly v James Njenga Karume [1992] eKLR which stated:
"Where there is a clear procedure for the redress of any particular grievance prescribed by the Constitution or an Act of Parliament, that procedure should be strictly followed.’
36. The petitioners told the court the trigger of his case was the issuance of a suspension letter on account of non-nomination, denying them the chance to exercise the rights of a union member. The first petitioner on eve of the nominations was issued with a letter dated 27th February 2026 as follows-
‘NOTICE OF ALLEGED PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT VIS-A-VIS ELIGIBILITY STATUS UPDATE The National Elections Board of the Kenya National Union of Teachers (KNUT), having reviewed the records and material placed before It, hereby notifies you that allegations have been preferred against you regarding the publication and/or dissemination of information on social media platforms prejudicial to the interests of the Union and inconsistent with its core values of Professionalism, Integrity. Solidarity, and Teamwork. ΤΟ Your attention is expressly drawn to Article XIV of the KNUT Constitution on Professional Conduct and Discipline, which stipulates that it shall amount unprofessional conduct for any member ofthe Union: Article XIV (5): "To indulge in damaging personalities whether in newspapers, correspondence or otherwise, or give publicity to any statement detrimental to the interest of the Union or a fellow member." The National Executive Council (NEC), being the organ duly mandated to enforce the Constitution, Rules and Regulations, Standing Orders, and By-laws of the Union, has formally taken cognizance of the matter and assumed jurisdiction. The NEC shall consider and determine the matter in accordance with the Constitution and shall, in due course, report to the Annual Delegates Conference, to which Conference any appeal by you, as the affected member, shall properly lie. Kindly further take notice that pursuant to Article 3(11) of the KNUT Constitution, a member who is subjected to disciplinary proceedings forfeits all rights during the pendency and subsistence of such disciplinary status In light of the foregoing, your eligibility status remains subject to the outcome of the said disciplinary process. You are accordingly required to take due notice of the same and be guided appropriately.’
37. It is my finding that there was no express decision on the allegations raised. Had the disciplinary proceedings started merely on the basis of information that the allegations had been received? Is it rational to suspend a union member's constitutional rights on the basis of mere allegations that have not even been investigated? In Mutsembi v Kenya National Union of Teachers (KNUT) Kakamega South Branch & another (Petition 029 of 2025) [2026] KEHC 392 (KLR) (26 January 2026) (Ruling), the court observed-
‘The record shows that he attended the said meeting at the KNUT house on 22nd October 2025, where the committee found that the petitioner was guilty of the allegations of misconduct against him and allowed him to appeal the decision at the National Executive Council (NEC); however, he failed to appeal. He, however, wrote a letter dated 4th December 2025 apologizing.
34.The evidence on record by the respondents has indicated that the Petitioner was well aware of the charges. There was evidence that the petitioner apologized in writing, attended a consultative meeting, and was advised to appeal to the NEC, but failed to do so formally. His subsequent letter requesting a pardon does not substitute for a proper appeal under the KNUT Constitution. The Petitioner has not demonstrated exceptional circumstances warranting bypass of the internal mechanisms, such as futility or irreparable harm beyond what the remedies could address. The suspension, while lengthy, stems from his own inaction in pursuing appeals.
35.The Respondents have demonstrated, through affidavit evidence, that the KNUT Constitution provides for disciplinary procedures and an appellate mechanism to the National Executive Council (NEC). It is not disputed that the Petitioner was advised to appeal to the NEC and that he did not do so within the prescribed framework.
36.In William Odhiambo Ramogi & 2 others v Attorney General & 6 others [2018] eKLR, the Court held that exhaustion may only be bypassed in exceptional circumstances, including where the internal mechanism is shown to be ineffective, biased, or incapable of providing an appropriate remedy.’
38. I find the above case relevant. In the instant case, the 1st petitioner’s rights were stopped without any merit finding on the allegations against him. A constitutional right (save for article 25-Fundamental Rights and freedoms that may not be limited ) can only be limited as per the Constitution under Article 24 of the Constitution, which states-
‘A right or fundamental freedom in the Bill of Rights shall not be limited except by law, and then only to the extent that the limitation is reasonable and justifiable in an open and democratic society based on human dignity, equality and freedom, taking into account all relevant factors, including—
(a)the nature of the right or fundamental freedom;
(b)the importance of the purpose of the limitation;
(c)the nature and extent of the limitation;
(d)the need to ensure that the enjoyment of rights and fundamental freedoms by any individual does not prejudice the rights and fundamental freedoms of others; and
(e)the relation between the limitation and its purpose and whether there are less restrictive means to achieve the purpose.’
39. The 1st petitioner’s right under Article 41(2) was limited on the basis of mere allegations, even before the 1st respondent established the truth thereof and heard the petitioner. The court finds that the limitation is not reasonable and justifiable in an open and democratic society based on human dignity, equality and freedom. The letter was sent on eve of the elections. The 1st respondent, in the replying affidavit, did not even disclose when it received the complaints. The court finds that this was a deliberate act of sabotaging the 1st petitioner's right to participate in the election nominations as there was no time to lodge any appeal. The communication was fait accompli as it relates to the 1st petitioner’s right to participate in the elections.
40. On the 2nd petitioner, the 1st respondent stated he was served with the letter of 25th February 2026, which indicated he had been suspended by the Mwingi branch on 1st August 2024. The 2nd petitioner in the affidavit averred he was not aware of any suspension from Mwingi Branch as alleged. Collins Oyoo, in his response, did not annex the minutes of the said suspension, despite having an opportunity to do so. The court finds that the limitation on participation in elections is not reasonable and justifiable in an open and democratic society based on human dignity, equality and freedom. The letter was sent on eve of the elections. The 1st respondent, in the replying affidavit, did not annex the minutes of the Mwingi branch meeting of 1st August 2024 suspending the petitioner. The 1st petitioner averred he was not aware of the suspension, and the burden was on the 1st respondent to prove the suspension by the Mwingi branch of the union as alleged to have happened. Minutes of the said meeting would have been helpful. The court finds the last-minute communication of the suspension was a deliberate act of sabotaging the right of the 2nd petitioner to participate in the nominations for elections. The communication was fait accompli, as the suspension deprived the 1st petitioner of the right to participate in the elections or time to seek redress under the internal mechanism.
41. am persuaded that the petitioners could not have had a remedy to the instant violations within the internal mechanism of the 1st respondent. The letters of suspension were issued on the eve of the elections; thus, no opportunity was available to invoke the mechanism under the Union Constitution to salvage their right to participate in the nominations.
Whether the petitioners are entitled to the relief sought
42. As indicated earlier, the petitioners are not entitled to any relief related to the elections as they came to court on the basis of a constitutional petition. I have found their right to participate in elections under Article 41(2) of the Constitution was violated by the 1st petitioner.
43. On finding a violation of the Constitution, the court is to consider remedies under Article 23 of the Constitution, to wit –
‘In any proceedings brought under Article 22, a court may grant appropriate relief, including—
(a)a declaration of rights;
(b)an injunction;
(c)a conservatory order;
(d)a declaration of invalidity of any law that denies, violates, infringes, or threatens a right or fundamental freedom in the Bill of Rights and is not justified under Article 24;
(e)an order for compensation; and
(f)an order of judicial review.’
44. The court held that the right of the petitioners to participate in union activities (Article 41(2)) was violated by the 1st respondent in this case, in the nomination held on 28th February 2026.
Disposition
45. The notice of preliminary objection is disallowed. Judgment is entered for the Petitioners against the 1st Respondent as follows-
a) A declaration that the 1st Respondent’s decision to bar the Petitioners from contesting in the KNUT Mwingi Branch elections held on 28th February 2026 was unlawful, null and void and in contravention of their rights under Articles 36, 41 and 47 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010.
b) A declaration that the decision by the 1st Respondent to declare the Petitioners ineligible to contest in the KNUT Mwingi Branch elections held on 28th February 2026 violated their right to freedom of association and right to participate in the activities and programs of their trade union contrary to Articles 36(1), and 41(1) & (2) of the Constitution of Kenya 2010.
c) The court grants remedy of compensation taking into account the violation limited their constitutional right to participate in the union elections, they had been campaigning with legitimate expectation to be nominated for the contest, and the disbar decision was given at the last minute, thus no chance to challenge the same under the union internal mechanisms. The petitioners are each awarded compensation of Kshs. 500,000 to vindicate their right to participate in trade union activities under Article 41 of the Constitution.
d) Cost of the petition.
46. It is so ordered.
DATED, SIGNED, AND DELIVERED VIRTUALLY AT NAIROBI THIS 16TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026.
JEMIMAH KELI,
JUDGE
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
Court Assistant: Otieno
Petitioners: Mwendwa
1st and 4th Respondents: Ms Esami